What do you think?
Rate this book
The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good
A hidden garden. An ancient tale. A missing child. This is an addictive mystery with crossing narratives that's impossible to put down.
Fran doesn't want to stay with her aunt and uncle and her annoying cousin, Imogen. Imogen is rude and unfriendly and, it turns out, missing... But her parents don't seem to know who Fran means - don't be silly, we don't have a daughter, you know that. So it's up to Fran, and Imogen's best friend, Bex, to find out what's happened to her.
Except Bex doesn't know who Imogen is either. All Fran knows is that it's got something to do with the hidden garden at Stillness Hall and the twelve statues that belong there. Could a mysterious old tale, a story of enchantment and death, hold the answers?
More brilliant stories by Kirsty
The Life and Time of Lonny Quicke
The Middler
Troofriend
Fran doesn't want to stay with her aunt and uncle and her annoying cousin, Imogen. Imogen is rude and unfriendly and, it turns out, missing... But her parents don't seem to know who Fran means - don't be silly, we don't have a daughter, you know that. So it's up to Fran, and Imogen's best friend, Bex, to find out what's happened to her.
Except Bex doesn't know who Imogen is either. All Fran knows is that it's got something to do with the hidden garden at Stillness Hall and the twelve statues that belong there. Could a mysterious old tale, a story of enchantment and death, hold the answers?
More brilliant stories by Kirsty
The Life and Time of Lonny Quicke
The Middler
Troofriend
Paperback
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews
September 18, 2025
4.5 Stars
One Liner: Love it!
Fran doesn’t want to stay with her uncle and aunt or their daughter, her annoying cousin Imogen. Doesn’t matter if it is only for a week. However, even Fran doesn’t expect what she sees. Imogen has disappeared, and no one remembers her, not even her parents or her best friend, Bex!
Fran is not willing to let it go. She will find out where Imogen is. But first, Fran has to determine what the hidden garden on the Stillness Estate has to do with it.
The story comes in the first-person POV of Fran, the third-person POV of Imogen and Bex, and the third-person POV of another character.
My Thoughts:
Nosy Crow is fast becoming a favorite middle-grade publisher. Their books are short, quick, and entertaining! This one is no different.
It has short chapters, 2-3 pages each, and maintains a wonderful tempo. I finished the entire book in a single sitting. Also, the cover is apt for the book.
The storytelling stands out here. We get the story in different POVs and a dual timeline narrative. That ensures that we can know what has happened and see how it affects the present. This also prevents the need for an info dump at a later stage and keeps the reader hooked.
Though Fran is the protagonist, she is not the only main character. Imogen and Bex also play major roles. I like that Imogen gets a third-person POV while Fran has the first-person (since her narration is a bit more). Kids will not be confused about whose story they are reading.
Moreover, the three girls are distinct from each other. They are layered while still being kids. Neither of them is perfect. They learn, they change, and they grow – all without making the story preachy or boring.
The actual mystery surrounding the disappearance is really intriguing. I wish we had more details about the thing, but kids will enjoy the plot as it is. There’s adventure, suspense, and danger.
The ending feels a bit abrupt, but I can see why it ended that way. It’s perfect for the plot.
After asking for illustrations, I did get one in this book. The first page of each chapter has the illustration of an element from the cover. I won’t mind more, though!
To summarize, The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good is a wonderful blend of fantasy, mystery, a bit of adventure, danger, and kids who learn to look beyond appearances.
Thank you, NetGalley and Nosy Crow, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley
One Liner: Love it!
Fran doesn’t want to stay with her uncle and aunt or their daughter, her annoying cousin Imogen. Doesn’t matter if it is only for a week. However, even Fran doesn’t expect what she sees. Imogen has disappeared, and no one remembers her, not even her parents or her best friend, Bex!
Fran is not willing to let it go. She will find out where Imogen is. But first, Fran has to determine what the hidden garden on the Stillness Estate has to do with it.
The story comes in the first-person POV of Fran, the third-person POV of Imogen and Bex, and the third-person POV of another character.
My Thoughts:
Nosy Crow is fast becoming a favorite middle-grade publisher. Their books are short, quick, and entertaining! This one is no different.
It has short chapters, 2-3 pages each, and maintains a wonderful tempo. I finished the entire book in a single sitting. Also, the cover is apt for the book.
The storytelling stands out here. We get the story in different POVs and a dual timeline narrative. That ensures that we can know what has happened and see how it affects the present. This also prevents the need for an info dump at a later stage and keeps the reader hooked.
Though Fran is the protagonist, she is not the only main character. Imogen and Bex also play major roles. I like that Imogen gets a third-person POV while Fran has the first-person (since her narration is a bit more). Kids will not be confused about whose story they are reading.
Moreover, the three girls are distinct from each other. They are layered while still being kids. Neither of them is perfect. They learn, they change, and they grow – all without making the story preachy or boring.
The actual mystery surrounding the disappearance is really intriguing. I wish we had more details about the thing, but kids will enjoy the plot as it is. There’s adventure, suspense, and danger.
The ending feels a bit abrupt, but I can see why it ended that way. It’s perfect for the plot.
After asking for illustrations, I did get one in this book. The first page of each chapter has the illustration of an element from the cover. I won’t mind more, though!
To summarize, The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good is a wonderful blend of fantasy, mystery, a bit of adventure, danger, and kids who learn to look beyond appearances.
Thank you, NetGalley and Nosy Crow, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley
October 11, 2025
Recommend-O-Meter: Big big yes for any kid!
Oh, this one was fun! I’m very young at heart and exactly the type of person who loves middle-grade books, and this particular title is definitely a gem amongst them.
We follow Fran, a kid who dreads having to interact with her dearly behated cousin, Imogen, during a short stay at her aunt and uncle’s place. Except the problem is, Imogen isn’t there and no one seems to remember she even exists. So of course, Fran takes it upon herself to solve the mystery, and what a ride it was! I won’t say anything more, but do know it’s both overflowing with magic and also just the right amount of creepy to be interesting. Every page felt like it was bursting with life and every unearthed piece of the puzzle was fascinating to behold.
It’s exactly the kind of book that my childhood self would’ve adored to bits (and that my adult self still did). I’d wholeheartedly recommend this one to any young reader, plus I’ll definitely be checking out Applebaum’s other work while I’m at it.
[I received an ARC of this book from the publisher on NetGalley. This does not in any way affect the contents of my review.]
Oh, this one was fun! I’m very young at heart and exactly the type of person who loves middle-grade books, and this particular title is definitely a gem amongst them.
We follow Fran, a kid who dreads having to interact with her dearly behated cousin, Imogen, during a short stay at her aunt and uncle’s place. Except the problem is, Imogen isn’t there and no one seems to remember she even exists. So of course, Fran takes it upon herself to solve the mystery, and what a ride it was! I won’t say anything more, but do know it’s both overflowing with magic and also just the right amount of creepy to be interesting. Every page felt like it was bursting with life and every unearthed piece of the puzzle was fascinating to behold.
It’s exactly the kind of book that my childhood self would’ve adored to bits (and that my adult self still did). I’d wholeheartedly recommend this one to any young reader, plus I’ll definitely be checking out Applebaum’s other work while I’m at it.
[I received an ARC of this book from the publisher on NetGalley. This does not in any way affect the contents of my review.]
Read
November 2, 2025The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good
Written by Kirsty Applebaum
Published by Nosy Crow
It has been a while since I have read a book by this author so I took this on holiday with me and read it in one day
Fran doesn't want to stay with her aunt and uncle and her annoying cousin, Imogen. Imogen is rude and unfriendly and, it turns out, missing... But her parents don't seem to know who Fran means - don't be silly, we don't have a daughter, you know that. So it's up to Fran, and Imogen's best friend, Bex, to find out what's happened to her.
Except Bex doesn't know who Imogen is either. All Fran knows is that it's got something to do with the hidden garden at Stillness Hall and the twelve statues that belong there. Could a mysterious old tale, a story of enchantment and death, hold the answers?
This hooked me straight in.
After reading this book I wondered( and hoped)that this is the first of a series.
I came away with the unlining message that us adults should listen to children more, and that bullies will never win.
I didn’t think I was going to like the character Imogen but she did warm up to her - it was strange because we don’t actually meet Imogen until half through the story and we only have the other characters opinion of her.
This is a great mystery for MG readers, full of imagination and hope.
Written by Kirsty Applebaum
Published by Nosy Crow
It has been a while since I have read a book by this author so I took this on holiday with me and read it in one day
Fran doesn't want to stay with her aunt and uncle and her annoying cousin, Imogen. Imogen is rude and unfriendly and, it turns out, missing... But her parents don't seem to know who Fran means - don't be silly, we don't have a daughter, you know that. So it's up to Fran, and Imogen's best friend, Bex, to find out what's happened to her.
Except Bex doesn't know who Imogen is either. All Fran knows is that it's got something to do with the hidden garden at Stillness Hall and the twelve statues that belong there. Could a mysterious old tale, a story of enchantment and death, hold the answers?
This hooked me straight in.
After reading this book I wondered( and hoped)that this is the first of a series.
I came away with the unlining message that us adults should listen to children more, and that bullies will never win.
I didn’t think I was going to like the character Imogen but she did warm up to her - it was strange because we don’t actually meet Imogen until half through the story and we only have the other characters opinion of her.
This is a great mystery for MG readers, full of imagination and hope.
August 31, 2025
This is an incredibly readble book, great writing, rounde characters, just enough peril for the age group
Two points that won't leave my brain though, I'm sure I know the 'in the past' story, but I can't place it... If anyone knows please tell me! I remember a less fleshed-out version, or I'm getting super strong deja vu!
Secondly, it ends really abruptly. I don't think there's enough remaining story for a sequel, and as an adult, I could imagine 2-3 things that would resolve it, but if you're reading this with a kid, or a kid is reading it themselves, you might want to have some answers ready for the "what next" questions that I think will arise.
Overall it's a strong recommend
I received an advance copy for free from NetGalley, on the expectation that I would provide an honest review.
Two points that won't leave my brain though, I'm sure I know the 'in the past' story, but I can't place it... If anyone knows please tell me! I remember a less fleshed-out version, or I'm getting super strong deja vu!
Secondly, it ends really abruptly. I don't think there's enough remaining story for a sequel, and as an adult, I could imagine 2-3 things that would resolve it, but if you're reading this with a kid, or a kid is reading it themselves, you might want to have some answers ready for the "what next" questions that I think will arise.
Overall it's a strong recommend
I received an advance copy for free from NetGalley, on the expectation that I would provide an honest review.
January 16, 2026
Upper elementary and lower middle school relevant. I read an ARC provided by the publisher. A fast-paced story with an intriguing premise. Fans of Mary Downing Hahn will enjoy this.
Read
September 18, 2025If I was 10 years younger I would have loved this book, even more so as part of a series. Great pacing, relatable characters and a story within a story, with some mild horror aspects.
Thank you to NetGalley and Nosy Crow for providing a copy of this book for review. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to NetGalley and Nosy Crow for providing a copy of this book for review. All opinions are my own.
September 26, 2025
I picked up a signed copy of this, with the intention of sharing it as a gift -- and like all gifted books, it's best to read the text first! For me it took about 2.5 hours on the train to finish - but keep in mind, I am an adult, so hardly a surprise. In all, it seemed like a good book for that funny 8-to-12 age range to start reading by themselves and transitioning towards more young-adult fiction, though the topics and tone remain within the children's book canon.
It was a charming mystery for young readers, written in a way to instantly capture the imagination and send one into a world of enchanted intrigue. Perfect for any child who's shown interest in classics like those written by Edith Nesbit, but would benefit from connecting with a more modern perspective they can relate to direct.
The story elegantly navigates topics like struggling with emotions when faced with adults who don't believe the truth of a matter, as well as the importance of standing up to bullies and being true to your own interests and sense of self, while supporting your friends along the way. Nothing groundbreaking, but it never spoke down to the reader and had consistent depiction of clearly defined characters. Like other reviewers, I was mostly charmed by the story -- and really appreciated the story-within-a-story which outlined how the enchanting central axis of the mystery came to be.
However I will admit there was one part which for a brief moment broke my sense of mystery and made me feel as if the book was a horror instead.
== Spoilers from here on. ==
Towards the end of the book, when the mystery is being revealed for Fran, there is an instance where the woman who inherited the enchanted garden that unbeknownst to her turns children into stone, makes mention of one child - a boy named Erik - having been freed from the enchantment eleven months prior.
The boy in the story is from a long-ago unspecified historic period, and lived in one of the servant's houses on the estate where the enchanted garden popped up. The new modern-day owner of the house makes mention to Fran, by way of trying to reassure her, that after being freed the boy discovered his family were long gone and his house no longer in existence, he burst into tears -- and then the very next thing this woman did was arrange to have him sent away that very day and put into a foster home. He is never mentioned again.
I cannot explain how absolutely chilling this was to me as a reader.
To imagine this poor boy who had broken free of the stone-statue enchantment - the experience of which is described at length by some of the other characters - and then finds himself in a new strange world, trying to make sense of things - only to have the first thing an adult living in the only familiar part of the world do to him? Is have authorities send him far, far away. Never to be considered or contacted again. No resolution for him about what had happened, or why the world is so different now.
It absolutely broke my heart.
More than that, it felt like a huge miss for the author to express a sense of empathy for lost children, and explore the possibility of what it means to care for others who have gone through difficult, uncomfortable or traumatic hardships. I understand there were likely editorial decisions to keep the story 'straightforward' or on a tight track -- but even having this boy out-of-time go to live with an understanding family member of the house's modern owner in another part of the country - or have been masquerading as her 'shy visiting nephew' to other villagers and being gently reintroduced to modernity after being freed from enchantment, would have been a kinder (and more interesting, narratively) fate than being disgarded as a ward of the state!
It felt both out of tone emotionally with the rest of the book, and a bit like a dismissive quick-fix for a hole in the plot. ('Gosh, if only x number of children can be turned into stone statues at a time, then 1 needs to be freed for my story to make sense - but I don't want to introduce another character, so he'll just instantly be sent away to child protective services! Never mind the trauma.')
With all this said; I can still recommend this book for young readers. Its overall story is strong, it's writing accessible, and its exploration of mystery a good introduction for young readers who aren't quite ready for more morally complex or frightening depictions of the world. Though I will put up a content warning for any children who are in/have been in care, or have had experiences being sent away from home unexpectedly -- they may need an adult to talk through some of the subjects in this book.
It was a charming mystery for young readers, written in a way to instantly capture the imagination and send one into a world of enchanted intrigue. Perfect for any child who's shown interest in classics like those written by Edith Nesbit, but would benefit from connecting with a more modern perspective they can relate to direct.
The story elegantly navigates topics like struggling with emotions when faced with adults who don't believe the truth of a matter, as well as the importance of standing up to bullies and being true to your own interests and sense of self, while supporting your friends along the way. Nothing groundbreaking, but it never spoke down to the reader and had consistent depiction of clearly defined characters. Like other reviewers, I was mostly charmed by the story -- and really appreciated the story-within-a-story which outlined how the enchanting central axis of the mystery came to be.
However I will admit there was one part which for a brief moment broke my sense of mystery and made me feel as if the book was a horror instead.
== Spoilers from here on. ==
Towards the end of the book, when the mystery is being revealed for Fran, there is an instance where the woman who inherited the enchanted garden that unbeknownst to her turns children into stone, makes mention of one child - a boy named Erik - having been freed from the enchantment eleven months prior.
The boy in the story is from a long-ago unspecified historic period, and lived in one of the servant's houses on the estate where the enchanted garden popped up. The new modern-day owner of the house makes mention to Fran, by way of trying to reassure her, that after being freed the boy discovered his family were long gone and his house no longer in existence, he burst into tears -- and then the very next thing this woman did was arrange to have him sent away that very day and put into a foster home. He is never mentioned again.
I cannot explain how absolutely chilling this was to me as a reader.
To imagine this poor boy who had broken free of the stone-statue enchantment - the experience of which is described at length by some of the other characters - and then finds himself in a new strange world, trying to make sense of things - only to have the first thing an adult living in the only familiar part of the world do to him? Is have authorities send him far, far away. Never to be considered or contacted again. No resolution for him about what had happened, or why the world is so different now.
It absolutely broke my heart.
More than that, it felt like a huge miss for the author to express a sense of empathy for lost children, and explore the possibility of what it means to care for others who have gone through difficult, uncomfortable or traumatic hardships. I understand there were likely editorial decisions to keep the story 'straightforward' or on a tight track -- but even having this boy out-of-time go to live with an understanding family member of the house's modern owner in another part of the country - or have been masquerading as her 'shy visiting nephew' to other villagers and being gently reintroduced to modernity after being freed from enchantment, would have been a kinder (and more interesting, narratively) fate than being disgarded as a ward of the state!
It felt both out of tone emotionally with the rest of the book, and a bit like a dismissive quick-fix for a hole in the plot. ('Gosh, if only x number of children can be turned into stone statues at a time, then 1 needs to be freed for my story to make sense - but I don't want to introduce another character, so he'll just instantly be sent away to child protective services! Never mind the trauma.')
With all this said; I can still recommend this book for young readers. Its overall story is strong, it's writing accessible, and its exploration of mystery a good introduction for young readers who aren't quite ready for more morally complex or frightening depictions of the world. Though I will put up a content warning for any children who are in/have been in care, or have had experiences being sent away from home unexpectedly -- they may need an adult to talk through some of the subjects in this book.
April 22, 2026
What worked:
Readers are treated to two stories instead of one, and the two parts are combined to form the overall plot. The opening pages describe Imogen and a friend named Bex when they approach a garden behind Stillness Hall. Everyone in town knows to stay away from it, but Imogen dares Bex. The book’s synopsis picks up from there, as Fran discovers no one knows a girl named Imogen. The plot follows Fran as she slowly realizes that the people here are trying to trick her. An unusual twist in this book is that there is still physical evidence of Imogen’s existence; her organized, dusty bedroom hasn’t been touched since she disappeared. There’s even a photograph of Bex alongside Imogen, but Bex has no memory of her. How can Imogen find Imogen when no one in town knows she exists?
Alternate chapters tell the tale of the original owners of Stillness Hall. The wealthy couple finally gives birth to a baby boy, but he later becomes dangerously ill. No one knows what’s wrong, so the parents go to drastic measures to save his life. Grief, anger, and enchantments lead to consequences that last for decades. Fran has no idea of the truth surrounding Stillness Hall, so she’s in danger of becoming the next victim. The book follows her relentless search for Imogen, and alternating chapters reveal the mystery’s origins and the property’s terrifying legends. Readers will anticipate the moment when the two stories merge to an eerie conclusion.
The plot addresses bullying and perceptions of others. Fran dreads seeing her cousin, Imogen, because Imogen is bossy and no fun to be around. Imogen doesn’t care for her sloppy cousin either, so their dislike is mutual. Imogen wants to be liked by a popular group of girls, so she bullies Bex into accepting a dare. That’s what ignites the main conflict. Fran realizes she may have bullied Bex, too, by pressurizing her into doing something she didn’t want to do. In a related way, the plot addresses atonement, as the girls try to make up for past indiscretions.
What didn’t work as well:
Part of the enchantment can be tricky to understand, as it doesn’t affect everyone. The story includes an explanation, but it may still have readers thinking twice.
The final verdict:
This speculative fiction story is skillfully crafted to share Fran’s determined efforts to do what’s right. Stillness Hall provides a mystery, and readers will follow hints from the alternate chapters to put together a solution. Of course, understanding the mystery doesn’t explain how to solve the problem. Overall, I recommend this book for all middle-grade readers who like mysteries.
Readers are treated to two stories instead of one, and the two parts are combined to form the overall plot. The opening pages describe Imogen and a friend named Bex when they approach a garden behind Stillness Hall. Everyone in town knows to stay away from it, but Imogen dares Bex. The book’s synopsis picks up from there, as Fran discovers no one knows a girl named Imogen. The plot follows Fran as she slowly realizes that the people here are trying to trick her. An unusual twist in this book is that there is still physical evidence of Imogen’s existence; her organized, dusty bedroom hasn’t been touched since she disappeared. There’s even a photograph of Bex alongside Imogen, but Bex has no memory of her. How can Imogen find Imogen when no one in town knows she exists?
Alternate chapters tell the tale of the original owners of Stillness Hall. The wealthy couple finally gives birth to a baby boy, but he later becomes dangerously ill. No one knows what’s wrong, so the parents go to drastic measures to save his life. Grief, anger, and enchantments lead to consequences that last for decades. Fran has no idea of the truth surrounding Stillness Hall, so she’s in danger of becoming the next victim. The book follows her relentless search for Imogen, and alternating chapters reveal the mystery’s origins and the property’s terrifying legends. Readers will anticipate the moment when the two stories merge to an eerie conclusion.
The plot addresses bullying and perceptions of others. Fran dreads seeing her cousin, Imogen, because Imogen is bossy and no fun to be around. Imogen doesn’t care for her sloppy cousin either, so their dislike is mutual. Imogen wants to be liked by a popular group of girls, so she bullies Bex into accepting a dare. That’s what ignites the main conflict. Fran realizes she may have bullied Bex, too, by pressurizing her into doing something she didn’t want to do. In a related way, the plot addresses atonement, as the girls try to make up for past indiscretions.
What didn’t work as well:
Part of the enchantment can be tricky to understand, as it doesn’t affect everyone. The story includes an explanation, but it may still have readers thinking twice.
The final verdict:
This speculative fiction story is skillfully crafted to share Fran’s determined efforts to do what’s right. Stillness Hall provides a mystery, and readers will follow hints from the alternate chapters to put together a solution. Of course, understanding the mystery doesn’t explain how to solve the problem. Overall, I recommend this book for all middle-grade readers who like mysteries.
May 18, 2026
Francesca “Fran” Good is not thrilled about spending a week with her aunt and uncle while her parents are away on business, mostly because she doesn’t get along that well with her bossy cousin Imogen. Aunty Liv, Uncle Pete, and Imogen live in a tiny cottage on the estate of Stillness Hall, which is surrounded by a mysterious, overgrown garden. Fran’s apprehension about the visit is intensified when she arrives to find that not only is Imogen not there, but no one seems to know who she is (even though her bedroom is still intact, and there are photos of her everywhere). Bewildered by her cousin's apparent erasure, Fran forms an uneasy alliance with neighbor girl Bex. Like Imogen’s parents, Bex does not remember Imogen, but she has a nagging feeling she should, or that she was involved in her disappearance.
Fran and Bex find Imogen’s journal and discover that the entries abruptly stopped 11 months prior. The journal provides clues to her activities on that day, which center around the garden at Stillness Hall. Despite several unpleasant encounters with the estate’s owner, Ms. Quincey, who adamantly opposes anyone visiting the garden and seems to take an instant dislike to Fran, the two girls venture into the garden. They are alarmed to see several lifelike statues of children, including one central figure on a pedestal and the rest appearing to be running away and frozen in motion. When Fran realizes one of the statues bears an uncanny resemblance to her cousin, she knows she needs to uncover the garden’s secrets before it’s too late.
The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good is a genre-blending and entertaining read for upper elementary students. It is a mildly spooky mystery with fantasy elements as well as realistic components involving bullying among tween girls. As the strange circumstances unfold and Fran tries to figure out what has happened to her cousin, readers have an advantage over her; for more than half the book, the short chapters alternate between Fran’s first person perspective and the text of an old story entitled “The Twelve Statues of Stillness Hall,” which relates the legend of the first residents of the estate and the origins of its mysterious garden. This story provides background information and context for Imogen’s disappearance but does not prepare readers for the twists and turns in store for Fran and Bex upon entering the garden. The ending is surprising and satisfying. Link to complete review: https://ysbookreviews.wordpress.com/2...
Fran and Bex find Imogen’s journal and discover that the entries abruptly stopped 11 months prior. The journal provides clues to her activities on that day, which center around the garden at Stillness Hall. Despite several unpleasant encounters with the estate’s owner, Ms. Quincey, who adamantly opposes anyone visiting the garden and seems to take an instant dislike to Fran, the two girls venture into the garden. They are alarmed to see several lifelike statues of children, including one central figure on a pedestal and the rest appearing to be running away and frozen in motion. When Fran realizes one of the statues bears an uncanny resemblance to her cousin, she knows she needs to uncover the garden’s secrets before it’s too late.
The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good is a genre-blending and entertaining read for upper elementary students. It is a mildly spooky mystery with fantasy elements as well as realistic components involving bullying among tween girls. As the strange circumstances unfold and Fran tries to figure out what has happened to her cousin, readers have an advantage over her; for more than half the book, the short chapters alternate between Fran’s first person perspective and the text of an old story entitled “The Twelve Statues of Stillness Hall,” which relates the legend of the first residents of the estate and the origins of its mysterious garden. This story provides background information and context for Imogen’s disappearance but does not prepare readers for the twists and turns in store for Fran and Bex upon entering the garden. The ending is surprising and satisfying. Link to complete review: https://ysbookreviews.wordpress.com/2...
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
E ARC provided by Netgalley
Fran is not happy that she has to spend a week with her Aunt Liz, Uncle Pete, and cousin Imogen in a small village near Stillness Estate, since she's never gotten a long with her cousin. Her mother has to go to a conference with her father to try to save the family business, though, so she's summarily dropped off despite her objections. Things get weird when her aunt and uncle tell her that they don't have a daughter! Since they still have Imogen's room with pictures of her in it, Fran feels she's being pranked, but neighbor Bex doesn't remember her either. Stillness Manor has a new owner, Ms. Quincey, who doesn't like children, and the secret garden there is supposedly evil and dangerous. Is it possible that Imogen went there? In alternating chapters, we see the story of Lord and Lady Stillness, who desperately wanted a child, only to have their son Leo become terribly ill when he was ten years old. A storyteller traveled to get a plant that could grant wishes, but wasn't able to make it back in time before Leo died, and Lord Stillness made a terrible wish. Fran manages to get Bex to help her investigate, but when they sneak into the garden, Bex is turned into a statue! Oddly, Imogen comes back. Fran and Imogran then try to save Bex, whose family doesn't remember her and is moving away in a few days. Will they be able to uncover the secret of the garden and work with Ms. Quincey to make sure that no more children go missing?
Strengths: This had a very classic feel to it; the first thing I was reminded of was Cameron's 1973 The Court of Stone Children. The back story about the death of Leo Stillness and the terrible wish his father made was interesting, and was a very British addition. Young readers will be very uncomfortable with the idea of their family not remembering them, even if the original thought was for families not to suffer when their children were turned into statues. Fran's desire to figure out the mystery and save Imogen and Bex was admirable, and I loved how hard she worked to do this. I would have very much enjoyed this book as a child.
Weaknesses: The backstory of Lord and Lady Stillness won't appeal to all readers, and this does have a particularly British feel to it.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who liked fantasy stories like Almond's Puppet, Dassori's Greta Ever After, or Saunders' Beswitched. This somehow reminded me of the surprisingly dark 13 Wishes by Harrison.
Fran is not happy that she has to spend a week with her Aunt Liz, Uncle Pete, and cousin Imogen in a small village near Stillness Estate, since she's never gotten a long with her cousin. Her mother has to go to a conference with her father to try to save the family business, though, so she's summarily dropped off despite her objections. Things get weird when her aunt and uncle tell her that they don't have a daughter! Since they still have Imogen's room with pictures of her in it, Fran feels she's being pranked, but neighbor Bex doesn't remember her either. Stillness Manor has a new owner, Ms. Quincey, who doesn't like children, and the secret garden there is supposedly evil and dangerous. Is it possible that Imogen went there? In alternating chapters, we see the story of Lord and Lady Stillness, who desperately wanted a child, only to have their son Leo become terribly ill when he was ten years old. A storyteller traveled to get a plant that could grant wishes, but wasn't able to make it back in time before Leo died, and Lord Stillness made a terrible wish. Fran manages to get Bex to help her investigate, but when they sneak into the garden, Bex is turned into a statue! Oddly, Imogen comes back. Fran and Imogran then try to save Bex, whose family doesn't remember her and is moving away in a few days. Will they be able to uncover the secret of the garden and work with Ms. Quincey to make sure that no more children go missing?
Strengths: This had a very classic feel to it; the first thing I was reminded of was Cameron's 1973 The Court of Stone Children. The back story about the death of Leo Stillness and the terrible wish his father made was interesting, and was a very British addition. Young readers will be very uncomfortable with the idea of their family not remembering them, even if the original thought was for families not to suffer when their children were turned into statues. Fran's desire to figure out the mystery and save Imogen and Bex was admirable, and I loved how hard she worked to do this. I would have very much enjoyed this book as a child.
Weaknesses: The backstory of Lord and Lady Stillness won't appeal to all readers, and this does have a particularly British feel to it.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who liked fantasy stories like Almond's Puppet, Dassori's Greta Ever After, or Saunders' Beswitched. This somehow reminded me of the surprisingly dark 13 Wishes by Harrison.
September 3, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This was a really enjoyable read! The strange disappearance of Imogen Good is book that follows our main character Fran who is on a mission to save her cousin Imogen who everyone seems to have forgotten.
To start, Fran is a really likeable main character for children to follow. She is determined and resilient in her mission to save Imogen despite originally not wanting to spend any time with her. I think this is a great dynamic for children to read because you may not like a person and still want them to be safe. This book has a running theme of friendships/ family and the people who are directly involved in your life. I also think Bex was a great character, imagine if you were a kid and your neighbours niece came to stay and started talking about a girl she swore you knew. (Bex “let me go ask my mum”) I think Fran’s whole reaction felt very realistic to how a kid would react.
The chapters of this book are short and alternate between chapters in Fran’s POV to a tale about the 12 statues. I think the alternating is a great way to build up suspense and readers are left questioning how the tale relates to the statues until the reveal. In a few instances however the change in storylines feels a bit abrupt and frustrating because Fran or the storytellers POV are getting interesting. This wasn’t a majority of the time and could just be a personal issue. (Side note the storyteller’s story reminded me of a picture book that got read to us at school where one child was turned to stone and needed to be turned back. Reading this book made me feel nostalgic because it’s a similar story just a bit aged up.)
When you think the mission is complete it’s revealed more work needs to be done, at this point Imogen is back and has her own POV which I think is a good contrast to Fran’s perspective. The whole lesson of Bex being picked on is seamlessly integrated into the story which I think makes for a productive conversation with kids about being kinder to others without being overly preaching or taking over the mystery. At the end I think an epilogue would have been nice to neatly tie up the story but it’s still a satisfying ending with the mystery and our characters next steps explained to the reader. Again, a really enjoyable read that I think will have young readers hooked!
This was a really enjoyable read! The strange disappearance of Imogen Good is book that follows our main character Fran who is on a mission to save her cousin Imogen who everyone seems to have forgotten.
To start, Fran is a really likeable main character for children to follow. She is determined and resilient in her mission to save Imogen despite originally not wanting to spend any time with her. I think this is a great dynamic for children to read because you may not like a person and still want them to be safe. This book has a running theme of friendships/ family and the people who are directly involved in your life. I also think Bex was a great character, imagine if you were a kid and your neighbours niece came to stay and started talking about a girl she swore you knew. (Bex “let me go ask my mum”) I think Fran’s whole reaction felt very realistic to how a kid would react.
The chapters of this book are short and alternate between chapters in Fran’s POV to a tale about the 12 statues. I think the alternating is a great way to build up suspense and readers are left questioning how the tale relates to the statues until the reveal. In a few instances however the change in storylines feels a bit abrupt and frustrating because Fran or the storytellers POV are getting interesting. This wasn’t a majority of the time and could just be a personal issue. (Side note the storyteller’s story reminded me of a picture book that got read to us at school where one child was turned to stone and needed to be turned back. Reading this book made me feel nostalgic because it’s a similar story just a bit aged up.)
When you think the mission is complete it’s revealed more work needs to be done, at this point Imogen is back and has her own POV which I think is a good contrast to Fran’s perspective. The whole lesson of Bex being picked on is seamlessly integrated into the story which I think makes for a productive conversation with kids about being kinder to others without being overly preaching or taking over the mystery. At the end I think an epilogue would have been nice to neatly tie up the story but it’s still a satisfying ending with the mystery and our characters next steps explained to the reader. Again, a really enjoyable read that I think will have young readers hooked!
August 30, 2025
An unsettling fantasy mystery ideal for upper primary age students.
Fran is dismayed at being abandoned to stay with relatives for a few days. She doesn't mind her aunt and uncle that much but she is dreading having to spend time with her cousin, Awful Imogen. But on arrival at their house she discovers that Imogen is missing. What's worse, no one even seems to realise as they have no recollection of an Imogen Good. Fran might not like Imogen very much but she is determined to find her.
I thought the main premise of the book was very good. It plays well on the fear of being forgotten by loved ones and shows how much we rely on those relationships. Fran tries so hard to provide evidence and convince others of Imogen's existence but it is explained away each time in a chillingly plausible way.
Interwoven with the chapters following Fran and Imogen we discover the story of the origin of problems at Stillness Hall. On the whole this works quite well as it drip feeds information to the reader and allows them to come up with their own theories rather than having everything revealed at once. The Stillness Hall chapters read more as fairytale than a historical record and add to the fantasy aspect of the book. However there were a few anachronisms that took me out of the story. While technically possible, they would have been highly unusual and were things that could have been picked up in the edit and altered to something more likely.
The story deals with bullying and learning to accept who you are rather than changing for others. It also encourages empathy and taking the time to get to know others in order to understand them better.
I was disappointed by the ending which lacked a proper resolution. But I can see that doing so might have required writing a much longer story, which could put off some readers, or writing a fairytale ending where everything is magically fine to get around the potential problems such resolution would bring.
An enjoyable read, definitely chilling in places, and ideal for upper primary age readers.
Thanks to Nosy Crow and NetGalley for the free eARC in return for an unbiased review.
Fran is dismayed at being abandoned to stay with relatives for a few days. She doesn't mind her aunt and uncle that much but she is dreading having to spend time with her cousin, Awful Imogen. But on arrival at their house she discovers that Imogen is missing. What's worse, no one even seems to realise as they have no recollection of an Imogen Good. Fran might not like Imogen very much but she is determined to find her.
I thought the main premise of the book was very good. It plays well on the fear of being forgotten by loved ones and shows how much we rely on those relationships. Fran tries so hard to provide evidence and convince others of Imogen's existence but it is explained away each time in a chillingly plausible way.
Interwoven with the chapters following Fran and Imogen we discover the story of the origin of problems at Stillness Hall. On the whole this works quite well as it drip feeds information to the reader and allows them to come up with their own theories rather than having everything revealed at once. The Stillness Hall chapters read more as fairytale than a historical record and add to the fantasy aspect of the book. However there were a few anachronisms that took me out of the story. While technically possible, they would have been highly unusual and were things that could have been picked up in the edit and altered to something more likely.
The story deals with bullying and learning to accept who you are rather than changing for others. It also encourages empathy and taking the time to get to know others in order to understand them better.
I was disappointed by the ending which lacked a proper resolution. But I can see that doing so might have required writing a much longer story, which could put off some readers, or writing a fairytale ending where everything is magically fine to get around the potential problems such resolution would bring.
An enjoyable read, definitely chilling in places, and ideal for upper primary age readers.
Thanks to Nosy Crow and NetGalley for the free eARC in return for an unbiased review.
May 4, 2026
Available May 5th, The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good by Kristy Applebaum is an amazingly clever, engaging middle grade read that blends mystery and fairy tale elements in a way that feels both fresh and familiar. This is exactly the kind of story I would have been completely obsessed with as a child, the kind where you finish a chapter and immediately need to know what happens next. There is a wonderful balance here between coming-of-age themes and the simple, still-important joys of childhood, which makes the story feel layered without losing its sense of fun and curiosity.
I especially appreciated the structure of the book. The short chapters make it incredibly readable, and the alternating perspectives and timelines keep the story moving at a satisfying pace. It creates just enough tension to keep readers fully invested without ever feeling overwhelming. The different points of view also allow each character to bring something unique to the story, and I loved how those perspectives work together to create a fuller picture of what is unfolding. My eight-year-old daughter is already completely obsessed, but I can easily see this appealing to a wide range of ages.
There is a slightly spooky atmosphere woven throughout, which adds to the intrigue without tipping into anything truly frightening. It feels more mysterious than scary, though very sensitive readers may find certain moments a little unsettling. What stands out most is how each girl’s voice feels distinct, offering different ways for readers to connect and see themselves reflected in the story. And I have to say, that ending absolutely feels like it is setting up for a sequel, which I would eagerly pick up. This is a memorable and imaginative read that will keep young readers hooked.
Thank you to Nosy Crow Inc and NetGalley for trusting me with an ARC of this title. It is truly appreciated and always such a treat to be able to read new books and share my opinions with fellow literature lovers.
I especially appreciated the structure of the book. The short chapters make it incredibly readable, and the alternating perspectives and timelines keep the story moving at a satisfying pace. It creates just enough tension to keep readers fully invested without ever feeling overwhelming. The different points of view also allow each character to bring something unique to the story, and I loved how those perspectives work together to create a fuller picture of what is unfolding. My eight-year-old daughter is already completely obsessed, but I can easily see this appealing to a wide range of ages.
There is a slightly spooky atmosphere woven throughout, which adds to the intrigue without tipping into anything truly frightening. It feels more mysterious than scary, though very sensitive readers may find certain moments a little unsettling. What stands out most is how each girl’s voice feels distinct, offering different ways for readers to connect and see themselves reflected in the story. And I have to say, that ending absolutely feels like it is setting up for a sequel, which I would eagerly pick up. This is a memorable and imaginative read that will keep young readers hooked.
Thank you to Nosy Crow Inc and NetGalley for trusting me with an ARC of this title. It is truly appreciated and always such a treat to be able to read new books and share my opinions with fellow literature lovers.
February 22, 2026
Spending time with her cousin Imogen is the last thing Fran wants to do while her parents are away on business. The last time Fran stayed with her uncle and aunt, Imogen was bossy, rude and altogether unfriendly. Fran decides to pretend to have a school project to work on while she is staying with them - to avoid Imogen.
But Imogen suddenly isn't the problem. In fact, according to Fran's uncle and aunt, they've even never heard of her. How can they forget they had a daughter?
Feeling very confused and then having a run-in with the lady next door, Fran just wants to go home. But when she finds someone else who might remember Imogen, Fran becomes curious about the mystery, and digs deeper.
Something very strange is going on in the little town, and the neighbour's garden seems to be at the centre of it all. Why is no-one allowed in there, and why do the local kids even avoid it?
Does it have something to do with the neighbour herself, or the wild rambling garden?
A tale of mystery, enchantment, missing children and loss, The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good is eerie but fun.
Short chapters with a clear font effortlessly pull readers into a story within a story - first told with chapters swapping between the present with Fran looking for her cousin Imogen, and a story of a loving family hundreds of years before who built and lived in the grand mansion next door.
The further you read, the viewpoint changes between Fran and her cousin, showing readers connections between disappearances, spells and wishes from the past.
Tension rises as a 'ticking clock' scenario builds, and children must do anything they can to save other children.
An entertaining and satisfying read.
Age - 9+
But Imogen suddenly isn't the problem. In fact, according to Fran's uncle and aunt, they've even never heard of her. How can they forget they had a daughter?
Feeling very confused and then having a run-in with the lady next door, Fran just wants to go home. But when she finds someone else who might remember Imogen, Fran becomes curious about the mystery, and digs deeper.
Something very strange is going on in the little town, and the neighbour's garden seems to be at the centre of it all. Why is no-one allowed in there, and why do the local kids even avoid it?
Does it have something to do with the neighbour herself, or the wild rambling garden?
A tale of mystery, enchantment, missing children and loss, The Strange Disappearance of Imogen Good is eerie but fun.
Short chapters with a clear font effortlessly pull readers into a story within a story - first told with chapters swapping between the present with Fran looking for her cousin Imogen, and a story of a loving family hundreds of years before who built and lived in the grand mansion next door.
The further you read, the viewpoint changes between Fran and her cousin, showing readers connections between disappearances, spells and wishes from the past.
Tension rises as a 'ticking clock' scenario builds, and children must do anything they can to save other children.
An entertaining and satisfying read.
Age - 9+
September 5, 2025
I didn’t realise this was a children’s book when I first started reading, but that didn’t diminish my enjoyment at all.
Fran isn’t thrilled about staying with her Aunt and Uncle while her parents are away—especially because it means putting up with her bossy cousin, Imogen. But when she arrives, her Aunt and Uncle claim they’ve never even heard of Imogen. Determined to solve the mystery, Fran takes it upon herself to find out what’s really going on.
The story weaves together Fran’s modern-day adventure with a fairytale-like legend, gradually revealing the truth behind Imogen’s disappearance. I particularly admired how the author managed to infuse what is essentially a children’s tale with a genuine sense of peril—it never felt patronising or watered down. This is exactly the sort of book I would have devoured in primary school.
The ending did feel a little abrupt; I found myself wishing for an extra twist or a stronger tie between the legend and the contemporary storyline. That said, for the intended age group, the resolution makes sense and avoids overcomplicating the plot.
One of the things I most appreciated was the subtle handling of themes like standing up to bullies and staying true to yourself. These ideas were present throughout, but never heavy-handed.
Overall, this is a solid and engaging read that blends mystery, folklore, and a relatable protagonist. It’s made me think I should dip into more children’s fiction—sometimes it captures magic that adult books don’t.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Fran isn’t thrilled about staying with her Aunt and Uncle while her parents are away—especially because it means putting up with her bossy cousin, Imogen. But when she arrives, her Aunt and Uncle claim they’ve never even heard of Imogen. Determined to solve the mystery, Fran takes it upon herself to find out what’s really going on.
The story weaves together Fran’s modern-day adventure with a fairytale-like legend, gradually revealing the truth behind Imogen’s disappearance. I particularly admired how the author managed to infuse what is essentially a children’s tale with a genuine sense of peril—it never felt patronising or watered down. This is exactly the sort of book I would have devoured in primary school.
The ending did feel a little abrupt; I found myself wishing for an extra twist or a stronger tie between the legend and the contemporary storyline. That said, for the intended age group, the resolution makes sense and avoids overcomplicating the plot.
One of the things I most appreciated was the subtle handling of themes like standing up to bullies and staying true to yourself. These ideas were present throughout, but never heavy-handed.
Overall, this is a solid and engaging read that blends mystery, folklore, and a relatable protagonist. It’s made me think I should dip into more children’s fiction—sometimes it captures magic that adult books don’t.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
August 22, 2025
a great read. a mysterious garden full of statues. missing children that only people from outside the village remember.
fran is dreading visiting her cousin Imogen for the week, but on arriving discovers that her cousin doesn't actually seem to exist. no one seems to remember her at all. part of her is pleased, she couldn't stand Imogen, and is glad not to have to deal with her. but when she finds Imogen's room just as it was...and rumours of a strange garden...Fran decides to do some digging.
this was a fantastic story full of intrigue, clever ideas and a little bit of sadness.
I had a great time reading it and a hard time putting it down. I just wish it had been a tad longer. there were a few parts that I felt were hinted at but never happened. or they did, but it was so subtle that maybe younger readers wouldn't really get it (this happens right at the end, so I don't want to say much). it doesn't seem enough for a sequel, but I'd have liked just a few more chapters to wrap things up a bit better.
fran is dreading visiting her cousin Imogen for the week, but on arriving discovers that her cousin doesn't actually seem to exist. no one seems to remember her at all. part of her is pleased, she couldn't stand Imogen, and is glad not to have to deal with her. but when she finds Imogen's room just as it was...and rumours of a strange garden...Fran decides to do some digging.
this was a fantastic story full of intrigue, clever ideas and a little bit of sadness.
I had a great time reading it and a hard time putting it down. I just wish it had been a tad longer. there were a few parts that I felt were hinted at but never happened. or they did, but it was so subtle that maybe younger readers wouldn't really get it (this happens right at the end, so I don't want to say much). it doesn't seem enough for a sequel, but I'd have liked just a few more chapters to wrap things up a bit better.
November 11, 2025
An engaging book for middle-grades readers interested in mystery and fantasy! The chapters are short and very digestible. The characters were likable, though not thoroughly fleshed out (but for a short middle-grades book, it was good). The prose is very well written, making for a quick read that keeps the reader engaged and wanting to know what happens next. A large part of that is also the mystery itself -- for such a relatively simple plot, the mystery ended up being quite interesting.
The one thing I feel could've been handled better was a character who was briefly mentioned toward the end of the book and basically discarded from the story. This character has an interesting story that could have been explored in more depth while integrating them into their new community rather than having them conveniently just disappear from the story.
I enjoyed this book, and I think the ages ~8-12 middle-grades readers will, too.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the digital ARC.
The one thing I feel could've been handled better was a character who was briefly mentioned toward the end of the book and basically discarded from the story. This character has an interesting story that could have been explored in more depth while integrating them into their new community rather than having them conveniently just disappear from the story.
I enjoyed this book, and I think the ages ~8-12 middle-grades readers will, too.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the digital ARC.
January 25, 2026
This was a decent thriller of sorts for a younger audience. Sometimes, that difference doesn’t really matter and an adult can get the same enjoyment from it, this wasn’t one of those.
It’s not a bad story. It has its hair-raising moments as well as the suspense of a not-directly mentioned solution. It’s this last bit that is a kind of nod to the intelligence of children. The author does not over explain, which I felt was a good way to end things.
Fran is not happy to be visiting her cousin. They didn’t get along. But it surprises her when no one seems to even remember that Imogen existed. The scenes before Fran’s arrival are alternated with the history of the location and that is the foundation of all the secrets.
The book is written well, with characters with redeeming qualities. Even if they are not likeable or trustworthy to begin with, they improve with time and experience.
I would definitely recommend this book to younger audiences.
I received an ARC thanks to Netgalley and the publishers but the review is entirely based on my own reading experience.
It’s not a bad story. It has its hair-raising moments as well as the suspense of a not-directly mentioned solution. It’s this last bit that is a kind of nod to the intelligence of children. The author does not over explain, which I felt was a good way to end things.
Fran is not happy to be visiting her cousin. They didn’t get along. But it surprises her when no one seems to even remember that Imogen existed. The scenes before Fran’s arrival are alternated with the history of the location and that is the foundation of all the secrets.
The book is written well, with characters with redeeming qualities. Even if they are not likeable or trustworthy to begin with, they improve with time and experience.
I would definitely recommend this book to younger audiences.
I received an ARC thanks to Netgalley and the publishers but the review is entirely based on my own reading experience.
March 13, 2026
This middle-grade book is about a perplexed girl on a visit to her uncle and aunt's, as to why neither of them seem to acknowledge the existence of their own daughter, however much she dislikes this cousin.
Fran doesn't like her cousin but has to stay with her relatives while her parents go on an important work trip. When she arrives, her cousin is nowhere to be seen and her uncle and aunt behave as if she never existed, to the extent of claiming that her bedroom is in fact a store room. When Fran sneaks in, she discovers the bedroom as she remembers it, except everything is covered with a layer of dust, and a diary whose entries suddenly stopped on Sep 21.
I enjoyed how the author has brought the story together. In the first three chapters we see meet Fran and Imogen. In chapter four, we are introduced to an old story. Fran's story and this old legend is then told in alternating chapters, until we see the connection midway in the book. Cleverly written, as it kept me turning the pages to find out how the two stories merge, and then the resolution.
Thoroughly enjoyable.
Fran doesn't like her cousin but has to stay with her relatives while her parents go on an important work trip. When she arrives, her cousin is nowhere to be seen and her uncle and aunt behave as if she never existed, to the extent of claiming that her bedroom is in fact a store room. When Fran sneaks in, she discovers the bedroom as she remembers it, except everything is covered with a layer of dust, and a diary whose entries suddenly stopped on Sep 21.
I enjoyed how the author has brought the story together. In the first three chapters we see meet Fran and Imogen. In chapter four, we are introduced to an old story. Fran's story and this old legend is then told in alternating chapters, until we see the connection midway in the book. Cleverly written, as it kept me turning the pages to find out how the two stories merge, and then the resolution.
Thoroughly enjoyable.
September 13, 2025
I would have loved this book as a 10-year-old! It has mystery, an eerie secret garden, and a touch of magic.
The thread about magical statues brings a lovely echo of Narnia. I particularly enjoyed how the book weaves two stories together: a tale from long ago and the present-day adventures of three young girls.
In terms of the format, the short chapters and steady pace make it easy and fun to read. The rapid shifts between multiple points of view felt at times a little unnecessary, and I would have perhaps liked a more literary tone in the tale sections, contrasting more strongly with the modern story.
But overall, this is a delightful read for middle graders who enjoy stories of magic and friendship.
Thank you to Nosy Crow, NetGalley and author Kirsty Applebaum for the advance reader copy. This is my honest opinion of the book.
The thread about magical statues brings a lovely echo of Narnia. I particularly enjoyed how the book weaves two stories together: a tale from long ago and the present-day adventures of three young girls.
In terms of the format, the short chapters and steady pace make it easy and fun to read. The rapid shifts between multiple points of view felt at times a little unnecessary, and I would have perhaps liked a more literary tone in the tale sections, contrasting more strongly with the modern story.
But overall, this is a delightful read for middle graders who enjoy stories of magic and friendship.
Thank you to Nosy Crow, NetGalley and author Kirsty Applebaum for the advance reader copy. This is my honest opinion of the book.
November 24, 2025
When Fran is sent to stay with her Uncle and Aunt while her parents are away on a business trip, the thing she is least looking forward to is having to spend time with her annoying cousin Imogen. But when she arrives Imogen is not there and everyone seems to have forgotten that she exists at all. It all seems to have something to do with the mysterious hidden garden and sinister statues at Stillness Hall so she teams up with Imogen's friend Bex to investigate. (Even though Bex can't remember Imogen either.)
The story is constructed with fairy tale-style inserts that explain the origin of the curse in between the chapters of Fran's narrative. This is an engaging standalone, MG fantasy - pitched perfectly for Upper KS2.
The story is constructed with fairy tale-style inserts that explain the origin of the curse in between the chapters of Fran's narrative. This is an engaging standalone, MG fantasy - pitched perfectly for Upper KS2.
December 1, 2025
This was a sweet and surprisingly thoughtful exploration of friendship and bullying and being true to yourself. It was also a slightly creepy (in a good, middle-grade appropriate, way), with curses and lost children and the tragedy of being forgotten. The writing was easy to engage with - even though I'm not the target demographic, I can definitely see how the fast pace and descriptive-yet-not-flowery language would appeal to those who are - and the story reads very quickly.
For what it's worth, I would have liked to have seen some illustrations, given the evocative imagery - this would lend itself to a very cool graphic novel adaptation!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
For what it's worth, I would have liked to have seen some illustrations, given the evocative imagery - this would lend itself to a very cool graphic novel adaptation!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
August 18, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. It's not a genre I would usually read. I tend to stick more to realistic mysteries when it comes to middle grade books, but the dissappearance elements made me give it a shot anyways. I'm really glad it did. There was something quite magical about reading this book. At times I struggled a bit with the shifting POVs, but I'm glad they were included. I feel like the story wouldn't be half as great without them. I also really enjoyed the storyteller's chapters. It really made the whole book feel like a fairy tale
*I got an ARC through netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
*I got an ARC through netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
September 4, 2025
Fran is no fan of her cousin Imogen. Nor is she happy to be staying with her aunt and uncle's family.
But even she is worried when it seems that she is the only one who remembers her less-than-inviting cousin after lmogen mysteriously disappears. But how is it even possible that Imogen's parents and best friend could just forget about her?
And what is Fran to do when this apparently leaves the responsibility to do something firmly on her plate?
This is a mysterious and somewhat magical tale with echoes of classic stories from the past. It will appeal to a wide range of readers.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
But even she is worried when it seems that she is the only one who remembers her less-than-inviting cousin after lmogen mysteriously disappears. But how is it even possible that Imogen's parents and best friend could just forget about her?
And what is Fran to do when this apparently leaves the responsibility to do something firmly on her plate?
This is a mysterious and somewhat magical tale with echoes of classic stories from the past. It will appeal to a wide range of readers.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
May 5, 2026
I’ve read a few spooky middle grades recently, and this one has been the best. It’s a relatively quiet, gentle read, but you feel as if you’re in good hands with the author. The action starts straightaway, with an uncanny situation where Fran is dropped off to stay with her cousin Imogen, but she is nowhere to be found, and her uncle and aunt can’t remember who Imogen is!
The writing is simple yet evocative, with imaginative descriptions of the neighbourhood gardens.
Recommended for readers Aged 8-12 wanting a cozy horror or thriller.
Disclaimer: This book is published by my publisher, Nosy Crow, but this review is unsolicited and entirely my opinion.
The writing is simple yet evocative, with imaginative descriptions of the neighbourhood gardens.
Recommended for readers Aged 8-12 wanting a cozy horror or thriller.
Disclaimer: This book is published by my publisher, Nosy Crow, but this review is unsolicited and entirely my opinion.
August 10, 2025
Another gripping tale from Kirsty Applebaum. Fran is staying with her aunt and uncle for a week whilst Mum helps Dad with his work. But there's something strange going on as her cousin, Imogen, is nowhere to be seen and nobody remembers her, including Imogen's best friend, Bex. Fran is determined to find out what's going on ... and it involves the secret garden at Stillness Hall that everybody avoids.
A tense story with touches of menace and magic. Perfect for readers aged 9 - 12 years who love horror (thought not too scary) and mystery.
A tense story with touches of menace and magic. Perfect for readers aged 9 - 12 years who love horror (thought not too scary) and mystery.
February 22, 2026
WOW! I know Nosy Crow from their fantastic picture and board books. Turns out, their middle grade is amazing also. The interweaving of three stories with three points of view is no easy feat, and Applebaum pulls it off seamlessly. A very real story of evolving friendships, a spooky hidden garden, and an old bit of magic - I can't wait to hand this one to young readers who like a little bit of fantasy with their realistic fiction.
Looking forward to diving into the next Nosy Crow middle grade and so happy they have come to the US market.
Looking forward to diving into the next Nosy Crow middle grade and so happy they have come to the US market.
May 15, 2026
I wasn't aware this was a kids book when I got it, I hadn't read the back just the title. I had to Google what middle grader was but despite it being aged for 8-12 year olds it was an excellent book.
I loved how those who touch the statues turn into them returning one to life and replacing it with the toucher.
I would have liked to have known more about the powers that made people forget though.
I'd definitely recommend it but I'd question it for an 8 year old simple because of kids turning to stone.
I loved how those who touch the statues turn into them returning one to life and replacing it with the toucher.
I would have liked to have known more about the powers that made people forget though.
I'd definitely recommend it but I'd question it for an 8 year old simple because of kids turning to stone.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 11, 2025
Firstly, thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC
A brilliant book for younger readers who enjoy mystery. Fran Good goes on holiday to her aunt and uncles, but no one seems to remember her cousin. can Imogen find out what is going on and what has happened to her cousin Imogen. With the help of Bex, a girl from the road, they go in search of Imogen, but things dont go exactly to plan.
I hope there is a follow-up to this book, as it left me with so many questions!
A brilliant book for younger readers who enjoy mystery. Fran Good goes on holiday to her aunt and uncles, but no one seems to remember her cousin. can Imogen find out what is going on and what has happened to her cousin Imogen. With the help of Bex, a girl from the road, they go in search of Imogen, but things dont go exactly to plan.
I hope there is a follow-up to this book, as it left me with so many questions!
November 16, 2025
I would have loved this as a child/teen and even as an adult, I really enjoyed it. The plot was very easy to follow, the characters were written very well and it was very easy to differentiate between them. I appreciated that it was short and didn't drag on in unnecessary ways like a lot of books do. I do hope there is a sequel and if there is, I'd love to read it. If you're young or young at heart, I would highly recommend this one.
Thank you to Netgalley and Nosy Crow Inc for this eARC.
Thank you to Netgalley and Nosy Crow Inc for this eARC.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews