What do you think?
Rate this book
Legends
Starlight
A little stalking never hurt anyone…
Or at least that’s what Akai told himself every time he checked on the human building the cabin deep in the woods. Before that, the man had camped there alone. Akai wants to believe that he’s only making sure the human doesn’t injure himself and die alone the same way his sister did. But it’s more than that, even though he doesn’t know what to do about it. Monsters aren’t supposed to reveal themselves to humans, and he’d already done that once before and narrowly avoided trouble.
For months, Cole Denny has felt like he’s being watched. Sometimes, he’ll find things near his cabin that shouldn’t be there. Yet he’s never seen evidence of another person.
Until one night, under a meteor shower, he sees something in the shadows. At first, it looks like a man. Then a wolf. Then something else entirely. Cole is always armed at the cabin, but he doesn’t want to hurt it, so he fires two warning shots into the air.
Wolves should not grow wings.
Now the creature lies at his feet—bleeding and broken--and Cole is dragged back to the worst night of his life when he lay dying on the road with the same red eyes staring down at him.
Enter the Legends world, where National Parks hold secrets—and monsters steal hearts. Starlight is a second chance, hurt/comfort, MM monster romance between an overly dramatic mothman and a human in search of escape. If Akai and Cole can face the past, they might have a future.
For readers who like second chance, hurt comfort, mm monster romance between a human looking for a new start and a monster who doesn't realise he wants a mate.
Or at least that’s what Akai told himself every time he checked on the human building the cabin deep in the woods. Before that, the man had camped there alone. Akai wants to believe that he’s only making sure the human doesn’t injure himself and die alone the same way his sister did. But it’s more than that, even though he doesn’t know what to do about it. Monsters aren’t supposed to reveal themselves to humans, and he’d already done that once before and narrowly avoided trouble.
For months, Cole Denny has felt like he’s being watched. Sometimes, he’ll find things near his cabin that shouldn’t be there. Yet he’s never seen evidence of another person.
Until one night, under a meteor shower, he sees something in the shadows. At first, it looks like a man. Then a wolf. Then something else entirely. Cole is always armed at the cabin, but he doesn’t want to hurt it, so he fires two warning shots into the air.
Wolves should not grow wings.
Now the creature lies at his feet—bleeding and broken--and Cole is dragged back to the worst night of his life when he lay dying on the road with the same red eyes staring down at him.
Enter the Legends world, where National Parks hold secrets—and monsters steal hearts. Starlight is a second chance, hurt/comfort, MM monster romance between an overly dramatic mothman and a human in search of escape. If Akai and Cole can face the past, they might have a future.
For readers who like second chance, hurt comfort, mm monster romance between a human looking for a new start and a monster who doesn't realise he wants a mate.
238 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 14, 2026
About the author
T.J. Nichols
98 books360 followersTJ Nichols (they/them) is the author of the Studies in Demonology and Familiar Mates series. They write mostly gay fantasy and paranormal romance, but sometimes gay action/horror as Toby J. Nichols.
After traveling all over the world and Australia, TJ now lives in Perth, Western Australia.
Free gay shifter novella when you join TJ's newsletter: http://tjnichols-author.com/lp/
You can find TJ on
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/TJNichols
Ream: https://reamstories.com/tjnichols
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TJNichols.au...
follow me on Amazon: http://amazon.com/author/tjnichols or Bookbub: https://www.bookbub.com/authors/tj-ni...
After traveling all over the world and Australia, TJ now lives in Perth, Western Australia.
Free gay shifter novella when you join TJ's newsletter: http://tjnichols-author.com/lp/
You can find TJ on
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/TJNichols
Ream: https://reamstories.com/tjnichols
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TJNichols.au...
follow me on Amazon: http://amazon.com/author/tjnichols or Bookbub: https://www.bookbub.com/authors/tj-ni...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 74 reviews
August 26, 2026
A Joyfully Jay review.
3.75 stars
Starlight is part of the Legends multi-author series featuring monsters of legend. I was intrigued by this series, so I picked up a couple of these, including Bootylicious, which I loved and reviewed last week. I really liked the initial set up here in terms of the flashback to Cole’s life before the accident and then the transition to where he is now. I don’t want to get into too much detail about how things all come together early on for fear of spoilers, though the key elements are established fairly quickly. The whole early portion is clever and interesting, particularly as we learn more about Akai. I am unfamiliar with the mothman legends (aka a harpy), so I really didn’t know what to expect here and I enjoyed getting some of the lore to this cryptid story.
The world building is interesting and the conflicts are engaging. I just felt like once things are established, they aren’t all resolved clearly enough for me. But if you enjoy monster stories, and particularly if you are liking the other books in the series, this one may be worth checking out.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
3.75 stars
Starlight is part of the Legends multi-author series featuring monsters of legend. I was intrigued by this series, so I picked up a couple of these, including Bootylicious, which I loved and reviewed last week. I really liked the initial set up here in terms of the flashback to Cole’s life before the accident and then the transition to where he is now. I don’t want to get into too much detail about how things all come together early on for fear of spoilers, though the key elements are established fairly quickly. The whole early portion is clever and interesting, particularly as we learn more about Akai. I am unfamiliar with the mothman legends (aka a harpy), so I really didn’t know what to expect here and I enjoyed getting some of the lore to this cryptid story.
The world building is interesting and the conflicts are engaging. I just felt like once things are established, they aren’t all resolved clearly enough for me. But if you enjoy monster stories, and particularly if you are liking the other books in the series, this one may be worth checking out.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
August 11, 2026
‼️SPOILERS‼️
After reading the book before this one, I just knew I needed to get my hands on this one. This one was such an amazing time and I was here to dive back into this series.
I love me a good second chance and meet again because these two haven’t had it easy. I feel bad for Cole because he was just trying to do the easy way after the accident that happened years ago. And poor Akai. Losing a family member is never easy.
When these two cross paths again, I was here for the banter we get with them. I laughed at a certain scene when he knew he was there. And when they meet up again, it was entertaining but it leads to very interesting things.
I love that Akai didn’t even realize he was the same boy he saved. Talk about shocking. I’m a sucker for a couples getting to know one another before jumping into a relationship.
Ugh, absolutely loved this book and I can’t wait to dive more into this lovely series.
I received a copy of this book and this is my honest review.
After reading the book before this one, I just knew I needed to get my hands on this one. This one was such an amazing time and I was here to dive back into this series.
I love me a good second chance and meet again because these two haven’t had it easy. I feel bad for Cole because he was just trying to do the easy way after the accident that happened years ago. And poor Akai. Losing a family member is never easy.
When these two cross paths again, I was here for the banter we get with them. I laughed at a certain scene when he knew he was there. And when they meet up again, it was entertaining but it leads to very interesting things.
I love that Akai didn’t even realize he was the same boy he saved. Talk about shocking. I’m a sucker for a couples getting to know one another before jumping into a relationship.
Ugh, absolutely loved this book and I can’t wait to dive more into this lovely series.
I received a copy of this book and this is my honest review.
August 16, 2026
Thank you to GRR for the arc.
This is the second book I’ve read from the Legends series and I must say the covers have been the been the best thing about them so far. While Bootylicious was mostly a bit too sweet and light for my tastes, this book just made no sense a lot of the time. The story was engaging to start with but rapidly dwindled off before ending rather abruptly.
I was really excited to read about Akai after the first book, but I think we got more about his chaotic nature and humour from Bootylicious than here. It couldn’t even seem to be sure about what Mothman should look like, at times describing him with very Moth like features but also having him refer to himself as a Harpy despite not having a beak or feathers.
Cole wasn’t a very engaging MMC and seemed very much to be lost and just grabbing at something different in his life. At times he came across as very selfish and childish, particularly in relation to his family who he seemed to have never been honest with yet expected them to know he hated his life: This wasn’t a great love story for him and even when becoming mate’s it seemed to be more about circumstances than because it was what they really wanted.
I really wanted to like this but unfortunately it just didn’t have enough plot or humour to really draw me in. I was just starting to feel like their story was beginning properly, when they get to the solstice gathering, and it suddenly ended. Nothing resolved, all talk of the difficult future they’d been thinking about throughout the book abandoned, not even any time exploring the festival or meeting anyone else. Very disappointing and I probably won’t bother with any more books in this series either now.
This is the second book I’ve read from the Legends series and I must say the covers have been the been the best thing about them so far. While Bootylicious was mostly a bit too sweet and light for my tastes, this book just made no sense a lot of the time. The story was engaging to start with but rapidly dwindled off before ending rather abruptly.
I was really excited to read about Akai after the first book, but I think we got more about his chaotic nature and humour from Bootylicious than here. It couldn’t even seem to be sure about what Mothman should look like, at times describing him with very Moth like features but also having him refer to himself as a Harpy despite not having a beak or feathers.
Cole wasn’t a very engaging MMC and seemed very much to be lost and just grabbing at something different in his life. At times he came across as very selfish and childish, particularly in relation to his family who he seemed to have never been honest with yet expected them to know he hated his life: This wasn’t a great love story for him and even when becoming mate’s it seemed to be more about circumstances than because it was what they really wanted.
I really wanted to like this but unfortunately it just didn’t have enough plot or humour to really draw me in. I was just starting to feel like their story was beginning properly, when they get to the solstice gathering, and it suddenly ended. Nothing resolved, all talk of the difficult future they’d been thinking about throughout the book abandoned, not even any time exploring the festival or meeting anyone else. Very disappointing and I probably won’t bother with any more books in this series either now.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 18, 2026
This one fascinated me. We had some page time with Akai through the previous books and a peek at Cole. Getting the whole story from both sides since the first meeting was what gave this story the depth and connection I wanted. I especially love how it isn’t a simple second meet to mating. We got their feelings and some angst instead of meet mate and happily ever after. TJ Nichols does that best. Makes them feel real. I am loving this series.
August 17, 2026
Hot Moth Boyfriend
I really loved this book, not only because Mothman is my favorite cryptid but because I really liked the chemistry between Akai and Denny. Their banter was fun and cute. I’ve been reading this series since it started and this one was the one I was looking forward to the most. I was not disappointed.
I really loved this book, not only because Mothman is my favorite cryptid but because I really liked the chemistry between Akai and Denny. Their banter was fun and cute. I’ve been reading this series since it started and this one was the one I was looking forward to the most. I was not disappointed.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I really enjoyed the premise of this story and thought it was well thought out and constructed. I enjoyed the characters we met along the way and felt the conflict that Cole had to deal with in his struggle to find his own way.
Cole Denny wants out of the family business. He never wanted to work in construction, so he was doing his best to secure a football scholarship, leaving the ‘family business’ to his cousins and uncle, and getting his family out of a situation that wasn’t healthy. But after a car crash kills his cousins and he’s rescued by a creature with big red eyes, Cole’s life gets thrown into turmoil. Barely surviving the crash and having to say goodbye to his hopes and dreams, Cole gets sucked into the family business and has been surviving life. Until he tries to scare a wolf away from his cabin in the woods and ends up with an injured Cryptid to look after.
Cole is deeply unhappy with how his life has turned out. He has pressure put on him by his parents to stay in the family business since the death of his cousins. Family means everything, but what happens when he tries to live his own life? Cole is kind-hearted and is ready to make a life for himself, but what will this new life look like now that he knows Monsters are real?
Akai is a young Harpy, and his family has lived in this area for a while; in fact, his uncle created the local legend of the Mothman. He doted on his sister, that is, until she was murdered by a couple of men hunting for sport. Filled with anger and seeking revenge, Akai sought out the two murderers and caused their car to crash, killing them both. He never expected that there was a third, innocent person in the car, though. Years later, Akai is intrigued by a lonely human building a cabin on his flight path, and he stops to watch, finally deciding to reveal himself but ends up being injured by the man instead.
Akai is lonely. After his sister's death, his family left the area, so he has been on his own. He also has a deep dislike of humans, so why this one has taken his interest is a bit beyond him. When he finds out that this is also the same human that he hurt/saved all those years ago, he realises that their fate lines have been entwined. Akai needs to decide what he wants. Does he want a mate? Is he ready for such a big commitment? Will Cole accept him? He has decisions to make.
I really liked this story and the relationship between Cole and Akai. It moves fast, but when you’re fated to be mates, why wait? They both provide each other with the support needed to start living their lives to the fullest. There are a couple of inconsistencies through the story, but not big enough to take you out of the moment. I enjoyed watching as Cole was introduced to a world that he never knew existed, and how Akai could calm him down with just his presence.
I would have liked to know more about the mate bond and how that ritual took place; it seems like a major milestone to take place in their relationship for it to just be brushed over!
Overall, it was such an engaging read, and I will for sure be buying a physical copy!
Cole Denny wants out of the family business. He never wanted to work in construction, so he was doing his best to secure a football scholarship, leaving the ‘family business’ to his cousins and uncle, and getting his family out of a situation that wasn’t healthy. But after a car crash kills his cousins and he’s rescued by a creature with big red eyes, Cole’s life gets thrown into turmoil. Barely surviving the crash and having to say goodbye to his hopes and dreams, Cole gets sucked into the family business and has been surviving life. Until he tries to scare a wolf away from his cabin in the woods and ends up with an injured Cryptid to look after.
Cole is deeply unhappy with how his life has turned out. He has pressure put on him by his parents to stay in the family business since the death of his cousins. Family means everything, but what happens when he tries to live his own life? Cole is kind-hearted and is ready to make a life for himself, but what will this new life look like now that he knows Monsters are real?
Akai is a young Harpy, and his family has lived in this area for a while; in fact, his uncle created the local legend of the Mothman. He doted on his sister, that is, until she was murdered by a couple of men hunting for sport. Filled with anger and seeking revenge, Akai sought out the two murderers and caused their car to crash, killing them both. He never expected that there was a third, innocent person in the car, though. Years later, Akai is intrigued by a lonely human building a cabin on his flight path, and he stops to watch, finally deciding to reveal himself but ends up being injured by the man instead.
Akai is lonely. After his sister's death, his family left the area, so he has been on his own. He also has a deep dislike of humans, so why this one has taken his interest is a bit beyond him. When he finds out that this is also the same human that he hurt/saved all those years ago, he realises that their fate lines have been entwined. Akai needs to decide what he wants. Does he want a mate? Is he ready for such a big commitment? Will Cole accept him? He has decisions to make.
I really liked this story and the relationship between Cole and Akai. It moves fast, but when you’re fated to be mates, why wait? They both provide each other with the support needed to start living their lives to the fullest. There are a couple of inconsistencies through the story, but not big enough to take you out of the moment. I enjoyed watching as Cole was introduced to a world that he never knew existed, and how Akai could calm him down with just his presence.
I would have liked to know more about the mate bond and how that ritual took place; it seems like a major milestone to take place in their relationship for it to just be brushed over!
Overall, it was such an engaging read, and I will for sure be buying a physical copy!
August 15, 2026
I'd like to start out by saying that I adore cryptid stories! There's something about the idea of the world being "more" and other beings existing on the edges, that really intrigues me. I've been loving all the "monster" and mates stories in this series and I have both positive and negative feelings about this book.
Positive: I am absolutely impressed with how multiple different authors created a world and then each wrote a little corner of that world. The recurring characters that pop up are the ties that join each separate book together and make these so much more enjoyable to read.
It took me half a tic to fully get involved with this particular book and I finally figured out what the issue was. While most of the stories deal with, what I would call, "adult" characters, this one actually involves two MCs that are physically and emotionally early twenties. Still on the cusp of adulthood and it shows in the way that both Cole and his mothman, Akai, are a bit indecisive and hesitant when it comes to making large future plans and decisions. I mean, most college age students would tell you that they're still trying to figure out what they want and where they want to go in their life, and Cole and Akai definitely fit into that mold. While there is definitely a physical attraction they also have to struggle with where they fit in each other's respective worlds - and that's not even taking into consideration their shared past trauma (and, no, I'm not going to ruin that discovery). Once I saw them in that light it was much easier for me to understand their dithering about their feelings - for want of a better description.
The negative wasn't so much a true "negative" but more that the author ended with so many unanswered questions and decisions. How are Cole and Akai going to navigate living in two different worlds - particularly since Akai can't blend in with humankind. What is Cole going to do about his parents - especially given that he's now going to have an extended lifespan? I just felt that the story ended with too many things up in the air and I really wanted more. I'm really hoping that the author will decide to revisit this book and perhaps add a second one that delves a little deeper into all these loose ends.
Overall, I did enjoy the story and how it fit in with the other books and I definitely recommend this series for those who you that like monster/human romance, like I do!
Positive: I am absolutely impressed with how multiple different authors created a world and then each wrote a little corner of that world. The recurring characters that pop up are the ties that join each separate book together and make these so much more enjoyable to read.
It took me half a tic to fully get involved with this particular book and I finally figured out what the issue was. While most of the stories deal with, what I would call, "adult" characters, this one actually involves two MCs that are physically and emotionally early twenties. Still on the cusp of adulthood and it shows in the way that both Cole and his mothman, Akai, are a bit indecisive and hesitant when it comes to making large future plans and decisions. I mean, most college age students would tell you that they're still trying to figure out what they want and where they want to go in their life, and Cole and Akai definitely fit into that mold. While there is definitely a physical attraction they also have to struggle with where they fit in each other's respective worlds - and that's not even taking into consideration their shared past trauma (and, no, I'm not going to ruin that discovery). Once I saw them in that light it was much easier for me to understand their dithering about their feelings - for want of a better description.
The negative wasn't so much a true "negative" but more that the author ended with so many unanswered questions and decisions. How are Cole and Akai going to navigate living in two different worlds - particularly since Akai can't blend in with humankind. What is Cole going to do about his parents - especially given that he's now going to have an extended lifespan? I just felt that the story ended with too many things up in the air and I really wanted more. I'm really hoping that the author will decide to revisit this book and perhaps add a second one that delves a little deeper into all these loose ends.
Overall, I did enjoy the story and how it fit in with the other books and I definitely recommend this series for those who you that like monster/human romance, like I do!
Review of advance copy
I am completely obsessed with Akai and Cole! This book was just as incredible as I thought it would be and I can’t wait for it to be released so that I can add a copy of it to my bookshelf! Akai and Cole have two awful meet cute’s where someone keeps ending up hurt but on the bright side they stay to help one another! I love how Akai was drawn to Cole even before realizing that they’ve met before and I love how Cole had an idea that Akai was out there watching him. Fated mate stories where they’re drawn to each other before even meeting are some of my favourites and these two do it so well! Akai is definitely a little dramatic and chaotic, basically the little brother of all the cryptids and I love that for him. He’s such a fun character and I really enjoy learning more about him after the glimpse I got from a previous book. He’s so sweet and a bit of a free spirit but also a little lonely and that loneliness led him to Cole. Cole is living a life that he didn’t plan for and doesn’t want after an accident happened and it made me happy seeing him find Akai who unintentionally changes the course of his life again and pushes him to do things for himself and find a path that makes him happier.
I think it was interesting how fate kept pushing them together under not the best circumstances but I really liked that they got a chance to get to know one another. I like how Cole helped patch Akai up and let him stay with him even knowing about their unfortunate past. And I think that this second chance gave both of them the chance to heal and start over. Cole became a new companion for Akai who was left alone for years and Akai led Cole into a whole new world with magic and cryptids. I also had a good laugh every time they brought up the accident that brought them together and I completely agree with Cole because if a wolf grew wings in front of me I’d also be very alarmed! Overall this entire book was a delight and I think these two are so sweet and also very funny. I am loving this series so far especially with all the unique cryptids and I am so happy about having another mothman book to reread! I can’t wait for what comes next in this world and to hopefully get another glimpse of these two!
Thank you GRR for the ARC!
I think it was interesting how fate kept pushing them together under not the best circumstances but I really liked that they got a chance to get to know one another. I like how Cole helped patch Akai up and let him stay with him even knowing about their unfortunate past. And I think that this second chance gave both of them the chance to heal and start over. Cole became a new companion for Akai who was left alone for years and Akai led Cole into a whole new world with magic and cryptids. I also had a good laugh every time they brought up the accident that brought them together and I completely agree with Cole because if a wolf grew wings in front of me I’d also be very alarmed! Overall this entire book was a delight and I think these two are so sweet and also very funny. I am loving this series so far especially with all the unique cryptids and I am so happy about having another mothman book to reread! I can’t wait for what comes next in this world and to hopefully get another glimpse of these two!
Thank you GRR for the ARC!
August 20, 2026
4.25 stars
Well to be fair, I'm biased because I love T.J. Nichols, hence why reviewing their book. Another lovely one to read.
This was a sweet and quirky monster/human love story, with a moth monster who is up to speed with current technology, and a human finding his way after a terrible accident which limits his life choices.
They met 7 years earlier when Akai had his revenge on Cole's crap for brains cousins, who had killed his sister (disguised as a wolf) and stolen the jewellery he had made. But he hadn't accounted for Cole being in the car, he saved him by calling for an ambulance, but Cole's hopes of escaping his fate with his father's company by football was lost by the injuries he sustained. Needless to say, I was on the side of Akai ref the cousins.
7 years later, Cole had ensured he had somewhere to avoid his current life by building a cabin in a remote location to escape to when he can, without realising he is being watched by Akai, who has no idea that this is the same person as the one in the car so many years previously. Cole is aware of being watched and effectively challenges him to come out, but when Akai appears to watch the meteor shower together in his guise as a wolf, Cole's warning shots catch his wing when he flies up to protect himself.
The story then develops of the two becoming closer, getting involved sexually and trying to understand how they feel about each other, with the backdrop of Cole dealing with his family who have no real idea of who Cole is or his sexuality. It also weaves a wonderful world of 'monsters' and the moth man lifestyle with their artisan jewellery making and nests.
It's a very satisfying read, and more a novella size so easily consumed. Love the cover and the title. Enjoy!
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my honest review.
Well to be fair, I'm biased because I love T.J. Nichols, hence why reviewing their book. Another lovely one to read.
This was a sweet and quirky monster/human love story, with a moth monster who is up to speed with current technology, and a human finding his way after a terrible accident which limits his life choices.
They met 7 years earlier when Akai had his revenge on Cole's crap for brains cousins, who had killed his sister (disguised as a wolf) and stolen the jewellery he had made. But he hadn't accounted for Cole being in the car, he saved him by calling for an ambulance, but Cole's hopes of escaping his fate with his father's company by football was lost by the injuries he sustained. Needless to say, I was on the side of Akai ref the cousins.
7 years later, Cole had ensured he had somewhere to avoid his current life by building a cabin in a remote location to escape to when he can, without realising he is being watched by Akai, who has no idea that this is the same person as the one in the car so many years previously. Cole is aware of being watched and effectively challenges him to come out, but when Akai appears to watch the meteor shower together in his guise as a wolf, Cole's warning shots catch his wing when he flies up to protect himself.
The story then develops of the two becoming closer, getting involved sexually and trying to understand how they feel about each other, with the backdrop of Cole dealing with his family who have no real idea of who Cole is or his sexuality. It also weaves a wonderful world of 'monsters' and the moth man lifestyle with their artisan jewellery making and nests.
It's a very satisfying read, and more a novella size so easily consumed. Love the cover and the title. Enjoy!
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my honest review.
August 19, 2026
Starlight
This is another monster book and I was intrigued. Who hasn’t heard the legend of the Mothman? As I was reading it, I found myself rather perplexed. If you look at the cover of the book, our main character, Akai, is a giant bug. I studied him for awhile, but no matter how hard I tried, I couldn’t find a way to picture him as intimate with a human man. There was nothing that looked even remotely familiar about him. Hands were claws, face was insect, etc. It didn’t help that the cover looked like it was a graphic arts drawing, cartoonish and unattractive. I have no idea what Cole, our human, looked like — I couldn’t get past the bug. Cole comes into contact with Akai, not just once, but twice, and both times the result is an injury that causes pain for one of them. You’d expect them to avoid each other, but fate apparently had other plans, since they are unaware that it’s their second encounter. At first. I can completely see how they might wind up as friends, in spite of their beginnings, but mates? I couldn’t even imagine them kissing and it was described for me! They did have strong, tender feelings for one another and we get love and an HEA and that’s always my jam. This is the fourth monster book I’ve read by TJ Nichols. Two were okay, one with a Minotaur and the other a Kelpie. I did not really like Scream and Steam. In this one, I really did enjoy the storyline, and of course, the writing, and I liked the characters. I am honestly not sure that monster stories are my thing, but TJ’s books are, and I like to read everything that TJ writes. This book is filled with plenty of spice (in the way I wish the shifter/fated mates books were) 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ It’s also for 18+ only.
This is another monster book and I was intrigued. Who hasn’t heard the legend of the Mothman? As I was reading it, I found myself rather perplexed. If you look at the cover of the book, our main character, Akai, is a giant bug. I studied him for awhile, but no matter how hard I tried, I couldn’t find a way to picture him as intimate with a human man. There was nothing that looked even remotely familiar about him. Hands were claws, face was insect, etc. It didn’t help that the cover looked like it was a graphic arts drawing, cartoonish and unattractive. I have no idea what Cole, our human, looked like — I couldn’t get past the bug. Cole comes into contact with Akai, not just once, but twice, and both times the result is an injury that causes pain for one of them. You’d expect them to avoid each other, but fate apparently had other plans, since they are unaware that it’s their second encounter. At first. I can completely see how they might wind up as friends, in spite of their beginnings, but mates? I couldn’t even imagine them kissing and it was described for me! They did have strong, tender feelings for one another and we get love and an HEA and that’s always my jam. This is the fourth monster book I’ve read by TJ Nichols. Two were okay, one with a Minotaur and the other a Kelpie. I did not really like Scream and Steam. In this one, I really did enjoy the storyline, and of course, the writing, and I liked the characters. I am honestly not sure that monster stories are my thing, but TJ’s books are, and I like to read everything that TJ writes. This book is filled with plenty of spice (in the way I wish the shifter/fated mates books were) 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ It’s also for 18+ only.
August 15, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✨I received this as an ARC from GRR Tours in exchange for my honest review✨
Another fantastic installment of the Legend series!💙
I loved this book! It was one of the books I was most looking forward to after reading the first in the series. Akai interested me from the first time he was introduced on page in the group chat with Boone!
And let me tell you, he did not disappoint.
In book 3, we follow Akai who is a harpy aka a mothman and Cole, the human who burrows his way right under Akai’s skin.
I liked the premise of this book quite a lot. I love a second chance, intertwined fates type situation a whole lot and I loved how Nichols approached this. I liked that Akai didn’t automatically remember that Cole was the boy from all of those years ago! It felt even more like fate since he wasn’t intentionally watching over him all that time.
This is the first book in the series where the cryptid did not have a human appearing form and I really appreciated that. It felt much more authentic to a monster romance. And it made for some great intrigue into how they were going to navigate a lasting future without Akai being able to walk down the street hand in hand with Cole in the human world.
My favorite part of this book tho, had to be the fun twist that the author took on the fake dating trope, but instead it was fake mating! I found it very refreshing and unique!
I really loved this and I absolutely devoured it, literally I read it in one sitting basically😂
Unfortunately I have not received the rest of the books in this series so I will have to wait alongside everyone else but I will absolutely be continuing with this series because I just adore it!
✨I received this as an ARC from GRR Tours in exchange for my honest review✨
Another fantastic installment of the Legend series!💙
I loved this book! It was one of the books I was most looking forward to after reading the first in the series. Akai interested me from the first time he was introduced on page in the group chat with Boone!
And let me tell you, he did not disappoint.
In book 3, we follow Akai who is a harpy aka a mothman and Cole, the human who burrows his way right under Akai’s skin.
I liked the premise of this book quite a lot. I love a second chance, intertwined fates type situation a whole lot and I loved how Nichols approached this. I liked that Akai didn’t automatically remember that Cole was the boy from all of those years ago! It felt even more like fate since he wasn’t intentionally watching over him all that time.
This is the first book in the series where the cryptid did not have a human appearing form and I really appreciated that. It felt much more authentic to a monster romance. And it made for some great intrigue into how they were going to navigate a lasting future without Akai being able to walk down the street hand in hand with Cole in the human world.
My favorite part of this book tho, had to be the fun twist that the author took on the fake dating trope, but instead it was fake mating! I found it very refreshing and unique!
I really loved this and I absolutely devoured it, literally I read it in one sitting basically😂
Unfortunately I have not received the rest of the books in this series so I will have to wait alongside everyone else but I will absolutely be continuing with this series because I just adore it!
August 17, 2026
3.5 stars. This is a captivating story about two lonely souls, a cryptid and a human man, who connect with each other first as friends, then as more. Akai - a mothman - causes the accident that completely changes Cole's life, and rescues him at the time. Seven years later, Cole accidentally shoots Akai and takes care of him. They develop a beautiful friendship, but it seems like they were destined to mean more to each other.
I would have liked it if Akai were described physically in more detail, as we only heard about his red eyes, his wings, his antennae and the hair on his body, but not the actual shape of his body or more about his face (did he look entirely like an insect?). He had an interesting and likable personality, but given the details about his appearance, I would like to know more about what attracted Cole to him.
I was disappointed that we didn't get to hear more details about the solstice party or meet any of the cryptids there. In addition, I really would like to have learned more about how they intended their relationship to work in the long run, and what kinds of decisions Cole made about his personal future. At times, it felt as if Cole chose to mate with Akai because he didn't know what else to do with his life. That was all left up in the air and the ending was rather abrupt.
Overall, I enjoyed the characters, the world building, and the humour. This is an interesting multi author series and I am looking forward to reading more books in the series.
I read an advanced copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I would have liked it if Akai were described physically in more detail, as we only heard about his red eyes, his wings, his antennae and the hair on his body, but not the actual shape of his body or more about his face (did he look entirely like an insect?). He had an interesting and likable personality, but given the details about his appearance, I would like to know more about what attracted Cole to him.
I was disappointed that we didn't get to hear more details about the solstice party or meet any of the cryptids there. In addition, I really would like to have learned more about how they intended their relationship to work in the long run, and what kinds of decisions Cole made about his personal future. At times, it felt as if Cole chose to mate with Akai because he didn't know what else to do with his life. That was all left up in the air and the ending was rather abrupt.
Overall, I enjoyed the characters, the world building, and the humour. This is an interesting multi author series and I am looking forward to reading more books in the series.
I read an advanced copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 21, 2026
"So now you don't want me seeing your nest... You're giving mixed signals. You want to see me naked, but you don't want to take me home."
It's been a hot second since I read a cryptid x human romance that tickled me like Starlight did.
Cole and Akai were such an odd, pairing - literally a giant moth with no discernible human features and a regular ol' human man - but they just... worked. Fate forced them, quite violently, together over and over and if that little gold string tying them together ain't what fated mates is all about, then what is?
The banter was exceptional - there were plenty of quips and funny moments that weren’t over the top and didn't take away from the scenes or feel forced. I loved how well their dry sense of humour complimented each other. They made me laugh so many times and their conversations felt so natural. So natural, in fact, that I almost forgot Akai was a giant moth until he picked a bug off a tree and ate it.
I loved their cosy moments at the cabin and their quiet intimacy with each other (that first morning on the deck included). The heat and the spice during their steamy moments was really well done. Ignoring the fact that they accidentally maimed each other each time they had a meet-cute, they were actually perfect for one another.
I do wish the ending wasn’t so rushed. I wanted to see solstice. I wanted to read about the stalls and the monsters and Cole’s interactions with the other human mates. There was so much build up to it that I wanted to be there, but I completely understand that there was only so much TJ could have included without spoiling the other books in the series or taking the stand-alone part out interconnected stand-alone. With the last quarter of the book a little more immersive, this would have been a five star read for me.
It's been a hot second since I read a cryptid x human romance that tickled me like Starlight did.
Cole and Akai were such an odd, pairing - literally a giant moth with no discernible human features and a regular ol' human man - but they just... worked. Fate forced them, quite violently, together over and over and if that little gold string tying them together ain't what fated mates is all about, then what is?
The banter was exceptional - there were plenty of quips and funny moments that weren’t over the top and didn't take away from the scenes or feel forced. I loved how well their dry sense of humour complimented each other. They made me laugh so many times and their conversations felt so natural. So natural, in fact, that I almost forgot Akai was a giant moth until he picked a bug off a tree and ate it.
I loved their cosy moments at the cabin and their quiet intimacy with each other (that first morning on the deck included). The heat and the spice during their steamy moments was really well done. Ignoring the fact that they accidentally maimed each other each time they had a meet-cute, they were actually perfect for one another.
I do wish the ending wasn’t so rushed. I wanted to see solstice. I wanted to read about the stalls and the monsters and Cole’s interactions with the other human mates. There was so much build up to it that I wanted to be there, but I completely understand that there was only so much TJ could have included without spoiling the other books in the series or taking the stand-alone part out interconnected stand-alone. With the last quarter of the book a little more immersive, this would have been a five star read for me.
August 20, 2026
I was so excited for this book after reading the blurb. The plot seemed interesting, exciting, and like it had a lot of potential for a great romance. In a way, it delivered because we do get a monster romance with some great characters. Akai and Cole were both likable on their own and their meet-again was as promised in the blurb. But once they meet and start to spend time together, the focus of the relationship was entirely on the physical and they don't really spend much time together. It felt difficult to believe they had actually fallen in love, especially on Cole's side.
Add to that how incomplete the story felt, I was left wanting more and frustrated that we didn't get it. It felt kind of like the author hit their deadline and had to race to the finish. Cole had so much potential for character development and he didn't really change, nor did his situation. He is left almost exactly where he was at the start. We aren't really told how Akai and Cole are going to move forward in any meaningful way. I don't want to get into any spoilers, but there were some scenes that were really important but weren't included or were glossed over. The ending was disappointing because it didn't really feel like an HEA and barely felt like an HFN. For me, this felt more like the first book of a duology rather than a complete story, and since that isn't the case, I'm left disappointed.
Add to that how incomplete the story felt, I was left wanting more and frustrated that we didn't get it. It felt kind of like the author hit their deadline and had to race to the finish. Cole had so much potential for character development and he didn't really change, nor did his situation. He is left almost exactly where he was at the start. We aren't really told how Akai and Cole are going to move forward in any meaningful way. I don't want to get into any spoilers, but there were some scenes that were really important but weren't included or were glossed over. The ending was disappointing because it didn't really feel like an HEA and barely felt like an HFN. For me, this felt more like the first book of a duology rather than a complete story, and since that isn't the case, I'm left disappointed.
August 20, 2026
This is part of a shared-world multi-author series that promises to be really interesting. I loved the first book I read (Bootylicious by Becca Seymour), fascinated by the world of America's national parks, the cryptids that infamously inhabit them and the nature-loving humans who fall for the monsters). Starlight didn't quite hit the high notes of book one, despite making my heart break a little and tears well up early on. I never quite connected with the characters, especially Akai, which was a shame as based on the glimpses of him I'd gotten in Bootylicious I was so excited to learn more about him and the other cryptids in the Monster Network. I think I struggled with not ever being able to picture Akai clearly from the descriptions (he's not a shifter, but a mothman that slightly confusingly calls himself and his species 'harpies'), and his relationship with Cole moves and resolves in rather abrupt shifts.
Feat:
- Human X Monster (Cryptid)
- Enmity to Lovers
- Hurt/Comfort
- Family conflict
- Starting over
- Monster-hunting humans
Feat:
- Human X Monster (Cryptid)
- Enmity to Lovers
- Hurt/Comfort
- Family conflict
- Starting over
- Monster-hunting humans
August 24, 2026
Akai has spent some time watching the man who camps in the woods. He has now built a cabin and comes regularly. Akai looks for him and follows him but there is no way he is stalking. Cole Denny senses someone watching him but while sometimes he finds things, there is no concrete evidence. That is until one night he sees a wolf approaching his campfire. Thinking to scare him, he shoots over his head only to have the wolf sprout wings and wind up in the path of a bullet. Now Cole finds a creature bleeding and broken and in need of help. The creature stirs a memory from seven years ago when he lay broken and dying from a car crash.
Your heart will go out to Cole and all he lost that night in the car crash. He has had to make do with his life but he is far from happy. Meeting Akai changes everything for him. Akai gives him a reason to live and not just exist. Akai experienced his own tragedy that night when lost a sister. He continues to struggle adjusting to life without her. Together the two are finding something of themselves they lost that night. Their interactions are cute and often playful. It was a delight watching them build something together. I have really enjoyed this series. If you are a paranormal lover, Starlight is perfect for you.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Your heart will go out to Cole and all he lost that night in the car crash. He has had to make do with his life but he is far from happy. Meeting Akai changes everything for him. Akai gives him a reason to live and not just exist. Akai experienced his own tragedy that night when lost a sister. He continues to struggle adjusting to life without her. Together the two are finding something of themselves they lost that night. Their interactions are cute and often playful. It was a delight watching them build something together. I have really enjoyed this series. If you are a paranormal lover, Starlight is perfect for you.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Starlight by TJ Nichols was a fun introduction to the paranormals/monsters from national parks, which took someone quite clever to even think of that premise. The MCs are Akai, a mothman, and Cole, a human trapped in more ways than one. He’s working at a job he hates and he hates living in his tiny home town. He thought he had a way out, but that future was taken away from him. Building a cabin in the woods is his only relief from everything. Akai has conflicted feelings toward humans, but finds Cole the exception to the rule.I wasn’t sure how these two would react to their second meet-cute, even if Cole does not know it as such. Little by little they shed layers of hurt to see what lies behind it. The author does an excellent job of making their relationship feel valid and their mutual explorations inevitable. The author is also good at creating the monster world and how it fits alongside the human world. Despite making a credible AU, I was not sure there could be a future for Akai and Cole. The author solves most of the hurdles the couple faces, but not all. It would be great if the author were to write a coda to tell us how everything worked out for Akai and Cole. I received a copy of the book from the author, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 13, 2026
Second chance romance with the sweetest mothman. Cole survived the worst night of his life because of a red eyed monster that sat with him until help arrived. That night also upended his whole life plan and has left him at a loss as to how to move forward. He's stuck in a job he doesn't like with a family that doesn't understand him. Cole's sole happiness is going to the remote cabin he built himself, but he often feels like he's being watched while there. Akai is the mothman doing the watching. He's also the mysterious monster that both caused the accident that changed Cole's life and saved him afterwards. They end up having to share a road trip that allows them to get to know one another better. This was a really fun and sweet monster romance, and the first one I've read with a mothman. Cole is a great character that rolls along with all the weirdness but still has some reservations about all of it. The way he accepts the differences between them is really nice. And bless the sweet heart of Akai and his initial disinterest in having a mate. It's a fun read and the world that is built in the series is definitely interesting, full of other cryptids and the humans who love them. Would totally recommend.
Review of advance copy
I really wanted to love this one, the last book in the series was fantastic but I went into this thinking Akai - the mothman - could shift into a human like the other cryptids in the series so far, and boy was I wrong. That immediately set the tone for me being so incredibly not invested in the love story between the leads. As someone who is genuinely grossed out by moths, the constant descriptions of the silvery hair, touching, having cum in it like little dew drops, etc. just had me immediately gagging and not seeing what on earth Cole found attractive.
Apparently I can get down monster romances with all kinds of creatures, snakes, orc's, giants, lich's, basilisks, sentient pumpkins, you name it. But my brain draws the line at moths, and it made every intimate scene and scene where Cole was adoring Akai and turned on by him having me shiver in horror.
Aside from that, the story itself was good, which is why it got three stars, but I could not get past that little dude on the cover being the love interest.
*****
I was sent a complimentary advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Thank you to Gay Romance Reviews for sending this my way.
Apparently I can get down monster romances with all kinds of creatures, snakes, orc's, giants, lich's, basilisks, sentient pumpkins, you name it. But my brain draws the line at moths, and it made every intimate scene and scene where Cole was adoring Akai and turned on by him having me shiver in horror.
Aside from that, the story itself was good, which is why it got three stars, but I could not get past that little dude on the cover being the love interest.
*****
I was sent a complimentary advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Thank you to Gay Romance Reviews for sending this my way.
August 14, 2026
Akai, a dramatic mothman, secretly watches Cole as he builds a cabin in the woods, telling himself it’s only to keep the human safe — though his feelings say otherwise. Cole has sensed a presence for months, but during a meteor shower he finally sees the creature shift from man to wolf to something winged. His warning shots leave Akai injured at his feet, forcing both men to confront a shared, painful past.
This story had an undeniable connection between Akai and Cole, one that stretched across every moment their paths crossed, past and present. Their initial reluctance to accept the possibility of a mate bond added a welcome layer of angst, and their curiosity about each other’s very different anatomy was handled in a thoughtful, non‑sensational way that fit the tone of the romance. The emotions throughout were clear, easy to understand, and gave the story real heart. I did find the ending a little strange — they seemed bonded and committed, yet not living together — which left me with questions. Still, the journey between them was compelling, tender, and full of feeling. This was an MM story with mature content.
This story had an undeniable connection between Akai and Cole, one that stretched across every moment their paths crossed, past and present. Their initial reluctance to accept the possibility of a mate bond added a welcome layer of angst, and their curiosity about each other’s very different anatomy was handled in a thoughtful, non‑sensational way that fit the tone of the romance. The emotions throughout were clear, easy to understand, and gave the story real heart. I did find the ending a little strange — they seemed bonded and committed, yet not living together — which left me with questions. Still, the journey between them was compelling, tender, and full of feeling. This was an MM story with mature content.
August 17, 2026
This story has great premise but I think it missed the emotional connection to carry it through.
I know this is a fantasy novel but Akai first meets Cole when he avenged the death of his sister and killed Cole’s two cousins whilst Cole was present. This situation was entirely swept under the rug - it’s a murder, it’s not a small thing that can be ignored yet it was.
They meet again years later and developed a relationship. Akai never seemed to have that conviction that he wanted Cole and Cole came off as very immature and whiny especially in relation to his job. Cole is lost and doesn’t know what he wants in life he just knows he doesn’t want the life he is currently living. At the end we don’t even know what Cole ended up doing (continuing on with the thread that he is lost and has no idea about real life).
Throughout the story I didn’t feel it between Akai and Cole and their sudden agreement to being mates really felt like it came out of nowhere. We are left at loose ends because we don’t get to see a future how they navigate their life as a human and monster mate (Akai is very obviously a monster and cannot live in the human world).
I know this is a fantasy novel but Akai first meets Cole when he avenged the death of his sister and killed Cole’s two cousins whilst Cole was present. This situation was entirely swept under the rug - it’s a murder, it’s not a small thing that can be ignored yet it was.
They meet again years later and developed a relationship. Akai never seemed to have that conviction that he wanted Cole and Cole came off as very immature and whiny especially in relation to his job. Cole is lost and doesn’t know what he wants in life he just knows he doesn’t want the life he is currently living. At the end we don’t even know what Cole ended up doing (continuing on with the thread that he is lost and has no idea about real life).
Throughout the story I didn’t feel it between Akai and Cole and their sudden agreement to being mates really felt like it came out of nowhere. We are left at loose ends because we don’t get to see a future how they navigate their life as a human and monster mate (Akai is very obviously a monster and cannot live in the human world).
August 18, 2026
This book is part of the multi-author Legends series. Each book is a standalone read and focuses on a different couple. This is the story of Akai and Cole. Akai is a harpy, commonly known as Mothman. Cole is a human male who is trying to figure out his future. Both Akai and Cole initially meet seven years earlier which culminated in three deaths. The injuries Cole sustained changed the trajectory of his life. Gone was the sports scholarship. Now relearning how to walk took priority. The second time they meet, Akai has seen that a human has built a cabin in his territory. He senses that the person is sad and approaches him at night. Cole, not realizing that there is someone else around, accidentally shoots Akai when he was trying to send warning shots. Cole immediately goes to give first aid and realizes that these are the same red eyes that stayed with him during his traumatic car crash. This is their story. I received a complementary advanced review copy of this book from the author and I am voluntarily leaving a review. The book is written well and is easy to read. I really enjoyed their banter. It was cute and made me smile. A good addition to this series.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Third in the Legends series, this one is about Akai (Mothman/Owlman/Harpy) and Cole (construction worker).
Akai is a drama queen, Cole is a grump. They argue a lot - which makes sense because they are so different. Akai cannot pass in the human world - he is not a shifter (like the 'monsters' in the first 2 books), so Akai and Cold have a different set of problems. Their arguing never goes on for very long, as Akai's personality is too cute to be annoyed with for long.
They originally met 7 years ago when Akai saved Cole from a car crash (that he had caused). They reunite when Cole accidentally shoots what he thinks is a wolf near his cabin. They are very attracted to each other, despite not even knowing if getting together will even 'work'. They figure things out on the drive to Yellowstone, and while at Yellowstone (for the Solstice party).
Fun book, fun characters - it's impossible not to like Akai. This one works well as a standalone - while we do meet some characters from the other books, it's very limited.
Akai is a drama queen, Cole is a grump. They argue a lot - which makes sense because they are so different. Akai cannot pass in the human world - he is not a shifter (like the 'monsters' in the first 2 books), so Akai and Cold have a different set of problems. Their arguing never goes on for very long, as Akai's personality is too cute to be annoyed with for long.
They originally met 7 years ago when Akai saved Cole from a car crash (that he had caused). They reunite when Cole accidentally shoots what he thinks is a wolf near his cabin. They are very attracted to each other, despite not even knowing if getting together will even 'work'. They figure things out on the drive to Yellowstone, and while at Yellowstone (for the Solstice party).
Fun book, fun characters - it's impossible not to like Akai. This one works well as a standalone - while we do meet some characters from the other books, it's very limited.
August 17, 2026
Review for (Legends-3) Starlight by TJ Nichols
I have found out that I love love monster romances. I love TJ Nichols, and this book flew out of the park for me. I loved Akai, who is a Mothman/Owlman/Harpy. Wow, that is a full mouthful lol. It fits really well, though. Akai just hit it with me. I loved the drama queen she was in this story. Now Cole is the opposite because he is grumpy. I love the banter between the two of them so much. I loved how TJ Nichols wrote Akai and what he is. This was so new to me, and I found out that I loved stories that are so different, like this story was. Cole and Akai met each other several years ago when Cole was in a car accident, and Akai saved him. And of course, the way the two of them met up again was great. Cole shoots what he thought was a wolf near his home. I loved the way their story grew and grew into what it became at the end. I just love the writing style TJ Nichols writes. She just pulls me into the story to where I feel like I'm there with them.
Nicole Harvey
I have found out that I love love monster romances. I love TJ Nichols, and this book flew out of the park for me. I loved Akai, who is a Mothman/Owlman/Harpy. Wow, that is a full mouthful lol. It fits really well, though. Akai just hit it with me. I loved the drama queen she was in this story. Now Cole is the opposite because he is grumpy. I love the banter between the two of them so much. I loved how TJ Nichols wrote Akai and what he is. This was so new to me, and I found out that I loved stories that are so different, like this story was. Cole and Akai met each other several years ago when Cole was in a car accident, and Akai saved him. And of course, the way the two of them met up again was great. Cole shoots what he thought was a wolf near his home. I loved the way their story grew and grew into what it became at the end. I just love the writing style TJ Nichols writes. She just pulls me into the story to where I feel like I'm there with them.
Nicole Harvey
August 17, 2026
Okay
I usually like this author’s books a lot more, but this one was… weird. Akai is physically different, but to make things work out with Cole, those differences are so glossed over, that it leaves much to be desired. How can he kiss Cole with that mouth? Yes, I’m picky, and when different species get together, I want it to work without taking away the differences. It felt rushed and weird, and there was so much potential… i liked how they got to know each other while Akai was healing in the cabin, and how they had to work things out between themselves, to heal the past, and work towards a better future for everyone. It was a good premise, it had really good points, but the glossing over of the differences, how the fact that Akai’s differences are what helps Cole bothered me. Good read, but I would have liked it better if the differences were not simply fixed and glossed over. But this is an author worth reading.
(Read via KU)
I usually like this author’s books a lot more, but this one was… weird. Akai is physically different, but to make things work out with Cole, those differences are so glossed over, that it leaves much to be desired. How can he kiss Cole with that mouth? Yes, I’m picky, and when different species get together, I want it to work without taking away the differences. It felt rushed and weird, and there was so much potential… i liked how they got to know each other while Akai was healing in the cabin, and how they had to work things out between themselves, to heal the past, and work towards a better future for everyone. It was a good premise, it had really good points, but the glossing over of the differences, how the fact that Akai’s differences are what helps Cole bothered me. Good read, but I would have liked it better if the differences were not simply fixed and glossed over. But this is an author worth reading.
(Read via KU)
August 17, 2026
Starlight is part of the multi-author Legends Series, that focuses on six different cryptids finding love. This is such a fun series and while the different cryptids communicate with each other over the Monster Network, each book is a stand-alone read. In Starlight, TJ Nichols brings us the story of Akai, a Mothman, and his human mate Cole Denny. Nichols writes such a creative and interesting story between Akai and Cole. Due to the actions of others, Cole and Akai unknowingly crossed paths in the past and meet each other again seven years later when Cole builds a cabin the forest.
Neither monster or man is looking for a mate but as fate keeps putting them together. They build a companionship that grows into more. In each other they find healing and comfort from old wounds and love together. I have enjoyed everyone of the books in the series and Starlight does not disappoint.
I received and ARC for my honest review.
Neither monster or man is looking for a mate but as fate keeps putting them together. They build a companionship that grows into more. In each other they find healing and comfort from old wounds and love together. I have enjoyed everyone of the books in the series and Starlight does not disappoint.
I received and ARC for my honest review.
August 17, 2026
There seems to be something about a shared experience that Cole, the human, and Akai, the mothman, had seven years before that created a connection or bond that has continued to exist. Cole moves to the mountain and settles into a cabin in Akai's territory. Cole senses a presence keeping track of him but it does not keep him from wanting to be there. Akai watches for Cole and worries about being seen, but it eventually happens and he gets hurt. Cole, who injured him not knowing him, does help him recover. They get to know one another while Akai is convalescing and an attraction blooms. They still have to work on making a relationship between a human and a mothman work. This story was different and interesting in ways I was not expecting. But that kept me engaged.
I received an ARC from GRR and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received an ARC from GRR and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 23, 2026
A mothman and a human, fate helping them cross paths again and again. A difficult past but their meeting leading to a brighter future.
I really enjoyed this story, it was no-angst, mid-slow burn, the right amount of steamy.
My only not really negative thought but what made me gave it 4 instead of 5 stars was that the last chapters seemed way too rushed like a a couple chapters were missing. After seeing all the details of their growing relationship, not witnessing some pretty important parts that were told and not shown made me sad. I would've definitely loved the last part expanded to show us what happened at the solstice party, that part went by way too fast.
I needed more, nevertheless it was a very cute love story and I'm definitely going to read the other books in the multi-author series!
I really enjoyed this story, it was no-angst, mid-slow burn, the right amount of steamy.
My only not really negative thought but what made me gave it 4 instead of 5 stars was that the last chapters seemed way too rushed like a a couple chapters were missing. After seeing all the details of their growing relationship, not witnessing some pretty important parts that were told and not shown made me sad. I would've definitely loved the last part expanded to show us what happened at the solstice party, that part went by way too fast.
I needed more, nevertheless it was a very cute love story and I'm definitely going to read the other books in the multi-author series!
August 29, 2026
This was... neither fun nor romantic, although the premise had potential. Multi-author shared world series can be hit or miss, and this one was definitely a miss for me. The pacing was wonky, neither MC was very likeable, they had some sex but no actual chemistry or emotional/romantic connection between them, the author skipped over
I feel like this is an author I'd previously decided wasn't for me, and then I got sucked in by the great covers and the fun way a different author portrayed Akai as a side character in their book. But I have to agree with my former self: this just isn't an author whose books work for me.
I feel like this is an author I'd previously decided wasn't for me, and then I got sucked in by the great covers and the fun way a different author portrayed Akai as a side character in their book. But I have to agree with my former self: this just isn't an author whose books work for me.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Starlight is part of the Legends series.
This is the second book I've read in this series, and I was really looking forward to it because what we see of Akai in the first book is pretty funny. But this book is a mixed bag—Cole and Akai have a lot of banter, but it's also a little tough at times.
Cole already has his life all figured out, he wants to get a soccer scholarship to get out of the town where he lives, but his cousins, after taking down a “wolf,” get into an accident in which Cole is also injured. That wolf was Akai’s sister, a harpy who can create illusions.
Years later, Akai and Cole meet again, but they share a past that sometimes weighs them down.
I really enjoyed it
This is the second book I've read in this series, and I was really looking forward to it because what we see of Akai in the first book is pretty funny. But this book is a mixed bag—Cole and Akai have a lot of banter, but it's also a little tough at times.
Cole already has his life all figured out, he wants to get a soccer scholarship to get out of the town where he lives, but his cousins, after taking down a “wolf,” get into an accident in which Cole is also injured. That wolf was Akai’s sister, a harpy who can create illusions.
Years later, Akai and Cole meet again, but they share a past that sometimes weighs them down.
I really enjoyed it
Displaying 1 - 30 of 74 reviews