I opened this book with positive expectations; they were partially fulfilled. At each turn however they were tainted by, of all things, politics. Why include so many references to an aspect of life that is sure to alienate not a small percentage of your potential readers?
Larry answers this himself. It is the in-your-face confrontational aspect of Irish music, Irish culture, and the Irish psyche. It is music whose message is meant to stimulate and challenge the listener, even to prod the listener into action, to join in the rage as it were. It is unsettling that Larry, when speaking of live performance, mentions of the danger of mixing alcohol with provocative lyrics and agitated delivery and yet never seem to connect the dots with regards to potential negative consequences.
Why the rage? The stereotypical image of the drunken Irishman looking for a fight to address an insult, real or imagined, no doubt stems from generations of Irishmen steeped in a septic outlook on life. Why would a culture, Irish or otherwise, evolve in that manner? The famine? The domination by England? Who knows. I do know that it is in many ways a culture of "us", the downtrodden, against "them", the oppressors. As such it is a culture of division and confrontation and, in my opinion, is medieval.
I have a hard time reconciling the two Larry Kirwans: One is the soft-spoken, humorous, engaging and thoughtful host of the Celtic Crush program. His voice sometimes descends into a whisper as he adds personal insights and anecdotes before and after the selections he plays. The other Larry Kirwan is the sometimes shouting, sometimes screaming, frenetic performer in Black 47.
Make no mistake, the history of groups, performers and venues, the tracing of the careers and ensemble iterations, the ups and downs of the significant players in this genre of music IS in the book. It's there, and it's interesting for sure, and that's where the three star rating came from. And to be sure, not all the music is political. There are at least two other themes: love, lost and potential; and Ireland itself as an ideal or as in causing homesickness in the diaspora populations. The book IS about the music with just enough politics to be distracting.
While not openly endorsing socialism, he comes close and more than once slams capitalism and "consumerism". He seems to buy into the nonsense of the "1%" and "economic slavery" while, I note, that he seems to be doing quite well for himself even with all the "chains" that "they" are imposing on the downtrodden.
Say, I wonder how Mr. Kirwan reconciles the Irish attitude of 'no insult left unpunished' with his clear distaste for America's response to 9/11? Dr. Freud, line one please...
I found the last entry in the book, the lyrics for a song called America 2014, written by Kirwan, maddening. What an unnecessary and misleading way to close. Perhaps Mr. Kirwan is employing his unstoppable inner Irish drive to rail against the biggest "them" of all, one that has done so much for so many and for him personally.