Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Saints of Purgatory #2

A Sanctuary for Sin

Rate this book
We haven’t seen the last of our favorite motorcycle club.
With more danger on the horizon, the Saints of Purgatory
are forced to face the deadly enemies at their doorstep.

As the vice president of a club on the brink of war with a
president newly in love with the killer who got them in this
mess in the first place, James Hartley takes on too many
responsibilities to handle alone. Which is how he finds
himself teaming up with the most relentlessly cheery
anomaly he’s ever met.

Sadie Oliver has only ever wanted to be whoever her people
need her to be. If that’s a spy to keep her best friend alive,
then just call her Jason Bourne. But it quickly becomes clear
she’s out of her depth, so who better to have as a partner than
the surly man who can’t seem to keep his eyes off her?

Everything they love is hanging in the balance, but neither
James nor Sadie can be prepared for what they’ll face next.
Or how facing it together could be the undoing they’re
desperate to avoid.

444 pages, Paperback

Published May 5, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Madison Lawson

21 books327 followers
Madison is a bestselling author of sci-fi and thriller novels filled with edge-of-your-seat suspense, multi-dimensional, relatable characters, and complex relationships and family dynamics. Madison is an English graduate from Texas A&M University and is currently studying for her master's degree in North Carolina where she lives with two roommates and her perfect dog, Teddy Lupin.

To stay updated, follow Madison on social media and check out her website at madisonlawson.com. Bring up Harry Potter, her dog, Halsey, or her books to get her talking nonstop. You probably won’t regret it.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
240 (36%)
4 stars
284 (43%)
3 stars
110 (16%)
2 stars
15 (2%)
1 star
4 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews
Profile Image for Brittany Ferraro.
340 reviews1,870 followers
May 12, 2026
Okay we were spoiled fucking rotten with these two narrators. James and Lucy absolutely killed this audiobook. As soon as I saw it was them, I literally did a happy dance.

Who would’ve thought I’d have a thing for redheads? I mean, I guess if he’s got tattoos, a beard, and rides a motorcycle, what’s not to like? I feel like that man is a ride I would not survive in the best way. And I love how he was paired up with Sadie. It’s kind of opposites attract, a little grumpy sunshine, but it was done tastefully and done right and never felt over the top. I really loved their dynamic and their banter it was playful, funny, and just worked.

I kind of wish we got a little more from them, though. I feel like a lot of the story focused on June and Theo, which of course I don’t mind because A Deal with the Reaper is such an amazing book and I loved seeing those same characters again. I just felt like the spotlight was mostly on them, and I wanted more from James and Sadie because their chemistry and connection were everything.

The connection to the plot in book one broke my fucking heart. We get more information about what happened to Theo’s daughter, who is also James’s niece, and that storyline was really fucking good. I was literally on the edge of my seat. I wanted to jump into the book and get revenge for that sweet little baby girl myself 😭😭😭 I actually love that Theo and James have a connection outside of the club since Theo was dating James’s sister. They really do have a brotherly relationship and I love it.

Something about a motorcycle gang just does something to me. I’m telling you, it stems from my love for Sons of Anarchy. I used to sit my ass down and binge-watch that show from sunup to sundown, baby. I love the gang activity. I love the danger. I love the men. I love the bikes. I love the roughness. It’s just all around a good time for me.

James and Sadie were so fucking hot together btw 🥵🥵 and I loved that James was all broody, “touch her and you die” vibes.

This was a really solid book and I enjoyed it so much. I love the Easter eggs and all of the other couples. I’m super excited to see if they all get books 🤭
Profile Image for Shes _Crafty_reader.
177 reviews7 followers
May 8, 2026
Story-4🌟
Audiobook 4.5🌟

-Grumpy x Sunshine
-Touch Her and 💀
-"Who Did
This To You?!”
-Motorcycle Club VP MMC
-Pop Culture References Galor
-Sometimes Shady Gardener FMC

A Sanctuary for Sin was such an addictive audiobook experience. The voice acting was done in duet by Lucy Rivers and James Cassidy, and they completely nailed the emotions, tension, and chemistry between the characters. I loved the FMC and MMC so much, their playful banter and connection made it impossible to stop listening. The plot kept me hooked, and the spicy scenes were flawlessly executed! A fantastic listen! I hope we get more audiobooks from this author!! 💜
Profile Image for Hailey Goshert.
462 reviews94 followers
May 29, 2026
3.5⭐️ 3.5🌶️ biiiig fan of June, our FMC... and apparently BIIIIG fan of an MMC who is compared to looking like Tormund Giantsbane from GoT lol

plot-wise i was really interested in the whole poison garden thing and i was excited that we got to see it in action a few times. i wasn't a huge fan of the undercover stuff just because i could tell early on that it would only blow up in everyone's faces... but i will admit it was highly entertaining.

i think i liked this slightly better than book one even if i can also admit that this didn't necessarily have the same level of emotional depth as book one did. idk i think i just enjoyed these characters as individuals more, and then i also enjoyed getting to know both the motorcycle club and the girl friend group a little better too. i can't tell for sure who's story will be next but i will for sure be picking up the next book no matter who it's about (but plz be Ace omg)
Profile Image for Shannon.
506 reviews
July 26, 2026
“If she ordered me to my knees I’d fall to the floor and grow roots” 🖤🏍️🪴
May 16, 2026
A Sanctuary of Sin 🎧
By: Madison Lawson
Performed by: Lucy Rivers & James Cassidy

MC romance? Yes please and thank you! Book two equally as good as book 1. And yes, give me book 3! I can see the set up for it, and I’m all in.
Getting some answers on Shiloh’s death, it’s great and all but still gut wrenching.
In the midst you think James and Sadie are building a bond and relationship, but are they the only ones?? Smooth little teaser plot twist with that one!
MC’s to me, have always been the best form of found family there is. And Madison Lawson writes them the way they are supposed to be written. She’s had me hooked since book one. Can’t wait to see what’s next. And will Soot be involved? 😉
James Cassidy as always gives a stellar performance with all the characters he embodied. With accents and all, it was a job well done! Lucy Rivers held her own along side him.
Great job to all who brought this story to life. Highly recommend!
Story: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Narration: 🎙️🎙️🎙️🎙️🎙️
Profile Image for Emma Thomas.
Author 2 books128 followers
July 14, 2026
A Sanctuary for Sin
ᴡʜᴀᴛ ᴛᴏ ᴇxᴘᴇᴄᴛ:
"ᴡʜᴏ ᴅɪᴅ ᴛʜɪs ᴛᴏ ʏᴏᴜ?"
ʟᴀᴜɢʜ ᴏᴜᴛ ʟᴏᴜᴅ ᴍᴏᴍᴇɴᴛs
ᴘᴏᴘ ᴄᴜʟᴛᴜʀᴇ ʀᴇғᴇʀᴇɴᴄᴇs ɢᴀʟᴏʀ
ᴏᴠᴇʀᴄᴏᴍɪɴɢ ᴛʀᴀᴜᴍᴀ
ᴛᴏᴜᴄʜ ʜᴇʀ ᴀɴᴅ ☠️
ғʀɪᴇɴᴅs (ᴋɪɴᴅᴀ) ᴛᴏ ʟᴏᴠᴇʀs
ɢʀᴜᴍᴘʏ x sᴜɴsʜɪɴᴇ
ғᴏᴜɴᴅ ғᴀᴍɪʟʏ
ᴍᴏᴛᴏʀᴄʏᴄʟᴇ ᴄʟᴜʙ ᴠᴘ ᴍᴍᴄ
sᴏᴍᴇᴛɪᴍᴇs sʜᴀᴅʏ ɢᴀʀᴅᴇɴᴇʀ ғᴍᴄ
ᴍᴏʀᴀʟʟʏ ɢʀᴇʏ ᴄʜᴀʀᴀᴄᴛᴇʀs
Profile Image for Michelle Grimison.
1,328 reviews7 followers
May 8, 2026
ALC (audio) Review!
Grumpy, traumatized VP of the club biker James looks into his Prez’s old lady’s best friend to ensure that she is no threat to his club. Sassy, sunshine botanical baddie Sadie becomes a problem to his sanity by trying to help them gain intel on the rival MC.

First of all: Mmmmmm James Cassidy! He can say all those naughty things in my ear ALL DAY! 🥵🫠 great choice for grumpy biker man!
Lucy Rivers did a great job delivering all Sadie’s snark & sass! And I’d be her “good boy” too (and I’m a 100% straight woman!)

I loved the characters dynamics… of course the grumpy/sunshine is always great, but the little things make it even better. All Sadie’s pop culture references had me cackling, and his failure to get them just made it even better! How she is actually a badass poisoner, and he lets her be a baddie even though he’s terrified of loosing her.

I can’t wait to see what comes next! And I hope it’s Ev & Ace! And honestly I still need Luna’s story!

🌶️🌶️🌶️/5
The Switch dynamic was fantastic! We always love a dominant man, but the fact that he needs to be her good boy sometimes was a wonderful change of pace! And the degrading praise he gives?! 🥵🥵🥵🫠🫠

Thank you Madison Lawson (and Book Funnel) for the Advanced Listener Copy!
98 reviews
May 9, 2026
I am gutted I really wanted to like this book…

The first 30% was basically just high-speed recap of the first book, but from James and Sadie’s point of view to see what they were up to, but the time jumps made it quite dull…

Sadly, after four days of trying and I couldn’t complete this book, on the first book was so good I really wanted to like it… maybe that’s my own fault for having such high expectations of it
Profile Image for Rita_Samo_Čita.
82 reviews1 follower
July 17, 2026
Was this a fun read? YES. Was it as good as the first? Not quite.
Honorable mentions for Sadie's humor, but the entire plot is lukewarm at best.
The spice is interesting but not as compelling as in the first book. Then again, I am biased to a good enemies-to-lovers trope, so this might be my reference, purely. The switch from dom to sub for the two of them is not as interesting as one might think. All in all, I am not against reading the 3rd book.
51 reviews
September 18, 2026
A perfect follow-up. Everything was great. The banter, the relationships, the plot, the giant dog lol
It builds the world out and blends the stories so well it's like just a straight continuation. The love these girls have for eachother is the kind of friendship everyone deserves. Literal ride or dies.

I can't wait for the third. Introductions to the next books characters is always important and Madison nails it. I'm already interested and want to know more.
Profile Image for Clarisa.
13 reviews
September 18, 2026
I absolutely love this series. I love James and Sadie's story more. I felt i was able to relate more to Sadie. Her wittyness his uptight demeanor is a perfect combo. Now I need to know more about Ace and Evelyn so I hope we get a third!
Profile Image for Jenn.
458 reviews5 followers
September 30, 2026
I devoured this, happily. The audio was chefs kiss 🧑‍🍳 💋
Profile Image for H.
1,170 reviews
September 25, 2026
Enjoyed. Mc VP finds love in his best friends old lady best friend.
Profile Image for Novellaworm.
398 reviews22 followers
May 16, 2026
Grumpy Biker Men, “Good Boy” Praise & Audio Perfection — Madison Lawson Absolutely Owned Me


Madison Lawson has officially ruined me in the best possible way. Receiving a Beta ALC of Sanctuary of Sin before the narrator announcement already had me excited… but finding out it was James Cassidy and Lucy Rivers? Immediate emotional collapse. My AirPods were fighting for their lives the entire time. 🫠🔥

This second book in the Saints of Purgatory series somehow manages to raise the stakes, deepen the world, AND deliver one of my favourite audiobook experiences ever. The way June and Theo’s continuing arc is woven into Sadie and James’ story was honestly genius. Everything feels connected, emotional, and so much bigger than just one couple.

And James Cassidy as James Hartley? UNREAL. His portrayal of the gruff, emotionally guarded biker man was perfection. The accents, the emotion, the tension in his voice… absolutely immaculate. He didn’t just narrate James — he became him. I’m still recovering from some of the things that man said in my headphones.

Then there’s Lucy Rivers bringing Sadie to life with the perfect mix of sass, humour, vulnerability, and complete chaotic energy. Sadie’s pop culture references had me laughing constantly, especially with James never understanding a single one of them. But underneath the humour, Sadie is such a badass in her own right, and I loved that James respected her strength even while being terrified of losing her.

The grumpy/sunshine dynamic was already incredible, but the switch dynamic? Madison Lawson, I owe you therapy bills. We love a dominant biker man, but the fact he also needs to be HER good boy sometimes? Elite. Exceptional. Life-changing, honestly.

The chemistry between Sadie and James was addictive, the danger and suspense kept me hooked, and the emotional connection between the characters made this impossible to stop listening to.

This audiobook was funny, intense, emotional, spicy, and completely unforgettable.

Read it. Listen to it. Do both at the same time if you value your sanity a little less than I do.

Madison Lawson absolutely nailed this one
112 reviews8 followers
May 9, 2026
I listened to ‘A Sanctuary for Sin’ and it pulled me back into the world of the Saints of Purgatory fast and honestly, I think I loved this one even more than the first book… that’s a rare thing!

James and Sadie were EVERYTHING. I’m such a sucker for the grumpy/sunshine dynamic and the tension between them was addictive from the start. James is carrying the weight of the club on his shoulders and Sadie’s chaotic optimism somehow manages to crack through all of that darkness in the best way possible, and her pop culture references are just so so good. Their chemistry felt natural, intense and emotional instead of just surface level spice and story tension.

What really stood out to me was how balanced the story felt. It had the danger, suspense and gritty MC atmosphere I wanted, but it also gave us emotional depth and characters that genuinely felt layered and totally fell for. Sadie especially surprised me… she wasn’t just comic relief or ‘the cheerful girl’. She was brave, messy, loyal and way more capable than people gave her credit for. I enjoyed getting to know more of the characters more.

The pacing kept me hooked in the entire time and I loved getting deeper into the Saints of Purgatory world. The stakes felt higher, the emotions hit harder and there were multiple moments where I genuinely didn’t know what was going to happen next and was worried for characters.

If you love dark MC romance with emotional tension, dangerous men, found family vibes and a couple that completely consumes the page whenever they’re together, then this book absolutely delivers it all!!

Madison Lawson somehow makes chaos, violence, romance and vulnerability blend together perfectly, and now I’m desperate for more from this series. The Saints of Purgatory world is becoming one of those series where I immediately need the next book the second I finish the current one.
Profile Image for Aubrey.
238 reviews4 followers
May 29, 2026
I love this series! This second book in the Saints of Purgatory series raises the stakes and deepens the world. The way June and Theo’s continuing arc is woven into Sadie and James’ story is honestly genius. Everything feels connected, emotional, and so much bigger than just one couple.

James Cassidy as James Hartley? Unreal. His portrayal of the gruff, emotionally guarded biker was perfection. The accents, the emotion, the tension in his voice, absolutely flawless. He didn’t just narrate James he became him. He never disappoints. James is a pure tortured soul.

Then there’s Lucy Rivers, who brings Sadie to life with the perfect mix of sass, humor, vulnerability, and complete chaotic energy. Sadie’s pop culture references had me laughing constantly, especially with James never understanding a single one of them. Underneath the humor, she’s such a badass in her own right, and I loved that James respected her strength even while being terrified of losing her.

The chemistry between Sadie and James was addictive. While the obsessive energy was palpable from the start, their story is a slow burn. The tension, the protectiveness, the emotional moments hit perfectly. The danger and suspense kept me hooked and the emotional connection between the characters made this impossible to stop listening to. The grumpy/sunshine dynamic was already incredible, but the switch dynamic? We love a dominant biker man, but the fact that he also needs to be her good boy sometimes? Amazing.

This book leans heavily into the darker gang/crime storyline for a good portion of the story, which occasionally made the romance feel slightly secondary early on. But the suspense and emotional stakes kept me completely invested.

I have a strong inkling of who our next couple is and I can't wait to see what Madison has in store next.
Profile Image for Charlie Rowan.
105 reviews
May 7, 2026
A Sanctuary for Sin was another addictive instalment in this series and I genuinely could not stop reading once things started escalating. Madison Lawson has created characters that feel messy, loyal, traumatised and fiercely protective in a way that makes you completely invested in all of them.

Sadie was such a standout FMC for me. She’s funny, chaotic, loyal to a fault and hides so much vulnerability behind humour and confidence. I loved her ‘soft rage’ moments and the way she’d do absolutely anything for the people she loves. James, meanwhile, is pure tortured soul. The obsessive energy was palpable early on though👀. The slow burn between them definitely takes its time, but once it ignites… wow. The tension, the protectiveness, the emotional moments. It all of hit perfectly.

This book leans heavily into the darker gang/crime storyline for a good chunk of the story, which sometimes made the romance feel slightly secondary early on, but honestly the suspense and emotional stakes kept me hooked the entire time. By the final stretch I was stressed, angry, emotional and fully ready to personally fight half the South Five myself.

Dark, emotional, rage-inducing, addictive and full of ride-or-die loyalty. Another 5⭐ read from Madison Lawson.

I also very Kindly received an ALC and while the Narrators haven’t been announced yet, I will say, they were chosen perfectly! Their performances were fantastic and I highly recommend adding the Audiobook to your TBR.
Profile Image for Andi.
145 reviews1 follower
June 15, 2026
a sanctuary for sin — ★★★★★

i regret not picking this up faster . i really do .

i read the first book originally for writing inspiration — my own fmc is also involved in some dark business — and came out of it with a brand new favorite . this second book did exactly the same thing . new favorite . again . madison lawson is just doing something right .

sadie was june’s best friend in the first book , so we already had a soft spot for her going in . jason is the vice president of the biker club ( basically a brother to theo ) , and he’d already been keeping an eye on sadie because of her relation to june — making sure she wasn’t a danger to the club’s president . that’s how they knew each other . and watching that careful , watchful dynamic slowly turn into something warm and gushy from jason’s side was so satisfying to read .

i love characters who deal in poison . i love characters connected to plants . they just feel cozy and specific and interesting in a way that’s hard to explain . so finding out what sadie does on the side was such a wonderful surprise — right up my alley in the best way .

the smut was fantastic ( that one scene at the end ? omg swoon ) . jason turning soft for sadie was fantastic . the whole thing was just fantastic .

i hope there’s more to come for the other characters because i’m not ready to leave this world yet .

five stars . read it sooner than i did .​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
Profile Image for Farrah Williams.
263 reviews3 followers
May 3, 2026
When this is the book dedication, I know it's going to be good.

"To everyone who has ever felt weak. Let them underestimate you. Then show them just how deadly you can be."

The first book in the series , A Deal With the Reaper was my first Motorcycle Club book and this follow up did not disappoint. While this is a dark romance, I love that the author gives us a very prominent story line that has to do with The Saints and their business along with the relationship aspect. I was so excited we got so much of June and Theo from the first book. I love Sadie and James and how they complement each other. I love that Sadie comes into her own and realizes her place in this world.. James carries so much and was so closed off, but I loved how Sadie snuck her way in.

Safe to say I’ll be sticking with this series to see where it goes next (if we get more )

Thank you to Madison Lawson for the opportunity to read this ARC!
Profile Image for Sandra (millennial.reading).
282 reviews3 followers
June 27, 2026
4.25⭐️ KU✅ 3.5🌶️ 1st person Dual POV

Definitely more interesting than book #1.
There are some unnecessary chapters that bored me, but still the story was fast-pacing.

I liked Sadie way more than June, as she was more energetic and grounded. I loved how she didn’t choose miscommunication in the key moments. She did annoy me a bit with her recklessness for some stupid reasons, but she was still cool enough.
James was perfect! Much better than Theo as a character. Special in his own way.
Their chemistry was developed nicely. It was not instant and unreasonable as in book #1.

I liked how the characters from book #1 are still in focus but now more as side characters where we can still folow their story.

It’s obvious who the next couple would be, and I am seriously excited to pick up the next one. Something tells me that the the war is not over.
Profile Image for Michelle.
2,209 reviews24 followers
May 23, 2026
Sadie & James
Dark romance
Motorcycle Club VP
Found Family
Grumpy x Sunshine

I immersive read this one and I loved it! It's duet narration by James Cassidy and Lucy Rivers, and they do an incredible job at bringing Sadie & James to life!

I loved book 1 but I think this one is my favourite!!

I love how obsessed James is with Sadie, even if he's trying to tell himself that he isn't 🤭

This book starts off with the first part being a parallel timeline of book 1, but from Sadie & James's POVs, which I love!! We get to see a whole extra depth to a story that we already love!

I wasn't expecting to love James as much as I did, but he surprised me in the best way 😍

I cannot wait for the next book in this series!
Profile Image for Nikki’s Books.
222 reviews2 followers
June 4, 2026
Everything a MC book should be. James is my favorite new psycho book boyfriend! The audio book is worth using a credit or just buying; trust me on this. Would absolutely recommend if you like the criminal underworld, but make it sexy morally grey & on the back of a bike!

Pleaaaaaase tell me Ev & Ace are the next book because the mystery of those two has me hooked.
Profile Image for Maria.
1,045 reviews1 follower
May 18, 2026
4.5


This series is just perfection. I mean I fuckin love the first book. I enjoyed this one. And I am foaming at the mouth for the 3rd one. Hoping it will be Acteon's. I just have this big feelings. Hahahahahaha.
Profile Image for Ilze.
251 reviews15 followers
June 14, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫Good time reading this MC romance. Second book is exploring Sadie and James as well as still revisiting June and Theo from first book Deal with a Reaper. Looking forward to to next one in this series
3 reviews
June 27, 2026
I liked continuing in this world. Book 1 was better. I listened to this as an audiobook, the male narrator was perfect. The female narrator was awful. It felt like a kindergarten teacher reading a story book. Really ruined it for me.
Profile Image for Breeannon Melville.
175 reviews
July 22, 2026
Okay I FUCKING LOVED THIS BOOK!!! Will forever be known as one of my god tier 5 star books, the spice, the story, the characters, the banter! Faaken sensational!
748 reviews3 followers
September 16, 2026
🎧 Audiobook review 🎧⚡ Spoilers and profanities might lie ahead —I usually like to talk shit about everything that goes down in these books

I feel like this book focused far more on the plot than on the romance—the motorcycle club business, the issue with the other gang, all the mystery, all the *things*—and unfortunately, that made it really hard for me to get invested in the actual relationship.

The two protagonists simply don’t spend enough time together for me to understand how we get from *“we’ve known each other for a couple of weeks”* to *“I love you.”* There are so many side quests and so many chapters where the plot conspires to keep them apart so they can go off and do utterly menial things: hang out with friends, train, fight, talk about shit… and, dear God, **talk about shit.** There are so many characters and so little interesting stuff for them to actually do that I found myself bored out of my fucking mind.

And the pining? Not enough. Sadie just didn’t feel special enough to me. She was fine. Perfectly fine. At times, even a little childish. Now June? **That** was a badass FMC with actual personality, interesting traits, hobbies, and enough presence to make me want to know more about her. Sadie, by comparison, felt like a bit of a run-of-the-mill FMC. She isn’t bad by any means—she’s eager, loyal, and does things here and there—but I felt like I’d already read her character a dozen times before. And ultimately, she still falls into the damsel-in-distress category and needs to be saved. Which is… not exactly my favourite flavour of heroine.

James was an even bigger *eh* for me. He somehow felt like a side character in his own book. Maybe that’s partly because he shares the same trauma as Theo, and Theo Zarvas is such a fucking force of nature that he manages to dominate the page even when he’s technically someone else’s supporting character.

The only time I found James genuinely interesting was when he submitted to Sadie. Everything else about him felt about as average as Sadie did to me. Even during the big revenge sequence, he somehow ends up standing in the background while another guy swoops in and saves Sadie. **Sir. This is your book. Please participate.**

The spice was spicing, sure, but nothing particularly revolutionary. We get quite a lot of sexy-time POV from Sadie’s perspective, and since we’ve already established that she can be a little childish, her inner thoughts—and some of the things she says to James—sometimes felt more like an actual dialogue exchange than a dirty session. Their chemistry was also a little off for me. I never quite got that *“Oh, these two are fucking fantastic together. They make each other better. Obviously they’re soulmates.”* Instead, it felt like they were pulled together largely through sheer proximity and their involvement in Theo and June’s story.

That being said, the story itself is good, and the writing is genuinely brilliant. I never got annoyed enough to want to DNF, and I didn’t experience that particular brand of second-hand embarrassment where I have to physically leave my body to survive a scene. 😂 I *did*, however, skip quite a lot because I have absolutely no interest in useless internal monologues or lengthy discussions about utterly menial shit like eating food, going somewhere, or hanging out.

And now, the exceptional thing: James Cassidy. And duet style narration.

I apologise to Lucy Rivers, but my brain has been so thoroughly conditioned to drool like a Pavlovian experiment the second I hear James Cassidy’s voice that I had to actively engage my higher cognitive functions to avoid panting like an idiot every time he started talking. His voice, his sighs, his timbre, the little things he does with his delivery—everything. Because that’s the thing with James Cassidy: he doesn’t just narrate. He acts. And he acts like nobody’s business.

Can you actually be in love with a voice? Because I fear I may have developed a medical condition. 😂

Overall, a solid book and a great effort for a second instalment, but unfortunately, it was completely overshadowed by Book 1 for me.
Profile Image for Brandy Slifer.
253 reviews2 followers
June 29, 2026
📖 A Sanctuary for Sin by Madison Lawson

🎧 Via Audible
Narrated by James Cassidy & Lucy Rivers

🔥 Vibe Check

• 🏍️ Grumpy x Sunshine
• 😂 Top-tier banter
• 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Spicy with light Dom/Sub vibes
• 😭 Emotional damage (bring tissues)
• 🐶 Best Boy Award: Soot the Great Dane
• 💜 Found family & motorcycle club chaos
• 💀 One heartbreaking plot twist

Going into book two is always a gamble. Sometimes it’s amazing… and sometimes it’s giving, “The author had absolutely no clue what to do next.”

Madison Lawson? She understood the assignment. 👏

This story picks up immediately after the events of book one, and I was hooked almost instantly. James Hartley and Sadie Oliver absolutely stole the show. Their banter is one of the strongest parts of this book. Sadie is basically a walking collection of movie quotes, sunshine, sarcasm, and controlled chaos wrapped up in a florist who could absolutely end your existence if she felt like it. She loves her people with everything she has, and you can feel that in every decision she makes.

Then there’s James…

This grumpy, sarcastic, redheaded Vice President never stood a chance. 😂

It’s painfully obvious he falls first, and as an enemies-to-lovers addict, I ate that up with a spoon. Watching him slowly realize he’s completely screwed while Sadie continues being her unapologetically chaotic self was absolutely priceless.

The overall plot continues to build from book one, raising the stakes while expanding the club’s war. Then Madison decided happiness was overrated and delivered one heartbreaking plot twist that had me mentally preparing my tissue box. My emotions were not consulted.

Can we also take a moment for Soot, the Great Dane?

🐶❤️

Don’t panic.

Nothing happens to the dog.

I know that’s everyone’s first concern. 😂 Soot brings the perfect amount of comedic relief throughout the story and honestly deserves employee of the month.

Now…

🌶️ Let’s talk about the spice.

It is spicy spicy.

We get some fun Dom/Sub dynamics without venturing into anything extreme. The chemistry is fantastic, the tension keeps building, and the scenes are vivid enough to make you glance over your shoulder before continuing.

BUT…

🚨 Here comes my biggest complaint.

We were in THE moment.

The chemistry was chemistry-ing.

The tension was tension-ing.

I was fully invested…

…and suddenly everyone slammed on the brakes for a full conversation about condoms, birth control, and STDs.

Listen…

I completely appreciate consent and safe sex.

I truly do.

But there are about a thousand smoother ways to work that conversation into the story than stopping the spicy scene dead in its tracks like someone yelled, “Hold on! Time for Health Class!”

The pacing hit a brick wall.

I swear I could physically feel someone dumping twenty pounds of ice into my hot bath. 😂

And honestly, this isn’t just Madison Lawson. I’ve noticed several romance authors doing this lately. There are much more natural ways to weave those conversations into a story without completely interrupting the momentum.

🎙️ Narrator Review

James Cassidy…

Sir.

You carried this book on those broad narrator shoulders. 😂

His dry sarcasm, emotional delivery, and ability to bring James to life elevated every single scene. He couldn’t have been cast any better.

Lucy Rivers was equally fantastic. She perfectly captured Sadie’s quirky, fearless, sunshine personality while also delivering the emotional moments with just the right amount of heart.

Together, this duet narration was an absolute win.

⭐ Final Verdict

This was an excellent sequel that delivered hilarious banter, emotional punches, fantastic chemistry, wonderful character growth, a compelling ongoing plot, and enough spice to leave your headphones blushing.

If you love motorcycle clubs, enemies-to-lovers, grumpy x sunshine, found family, emotional damage, and one of the best canine side characters around…

You’ll have a great time with this one.

⭐ 4.5/5 Stars

Now if romance authors could kindly stop scheduling Health Class in the middle of foreplay…

…we’d all appreciate it. 😂
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews