Dr. Lila Callaway excels at putting broken things back together. But she could never mend her heart after Asher Wayne, the boy who promised her forever, chose football over their relationship. Years later, she runs the physical therapy department at Blue Crescent Medical Center, keeping her life orderly, safe, and free of infuriatingly charming athletes.
Until a severe ankle injury sidelines the NFL superstar. He belongs in world-class facilities, not a small-town clinic. But Ash will only let Lila oversee his rehabilitation, pushing all her buttons and looking far too handsome during their grueling daily sessions.
Lila establishes strict boundaries: no personal questions, no reminiscing, and absolutely no acknowledging the explosive chemistry still burning between them. Ash agrees to her terms, yet every intense exercise and lingering glance chips away at her ironclad defenses. He claims he returned for his recovery, but his relentless focus remains on her, making his temporary homecoming feel like a play for keeps.
Thirteen years apart, ten weeks of forced proximity, will it be enough for a second chance at first love?
Camilla is an engineer who left science behind to enter the whimsical realm of romantic fiction.
She writes contemporary rom-coms. Her characters have big hearts, might be a little stubborn at times, and love to banter with each other. Every story she pens has a guaranteed HEA that will make your heart beat faster. Unless you're a vampire, of course.
Camilla is a cat lover, coffee addict, and shoe hoarder. Besides writing, she loves reading—duh!—cooking, watching bad TV, and going to the movies—popcorn, please. She's a bit of a foodie, nothing too serious. A keen traveler, Camilla knows mosquitoes play a role in the ecosystem, and she doesn't want to starve all those frog princes out there, but she could really live without them.
I always enjoy this author’s books. They’re entertaining and well-written, and every FMC is a badass.
Asher broke Lila’s heart thirteen years ago. THIRTEEN YEARS! He broke his own heart too, though… 😭 Neither of them ever moved on because they never stopped loving each other 🥹💗
I was curious about this book. I wanted to know exactly what happened and what it would take for them to get back together. And I’m not disappointed! I loved Lila in this book. She was angry at the beginning, but once she realized that Asher had come back for her, she decided not to be a drama queen and give him a chance. The best thing about it was that she was doing it for herself. She knew she’d never stopped loving him, so why would she deny herself the relationship she’d always wanted? In a world of stupid miscommunications and fabricated drama, that’s a refreshing display of much-needed logic.
Asher was so committed! Love me a man who refuses millions because he’s grown up and knows what’s important 🥹. Also, the fact that he was staying at his parents’ house was hilarious and made the high school sweethearts vibes even stronger.
I’m not giving this book five stars because thirteen years is a very long time, and it was heartbreaking that they had to suffer for that long. Also, there were some cheesy bits towards the end that I didn’t love. However, all in all, it was a very entertaining story, and I’m secretly hoping Lila’s brother’s book is next because he’s my favorite character in the entire series 🥰
Thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the arc, all opinions are my own.
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC 🥹🫶🏻 And thank you, Camilla Isley, for writing this!
Asher broke Lila’s heart 13 years ago when he left her to pursue his pro football career. Now he’s back home with an injury, and he wants her to be his physical therapist.
Asher & Lila were everything. I have a little beef with second chance romance, but I looooove it when it’s done this beautifully.
The TENSION? Excuse me??? I felt everything these two were feeling. The longing, the angst?! I was screaming.
I don’t like it when everything is immediately forgiven in a second-chance romance, so I loved that Asher had to earn Lila’s forgiveness. His explanation actually made sense to me, and I could understand why she was willing to give him another chance.
Thirteen years is a LONG time, but the feelings were still there. They still cared so much about each other, and I was rooting for them so badly. I’m so happy they got their HEA.
Definitely want to read more from Camilla Isley after this!
Win Me Back by Camilla Isley Blue Crescent Harbor 3
I am really enjoying the Blue Crescent Harbor series.
Lila and Asher were high school sweethearts, then he left. 13 years later he is back in town and wants Lila back. Second chance can be tricky to pull off but this one worked for me.
I enjoyed the beginning as Asher did his best to get Lila to let him in and I’m glad she didn’t give in too easily.
The last part of the book showed a realistic portrayal of what it would actually be like to be in a relationship with two people with very demanding careers and I liked how Lila addressed this with Asher.
I look forward to more in this series.
Thanks to NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Camilla Isley for the ARC, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
I was SO excited when this landed pre-approved in my mailbox and couldn’t wait to head back to Blue Crescent Harbour!
I absolutely love a second-chance romance, and Ash and Lila’s story was everything I wanted and more. The perfect mix of romance, feels and all the reasons I love this series! 💕
If you’re a romance girlie, I’d definitely recommend this one and honestly, the whole series!
Already waiting patiently for Rory’s story 🥰
Thank you to Camilla Isley, Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this as an ARC.
Every single book written by Camilla Isley has taken me on the most swoon-worthy journey, and it's one of the many reasons I'm completely obsessed with her books! 🥹💗
Win Me Back was no different! Book 3 in the Blue Crescent Harbor series is officially my favourite so far, and for the completely biased reason that it mentions my favourite football team, the Kansas City Chiefs! That, and the fact that Lila finally got her happy ending in the most adorable, heart-tugging way possible!
It's impossible not to love this series with its small-town charm, swoon-worthy MMCs, and fierce friendships. 🫶🏻
The second chance romance was beautifully done! It showed the heartache and heartbreak but also the maturity of the characters by the end of it. Camilla has this incredible ability to take one of my least favourite tropes and turn it into a book I absolutely DEVOUR. And it's what makes her such a phenomenal writer! She has a way of making you fall in love with a trope regardless of how you felt about it before picking up her book.
This PT and football player romance was sweet, charming, funny, and filled with that signature Camilla banter that has you grinning like an absolute fool. 🤭❤️ I loved every minute of it!
Lila and Ash's love story survived time, heartbreak, and everything in between, only to bring them back together stronger than ever. Their journey was beautiful, and seeing them find their way to each other made my heart so happy! 🥹💕
Another five-star Camilla Isley read!
Thank you to the author, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this early ARC!
I really enjoyed the storyline and the mix of small-town charm, sports romance and all the unresolved feelings between two people who clearly never stopped caring about each other.
Lila and Ash were great characters, and I loved the tension between them. After thirteen years apart, they find themselves back in each other’s lives, with Ash needing Lila’s help to recover from his injury. Lila is determined to keep things professional and protect her heart, but with Ash around every day, sticking to those boundaries is easier said than done!
The chemistry between these two was fantastic, and I really enjoyed their banter and the little moments when their feelings started to show through. There was so much history between them, which made their journey even more emotional. I also loved seeing Ash work to prove himself and show Lila that he wasn’t the same boy who broke her heart all those years ago.
The forced proximity worked so well, and I enjoyed the balance between the physical therapy sessions, the romantic tension and the more heartfelt moments. It was lovely watching them slowly work through their past and discover whether love really could give them a second chance.
If you love small-town romances, charming athletes, plenty of banter and a second-chance love story that makes you root for the couple, this is definitely one to add to your TBR!
A heartwarming, feel-good romance with plenty of chemistry, emotional moments and the hope that sometimes first love really can become forever. 💕📚
*Thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for this eARC; the review is my own.*
I have been so lucky to get all ARCs of all three books in the Blue Crescent Harbor series so far, and they’ve all been wonderful! This is my eighth Camilla Isley book, and it won’t be my last. She writes such easily likable characters (even if you think you won’t like them, you will), and most of their stories are pretty believable. I love that Isley’s books aren’t all drama and heartbreak; yes, it’s there. But the book isn’t swallowed up in it. I still get all the happy feelings I want out of a rom-com. There’s a little bit of “how will this work?” but never a question if it will. Camilla Isley has become an author I can trust to give me the story I want to read.
In this book, Ash (31) and Lila (31) get a second chance together after he broke her heart 14 years before. He is so incredibly determined to win her back and wears his heart on his sleeve the entire time. I’m not sure I’ve ever read a character with more hearts and googly eyes radiating off of him. Though Lila clearly still has feelings for him, she protects herself well. But I also love that Liam (Lila’s best friend) and Preston (her twin) have her back in case she needs them to run interference.
I am so excited that the Blue Crescent Harbor series isn’t finished. Honestly, there are so many characters I want to read about (anyone else sense the unrequited best-friend love January has for the youngest Evans brother?), and I hope Isley doesn’t end at book four.
How it ends:
Language: Minimal but included f words Violence: None Alcohol & drugs: None Physical Intimacy: A couple of mild open-door sex scenes, innuendo, references to sex LGBT: None
Please note - all these comments were written whilst reading! So they're choppy and might as well be bullet points. But here's my thoughts on this epic book!
♡
Now, when I got the arc for this, I did something odd, I saved it for later. Why? I don't know. I was ecstatic that a new book was out. I guess it was like saving the best part of your meal for last? I found myself stopping constantly while reading. Cause I knew if I kept reading, I was going to finish too soon and I wanted to savour it! I'm honestly passed nutter with these books Camilla!
Also, get this, this is a book I would have physically marked and highlighted throughout, cause it was just that f-ing good! And I have NEVER dared such a thing before 😲 (No hate to those that do, but my books are pristine cause I'm psycho)
Either way, less than a chapter in and I was already stupid giddy.
If you read this book, which you should, you will have no questions as to why Camilla Isley books are on auto read. My god, this book had me cackling out loud like a crazy witch!
Asher is shocking smart when it comes to the female species and how to swoon Lila. He might just be the ultimate book boyfriend.
Damn it. I don't even know who's side to be on. Its maddening! Do I want her to win this stand off or do I want her to buckle and get swept up in the hot NFL player?! Argh!
Ugh! *still screaming* The angst, the feelings, the tears, the rage I had (thankful I wasn't reading a paperback that surely would have been horrifically damaged at my rage throw across the room during some of those later chapters) yep. I'm mad.
This book was actually the perfect read. And now it's over and I don't know what to do with my life. But for anyone else, go read Win Me Back. ASAP. I HIGHLY recommend.
P.S. Camilla, you made me literally laugh out loud when you introduced Asher, but why only make him 6'2"? ( Kidding! Kinda. I wanna know! )
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for granting my request to read this e-ARC and provide my honest opinions.
I have loved the first two books in this series, and reading this one was an absolute no-brainer 😏
Dr. Callaway and Asher, I loved them as strong individual characters, together as a couple, they were a bit... I don't even know the word to use. But throwing in a second-chance romance in which the MMC breaks up with the FMC when they are eighteen, leaves his town without looking back, takes his time, and then returns at thirty-one to come and grovel? It rubs off in some kind of way, but I get it. Love wants what it wants.
I also understand the reason why Asher left the first time. As teenagers, grappling with the effects of long distance and balancing their individual careers — Asher's football career and Callaway's physical therapy career — it would have been so hard to do both at their young ages. So, I get the need for a clean break.
We could just absolutely tell that Lila and Asher love each other so much, and that so many years and so much distance couldn't even dampen their love. Even if second chance romance isn't my favorite, I loved seeing Lila and Asher find their way back to each other.
It was great seeing my favourite couples again, Liam and Peyton 🥺🥺🥺🥺 and my other favourites, Ryder and Faye. Until the next book in the series! 😊
4.5/5. With each installment of the series, Blue Crescent Harbor feels more and more like home.
I don't know what would have to happen for me to dislike a Camilla Isley book. I'm not big on second chances or angst, but did that stop me from enjoying this? Of course not, clearly.
There's just something in the writing itself that makes this author really readable. The language flows really effortlessly, sounding so natural and light, and yet having no problems with punching you in the gut. It's amazing and the perfect escapism.
As much as my love for different parts of this series varies, I adore the casual overlap between them and watching the people who'd had their stories play out - or are still waiting for their turn - casually popping up in the background. It's the properly done small town trope of it all, and it pulls you in, craving more.
It's also impressive to me how much research must go into each book Camilla writes (especially since she does it so fast), because I feel like I'm learning a lot - in this case - about physical therapy (and bouquet making!). Of course, I'm not a medical professional, so I can't say anything about its accuracy, but it sounded well-done.
The relationship dynamics between the characters are well-written and make you feel like you're watching someone's life play out, which is the goal. It's well-rounded, it doesn't just focus on the main love interests and that's what makes it more immersive.
There's not much tension in this one, but instead their feelings kind of compare to putting on a well-worn pair of jeans which you couldn't fit into for a few years - there's comfort, nostalgia, and angst caused by the separation. Plus, the emotional outburst they had at one point was golden.
The only thing that didn't work for me was Asher, but that's truly personal preference as there wasn't anything outwardly wrong with him - there were many subtleties that amounted to something in my head over time, the way he would speak and act. Some people simply do that to you. To me, he just seemed so forceful and full-of-himself. Cornering someone into being close to you when you can clearly see they don't want to is not a move that's romantic in my head. Deciding what's best for someone without them having any say doesn't look good. Even the way he asked her out in the first place didn't sit well with me. I do think they fit together and their story is quite sweet, it didn't take away from that, but I just can't get rid of this icky sensation when I consider Ash. He does love Lila and is a kind person in general, though, that much is clear.
If you're into second chance romances that are angsty, sweet and a fast read, I'd really recommend going for this.
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for letting me read the ARC!
"I am insane...Insanely in love with you. Have been forever. It never stopped."
In high school, Lila and Ash were a solid couple with future plans, until Ash broke her heart. For the last thirteen years, she's locked that hurt away, made easier by Ash's absence from Blue Crescent Harbor. Suddenly, he's back in town, injured, and guess who's been assigned as his PT?
"Asher Wayne is my endgame, for better or worse. And if he leaves me again, I'm going to be destroyed, but at least I won't have any regrets."
I thought this was a well-balanced read. Lila gave Ash just enough cold treatment, while he tried his darnedest to get into her good books. He didn't push too hard - he was just present. Their interactions had enough push-and-pull to keep me hooked. It would have been easy to hate on Ash for how he'd done things as a young man, but I was happy that Lila recognised he'd probably done the right thing by them both. My only wish was that he hadn't waited for so long - a lot can happen in thirteen years! And, her father? Yeah, not a fan of his, at all. Considering the age of Lila and her twin, Preston, their father seemed to still treat them like kids. However, I loved their friendship group and I loved book club night!
Camilla Isley is my comfort author, I can always trust that she is going to write exactly what I need. I swear she knows what I want to read before I do. It’s the only way to explain how she knew I was on a doctor kick.
Win Me Back is the third book in the Blue Crescent Harbour series of interconnected standalones. It follows Lila and Ash, high school sweethearts who were torn apart by Ash’s football ambitions. Now thirteen years later after a bad injury Ash goes to his home town to heal. Guess who the resident physical therapist is? Well Lila of course. Ash is determined to win her back at any cost.
I truly adored this book, for starters pining men are my favourite. Ash doesn’t even pretend to play it cool, right from the start he is home on a mission and he will do whatever it takes. Lila is a doctor and I don’t know what it is about the hurt/healing trope but I am here for it. Maybe a bit of a competency kink too because I swear I have been having the time of my life with doctor romances. I love a second chance romance because, well the grovelling- and Ash does it well. If you are looking for a sweet easy fast paced read, you’ve got it here! Highly recommend!
“And now he’s back, expecting me to fix his ankle so he can return to the life he chose instead of me.”
Lila and Asher- wow! Their chemistry was everything, and I was rooting for Ash from day 1!
High school sweethearts, Ash broke Lila’s heart when he left her to pursue his pro football dreams. Now both 31, he’s back home with an injury and wants her to be the PT who does all his rehab during the off season….but that’s not the only reason he’s home- he also plans to win her back.
I didn’t want to put this story down. There were a couple of flashbacks which really helped build a picture of their younger years together and show the strength of their relationship and bond back then. I loved how Ash didn’t push Lila to do anything she didn’t want but was all in from the start and put his cards on the table straight away. He worked hard to show her he wanted her back and wasn’t going anywhere, so he could rebuild her trust.
This was by far my favourite of the series, and could definitely be read as a stand alone.
Thank you to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for this ARC.
When I saw this on NetGalley and found it available to request, I didn’t hesitate for even a second because I knew Camilla Isley could never disappoint me. Being set in a small town immediately drew me into the story, as I’m a sucker for small-town romances. With the flawless storytelling and smooth flow of events, the story felt even more addictive.
The characters were also well developed and had emotional depth, which made the story even more interesting. The romance blossoming between the two nemeses was engaging and full of tension. The side characters weren’t forgotten after their initial introduction and continued to make appearances throughout the story, which I really appreciated. I also fell in love with the close-knit community vibes.
I’d highly recommend this to anyone who loves small-town romances with great chemistry, lovable characters, and a heartwarming community feel.
Thank you to Boldwood Books and Camilla Isley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Win Me Back by Camilla Isley is a charming romance that explores love, second chances, and the challenges of navigating relationships. I enjoyed the romantic tension, heartfelt moments, and humor that helped keep the story engaging. The writing style was easy to follow, making it a great choice for anyone looking for an entertaining contemporary romance. I especially enjoyed the emotional elements of the story and the reminder that love sometimes deserves another chance. The characters and relationship dynamics made it easy to get invested in the romance and want to see how things turn out. Overall, Win Me Back was a lovely read for fans of second-chance romance who enjoy stories filled with emotions, romantic moments, and the possibility of a happy ending.
I received an ARC copy from NetGalley. Thank you for giving me the chance to read this novel and share my honest review of the novel
🏈 Second-chance romance 💕 First love 🏡 Small-town romance 🏆 Sports romance 🔥 Forced proximity 💚 Groveling hero ❤️🩹 He never stopped loving her
We love a good second-chance romance, but we REALLY love a good grovel, and Asher came prepared! He was determined to win Lila back, never got discouraged, and didn't give up when things got difficult. He knew he had made a mistake 13 years ago and it's tormented him ever since. He was willing to do whatever it took to prove he wasn't going to make it twice. Even when that meant sacrificing millions of dollars and his career. Now THAT is commitment!
Two of my favorite quotes perfectly capture Asher's attitude:
"A woman who doesn't care about you stays for the Memory Lane punch and the small talk. A woman who runs, is a woman I can chase."
"I have a lot to atone for, but groveling is on the menu and I showed up hungry."
I mean, hot damn!
The chemistry and tension between these two were fantastic. Thirteen years is a LONG time to carry that kind of heartbreak, and I loved that Lila didn't simply hand Asher forgiveness. She had to work through her hurt, and he had to show her through his actions that he was worth taking a chance on again. The banter, emotional moments, and all those unresolved feelings had me completely invested.
Jennifer Woodward and William Macleod were fantastic narrators! Jennifer absolutely nailed Lila's hurt, anger, and constant battle between what her head was telling her and what her heart wanted. William, meanwhile, had Asher's determination and flirtation turned up to 10. Together, they brought so much personality and emotion to the story.
A swoony, heartfelt second-chance romance with fantastic banter, plenty of angst, and, most importantly, a hero who knows how to grovel and backs it up with action. My first Camilla Isley read, but definitely not my last. I would love to go back and catch up on this series.
Thank you, Camilla and Libro.FM for the gifted audio.
Thirteen years ago, Asher broke Lila’s heart when he chose football over her, and they haven’t seen each other since. Now he’s back in town, and he’s determined to win her back.
I have such mixed feelings about this one. The writing felt a little slow paced to me, but at the same time, I couldn’t stop reading, so I guess the slower pace didn’t really bother me this time. It was impossible not to get invested in Asher and Lila’s story, especially knowing what happened between them in the past.
That being said, I didn’t really connect with the characters or the romance. I liked the story and definitely got hooked, but that was pretty much it. It didn’t blow me away or leave me thinking about it long after I finished.
Still, I had a good time reading it, and sometimes that’s enough.
This was a wonderfully smooth read. I could easily set it down and return to it hours later without losing my place. While I'm not typically a fan of second chance romances, Ash's heartfelt apologies were truly exceptional. He demonstrated to her that they are meant to be together, despite having broken up after high school. I would definitely read more from this author. The story focuses on love and the deep connection between the characters rather than just the spice. Camilla beautifully weaves together the journey of two broken souls, creating an enchanting love story.
Thank you for this amazing opportunity to read the eARC, and I am happy to provide my honest review in return.
Camilla Isley has her rom com formula down, and I really enjoy the town of Blue Crescent Harbor. I enjoyed the characters vocations in this one (physical therapist and professional football player)— sometimes that’s what can set these similar type books apart!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Lila🧎🏻♀️🧎🏻♀️🧎🏻♀️🧎🏻♀️ ash🛐🛐 Me gustó muchísimo esta pareja, tengo algo con los mmc que se arrastran🫦🫦 El bookclub, las amo, la escena del cristal😂😂😂 La escena de la cita es muuuuy bonita🥹🥹 No es un 5⭐ por el epílogo, más largo y no tantos saltos en el tiempo Espero que haya libro de remy, january y emma👀👀
This is the third book of the Blue Crescent small town series. While you can read as a standalone, a few of the side characters have their own stories that are good to read beforehand. This story follows Lila (bff of Liam from book 2), a PT dr, and Asher, a NFL tight end. Lila and Asher were first loves until Asher broke up with her prior to college. 13 years later, he’s returned to win her back by doing pt with her after an injury. Lila is still heartbroken, but not easily swayed by Asher. This is a classic second chance at romance story. I really liked the last 3rd of the book as it was not all sunshine and rainbows (but no third act breakup). This is a closed-door romance and readers should feel comfortable with the low spice (maybe half a pepper’s worth).
Thank you, Boldwood Books, for providing this book for review consideration through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
Cute, light, funny, smutty.. the sugar cookie of desserts but I want cheesecake!! However, the references to the Kansas City Cheifs did garner bonus points.
Another cute small town romance by Camilla Isley and I loved it to bits !! I was interested in Lila’s story since the last book of the series and Im so happy we got it. Im not a fan of second chance romances but really enjoyed Lila and Asher’s book. The story was fun, sweet, a bit emotional and amazing. Definitely a must read if you’re looking for something light hearted and heartwarming!
Lila and Ash were in a relationship, and Ash made decisions for both of them—both when he broke up with her and when he came back. There were some sweet moments, but nothing particularly extraordinary. For now, Liam’s story remains the best in the series, but I’m still looking forward to the book about Preston, Lila’s twin.
Lila e Ash avevano una storia, poi Ash ha deciso per entrambi sia quando l'ha lasciato, sia quando é tornato. Scambi carini, ma niente di particolarmente straordinario. Per ora quello di Liam resta il migliore della serie, ma resto in attesa del libro su Preston, il gemello di Lila.
I received from the Publisher a complimentary digital advanced review copy of the book in exchange for a honest review.
This was quick and entertaining. But it's not my favourite of the series. I'm not a huge fan of second chance, so it's likely just a me thing. I struggled a little with the time frame. Lila and Ash were together in high school until he broke up with her. 13 years later, they are still stuck on each other, and the hurt.
I felt Ash's reason for the teenage break up was justified as it was later proved, so I found Lilas anger a little unjustified.
I also found them both a bit lusty. With a focus on physical rather than emotional connection.
ARC received from NetGalley and Boldwood Books in exchange for honest review.
⚡REVIEW⚡ It's no secret that I've really enjoyed Camilla Isley's Blue Crescent Harbor series, and I was super excited to get stuck into Lila Callaway's story, after seeing flashes of her character in the other books. I was not disappointed! This second chance romance was nuanced and layered giving it a deliciously slowed down reveal before the bombshell truth about their initial split comes out.
At 17 years old, Asher James absolutely destroyed his girlfriend's life by breaking up with her after the perfect date night, announcing he had been scouted to a college for budding NFL players, and knowing they wouldn't survive long distance. Lila has been through years of therapy to get over it, when her hospital-owning father announces that they have a new client signed up to her physiotherapy unit - Asher. He gives her no choice but to work with him, and Lila is utterly determined to keep those walls up. But as Asher chips away at her defences, and she overhears a phone call that changes things, it proves impossible for them to not revisit their feelings. But can what was so thoroughly broken be repaired?
Lila altered her life path after Ash left, and pivoted to physiotherapy instead of the medicine her father wanted her to do. She's never gotten over Ash, is perpetually single, and utterly furious with him for returning and declaring he never stopped loving her. 13 years and not even a text message. But whilst she's been using fake profiles to spy on her, she's got no idea he has been doing the same. Understandably her walls are a million feet high,but every minute with Ash sees them drop, before a book club meeting (I absolutely ADORED this plot device) saw a make out session in the rain that just had me kicking my feet. As he continues to chip away, she realises that there is no coming back from this another time, before a plot twist (how very dare you, Camilla Isley!) that had my heart in my mouth. I literally could not have borne it if they hadn't had their HEA.
Ash knows he made a big mistake all those years ago, so when an ankle injury needs rehabbing, he finally sees an opportunity to return to Blue Crescent Harbor - and to the girl he screwed everything up with. And despite her open hostility, he refuses to give up on the chance that he'll get to explain himself fully, and earn her forgiveness, and her love back. Had it not been for the initial offence, he'd be waving all the green flags. He is thoughtful, considerate, supportive, and he knows that without her, there is nothing. When the truth finally comes out about that night, you're still mad at him but you also hurt for him, because manipulative behaviour is not the one. But the joy that radiates from him every time he's in her presence is so beautiful. It's boundless, even when things look shaky. That plot twist was absolutely vicious, and his fear from it was heart wrenching - but they got their happy ending, and you want nothing more from a romance novel.
I would have quite liked to have seen Lila's showdown with the person who influenced Ash's decision to break up with her - she's so fiery and feisty that I believe it would have been spectacular - but truly, I feel that's the only thing missing from Win Me Back. It was a really lovely second chance romance, packed with heart and humour, gentle spice, and an ensemble cast who continue to entertain (the boys arriving en masse to gatecrash girls night book club will never not be funny!). There was not a lot of sports content, purely because it was mostly set during a rehab phase of an injury, so no foul there. Just another really enjoyable instalment in the Blue Crescent Harbor series, and I'm already looking forward to the next - particularly if it features who the hints seem to suggest!
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review this book!
Thank you to Camilla Isley, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review! 💝
This book was honestly okay and pretty easy to read. I liked it for what it was, especially because it’s a second-chance romance between a football athlete and a physical therapist. I already enjoyed getting little snippets of Lila in the previous book because of her personality, so I was interested in finally getting her story and finding out how her heart ended up getting broken by Asher.
Lila is committed and very straightforward about what she wants in life, especially when it comes to her career. She knows that she wants to be a physical therapist for athletes and eventually create her own sports rehabilitation hub. But there’s always been this one part of her life that feels incomplete, and that’s her heart. Asher broke it 13 years ago when he left to pursue his football career, and she never completely moved on from him.
I actually liked seeing Lila slowly understand why Asher made the decisions he did all those years ago. She had every right to be hurt and angry, but I appreciated that she eventually became more open to understanding his side instead of holding onto the resentment forever. I also liked that she never gave up on her own passion and career because of him. She still had her own goals and dreams outside of their relationship, which I really appreciated.
And honestly, I would probably be Lila too. If the person I loved suddenly came back then moved far away again, I would OVERTHINK EVERYTHING. So I definitely related to her in that sense because we are both professional overthinkers.
Asher is a star football athlete who ends up dealing with an injury, which brings him back into Lila’s life when he needs someone to help him with his recovery and rehabilitation. And after 13 years of not seeing each other, he basically decided to take the biggest risk of his life and try to win Lila back. I liked that he didn’t just expect everything to magically go back to the way it was. He actually put in the effort to earn her trust and show her that his feelings were still there.
Watching Asher slowly try to capture Lila’s heart again was cute, and obviously, he succeeded. By the end, they’re married, and honestly, I’m happy for them. After everything they went through, they deserved their happy ending.
I also loved getting to see Ryder, Faye, Liam, and Peyton again! 🥹 I always enjoy when interconnected series bring back previous couples because I like seeing what happens to them after their own books. It makes the whole series feel more connected, and I enjoyed seeing their relationships continue in the background.
Overall, this was a cute and easy second-chance romance. It wasn’t a book that completely blew me away, but I enjoyed Lila and Asher’s story, especially seeing them work through 13 years of hurt, misunderstandings, and unfinished feelings.
I’m also excited for the next book in the series, especially because it’s Rory’s story! She owns Shelf Indulgent, the bookstore, and her love interest is a novelist. 👀 A bookstore owner + novelist romance? Yeah, I’m definitely curious about this one.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I had high expectations from Win Me Back because I've really enjoyed the Blue Crescent Harbor series so far. Fall for Me was an almost five-star read for me, and Liam and Peyton's story is easily my favourite in the series. I was especially excited to see more of Liam's best friend, Lila, and finally get her story. Unfortunately, this book was a huge letdown.
The premise sounded promising. Lila is a physical therapist who has spent thirteen years moving on from her first love, Asher Wayne, who left her to pursue his NFL career. Now he's back in Blue Crescent Harbor with a career-threatening ankle injury, and he's determined to have Lila handle his rehabilitation. Forced proximity, second chances, and unresolved feelings? This should have worked for me.
But I never bought into their romance.
My biggest problem was that Lila and Asher never felt like two people who had once been deeply in love. We're constantly reminded of their history, but I never actually felt it. I couldn't see what made them so special together or why their feelings had supposedly survived thirteen years apart. Their chemistry fell flat, and their relationship never gave me a reason to root for them as a couple.
Honestly, the Lila in Fall for Me doesn't even feel like the same person in this book. I loved getting to know her through Liam and Peyton's story, but here she felt like an entirely different character who just happened to have the same name. I struggled to connect with her, which made it even harder to care about her romantic journey.
As for Asher, I wasn't particularly impressed with him either. Thirteen years ago, he made the decision to leave Lila behind without giving her much of a say. Now he's back, deciding that he wants her again and pushing his way into her life. His determination is clearly supposed to be romantic, but it often came across as presumptuous. I wanted him to show more consideration for Lila's feelings and demonstrate that he'd grown since their breakup. Instead, too much of the relationship seemed to happen on his terms.
There were some sweet moments, and I still enjoyed returning to Blue Crescent Harbor. The small-town atmosphere remains charming, and seeing Liam and Peyton again was a highlight. Honestly, their presence reminded me of how much I loved the previous book and made me wish I were reading about them instead.
Despite my disappointment, I'm still interested in Preston's story, and the growing tension between January and Remy has caught my attention. I'm hoping the next instalment will bring back what I loved about this series.
Unfortunately, Win Me Back didn't work for me. I can overlook plenty in a romance, but I need to believe in the couple, and I never believed in Asher and Lila. Their supposed history, chemistry, and love simply didn't come alive on the page.
For now, Liam and Peyton remain the standard this series has yet to match.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC!
At this point, I'm convinced a Camilla Isley book is basically a guaranteed good time.
Win Me Back is the third book I've read by her, and I have yet to find one I haven't enjoyed. After meeting Lila earlier in the Blue Crescent Harbor series, I'd been waiting for her story, so I was incredibly excited to finally get it, and her second-chance romance gave me pretty much everything I wanted.
Lila and Ash have history. Thirteen years of it. They were each other's first love, had plans for their future, and then Ash chose football and left Lila with a broken heart. So when he walks back into her life needing her help with his rehabilitation, I was VERY happy that she didn't simply take one look at him and decide all was forgiven.
No, sir. You're going to have to work for it. 😂
And honestly, that was probably my favorite part of their romance. Their second chance felt earned. Lila had built a life for herself without Ash, and I loved that she protected her heart and established boundaries rather than immediately falling back into their old relationship. She made him prove that he wasn't going to leave her behind again.
Of course, that also meant we got plenty of yearning and tension along the way.
And it was SO good.
You could feel how much these two still cared about each other despite all the years they'd spent apart. Every lingering look, every physical therapy session, every little crack in Lila's defenses made me want them together even more. I especially loved that underneath all the attraction was the familiarity of two people who had once known each other better than anyone else.
Ash also really had to win me over alongside Lila. I loved watching him show her through his actions that he wasn't the same person who had walked away thirteen years earlier. There was something incredibly sweet about seeing him so determined to earn another chance rather than simply expecting one because they still had feelings for each other.
And I loved finally getting more of Lila! She's capable, independent, and understandably guarded when it comes to Ash, but there's also such a vulnerable side underneath all of that. After waiting for her story, I'm so glad she got a romance that allowed her to be angry and hesitant while still giving her the possibility of the future she'd once wanted.
Between the second chance, first love, forced proximity, sports romance, small-town setting, and thirteen years' worth of unresolved feelings, this one had so many things I love in a romance.
Sweet, funny, romantic, and full of delicious tension, Win Me Back was another really enjoyable addition to the Blue Crescent Harbor series. And apparently Camilla Isley and I are now three for three. 🤍
I am a longtime romance lover, and second chance romance is one of those tropes that almost always catches my attention. After reading "Rein Me In" and later "Fall for Me," I was excited to return to the Blue Crescent Harbor series, especially since Lila was one of the characters I really enjoyed in the last book. I remember being genuinely shocked that nothing had ever happened between her and Liam over the years. Well, now I understand why! 😂 There was clearly a part of Lila's heart that had never completely moved on from Ash, even after thirteen years apart.
I liked Ash from the beginning, even knowing that he was the one who ended their relationship all those years ago. What really worked for me was that he didn't come back expecting Lila to simply forget the past because he was ready for another chance. He knew he had hurt her, and I liked watching him put in the effort to repair what he had broken. As the story progressed, I started to suspect there was more behind their original breakup than Lila knew, and I was right. I won't spoil what happened, but I will say I REALLY wanted Lila to get the opportunity to confront a certain someone once everything came to light. I was waiting for that scene!
I also appreciated that the second-chance aspect wasn't treated as though thirteen years apart could be erased simply because they still loved each other. Once Lila and Ash began seriously considering what another chance might look like, they still had things to work through. In some ways, I think that helped Lila better understand the choices they made when they were younger. They aren't the same people they were back then, and I liked seeing them figure out whether the adults they had become could build something stronger than what they had before. There were also moments when Lila had to make some difficult choices of her own, and I loved seeing her willing to fight for their relationship too.
Overall, I really loved this installment of the Blue Crescent Harbor series. Lila and Ash had history, chemistry, unresolved hurt, and plenty of reasons why getting back together wasn't going to be easy, which is exactly what I want from a good second chance romance. I especially liked that Ash wasn't the only one who had to grow or make sacrifices for their relationship to work. Now I am excited to see where the series goes next! And I'm putting in my request early: I really hope Rebecca, Ryder's sister, and Preston, Lila's twin brother, eventually get stories of their own. There are still plenty of people in Blue Crescent Harbor whose business I need to know. 😂
**I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.**