'The message of this book is both highly liberating and optimistic', Rory Sutherland
Drawing on six decades of pioneering research and a sweeping reexamination of the last 2500 years-from Periclean Athens and the Hebrew Torah to the Renaissance, the Enlightenment and the Civil Rights Movement-Martin Seligman shows how rises and falls in agency have steered the course of history.
Agency is the big idea for our when individuals have confidence, optimism and imagination, civilizations leap forward. In their absence, societies stagnate-no matter how rich their resources or how brilliant their citizens.
This remarkable book shows how individuals can act with agency and, with a clear-eyed view of an AI-transformed future, argues that we are entering the next great era of human flourishing.
"Agency: The Psychological History of Human Progress" is an extraordinarily ambitious book. At the age of 84, Martin Seligman sets out to reinterpret thousands of years of human civilization through a single psychological variable: agency, understood as the combination of efficacy, optimism, and imagination that allows us to believe we can change the world. From Ancient Greece to China, from Christianity to the Renaissance, from the Industrial Revolution to artificial intelligence, Seligman takes us on a fascinating intellectual journey. There were chapters I simply did not want to stop reading. The book's greatest strength lies in its ability to make us revisit familiar historical events through an unexpected perspective, revealing connections that would be difficult to find elsewhere.
The problems begin when Seligman attempts to turn this interpretation into a scientific demonstration. His quantitative analyses of language, frequently supported by artificial intelligence, seem to me methodologically too fragile to sustain such sweeping conclusions about the psychological states of entire civilizations. And a fundamental question remains: does agency actually explain progress, or does it merely redescribe it? Even so, I loved much of the book, particularly the final chapter, in which Seligman proposes artificial intelligence as a means of expanding human agency. Perhaps the best way to approach this work is as a sweeping intellectual essay, speculative, provocative, and frequently exhilarating, rather than as a scientific theory of history. Seligman did not convince me that he had discovered a new explanation for human progress, but he offered me an extraordinarily fertile new way of looking at it.
Well… I don’t know what I expected… but it really is the history of agency. I guess I wanted a little more about how to create agency which he did cover, but not in the depth that I was hoping.
Pros >>An interesting inquiry into the role of human agency and optimism in driving historical progress. It's the kind of big-swing question that makes you want the book to succeed. >>Easy to read and reasonably well paced for the scope of the subject.
Cons >>The methodology is deeply suspect. The author uses AI to scan the corpus of human writing, assigns agentic values to key terms, and uses that to rate the agency levels of entire societies across history. This assumes we have comprehensive access to ancient texts, that those in power didn’t selectively destroy anti-establishment content, that translations are accurate, and that “agenticism” can be meaningfully quantified at all. None of these assumptions are defended. The reliance on AI as a research methodology (for a book about human agency, no less) is hard to take seriously and raises the question of how much of the prose itself was generated the same way. >>The western bias runs deep and goes unexamined. The author cherry-picks achievements to support his thesis while conveniently ignoring anything that complicates it. One of the most glaring, the fact that the USSR beat the U.S. to space, which sits awkwardly alongside his use of the moon landing as a trophy example of agentic thinking. If communists without individual agency can beat the capitalist west into orbit, the thesis has a problem it never addresses. >>The core argument that belief in human agency and optimism can solve essentially anything is thin, reductive, and ultimately unresolved. The author doesn’t account for people with executive function conditions for whom “just believe in your agency” is not a meaningful prescription. He doesn’t square how so much “progress” came from Calvinist groups that his own framework would score low on agency. He raises serious rebuttals to his own optimism thesis near the end and then simply... doesn’t answer them. The book just ends. Most damning of all, he never considers that an over-emphasis on individual agency can itself be weaponized. That is, keeping people focused on personal optimization while structural theft happens at scale. People counting macros while their groceries double in price. People refining their budgets while their wages stagnate. Individual agency as a distraction from collective action is one of the most important dynamics of our time, and this book is too naive to see it.
Summary A book with an interesting question and a methodology too shaky to answer it. The inquiry into how belief in human agency has shaped historical progress is genuinely compelling, and in more rigorous hands it could have been a landmark work. Instead it cherry-picks evidence to fit a predetermined thesis, leans on AI analysis that can’t bear the weight it’s assigned, ignores anything inconvenient (like Soviet space achievements) and ultimately fails to defend its own central claims when challenged. The optimism-solves-everything argument isn’t just thin, it’s dangerous in the way all reductive thinking is dangerous: it locates the problem in individual mindset rather than in structures that benefit from you believing that. Worth reading if the subject pulls you in. Not worth trusting.
This new book does something wild: He takes a concept, a loose concept, tightens it, then proceeds to tie it to the end of a long stick and just draaaaaaaag it through the annals of history. Per the subtitle this is ‘the psychological history of human progress.’ But, uh, what even is agency? That would be “the belief that ‘I can accomplish my goals.’” What are its components?? Marty’s masterfully distills it into 1) Efficacy (“my estimate of achieving a specific goal in the here and now”), 2) Optimism (“my estimate that I can achieve my goal in the future, perhaps the distant future”), and 3) Imagination (“my mental representation of the range of goals I can achieve beyond the here and now”). He lays out his core hypothesis: “Agency drives action. This psychological state is a proximal driver of human progress over history. When it is present, progress occurs. When it is absent, stagnation occurs.”
Marty says progress has five realms: Thought, Philosophy, and Religion; Science, Medicine, and Technology; Literature, Music, and Art; Quality of Human Life; and Politics and Freedom. Here comes 230 pages of whooshing history—from 40,000 BCE to Ancient Greece to Ancient China (mesmerizing!) to Medieval Europe to the Renaissance to Black Agency to Women’s Agency. This is the history book I’ve always wanted: economical on WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED, expansive on WHAT IT MEANT.
No corners were cut in the making of this book. Great philosophers? All mentioned. World altering literature? Big inventions? Major historical events? All discussed. With details on how they were driven by agency. All with citations! And we need agency. This is a book to get your agency back, get your mojo back.
This is an incredible book that feels like you're riding a rocketship through time with the greatest self-help writer of the past half century. Thank you, Marty. You are a glittering and brilliant gem.
El tema del libro y el análisis histórico-psicológico prometían, pero según avanzas acaba siendo muy cansino la insistencia en eficacia-optimismo-imaginación, lees esas palabras al menos 3 veces por página. El argumento es interesante pero no es probable y los ejemplos son muy convenientes para favorecerlo. Pero lo peor de todo, es la sensación continua de estar leyendo texto generado por IA, lo cual no me extrañaría viendo lo que comenta en el último capítulo del libro. Tras aguantar la chapa unas 70 páginas lo fui avanzando a ver si se volvía menos chapa, pero continuó así hasta el final así que he decidido no perder más tiempo.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Agency by Martin Seligman explores an interesting and important idea, but I found the writing style too academic and research-heavy for the average reader.
The book is full of historical details, scientific studies, and complex terminology, which made it difficult to read and follow at times.
I ended up using AI to simplify the content and help me extract practical insights and ideas I could actually apply to my life.
I think this book is better suited for researchers or readers interested in the academic side of psychology and history, rather than those looking for an accessible, engaging, and practical psychology book.
Bueno, el autor propone que la eficacia, el optimismo y la imaginación impulsan el progreso humano de acuerdo a actuar, perseverar y construir posibilidades colectivas y personales. Sin embargo, su recorrido histórico simplifica procesos complejos e interpretaciones discutibles como Agency influenció sobre el cristianismo, la Edad Media y la modernidad. Sobre inteligencia artificial es sugerente, pero especulativo. Creo que se acabó la gasolina a Seligman.
Provided outstanding evidence linking times of significant innovation with increased agency (individual and collective)throughout history. A refreshing must-read for anyone with a pessimistic view of our future with the increasingly important role AI will play.