When war erupts across the globe, it does not come alone.
Jack Callahan has spent his life hiding what he is- an Inkbinder, capable of weaving magic through hand-crafted cards. But when the attack on Pearl Harbor pulls the United States into the war, hiding is no longer an option.
Impersonating his grandfather, Jack joins the Allied Occult Division, a covert unit tasked with combating the supernatural forces shaping the battlefield from the shadows. There, he’s forced into close quarters with soldiers unlike any he’s known- among them, Alastair Morgan, a disciplined British operative whose presence begins to unsettle Jack in ways he doesn’t fully understand.
As the Nachtarmee - a secret faction manipulating the Axis through dark, ritual magic - moves to tip the balance of the war, Jack must learn to wield a power he was never meant to carry. But magic is unpredictable, alliances are fragile, and the line between weapon and wielder begins to blur.
Because some battles aren’t fought on the front lines....
I absolutely love historical fiction and fantasy, so the fact that I haven't read many historical fantasy books is really a shame. The genre is what drew me to this book, and I'm glad it did.
The magic feels very unique, with runed cards being the source of the main character's magic. It reminds me of Rachel Gillig—it's intruiging in the same way her magic systems are. I don't fully follow how it works, but it definitely draws me in the entire time. Other characters have different magic; theirs is less unique (siren, werewolf, pyromancer, healer, etc.) but having them work together creates a new feel to the powers.
The writing is extremely well done. The action is intense, often fast-paced but never difficult to follow. It really grabs the reader. The imagery is described very well and is immediately noticeable. The dialogue feels natural and intentional, which really helps push the plot forward. The major characters feel very fleshed out. There's a really good Mulan moment that shows Jack's character. His grandpa wants to protect Jack by going to war and keeping Jack hidden, but Jack decides to leave in the middle of the night when his grandpa isn't awake to stop him. His motivation seems to be to protect his grandfather, and not much else. It shows how loyal he is to those he is close to. Jack's character is very strong throughout, as are his relationships.
I had small gripes throughout the book. These did not negatively impact the plot, they did pull me out of the book a bit. With these polished this would've been a five star for sure!
The preface was interesting, but a bit hard to get into because of the written out accent—something I was taught never to do in my writing classes but recognize is done in very famous works (Their Eyes were Watching God, for instance). It just feels a bit amateur to me. It's also a bit weird that only the Germans have their accent written out when there are other accents (Russian, Italian, Japanese) that could've been treated the same.
Alastair Morgan and Fleur Durand remind me of Alastor Moody and Fleur Delacour. Not necessarily a bad thing but the similarities in the names felt a little odd. And it's a tad unfortunate that Alastair looks like Moody in my head, but definitely not the author's fault there lol.
The pacing felt a little bit off. Like they jumped around a bit too easily. It made the book feel disjointed to me. Travel was mentioned but rarely shown, so they would be in Africa, then the UK, than France and it felt like there was no real time in between the countries. It was good to get right to the important scenes, but I think some filler would've been okay to flesh out the characters a bit more.
I wish some more time was spent on Jack's training. He was told he'd be trained by the AOD, but he didn't seem to be trained really at all. The team practiced but it was rare, otherwise he read books, which doesn't seem like the best for combat training. We see his perseverance, which is good, but I wish he would've had more help from others to help him grow in his powers.
I think there are a few too many characters. While the core characters are well written, more background characters are forgotten about. They don't feel fleshed out, which isn't necessarily bad, but it makes it harder to understand how the team works together.
Overall, the writing is great, the plot is interesting, and the magic is unique. But I think this needs to be polished a bit further before it gets a 5 star from me.
I loved this!! The concept was incredibly fleshed out and so well written. It has this almost X-Men/comic-book feel to it, with the protagonist being part of a military unit made up of people with different supernatural abilities, except it’s all happening against the backdrop of WWII. And somehow it WORKS so well.
The main character also uses card-based magic that gave me major Gambit vibes, which I thought was so cool. That’s not a type of magic I feel like you see portrayed very often, so it made his abilities feel really unique and memorable.
I don’t normally gravitate toward stories centered around war, but holy sht, I was immersed. I genuinely did not get bored once while reading this. Every beat kept me hooked, and the WWII setting added so much to the story without taking away from the supernatural/fantasy elements. I really loved the way the two were woven together.
The slow burn between Jack and Alistair was EVERYTHING and personally so worth the wait. I loved watching their relationship develop alongside everything else happening. And the characters as a whole?? Amazing. This really gave me found family in the best way, and I got so attached to the entire unit.
I also really loved how the Mulan situation was handled. The story knew when to be dark and heavy, especially given the setting and subject matter, but it never felt overwhelmingly depressing. There was enough warmth, connection, humor, and hope throughout to balance everything out.
The writing was descriptive without ever feeling like too much. This is definitely a longer book, but it honestly never felt long to me because I was invested the entire time.
My biggest complaint is basically that I NEED MORE. I got to the ending and genuinely found myself tapping the screen because I thought there had to be another page. I would absolutely read a continuation because now I need to know what happens next!! The ending left me wanting more, but very much in an “okay but WHAT NOW??” way rather than me being unhappy with where it ended. I just got way too invested in this world and these characters to be ready to leave them yet.
Since I read an ARC, I did notice some grammatical/editing errors that could probably use one more pass before publication, but that was really my only technical critique.
Overall, I had such a good time with this. If you’re a historical fantasy reader, love found family and slow-burn queer romance, or you’re a comic-book/X-Men person who likes the idea of a team of powered people dropped into a WWII setting, I absolutely think this is one to check out. I’m already super invested in wherever this story goes next.
Wow. That's all I can say. Like many others who read this book, I am not the biggest fan of war stories; however, this one felt larger than life. The romance between Jack and Alastair, while not incredibly slow (developing until about the halfway point), was filled with the witty banter and unsure longing I love in books. The romance is by no means the focal point of the story, partially due to the impossibility of it all thanks to the war, but it adds a nice reprieve amid all the fighting.
The final battle was easily my favorite part of the book; it felt like a cross between A Wrinkle in Time, Stranger Things, and a Stephen King novel in the best way. I literally could not put it down. The cast of characters that Jack meets are very well written, and the camaraderie they gain is by far the best part of the book, despite the looming war. The magic system Romero designed is incredibly intricate, with seemingly limitless possibilities.
I have but a few critiques, merely warnings should you pick up this book. Firstly, I found the battles to be somewhat repetitive towards the middle (though I understand that is the nature of war), and I wish the ending had more resolution, even a way for us to catch up with the characters after the final battle had time to settle. Also, because I received this book as an ARC, there were a few minor grammatical errors, but they were negligible and have surely been fixed upon release.
While the plot is fantastical to say the least, there are clear moments and phrases that show real meaning beyond the characters winning a war, times worth pausing and reflecting on, that make the characters and experiences all the more real. Is Romero's writing perfect, technically speaking? No. But it is some of the most grounded writing I've read in a long time, a book that shows a real connection between the author, his audience, and his characters. While not many, if any, readers of this book actually lived through WWII, I'm sure you can find something to connect to in this book, whether it is a found family, the pressure of keeping a secret, or a wish to do something greater with the talents you have.
If you love Avengers-esque stories, this is for you. I also sincerely believe this could have a good screen adaptation, if you prefer your books to feel like you could see them on a screen. The battle sequences were extremely reminiscent of story-focused video games, which I heavily enjoyed. All that being said, I genuinely believe this book has something for everyone, whether these kinds of stories are your cup of tea or not.
I received a free e-arc from the author in exchange for an honest opinion.
I want to start off by saying I really enjoyed the plot of this book. I loved the characters in it, and I'm very glad for how much page time they all got. I think this book is appropriately dark for a WWII fantasy. It allows repercussions for their actions and doesn't shy away from the atrocities. Plus fighting an evil magical cult makes for an interesting read on its own merit.
I liked how Jack and Alastair interact. Their relationship is allowed to grow and change, and the amount of teasing is quite fun. It does feel like it develops a little out of nowhere but I liked it all the same.
I would honestly love a book on Elena. There's references in Inkbinder's War that makes me feel she has more backstory that we have not been given, and it sounds like there's enough for there to be a full book. It's certainly enough for me to be hooked, especially since this book feels like it can be read as a standalone but it's marketed as a trilogy.
My main critique, however, is that Inkbinder's War does not feel like it's been edited enough to a final draft. I did read an ARC copy, so it's possible way more editing happens between when I received it and publication (in which case I will remove this part). However, there's a multitude of typos, quite a bit of repetition, and at one point almost an entire chapter is copy and pasted. The writing itself is also extremely choppy at varying points.
I did like this book, and I see the potential of it with further editing. Jack's story is absolutely worth reading, but you should be aware of the issues above (if they are not fixed) if this is something that might bother you as a reader.
So this is going to be a two part review. My rating is about the storyline and feel of the book.
Story line and essence of the book was amazing!! I loved each character and their interactions with each other. They really became chosen family. This story really felt like a league of extraordinary gentlemen mixed with HellBoy fae magic set in WWII. Bloody actions scenes. more intense build up each time and more to lose as the war and story goes on. I would have loved to know more about the main character and some references maybe i missed about him being half-blood and how his magic is created/used/where it pulls from. I thoroughly enjoyed the book and would recommend people to check it out.
Second part of my review has no sway on my rating. Since it was an arc read there were small clerical errors her and there in the book. i kind of felt smart catching them and actually made me think (my degree is in math). Also figured these would be caught before bing published as well 😊 The other part is chapter 29 and 30 were exactly the same but played out differently after they saw the camp.... i dont know which one was chosen but it seems odd even for an arc.
I received this as an e-arc and this is an honest review.
Inkbinder's War is an X-men inspired, WW2 fantasy featuring secret magic, found family, slow-burn 'forbidden' romance (due to the time period) between two male soldiers, monsters and evils beyond what we know.
This is an absolutely beautifully thought out, fleshed out book. The characters are so wonderfully written, all of them, and the plot is like nothing I've read before. You can feel the darkness, the desperation, the horror. Jack is an amazing MC, and his growth is both magnificent and magical throughout the story, as is his relationship with Alastair. From the 'dedication' (same) to the very last page, I was very much intrigued. The pacing was great, and yes, it's graphic and brutal, but that's sadly what war is.
I do agree that there were quite a few typos in the arc, but I'm sure that another round of edits before release will clear those up. Other than that, as I mentioned, it is an absolutely beautifully written story that I would highly recommend to anyone.
Some of my favorite highlights:
“I don’t know when it started,” Alastair said hoarsely. ‘Or how. I just know that somewhere along the way, you lodged yourself into my thoughts, into my instincts, into places nothing has ever reach before. You’ve been in my thoughts since the moment we met. You’ve rooted yourself so deeply in me that I can’t separate where you end and I begin.”
"You make it sound so simple,” Jack murmured, a faint smile tugging at his lips. “It’s not,” Alastair admitted, his voice softening. “But nothing worth it ever is.”
“Resilience is overrated. Pastries, however, are eternal.”
I listened to the Audio book- first off highly recommend!
I was a little overwhelmed by the ensemble cast of characters that left me wanting more but all them felt pretty distinct in their personalities. I just wanted more.
Jack is a great character that is still finding himself some as a man in his young 20s (so real king). Alistair is a great pairing to Jack and the writing brings a surprising but well done softness to the character that I love.
Dani is my favorite character. Best girl, I love her