What do you think?
Rate this book
Hiding the truth from you is no longer protecting you. Sit and I will tell you what you need to know.
With these words the secrets of my great grandmother, Genevieve Silver, were unburied and my role as a Protector of the Elemental Magic revealed.
My name is Mara. I've always felt that there is something missing; that nothing is permanent. Why would I feel that way? I was raised with my little sister by my grandmother, who loved and doted on me. And then there was Cole Sands. Who could forget the blue-eyed boy that had stolen my heart. What more could a girl need?
Little did I know that with one secret, my life and the world I live in would change forever.
With these words the secrets of my great grandmother, Genevieve Silver, were unburied and my role as a Protector of the Elemental Magic revealed.
My name is Mara. I've always felt that there is something missing; that nothing is permanent. Why would I feel that way? I was raised with my little sister by my grandmother, who loved and doted on me. And then there was Cole Sands. Who could forget the blue-eyed boy that had stolen my heart. What more could a girl need?
Little did I know that with one secret, my life and the world I live in would change forever.
261 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 7, 2015
79 people are currently reading
222 people want to read
About the author
Marnie Cate
26 books69 followersMarnie Cate is a writer of coming of age and urban fantasy novels. Born in an Irish mining town in Montana, she always had a flair for the dramatic and a vivid imagination, and spent her childhood lost in the elaborate worlds she created with the help of her dolls.
One day Marnie Cate was struck by a powerful image in her mind. This seed created the world of Starten and the complicated world of goddesses and their touch on the mortal world.
Inspired by the actress Dame Judi Dench, she pursued her dream of sharing the stories that were brewing in her mind. With the urging of friends and family, she wrote in every spare moment she had.
After countless weekends spent at the local coffee shop typing away and people watching, Marnie finished her first novel, Remember: Protectors of the Elemental Magic. With the world of elemental magic and the humans they lived in released, the stories have just begun.
In addition to the Protectors series, Marnie has written her first women's literature books with A Broken Girl Collection. Chasing Caitlyn and Forgiving Ginger dives into the hard subject of how life's pain shapes us and how we can break the mold.
When not writing, Marnie enjoys reading, coffee and spending time with her family. She lives in Arizona.
One day Marnie Cate was struck by a powerful image in her mind. This seed created the world of Starten and the complicated world of goddesses and their touch on the mortal world.
Inspired by the actress Dame Judi Dench, she pursued her dream of sharing the stories that were brewing in her mind. With the urging of friends and family, she wrote in every spare moment she had.
After countless weekends spent at the local coffee shop typing away and people watching, Marnie finished her first novel, Remember: Protectors of the Elemental Magic. With the world of elemental magic and the humans they lived in released, the stories have just begun.
In addition to the Protectors series, Marnie has written her first women's literature books with A Broken Girl Collection. Chasing Caitlyn and Forgiving Ginger dives into the hard subject of how life's pain shapes us and how we can break the mold.
When not writing, Marnie enjoys reading, coffee and spending time with her family. She lives in Arizona.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews
November 22, 2015
While II am always the first to say you can't judge a book by its cover, I'm going to say that there are some exceptions. This is one of them. Beautifully colorful would be my two word review for this book, but really, two words aren't enough.
The story is intriguing. Taking place somewhere in the near future where the world has gone slightly topsy turvy (trout are land animals) and magic exists, it reads like a hybrid of a fairytale and a survivalist dystopian tale. The heroes are easy to like and the villains are appropriately nasty, but there is a depth to each that is explored well.
I will admit that there were moments that had me sniffling and wiping tears. While most of the story is light, there are some heavily emotional scenes. A definite must read for fans of all types of fantasy, not just YA.
The story is intriguing. Taking place somewhere in the near future where the world has gone slightly topsy turvy (trout are land animals) and magic exists, it reads like a hybrid of a fairytale and a survivalist dystopian tale. The heroes are easy to like and the villains are appropriately nasty, but there is a depth to each that is explored well.
I will admit that there were moments that had me sniffling and wiping tears. While most of the story is light, there are some heavily emotional scenes. A definite must read for fans of all types of fantasy, not just YA.
July 7, 2015
First of all, if there’s ever such a thing as a scratch-and-taste book, I nominate this one. There’s so much wonderful description of foods and drinks that my mouth was watering several times. Really, there’s wonderful description of everything – which is great in a fantasy novel such as this. The writing gives a clear picture of what the author had in mind, but it’s not so overly done that your own imagination doesn’t have room to create pictures.
As for the story itself, I really enjoyed the interesting mix of magic in an apparently alternate/future setting. Not a lot is said about what happened to the world between now and then, but it’s clear that some magical force opened up, at least for some. (At least, this is what I assume is going on, since I’ve never seen flying trout.) The use of the Elements and the goddess as the source of this magic was really cool. With the rings involved and the fact that a person’s magic ties to either Air, Fire, Water, or Earth, it reminded me a little of Captain Planet but way, way, way better.
The characters are great, mostly. A big focus of this story is FAMILY, and it was a pleasure to see such a close sibling relationship between the two girls as well as with Gram, who for all intents and purposes is a stepmother/single parent. The use of Cole as the love interest made me really, really happy – he’s cute and loving and romantic, but he also is supportive and respects Mara as a fully competent human being. I also loved that Meg, the little sister, is a strong young girl with tons of personality rather than just being a kid in need of saving.
I will say that the danger isn’t as fleshed out as you might expect. You don’t really see much of what the bad guys are up to. I won’t spoil anything, but the main bad “guy” was an interesting change-up from a lot of what I’m used to reading. But, I wasn’t always super clear on what the dark magic was exactly, or what they were trying to stop it being used for. Also, the sudden appearance of an important (I would think) character turned out to be a little flat for me.
Overall, this story was heartwarming and a fun fantasy use of magic in a way I don’t recall seeing before. The writing itself is pretty basic and easy for teens to read (I’m assuming that’s the main audience). There were some typos or formatting issues every now and then, but not enough to completely distract as I was reading.
As for the story itself, I really enjoyed the interesting mix of magic in an apparently alternate/future setting. Not a lot is said about what happened to the world between now and then, but it’s clear that some magical force opened up, at least for some. (At least, this is what I assume is going on, since I’ve never seen flying trout.) The use of the Elements and the goddess as the source of this magic was really cool. With the rings involved and the fact that a person’s magic ties to either Air, Fire, Water, or Earth, it reminded me a little of Captain Planet but way, way, way better.
The characters are great, mostly. A big focus of this story is FAMILY, and it was a pleasure to see such a close sibling relationship between the two girls as well as with Gram, who for all intents and purposes is a stepmother/single parent. The use of Cole as the love interest made me really, really happy – he’s cute and loving and romantic, but he also is supportive and respects Mara as a fully competent human being. I also loved that Meg, the little sister, is a strong young girl with tons of personality rather than just being a kid in need of saving.
I will say that the danger isn’t as fleshed out as you might expect. You don’t really see much of what the bad guys are up to. I won’t spoil anything, but the main bad “guy” was an interesting change-up from a lot of what I’m used to reading. But, I wasn’t always super clear on what the dark magic was exactly, or what they were trying to stop it being used for. Also, the sudden appearance of an important (I would think) character turned out to be a little flat for me.
Overall, this story was heartwarming and a fun fantasy use of magic in a way I don’t recall seeing before. The writing itself is pretty basic and easy for teens to read (I’m assuming that’s the main audience). There were some typos or formatting issues every now and then, but not enough to completely distract as I was reading.
June 26, 2015
Featuring a wicked witch of a woman and her mangy and power-hungry partner, a kindly grandmother, a Prince Charming type guy who actually is charming, the elemental magic of Earth, Wind, Fire, and Air, and a cast of ethereal fairies, this book really is a modern-day fairytale fueled by the author's vivid imagination. And I haven't even begun to talk about this tale's protagonist-- Mara.
Mara's transformation from timid ingénue to protector of the elemental magic under her Gram's loving guidance is an enchanting coming of age story where secrets are uncovered and tough choices are made. Oh, and if you like tantalizing descriptions of food, this book doesn't disappoint. As an example, it left me feeling very self conscious about my mediocre PB&J recipe.
Pick this one up if you are in the mood for a modern book with a classic fairy-tale vibe.
Mara's transformation from timid ingénue to protector of the elemental magic under her Gram's loving guidance is an enchanting coming of age story where secrets are uncovered and tough choices are made. Oh, and if you like tantalizing descriptions of food, this book doesn't disappoint. As an example, it left me feeling very self conscious about my mediocre PB&J recipe.
Pick this one up if you are in the mood for a modern book with a classic fairy-tale vibe.
October 18, 2017
Living peacefully with her Gram and sister; it is now time for Mara to discover her heritage, as a protector of magic.
I've been meaning to read this book for ages, elements and witches, and all things good.
We follow Mara who, now she has come of age, has two major changes in her life.
First, her childhood sweetheart proposes.
Second, her Gram reveals that she had purposefully removed Mara's memories and bound her powers, to protect her from a dark witch. But now is the time for her to realise her inheritance, and her destiny.
This is a nice and very gentle read. It would be suitable for younger readers.
There's an emphasis on the importance of family - whether it is those you are related to, or the family you make.
The whole story gives off a warm and homely vibe, and a lot of attention is paid to Grams house, and the baking, lots and lots of baking.
There is a lot of respect given to the spells and magic used. They are always accompanied by full descriptions.
The not-so-good.
It's too nice for my tastes.
Everyone's reactions are very considerate, and logical, and ultimately gentle.
Mara's "dead" father returns from his self-imposed exile. OK, no abandonment issues, and only mild distrust there.
Mara's Gram stole her memories, and bound her magic. No sense of crossing the line, or a breach of a person's rights. Straight to understanding and love.
Mara's sister is kidnapped; but even before the vision that showed she was safe, everything relaxed pretty quickly.
And don't even get me started on Mara's mum.
I know she's our heroine, but she is the most composed and mature teenager I've come across.
As much as I appreciated the respectful approach to magic, I felt it got a little text-booky and slowed the pace of the plot. The spells, potions and ingredients are considered in length.
Overall, this is a nice book, and I would recommend it for younger readers.
I've been meaning to read this book for ages, elements and witches, and all things good.
We follow Mara who, now she has come of age, has two major changes in her life.
First, her childhood sweetheart proposes.
Second, her Gram reveals that she had purposefully removed Mara's memories and bound her powers, to protect her from a dark witch. But now is the time for her to realise her inheritance, and her destiny.
This is a nice and very gentle read. It would be suitable for younger readers.
There's an emphasis on the importance of family - whether it is those you are related to, or the family you make.
The whole story gives off a warm and homely vibe, and a lot of attention is paid to Grams house, and the baking, lots and lots of baking.
There is a lot of respect given to the spells and magic used. They are always accompanied by full descriptions.
The not-so-good.
It's too nice for my tastes.
Everyone's reactions are very considerate, and logical, and ultimately gentle.
Mara's "dead" father returns from his self-imposed exile. OK, no abandonment issues, and only mild distrust there.
Mara's Gram stole her memories, and bound her magic. No sense of crossing the line, or a breach of a person's rights. Straight to understanding and love.
Mara's sister is kidnapped; but even before the vision that showed she was safe, everything relaxed pretty quickly.
And don't even get me started on Mara's mum.
I know she's our heroine, but she is the most composed and mature teenager I've come across.
As much as I appreciated the respectful approach to magic, I felt it got a little text-booky and slowed the pace of the plot. The spells, potions and ingredients are considered in length.
Overall, this is a nice book, and I would recommend it for younger readers.
February 3, 2018
Discovering she is one in a long line of protectors of magic has transformed young Mara’s peaceful existence into one filled with secrets and dark magic. Deceptions are revealed, danger returns from the past, and Mara’s life with her grandmother and young sister, will never be the same.
With a definite fairytale feel, this heartwarming YA coming of age story focuses heavily on family bonds, friendship, and tradition. The detailed imagery of meals and festivals was a delight to the senses. The author should seriously consider writing a cookbook! The elemental magic was interesting and well done, complete with fairies (and who doesn’t like fairies!) Though, I would have liked to know more about the dark magic and those who wield it. As far as the character go, my favorites were Cole and Meg. I felt they really came alive versus some of the others. Cole was affection and all around adorable, and Meg had personality to spare. I would have liked a little more background/worldbuilding to have a better idea of why the world is the way it is.
The last half really picked up the pace. Secrets and suspicions abound, and you’re not sure who to trust. Yet even then, you get the tender, positive, homespun vibe that is sprinkled throughout.
Overall, reading this book leaves you with that warm, fuzzy feeling of curling up by the fireplace after a home cooked meal. Remember succeeds in delivering a positive message—not by hitting you over the head with it, but by wrapping it in a charming bow of magic and imagination.
With a definite fairytale feel, this heartwarming YA coming of age story focuses heavily on family bonds, friendship, and tradition. The detailed imagery of meals and festivals was a delight to the senses. The author should seriously consider writing a cookbook! The elemental magic was interesting and well done, complete with fairies (and who doesn’t like fairies!) Though, I would have liked to know more about the dark magic and those who wield it. As far as the character go, my favorites were Cole and Meg. I felt they really came alive versus some of the others. Cole was affection and all around adorable, and Meg had personality to spare. I would have liked a little more background/worldbuilding to have a better idea of why the world is the way it is.
The last half really picked up the pace. Secrets and suspicions abound, and you’re not sure who to trust. Yet even then, you get the tender, positive, homespun vibe that is sprinkled throughout.
Overall, reading this book leaves you with that warm, fuzzy feeling of curling up by the fireplace after a home cooked meal. Remember succeeds in delivering a positive message—not by hitting you over the head with it, but by wrapping it in a charming bow of magic and imagination.
October 12, 2019
***HIGHLY ENCHANTING***
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
August 2, 2025
Ugh. So some of the things in this book were great. The magical things and what they looked like and felt like. But this "romance!" Kill me now! It sounds like the most boring romance ever lived. There is absolutely no passion. I was routing for Cole to go down. How does one get a love life this boring and then write it into a fantasy novel. Who would fantasize about that? I've got to admit, I stopped about 70% of the way through. I kept waiting for it to get more exciting. For something to happen that made me invested in these characters. But I could not. It was snooze fest boring. Which goes with its theme of everything smelling like lavender and vanilla. Boring! I'm having some mild daymares imagining what life would've been like if I'd let myself get married to the really boring, super nice, asexual accountant I was dating at 17. Ugh! No thank you! Life's more exciting alone!
March 26, 2019
I am not generally a fan of fantasy, witchcraft, the occult world, but Ms. Cate has converted me with this story, at least for this book. It is a wonderful family story, a story filled with values and mores, a story filled with hope, the conquering of anger and the concentration on the good in life. To honor all those things I must give the book five stars. It is well presented, this Remembering book, with a good story line which maintains to the end, and vital characters which breath life into the story. For those reasons I give the book five stars. I enjoyed it immensely. I think it was written for a younger audience, at least much younger than me, but still it was a fun read which I enjoyed immensely. Good job. Ms. Cate.
June 16, 2021
From the very first page, this story draws in the reader. From the description, and because it was fantasy, I had assumed it was set in a bygone era. It wasn’t, it was modern-day.
It is told in the first person by seventeen-year-old Marina, Mara for short. She and her family, a nine-year-old sister, are being brought up by Gram in a cottage on the outskirts of town. Mara has a boyfriend, Cole, who is there most of the time and one of the family already.
The thing that sets them apart, and what makes the story interesting, is the magic inherited down the generations. There is a very exciting and violent climax to the book that has magic fighting magic. Overall, a very good story.
It is told in the first person by seventeen-year-old Marina, Mara for short. She and her family, a nine-year-old sister, are being brought up by Gram in a cottage on the outskirts of town. Mara has a boyfriend, Cole, who is there most of the time and one of the family already.
The thing that sets them apart, and what makes the story interesting, is the magic inherited down the generations. There is a very exciting and violent climax to the book that has magic fighting magic. Overall, a very good story.
March 22, 2017
This is an interesting magical read. mara Stone and her sister Meg, live with their Grandma, mostly because their mother Eliza, isn't the nicest person. I think the story is well told and combines a magical journey with a great deal of friendship and yes even a bit of romance. The author does a great job introducing the characters in this tale and keeping readers interest in an inviting story.
November 10, 2019
Remember
by Marnie Cate
This book is a great connection to the young adult reader. The main character is a young girl facing her families past. She has to reconcile herself with the choices her mother, and grandmother did to protect her.
by Marnie Cate
This book is a great connection to the young adult reader. The main character is a young girl facing her families past. She has to reconcile herself with the choices her mother, and grandmother did to protect her.
September 5, 2017
This was a little to hokey for me
August 10, 2022
***HIGHLY ENCHANTING***
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
Merged review:
***HIGHLY ENCHANTING***
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
Merged review:
***HIGHLY ENCHANTING***
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
July 20, 2015
I don’t read a lot of teen and young adult fantasy stories, so fair warning I’m used to darker, urban paranormal book. This book centers on a Mara, a young woman learning to use the magic that she has inherited.
Family is important to the young, aspiring magical heroine. Mara has a great relationship and a special way of communicating with her Gram who is an amazing cook (cinnamon and cayenne pepper in peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, who knew?). Gram is also a magical adept who guides her granddaughter both directly and indirectly. Mara has to reconstruct sealed childhood memories of her own gifts and penetrate many secrets around her missing mother, who is coming back into her life in a malevolent was just as Mara develops her magical skills.
Mara struggles to unlock the magic inside herself and to protect her family and her boyfriend, Cole.
This book reminded me of one of those Marc Chagall photos where people and animals are floating in colorful formations. The elemental magic in the book involves many senses including taste and scent. Also, many scenes take place in the kitchen and you may find yourself wanting pancakes or other tasty treats, or at the very least writing down some of Gram’s innovative ideas with spices! This is a warm, family friendly story.
Family is important to the young, aspiring magical heroine. Mara has a great relationship and a special way of communicating with her Gram who is an amazing cook (cinnamon and cayenne pepper in peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, who knew?). Gram is also a magical adept who guides her granddaughter both directly and indirectly. Mara has to reconstruct sealed childhood memories of her own gifts and penetrate many secrets around her missing mother, who is coming back into her life in a malevolent was just as Mara develops her magical skills.
Mara struggles to unlock the magic inside herself and to protect her family and her boyfriend, Cole.
This book reminded me of one of those Marc Chagall photos where people and animals are floating in colorful formations. The elemental magic in the book involves many senses including taste and scent. Also, many scenes take place in the kitchen and you may find yourself wanting pancakes or other tasty treats, or at the very least writing down some of Gram’s innovative ideas with spices! This is a warm, family friendly story.
August 10, 2022
***HIGHLY ENCHANTING***
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
July 13, 2018
***HIGHLY ENCHANTING***
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
REMEMBER not only setup the worlds involved in this amazing story, but it drew me into the lives of characters I fell in love with...even the ones I hated!
This tale is magical and symbolic in ways that honor elemental beliefs and family sagas alike. While giving you a glimpse into the human psyche and how personal choice (or the lack thereof) can impact generations and community, you are given tantalizing tidbits of the unseen world of fae, gods, and goddesses. Beautifully described and masterfully executed, Marnie Cate delivers an emotional story with twists and turns. I have no doubt you will be sucked into this series, just as I have been, by the story of loss, love, family, betrayal, and elemental magic.
The more I read the works of Marnie Cate, the bigger fan I become.
The more I read in this series, the more affected I am by it. I cannot get enough and I am looking forward to book two...three...four...etc!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
-----
This is book one in a magical series about fickle gods and goddesses and the families who's lives they affect. Each book can be read as a standalone novel, but together, they create a rich and satisfying book series.
May 3, 2015
I received this book as a gift and set aside my usual fair of reading (crime/thriller) to look it over this weekend. I’m glad I did.
What a wonderful treasure of a book. It is small in scale but big in heart. Magic, elemental forces, spirits and spells all play a big role in this story, but deep down, deep in its heart it is the story of a Family and their loves. I particularly liked the interactions between the girls and their Grand-mother (“Gram”). And of course there is always the dark parts of the family, the black sheep which in this case is Eliza, the missing mother of the girls and the mystery of her past.
The author’s narrative and attention to detail in the descriptions gives the story an almost ethereal feel, a fairy tale quality that draws you in. You can almost smell the coffee roasting and the warm apple bread in the kitchen.
Highly recommended and I look forward to a part 2 soon.
What a wonderful treasure of a book. It is small in scale but big in heart. Magic, elemental forces, spirits and spells all play a big role in this story, but deep down, deep in its heart it is the story of a Family and their loves. I particularly liked the interactions between the girls and their Grand-mother (“Gram”). And of course there is always the dark parts of the family, the black sheep which in this case is Eliza, the missing mother of the girls and the mystery of her past.
The author’s narrative and attention to detail in the descriptions gives the story an almost ethereal feel, a fairy tale quality that draws you in. You can almost smell the coffee roasting and the warm apple bread in the kitchen.
Highly recommended and I look forward to a part 2 soon.
May 29, 2015
Homespun magic with a touch of menace
Author Marnie Cates has created tale primarily for a YA audience but one that will be enjoyed by older readers as well. The story concerns 17y.o Mara and her discovery that she is a protector of Elemental magic like the women in her family before her. The threat to Mara's family comes from another family who use dark magic. 's Cate's description of home cooked meals and country festivals make the story come alive. My only criticism of the book is that some of the characters are a little one dimensional, either all good or all bad but as a first novel and considering the target audience this is only a minor criticism. A great first novel from a very talented young author.
Author Marnie Cates has created tale primarily for a YA audience but one that will be enjoyed by older readers as well. The story concerns 17y.o Mara and her discovery that she is a protector of Elemental magic like the women in her family before her. The threat to Mara's family comes from another family who use dark magic. 's Cate's description of home cooked meals and country festivals make the story come alive. My only criticism of the book is that some of the characters are a little one dimensional, either all good or all bad but as a first novel and considering the target audience this is only a minor criticism. A great first novel from a very talented young author.
January 6, 2017
I would have given this story a five star review but for me the pacing was a bit slow, not enough to affect the story but for me I would have loved a bit more action.
This is not to say that the story lacks in action. It most certainly does not. Though when you get to the top of the mountain and see where you came from and what is to come. There is a sudden rush of joy as everything that has brought you to this point is reaching the perfect storm for the imagination.
I would definitely recommend this work for anyone looking for a break from the traditional "I am a wizard here is my wand and my magic." stuff. The magic used in this work definitely hits a point in myself and would with anyone who has researched or is a follower of nature magic.
This is not to say that the story lacks in action. It most certainly does not. Though when you get to the top of the mountain and see where you came from and what is to come. There is a sudden rush of joy as everything that has brought you to this point is reaching the perfect storm for the imagination.
I would definitely recommend this work for anyone looking for a break from the traditional "I am a wizard here is my wand and my magic." stuff. The magic used in this work definitely hits a point in myself and would with anyone who has researched or is a follower of nature magic.
October 15, 2018
This a tale of a young adult learning to trust her own internal good instinct. It is a fantasy, but still is for someone to learn their own strengths and to rely on them. The heroine is caught in a web of evil that her own mother has helped to create. Her grandmother has raised her and kept her from the evil, but now it is closing around her and the magical powers are returned. Somehow Mara must understand that she is the one that must confront it. There is a rousing ending that combines action with pathos, love, and loyalty.
February 14, 2016
Awesome new take on magic and those who protect it!!
Awesome book! Great characters and amazing new take magic and those who protect it. I love Mara and Grams relationship and how that turns her into the strong woman she is. I truly love all of the characters, amazing work. I am a new fan!! This book had me laughing, angry, crying, you name it, I was invested in the characters and their outcome.
Awesome book! Great characters and amazing new take magic and those who protect it. I love Mara and Grams relationship and how that turns her into the strong woman she is. I truly love all of the characters, amazing work. I am a new fan!! This book had me laughing, angry, crying, you name it, I was invested in the characters and their outcome.
February 18, 2021
Well, I wish I had known that this book was written for 8-10 yr olds. But even writers like Tamora Pierce, who writes for young readers, can do so without talking down to the reader and being so boring in terms of writing style. Even though I thought the story line itself was very good, I just could not get past the elementary writing style. I had fully intended to read the next two books in the series but that is just not going to be possible.
August 10, 2016
If you need a well written clean book
I love this story line. Good read, I loved watching the characters grow, the discoveries in the book, the loving relationships. Clear delineation between good and evil. About to start book two.
I love this story line. Good read, I loved watching the characters grow, the discoveries in the book, the loving relationships. Clear delineation between good and evil. About to start book two.
March 26, 2017
So much love and gentleness behind a fiercely protective exterior. Gram made sure the girls did not suffer because of their gifts and guided them both as well as Cole to use them for good. Some surprises, lots of magic, and inevitably sadness. But the family bonds are strong ... Loved the evocative descriptions, and the character portrayal.
May 1, 2017
This is the first book I've read for RRR, and at first, I was very excited. The cover is beautiful, and the book seemed to have an interesting plot.
Well... I'm kind of disappointed. The beginning was really slow, just typical life things. Eating breakfast, seeing your boyfriend, him coming to dinner, etc... Then Mara's grandmother revealed a huge secret. It picked up a little from there, but I could not get past the writing. I love the characters, and as I said before, the plot seems pretty good.
There are scenes where nothing huge is happening, and the author goes into a lot of detail about smells, food, tastes, etc. which is good. I'm glad I feel like I can smell the lavender, vanilla, and cinnamon. I felt when it came to bigger, more important scenes, that those were rushed, and I had no clue what was going on, and I felt like I couldn't keep up. I'm disappointed because I thought I was really going to like this book, but I can't get past 27%.
I did not finish it, but I may try again sometime in the future.
Well... I'm kind of disappointed. The beginning was really slow, just typical life things. Eating breakfast, seeing your boyfriend, him coming to dinner, etc... Then Mara's grandmother revealed a huge secret. It picked up a little from there, but I could not get past the writing. I love the characters, and as I said before, the plot seems pretty good.
There are scenes where nothing huge is happening, and the author goes into a lot of detail about smells, food, tastes, etc. which is good. I'm glad I feel like I can smell the lavender, vanilla, and cinnamon. I felt when it came to bigger, more important scenes, that those were rushed, and I had no clue what was going on, and I felt like I couldn't keep up. I'm disappointed because I thought I was really going to like this book, but I can't get past 27%.
I did not finish it, but I may try again sometime in the future.
December 11, 2017
3 star
It has a lot of really good parts, such as the excellent characterization. However, something is off in the world building. Starts with a fascinating world where all animals a little twisted. But then that isn't carried through and most is normal recent world only without tech. If author learned difference between lie and lay and followed through on the worldbuilding, it could be a very powerful book. Even just adjusting world building to eliminate ignored oddity would help. But as is.... It's just average.
It has a lot of really good parts, such as the excellent characterization. However, something is off in the world building. Starts with a fascinating world where all animals a little twisted. But then that isn't carried through and most is normal recent world only without tech. If author learned difference between lie and lay and followed through on the worldbuilding, it could be a very powerful book. Even just adjusting world building to eliminate ignored oddity would help. But as is.... It's just average.
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews