Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Alchemists: A Contemporary Dark Academia Fantasy Romance

Rate this book
Enter the spellbinding world of The Alchemists—where arcana, secrets, and romance collide in a modern-day dark academia fantasy perfect for fans of R.F. Kuang’s Katabasis, and Leigh Bardugo’s Ninth House series.

Windermere College for the Ætheric Arts was founded to make magic accessible to anyone who can call Æther, but in the 300 years since its founding it’s become the perfect symbol for magical elitism: to get in one needs old money, old connections, or both.

Sebastian Allsaires is old money and old magic—a sportsman and a scholar. And Lily Perkins? Lily is a loner, and more importantly she’s cursed. Literally.

When they’re thrown together as lab partners for a year long Alchemy course they realize they have far more in common than meets the eye. Together they uncover secrets both arcane and mundane about the founding of their school and the fabric of their society. What they learn just may bring them together if it doesn’t tear them apart first.

Magic itself has intention, and the truth will out.

For readers who crave intelligent characters, precisely rendered magic, and an unforgettable romance—join Sebastian Allsaires and Lily Perkins at Windermere College for the Ætheric Arts for an academic year unlike any other.

593 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 22, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Stacey Strange

1 book19 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
66 (55%)
4 stars
40 (33%)
3 stars
9 (7%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
2 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews
Profile Image for Marissa C.
284 reviews65 followers
August 11, 2026
The Alchemists by Stacey Strange is a magical academia book with romance.
It features LGBQTIA+ characters and offers a world full of magical spells and alchemy. Many times, I did find myself comparing it to Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, but this is definitely more contemporary is for a more mature audience. It leans more into the romance, but is not too spicy. I wish I had read the Appendixes first, as there were times I was a bit confused in the magical terms.
Chant and Tori were my favorite secondary characters that offered genuine depth to the book. They truly cared for Seb and Lily and were well rounded characters.
I thought the romance was very well done. It felt sweet and real, from hurt and sacrifice to a deep friendship and eventually, love.
The Enumara trials and Cantrea were my favorite magical aspects of this book. Cantrea being the magical sport and Enumara being the adventuresome alchemical quest for the students.
Overall, this was an enjoyable book that was a magical romance. I think it would be very enjoyable for young adults and adults alike. This would be a 3.5 for me! A big thanks to the author for a the ARC!
Profile Image for Cierra.
58 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 20, 2026
The book was provided as an ARC from the author! Thank you for the opportunity!

Ending:
TW:
Spiciness: Closed door/fade to black

As per the Romance Writers of America, a book categorized as “romance” (and not just a romance subplot) has two have two things: a central love story and an emotionally satisfying and optimistic ending (better known as a happily ever after/HFA or happy for now/HFN ending) (Source: rwa.org/the-romance-genre). Without those two things, you do not have a book that should be in the romance category.

I will come back to this later, but first:

The Alchemists is a third person POV dark academia fantasy that switches back and forth between our FMC (Lily) and MMC (Sebastian). Our story is about two misfits who feel like they don’t fit in as much as they would like to (one because of her curse and the other because of his past). Both characters are students at Windermere College and use magic that is called Aether to learn, live, fight, love. Sebastian (or Seb) comes from old money, and Lily is the downtrodden cursed girl who everyone treats like trash. After they get unexpectedly paired, they learn new things about themselves and the world around them and try to keep each other safe by any means possible.

The first 30ish% of the book felt almost…pretentious in its use of “vocabulary” words, so it was a little difficult to get through that bit; after about the 30% mark, the story flowed a lot better, almost like the author had to shake off some nervousness before reaching her flow state.

The love story of Lily and Seb and the fact that they were both smart and accomplished, fairly well matched (outside of the curse) was really good/nice. I feel like sometimes in these types of books, either one character is way better than the other or it’s a “SURPRISE! MC has powers they didn’t know about!” There was a lot of LGBTQ+ representation in the book, with trans and bi characters. However, we do see that this society is snooty (like most of the upper crust), and do not like the queerness of our LGBT characters, much as it is in real life.

The villain/s felt almost too demonic/evil/bad, if that makes sense? Like there were no moral grey spots here, it was like every bad thing that a character could do, they did it. Additionally, I had some questions that were left unanswered And, although I really liked Seb’s friends (ride-or-die types) after they really get to know Lily, I wish they had apologized orsomething since they were also technically bullies/bystanders to the bullying in the before [before the book began]. Seb apologies like a million times, but Tori only apologies when she’s done something after Lily joins up.

And now, we are going to come back to what I said at the beginning of the review, about the romance genre.

The ending of this book The ending almost felt like a precipice that something was maybe going to happen eventually a while down the road, but that is not a true ending to a romance book with no sequels. Like you’re at the top of the rollercoaster, but instead of going down the hill and completing the ride, you get sent slowly backwards back to the station because the ride can’t function anymore.

I will say that this story did feel fairly different and had a lot of diverse characters in it. Honestly, the characters themselves (not the villains of course) is what kept this book from being lower than it is. The scene-setting also helped keep the score up, as I feel the descriptions were very easily imaginable and actually did feel very much like the “dark academia” the book touts itself as.

I hate the ending (and epilogue), but loved most of the story and characters, which is why this book is getting three stars from me.
 
Profile Image for Tiffani.
156 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 21, 2026
Thank you to the author for this ARC!

Release date: September 22, 2026

What to expect
📚 Dual POV
📚 Dark academia
📚 Friends to lovers
📚 Magical academy
📚 Cursed FMC
📚 Queer representation
⚠️ Trigger warnings: bullying, mention of sexual assault (not between main characters), homophobia, transphobia

What a great debut! I devoured this book and really enjoyed it! I can tell that the author put a lot of thought into creating this world and the magic system. I appreciated the detailed appendices at the end as there were times I found myself getting confused at the magical terms being used. However, that did not affect my reading experience.

I loved the academic setting, the magical quest, the found family and the unraveling of secrets surrounding Windermere College. But what truly gives this story its heart are the main characters Lily and Seb. Oh, how I love these two. Lily is so sweet and endearing even though she has been treated as an outcast by the magical society and her peers her entire life. I couldn't help but root for her, especially with her curse looming over her. I adored Sebastian because despite being known as the confident, golden boy elite of the school he was actually someone struggling deeply with family expectations and unresolved trauma. I wanted to wrap both Lily and Seb up in a giant bear hug and protect them from the world.

The romance between Lily and Seb was incredibly sweet and heartbreaking. Their relationship starts as careful interest and grows deeper as they work together as lab partners for their class. I really loved how vulnerable they were with each other and that they showed pieces of themselves that no one else has seen. It is their deep understanding and trust in each other that ultimately pushes them from friends to lovers. The way my heart was ripped out of my chest with the ending...JAIL!!! I had to stare at the wall for a while because I was so HURT 😭

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"He wanted, he realized, to make her smile every day. He wanted to kiss her every second."

"She was a book he wanted to read every page of and commit to memory with perfect recall."
Profile Image for katrina カトリーナ.
63 reviews
July 8, 2026
Review! This is divided in 3 parts: the short version, my initial 5 seconds post read, and the long book report style. Thank you so much for the ARC & without further ado…. my thoughts on The Alchemists.

~~~THE SHORT VERSION~~~
Why I wanted to read this one: you had me at arcane magical academic story

Why I love this: This feels like a love letter to ambition in the face of life’s unexpected challenges. Be it a curse no one asked for, expectations of society, social pressures, or connection in the most unlikely of places… The world Lily and Seb live in is so dynamic. Not only do the characters grow multi-dimensionally throughout the course of the book, but also are so deeply tied to the world and literal magic around them.


~~~I FINISHED 5 SECONDS AGO HERE ARE MY THOUGHTS~~~
Reading this felt like a whirlwind & was absolutely a book I could not put down (save for sleep). The story was thrilling, heart wrenching, and so incredibly lovely that it’s hard to believe that the premise is magical academia & a girl who is cursed.

What transpires within the pages is unexpectedly so much more. The writing flows, the characters and their personalities give you something to root for (or against in some cases), and the intricacies of the magic system are absolute fun to nerd out over. There’s equally space left for “what’s unsaid” or the transition between scenes. While originally I felt a lot of “no wdym explain that” by the end I see how it’s all tied together.

Will update after I’ve sat with it for a bit but holy heck 5 stars

~~~LONG STORY LONG: WHY THIS BOOK DESERVES EVERY STAR!~~~
So… how did we get here and by here I mean the end of this book. What I originally thought was going to be the story of Lily, a student with a curse hanging over her head, ended up being a world full of color. How many possible storylines could overlap here? Its incredible that it all works — from Lily and Seb’s individual issues, their relationships with each other, their relationships with classmates, um what’s Chant’s deal?, Cantrea!, a school-wide competition (Elumnara), the actual academics of studying at a magical school like Windermere, the class divide between old money and… the rest of them (?), competition with other schools,… I could go on, but there’s so much here that every page and perspective flip felt like new ideas to raise questions about. Honestly, I was fearful that it wouldn’t all come together in the end!

The systems and complexities of said systems were thoroughly fun to learn. Like wdym I’m so invested in Cantréa and the rules (shoutout to the appendix for sharing the full details to support what’s seen through Lily and Seb’s POVs).

Let’s talk about WORDS, because this book is full of ‘em! And before you say, “duh”… hear me out. There’s very specific ways that a Magician’s Words are discussed, and how Words are the equivalent of the deepest most intimate part of one’s soul. Isn’t that profound? There’s also the way names change (completely, in Tori’s case), like how as Lily gets closer to him, Seb goes from Allsaires to Sebastian to Seb (back to… well read and find out). Speaking of words, I happened to read this shortly after that one Threads/Book social media heated discussion regarding authors including uncommon / difficult words — man the number that I highlighted as “wow haven't seen that in a while” or “wow I didn’t know you could use X like that” — added tremendously to the story.

Some favorites:
- languorous
- boustrophedon
- subterfuge
- triptych
- facsimiles
- prescience
- knell
- apotheosis
- defenestrated
***perhaps reading words like this merely contributed to the overall “dark academia” vibe, perhaps it gave me flashbacks to drilling SAT vocab cards bc that was definitely the last time I’ve seen most if not all of these… but who’s to say for sure!

Also, I enjoyed that the Words and Spells were also informed by other cultures. There’s a mention at the beginning about the tones in Mandarin and Cantonese being special to Words of Power. Some spells cast during Cantrea have origins in Feudal Era Japan. It was refreshing to see intersectional inspirations, especially as related to magic.

To conclude these rather rambling thoughts, I loved this! A book that I don't want to put down, that I would love to lose sleep over, and felt my emotions respond in a physical way = can only be one thing ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Notable scenes:
✨ Basically anything in Chant’s class, but the wolves are certainly a highlight

✨ Every. Single. Cantrea. Match.

✨ The winery… all of it (even tho the back half of that scene that ends up with Lily driving is pure trauma… my blood was boiling whilst reading this)

✨ The phone call until he fell asleep :,)


Quotes:

✨ “Memory is an unreliable mistress that way.”

✨ “Alchemy is the poetry of matter.”

✨ “’She knows what the real world has to offer.’” - Asher

✨ “She loved the sport as much as any Magician, and somehow that ruthless boy made the intersection of movement and magic seem next to godliness. Lily grimaced at her toast and wondered if perhaps her love of Cantrea was really a love of watching Allsaires play Cantrea.

✨”Yet somehow Fate, that slow weaving, merciless and merciful mistress, has thrown us together, like twin opposites, into the alembic… There was a thread, invisible, running between him and Lily Perkins. If you boiled them down to their essence, that thread would remain.”


✨✨✨ Note to the Author ✨✨✨
TYSM FOR THE ARC
also…. respectfully and in the best way: HOW DID YOU DO THIS HOW DID YOU WRITE THIS??? IT IS PURE MAGIC


🚨🚨🚨SPOILERS BELOW!🚨🚨🚨
Okay at 76% I made a comment about if the ending turns out to be Romeo and Juliet type (since Shakespeare had already come up passively) that I’d throw hands / be upset… THE ENDING??? Please let this be an opening for a sequel or for something else because WHAT DO YOU MEAN Lily lives but the cost is all of Seb’s memories??????????? On one hand thank god some things are forgotten but the fact that he doesn’t remember her????? BRO

I will be hung up on this for at least a week if not longer…. @ Ms. Stacey Strange this is my formal request for more of Lily and Seb please
Profile Image for TattedmomREADS.
178 reviews14 followers
October 2, 2026
There are some books you finish and immediately know you are going to be thinking about them for a very, very long time. This is one of those books. In fact, it may be one of the best reading experiences I have had in a long time.
The magic system alone is extraordinary. It is novel, intricate, and so deeply woven into the story that it never feels like worldbuilding for worldbuilding’s sake. The academic setting is equally immersive. I loved how much time we spend learning alongside the characters, in their classrooms & through their coursework. There is something so satisfying about watching the characters actually study magic and alchemy rather than simply existing in a world where magic happens. At times, I wanted to describe it as a more mature, sophisticated Harry Potter-esque world, but that comparison feels wholly inadequate. This book is doing something far more intricate and emotionally complex. And as someone who spent nearly a decade formally studying English literature, I absolutely adored the literary allusions scattered throughout the story. Shakespeare, Mary and Percy Shelley, Byron, Keats 🙂 Those references made my little literature-loving heart bounce! They add another layer of texture and meaning to an already incredibly rich story.

Lily has resigned herself to her curse and to living quietly in the shadowed corners, content and determined to remain unseen. Then Seb, the perceived golden boy, finally truly notices her, dancing alone in an empty studio. From that moment, something between them begins to take shape that feels enormous. I loved that they don't immediately fall into romance, they first become genuine friends. We get to watch them learn each other & challenge the assumptions they have made about one another. Slowly, they become tethered in a way that feels both inevitable and completely consuming. Their love story is emotionally brilliant. It is tender and all-consuming, and ultimately so beautifully devastating that I genuinely don't know how to talk about it without saying too much or breaking down in tears. The ending left me absolutely wrecked, but in that rare way where the devastation feels earned & profoundly beautiful. This is the kind of romance that reminds you why stories about love can hurt so much in the first place.

Stacey Strange's writing is immaculate & deeply moving to me. She writes emotion with such precision that even the quieter moments carry enormous weight. The characters have my entire heart. Lily and Seb, obviously, but also the side characters who became just as vivid to me: Professor Chant, Asher, Tori. They are all so distinct that I could picture them almost immediately. The book also goes places that feel remarkably honest and difficult. Its LGBTQ+ representation is woven naturally into the world, while its treatment of PTSD and trauma stemming from sexual assault is harrowing in a way that never feels gratuitous. These elements give the story a depth that reaches far beyond the fantasy romance framework. That emotional complexity is a huge part of what elevates this book for me.

I finished this book feeling like I had experienced something rather than simply read it. And honestly, I'm still not over it. I don’t know if I ever will be.

Favorite Quotes:
“Seb had his own gravity, pulling in innumerable other bodies, celestial and otherwise, while Lily was some small, dark planet that took generations to orbit the sun.”
“It took her a moment to realize that she was comforting him. No one had ever wanted her comfort before--she hadn’t known she’d had any to give.”
“...they started to twist like saplings around each other, striving for the same sun.”
“She was a book he wanted to read every page of and commit to memory with perfect recall.”
“I fear that nothing but the sky shall satisfy the ache in me.”
“Relationships are their own sort of alchemy, I think. They require a similar process—purifying, refining, dissolving of two seemingly disparate entities, until you find a center that can hold.”
Profile Image for Alexandra Chase.
34 reviews
July 5, 2026
The Alchemist follows two magicians at Windermere College whose worlds unexpectedly collide. One who is born into an elite family and wants to earn things in his life, as everything is handed to him. And another who is a cursed half magician who works hard for everything she has.

I throughly enjoyed this book. The magic system was unique and well thought out. There is a game element to the book which was also unique and thought out. I love that the author included further information on the magic system, the game, and all the magic institutions. I don’t feel it is necessary to read the extra information if you do not want, but it was nice to reference.

The book in the beginning is slower and picks the more you get into the book. I felt this pacing was nice as it gives you time to wrap your head around the world and the magic system.

I loved watching the characters grow and learn to accept themselves as they were.

I will definitely be adding this book to my recommendations.

I was not paid for this review.
Profile Image for Becky.
434 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 9, 2026
4.5⭐️, but I'm rounding up for Seb!
" Relationships are their own sort of alchemy, I think. They require a similar process- purifying, refining, dissolving of two seemingly disparate entities, until you find a center that can hold."

Me sitting here for 20 minutes after I got to the end trying to process because please someone tell me it is not ending here!
This isn't just a dark academia story. It has such a beautiful love story with one of the best mmcs I've ever read.
Lily Perkins is cursed to die. Born as a half magical, an anomaly that shouldn't exist in her world, she is both feared and hated.
Sebastian is Windermere Academy's golden boy. Handsome, wealthy, and athletic. He appears to have it all, but not everything is as it seems.
When Lily and Seb are forced to become partners, secrets come to light.
I absolutely love Sebastian. He was such a refreshing break from the typical morally gray mmc. He's such a kind and loving soul to Lily and his friends. His reaction when he competes against Adriana in the tournament is a perfect example. It was absolutely heartwarming.
The story was a little slow in the beginning, but the last 100 pages were absolutely insane. There were so many twists and turns that I did not see coming. Especially the one with Gemma.
But that ending! How rude! I need to know what happens next with their relationship!
Thank you for choosing me to be an ARC Reader!
Profile Image for K.B. Mallows.
68 reviews11 followers
September 19, 2026
4⭐️
I had to sit with this for a few days to decide how I felt. I've alternated between feeling down right angry about that ending or completely impressed that it was like no ending I've ever read before. I'm trying to look at this book as a whole and not just judge it by how the conclusion made me feel on top of the knowledge that this may very well be a standalone.

There were moments of pure genius in this book, and moments that filled me with more anxiety than I think I've ever felt for fictional characters. I both loved and hated the latter. Loved because it made me feel something real. Hated because, well, who really wants to feel constant anxiety?

The writing is lovely and descriptive. The style reminds me of literary fiction; if you're looking for an easy read, this is not the book. This book will challenge you to think and feel, and some of it may be uncomfortable.

The Alchemists takes place in an academic setting for individuals with magic - magicians, if you will. Immediately I got dark, adult Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire vibes. The world of magic is deeply layered and complex, fascinating and unusual, and you can tell that the author spent a great deal of time planning out this magic system. It was so deeply layered to sometimes be ambiguous, and I found myself rereading scenes to make sure I fully grasped the meaning.

The Cantrea games (like a magician style combat competition) and the race against time to uncover clues for the school trials added a necessary layer of fun to a story that quickly revealed itself to be dealing with some very heavy themes. The literal magic in this book was fantastic, but the true magic was what the author did with these two main characters, Lily and Seb.

I love a good character-driven story, and every character in The Alchemists was full of depth. I quickly felt attached to both Lily and Seb for entirely different reasons.

Lily and her station in life were very relatable to me - an introvert from a middle-class family who tried very hard to be invisible in school to avoid the bullies. I felt very protective of her, despite her obvious inner strength.

Seb was an interesting character because his lifestyle was foreign to me - wealthy boy who's good at everything and whom everyone wants to be, but he's hiding behind this persona, desperate for someone to truly see him. I empathized with him, but could never fully trust him. He had too many moments of regret and near bad decisions that would have hurt Lily.

The way this author brought together these two characters from different social classes and led them to find common ground was masterful. Their love story was tender and believable, and I wanted more of this. But the tone of their love felt to me like it changed after they were intimate and helped one another to deal with each of their personal traumas, with Seb becoming more self-absorbed.

And, lord, were their traumas traumatic! They were probably the worst traumas I've seen two characters have to deal with. Their growth in overcoming these personal traumas together was raw and beautiful. They were attuned to each other's needs in a way I haven't experienced often in two romantic characters. The author's talent with words helps you visualize or feel exactly what the characters were feeling as they felt it, which I think is one reason why I felt so strongly about them.

True romantic relationships when you are young (and especially in your college years) are too often messy, complicated, uncertain, intoxicating, gut-wrenching, and led entirely by emotion. I appreciated how REAL these college relationships felt in this book even if my heart rebelled against it a little bit because I'm at a place of peace in my life where I don't want to be reminded of how young love can hurt.

But then came the ending... and this was entirely too much. After so many anxiety-inducing moments, I longed for these two, who've overcome SO much trauma already, to finally get their happily ever after. I NEEDED it! But, no. It ended in the most anxiety-inducing way I could have imagined, with no real resolve. I feel a bit empty and slightly betrayed. I know this was left open to interpretation. But I don't want to draw my own conclusions; I want something concrete.

I'm giving this book 4⭐️ because I think anything less for such a well written book would be a travesty. The mark of a true storyteller is one who can put you through all the emotions in few words, and I definitely went down the emotional rollercoaster with this one. I may not be satisfied with the conclusion, but I can appreciate that the underlying message was solid, and I believe many readers will enjoy this book just as it is.

If you like books that are heavily character-driven and complex, in a magical academic setting with a dark history and even darker secrets, and a storyline that might fray your nerves with its realness, you'll probably enjoy this book.

Thank you to the author for sharing an advanced reader copy of this book with me. This review is my honest opinion, and I'm leaving it voluntarily.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Amber Fitzpatrick.
31 reviews4 followers
July 21, 2026
5/5 ⭐️s

Lily and Seb…..Seb and Lily. These characters have burrowed their way into a little piece of my heart, and I will never forget them.

If you like….

🪄Dark Academia
🪄A Cursed FMC
🪄Dual POV
🪄Romance with Minimal Spice
🪄An MMC in Touch with his Emotions (mostly)
🪄LGBTQ+ Themes
🪄Arcane Magic

Then this book is for you! Reminiscent of Ninth House, Babel and An Arcane Study of Stars, The Alchemists delievered in every way. The story is set at Windemere College, and the students are magicians. Lily is a cursed loner, while Sebastian is wealthy and popular. When they are matched together as lab partners, they are both surprised to learn they aren’t as different as they thought they were. As their relationship develops, will they be able to overcome the scrutiny and challenges facing them, and even more importantly, will they survive Lily’s curse? This book is full of romance (mild spice), magic, magical tournaments and magical quests! The character development is out of this world, and the story will have you ignoring your bedtime to keep reading.

The Alchemists will be released on September 22, 2026.

And finally, thank you to Stacey for giving me the opportunity to read this beautiful book!
Profile Image for BrizeeReads .
132 reviews8 followers
August 22, 2026

Let’s talk about The Alchemists!
Do you want a friends to lover story?
Do you want age appropriate characters who you don’t have to feel awkward about?
Do you want a magical school with its own magical rules?
Do you want magic?
What about characters that will break and heal your heart all at the same time?
An epic representation of the LGBTQ community?
Yes yes and YES!!!

In this spellbinding story we follow Lilly a cursed magician who has an expectation date looming over her head and Sebastian a well off rich boy with internal struggles about his privilege.
This is duel POV story that intertwines our main characters together along with some fated magic.
This book had me hooked from the start and ripped my heart out by the end. Some parts had me on the edge of my seat while others had me screaming at the book itself. The world is immersive and the characters felt real. The story does NOT hold back on the trauma and violence without it feeling forced or just for shock value. Everything was written with intent and beauty. I would highly recommend this book to those who love fantasy and academia.
Profile Image for inkedbyashreads.
40 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 19, 2026
Stacey, you have ripped my heart out, gave it back to me, and then somehow ripped it out all over again 😩

I genuinely don’t think I have the words to explain how much this book affected me. I went into The Alchemists expecting dark academia, magic, secrets and romance, but I was not prepared for how emotionally attached I would become to Lily and Seb and the world of Windermere.

Their story had me feeling absolutely everything. The tension, the heartbreak, the longing, the love, the moments that made me hopeful and the moments that completely shattered me. I felt so invested in them that by the end, I just sat there trying to process everything I’d read.

I also loved the academic setting, the arcane magic, the secret histories and the whole atmosphere surrounding Windermere College. It felt intelligent, immersive and completely addictive but for me, Lily and Seb were the heart of this book.

This is one of those stories that doesn’t just end when you close the book. It stays with you.

Lily and Seb’s story will stay with me for a very, very long time.

Phenomenal. Emotional. Unforgettable.

I truly have no words other than… wow. ❤️‍🩹
Profile Image for escapepassage.
25 reviews2 followers
September 9, 2026
I finished this last night and needed time to gather my thoughts, I felt like I got the wind knocked out of me, because, it can’t end like that! This story is engaging, addictive, heartwrenching, hopeful, and just so beautifully written.

The character development was incredible and the story had such a diverse representation, including mental health, SA, LGBTQ, etc. We get a duel POV with this. Lily, our FMC, has carried a curse all her life, as a punishment for deeds not her own. Our MMC, Sebastian (Seb), comes from an elite family and has been handed everything his entire life but wants to find a way to earn it. We also have some well fleshed out secondary characters with trauma and growth of their own.

The world building was also top tier. The magical school, game, society, history and quest are so intricately depicted that you can see this world. And of course, the Alchemy, what brought all these characters together and was so poetically written and immersed in the characters growth that “all is circular” (page 20).
Profile Image for Teela Mostowy .
17 reviews4 followers
September 24, 2026
Thank you for choosing me to be an ARC reader!

I really enjoyed The Alchemists by Stacey Strange. I loved the magical academy setting and the world that was created. The writing is so good, and the alchemy parts were so interesting. I loved learning about how the alchemy worked within the magical world.

Lily and Seb were definitely my favorite part of the book. Their relationship felt very sweet and tender, and I loved watching them go from friends to something more.

I also enjoyed the magical classes, games, quests, and the secrets surrounding the academy. There was a lot to discover, and I liked seeing the magical world come together throughout the story.

What to expect:

✨ Dark academia
✨ Magical academy
✨ Friends to lovers
✨ Slow burn
✨ Dual POV
✨ Found family
✨ Magic & alchemy
✨ Cursed FMC
✨ LGBTQIA+ representation

Overall, this was a really fun read for me. I enjoyed the characters, the romance, and especially the alchemy and magical elements. The ending...uuuggghhhh

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thank you again for the ARC!
Profile Image for Anna Berger.
136 reviews1 follower
September 21, 2026
ARC REVIEW:

This was genuinely one of the best books I’ve read in a while. Everything about it was top tier.

Each character, including side characters, were thoughtfully written and had beautiful arcs. I’m also literally obsessed with Lily and Seb.

The plot was incredible, there were so many twists and turns, and despite the numerous riddles that I could never figure out everything was so well explained. It’s also important to note that this author is a master of show don’t tell - like there was hardly any scenes that felt like fluff of unnecessary.

Not to mention the world building in this book -incredible- while magic books can something be complex this was perfect. It was just the right amount of things being thoughtfully detailed but not overwhelmingly so. I loved it when the different spells had annotations to go with them explaining the origins. This was seriously a well crafted and well written world.

Overall, this was such an amazing read and I would 100% recommend reading this book!

⭐️5/5
Profile Image for Dana Vit.
186 reviews3 followers
September 13, 2026
A slow start that ended up being a book I didn’t want to put down.

“People said “dream big”, but there was only pain in the unattainable.”

Ok. This took me by surprise. It started out slow, took me a while to get into, but about 30% in I was captivated and crying by the end. I really liked the MMC and his friends, they were all good people, good friends. I love good friendships. I’m a happy ending girl, so I wasn’t thrilled by the ending, but the more time went by and I thought about it, it was a good ending. I like when magic is portrayed scientifically, elementally. The Elumnara contest was exciting, like a treasure hunt! The sport of Cantréa was fun too! Definitely some unique ideas in this book that were cool to think about. It was also a good example of romance without spice, keeping it PG-13, which I very much enjoyed.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Allie.
20 reviews
September 1, 2026
I loved this!!

The Alchemists by Stacey Strange is like stepping into the world of Hogwarts, if Harry Potter was a New Adult series full of Magicians instead of Wizards. I was lucky enough to get an ARC of this book, and it took my breath away! The characters were unique and relatable, the mystery was compelling and interesting, and the stakes were high. 10/10 best read to start off spooky season!

You’ll love it too if you like:
- scavenger hunts and riddles
- a cursed FMC
- queer representation
- magical games
- magic and alchemy classes
- mundane world vs magic world
- dark academia vibes
- duel pov

Thanks you to Stacey and to BookSirens for giving me this ARC to read!
Profile Image for Hannah.
41 reviews
July 12, 2026
If your book vibe is…

🏫 Dark Academia
🧪 Arcane Magic
🗝️ Secret Histories
💋 Antagonists to Lovers
🏳️‍🌈 LGBTQ+ Rep

Then The Alchemists by Stacey Stange is for you!

This book is apart of my existence for eternity. I will never stop thinking or talking about this book.

I absolutely adore Lily and Sebastian. Their love story is timeless and eternal. I loved how real they felt. Stacey did an absolutely amazing job tackling very real and hard problems that I resonated with at my core. I loved that Sebastian was strong, protective, and loves Lily so fiercely, but also isn’t above facing his demons and showing emotion and weakness.

Lilly grew into a beautiful character by the end. She became strong and resilient. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, found family is one of my favorite tropes and Lily acquired the most amazing found family I’ve ever read about.

The magic system was so intriguing and new to the fantasy space that it kept pulling me back for more. There wasn’t a whole lot of world building in the sense the location was a college campus, but it felt so big and vibrant that I didn’t even care that they were in familiar haunts throughout the whole book.

If I could give this book 6+ stars I would. I’m literally rushing to pre-order it right now so that I can have my own personal copy to grace my bookshelf for eternity. Thank you for a beautifully written book Stacey! I can’t wait to read more of your work!

I received a free copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Ashley.
189 reviews8 followers
September 22, 2026
I LOVED this book! It was everything I wanted from a dark academia novel. Magic, mystery, angst, and romance. I was rooting for Lily and Sebastian the whole time and loved their partners in crime, friends to lovers dynamic. Also, the writing was exquisite! A 500+ page masterpiece! I need more of these characters!

If you love, magical schools, alchemy spells, fencing, dance, riddles, and friendships, then you should definitely read this one!
Profile Image for Evie Oliva.
440 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 21, 2026
Dark academia has been hit or miss for me more often than not but THIS BOOK is BRILLIANT!!

Full review to come.
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
July 24, 2026
The Alchemists was a highlight for me each day, urging me to get quickly to my bedtime read routine. The lyrical imagery in this immersive and original story captivated me from page 1 and now leaves me wondering and hoping I will someday hangout with the characters in this magically real world again.
2 reviews
October 20, 2026
I needed a break from my historical fiction rut and came upon “The Alchemists” by Stacey Strange. This book is a modern day dark academia fantasy, and I thought it would be out of my league. I was so wrong! The characters quickly came to life with the clever fast moving his/her story. Windermere College with all its nooks and crannies appeared magically in my mind. “The Alchemists” is filled with gorgeous similes, descriptive imagery, musical sentences, seemingly impossible to solve problems, and above all a beautiful love story. This is the perfect book to challenge anyone, young and old and everyone in between, who is stuck in a certain genre. Stacey Strange has truly written a book for the ages.
Profile Image for Jessica Campbell.
26 reviews
September 21, 2026

4.5 stars!

Absolutely beautiful yet heartbreaking in the best way. I truly love the world that Stacey Strange has built with The Alchemists.
The beginning is a bit slow, as others have also stated, but I feel that is partially due to the explanation of alchemy and its rules, but once you get going, you truly get going!
I absolutely love Lily and Seb’s story, and truly am sad to be at the end.
Profile Image for Fifi O’Reilly.
71 reviews2 followers
October 8, 2026
ahhh, it’s been way too long since i’ve read a dark academia novel! i had SO MUCH fun with “The Alchemists!” i thought Seb’s and Lily’s story was well executed and just so full of heart, while making room for serious conversations. Lily’s tenacity — the sheer vibrancy of her personality — was so lovely; i deeply admired her courage, but also her own emotional growth journey as a character. Seb’s personality was also a light and so much courage involved in his story as well. Asher and Tori were awesome as well and added so much beauty to the story. i’m not sure if this was the author’s intention for the story, but i felt like it was about finding who you are; standing up for yourself and others; and believing in a world where good and justice can prevail, even if that’s not the popular position. i am so incredibly thankful that i was chosen to read the author’s work. it was truly a delightful read☺️

NOTE: I was an ARC reader and I have provided my honest, voluntary review.
Profile Image for her nose stuck  ina book.
69 reviews2 followers
Read
October 5, 2026
Title: The Alchemists
Author: Stacey Strange
Series: Standalone (I think)
Format: ebook
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |🫑

✨📚 ARC Review 📚 ✨

Wow. Full stop. This story was engrossing, equal parts entertaining and heartbreaking, and had you wishing these characters were in your friend group!

This book ushered me through the gates of Windemere College and had me wanting to be one of lucky few selected for Chant's alchemy course and learning the campus secrets while on a magical scavenger hunt. The dark and mysterious academia setting just felt very appropriate for fall 🍂 and I just could not put this one down until I finished all 500+ pages!

If you love creative magic systems, magical academy settings, and an unforgettable romance - you need to go get The Alchemists!!

Thank you to the author for the gifted copy of this book! My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Audiobooksgirlie.
157 reviews30 followers
September 23, 2026
The Alchemists

Dark academia, secret societies, old money, old magic, and a cursed FMC. Obviously, I was intrigued.

Lily Perkins arrives at Windermere College carrying a curse and ends up paired with Sebastian Allsaires, who comes from exactly the kind of powerful magical family this very elitist school loves. I really enjoyed their dynamic, especially as their partnership starts pulling them deeper into Windermere’s secrets.

The worldbuilding was probably my favorite part. This is actual dark academia. We get the classes, the Alchemy, the Aether, the politics, and all the questionable things happening behind the pretty old institution. I also liked how the story explores privilege and who actually gets access to magic.

This is definitely a book that takes its time building the world. There were moments where the pacing felt slower for me, but there was also so much detail going into Windermere that I genuinely felt like I had enrolled by the end. 😂

Overall, I enjoyed the mystery, the magic system, and Lily and Sebastian enough to keep wanting to know what the hell this school was hiding.

Thank you to Stacey Strange and BookSirens for providing the eARC in exchange for an honest review. 🖤
Profile Image for Liz Fully Booked.
692 reviews52 followers
September 28, 2026
There’s nothing I love more than a good dark academia book, other than a great dark academia book, and this one is that! The Alchemists by Stacey Strange was a fantastic, magical, dark academia book. Despite its chonky size, I’m sad it’s over, I want more!

Lily is a student at Windermere College for the Ætheric Arts, but she is a pariah, and cursed to die at the end of the school year. Sebastian is rich, handsome, popular and graduating this year, and definitely not a fan of “Leper Lily”. Forced to work together on a project, the two begin to unwind the mysteries of Windermere college, all while slowly falling in love. How will they handle Lily’s curse? And will anyone in Seb’s circle approve of his relationship with Lily?

I loved Lily and Seb’s slow burn relationship. I loved the magic system in the book, the worldbuilding, the mystery of Windermere college they’re trying to solve, the bullying they both experience from other students who cannot stand Lily because she is partial non-magical and cursed. This whole story was just magnificent to read, and that ending! No spoilers!

What a great dark academia romance. I totally recommend reading this book. Lots of trigger warnings though, so make sure to read them.
Profile Image for Escapades In Prose.
71 reviews3 followers
September 22, 2026
ARC REVIEW

I often find myself staring at the pages (or in my case, a screen) of a book and think, “someone actually imagined this. Someone built this system, this world, this magic and wrote it into this story I get to witness.” I often find myself in completely awe of what writers release into the world.

This is one of those times. @staceystrangewrites , I cannot imagine the amount of research and thought that went into writing, not only all the alchemical structures of this story, but the footnotes, the appendices and brought everything together.

This book is very Ethereal and Cognitive (I still cannot figure out if this is the best way to say this). You are literally in class with the characters, learning alchemy and utterly convinced you can make this happen in real life.

It’s so well written. The characters have so much depth. I will say, I kept wanting to put this timeline in the past at the beginning of the book. But it’s in modern times. And , I cried like 5 times… 😳

DISCLAIMERS:
1. Very much a LGBTQ story. If it’s not your forte, now you know. If it is, Add it to your TBR, and look out for September 22!

2. One character is R@p3d. It is NOT a heavily written scene (you only see glimpses). Just be aware. You do see the character work through it, which I think was beautifully written.

3. You will learn new words… lots of them

4. You are left with so many questions - it’s only BOOK 1!!

RATING: 5/5 ⭐️’s
Spice : 0.5 🌶️
Character Development: 5/5 ⭐️
Plot: 5/5: ⭐️
Cliffhanger: 2/ 💀
1 review
September 23, 2026
The alchemists combined so many of my favorite things into one story! Magic, dance, alchemy, falling in love…

Is everyone as shocked as I am that this is Stacey’s first book? How could she keep this talent a secret??? I am absolutely obsessed with Stacey’s writing style. I will devour anything she writes for the rest of time. Her prose is genuinely virtuosic. I found myself slowing down, rereading and highlighting her artwork. Every word is deliberately chosen and it is such a gift to the reader.

I expanded my own vocabulary reading this, and I'm already anticipating reading it alongside my daughter someday, both for the bonding and for the linguistic enrichment.

I have recently had an interest in Jungian alchemy and this book reinvigorated it. I learned so much. She beautifully paired literal alchemy with psychological alchemy and left me thoroughly impressed with her intellect and creativity.

I finished the book on an airplane and I found myself, unexpectedly, thoroughly undone. Not just tears dripping down, but a contorted, probably crimson face. It is a good thing it was dark or people would have been very concerned. The Alchemists held space for me to face my own fears and physically release them. I cherish books that can do this. They hold a special place in my heart forever.

I couldn’t be more impressed with her writing style, her creativity and her wit. It is an honor to have this book star on my bookshelf.
Profile Image for K Huskić.
2,450 reviews53 followers
September 30, 2026
Magic, a little romance, and an intriguing plot? I enjoyed this one!
Lily and Seb are two magicians attending Windermere College. They're partnered together in one of their classes and have to work together to complete a quest - not really comprehending the lengths people will go to in order to win.
Lily is cursed and grew up knowing she'd die at a specific time. What she didn't expect was falling for someone right before her time would be up. Now, I just adored Lily and Seb together! I was so rooting for them to be together and to somehow cure her. But that ending? I need more! It can't end there.
109 reviews3 followers
September 30, 2026
Lily and Sebastian are put together as partners in a school project when they start working together on discovering secrets of Windermere College. Lily is clever and Sebastian is conscientious. I loved how they supported each other and their friends. The magic was so interesting and I really enjoyed reading this book. I recommend this book for readers who enjoy dark academia fantasy with magic, secrets, and scavenger hunts. Voluntary ARC review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews