3.5 stars
I loved all the references to Macbeth, Shakespeare, and literature but ultimately this adaptation was somewhat disappointing. One of the biggest problems is the failure to commit to having an unlikeable protagonist. As a child celebrity in Hollywood Beth barely has any agency, and nearly every other female character is more petty, ambitious, and fame-hungry than she is, but somehow she is the one who needs to learn that fame and money are bad? She is not amoral enough to be a believable Lady Macbeth, but she is blamed and shamed for vices she does not have. From the beginning of the story she wants her boyfriend to be happier and achieve his ambitions, to repair her broken friendship with Duncan, to have some breathing room from her mother and her team, and to get more acting jobs (which is reasonable, this is her career). None of those things scream love of fame and money. Yet at the end of the story she has been "humbled" and shamed by her father and childhood friend/love interest, and hopes to do some New York theatre - if they "let" her. It feels very paternalistic, and somewhat elitist (theatre vs film, classics vs blockbusters, etc.).
The money aspect doesn't even make sense TeenTV is meant to be a stand in for Disney or Nick (there is a slime award show) but those networks make a huge amount of money off of their child stars without actually paying those stars very much. While a portion of her money would go in her Coogan account, a significant amount would also be paid to her manager, agent, publicist, etc. I just didn't buy that she was some rich star. While the book acknowledged and showed how exploitative and manipulative the system, networks, and adults are in that industry, it still felt tainted by attitudes carries over from the '00's and insists on blaming and shaming the child actors portraying them as petty, depraved, degenerate, etc. Yes, unfortunately there is a "Britney Spears shaved her head" reference. This book was published in 2015. By the end of the story the child protagonists were shamed and paid the emotional price for wanting into the industry, while the adults and the Hollywood machine were shrugged off as an inevitable evil that just existed. I could be biased from having recently read Jennette McCurdy's memoir and watched Selena Gomez's documentary, but the entire Hollywood side of the story left me frustrated and it felt like blaming the victim in many ways.
This book failed as both an adaptation of Macbeth and a story set in Hollywood. Ray refused to give her protagonist agency or let her be amoral, failing to make her a believable Lady Macbeth. At the same time, she insists on punishing the protagonist for "ambition and selfishness" that she does not possess, while fully displaying the evils of Hollywood and choosing to punish and shame the child victims of that system. Some parts of the story were pretty good, there was some nice tension, and a fair amount of potential. Unfortunately, things just did not come together in a satisfying way.