Jump to ratings and reviews

Win a free print copy of this book!

9 days and 23:20:06

100 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book

We Go Way Back

Not yet published
Expected 2 Mar 27

Win a free print copy of this book!

9 days and 23:20:06

100 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book
Frances has imagined this wedding a million times. But in no version was she alone in her hotel room, trying not to cry.

In every version, she was supposed to be the one marrying Callum Sutton.

So how did they end up here?

Interwoven with the wedding weekend is the story of a friendship forever on the brink of being something more. From the early days of homemade mixtapes and drunken almost-kisses, through birthdays, weddings, life-upending bereavements, to the final heartbreak that led them here.

To Callum, marrying someone else.

As Frances unpacks her suitcase, there's a knock at the hotel door. Callum, in the flesh, for the first time in over three years. And the answer to 'will they, won't they?' suddenly becomes a lot less certain.

We Go Way Back is an epic will-they-won't-they love story. But it's also a novel about friendship, forgiveness, and figuring out who you want to be. It's perfect for fans of Dolly Alderton, Coco Mellors and Caroline O'Donoghue, but, really, it's for anyone who loves a good read-in-one-sitting, bus-stop-missing, late-into-the-night love story. This one has it it's funny and tender and sexy and moving.

320 pages, Kindle Edition

Expected publication February 2, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Niamh Connolly

1 book29 followers
Niamh Connolly is an Irish writer. She won the 2024 Women's Prize Discoveries award, from almost 3,000 entries, with the opening of her debut novel, WE GO WAY BACK.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
105 (43%)
4 stars
97 (40%)
3 stars
26 (10%)
2 stars
10 (4%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews
Profile Image for Sarah.
397 reviews277 followers
arcs-to-read
November 1, 2026
I love you St. Martin's Press 😭🫶🏼 I'm so excited to read this!!! 🤭🩵
Profile Image for ahmeeka.
235 reviews
November 15, 2026
[arc review] it’s 00:11am, I’ve just finished the book, and I need to review it before I do anything else.

this review will likely be all over the place, and maybe I’ll edit it tomorrow and smooth it out, or maybe I won’t—because if I can convince anyone to read a book, it’s going to be this.

I’ll start off by saying I don’t know what I expected when I went into ‘we go way back’ beyond an enticing cover, a good description, and comparisons to ‘one day’ and ‘normal people.’

except it exceeded all expectations, and I’ve not had such a visceral reaction to a book in a while—a reaction where I can feel the pain and anguish of the characters.

I’ll also add that for the longest time I’ve been looking for a book that feels like merry christmas, please don’t call by bleachers and this. is. it.

‘we go way back’ follows frances and her relationship with callum that spans two decades. a story of quiet pining, unspoken feelings, and so many missed opportunities—a true will they, won’t they.

I loved this for so many reasons, but one of my favourites is that frances feels so real, and she isn’t written in a way where she’s this perfect all rounded protagonist.

frances has trauma, she hates confrontation, and she is a textbook anxious avoidant. at the earliest sign of feeling out of control, frances will push her loved ones away because she is terrified of them leaving first.

callum has always been there, a reliable friend who makes frances feel seen. over the years, frances has harboured a love that she can’t really explain, and in every future, she’s always pictured it with him.

except in this one—the very real one—callum is getting married to someone else.

I was on the edge of my seat until the very last page, and I need more. I need more of frances and callum. I need more of dolly and stella and clare and alistair and all the characters that made this book what it is.

while this is a fantastic second chance romance, it’s also a brilliant story that depicts trauma, friendships, getting things wrong, making amends, and hope.

I can’t believe this is niamh connolly’s debut novel! it only shows what an incredible author she is, and I’m really excited to read anything she puts out there in the future.

thank you hodder & stoughton for the advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review!
Profile Image for Stephanie.
547 reviews211 followers
November 2, 2026
A solid four stars about two friends who meet when they’re twelve, and everything that happens with them 20+ years later.

We Go Way Back is receiving comparisons to two books I've never read (but did see the screen adaptations!), Normal People and One Day.
Two people who meet when they're young, and after years of back and forth, realize they truly do love each other, and this is without spoilers.This is a second chance romance, told with Irish prose that I love.

Frances is back in Ireland for a friend’s wedding, except this is the wedding she always imagined would be hers - marrying her longtime best friend, Callum Sutton. Instead, she’s single, alone in her hotel room, and bracing herself for four grueling days of putting on a brave face while Callum marries someone else.

Should she shy away from expressing her love to him, or should she stay clear away from destroying a future family? Tough decisions, but also important ones, because if Callum still loves her, shouldn't he call off the wedding?

The story flashes back through their complicated, years-long history, without interrupting they inevitable will or won't they premise.

While We Go Way Back is just as much about friendship, forgiveness, and figuring out who you want to be as you get older. The romantic tension is a testament to how authentically messy love can be, friendship included.

While I found the ending to be a bit rushed, I did enjoy this romance as it's fairly deep as opposed to witty and clumsy as many romances are these days.
I look forward to what Niamh Connolly writes next!
Profile Image for Lynn Peterson.
1,313 reviews388 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 18, 2026
Oompf . . .what did I just finish - my brain needs time to slow down and reflect on this book. I felt like I was racing to the end and now that it ended I don't want it to end. Niamh Connolly is a shining star in her debut novel, We Go Way Back, wherein she somehow manages to create so many perfectly imperfect characters that I want to move in the Sutters and become their friend too. Frances has not had an easy life, she really hasn't but she has somehow surrounded herself with the best people out there (only sometimes she doesn't realize it). She is so hard on herself but tries so very hard to be her best. Callum has not had an easy life either, losing both parents to a car accident, but somehow he manages to put on a smile and put everyone before himself. These two "orphans" meet at the Sutter home and their lives are never the same afterwards. But Frances' mind just keeps getting in the way of asking for and getting everything her heart desires.

Life moves on in time and distance and these two people meet time and again at different stages of their lives. This was just an intense ride to watch Frances as a little girl growing up and branching out into the world. My heart was in my throat most of this book watching these two and I have to say I actually agree with the similarities to Normal People and One Day. Niamh Connolly writes about normal everyday people who just happen to surround themselves with extraordinary people who cheerlead for them and call them out when they fail.

Can you imagine the heartbreak of watching the one you let get away marry someone else? And all that it conjures up in your heart and head? This book interweaves the present with the past so as a reader you really learn about these characters and their heartbreaks and triumphs.

A resounding successful debut novel - I cannot wait to see what Ms. Connolly comes up with next - I will definitely be reading it. Thank you so much to St Martin's Press and NetGalley and Niamh Connolly for this amazing e-ARC. Put this on your TBR when you want to escape the happy world for a few days and dive into sadness mixed with hope when a girl loves a boy . . . but just can't tell him. Publishes February 2, 2027.
Profile Image for Donna McCaul Thibodeau.
1,533 reviews38 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 7, 2026
Frances always could picture herself in a hotel the night before a wedding. But in her dreams, she was the one marrying Callum. How did things come to this? We need to go back to how things started...
In full transparency, I am not the audience this book was written for, I'm sixty five years old. I'm sure that younger women have a totally different opinion. I found Frances to be one of the most annoying characters I have ever read. Her childhood was tragic, but she let it overshadow every aspect of her life. If anyone was a good candidate for therapy, it's Frances. And the ending? All I could think about was that poor bride getting dumped at the very last minute. It took Callum that long to realize he still loved Frances? This was definitely not a favorite of mine.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Cara McDermott.
104 reviews13 followers
October 10, 2026
Think Normal People meets One Day, with a little Sorrow and Bliss thrown in. Romantic without being sentimental, sad without being relentlessly bleak. It’s not even published yet and I’m already looking forward to whatever Connolly writes next.
Profile Image for Angie Miale.
1,542 reviews239 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 13, 2026
🇮🇪 If Sally Rooney’s Normal People broke your heart, you need to put We Go Way Back by Niamh Connolly on your radar! 💚

This February 2027 release from St. Martin’s Press is a beautifully written Irish romance that feels so authentic to contemporary Irish life. It’s hard to believe this is a debut novel!

📖 Meet Frances and Callum. He’s her best friend’s brother, and they’ve known each other for years. We learn early on that Callum is getting married… but not to Frances. And she has some complicated feelings about that. 👀

What unfolds is part second-chance romance, part coming-of-age story, exploring the messy, complicated ways people grow up, fall in love, make terrible decisions, and sometimes hurt the people they care about most.

What impressed me most was the structure and passage of time. The story moves back and forth across different periods in Frances and Callum’s lives, yet I never struggled to understand who they were or where they were emotionally. That’s incredibly difficult to pull off, especially in a debut! The characters are endearing even when their behavior is downright reprehensible. And that messiness makes them feel wonderfully human.

The writing reminded me so much of Sally Rooney, particularly Normal People. It has that same distinctly Irish atmosphere, emotional complexity, and unflinching examination of relationships.

🔥 A small personal caveat: There are a couple of open-door scenes, but it’s more the frequently sexual nature of the conversations that wasn’t entirely my style. That’s purely a matter of personal preference and didn’t take away from how impressed I was with the writing.

Overall, this was a wonderful read, and I suspect we’ll be hearing a LOT about it come February. Request that ARC now so you can say you read it before everyone else falls in love with it! 📚💚

💌 Thank you to St. Martin’s Press for the complimentary electronic ARC, and to Sherry for putting this one on my radar!

💬 QOTD: Do you enjoy romances that follow characters over many years, or do you prefer stories that unfold over a shorter period?
Profile Image for Fernanda (ivyfer_isreading).
502 reviews150 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
November 16, 2026
We Go Way Back is a Sally Rooney-esque novel(but in the normal people sense, not the beautiful world one, which is my preference) with a lot of yearning and emotion. I immediately got the comparison, the writing is very reminiscent of Rooney's, it's that type of dialogue that isn't bad but I can't quite point out why it is weird, and the setting of course. 
I didn't know much going into it, I saw the praise by Emma Brodie on the cover and had to get it, since into the blue is one of my favorite books of the year. I think this is once more a fault of marketing, this is more enjoyable as a character study than as a romance, and if I had gone in expecting that maybe my experience would've been better. 
The characters are very unlikable, they make some rash decisions and it gives the “you deserve each other, in a bad way” vibe. I recognize how good the author is at making you feel, there are some great parts where you will ache for these characters, and those were my favorites. 
I can't say I enjoyed it, but I see why people did. It's a good debut though, that I must admit. 

Thank you Netgalley and SMP for the ARC. 
Profile Image for daisy.
435 reviews1,092 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 16, 2026
this is about to be THE lit fic release of 2027
Profile Image for Kayla.
133 reviews118 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 19, 2026
The comps for this book were One Day and Normal People, but with maybe slightly less emotional devastation. For me, that's music to my ears. I simply cannot get enough of stories about two people who are consistently circling each other in their lives and we, the reader, have to find out if they will finally pull through and get it together.

Niamh Connolly's writing absolutely shines in this. I fell in love with her prose and pacing throughout the story. It's told between past and present, similar to many books like this, but never once did I feel annoyed at having to be in one time period or another. Each chapter was very intentional and necessary for the buildup and foundation of Frances and Callum.

I was unable to put this book down because I was so eager to see how it would end. Can you imagine, having to watch the love of your life marry someone else? How heartbreaking that would be? The push and pull of Frances and Callum was so real to me. I genuinely did not know how the story was going to end! And even though these characters did frustrate me at time, they felt so human and raw in their emotions. I couldn't get enough.

Thank you SMP and Netgalley for the ARC!
Profile Image for Haley.
72 reviews
tbr-arc
November 16, 2026
pre-read: the netgalley gods really do be looking out for me rn 🙂‍↕️🙏 thank you st. martin's press for more yearning and pain!!
Profile Image for Madison.
301 reviews15 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 17, 2026
4.5 ☆

Thank you St. Martins Press for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.

I really loved this story and connected deeply to Frances and Callum. There's something so specific about a will-they-won't-they book that has you clinging to the pages to see how it will all unfold. Meeting Frances and Callum both in adolescence and growing along with them through the complexities of being a teen all the way through becoming a grown adult made a beautiful rounded story that simply made parting from them irresistibly hard. I loved the layout of this story with each chapter as a different year in their shared story that then ended back to the present day. This flowed seamlessly and kept the progression at a steady pace throughout.

Meeting Frances as a confused child grieving her mother, while concurrently being sent to another country to stay with her cold and unwelcoming grandmother who overtook custody, immediately left me wanting to jump through the pages to protect her. She gets sent away to a boarding school where her she quickly falls into the hands of Dolly, her roommate, who not only becomes her best friend, but warmly welcomed within the circle of her family which ends up becoming a safe landing pad that she was lacking since her mom passed. And Callum, similarly to Frances, lost his parents young and fell into the care of his aunt, uncle who just happened to be Dolly's family. The way Dolly and her family (Clare, Alistar, and Stella) accepted Frances and Callum with open arms and an infinitely deep well of love was such a pure dynamic to read about. It genuinely added a tender wholesome element to a story that contained a lot of complex, heavy themes. The mental illness, grief and trauma were explored in this raw manner that felt very personal to me. I felt myself seeping into the pages with a long awaited relatability I have been looking for. Frances and Callum were both dealt such unfair cards and seeing the way that they navigated the trauma in every capacity kept my emotions ebbing and flowing throughout the entirety of this novel. I hurt with them, I grieved with them, I cried with them, I was angry with them (or at them sometimes lol). Watching their friendship cycle on the border of being something more for just about 20 years and how through each stage of their life it began to change and shift with time, although not a unique concept, was done with such certainty in it's plotline with well crafted characterization that made this author's debut novel stick out to me as a very memorable read of 2026. I look forward to seeing what the author has in store for future publication. My only reservation from not giving it the full 5 stars is the ending felt a bit rushed for what the last 15 percent put you through. I was gripping my kindle so tightly and the resolution came a bit quickly. I think I was hoping for a bit more than what was given. Still, it was a very pleasant read I look forward to revisiting.
Profile Image for Tate.
314 reviews7 followers
November 2, 2026
Tagged as "If My Best Friend's Wedding was written by Sally Rooney" but BETTER. I'd say it's Normal People if it were half as traumatic and had a happier ending. This book didn't leave me with a horrible ache in my chest, but I experienced a rollercoaster of emotions and nostalgia while reading (positive).

I loved the setup of this story. Each chapter takes you back to a different year in our characters' lives (starting in the early 2000s), and at the end of these chapters, you're brought back to the present day and left wondering how we got here. I couldn't put it down. The characters were dynamic and easy to love (other than our girl Frances... I found myself SO frustrated with her throughout the story, but I think that was intentional).

I can't wait for this book to hit the shelves early next year. Adding Niamh Connolly to my list of auto-buy authors. Thank you Macmillan and NetGalley for the ARC!
Profile Image for Lex.ᐟ.
422 reviews1 follower
November 3, 2026
Rating: 3.50⭐️ | Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!! 🫶🏻

This was so sad oh my god. I had a great time reading it, but oh my.
France’s my girl just needs a hug. Her relationship with Callum through the years was very real in a way it seems realistic and ai think that’s why it hit me lol. And the misunderstandings are just something I hate in books, however I think like I mentioned but, I do want to say since it felt very real and almost raw in a way that it worked out because these types of things happen all the time with people.
Profile Image for ReneeReads.
1,867 reviews156 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 6, 2026
I thought this was going to be a sweet and fluffy rom-com but what we get with this book is so much more. It's complicated and relatable and it will hook you from page one. This is more of a love story than a rom com to which I am grateful for. While I didn't love the way the conclusion was handled, I think that made it more relatable in that life is messy and decisions can often have consequences both good and bad.

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for access to the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Sherry Moyer.
859 reviews34 followers
October 27, 2026
𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗛𝗔𝗣𝗦
Frances is alone and lonely, a young girl at boarding school who is taken under the wing of Dolly and her loving family. It’s there that she meets Dolly’s cousin Callum, a boy almost her age who has suffered a loss similar to Frances’.

The two become friends, and the yearning becomes a third party in their relationship as in weaves in and out of two decades.

Their past is told with interstitials. It’s wedding weekend—just not the one Frances imagined for herself.

But then Callum is at her door. Unbelievably. Unexpectedly. Three years have passed since everything fell apart and now they will have to face all of the problems they’ve tried to leave in the past.

𝗙𝗘𝗘𝗟𝗜𝗡𝗚𝗦
My gosh. This is a debut?

I was immediately taken with this story, these characters, their deep flaws and unforgivable choices, their insecurities and unabiding desire. I wanted to strangle them as much as I wanted to hold them close.

There’s a family instrumental in Frances and Callum’s story: Dolly and Stella, Callum’s cousins, along with Alastair and Claire, the girls’ parents. Each brings something to this story, each as compelling as the leads.

The way in which the story unravels uniquely builds suspense, helping the longing to unfold.

But there’s so much more here. The loss of family, mental health issues, female friendship, found family, Catholicism, the repercussions of choices made.

In particular, I relate so strongly (pre-therapy) to Frances and the way she chooses to push people away before the relationship ends because “they always do.” My heart screamed and broke and I felt this deeply in my bones.

𝗩𝗜𝗕𝗘 𝗖𝗛𝗘𝗖𝗞
One Day. Rooney’s books. Talking at Night.

𝗥𝗘𝗖𝗢𝗠𝗠𝗘𝗡𝗗
This doesn’t come out until February of 2027 but it will be one of the best books I read this year. Without reservation I highly recommend this one.
Profile Image for Sam.
882 reviews
November 19, 2026
Wow. We Go Way Back took me on an emotional roller coaster. This book took “will they won’t they” to the extreme. It reminded me a lot of One Day, but with a happier outcome. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC.
Profile Image for jasmine.
38 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 21, 2026
I think I’m just a hater because there was nothing glaringly bad about this book and I still didn’t enjoy it. I found it all to be a drag. I didn’t like the relationship between these two characters but that could be entirely because I’m not loving romance books right now. Unrequited yearning makes me miserable. If this had come out maybe two years ago I’m sure I would have liked it a lot more. I’m sad to bring this book’s average rating down because I was so excited to pick this up, but what can you do.

Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for providing me an early copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Lindsay Smith.
408 reviews17 followers
Read
November 19, 2026
We Go Way Back is a debut literary fiction and romance novel by Niamh Connolly. After reading the first 25%, I concluded this was not a good match for my reading preferences. Here are the things I liked and didn't like in the portion that I read:

What I Liked:
- The settings were great: England and Ireland, large manor homes, and a boarding school.
- The character descriptions and development were well done from the portion I read. The author can definitely write.
- The early 2000s nostalgia was fun in the past timeline.

What I Didn't Like:
- The primary reason I chose to DNF this book is because of the pervasive explicit sexual references. I found it distracting, unnecessary, and as someone who normally skips past explicit scenes, it was impossible to do that with the embedded and scattered sexual discourse.
- Strong profanity was also frequent and pervasive, and used more as a communication habit than just to convey strong emotion.
- I felt empathy for Callum's fiance because even the short time Callum and Frances were together in her hotel room in the present day timeline it felt cheating-adjacent.
- There was some anti-religious commentary in the beginning of the book. I could see how this was building the character of Frances' mom, but some of it didn't land right with me.

Bottom Line: This wasn't the right book for me, but I appreciated the opportunity to try it.

Content Considerations (from first 25%): Explicit sexual references and brief sexual scenes, strong profanity, drug references, cheating-adjacent behavior.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for the complementary copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. My review is in no way influenced by the author or publisher.
Profile Image for Kelly Leahy.
390 reviews59 followers
November 8, 2026
📖 oh my gosh 🥹😭❤️ I loved this angsty, "will they? Won't they" romance so much.

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the early e-book. We Go Way Back publishes February 2, 2027.

To me, a 5-star romance doesn't necessarily mean a perfect book where nothing annoys me (referring to the bit of miscommunication in this case!), but rather I mean a story that I am completely invested in. I typically prefer a romance where the characters are flawed and the romance is messy. I enjoy a light romcom as much as the next person, but these super emotional and angsty romances where you truly don't know if the characters will (or should) end up together really get me! So... will this be a 5-star romance for you? Maybe, maybe not. Depends on your preferences.

Other aspects of this book that made it a 5-star read:
-Excellent dialogue, emails, and texts
-Great witty banter, butterflies, and no cheese
-So much yearning and tension!
-Loved the pacing and dual timelines (present day and then back to 2000- so much nostalgia- and working their way to present day)
-Single POV here really works. The reader not knowing Callum's POV adds to the overall suspense.
-The characters' regret at parts is heartbreaking!
-Connolly goes deep with these characters. Both have experienced such trauma and going through phases where they do and do not deal with it in a healthy way. Connolly writes about this masterfully!

I felt like I was watching a train wreck at times, but I oh so was rooting for them to figure it out!!
Profile Image for Jenn.
334 reviews71 followers
November 2, 2026
Thank you, @stmartinspress, for the gifted eARC in exchange for my honest thoughts.

🔥🔥🔥🔥 Multiple brief open door scenes with a lot of chatter outside of the bedroom.
CW: parental loss at a young age, depression, loneliness, suicidal ideation, infertility

This book was a stressful read. Niamh very masterfully builds tension as she alternates between the two timelines - one starting from our France’s childhood and meeting Callum at a young age and barreling toward what ultimately broke them and and the other the day before Callum’s wedding to….not Frances.

This book is packed with emotionally depth - there’s grief, loss, depression, suicidal ideation, so take care when picking it up. Our MCs act and respond out of trauma and hurt as well, so there are some big hurtful fights that felt so realistic and were written with so much care. Gosh, I wanted to just give Frances a hug. Over the past timeline, we are able to bear witness to their bumbling friendship and how they age and grow up and change. And what ultimately brought them to the painful present. OMG, additionally, Niamh perfectly sets you in each year during the flashbacks with excellent pop culture and news references PARTICULARLY strong music nods that really ground you in the time.

I finished this book on a flight from Omaha to STL in a window seat smushed aside two of the broadest chested men I have ever seen - that is to say I was a sobbing soeckale in one of the smallest spaces I’ve ever wedged myself into. My apologies to my row mates for the sorry sight.

This book is for you if you like deep and emotional romances, books set in Ireland or England, dual timelines, first person single POV, discovering new debut authors to love, and crying on planes.
Profile Image for Sarah (Books_with_a_cuppa).
355 reviews5 followers
November 5, 2026
I really loved this.

I got immediately hooked into the dual timeline story - the weekend of Callum’s wedding and a friendship that spans nearly two decades. I was so invested in what happened to get them to this point, and why, that I really didn’t want to put it down.

Frances is carrying a lot of insecurity, unresolved trauma and grief. Her experiences in this felt raw and realistic. I actually found myself really feeling for her at times - even in the moments where you wanted to give her a shake, my heart still broke for her. But with Frances you get no airs and graces but you do get some great humour. She had me laughing out loud so many times.

This isn’t your typical love story, it’s not trying to sugar coat anything and that’s honestly what made it so so good. It’s tender and full of heart. And the ‘will they won’t they’ elements are done to perfection.

I would really recommend picking this up.

Thank you very much to the publisher for this gifted e-arc to read & review. I need to get myself a trophy copy immediately.
Profile Image for Sara Ansari.
131 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 11, 2026
I started this expecting an easy rom-com as a palate cleanser but this turned out to be a fully fleshed story with rich character arcs, a solid plot, and decent writing. This book deals with mental illness in a way that didn’t make me hate the protagonist (unlike Sorrow and Bliss) even though she was often insufferable and her initial lack of accountability for her own actions had me tearing my hair out. I also think the ending was rushed and I felt absolutely terrible for Olivia. All in all, a good read but I might not have picked it up had I known it revolved around mental illness as much as it did.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC.
Profile Image for Sarah.
215 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
November 6, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a free advance copy ebook in exchange for an honest review ❤️

This is a tough one for me to rate... The writing was great. The delicate balance of past and present going back and forth until the timeline matches up again was wonderful. I just could not get behind the decisions of the characters, and I had a feeling that was going to happen right from the beginning.

That being said, this is a wonderfully written book that I may not have been quite the targeted audience. I would still give it 3.5 stars for the writing, but I just can't quite get behind any of the events of the "present" timeline. I completely devoured the "past" timeline and wish it could have taken a different turn, but that's just me!
Profile Image for Suzie.
67 reviews52 followers
October 14, 2026
I’m calling it now, this might be my favourite book this year 👀💗

We Go Way Back by Niamh Connolly was completely utterly heart-rending. This book made me laugh, tear up, grip the pages, wince, and savour every second.

It starts with our main character Frances the night before the wedding she’d imagined a million times. Yet she’s not the one marrying Callum Sutton. She’s ruined everything.

We jump back and forth in time, slowing unraveling how she’s ended up here.

I’ve not had this feeling when reading a book since I read Normal People for the first time. There is just something about Frances and Callum that stays with you. They are so raw, complicated and feel so real!

This is a sloooow burn that leaves you guessing and hoping till the very last second. I got so frustrated with Frances, while also emphasised with her massively.

But there is also so much more to this than just the romance. The way it shows Frances dealing with anxiety and grief and moving on from her past was beautiful and heartbreaking to read.

It’s about found family, grief, loneliness, belonging 🫶

At times you just wanted to scream ‘talk to each other!!’. I don’t know why I love this as it’s excruciating but I do.

If you loved One Day or anything by Sally Rooney, you are going to want to devour this 💗

I was kindly sent a proof copy 🫶
Profile Image for Stress Reader.
317 reviews40 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
November 5, 2026
We Go Way Back - ARC Review

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
🌶️

🗓️ February 2, 2027

A tender, yearning-filled love story about decades of friendship, terrible timing, old heartbreaks, and the possibility that the person you've loved for years might still be your person—even if they're marrying someone else.

Thank you to Niamh Connolly, @StMartinsPress and @netgalley for the opportunity to read this gifted eARC. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and freely given.

Twenty years of history and yearning. A wedding weekend. One of them getting married, the other is watching the person they've spent years trying to stop loving get married.

🫵🏼 We Go Way Back is for readers who:
• live for romantic yearning and pining
• love complicated relationships
• enjoy complex, not always likeable people
• enjoy stories spanning years
• want emotional weight, even when it gets messy
• enjoy stories with grief, healing, and mental health themes
• love relationship-driven stories
• enjoy books heavy on reflection and intimately internal
• want emotional intimacy and spice that elevates the story

🚫 You may not love it if you:
• prefer fast-moving plots with lots of external action over relationship-driven storytelling
• don't enjoy books heavy on reflection and/or intimately internal
• frustrated by miscommunication, missed opportunities, and years of unresolved romantic tension
• want a straightforward, lighthearted romance/romcom
• dislike stories that explore grief, mental health, heartbreak, and imperfect people making painful choices
• prefer a romance to focus exclusively on the couple, rather than giving friendship and personal growth comparable importance
• prefer characters to always be likeable

📜 Review

Some love stories make you believe in soulmates. Others make you want to shake two fictional people by the shoulders and scream, “YOU HAVE HAD YEARS TO FIGURE THIS OUT!” We Go Way Back provides both kinds of emotional investment. Niamh Connolly takes a lifelong friendship, decades of almosts, a wedding to someone else, and a whole lot of unresolved feelings, then asks what happens when the person you've always imagined a future with becomes someone you might have already lost. Beneath the romantic yearning is a messier, more human story about grief, forgiveness, growing up, and learning to love people without losing yourself in the process.

The premise takes a familiar romantic question — will these lifelong friends ever get together? — and adds an immediate source of tension: Frances is attending Callum's wedding to someone else. The dual time frame, with the present-day wedding weekend interwoven with years of shared history, creates two simultaneous mysteries: how they reached this point and whether their connection can survive what has happened.

The strongest overall aspect of the plot is the way it makes seemingly small past events acquire new meaning. A drunken almost-kiss, a birthday, or a moment of emotional vulnerability can become more significant when readers know what the characters eventually lose. The wedding also provides a ticking clock without requiring a conventional thriller-style plot. It explores not only whether Frances and Callum can find their way back to each other, but whether they can become people who are ready for the relationship they have spent so long separately yearning for.

There's a risk that comes with a story built around missed opportunities - they can become repetitive if every turning point relies on another misunderstanding or another failure to communicate. For me, this book avoided that risk. Or maybe it was that I was so wholly emotionally invested in these characters and their relationships that I missed it. Either way, I loved this book and was hooked from the very first line.

The most interesting thematic aspect is that We Go Way Back isn't simply asking whether two people belong together. It is asking how much of our identity we build around another person, and what happens when the future we've imagined with them doesn't materialize. At least not in the way(s) we had envisioned.

The title itself invites a double reading. To “go way back” is to share history, but history can be both a source of intimacy and a trap. Knowing someone for years doesn't automatically mean knowing who they have become, or will become — or understanding what they need now.

The wedding functions as a particularly effective symbolic setting. Weddings publicly celebrate certainty, commitment, and a future together; Frances's experience exposes the private uncertainty and grief that can exist alongside somebody else's celebration. The contrast also raises questions about the stories we tell ourselves about love: is a shared past evidence of a destined future, or simply a shared past?

💗 What I loved most
We get a romantic relationship that spans decades and gives us years of nostalgia, yearning, will they/won't they, change, and the painful recognition that loving someone and being ready for them are two different things. Frances and Callum don't "fix" one another, either. The romantic tension with a deadline (the impending wedding) gives the will they/won't they premise an immediate and palpable sense of urgency. The romance has a wider emotional purpose — grief, friendship, forgiveness, and identity providing opportunities for the novel to mean more than simply getting the couple together. I loved the found family itself, their relationships with one another, and what the Sutton family represents to Frances (and Callum, for that matter). There are many strong relationships that stand the test of time.

At various times, I felt so many emotions reading this. Either alone or as a mixture of romantic anticipation, nostalgia, frustration, tenderness, and grief. The premise is designed to make readers root for the relationship while questioning whether love alone is enough. I'm not sure I've ever questioned if love is enough for characters as much as I did reading this book.

I will say, the ending felt a bit abrupt and the pacing in the middle to later middle felt a bit muddled at times. While I didn't care, I was too invested in the characters and the relationships to care, but I did notice it. I won't spoil it, but I'll just say I loved the ending and also felt a deep sadness—it felt gut wrenchingly bittersweet.

I genuinely couldn't have been more flabbergasted than when I got to the end and saw this was a debut. 🤯 Connolly's prose beautifully balances emotional sincerity with humor, while viscerally capturing yearning and showcasing emotional intelligence with precision. There's so much growth in this book. Stylistically, it's contemporary, psychologically attentive prose that prioritizes emotional nuance and recognizable human behavior.

This is a yearning-heavy, character-driven contemporary romance with literary-fiction sensibilities and I was glued to it from the very first sentence. We get the nostalgia of a lifelong connection, the ache of years spent almost getting it right, and the uncomfortable reality that love doesn't magically erase grief, mistakes, or the ways we hurt one another. For readers who love yearning, complicated characters, and romances that leave them contemplating their own what-ifs, this is one to keep on the radar. Because sometimes the most heartbreaking love stories aren't about falling for someone new — they're about discovering what it means to love someone you've never really stopped loving.

If you enjoy relationship driven, coming of age, childhood friends to lovers with all the yearning, alongside deeper themes, I recommend adding this to your TBR. Particularly if you enjoyed Normal People and/or Our Perfect Storm.



Twenty years of friendship
+ Decades of yearning
+ Terrible timing
+ One emotionally catastrophic wedding
+ Grief, growing pains & forgiveness
= We Go Way Back
Think Normal People + Our Perfect Storm meets My Best Friend's Wedding, with the emotional introspection of contemporary literary fiction.
Profile Image for Louise Karolina.
96 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 18, 2026
I don't really know how to feel about We Go Way Back.

This novel is a well written love story spanning over 20 years, and we follow Frances from her teenage years to adulthood, through highs and lows, drunken nights, heartbreak and grief, all culminating at a wedding. This premise sounded really interesting and I was excited to dive into this world; however, the story did drag a little bit. The flashbacks, especially from their early teenage years, didn't pull me in and I was more interested in the present day story. I'm also disappointed that it ended the way it did, even though I saw it coming from a mile away.

The highlight for me was two of Frances's friends, Stella and Mae. Stella is funny and real and honest and along with Mae, they're the best friends a girl could ask for and Frances was lucky that they stood by her through it all. I found Frances to be... pretty insufferable, to be honest, and Callum wasn't much better. They were hard to relate to and made so many dumb decisions throughout this novel that it was hard to keep track.

The prose is very descriptive, at times a bit too much, and occasionally the characters would say things that real humans wouldn't really say. I also realized while reading that all this taking place at another woman's wedding just felt very... wrong.

It is, however, a well written story and I think readers who enjoyed One Day or Normal People would enjoy this (honestly, this made me feel the exact same way Normal People did, so you liked that one, you'll love this novel). It just wasn't my favorite. 2.5 stars.

I’d like to thank the author, publisher and Netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read this arc.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews