I enjoyed this book. Felt like slapping Eliza and Nathaniel for listening to lies and not checking the information for themselves! Amazed at Nathaniel's trusting nature when knows Silas not as was! It was well done. I like clean stories with strong characters and a good ending. I especially appreciated the comments on what makes a good witness; how men and women differ. Fun. The extended epilogue was a nice thing up of loose ends. Very satisfying.