What do you think?
Rate this book
Whisper Me A Love Song 11
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
May 15, 2026
Picture a warm summer day, frolicking amongst a blooming field of lilies. Suddenly, you step on a rusty nail. While enduring that, you pivot into some medical waste, then finally wind up on a land mine.
Add to that the flushing of a thousand toilets in unison and you might closely approximate the loss of goodwill for the entire series to date that this volume engenders.
On the plus side, Yori and Himari are both making the most of their limited page time. They are the reason this series went anywhere and I wish it was far more focused on them (I would allow for Aki and Shiho as the side pairing).
There’s a ridiculous chapter where they’re on a date after school and decide to spy on Aki and Shiho to see what’s going on between them and it’s an especially charming diversion that also leads to Shiho letting her walls down a little more afterwards.
I also like that Yori gets given a bit more to do this volume, even as just a senpai giving advice. It leverages the time she’s spent dating Himari too, which is a great way to keep her relevant.
There’s also a series of silent panels presented when somebody calls somebody and the way the art comes together to present a gorgeous moment that’s really heartfelt and meaningful is wonderful. It’s very artistically done.
And it’s done in service to this stupid, stupid idea that Miki savagely rejected Ayaka’s confession last volume because she is in love with Aki. Who is also her sister. There’s that flushing sound.
Incest is annoying enough, but showing up suddenly after no hint of it earlier is practically a bait and switch. There’s no reason for it to be here and it is terrible. I often personally feel when it shows up in yuri spaces that there’s this false equivalency of ‘well, two girls in love is taboo, so sibling love is also taboo in the same way’. That is a lie - one of those is absolutely fine.
There’s even a moment where they could absolutely have walked it back, salvaging literally most of the volume, and choose to double down instead. Yippee. Shoot yourself in the other foot why don’t you?
It sucks because everybody just accepts this as totally reasonable and, no, I am sorry, that’s garbage. I don’t like this series’ yuri paradise atmosphere as a rule, everybody is basically pairing off as quick as possible, but it’s better than this cul-de-sac.
In fact, I gave I’m in Love With the Villainess a lot less crap and it also had incest. But it acknowledged it was a bit weird and, more importantly, spent the rest of its time espousing actual gender identity and sexuality. That took the edge off.
I’m not going to drop this, the implication in the afterward is that this might be tabled for a bit and the next storyline looks like it’ll be back on Yori and Himari. But I will be this savage about a volume that got on my case for 85% of its extended page count.
2 stars - what a stupid, stupid idea. It adds nothing except my considerable consternation. This has been one of the most reliable yuri going and that status been stripped in one fell swoop.
Add to that the flushing of a thousand toilets in unison and you might closely approximate the loss of goodwill for the entire series to date that this volume engenders.
On the plus side, Yori and Himari are both making the most of their limited page time. They are the reason this series went anywhere and I wish it was far more focused on them (I would allow for Aki and Shiho as the side pairing).
There’s a ridiculous chapter where they’re on a date after school and decide to spy on Aki and Shiho to see what’s going on between them and it’s an especially charming diversion that also leads to Shiho letting her walls down a little more afterwards.
I also like that Yori gets given a bit more to do this volume, even as just a senpai giving advice. It leverages the time she’s spent dating Himari too, which is a great way to keep her relevant.
There’s also a series of silent panels presented when somebody calls somebody and the way the art comes together to present a gorgeous moment that’s really heartfelt and meaningful is wonderful. It’s very artistically done.
And it’s done in service to this stupid, stupid idea that Miki savagely rejected Ayaka’s confession last volume because she is in love with Aki. Who is also her sister. There’s that flushing sound.
Incest is annoying enough, but showing up suddenly after no hint of it earlier is practically a bait and switch. There’s no reason for it to be here and it is terrible. I often personally feel when it shows up in yuri spaces that there’s this false equivalency of ‘well, two girls in love is taboo, so sibling love is also taboo in the same way’. That is a lie - one of those is absolutely fine.
There’s even a moment where they could absolutely have walked it back, salvaging literally most of the volume, and choose to double down instead. Yippee. Shoot yourself in the other foot why don’t you?
It sucks because everybody just accepts this as totally reasonable and, no, I am sorry, that’s garbage. I don’t like this series’ yuri paradise atmosphere as a rule, everybody is basically pairing off as quick as possible, but it’s better than this cul-de-sac.
In fact, I gave I’m in Love With the Villainess a lot less crap and it also had incest. But it acknowledged it was a bit weird and, more importantly, spent the rest of its time espousing actual gender identity and sexuality. That took the edge off.
I’m not going to drop this, the implication in the afterward is that this might be tabled for a bit and the next storyline looks like it’ll be back on Yori and Himari. But I will be this savage about a volume that got on my case for 85% of its extended page count.
2 stars - what a stupid, stupid idea. It adds nothing except my considerable consternation. This has been one of the most reliable yuri going and that status been stripped in one fell swoop.
May 14, 2026
Spoiler Alert
Sadly the last two non-same sex attracted girls are shown to be into girls.
Although one wasn’t a surprise, it does make this seem situation seem very unbelievable.
Also
TRIGGER WARNING
Includes a one way sister crush (incest)
Sadly the last two non-same sex attracted girls are shown to be into girls.
Although one wasn’t a surprise, it does make this seem situation seem very unbelievable.
Also
TRIGGER WARNING
Includes a one way sister crush (incest)
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews