What do you think?
Rate this book
The Perils of Proximity: An Anthology of Pride and Prejudice Variations
382 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 27, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
There are a seemingly limitless number of ways to throw Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy together such that neither can escape the presence of the other. That's the theme eight talented JAFF authors explore in these clever not-quite-novella-length stories. All begin after Elizabeth stayed at Netherfield for several days to nurse her sister, and most occur after the (in)famous proposal, refusal, and letter.
The methods employed to force proximity between the two run the gamut from serious to silly.
An injured Mr. Darcy is discovered by Elizabeth and the Gardiners during a multi-day downpour of rain, leading to an extended stay at a less-than-comfortable Derbyshire inn. In another, Mr. Darcy's godfather is good friends with Mr. Bennet, who brings Elizabeth along for a week-long visit, the timing of which happens to coincide with Mr. Darcy and his sister having arrived there for a stay. The most humorous tale, this one in Hunsford, has Elizabeth so discomfited immediately after reading Mr. Darcy's letter that she ducks into a dilapidated garden shed to avoid him at the parsonage. Unfortunately for her, he spots her and excuses himself to follow her to her hiding place, but then the oblivious Mr. Collins strolls by and locks the door. Their subsequent conversation suffers frequent interruptions as they bump into the various garden implements surrounding them.
My favorite stories in this collection show particularly stellar creativity. Mary Smythe's "Not in Vain" follows Lydia Bennet's point of view, starting in London as Mr. Darcy bursts in upon her and her dear Wickham (who escapes out the window). Upon reuniting with her family, she truly does not understand why they're making such a fuss. And she sees that Elizabeth and Darcy clearly have a thing for one another, so why does neither of them DO anything about it? Once she's safely married, Lydia decides she'll fix things herself.
"A Just and Tender Spirit" by Julie Cooper is the creme de la creme that concludes this short story octet with an inspired switcheroo. Mr. Darcy - yes, the same haughty, superior man from canon - has the living at Hunsford and is the cousin who will inherit Longbourn thanks to the entail. Mr. Collins - the usual foolish dolt - is the rich friend staying with Mr. Bingley. How do you think THAT goes?!?
Content is clean.
I received a free copy and am voluntarily leaving a review
The methods employed to force proximity between the two run the gamut from serious to silly.
An injured Mr. Darcy is discovered by Elizabeth and the Gardiners during a multi-day downpour of rain, leading to an extended stay at a less-than-comfortable Derbyshire inn. In another, Mr. Darcy's godfather is good friends with Mr. Bennet, who brings Elizabeth along for a week-long visit, the timing of which happens to coincide with Mr. Darcy and his sister having arrived there for a stay. The most humorous tale, this one in Hunsford, has Elizabeth so discomfited immediately after reading Mr. Darcy's letter that she ducks into a dilapidated garden shed to avoid him at the parsonage. Unfortunately for her, he spots her and excuses himself to follow her to her hiding place, but then the oblivious Mr. Collins strolls by and locks the door. Their subsequent conversation suffers frequent interruptions as they bump into the various garden implements surrounding them.
My favorite stories in this collection show particularly stellar creativity. Mary Smythe's "Not in Vain" follows Lydia Bennet's point of view, starting in London as Mr. Darcy bursts in upon her and her dear Wickham (who escapes out the window). Upon reuniting with her family, she truly does not understand why they're making such a fuss. And she sees that Elizabeth and Darcy clearly have a thing for one another, so why does neither of them DO anything about it? Once she's safely married, Lydia decides she'll fix things herself.
"A Just and Tender Spirit" by Julie Cooper is the creme de la creme that concludes this short story octet with an inspired switcheroo. Mr. Darcy - yes, the same haughty, superior man from canon - has the living at Hunsford and is the cousin who will inherit Longbourn thanks to the entail. Mr. Collins - the usual foolish dolt - is the rich friend staying with Mr. Bingley. How do you think THAT goes?!?
Content is clean.
I received a free copy and am voluntarily leaving a review
July 30, 2026
Usually with an anthology there are strong stories and other stories. This anthology has all bangers and no duds. It's very good.
July 27, 2026
An excellent anthology of stories by some of the best authors in the genre
This was a universally charming book from start to finish. Each author clearly understood their brief and wrote stories which were well constructed with fully rounded characters and no extraneous detail. In these collections it is always difficult to pick a favourite but perhaps if pushed I would plump for Jan Ashton's offering, A Tax on HIs Forbearance, as I very much appreciated the rare writing of a sympathetic Aunt Phillips.
Definitely one to recommend.
This was a universally charming book from start to finish. Each author clearly understood their brief and wrote stories which were well constructed with fully rounded characters and no extraneous detail. In these collections it is always difficult to pick a favourite but perhaps if pushed I would plump for Jan Ashton's offering, A Tax on HIs Forbearance, as I very much appreciated the rare writing of a sympathetic Aunt Phillips.
Definitely one to recommend.
August 1, 2026
Tell me a fact, and I’ll learn. Tell me a truth, and I’ll believe. But tell me a story, and it will live in my heart forever. — Ed Sabol
A bevy of favorite storytellers.
A plethora of well-told stories.
A profusion of happy endings
I loved this book!
The greatest art in the world is the art of storytelling. — Cecil B. DeMille
A bevy of favorite storytellers.
A plethora of well-told stories.
A profusion of happy endings
I loved this book!
The greatest art in the world is the art of storytelling. — Cecil B. DeMille
August 6, 2026
The perils of proximity is a collection of short stories by eight well-known JAFF authors.
TEMPEST by Frances Reynolds
After Elizabeth rejects his proposal of marriage Darcy is about to leave the parsonage when the storm makes his escape impossible. Will they, while they are stuck together, be able to clear their misunderstandings and reach a more satisfying conclusion?
I really like that, due to the weather, Darcy and Elizabeth can’t escape and need to talk about the proposal and clear their misunderstandings. This gives them the basics for a better understanding of one another and a new beginning.
A TAX ON HIS FORBEARANCE by Jan Ashton
Shortly before the Netherfield Ball Darcy returns to Netherfield after seeing to business in town. He is denied entry because an illness has afflicted Netherfield and the neighbouring estates. As the inn is already occupied Darcy is invited to stay with the Philips and discovers that Elizabeth has also found refuge there. Will Darcy’s feelings for Elizabeth become the better of him and let him declare himself?
Oh I liked the aunt and uncle Philips in this story. They were such nice people. And I was so glad that Darcy did see it too, even if it took him a little to acknowledge that they are loving and caring relatives of Elizabeth. And I loved Darcy and Elizabeth’s opportunity to talk to one another and discover that the other may be the person you never want to part with.
CERTAIN EVILS by Amy D’Orazio
After reading parts of Darcy’s letter of explanation Elizabeth is furious. How dare he insult her sister. In a fit of anger she tosses the letter in a well with wishes that certain evils may be brought down on him. A short time later Elizabeth discovers that her wishes may have come true, the gentleman needs to stay in the parsonage because he unexpectedly broke his leg and is not to be moved. In the course of the next days more calamities befall Darcy like Elizabeth had cursed him with her wishes. She, on her part, discovers that she may have misjudged him and soon wishes for all the misfortunes to stop. Will she be able to bring back joy in his life?
Poor Darcy, he suffers many misfortunes in this story. I like that Elizabeth, although she initially wanted him to suffer, soon discovers that she does not want him to experience all these dreadful things. I like that she spends time with him and gets to know him better and that she also sees how he handles crises. I was so glad that she actively searches for a way to end his suffering and that she is, in the end, successful.
BUILDING BRIDGES by Ali Scott
Elizabeth and her uncle and aunt Gardiner are visiting Derbyshire when flooding causes them to interrupt their journey at an Inn. Shortly before they have found an injured horseman on the road and have taken him with them - the wounded rider is none other than Mr Darcy. Forced to stay in the village due to the weather Darcy and Elizabeth spent much time together and Elizabeth sees how altered he is since their last encounter in Kent. Will Darcy be able to show her that he has taken her reprimands to heart and that he still loves her?
I really loved that Elizabeth needed to care for Darcy and that they, due to his recovery and the bad weather, are able to spend time with one another. This gives Elizabeth the opportunity to see his changed behaviour and him to show it to her. Elizabeth can also see a different side of Darcy when he is able to secure better accommodations with people he knows. I like the side Elizabeth gets to see very much.
NOT IN VAIN by Mary Smythe
When Elizabeth receives Jane's letter in Lambton she is sure that she will never see Darcy again. Subdued, she returns to London with her aunt and uncle to be of help when Lydia is retrieved. Therefore she is again in Darcy’s company but both seem to be unable to overcome the changes caused by Lydia’s thoughtless actions. A fit of anger and the accusation that her actions have cost Elizabeth her happiness let Lydia finally see that her sister is in love with Darcy. As the two seem unable to make amends Lydia and her new husband, Mr Stone, take matters in hand. Will they be able to reconcile the two lovers?
This story was a bit sad because both Elizabeth and Darcy have no hope of ever being together. I like that Lydia takes it in hand to reunite them - after all it was she who was responsible for their separation. I loved Lydia for her idea but I can totally comprehend that Elizabeth despaired first. Until she comprehended that her actions were responsible for Elizabeth’s misery she was so selfish.
CLUTTER AND CONCEALMENT by Nan Harrison
After she receives his letter Elizabeth returns to the parsonage - only to see that Darcy is waiting for her in the parlor. Elizabeth is not ready to face him again and therefore decides to hide in Mr Collin’s garden shed until he is gone. Unfortunately Darcy sees her hiding and decides to look after her. Will they, without the company of the others, be able to overcome the accusations of the previous afternoon and read a better understanding of one another?
Darcy and Elizabeth in earnest conversation among Mr Collins’ garden tools without the opportunity to move because moving could become dangerous due to the instability of the building - I really like the idea. Darcy and Elizabeth have certainly no way to escape and no other occupation than to talk.
SEVEN DAYS IN NOTHAMPTENSHIRE by Lucy Marin
Immediately after she rejected Darcy in Kent Elizabeth and her father travel to his old friend in Northamptonshire because the two men want to talk about Earl's newly acquired book. But instead of sitting with the men Elizabeth discovers that she is not the only uninterested guest, the Earl’s godson and his sister are also there, Mr and Miss Darcy of Pemberley. Elizabeth first thinks that this may be the longest seven days of her life but soon she begins to discover that she may have judged Darcy wrong all the time and she begins to enjoy spending time with him. Will they be able to come to love each other despite Elizabeth’s harsh rejection only some days prior?
I really love that Darcy and Elizabeth are forced together so shortly after Darcy’s proposal and that they need to behave civilly because they are in company. I like that Elizabeth can see Darcy interact with his sister and his godfather and that she also got their accounts of his kindness and loyalty and that she his therefore able to form a different picture of him
A JUST AND SOUND SPIRIT by Julie Cooper
Vicar Darcy and his cousin, Mr Bennet, are not on good terms because Darcy will inherit Mr Bennet's estate after the latter's death. Now Vicar Darcy has written to his cousin and intends to visit him with the extended aim of probably finding a wife among his daughters. When Elizabeth sees Jane's fear of being forced to consider him despite being in love with another man, she decides to try to redirect his attention to her. When Darcy arrives her interest is immediately peaked and Darcy is equally captivated. Will the two be able to form a union or will the entail and the past stand in their way?
I had not formerly imagined Darcy as a vicar but after this story I am able to do it. And it worked well. I really liked the relationship they formed and that they were able to talk about everything. It was a really unique story.
If you like to read eight different short stories with Darcy and Elizabeth in situations where they are forced to solve their differences without running away, you should definitely read this excellent collection.
I highly recommend it.
TEMPEST by Frances Reynolds
After Elizabeth rejects his proposal of marriage Darcy is about to leave the parsonage when the storm makes his escape impossible. Will they, while they are stuck together, be able to clear their misunderstandings and reach a more satisfying conclusion?
I really like that, due to the weather, Darcy and Elizabeth can’t escape and need to talk about the proposal and clear their misunderstandings. This gives them the basics for a better understanding of one another and a new beginning.
A TAX ON HIS FORBEARANCE by Jan Ashton
Shortly before the Netherfield Ball Darcy returns to Netherfield after seeing to business in town. He is denied entry because an illness has afflicted Netherfield and the neighbouring estates. As the inn is already occupied Darcy is invited to stay with the Philips and discovers that Elizabeth has also found refuge there. Will Darcy’s feelings for Elizabeth become the better of him and let him declare himself?
Oh I liked the aunt and uncle Philips in this story. They were such nice people. And I was so glad that Darcy did see it too, even if it took him a little to acknowledge that they are loving and caring relatives of Elizabeth. And I loved Darcy and Elizabeth’s opportunity to talk to one another and discover that the other may be the person you never want to part with.
CERTAIN EVILS by Amy D’Orazio
After reading parts of Darcy’s letter of explanation Elizabeth is furious. How dare he insult her sister. In a fit of anger she tosses the letter in a well with wishes that certain evils may be brought down on him. A short time later Elizabeth discovers that her wishes may have come true, the gentleman needs to stay in the parsonage because he unexpectedly broke his leg and is not to be moved. In the course of the next days more calamities befall Darcy like Elizabeth had cursed him with her wishes. She, on her part, discovers that she may have misjudged him and soon wishes for all the misfortunes to stop. Will she be able to bring back joy in his life?
Poor Darcy, he suffers many misfortunes in this story. I like that Elizabeth, although she initially wanted him to suffer, soon discovers that she does not want him to experience all these dreadful things. I like that she spends time with him and gets to know him better and that she also sees how he handles crises. I was so glad that she actively searches for a way to end his suffering and that she is, in the end, successful.
BUILDING BRIDGES by Ali Scott
Elizabeth and her uncle and aunt Gardiner are visiting Derbyshire when flooding causes them to interrupt their journey at an Inn. Shortly before they have found an injured horseman on the road and have taken him with them - the wounded rider is none other than Mr Darcy. Forced to stay in the village due to the weather Darcy and Elizabeth spent much time together and Elizabeth sees how altered he is since their last encounter in Kent. Will Darcy be able to show her that he has taken her reprimands to heart and that he still loves her?
I really loved that Elizabeth needed to care for Darcy and that they, due to his recovery and the bad weather, are able to spend time with one another. This gives Elizabeth the opportunity to see his changed behaviour and him to show it to her. Elizabeth can also see a different side of Darcy when he is able to secure better accommodations with people he knows. I like the side Elizabeth gets to see very much.
NOT IN VAIN by Mary Smythe
When Elizabeth receives Jane's letter in Lambton she is sure that she will never see Darcy again. Subdued, she returns to London with her aunt and uncle to be of help when Lydia is retrieved. Therefore she is again in Darcy’s company but both seem to be unable to overcome the changes caused by Lydia’s thoughtless actions. A fit of anger and the accusation that her actions have cost Elizabeth her happiness let Lydia finally see that her sister is in love with Darcy. As the two seem unable to make amends Lydia and her new husband, Mr Stone, take matters in hand. Will they be able to reconcile the two lovers?
This story was a bit sad because both Elizabeth and Darcy have no hope of ever being together. I like that Lydia takes it in hand to reunite them - after all it was she who was responsible for their separation. I loved Lydia for her idea but I can totally comprehend that Elizabeth despaired first. Until she comprehended that her actions were responsible for Elizabeth’s misery she was so selfish.
CLUTTER AND CONCEALMENT by Nan Harrison
After she receives his letter Elizabeth returns to the parsonage - only to see that Darcy is waiting for her in the parlor. Elizabeth is not ready to face him again and therefore decides to hide in Mr Collin’s garden shed until he is gone. Unfortunately Darcy sees her hiding and decides to look after her. Will they, without the company of the others, be able to overcome the accusations of the previous afternoon and read a better understanding of one another?
Darcy and Elizabeth in earnest conversation among Mr Collins’ garden tools without the opportunity to move because moving could become dangerous due to the instability of the building - I really like the idea. Darcy and Elizabeth have certainly no way to escape and no other occupation than to talk.
SEVEN DAYS IN NOTHAMPTENSHIRE by Lucy Marin
Immediately after she rejected Darcy in Kent Elizabeth and her father travel to his old friend in Northamptonshire because the two men want to talk about Earl's newly acquired book. But instead of sitting with the men Elizabeth discovers that she is not the only uninterested guest, the Earl’s godson and his sister are also there, Mr and Miss Darcy of Pemberley. Elizabeth first thinks that this may be the longest seven days of her life but soon she begins to discover that she may have judged Darcy wrong all the time and she begins to enjoy spending time with him. Will they be able to come to love each other despite Elizabeth’s harsh rejection only some days prior?
I really love that Darcy and Elizabeth are forced together so shortly after Darcy’s proposal and that they need to behave civilly because they are in company. I like that Elizabeth can see Darcy interact with his sister and his godfather and that she also got their accounts of his kindness and loyalty and that she his therefore able to form a different picture of him
A JUST AND SOUND SPIRIT by Julie Cooper
Vicar Darcy and his cousin, Mr Bennet, are not on good terms because Darcy will inherit Mr Bennet's estate after the latter's death. Now Vicar Darcy has written to his cousin and intends to visit him with the extended aim of probably finding a wife among his daughters. When Elizabeth sees Jane's fear of being forced to consider him despite being in love with another man, she decides to try to redirect his attention to her. When Darcy arrives her interest is immediately peaked and Darcy is equally captivated. Will the two be able to form a union or will the entail and the past stand in their way?
I had not formerly imagined Darcy as a vicar but after this story I am able to do it. And it worked well. I really liked the relationship they formed and that they were able to talk about everything. It was a really unique story.
If you like to read eight different short stories with Darcy and Elizabeth in situations where they are forced to solve their differences without running away, you should definitely read this excellent collection.
I highly recommend it.
August 7, 2026
The 1 star is for the 1st story ... the last one though... i returned 2 times to the 1st paragraph to see if i read it correctly... yeap ... Darcy was Mr Collins ... nope just absolutely no!!! What in the parallel universe type of Pride and Prejudice was that?! I swear some of these authors just should give up...
August 2, 2026
Eight different opportunities for conversation through forced proximity, or otherwise. Some of the best authors of JAFF set their creative minds to these short stories or novelettes, which lead to a quicker HEA for Darcy and Elizabeth. There seems to be no shortage of ways to reach the same outcome. My favorite was The Tempest, by Frances Reynolds.
The guy on the cover looks more like Bingley. Overall, 4.2 stars
The guy on the cover looks more like Bingley. Overall, 4.2 stars
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
What a cute collection of forced proximity stories where Elizabeth and Darcy are the stars! Because of their bite-sized nature, ODC remain front-and-center. There is something special to love in each mini variation by a talented collection of authors.
Tempest by Francis Reynolds
"Never before had silence been so intolerable. Their earlier words seemed to hang in the air like smoke, dark and choking."
A second chance for ODC when a thunderstorm forces them together after the dreaded Hunsford proposal. The opportunity for communication was perfectly done and I loved seeing how a fresh perspective could bring E&D into a better understanding quickly.
A Tax on His Forebearance by Jan Ashton
“You, Elizabeth Bennet, are lovely, intelligent, and spirited beyond any woman I have ever known—and you have, quite against my will, compelled my affections.”
A bout of sickness forces E&D out of their respective houses and into the hospitality of the Phillips. Darcy is forced to see things through new eyes and a sweet moment of impropriety brings feelings forward. I enjoyed the quiet conversation and tender thoughts shared by ODC in this variation.
Certain Evils by Amy D'Orazio
"She had brought him the deepest misery, and it was an undeniable satisfaction to have brought him, instead, to such joy."
Elizabeth's impulsive action may have brought calamity on Mr Darcy and she must work hard to bring about resolution while reflecting on the way she never understood him. This variation is unique with a touch of the supernatural (or coincidence- you decide) and this time I enjoyed Elizabeth's greater reflection and reversal of feelings.
Building Bridges by Ali Scott
"It was as though she were on a bridge between her former life and her future; ahead lay the possibility of great happiness, if only she were brave enough to take the first step."
Elizabeth and the Gardiners encounter Darcy after an accident on their trip to Derbyshire. Possibly the swooniest of the variations as Elizabeth helps to nurse Mr Darcy back to health and he lets her see parts of his life that reveal his true character. The waterfall scene... perfection.
Not in Vain by Mary Smythe
“...I will accept your admission that my way of getting husbands is not so bad after all.”
Told primarily from Lydia's perspective after a foiled elopement with Wickham, she finds out the cost of her perfidy and that she wasn't the only one to lose a beau. Lydia's way of making amends was quite funny as she watched ODC pine for one another. I enjoyed this little twist on the fallout.
Clutter and Concealment by Nan Harrison
"I want a true partner in life, to plan and dream together; to succeed or fail together…”
Mr Darcy takes a chance before exiting Hunsford to find out how Elizabeth took the contents of his letter. This was the funniest variation and had me laughing out loud several times. I really loved seeing Darcy rise above his hurt to reveal his true character. The circumstances of this forced confinement were an absolute romp and delight.
Seven Days in Northhamptonshire by Lucy Marin
"...what exactly was her connexion to him? And why did it feel like it had completely altered after their recent conversation?"
Another coincidental meeting brings ODC together after the dreaded Hunsford Proposal. When circumstances leave them largely to their own devices, true courting begins and they are able to see one another with fresh eyes. I loved the parallel do-overs from Kent to Northhamptonshire and their equal desire to set things right.
A Just and Tender Spirit by Julie Cooper
"...Elizabeth could never have guessed just how passionate and exciting a man of the cloth could be."
Truly unique! Darcy and Collins have a role reversal and when Darcy writes to his cousin to let him know to expect him at Longbourn to consider one of his daughters for a bride, he was unprepared for the jewel that is the second Bennet daughter. This was a fun and lovely way for ODC to come together without wealth and arrogance interfering, and their courtship was absolutely adorable.
Thank you to Quills and Quartos for my copy of this anthology. All thoughts contained here are my own honest opinions.
Tempest by Francis Reynolds
"Never before had silence been so intolerable. Their earlier words seemed to hang in the air like smoke, dark and choking."
A second chance for ODC when a thunderstorm forces them together after the dreaded Hunsford proposal. The opportunity for communication was perfectly done and I loved seeing how a fresh perspective could bring E&D into a better understanding quickly.
A Tax on His Forebearance by Jan Ashton
“You, Elizabeth Bennet, are lovely, intelligent, and spirited beyond any woman I have ever known—and you have, quite against my will, compelled my affections.”
A bout of sickness forces E&D out of their respective houses and into the hospitality of the Phillips. Darcy is forced to see things through new eyes and a sweet moment of impropriety brings feelings forward. I enjoyed the quiet conversation and tender thoughts shared by ODC in this variation.
Certain Evils by Amy D'Orazio
"She had brought him the deepest misery, and it was an undeniable satisfaction to have brought him, instead, to such joy."
Elizabeth's impulsive action may have brought calamity on Mr Darcy and she must work hard to bring about resolution while reflecting on the way she never understood him. This variation is unique with a touch of the supernatural (or coincidence- you decide) and this time I enjoyed Elizabeth's greater reflection and reversal of feelings.
Building Bridges by Ali Scott
"It was as though she were on a bridge between her former life and her future; ahead lay the possibility of great happiness, if only she were brave enough to take the first step."
Elizabeth and the Gardiners encounter Darcy after an accident on their trip to Derbyshire. Possibly the swooniest of the variations as Elizabeth helps to nurse Mr Darcy back to health and he lets her see parts of his life that reveal his true character. The waterfall scene... perfection.
Not in Vain by Mary Smythe
“...I will accept your admission that my way of getting husbands is not so bad after all.”
Told primarily from Lydia's perspective after a foiled elopement with Wickham, she finds out the cost of her perfidy and that she wasn't the only one to lose a beau. Lydia's way of making amends was quite funny as she watched ODC pine for one another. I enjoyed this little twist on the fallout.
Clutter and Concealment by Nan Harrison
"I want a true partner in life, to plan and dream together; to succeed or fail together…”
Mr Darcy takes a chance before exiting Hunsford to find out how Elizabeth took the contents of his letter. This was the funniest variation and had me laughing out loud several times. I really loved seeing Darcy rise above his hurt to reveal his true character. The circumstances of this forced confinement were an absolute romp and delight.
Seven Days in Northhamptonshire by Lucy Marin
"...what exactly was her connexion to him? And why did it feel like it had completely altered after their recent conversation?"
Another coincidental meeting brings ODC together after the dreaded Hunsford Proposal. When circumstances leave them largely to their own devices, true courting begins and they are able to see one another with fresh eyes. I loved the parallel do-overs from Kent to Northhamptonshire and their equal desire to set things right.
A Just and Tender Spirit by Julie Cooper
"...Elizabeth could never have guessed just how passionate and exciting a man of the cloth could be."
Truly unique! Darcy and Collins have a role reversal and when Darcy writes to his cousin to let him know to expect him at Longbourn to consider one of his daughters for a bride, he was unprepared for the jewel that is the second Bennet daughter. This was a fun and lovely way for ODC to come together without wealth and arrogance interfering, and their courtship was absolutely adorable.
Thank you to Quills and Quartos for my copy of this anthology. All thoughts contained here are my own honest opinions.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
My Rating: 4.5* rounded up to 5*
Another wonderful collection of short stories that hit the mark! There were a few that really sparked joy for me!
Tempest by Frances Reynolds:
“She would think of Jane later, weep for her sister’s lost happiness at some other hour. First, she must endure this trial of being trapped with the cause of it for as long as the rain lasted.” (quote from the book)
A refusal, a thunderstorm and quiet civility with tea.
A Tax on his Forbearance by Jan Ashton:
“Well, if this is the result of a little inconvenience, I hope we may be put out of our way again very soon.” (quote from the book)
Mushrooms, illness and unexpected accommodations that prove enlightening.
Certain Evils by Amy D’Orazio:
“May certain evils be brought down on your head, Mr Darcy!” (quote from the book)
A letter, a well and a crone…or was it all just coincidence?
Building Bridges by Ali Scott:
“Who was this charming man, with easy manners, that slipped into friendly conversation with her beloved relations.” (quote from the book)
A Derbyshire tour beset by rain, rain and more rain.
Not in Vain by Mary Smythe:
“Never had she so honestly felt that she could have loved him as now, when all hope must be in vain.” (quote from the book)
A twist of fate for Lydia who helps things along for Elizabeth and Darcy.
Clutter and Concealment by Nan Harrison:
“She had flattered herself that her superior discernment kept her from error. It was humbling to realise that she had her own improper pride and vanity that caused her to make mistakes in judgement. Terrible mistakes.” (quote from the book)
A garden shed, conversation and Mr. Collins.
Seven Days in Northhamptonshire:
“Standing here so close to her, after their difficult but necessary exchange, he realised he was not yet finished falling in love with her.” (quote from the book)
Surprise, awkwardness and much reflection.
A Just and Tender Spirit by Julie Cooper:
Devil take Lady Catherine for her far-reaching tentacles of gossip, for thoughtlessly tossing this problem at my feet…” (quote from the book)
The shoe is on the other foot! A complete and utterly delightful surprise in this one!
I received an ARC and am voluntarily leaving my review.
Another wonderful collection of short stories that hit the mark! There were a few that really sparked joy for me!
Tempest by Frances Reynolds:
“She would think of Jane later, weep for her sister’s lost happiness at some other hour. First, she must endure this trial of being trapped with the cause of it for as long as the rain lasted.” (quote from the book)
A refusal, a thunderstorm and quiet civility with tea.
A Tax on his Forbearance by Jan Ashton:
“Well, if this is the result of a little inconvenience, I hope we may be put out of our way again very soon.” (quote from the book)
Mushrooms, illness and unexpected accommodations that prove enlightening.
Certain Evils by Amy D’Orazio:
“May certain evils be brought down on your head, Mr Darcy!” (quote from the book)
A letter, a well and a crone…or was it all just coincidence?
Building Bridges by Ali Scott:
“Who was this charming man, with easy manners, that slipped into friendly conversation with her beloved relations.” (quote from the book)
A Derbyshire tour beset by rain, rain and more rain.
Not in Vain by Mary Smythe:
“Never had she so honestly felt that she could have loved him as now, when all hope must be in vain.” (quote from the book)
A twist of fate for Lydia who helps things along for Elizabeth and Darcy.
Clutter and Concealment by Nan Harrison:
“She had flattered herself that her superior discernment kept her from error. It was humbling to realise that she had her own improper pride and vanity that caused her to make mistakes in judgement. Terrible mistakes.” (quote from the book)
A garden shed, conversation and Mr. Collins.
Seven Days in Northhamptonshire:
“Standing here so close to her, after their difficult but necessary exchange, he realised he was not yet finished falling in love with her.” (quote from the book)
Surprise, awkwardness and much reflection.
A Just and Tender Spirit by Julie Cooper:
Devil take Lady Catherine for her far-reaching tentacles of gossip, for thoughtlessly tossing this problem at my feet…” (quote from the book)
The shoe is on the other foot! A complete and utterly delightful surprise in this one!
I received an ARC and am voluntarily leaving my review.
July 27, 2026
This is a collection of stories in which Darcy and Elizabeth are forced to spend some time together and end up understanding each other better. A few take place before or after Hunsford and Julie Cooper's story has changed the setting a bit more, making Darcy the estranged cousin to whom Longbourn is entailed.
Normally at this point of an anthology review, I would tell you which one was my favourite, but I am sorry, I can't help you there, I loved them all.
Steam level: Kissing.
Normally at this point of an anthology review, I would tell you which one was my favourite, but I am sorry, I can't help you there, I loved them all.
Steam level: Kissing.
August 1, 2026
Tempest, Frances Reynolds - 3 stars
A Tax on His Forbearance, Jan Ashton - 4 stars. I enjoyed the Phillipses.
Certain Evils, Amy D’Orazio - 3 stars.
Building Bridges, Ali Scott - 3.5 stars. I enjoyed Mrs Langford.
Not in Vain, Mary Smythe - 4 stars. Lydia’s role was fun.
Clutter and Concealment, Nan Harrison - 1 star.
Seven Days in Northamptonshire, Lucy Marin - 5 stars.
A Just and Tender Spirit, Julie Cooper - 4 stars. I enjoyed the Darcy/Collins swap.
A Tax on His Forbearance, Jan Ashton - 4 stars. I enjoyed the Phillipses.
Certain Evils, Amy D’Orazio - 3 stars.
Building Bridges, Ali Scott - 3.5 stars. I enjoyed Mrs Langford.
Not in Vain, Mary Smythe - 4 stars. Lydia’s role was fun.
Clutter and Concealment, Nan Harrison - 1 star.
Seven Days in Northamptonshire, Lucy Marin - 5 stars.
A Just and Tender Spirit, Julie Cooper - 4 stars. I enjoyed the Darcy/Collins swap.
August 2, 2026
Breathe of Fresh Air
4.5 stars rounded up for me. I would prefer if they stories were just a smidge longer, but it was a breath of fresh air to see AI free writing - complex sentences and error free, well- written stories! Like all anthologies, some stories are better liked than others. For me, Mary Smythe always writes the best short stories. I believe hers was my favorite in this collection, which was the same for the Tis the Season anthology.
4.5 stars rounded up for me. I would prefer if they stories were just a smidge longer, but it was a breath of fresh air to see AI free writing - complex sentences and error free, well- written stories! Like all anthologies, some stories are better liked than others. For me, Mary Smythe always writes the best short stories. I believe hers was my favorite in this collection, which was the same for the Tis the Season anthology.
August 2, 2026
Time Together Well Spent
Indeed… forced proximity is the common thread to all of theses wonderful short stories. Be it illness, injury, the “Lydia effect”, locked doors or even a reimagining of character roles- time together actually talking and understanding each other was key. I loved seeing Darcy and Elizabeth connect under each of the different circumstances to find their HEA.
Indeed… forced proximity is the common thread to all of theses wonderful short stories. Be it illness, injury, the “Lydia effect”, locked doors or even a reimagining of character roles- time together actually talking and understanding each other was key. I loved seeing Darcy and Elizabeth connect under each of the different circumstances to find their HEA.
August 9, 2026
Love the Quick Doses of ODC!
Honestly, I love the novella variation compilations with the added delight that they are from my favorite authors! Sometimes you need a quick fix and no time to devote to a full length novel. Keep collaborating and bringing these well written, unique and enjoyable stories!
Honestly, I love the novella variation compilations with the added delight that they are from my favorite authors! Sometimes you need a quick fix and no time to devote to a full length novel. Keep collaborating and bringing these well written, unique and enjoyable stories!
July 29, 2026
Creative what-if story stories
Fantastic reimaginings of circumstances surrounding the events in P&P that force Darcy and Elizabeth together. For all of us who just wishes that they had not been afraid to talk to each other earlier - Here are some scenarios in which they must!
Fantastic reimaginings of circumstances surrounding the events in P&P that force Darcy and Elizabeth together. For all of us who just wishes that they had not been afraid to talk to each other earlier - Here are some scenarios in which they must!
August 1, 2026
Gift to all JAFF fans
What a great compendium of short stories! Thank you to all of the fabulous authors. All are favorites and for good reasons. I highly recommend this book. Well done!
What a great compendium of short stories! Thank you to all of the fabulous authors. All are favorites and for good reasons. I highly recommend this book. Well done!
July 28, 2026
This is a delightful and different variation that contains multiple novelettes.
They are all enjoyable and perfect for a quick uplifting evening.
They are all enjoyable and perfect for a quick uplifting evening.
August 6, 2026
Really enjoyed this one. It’s like the best part of every book
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
A Charming Assortment
I love seeing a new upcoming anthology offered by the talented authors from Quills & Quartos Publishing. They never disappoint, and I always look forward to them. They’re perfect for when I’m pinched for time, but still need a little fix from the characters I love, knowing one of these stories will do just the trick. Or… reading them all in one sitting is just as fine. This collection especially delights me because when Darcy and Elizabeth cannot escape each other…they talk. It’s what I love about the forced-proximity trope, the main theme for this collection.
Tempest by Frances Reynolds
A dual Darcy-Elizabeth POV of what happens after Darcy is forced to remain at the parsonage due to a severe storm following Elizabeth’s refusal of his proposal.
A Tax on His Forbearance by Jan Ashton
Darcy is given hospitality by the Philipses when Netherfield and Longbourn are quarantined due to an outbreak of dyspepsia in the neighbourhood. To his surprise, he discovers Elizabeth is there too.
Certain Evils by Amy D’Orazio
A touch of fantasy in this tale. Thinking Darcy’s letter describes Jane as ‘a certain evil’, Elizabeth tosses it into a nearby well and exclaims, “May certain evils be brought down on your head, Mr Darcy!” The resulting calamities that befall him have her feeling remorseful and fearful she has truly cursed him.
Building Bridges by Ali Scott
Darcy is thrown from his horse directly in front of the carriage Elizabeth and the Gardiners are travelling in on their way to Lambton. With bad roads and a bridge out, they are forced to take an injured Darcy to the only available inn nearby as he recovers.
Not in Vain by Mary Smythe
This is the only offering that departs from the collection’s forced-proximity theme for Elizabeth and Darcy. Instead, it explores the consequences of Lydia’s forced proximity to Wickham, with results that are not quite what one might expect.
Clutter and Concealment by Nan Harrison
When Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam call at the parsonage to take their leave the morning Elizabeth receives Darcy’s letter, and embarrassed to have to see or speak to Darcy again, she takes refuge in Mr Collins’ garden shed. What could go wrong—or maybe right?
Seven Days in Northamptonshire by Lucy Marin
Not long after Hunsford, Elizabeth and Darcy are shocked to find themselves in company once more at the estate of Darcy’s godfather who, unknown to our dear couple, is an acquaintance of Mr Bennet. Hating travel, Bennet met Elizabeth at the Gardiners’ to have her accompany him to visit his friend. This results in perhaps the most romantic re-declarations of love in this collection.
A Just and Tender Spirit by Julie Cooper
Ha! This one commands that you suspend belief. I’m still grinning after finishing it. Quite a diverting premise! No spoilers here. Don’t skip it.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher and am voluntarily offering my review. I have this book preordered.
I love seeing a new upcoming anthology offered by the talented authors from Quills & Quartos Publishing. They never disappoint, and I always look forward to them. They’re perfect for when I’m pinched for time, but still need a little fix from the characters I love, knowing one of these stories will do just the trick. Or… reading them all in one sitting is just as fine. This collection especially delights me because when Darcy and Elizabeth cannot escape each other…they talk. It’s what I love about the forced-proximity trope, the main theme for this collection.
Tempest by Frances Reynolds
A dual Darcy-Elizabeth POV of what happens after Darcy is forced to remain at the parsonage due to a severe storm following Elizabeth’s refusal of his proposal.
A Tax on His Forbearance by Jan Ashton
Darcy is given hospitality by the Philipses when Netherfield and Longbourn are quarantined due to an outbreak of dyspepsia in the neighbourhood. To his surprise, he discovers Elizabeth is there too.
Certain Evils by Amy D’Orazio
A touch of fantasy in this tale. Thinking Darcy’s letter describes Jane as ‘a certain evil’, Elizabeth tosses it into a nearby well and exclaims, “May certain evils be brought down on your head, Mr Darcy!” The resulting calamities that befall him have her feeling remorseful and fearful she has truly cursed him.
Building Bridges by Ali Scott
Darcy is thrown from his horse directly in front of the carriage Elizabeth and the Gardiners are travelling in on their way to Lambton. With bad roads and a bridge out, they are forced to take an injured Darcy to the only available inn nearby as he recovers.
Not in Vain by Mary Smythe
This is the only offering that departs from the collection’s forced-proximity theme for Elizabeth and Darcy. Instead, it explores the consequences of Lydia’s forced proximity to Wickham, with results that are not quite what one might expect.
Clutter and Concealment by Nan Harrison
When Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam call at the parsonage to take their leave the morning Elizabeth receives Darcy’s letter, and embarrassed to have to see or speak to Darcy again, she takes refuge in Mr Collins’ garden shed. What could go wrong—or maybe right?
Seven Days in Northamptonshire by Lucy Marin
Not long after Hunsford, Elizabeth and Darcy are shocked to find themselves in company once more at the estate of Darcy’s godfather who, unknown to our dear couple, is an acquaintance of Mr Bennet. Hating travel, Bennet met Elizabeth at the Gardiners’ to have her accompany him to visit his friend. This results in perhaps the most romantic re-declarations of love in this collection.
A Just and Tender Spirit by Julie Cooper
Ha! This one commands that you suspend belief. I’m still grinning after finishing it. Quite a diverting premise! No spoilers here. Don’t skip it.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher and am voluntarily offering my review. I have this book preordered.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
A collection of 8 forced proximity stories.
At some point following the failed proposal (mostly directly after) they are stuck or brought together in one fashion or another.
All but one focus mainly on Our Dear Couple. One, interestingly, had Lydia and her chaotic turmoil added to the mix.
Each one is an entertaining gem.
This was an interesting take on an anthology collection. They tend to be utterly romantic and sometimes highly emotional.
Here, it was fascinating to read the premise of a forced situation with the tension of a failed Hunsford proposal as the backdrop, story after story.
None are the same. The authors' individual stamps are evident with each offering. Its only a shame the collection has only 8 stories. I'd have loved a couple more!
I received an Advance Reader Copy and voluntarily leave my review.
At some point following the failed proposal (mostly directly after) they are stuck or brought together in one fashion or another.
All but one focus mainly on Our Dear Couple. One, interestingly, had Lydia and her chaotic turmoil added to the mix.
Each one is an entertaining gem.
This was an interesting take on an anthology collection. They tend to be utterly romantic and sometimes highly emotional.
Here, it was fascinating to read the premise of a forced situation with the tension of a failed Hunsford proposal as the backdrop, story after story.
None are the same. The authors' individual stamps are evident with each offering. Its only a shame the collection has only 8 stories. I'd have loved a couple more!
I received an Advance Reader Copy and voluntarily leave my review.
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews