3/10. [This is a review and rating of the Japanese language digital versions of volumes 1 through 20, NOT just volume 20]
I started reading Gantz because of an acquaintance showing some of its weird art, and Super Eyepatch Wolf his video.
Gantz, a unique ake on the death game concept, is also a unique combination of terrible. ''Terrible'' in terms of the dark things that happen, which I was warned of and doesn't necessarily make something bad so I figured I could keep reading. But what it poorly conveyed is just how terrible it is in the morality of its problematic way of handling this subject matter, and how terrible its writing is. If you are a survivor of sexual or violent trauma, I highly advise you to read it with caution. I'm not, but I stopped reading at my first attempt because the way it treats women in general is just really fucking off putting, but hey..It's a manga/anime, and we know how they tend to be with that, but still. Get ready for misogyny, violent massacres everywhere, suicide, blatant homophobia, racial insensitivity (there's a blackface mass shooting for christ sake), PTSD, sexual harassment fanservice, sexualizing of minors, shock value rape and domestic abuse. Often NOT handled with respect.
Reading Gantz feels like its mangaka primarily set out to have an excuse to randomly:
1: Draw things he gets off to, like titties.
2: Draw things he finds edgy, badass or gruesome that probably remind him of his favorite movies.
3: Draw weird often big groups of giant aliens that look cool.
4: Shock or titelate the audience.
5: Do some unexpected shit with its rules and gimmicks while keeping things mysterious not because it fits the story but so people will keep reading and he can have climactic moments without them even being warranted.
6: Give some wish fulfillment for dudes.
Don't believe me? Well, almost every weekly chapter cover (that's hundreds of pictures), has a pinup girl on the front that's super sexualized and either naked or half naked. A lot of the time they have absolutely nothing to do with the story. I think that should be enough evidence for where this stories priorities lie. It's for edgy teen dudes who want to see some shocking shit, cool action and titties, but need some extra developments, moments and mystery to keep them reading.
A lot of Gantz reads like some fucked up fantasy of some dude with little rhyme or reason or logic. Sometimes people barely behave like human beings. There's this one part where the protag just asks a random chick that seemed interested out of nowhere (because everyone keeps falling for his dick for no reason) and he just asks her to have sex and..Then they do. It has nothing to do with the rest of the story. It wasn't earned. It just happens so that it happens. That's what half of this manga feels like. Female characters either exist for male characters and their personality is entirely about them, or for rape shock value.
This is ESPECIALLY evident in the early arcs with the first team (the first three battles or so). The first only female character is an absolute joke. It almost offends me, she PURELY exists for fanservice , to praise katou and to potentially get raped/sexually harassed (or..Licked up down there by a DOG?!), while they make light of her damn suicide. Let's also keep in mind this is a 15 year old with giant boobs who's naked all the time for no real reason, in a manga aimed at young adult dudes. Let that sink in. Thanks Japan.
The issue is that while gantz is bad..Somehow it's also kinda good? I mean, it somehow kept me reading for quite a while, and I'm still kind of intrigued even if I started to lose interest by volume 15. I feel like after the third battle things really started picking up and getting more interesting, and the mangas initial issues became less exaggerated.
But like, I don't know how to explain it.
At first I kept reading it in a ''so bad it's good'' way, but there's some things it's doing right. Hell, there's even a few heartwarming and thrilling moments that I genuinely liked, such as (I'll be vague to not spoil anything) katou and his brother, the thing with the big guy and the kid, the interactions kurono has with the older guy, that point kurono was alone, the sort of ''win'' moment for kurono around this point, the relationship with tae (probably my favorite part, oddly enough), some scenes between katou and kurono, the grandma and her child, kurono's development from interestingly assholy character to something else, the silly panda, just the whole concept itself and of the different battles, but the thing is, that's not really what most of the manga is. Let's be fucking real here, most of this manga is basically: Smut fantasizing. Not in the ''it's only erotic'' sense, I mean asin, it's not high art. It's mostly shock value and wish fulfillment. But It's like a disaster I couldn't turn my eyes away from.
It's not just the edginess that's the issue.
The pacing is all over the place, you kind of become decensitized to it all, the plot is all over the place and seems to switch rules as the author sees fit to keep the suspense and mystery up, the action scenes make no sense sometimes with a lot of people kind of standing around for no reason, most of its characters are ass (ESPECIALLY the female ones), the dialogue and character interactions can be rather awkward and unnatural, it's just..aaargh.
On one hand I fucking hate this manga and felt like Super Eyepatch Wolf did some inaccurate advertising, and on the other hand, something about it is kind of interesting. There are some very well executed moments, and I genuinely think Kurono has quite a unique character arc and relationship that I eventually felt invested in, but is it really worth it? I don't know how it ends, but I heard people who LIKE the manga talk about how its ending is shit, so there's that. We'll see, maybe I'll pick up the rest some time, but for now it feels like it's dragging on. I'm writing this review now because I'm losing interest, and volume 20 marks the end of the first of three ''phases''.