I wish Marvel would commit to an ongoing series for some of these characters and rarely find these single-issue comics fulfilling. This one, however, worked. It's a short story tat really gets to the heart of who Saw Gerrera is. I also appreciate that it didn't try to squeeze the events of the comic into the short time period before Rogue One, which the Jyn and Cassian comics did.
Me gustó mucho esta historia. Me encanta como establece de gran forma quién es Saw, lo comprometido que es a su causa y por qué es tanto un peligro como un poderoso aliado. Realmente te llega al corazón. De todas las historias hasta ahora, esta se sienta más como su propia historia y menos como la precuela de la precuela. Muy recomendable!
1.5/5 stars Saw Gerrera hates the 'soft places', Saw hates politicians, Gerrera wants to cause destruction and mayhem. Oh, and he meets the Ersos. Add in an internal monologue and a lecture about how no one has the right to judge him, that's basically the entire of this issue. Unlike the first two, which added a lot to both Cassian and Jyn, I feel like this issue was emblematic of every Saw appearance since his original Clone Wars arc: pointless.
I'm not even sure I can blame the writer for it. Like Alexander Freed with The Mask of Fear, including Saw in these one-shots feels like an editorial decision. And Marc Bernadin drew the short straw. So, because he didn't have much else to say, he fell back on the Greatest Hits. Oh, and a massive bomb drop at the end which is so stunningly aweful that I can't help wonder whether Saw was lying just to make Bail Organa squirm: There's so much character development in that revelation and Bernadin does nothing with it. Is Saw just a coward with a death wish, hoping someone will kill him because he isn't brave enough to do it himself? And why didn't Bail call him out on his story? All so we can get a shot of Saw tut-tutting about politicians? Why not lean into that as far as it would go? No, can't do: we have to end on Saw meeting the Ersos. Even though it adds... nothing to the story. This scene joins the only other scene I can think of that added anything at all to Saw's character: his first appearance in Andor, the scene when he asks Luthen Rael whether he would still be living in a damp cave on a remote world if he had just stolen millions of credits. Luthen telling him that that's exactly what he would do was the most in-depth look at Saw the franchise has ever attempted until now. And both of them never leant into what that meant.
In the end, why is Saw such a controversial character? Why has he so often failed to live up to expectations? Because, since The Clone Wars, he has been a terrorist. And most stories about him either lean into him being a terrorist, which makes him a villain, or has tried to humanise him. But how do you humanise a terrorist? Not even Rogue One managed it, treating him like a plot device rather than leaning into that frankly amazing introduction of him as a pseudo-Vader, barely held together by technology (he even has his own Vader breath). That's the Saw Gerrera I wish we'd get: someone whose so afraid to give up the fight he no longer knows what he's fighting anymore. And, if I'm spit-balling, that's the Saw Gerrera story I want: a confrontation between him and Vader, a perfect full-circle moment for both characters.
But if all we're going to get is more of the same, pointless stories about a terrorist with the occasional attempt to scratch beneath the surface just a little, then it's time to do something Star Wars should have done a long time ago: retired Saw Gerrera.
After the Andor issue, which I really only picked up on a whim, letting me down that hard, I didn’t expect I’d read the rest of these. Certainly not for a while. But once again had such a whim and I’m very glad that I did, because this is head-and-shoulders above the first. This feels like Star Wars: “In the Pale Moonlight” (iykyk). It actually had me gasp once. For a quick one-shot such as this, it does a lot of heavy lifting, and filled a gap I kinda needed filled. Why is Saw outcast from the Rebellion if they’re actively trying to unify? This makes… a really good case. All I’ll say, a really, really good case. As far as I can tell, this is a brand new writer with no other credits on Goodreads, and I’m impressed. In terms of continuity, I’m a little curious about the timing of it, but overall I think it works well and the story is good enough to justify a little leap in that department.
These Rogue One anniversary one-shots have improved with each release.
Cassian’s wasn’t necessary, Jyn’s was interesting, but Saw’s did what it needed to do. Solidify the methodology of how Saw Gerrera operates.
We’ve seen the tactics that Saw uses in Rogue One and Andor, now we get to see them a bit here in this comic. He is a character who has flaws, is lethal, and will generally do whatever he needs to in order to achieve the results that he wants.
He hates the Empire, he may even hate the Rebellion, and that is on full display in this comic.
It’s a good story for the character and this is one that I could see potential of getting a full series with how it ended. I’d like to see that from writer Marc Bernadin.
This is definitely the best of the Rogue One prequel one-shots so far. This one actually felt like it showed us something the movie and other media hasn’t. I also really enjoy Saw as a character. It’s so compelling to see a man as committed to the cause as him. You see characters we know, love, and trust questioning his methods - but you can’t deny that Saw has a point. The Empire wouldn’t hesitate to do what’s doing - hell, they’ve done worse. They’ve blown up whole planets. Saw is the perfect example of a man who has been so broken that he’ll do whatever it takes to affect change.
Number 3 out of 5 Rogue One one-shots (of which I hope there will be a collected TPB, but with none scheduled, I started reading the one-shots on their own). Officially called Star Wars: Rogue One – Saw Gerrera: The Price.
This one is better than I expected. Short, yes, but it also manages to raise an important question: is Saw Gerrera a rebel, soldier, or terrorist? Good short stuff.
This was utterly excellent, especially in the context of the recently released Edge of the Abyss. Saw is a fascinating character, not meant for the world that comes after the fall of the Empire, but well suited to do the things no one is willing to do while the reign continues.
The other stories in this mini series have been… fine. This one is a must read for Andor/Reign of the Empire fans.