What do you think?
The Thunder Between Us
She believed in law, order, and the God of her ancestors. He came with dust on his sandals, thunder in his voice—and a message that tore everything apart.
Talia has worked the family vineyard since she could carry a pruning blade. With her father growing weaker, she now shoulders the harvest, the workers, and the taxes—clinging to the one thing she still tradition. In a world of Roman greed and rising unrest, faith must be quiet, reverent, and safe.
Then James of Zebedee arrives—loud, relentless, and impossible to ignore. A fisherman turned follower of a Galilean teacher, preaching kingdoms and miracles. To Talia, Jesus is no messiah—just another would-be prophet with reckless followers and dangerous ideas.
From the moment they meet, James challenges everything about her. But when a storm devastates the vineyard and tax collectors arrive early, Talia faces the accepting help from the very man she once tried to drive away.
James is brash, infuriating, and far too familiar with the cracks in her armor. But he stays—challenging her, helping her, seeing more than she wants him to. As the disciples labor beside her workers and the days stretch longer, Talia begins to question everything she thought she knew.
Maybe Jesus isn’t the threat—but instead—the answer. And maybe James isn’t the storm, but the one to walk with her through it.
Talia has worked the family vineyard since she could carry a pruning blade. With her father growing weaker, she now shoulders the harvest, the workers, and the taxes—clinging to the one thing she still tradition. In a world of Roman greed and rising unrest, faith must be quiet, reverent, and safe.
Then James of Zebedee arrives—loud, relentless, and impossible to ignore. A fisherman turned follower of a Galilean teacher, preaching kingdoms and miracles. To Talia, Jesus is no messiah—just another would-be prophet with reckless followers and dangerous ideas.
From the moment they meet, James challenges everything about her. But when a storm devastates the vineyard and tax collectors arrive early, Talia faces the accepting help from the very man she once tried to drive away.
James is brash, infuriating, and far too familiar with the cracks in her armor. But he stays—challenging her, helping her, seeing more than she wants him to. As the disciples labor beside her workers and the days stretch longer, Talia begins to question everything she thought she knew.
Maybe Jesus isn’t the threat—but instead—the answer. And maybe James isn’t the storm, but the one to walk with her through it.
386 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 21, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
June 26, 2026
Kaylee has an incredible gift for transporting readers back in time. She masterfully weaves authentic historical details into the story, creating an immersive setting without sacrificing readability or emotional connection. Striking that balance is no easy feat, and it’s something many historical fiction authors struggle to achieve. But Kaylee does it effortlessly!! I was captivated from the very first page. Her characters are richly developed with genuine emotional depth, and the biblical themes add even more meaning and richness to the story. I’ll gladly read anything she writes!
July 20, 2026
The story was good. A glimpse at what could have been for the apostle James since we don’t know for sure if he had a wife.
One complaint is how repetitive the author can be. There are entire chapters we didn’t need. I’d also like to see her use a different word besides “loud” to describe the apostles. In book one, she described Peter as loud in what felt like every page of the book lol. She used the same word to describe James multiple times. It’s time to move on from that descriptor! 😂 (She also used “thunder” to describe James over and over again in this book.)
In all seriousness, it’s a good read and I’m very interested in the third book which will be John’s story!
One complaint is how repetitive the author can be. There are entire chapters we didn’t need. I’d also like to see her use a different word besides “loud” to describe the apostles. In book one, she described Peter as loud in what felt like every page of the book lol. She used the same word to describe James multiple times. It’s time to move on from that descriptor! 😂 (She also used “thunder” to describe James over and over again in this book.)
In all seriousness, it’s a good read and I’m very interested in the third book which will be John’s story!
July 10, 2026
When I finished The Fisherman's Wife, I immediately wanted to read The Thunder Between Us. Imagine my excitement, then, when I learned the release was only a few weeks away. I counted those weeks with great anticipation, and Kaylee did not disappoint.
I want to start with Talia bat Yosef. She's a "literary soul sister," but it wasn't until I was deep in the novel that I realized how deeply I related to her and needed to learn the lessons she did. As in, like Talia, I'm an oldest daughter (though not an only child). Like her, I've clung to the rules, the work, the tight vines. I've choked my heart and spirit without knowing it, because I thought, "This is safe. This keeps me from sin. This ensures I don't have to feel certain things." And *sigh.* Yes. I'd like to say I'd believe in Jesus upon first meeting Him, but as Jesus does, He tenderly uncovered truths about me I couldn't have faced otherwise.
Because of this, the spiritual threads in The Thunder Between Us grabbed me and wouldn't let go. This was one of those books I caught myself putting down often so I could pray and absorb. When Talia realized that she had been "tightening vines" so maybe God would see her and give her what she asked for--I felt that so deeply I could hardly breathe. And when Jesus told Talia she and her labor were seen, when she finally looked into His eyes--whew! When a fictional scene takes your breath like that, you know you've got a winner.
If this book were just about Talia and her encounters with Jesus, I'd have loved it. But I loved the other characters just as much. Kaylee nails James' portrayal as a Son of Thunder. I especially loved the scenes where James made clear, he doesn't tolerate bullies. But I also loved the scenes where he showed vulnerability and humility, because they reminded me, Jesus loved *all* of James. Perhaps the same way He...loves all of me? That thread runs through all the disciples, Malka, Mira, and others, a quiet but persistent hum. That hum stands out especially with Malka and Lavi--reading Lavi's encounter with Jesus after the cart disaster, I almost cried.
The plot itself is rich in detail and gravitas. It's the story of Jesus I grew up on--and yet it isn't. This story, like The Fisherman's Wife, shows in exquisite detail what it might have been like to be an average believer while Jesus walked the earth. Yet it's not a retread; this novel has its own flavor and trajectory. In particular, I applaud how Kaylee handled the crucifixion and resurrection. Without spoilers, I've never seen those events written and handled that way before, in such a way as to ask so much from characters and readers.
The last third of the book gets a bit long, and events move faster than I would've expected. But I applaud Kaylee for including what she did, because so often, I think modern Christians still get to that place of, "I committed to Jesus--now what?" Or, "I didn't expect this and I don't know how to deal with it or what my place and purpose is in the aftermath." But that last third does a great job of showing, not just telling, where Jesus is in "the aftermath."
As you can probably tell, I can't say enough. I'm already marking my calendar in anticipation of John and Ruth's story, and hoping this series doesn't end with just three books. But even if it does, this series is and will be masterful. Read these books--I know you'll love them!
I want to start with Talia bat Yosef. She's a "literary soul sister," but it wasn't until I was deep in the novel that I realized how deeply I related to her and needed to learn the lessons she did. As in, like Talia, I'm an oldest daughter (though not an only child). Like her, I've clung to the rules, the work, the tight vines. I've choked my heart and spirit without knowing it, because I thought, "This is safe. This keeps me from sin. This ensures I don't have to feel certain things." And *sigh.* Yes. I'd like to say I'd believe in Jesus upon first meeting Him, but as Jesus does, He tenderly uncovered truths about me I couldn't have faced otherwise.
Because of this, the spiritual threads in The Thunder Between Us grabbed me and wouldn't let go. This was one of those books I caught myself putting down often so I could pray and absorb. When Talia realized that she had been "tightening vines" so maybe God would see her and give her what she asked for--I felt that so deeply I could hardly breathe. And when Jesus told Talia she and her labor were seen, when she finally looked into His eyes--whew! When a fictional scene takes your breath like that, you know you've got a winner.
If this book were just about Talia and her encounters with Jesus, I'd have loved it. But I loved the other characters just as much. Kaylee nails James' portrayal as a Son of Thunder. I especially loved the scenes where James made clear, he doesn't tolerate bullies. But I also loved the scenes where he showed vulnerability and humility, because they reminded me, Jesus loved *all* of James. Perhaps the same way He...loves all of me? That thread runs through all the disciples, Malka, Mira, and others, a quiet but persistent hum. That hum stands out especially with Malka and Lavi--reading Lavi's encounter with Jesus after the cart disaster, I almost cried.
The plot itself is rich in detail and gravitas. It's the story of Jesus I grew up on--and yet it isn't. This story, like The Fisherman's Wife, shows in exquisite detail what it might have been like to be an average believer while Jesus walked the earth. Yet it's not a retread; this novel has its own flavor and trajectory. In particular, I applaud how Kaylee handled the crucifixion and resurrection. Without spoilers, I've never seen those events written and handled that way before, in such a way as to ask so much from characters and readers.
The last third of the book gets a bit long, and events move faster than I would've expected. But I applaud Kaylee for including what she did, because so often, I think modern Christians still get to that place of, "I committed to Jesus--now what?" Or, "I didn't expect this and I don't know how to deal with it or what my place and purpose is in the aftermath." But that last third does a great job of showing, not just telling, where Jesus is in "the aftermath."
As you can probably tell, I can't say enough. I'm already marking my calendar in anticipation of John and Ruth's story, and hoping this series doesn't end with just three books. But even if it does, this series is and will be masterful. Read these books--I know you'll love them!
July 5, 2026
This one is a MUST READ!!
It's the second book in the series. ( The Fisherman's Wife was the first.) This story is about Talia. She is about as stubborn as they come! Continuously piling in her own plate because it feels safer than trusting anyone else to help carry it, or maybe it's her way of clinging to a little control when everything else in her life feels like chaos... Either way! Enter James, one of the twelve disciples, whom makes it his personal goal to help her carry things ( literally and figuratively) from the moment he lays eyes on her. She is not a fan. Typical enemies to lovers trope.
There were so many things I loved about this book:
1) The banter between characters made me laugh out loud. I loved every last one of them and loved that many of the characters from book one made a return.
2) This goes for both books in the series, but I absolutely adore how Kaylee brings Jesus' character to life. In the first book, he had all these sweet, intimate, reassuring conversations with Mira, which was exactly what she needed. Talia was a harder but to crack as she was a little hesitant to believe he was the Messiah. There was one moment where he had come to her vineyard and was commenting on her work (something deeply meaningful to her as she feels so unseen in the weight she carries..) However as I mentioned before she's a little stubborn and doesn't know how to take a compliment, so she responds in sarcasm. Jesus politely gives it back. Saying something along the lines of " Ohhh, so you're the one who gives the vines life" 🤣 Still he met her with patience, spoke truth and took his leave.
Then there was the conversation with Lavi about his biological parents, ensuring him he was loved and wanted. I just feel like the author has this gift of reflecting who He is, and his heart for his people. It's so sweet to me. I could almost envision him looking me in the eyes and having some of these conversations with me personally.
3) The people God placed in Talia's life to help her through heart break over and over. People willing to put in work. People who were willing to sit with her in her grief. People who loved her fiercely.and pointed her to truth People who walked the same road she did so they could emphasize with her pain, and people who were going to kick her in the butt and get her moving in the right direction. ( Malka has been one of my favorite characters in both books!)
This book made me laugh. It made me sob for several consecutive chapters, but it also healed little pieces of me.
It's the second book in the series. ( The Fisherman's Wife was the first.) This story is about Talia. She is about as stubborn as they come! Continuously piling in her own plate because it feels safer than trusting anyone else to help carry it, or maybe it's her way of clinging to a little control when everything else in her life feels like chaos... Either way! Enter James, one of the twelve disciples, whom makes it his personal goal to help her carry things ( literally and figuratively) from the moment he lays eyes on her. She is not a fan. Typical enemies to lovers trope.
There were so many things I loved about this book:
1) The banter between characters made me laugh out loud. I loved every last one of them and loved that many of the characters from book one made a return.
2) This goes for both books in the series, but I absolutely adore how Kaylee brings Jesus' character to life. In the first book, he had all these sweet, intimate, reassuring conversations with Mira, which was exactly what she needed. Talia was a harder but to crack as she was a little hesitant to believe he was the Messiah. There was one moment where he had come to her vineyard and was commenting on her work (something deeply meaningful to her as she feels so unseen in the weight she carries..) However as I mentioned before she's a little stubborn and doesn't know how to take a compliment, so she responds in sarcasm. Jesus politely gives it back. Saying something along the lines of " Ohhh, so you're the one who gives the vines life" 🤣 Still he met her with patience, spoke truth and took his leave.
Then there was the conversation with Lavi about his biological parents, ensuring him he was loved and wanted. I just feel like the author has this gift of reflecting who He is, and his heart for his people. It's so sweet to me. I could almost envision him looking me in the eyes and having some of these conversations with me personally.
3) The people God placed in Talia's life to help her through heart break over and over. People willing to put in work. People who were willing to sit with her in her grief. People who loved her fiercely.and pointed her to truth People who walked the same road she did so they could emphasize with her pain, and people who were going to kick her in the butt and get her moving in the right direction. ( Malka has been one of my favorite characters in both books!)
This book made me laugh. It made me sob for several consecutive chapters, but it also healed little pieces of me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 24, 2026
The second book in the series, (The Hearts of the Twelve), like the first is written from the perspective of the women - this time through the eyes of Talia, the vineyard owner and faithful keeper of the Law.
Talia sees keeping The Law as protection and blessing. There is little to no room for error or grace.
However, the vineyard is struggling and Talia can barely keep afloat with the excessive taxation demands. Her neighbour, Simon keeps prowling around, threatening, blustering and importuning her to marry him. Will Talia give in to his importunities when hardpressed?
Into this scenario, James bounces into her life without so much as a by your leave. Each encounter between them is like thunder rolling around.
Talia is sceptical of James and his offers to help and his assertion that Jesus is the long awaited and looked for Messiah? Is He the fulfillment of the Law or has He come to destroy it?
Talia's faith journey is like that of any skeptic, who wonders if God will accept him/her after they have spit on him and told him to get out!!
Scherer has also ably dealt with hard questions of faith, belief, sorrow, waves of intense grief, unanswerable, hard, 'why' questions, and without giving pat, glib answers, gently offers genuine consolation, carefully thoughtful different viewpoints and points us back to the Source as the one steady beacon through it all.
It's only on reading novels like this, you realise there is a considerable gap between Jesus' ascension and James' martyrdom. Gaps that could plausibly be filled as described in the novel.
While it is novel and fiction, one wonders if James was indeed married? As were the other apostles. Scripture is silent about it, but given the culture of the times, it is entirely possible.
Then, to have a gifted writer like Scherer exploring the possibilities and nuances, is to be served up a delectable feast for the senses.
I was given an eARC, but these opinions are my own.
Star rating: 4.5/5.
Talia sees keeping The Law as protection and blessing. There is little to no room for error or grace.
However, the vineyard is struggling and Talia can barely keep afloat with the excessive taxation demands. Her neighbour, Simon keeps prowling around, threatening, blustering and importuning her to marry him. Will Talia give in to his importunities when hardpressed?
Into this scenario, James bounces into her life without so much as a by your leave. Each encounter between them is like thunder rolling around.
Talia is sceptical of James and his offers to help and his assertion that Jesus is the long awaited and looked for Messiah? Is He the fulfillment of the Law or has He come to destroy it?
Talia's faith journey is like that of any skeptic, who wonders if God will accept him/her after they have spit on him and told him to get out!!
Scherer has also ably dealt with hard questions of faith, belief, sorrow, waves of intense grief, unanswerable, hard, 'why' questions, and without giving pat, glib answers, gently offers genuine consolation, carefully thoughtful different viewpoints and points us back to the Source as the one steady beacon through it all.
It's only on reading novels like this, you realise there is a considerable gap between Jesus' ascension and James' martyrdom. Gaps that could plausibly be filled as described in the novel.
While it is novel and fiction, one wonders if James was indeed married? As were the other apostles. Scripture is silent about it, but given the culture of the times, it is entirely possible.
Then, to have a gifted writer like Scherer exploring the possibilities and nuances, is to be served up a delectable feast for the senses.
I was given an eARC, but these opinions are my own.
Star rating: 4.5/5.
July 25, 2026
My review for this book is long overdue, but I found myself truly cherishing it--taking in every page, scene, and heartfelt moment and message. Kaylee Scherer's books will do that to you! The Thunder Between Us is not an exception; I absolutely loved everything about it: the writing, the storytelling, the characters, and especially the flawless incorporation of the real-life struggles we have as Christians.
Talia's character is one I deeply resonated with. Much like her, I tend to be ultra-independent, find it hard to rest, and even more difficult to ask for help and trust in things that are new, different, or scary for me. I love how this story takes her insecurities and weaknesses and uses them to steadily grow her faith and belief in Him.
I also love enemies-to-lovers romances, and really enjoyed Talia and James together, as well as the found family theme and precious mother-son duo between Talia and Lavi.
Finally, I love how Scherer seamlessly weaves in our real, human struggles. Grief and heartache are something we've all likely experienced before. Things happen that unravel and test our faith. Difficult circumstances cloud our judgment, our belief in Him. I've struggled with this so much. However, it's in those moments where you truly trust Him and His plan that you'll find the peace and understanding you need, just like Talia did. ❤️
Definitely pick up this book. It's worth every second of your time, and you'll feel encouraged, inspired, and reminded that you're loved by Him afterwards. ❤️ I can't wait to read John and Ruth's story in book #3!
✨ Biblical History
✨ Found Family
✨ Enemies-to-More
✨ Depression & Grief
✨ Grace vs. Legalism
✨ Jesus Calling
✨ Growing Faith
✨ The Thunder Between Us is the second installment of the "Hearts of the Twelve" series, but can be read as a standalone. Suitable for mature (16+) young adult readers and older for heavy thematic content, including grief and depression. ✨
Talia's character is one I deeply resonated with. Much like her, I tend to be ultra-independent, find it hard to rest, and even more difficult to ask for help and trust in things that are new, different, or scary for me. I love how this story takes her insecurities and weaknesses and uses them to steadily grow her faith and belief in Him.
I also love enemies-to-lovers romances, and really enjoyed Talia and James together, as well as the found family theme and precious mother-son duo between Talia and Lavi.
Finally, I love how Scherer seamlessly weaves in our real, human struggles. Grief and heartache are something we've all likely experienced before. Things happen that unravel and test our faith. Difficult circumstances cloud our judgment, our belief in Him. I've struggled with this so much. However, it's in those moments where you truly trust Him and His plan that you'll find the peace and understanding you need, just like Talia did. ❤️
Definitely pick up this book. It's worth every second of your time, and you'll feel encouraged, inspired, and reminded that you're loved by Him afterwards. ❤️ I can't wait to read John and Ruth's story in book #3!
✨ Biblical History
✨ Found Family
✨ Enemies-to-More
✨ Depression & Grief
✨ Grace vs. Legalism
✨ Jesus Calling
✨ Growing Faith
✨ The Thunder Between Us is the second installment of the "Hearts of the Twelve" series, but can be read as a standalone. Suitable for mature (16+) young adult readers and older for heavy thematic content, including grief and depression. ✨
Review of advance copy received from Author
I felt transported into Talia’s world. The vineyard, the struggles, the tension of Roman rule, and the weight of tradition all felt so vivid and beautifully written that I could almost feel the dust beneath my feet and the heat of the sun.
Talia was everything I love in a heroine. Fierce, determined, loyal, and stubborn in the most relatable way. She carried so much on her shoulders, and watching her wrestle with faith, fear, and the possibility that everything she believed could be challenged was such a powerful journey.
And James… what a character. Strong, bold, frustrating, compassionate, and exactly the kind of person Talia needed. Their dynamic was incredible because he didn’t just change her mind, he challenged her heart. Their story felt less like a romance and more like two people learning to truly see each other.
I absolutely loved all the characters. Talia was fierce, James was strong, Baruch grew on me and seeing Malka return was such a treat. Every character added something meaningful to the story.
The atmosphere was undeniable. The author brought this time period to life in a way that made the world feel real, not just like a backdrop. The struggles, the faith, the uncertainty, and the hope were woven together so beautifully.
This book will encompass your life while you’re reading it. It’s the kind of story you don’t just read but you live alongside the characters. A powerful story of faith, courage, love, and learning that sometimes the things we fear the most are the very things that lead us closer to the truth.
I received an ARC from the author. These thoughts are my own.
Talia was everything I love in a heroine. Fierce, determined, loyal, and stubborn in the most relatable way. She carried so much on her shoulders, and watching her wrestle with faith, fear, and the possibility that everything she believed could be challenged was such a powerful journey.
And James… what a character. Strong, bold, frustrating, compassionate, and exactly the kind of person Talia needed. Their dynamic was incredible because he didn’t just change her mind, he challenged her heart. Their story felt less like a romance and more like two people learning to truly see each other.
I absolutely loved all the characters. Talia was fierce, James was strong, Baruch grew on me and seeing Malka return was such a treat. Every character added something meaningful to the story.
The atmosphere was undeniable. The author brought this time period to life in a way that made the world feel real, not just like a backdrop. The struggles, the faith, the uncertainty, and the hope were woven together so beautifully.
This book will encompass your life while you’re reading it. It’s the kind of story you don’t just read but you live alongside the characters. A powerful story of faith, courage, love, and learning that sometimes the things we fear the most are the very things that lead us closer to the truth.
I received an ARC from the author. These thoughts are my own.
July 17, 2026
If you enjoy Christian fiction that brings Scripture to life, this one is worth picking up.
The Thunder Between is Book 2 in the Hearts of the Twelve Series. There’s just something about Kaylee’s stories that brings me to the feet of Jesus.
The lessons in her stories never come across as condemning. They reflect the gentle way Jesus meets us—with truth, grace, and love. Every time she writes Jesus onto the page, I'm reminded of watching The Chosen. It feels as though He's looking right at me, gently speaking to my heart.
I absolutely love Biblical fiction, and Kaylee is one of my favorites in this genre. This book was different from Peter and Mira’s story, but I enjoyed reading James and Talia’s story. It’s marketed as enemies to more, but I never really saw James viewing her as an enemy. She was definitely guarded and defensive around him, so I’d describe it more as a black cat and golden retriever dynamic—with her keeping her walls up and him bringing the warmth.
Through Talia, a fictional character woven into this biblical setting, we get to see someone who is guarded and standoffish begin to open her heart to James and discover the grace of Jesus. Her struggle between the law and grace was one of the most meaningful parts of the story.
I keep crying whenever I think about James. He really carried thunder with his bold and passionate personality. There were also moments of softness and gentleness when it came to Talia. But what stood out most was his unwavering devotion to Jesus - his faith was the foundation of who he was.
This story also explores depression and grief in such a raw and honest way. The characters’ struggles felt so real that I found myself hurting and hoping alongside them.
I enjoyed seeing the other disciples, the women, and meeting new characters like Lavi and Baruch. The found family in this story is so beautiful! Talia devotes so much of her time and energy to the vineyard that, when she’s welcomed into the church community, it becomes the found family she didn’t realize she needed.
The themes of seeds, gardens, timing, and growth make for such meaningful lessons of faith throughout the story. The verse that stayed with me while reading was John 15, which says that Jesus is the vine, we are the branches, and we need to abide in Him.
I’m looking forward to the next 10 books because the first two have already left a mark on my heart.
If you love Christian romance, especially Biblical romance, you will love this book.
The Thunder Between is Book 2 in the Hearts of the Twelve Series. There’s just something about Kaylee’s stories that brings me to the feet of Jesus.
The lessons in her stories never come across as condemning. They reflect the gentle way Jesus meets us—with truth, grace, and love. Every time she writes Jesus onto the page, I'm reminded of watching The Chosen. It feels as though He's looking right at me, gently speaking to my heart.
I absolutely love Biblical fiction, and Kaylee is one of my favorites in this genre. This book was different from Peter and Mira’s story, but I enjoyed reading James and Talia’s story. It’s marketed as enemies to more, but I never really saw James viewing her as an enemy. She was definitely guarded and defensive around him, so I’d describe it more as a black cat and golden retriever dynamic—with her keeping her walls up and him bringing the warmth.
Through Talia, a fictional character woven into this biblical setting, we get to see someone who is guarded and standoffish begin to open her heart to James and discover the grace of Jesus. Her struggle between the law and grace was one of the most meaningful parts of the story.
I keep crying whenever I think about James. He really carried thunder with his bold and passionate personality. There were also moments of softness and gentleness when it came to Talia. But what stood out most was his unwavering devotion to Jesus - his faith was the foundation of who he was.
This story also explores depression and grief in such a raw and honest way. The characters’ struggles felt so real that I found myself hurting and hoping alongside them.
I enjoyed seeing the other disciples, the women, and meeting new characters like Lavi and Baruch. The found family in this story is so beautiful! Talia devotes so much of her time and energy to the vineyard that, when she’s welcomed into the church community, it becomes the found family she didn’t realize she needed.
The themes of seeds, gardens, timing, and growth make for such meaningful lessons of faith throughout the story. The verse that stayed with me while reading was John 15, which says that Jesus is the vine, we are the branches, and we need to abide in Him.
I’m looking forward to the next 10 books because the first two have already left a mark on my heart.
If you love Christian romance, especially Biblical romance, you will love this book.
June 26, 2026
*Review of advance copy received from Author*
If you love biblical fiction that doesn't shy away from the messy, human side of faith, The Thunder Between Us is going to become one of your favourites.
This second book in the Hearts of the Twelve series follows Talia, a vineyard keeper whose life is ruled by hard work, control, and rigid adherence to the Law. When the loud, brash fisherman James (one the "Sons of Thunder") and his Teacher show up at her gate, Talia's carefully built walls begin to crack and what follows is a slow, painful, and beautiful journey toward grace and growth.
What I loved most: Talia is not instantly likeable, and that's exactly why her story resonates. She's stubborn, proud, and terrified of vulnerability, but her growth feels honest and earned. James is more than just thunder; he's loyal, tender, and respects Talia's strength without trying to diminish it. Their romance is a slow burn built on mutual respect, and the pacing feels natural as they don't fall in love quickly.
The novel also handles grief and depression with real care, which was a pleasant surprise, Talia's struggles after loss are raw and unflinching, and the way her community refuses to abandon her is a powerful reminder of the importance of sisterhood.
Minor caveat: The middle pacing lags a bit in Talia's internal resistance, and some supporting disciples feel underexplored. But the emotional payoff is absolutely worth it.
If you love biblical fiction that doesn't shy away from the messy, human side of faith, The Thunder Between Us is going to become one of your favourites.
This second book in the Hearts of the Twelve series follows Talia, a vineyard keeper whose life is ruled by hard work, control, and rigid adherence to the Law. When the loud, brash fisherman James (one the "Sons of Thunder") and his Teacher show up at her gate, Talia's carefully built walls begin to crack and what follows is a slow, painful, and beautiful journey toward grace and growth.
What I loved most: Talia is not instantly likeable, and that's exactly why her story resonates. She's stubborn, proud, and terrified of vulnerability, but her growth feels honest and earned. James is more than just thunder; he's loyal, tender, and respects Talia's strength without trying to diminish it. Their romance is a slow burn built on mutual respect, and the pacing feels natural as they don't fall in love quickly.
The novel also handles grief and depression with real care, which was a pleasant surprise, Talia's struggles after loss are raw and unflinching, and the way her community refuses to abandon her is a powerful reminder of the importance of sisterhood.
Minor caveat: The middle pacing lags a bit in Talia's internal resistance, and some supporting disciples feel underexplored. But the emotional payoff is absolutely worth it.
June 25, 2026
Why Biblical fiction? For me, it is a cross between historical fiction and Christian fiction. One cannot go into this type of book expecting fact and truth. Well, sort of… The truths presented in this book are not about the people who knew the apostles; rather, these truths pertain to any Christian, regardless of time period.
I received an ARC of this book, and it was suggested that I read the first book in the series before starting on this one, so I did. The first book was good, but it was just good. This book hit closer to home for me, and maybe that made me enjoy it more.
Talia clings to control, something I can relate to. In describing her relationship with God and her prayer life, she states, “Prayer was not a conversation. It was alignment. Order. Faithfulness rooted in obedience, not feeling.” My first reaction was “How sad.” Then it hit me: how many of us have been where Talia was, trying to do what is right, seemingly without results? So set in our ways that we can’t even see that there IS another way?
Understand: this series is not about the apostles; it is about the fictional women who were in their lives. I love how the author weaves what we know from the Gospels with what we feel today in our own lives. The fact that Talia was so relatable for me is what made this novel come alive. Looking forward to more!
I received an ARC of this book, and it was suggested that I read the first book in the series before starting on this one, so I did. The first book was good, but it was just good. This book hit closer to home for me, and maybe that made me enjoy it more.
Talia clings to control, something I can relate to. In describing her relationship with God and her prayer life, she states, “Prayer was not a conversation. It was alignment. Order. Faithfulness rooted in obedience, not feeling.” My first reaction was “How sad.” Then it hit me: how many of us have been where Talia was, trying to do what is right, seemingly without results? So set in our ways that we can’t even see that there IS another way?
Understand: this series is not about the apostles; it is about the fictional women who were in their lives. I love how the author weaves what we know from the Gospels with what we feel today in our own lives. The fact that Talia was so relatable for me is what made this novel come alive. Looking forward to more!
June 19, 2026
What an incredible book. This series of Biblical fiction has been the first for me that has really connected, made me raise questions, and internally look at my own faith. And I’m completely smitten with the wonderful cast of characters Kaylee has developed and created. Not only does Kaylee do a wonderful job creating romance in a story that is already preexisting in Scripture, but to give such incredible depth to these characters we are already familiar with. Watching Talia deal with her doubt and uncertainty of Jesus is something so many of us struggle with—especially without being able to see and witness the miracles from Scripture, and then her subsequent guilt at being “late” in believing is so real and encouraging that we aren’t alone in our struggle of accepting the Gospel at times.
For me, it felt like this book was written in a way that we are able to put a piece of ourselves in as Talia and gain something from her experiences in our own lives and how we grow and build our own faith, because it’s never a constant thing.
Five stars from my shelf to yours, I cannot wait for the rest of this series!
“Wrongness, is not the end of a man or a woman. It is the beginning of wisdom.”
For me, it felt like this book was written in a way that we are able to put a piece of ourselves in as Talia and gain something from her experiences in our own lives and how we grow and build our own faith, because it’s never a constant thing.
Five stars from my shelf to yours, I cannot wait for the rest of this series!
“Wrongness, is not the end of a man or a woman. It is the beginning of wisdom.”
Review of advance copy received from Author
Talia is responsible for tending to the family vineyard. A merchant from Capernaum is requesting her family’s wine again for a wedding party. She meets James, the son of Zebedee, whom she finds arrogant. Years later at the vineyard, a group of men are walking down the path and she recognizes James and he says they are followers of this Teacher. They stayed in their courtyard for the night and as He taught, she listened and it stirred something in her. James tells her that He is the Messiah. But she doesn’t believe him and sends them all away. Someone close to Talia is in a severe accident and is miraculously healed, and then she witnesses a miracle among thousands of people. But what will it take to get her to believe in this man they call the Son of God?
This is a story of a woman who could have walked beside one of Jesus’ closest followers. We know that there were women who were involved in the ministry and Talia’s story is imagining the life of one of them. It was a beautiful story that reminds us that He is the vine and we are the branches. 📚
Thanks to Kaylee Scherer for this ARC.
This is a story of a woman who could have walked beside one of Jesus’ closest followers. We know that there were women who were involved in the ministry and Talia’s story is imagining the life of one of them. It was a beautiful story that reminds us that He is the vine and we are the branches. 📚
Thanks to Kaylee Scherer for this ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Author
BLOWN AWAY! The Thunder Between Us is an awesome read, filled with faith, hope and resilience. The author wrote a fantastic story, insightful, mind-blowing and a story that keeps resonating through the years.
The Thunder between us is the story of Talia and James, the disciple of Jesus. I enjoyed the way the author interwove faith, finding God and learning to let go of tradition and accept God truly. Talia is a strong vibrant woman who is set to take up any obstacle, courageous and determined. As she meets James and the other disciples, she learns to step back, accept help as she knew God and not what was defined by the law .
I enjoyed seeing other characters as they walked with Jesus. Malka..... one woman that is so genuine, friendly and not one to shy away from the truth. Abba, Lavi, Baruch, Mira, John and all the characters made Thunder between us a fantastic read.
The way the author interwove fiction with the Bible... this story helps to shine more light on the human feelings and traits of the disciples as they walked with Jesus. The strength of Talia, James is one that keeps resonating.
I voluntarily read a copy of this book and the opinions are mine.
The Thunder between us is the story of Talia and James, the disciple of Jesus. I enjoyed the way the author interwove faith, finding God and learning to let go of tradition and accept God truly. Talia is a strong vibrant woman who is set to take up any obstacle, courageous and determined. As she meets James and the other disciples, she learns to step back, accept help as she knew God and not what was defined by the law .
I enjoyed seeing other characters as they walked with Jesus. Malka..... one woman that is so genuine, friendly and not one to shy away from the truth. Abba, Lavi, Baruch, Mira, John and all the characters made Thunder between us a fantastic read.
The way the author interwove fiction with the Bible... this story helps to shine more light on the human feelings and traits of the disciples as they walked with Jesus. The strength of Talia, James is one that keeps resonating.
I voluntarily read a copy of this book and the opinions are mine.
June 22, 2026
I was so blessed to ARC read The Thunder Between Us by @kaylee_scherer_author.
This is the second book in Hearts of the Twelve series. And it was a good one too.
I loved the story of Talia, not just because of her faith, but because of her resilience and her strength.
Even though she was unsure at times, she still had faith and trust. Talia still hung onto hope.
I loved how Kaylee created this beautiful, moving story, and she didn’t take anything away from the Bible or added anything to the Bible. She simple took creative liberty to give us a story of hope, trust, faith, love, and so much more.
I loved all the characters, especially Lavi. He was such a great character that added so much to the storyline. I loved how fierce and funny he was.
Overall, this story was really heartwarming and moving.
Thank you, @kaylee_scherer_author, for sharing this with us.
I highly recommend you read The Thunder Between Us. And I highly recommend you go read The New Testament about Jesus’ miracles that are mentioned in this book and the book of James.
You won’t regret reading any of this.
#heartsofthetwelve
#kayleeschererauthor
#faith
#Jesus
This is the second book in Hearts of the Twelve series. And it was a good one too.
I loved the story of Talia, not just because of her faith, but because of her resilience and her strength.
Even though she was unsure at times, she still had faith and trust. Talia still hung onto hope.
I loved how Kaylee created this beautiful, moving story, and she didn’t take anything away from the Bible or added anything to the Bible. She simple took creative liberty to give us a story of hope, trust, faith, love, and so much more.
I loved all the characters, especially Lavi. He was such a great character that added so much to the storyline. I loved how fierce and funny he was.
Overall, this story was really heartwarming and moving.
Thank you, @kaylee_scherer_author, for sharing this with us.
I highly recommend you read The Thunder Between Us. And I highly recommend you go read The New Testament about Jesus’ miracles that are mentioned in this book and the book of James.
You won’t regret reading any of this.
#heartsofthetwelve
#kayleeschererauthor
#faith
#Jesus
Review of advance copy received from Author
The Thunder Between Us is second book in the Hearts of the Twelve series. Main characters: James, Talia, Lavi, and many more.
I got the special opportunity to read this is a beta reader. I have read it several times since and every time I cry the same. It’s a beautiful story of redemption, grace, and love. I keep coming back to the main scripture in John 15 about the vine. Jesus is our true Vine & we are His branches.
“Remain in me, and I will remain in you. For a branch cannot produce fruit if it is severed from the vine, and you cannot be fruitful unless you remain in me.”
John 15:4 NLT
Talia had to learn how to trust that Jesus was who He says He was. She had always lived by the law of truth but never knowing the heart of God. When she meets James, one of Jesus’ disciples he changes everything about her. When a storm devastates the vineyard and tax collectors arrive early, Talia faces the unthinkable: accepting help from the very man she once tried to drive away or have her vineyard fall into the hands of very one she despises. Talia is challenged many times over the years and because she’s always worked so hard she has a hard time letting go of control.
James is the calm in her storm, one of my favorite parts of the book. He teaches her to trust Jesus too.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are all my own.
.
I got the special opportunity to read this is a beta reader. I have read it several times since and every time I cry the same. It’s a beautiful story of redemption, grace, and love. I keep coming back to the main scripture in John 15 about the vine. Jesus is our true Vine & we are His branches.
“Remain in me, and I will remain in you. For a branch cannot produce fruit if it is severed from the vine, and you cannot be fruitful unless you remain in me.”
John 15:4 NLT
Talia had to learn how to trust that Jesus was who He says He was. She had always lived by the law of truth but never knowing the heart of God. When she meets James, one of Jesus’ disciples he changes everything about her. When a storm devastates the vineyard and tax collectors arrive early, Talia faces the unthinkable: accepting help from the very man she once tried to drive away or have her vineyard fall into the hands of very one she despises. Talia is challenged many times over the years and because she’s always worked so hard she has a hard time letting go of control.
James is the calm in her storm, one of my favorite parts of the book. He teaches her to trust Jesus too.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are all my own.
.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is my new favorite by this author! It was poignant and beautifully descriptive. I was in tears by the end, but it wasn’t sad, it was from rejoicing and truly feeling the main female character’s emotions. Thalia is such a beautiful character and I understand her viewpoint, because I didn’t always follow Christ. It is better to not shame yourself for the time that you spent not following Him. He does not call you to do that. He only wants to follow Him, in whatever way He calls you. I grew closer to God through this book and I can’t recommend it enough! Thank you for letting me read this early and being a part of this.
August 10, 2026
Heart wrenching !! A Must Read !!
Many Women are like Talia , hard working humble not Realizing yourself worth . But The Lord Sees You & Everything You do , small or great . This book opens your eyes to grace & redemption . You may not be looking for it but The Lord Sees Are Needs before hand . James Was Right There All Along in front of Talia , Lord new she needed help & To be Loved. This book will open your heart to Grace & Love , True Love that only comes from Our Father In Heaven !!
Many Women are like Talia , hard working humble not Realizing yourself worth . But The Lord Sees You & Everything You do , small or great . This book opens your eyes to grace & redemption . You may not be looking for it but The Lord Sees Are Needs before hand . James Was Right There All Along in front of Talia , Lord new she needed help & To be Loved. This book will open your heart to Grace & Love , True Love that only comes from Our Father In Heaven !!
June 30, 2026
This series!!! I thought I loved the first book, but man this one was just as powerful! I loved that it was a completely different story, but it felt like stepping into the same world as the first. For some reason, when a book is really powerful and hits me with all the feels, I have the hardest time putting words to my review. I can only say that this book made me laugh, cry, but most importantly it brought me closer to my Savior. I highly recommend not just this book, but the entire series!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This second story of the Hearts of the Twelve series is even more moving than The Fisherman's Wife, this one struck me, i laughed, I gasped, I cried, I felt allll the feels. I love Talia and James, their story is sooo good, i definitely recommend.
Disclaimer: I was provided an advance reader copy by the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Disclaimer: I was provided an advance reader copy by the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
June 23, 2026
I absolutely loved this book! It was hard for me to put it down. This book is so far my favorite out of the series! I can’t wait to see what to read the others when they come out. The author did a beautiful job writing this book and just bringing God into this reading moment for me. I felt Holy Spirit when reading this book and it even at times made me emotional.
July 3, 2026
The Thunder
What a wonderful book.It helped to bring to life what it was like to be a true believer in the beginning. What a blessing to be able to meet Jesus and his disciples.I know that we all struggle with some of the same things we find in this book,but what a joy to know we can all enjoy the same rewards.
What a wonderful book.It helped to bring to life what it was like to be a true believer in the beginning. What a blessing to be able to meet Jesus and his disciples.I know that we all struggle with some of the same things we find in this book,but what a joy to know we can all enjoy the same rewards.
September 12, 2026
A beautiful read!
I read biblical fiction often because I love imagining with the author the stories in between. It is rare to find a book in this genre so beautifully written! I enjoyed the poetry of her descriptions and the passion of the character's struggles. Truly, I didn't want to come to the end. Masterfully done! Thank you.
I read biblical fiction often because I love imagining with the author the stories in between. It is rare to find a book in this genre so beautifully written! I enjoyed the poetry of her descriptions and the passion of the character's struggles. Truly, I didn't want to come to the end. Masterfully done! Thank you.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is an amazing faith filled story. Talia and James story is really sweet, and the biblical elements were written really well and helped me learn and understand things much better as well. This was a terrific book, and I would definitely recommend it.
June 24, 2026
love love love these books
I loved the first book and I was not disappointed with this one. I look forward to reading more of what this author writes. Definitely one of my favorite series. Highly highly recommend
I loved the first book and I was not disappointed with this one. I look forward to reading more of what this author writes. Definitely one of my favorite series. Highly highly recommend
June 27, 2026
A great book!
I really enjoyed this book. I am so stubborn and could relate to the characters. Great writing! Relatable! Top notch!
I really enjoyed this book. I am so stubborn and could relate to the characters. Great writing! Relatable! Top notch!
August 6, 2026
Kindle Unlimited
June 20, 2026
This book is by far my favorite in the series, thus far! A beautiful story of finding faith, and that no matter how long it takes to come to faith you are still just as usable to Christ. I love that the parables are used so much to relate to the characters lives and that the characters lives explain the parables to our hearts. What a fantastic story and worth the read!
*I was given a complementary copy and was not required to leave a review.
*I was given a complementary copy and was not required to leave a review.
August 17, 2026
This author never disappoints!! I loved everything about it and I deeply needed the nuggets of encouragement placed inside. Excited for the next one!!
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews