A provocative and transformative tour through literature as an insight into despair and how to understand it, and why the practice of reading is needed more than ever—based on the wildly popular UPenn course Existential Despair.
“This book is brimming with moving reflections on some of the greatest literature you’ve ever read. In an era when we’re starving for humanity, it’s the dose of the humanities that we desperately need.”—Adam Grant, #1 New York Times bestselling author of Vibe and Think Again; host of the podcast
Imagine a class that meets for eight hours once a week. There are no devices, just one book to read in silence and discuss with the group at the end. No prep. No papers. No final exams. Just read a book and think about it.
That’s exactly what University of Pennsylvania professor Justin McDaniel—former Buddhist monk and Guggenheim Fellow—asks of his students in Existential Despair, which perhaps ironically became the most popular course on campus. Drawing on this celebrated class, McDaniel now guides readers through sixteen weeks of radical reading designed to unsettle, transform, and restore.
With bracing candor and erudite analysis, Existential Despair introduces readers to modern classics of literature by James Baldwin, Carmen Maria Machado, Yukio Mishima, Ottessa Moshfegh, Paul Bowles, and others, exploring universal themes including childhood, longing, sex, loneliness, and death. Each chapter models McDaniel’s unconventional reading entire novels in one sitting, grappling with discomfort, and practicing deep concentration free of distraction. This book is not a self-help manual, nor a path to quick fixes. Instead, it offers readers an opportunity to experience what hundreds of students already literature as a way to wrestle with grief, meaning, and survival.
As McDaniel writes, “This is not about hope or triumph—it’s about learning to live alongside despair.”
Existential Despair is an immersive reading experience that cultivates rigorous intellectual and personal engagement, a crash course in living with focus, intention, and presence of mind.
The word “despair” comes from the Middle English word "despeir," which is derived from the Anglo-French "despoir" and the Latin "dēspērāre," meaning "to lose hope." The components of the Latin term include "de-" (meaning "down from") and "sperare" (meaning "to hope").
So how might hope lost best be found (a.k.a. “respair”; cue “Amazing Grace”) … and then kept, or even shared?
More to the point, what does existential despair, and 10 dozen “sad books” that reference it, have to do with attention activism?
As it turns out, just about everything.
Justin Thomas McDaniel’s acclaimed University of Pennsylvania course (RELS 2560 - Existential Despair) suggests that “unplugging from distractions and focusing on one thing at a time can lead to unexpected breakthroughs and moments of clarity. It’s a fascinating look at how simplifying our lives can open up new ways of thinking.”
Sixteen books in 16 weeks, spanning topics as universal as struggling, bodies, childhood, obsession, love, sex, loneliness, the self, addiction, parenthood, legacy, faith, the future, death, silence, and beauty. Each read in a single and uninterrupted setting.
No “bleeping” biographies or self-help books (p. 7), my two favorite categories (possibly excepting dreamscape or “witnessing” memoirs like Carmen Machado’s; p. 106). Lucky for me, my third-favorite category is fiction, which, it turns out, is quite useful for “test-driving” realities that emerge unbidden at the most inappropriate times of life.
Plenty of opportunities for “negative capability,” though; i.e., John Keats (1817) and the artist's access to truth without the pressure and framework of logic or science.
Plenty of aporias also, i.e., attempts to synthesize and systematize ways of dealing with information overload, and the paradoxes/double-binds of cognitive dissonance.
And a whole lot more about how we move through Life and how Life, in turn, “moves” us: “Just as we learn through being moved and moving through space as a child, we are moved by great literature, art and music, light and smell, clutter and quiet. It is paying close attention to those movements, these emotional moments, that provide clarity” (p. 61).
“We rarely seek that which we do not expect to find” (p. 83; Sabahattin Ali). And so McDaniel counsels us to use the Italian verb stare (to stay/first person sto; p. 91), rather than the excessive use of the English gerund (-ing), to focus on what we are doing right now.
Assisted by philosopher Hannah Arendt, he also distinguishes between complexity and complication (p. 148 and pp. 235-236); “work” vs. “action” or “natality” (p. 149).
He further notes that Paul Bowles’ “The Sheltering Sky” is “the most beautiful reflection on paying attention and mastering the present moment I have ever encountered” (p. 211). In discussing the concept of sidereal time, he asks “Do we pay attention? Do we let the wonder of the forms around us point to the dizzying and bone-marrow-scraping aporia [that word, again] of emptiness?” (p. 215)
This, from someone who is at least 11 years younger than me (April 8, 1972) and has already weathered three heart attacks, one major (p. 218), inspires an odd kind of FOMO, in that he continues to cultivate “a slow attention” that allows him to be fully present for others’ future hopelessness (p. 219), despite (or perhaps, because of) what are clearly a series of akratic life-choices.
By paying attention to relentless despair’s alternative, “complex and dismantling beauty,” in every moment, savoring abstractions and antitheses to closure (p. 225), McDaniel suggests that we can obliterate all consideration (p. 234).
The book opens (cover art) and closes, not with words, but with a painting, Adriaen Coorte’s “Still Life with Wild Strawberries” (1705). According to McDaniel, “Once seeing these paintings, just lingering, you cannot look at a piece of fruit the same way again. Coorte teaches you to pay attention, to stand in awe facing the vibrancy of raw existence, to remain in quiddity” (also known as “what-ness,” as distinguished from haecceity or "this-ness"; p. 241).
The book adds to the work of eudaimonic scholars “less interested in ideological pronouncements and entrenched positions and more interested in innovative approaches, interdisciplinary collaborations, and empirical investigations … the conversation about well-being, with its focus on the interdisciplinary investigation of the best things in life, [has been labeled] the ‘eudaimonic turn’” (Pawelski/Moores, 2013).
One caveat: while McDaniel’s syllabus directs students to read the suggested books through without interruption, he instead encourages readers of this book to intersperse readings of the suggested books between his chapter intros and before the related discussion prompts and further suggestions; to “sit with” the feelings reading these suggested books summons, which will likely be different for each reader.
Having not done this myself, and choosing to apply the readings of chapters most pertinent to me first (e.g., “Week Eleven: On Legacy”), digesting them over time so that they can consolidate in my conscience, I may actually be under-selling the merits of this book for others who take direction more readily.
Existential despair is the millennial state of being and this narrative really grasps the melancholy of the human condition. I am drawn to this title and was not disappointed. A formulaic approach to McDaniel’s class on the existential. This is a guide on becoming comfortable with uncomfortable discussions related to all thing's melancholy. Instead of being stuck in a state of despair we can learn how to manipulate this into our art and understanding of others. Through the connections you make in this book you are bound to find something relatable. The discussions here are noteworthy and focus on literature, poetry, and media that may not have a happy conclusion. An extensive but non exhaustive list to show you how he incorporates the readings in his classroom to have people engage. I do encourage you to approach this narrative in a decent head space. The material can be dense, but it is fruitful to gain something from. My negative critique of this narrative is that at times the author’s ego gets in the way. I want to hear more about how he uses this syllabus in the classroom instead of the moments of a hero complex. The inclusion of the discussion prompts, and further readings does highlight his passion for the project and why these discussions are vital! All opinions are my own. Thank you, Justin McDaniel, Crown Publishing, and Netgalley for this advanced digital copy.
3.75 rated up!
For tarot readings, recommendations, and reviews, check out my blog, brujerialibrary.wordpress.com
In all honesty this title was sent to me by error as winner of another book. The correction was made by the publisher, but by then I had read this unexpected volume and found much to engage my attention. The book comes out of the author's experience teaching a much in demand course at the University of Pennsylvania, described as the most popular course on campus. While the teaching experiences will appeal to educators reading this volume, I-not a teacher-found much to enjoy and store up within my mind. Reflections-mini biographies-of authors, their life experiences and actual words are enriching. James Baldwin and Hart Crane are among the diverse authors cited. Thanks to Crown and by extension Goodreads for this advance uncorrected copy.