Edward Hoonaert's "Alien Contact for Idiots" is a long, but charming romantic comedy with some notable sci-fi flourishes. But what makes it worth reading is a rare, imaginative characterization of one of society's most pigeonholed groups, the American Indian.
First, for those hardcore sci-fi fans picking up "Alien Contact for Idiots" in hopes of imbibing intergalactic intrigue and energy weaponry warfare galore...sorry. While exotic tech like "hop-flicks" and "nano molecular carbon shields" pop up, the bulk of sci-fi is geared towards advancing the time-tripping plot. However, author Hoonaert does score bonus points for crafting a plot that draws from what a "real" American first contact scenario with an "alien civilization" might involve. Though staying in the vein of "The Day the Earth Stood Still" scenario of public awareness of first contact, Hoonaert's quarantine situation (in which the visitors are eased, albeit comedically, into society) has been theorized in places such as a 2004 "Popular Mechanics" article as government protocol for handling first contact. It even has some loose historical basis in the since-repealed Title 14, Section 1211 of the Code of Federal Regulations' "Extra-Terrestrial Exposure Law." Of course, the book's greater comedic and romantic themes douce any hopes of this being some great E.T. expose.
As for the book's characters and pace? Early on, things don't seem promising. Any suspense about whether or not the visitors to the modern American Great Northwest are indeed "alien" is all but dashed by an overenthusiastic blurb that heralds, "When American Indians [officially "Kwadrans"] from the future move their entire island nation to our Earth, Ell Harmon makes the first alien contact." Furthermore, the innovative "human" liaison is a rather typically-drawn heroine in Dr. Elinor "Ell" Harmon: The smart, sassy white career-woman who has everything (including academic and political clout and even a name akin to the heroine of "Contact")--everything except true love. Sadly, too many such cookie cutter characterizations inhabit many modern romances, fantasies, and other genres--more playing to the base, perhaps? While the clash of cultures concept is obvious, it would have been more fascinating to have made Ell Asian or some other racial persuasion, and then read the results.
But what the female protagonist lacks in excitement and originality is more than made up for by author Hoonaert's painstaking crafting of the Kwadran civilization and its charismatic leader Prince Tro Eaglesbrood. This is the story's strongest selling point and a bold multicultural move.
American Indians are arguably popular entertainment's least represented and statically portrayed racial groups. Whereas blacks and Asians have risen from stereotypical roles in literature and film to become prominent, groundbreaking characters, American Indians are still rarely afforded more than pigeonholed parts in Westerns or as solemn naturalists. But not here. The Kwadarans are remarkably technologically advanced and captivating in their ability to transport their entire nation back in time--a nation that, in the future, is the world's most advanced! And what seems like a turn towards cheap pidgin English laughs and stereotypical spiritualist tendencies takes a sharp turn into intelligent comedy and social commentary that is driven in large part by Tro and his clever adaptation to Ell and the idiosyncrasies of the past.
So despite a lackluster leading lady and over length, at 300 + pages, "Alien Contact for Idiots" maintains a compelling plot and palpable sense of place that are bolstered by a refreshing and reassuring vision of the American Indian as capable of technological, linguistic, and even romantic prowess in popular fiction.