I found this book just in time.
Like many people my age, I've started to see the unpleasant sides of a society addicted to social media. However, my thoughts and dissatisfactions were scattered and listless. Then comes "Terms of Service"— a nuanced, all-compassing meditation on the "price of constant connection".
But, like many of the social media networks that I use, this book had some unpleasant "Terms of Service" itself.
There were some unexpectedly memorable passages, including this beautiful description of netizens "tending to their profiles, little gardens of personality in which only pleasantries bloom and life's setbacks, even a death in the family, are presented with such overwrought sentimentality that it's possible to think that such tragedies are welcomed, because they offer an opportunity to share and be embraced by the social media cocoon." (46)
Wow.
(I had to reread that sentence four times— twice just to unpack it, twice to appreciate it.)
Yet this quote in itself presents some of the flaws in Silverman's meditation. 1) It's cluttered, almost unorganized. 2) Its apocalyptic tone is grating. 3) It's quite repetitive, and content is often built on assumptions. 4) Most irritating of all, it's self-flagellating, "a point which I'll get to later." (182)
1) ORGANIZATION
Silverman is quite good at bringing up nuanced arguments about the downsides of social media. Each chapter starts out strong, elicits questions, and catches your attention. However, by the time you're a dozen pages in, your eyes begin to unfocus. At that point, most of the clarity and confidence has dissolved into roundabout arguments and anecdotal evidence. I skimmed a lot of the midsections.
2) TONE
While there was some attempt at restraint, the book still oozed some very strong, very negative opinions about social media. It presents itself as a reality check...but for the entire 400 some pages. It really wears down on the curious reader after a while.
3) REPETITION
Yes, Silverman is quite good at bringing up nuanced arguments. The problem is, the nuance is sometimes lost since the evidence tended to be repetitive. Perhaps that is the nature of the evidence itself, but that doesn't change the fact that "Terms of Service" was written with the assumption that every single social media user overshares, overuses, and overlooks. Everyone is Facebook's "ideal user"— the type to thought-vomit on statuses and put every single life event online. Out of the several hundred friends I have on Facebook, there are exactly two people I can think of who do that. In short, the book exaggerates its assumptions to make itself more important.
4) UGH
"A point which I'll get to later." This phrase was used several times in the book. This phrase was also the bane of my existence while I was reading. This phrase also shows exactly how unorganized this book can be at times, and how self-important the book sounded.
So.
I actually highly recommend reading this book. It's extremely thought-provoking and interesting. It's kind of like taking really bitter preventative medicine. You know you should do it, but you regret it afterward because of the experience.