Nothing is stronger than the shield around Cerise's heart. Except Oberon's determination.
Cerise and her sister, Eirwen, live in a dying wood, cursed by the bones of a dead God. After a lifetime of neglect, abuses, and manipulations, she's learned it's safer to be alone. All that matters to Cerise now is survival, ensuring the curse doesn't bleed into the small, protected patch of land she calls home.
Cerise's false sense of security fractures when a mysterious stranger comes to her door, needing help tracking a necromancer who wants to revive the dead God. She soon discovers he’s a prince--an accomplice to the tragedies she and Eirwen suffered. But when a black bane seeps into her garden she knows she has no choice but to aid him.
On their quest, she finds the prince is more than he seems. A multi-talented man ablaze with compassion and purpose. Strong as mountains, yet gentle as the breeze. And he seems to have his eye on Cerise.
How much stalling there can be in a novella-sized book? The author made a bizarre choice of creating a protagonist who acts like a 3yo who says "no" to everything. No, I will not listen to you. No, I will not go there. No, I will not help you. No, I will not participate in this plot. And while a reluctant hero can work, usually in those cases the plot gives them no choice. They have to participate in the plot, grumbling and swearing, but they're quickly forced out of the door and the bridges burnt behind them. This is a second book within a month where there are chapters upon chapters of mc digging heels in and repeating "I just want my quaint ordinary life to continue", well, except in this one the life she has is also quite miserable.
It's probably "realistic" that after all the awful things that happened to her in the past, she has no appetite for more adventures and no hope she can turn her fate around, but this makes for a tragically boring read.
To add to it, the prose is overly descriptive, and the worldbuilding with all those different gods too much for such a short book. I swear every time I see a fantasy book with a lengthy glossary I already dread the situation where the author put all that effort into worldbuilding, so now the reader has to learn about all of it, whether it serves the story or crowds it. Especially when the story mostly takes place in a backwater corner of the world, so a lot of these worldbuilding elements are talked about rather than experienced.
Especially since this book seems to be a part of a multi-author anthology rather than a part of a series in the same world, so it's not like all that robust worldbuilding is established because it's needed for future installments.
I was wondering if there's at least something in this book that would change my initial impression for the better, but alas, the ending left me underwhelmed and the spice utilized one of my most hated, overdone line - this time it wasn't the dreaded "good girl", but close, it was mmc telling fmc "come for me", twice. Women's orgasms are not gifts to men, or some performance women need to show for men to applaud. Can we already retire this sexist line together with "you take me so well" or "you're so responsive". All those always read like the woman has sex to make the man pleased with her, rather than for her own pleasure.
I was recently reading another story with a fmc who believed she can't have her own sexual pleasure (Demon for a Knight) and in contrast, that one had the love interest coax the mc out of her shell in a way that didn't read like "I've heard the same stock lines 50 times before", I actually enjoyed the spicy scenes there.
In the end, I was very bored with this one. But at least the depiction of chronic pain and impact of past trauma felt like the author committed to it, it wasn't the kind of disability that's barely there for sympathy points, it affected the fmc significantly.
2.5 stars rounded up.
I've received the ARC thanks to Morgan Vayle's open call on instagram. I'm sharing my honest opinion as a voluntary review.
I really wanted to like this book but unfortunately, it missed the mark for me.
The amount of resistance and times the FMC said “no” in this annoyed me. She originally didn’t want to do anything but eventually gives in because if she didn’t the book wouldn’t have continued even thought to me, the common sense answer was “yes” or “go do the thing you’re resisting” in ever situation that happened.
I continued reading in hopes that I would change my mind about this story, unfortunately though this book just wasn’t for me.
**𝓝𝓞 𝓢𝓟𝓞𝓘𝓛𝓔𝓡𝓢** ⚜️𝔻𝕖𝕥𝕒𝕚𝕝𝕖𝕕 𝕣𝕖𝕧𝕚𝕖𝕨 𝕠𝕗- The Withering Wood by Morgan Vayle
⚜️ℝ𝕒𝕥𝕚𝕟𝕘𝕤- (out of 5 stars, my rating scale is at the end) * 📚 𝗦𝘁𝗼𝗿𝘆 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ * 🌡️ 𝗦𝗽𝗶𝗰𝗲 🌶️🌶️ / 5 -𝑐ℎ𝑒𝑐𝑘 𝑜𝑢𝑡 𝑚𝑦 𝐺𝑜𝑜𝑑𝑟𝑒𝑎𝑑𝑠 𝑠ℎ𝑒𝑙𝑣𝑒𝑠 𝑜𝑛 𝑚𝑦 𝑟𝑒𝑣𝑖𝑒𝑤 𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑑𝑒𝑡𝑎𝑖𝑙𝑒𝑑 𝑠𝑝𝑖𝑐𝑒 𝑚𝑖𝑐𝑟𝑜𝑡𝑟𝑜𝑝𝑒𝑠 * Which books have I also given this same rating? (𝑠𝑜 𝑦𝑜𝑢 𝑐𝑎𝑛 𝑐𝑜𝑚𝑝𝑎𝑟𝑒 𝑚𝑦 𝑠𝑡𝑦𝑙𝑒 𝑜𝑓 𝑟𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑡𝑜 𝑦𝑜𝑢𝑟 𝑜𝑤𝑛) 5⭐️ Fourth Wing / Bound by Inked Flame / Anathama / The Lies of Lena / Of Silver and Curses 5⭐️ Bitten / The Female / Quicksilver / Bride / Lights Out / A Bargain so Bloody 4⭐️ ACOTAR / Spellcaster / One Dark Window / From Blood and Ash / Phantasma / Butcher & Blackbird 3⭐️ We Who Will Die / The Wolf King / Daughter of No Worlds / The Ex Hex
⚜️𝕂𝕖𝕪 𝕀𝕟𝕗𝕠: * Genre- Fantasy Romance / Dark Fairytale Retelling * 📖 𝗣𝗮𝗴𝗲𝘀- 236 * 𝗣𝗢𝗩- Dual third person * 𝗥𝗲𝗹𝗲𝗮𝘀𝗲 𝗱𝗮𝘁𝗲- 22nd September 2026 * 𝗣𝗹𝗼𝘁 or 𝗖𝗵𝗮𝗿𝗮𝗰𝘁𝗲𝗿 driven? A Mix * 𝗦𝗲𝗿𝗶𝗲𝘀 𝗡𝗮𝗺𝗲 & 𝗕𝗼𝗼𝗸 𝗻𝗼- Romance Fairytale Retellings #6, a multi-author collection * 𝗔𝘃𝗮𝗶𝗹𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 on 𝗞𝗨? * 𝗣𝗮𝗰𝗲- Fast * 𝗠𝗲𝗺𝗼𝗿𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲? ✅ Yes * 𝐀𝐧𝐲 𝐑𝐞𝐩𝐫𝐞𝐬𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧? ✅ Chronic pain and PTSD representation. * ℳℴℴ𝒹𝓈; Adventurous, Emotional, Romantic, Magical, Dark, Tense, Foreboding, Trauma-heavy, Steamy, Hopeful, Haunting. * 𝒟𝒾𝒹 𝒾 ℯ𝓃𝒿ℴ𝓎 𝓉𝒽𝒾𝓈? ✅ Absolutely! I loved it. * 𝒲𝒾𝓁𝓁 𝒾 𝓇ℯ𝒶𝒹 𝓉ℎℯ 𝓃ℯ𝓍𝓉 𝒷ℴ𝕠𝕜 𝒾𝓃 𝓉𝒽𝒾𝓈 𝓈ℯ𝓇𝒾ℯ𝓈? There currently doesn’t appear to be a direct sequel, but I REALLY wish there was! * 𝒲ℴ𝓊𝓁𝒹 𝒾 𝓇ℯ𝒶𝒹 𝒶𝓃𝓎𝓉ℎ𝒾𝓃𝑔 ℯ𝓁𝓈ℯ 𝒷𝓎 𝓉𝒽𝒾𝓈 𝒶𝓊𝓉ℎℴ𝓇? ✅ Definitely. This was my kind of fantasy. * 𝖂𝖍𝖔 𝖜𝖔𝖚𝖑𝖉 𝖎 𝖗𝖊𝖈𝖔𝖒𝖎𝖓𝖉 𝖙𝖍𝖎𝓈 𝖙𝖔? Readers who love darker fairytale retellings, damaged but fiercely capable FMCs, chronic pain representation, gentle giant MMCs, eternal winter settings, necromancy, dead gods, forced proximity, hurt/comfort and fantasy romance that gives its heroine genuine scars rather than magically erasing what she’s survived.
⚜️𝕋ℝ𝕆ℙ𝔼𝕊 🧭 Quest ☯️ Religion/Deities 🪦 Horror Elements 🕯️ Forbidden/Dark Magic 🧩 Forced Proximity 💈 Banter 🏹 Bad Ass FMC 🤬 Feminine Rage 🐶 Reluctant Hero 👑 Spare Prince 🪓 Axe to Throat ❄️ Eternal Winter 💀 Necromancy 🖤 Stone-hearted FMC 🤍 Gentle Giant MMC 🌹 Snow-White and Rose-Red Retelling
✨ TᕼᗴᗰᗴՏ ✨ Survival • Trauma • Chronic pain • Sisterhood • Hope • Healing • War • Duty • Sacrifice • Trust • Vulnerability • Isolation • Learning to accept help • Living after survival • Love after trauma • Gods and mortality
📝Cliff Notes Review- I absolutely loved this, but my biggest complaint is that I wanted MORE. The fast pace, eternal winter, sisters surviving independently in the woods, chronic pain representation, dead gods, necromancy and Cerise/Oberon’s chemistry had me completely invested, but this world felt far too big for such a short book. I wanted the story to begin earlier so I could actually experience more of the war, history, gods and character relationships rather than meeting everyone after so much had already happened. A fantastic dark fairytale romantasy that felt more like the beginning of a series than a complete standalone to me.
😥 𝕎𝕙𝕪 𝕟𝕠 𝕗𝕚𝕧𝕖 𝕤𝕥𝕒𝕣𝕤? Quite simply: because I wanted a full novel. That’s actually a compliment disguised as criticism because I absolutely loved what Morgan Vayle created. My problem isn’t that there wasn’t enough happening. It’s that the world, characters and history were interesting enough that 236 pages didn’t feel remotely sufficient to explore them.
Before the story even starts we’re given pronunciation guides and information about the gods. Weirdly, that initially had the opposite effect on me than intended because I saw all that information and thought, Oh God, what have I signed myself up for? 😂 It made the world look extremely complicated before I’d even met anybody. And after reading I did wonder whether some of that information would have been better experienced through the story instead.
I wanted to begin earlier. Cerise has already lived through SO much by the time we meet her. There’s war, gods, necromancy, trauma, her former life as a Templar, her injury, chronic pain and the history that has shaped her relationship with the world. Eirwen has her own experiences too. There is clearly an enormous history behind the eternal winter and the dead god whose remains are poisoning the land.
I wanted to LIVE some of that rather than arrive afterwards.
There were also so many gods and Celestials that I never felt I’d completely grasped who everyone was, what their individual roles were or how the wider mythology worked. The foundations are clearly there. In fact, they feel surprisingly detailed. I just wanted the book itself to give them more room.
And then it ended!
I genuinely expected more because emotionally it didn’t feel like “and they lived happily ever after.” It felt like “right, brilliant, now we’re ready for book two.”
🌍 𝕎𝕠𝕣𝕝𝕕 𝕓𝕦𝕚𝕝𝕕𝕚𝕟𝕘, 𝕨𝕣𝕚𝕥𝕚𝕟𝕘 𝕒𝕟𝕕 𝕡𝕒𝕔𝕚𝕟𝕘: The setting was one of my favourite things about this book. The world feels wounded. A dead god has poisoned the land, winter has become permanent and Cerise and Eirwen have carved out this tiny existence for themselves in a dying forest. There’s something wonderfully atmospheric about two sisters simply surviving independently in the woods while the remnants of divine catastrophe rot around them.
I also loved the fast pace. This is one area where I disagree with some of the reviews finding it too rushed as an overall reading experience. I wasn’t bored and I didn’t feel as though I was slogging through endless descriptions waiting for something to happen. The story MOVES, and I really enjoyed that. But fast pacing and insufficient length aren’t necessarily the same problem.
I wanted it to move exactly as it did while simply having more story before and around it. Give me another 150 pages. Show me more history. Let me understand the gods properly. Give me more of the sisters. Let me understand Cerise before the story begins changing her. Expand the mythology and magic. Give the relationships more space. There is enough world here to support it.
That’s also why the opening reference material frustrated me slightly. The author clearly KNOWS this world. There’s obviously thought behind the mythology. I just wanted more of that knowledge woven naturally into the narrative rather than sitting outside it in explanatory pages.
The writing itself created some wonderfully vivid imagery, particularly around the poisoned forest and eternal winter. This feels like a world where survival has become ordinary, which made those warmer emotional moments stand out beautifully against all that cold.
🧝♂️ ℂ𝕙𝕒𝕣𝕒𝕔𝕥𝕖𝕣𝕤: Cerise was brilliant. She’s physically strong, mentally stubborn, protective and capable, but she’s also living with chronic pain and trauma that haven’t conveniently disappeared simply because she’s the heroine. I really appreciated that.
I am a disabled woman with chronic pain myself, and I really appreciated how her pain actually affects her life. Her past affects her decisions. She’s not given a disability for one emotional chapter before suddenly sprinting across the continent because the plot needs her to. She’s adapted around what happened to her and built a life where she feels some degree of control.
I also completely understood why she was reluctant to become involved again. Some readers may see her constant refusal as frustrating, but I thought it made sense. She’s already given enough. She’s survived war, injury and trauma and finally created this tiny patch of existence with her sister. Why WOULD she immediately volunteer when another man appears asking her to help save everybody again?
I loved the idea of these sisters building an independent life together in the woods, particularly because their different histories have shaped how they view hope and the world around them. Their relationship made the opening feel intimate despite the enormous fantasy world sitting outside their home.
And then there’s Oberon. Gentle giant + emotionally armoured FMC is apparently an extremely effective combination. He doesn’t need Cerise to become softer, weaker or less capable before he can love her. Her pain isn’t something that makes her less desirable and her independence isn’t treated like a personality defect he needs to correct. Their chemistry worked because he gradually found spaces between her defences rather than simply bulldozing through them.
I loved watching their emotional understanding develop alongside the attraction. Cerise doesn’t need somebody to rescue her. What she desperately needs is somebody capable of standing beside her without expecting her to carry absolutely everything herself.
🪧𝔽𝕚𝕟𝕒𝕝 𝕥𝕙𝕠𝕦𝕘𝕙𝕥𝕤:
The Withering Wood gave me almost everything I wanted except enough pages. I loved the fast pace, frozen dying world, two sisters surviving independently in the woods, Cerise’s strength and chronic pain representation, the necromancy, dead gods and her chemistry with Oberon.
My biggest criticism is actually born from how much I enjoyed it. This world felt bigger than the novella containing it. I wanted the story to begin earlier so I could experience more of Cerise’s history, the war, the gods, magic and relationships rather than arriving after so much had already happened. The ending also felt more like the door opening onto another story than a definitive HEA, so I desperately hope Morgan Vayle eventually returns to this world.
Loved it. In this book you meet Cerise (Fmc) who's protective and strong not just in a physical way but mentally as well. Battling chronic pain and trying to protect her sister but the land is unforgiving and the dying forrest is filled with the bones of a dead god. You'll have to read to find out more. The world building truly stood out to me in this novella with depth and description being written so vividly thats it hard to believe your not there. If you love a snow white retelling with magic that'll have you enthralled and shocked at the originality of it then this is the read for you. Highly Recommend! I got this book via the author and this is my voluntary review.
DNF @ 45% Am I missing something? These are all the tropes I copied from the form into my Notes app to keep track of my arcs: A tough-as-nails ex-Templar. He's the spare prince. Together, they must stop a dead God from rising. But surviving the cursed forest ahead may capture their hearts. Touch me and die · Axe to throat · One tent · Eternal Winter · Necromancy · Hurt/Comfort · Chronic Pain Rep · PTSD · Stone-hearted FMC · Gentle Giant MMC. With all those delicious menu, The Withering Wood should've been my next obsession. I love role reversal. I love opposites attract. Heck, even before reading this book, I told my bestie that I was craving a grumpy woman. While Cerise checked the vibe, the story left me so confused.
There were A LOT of names and places dropped randomly from chapter one, to the point where I felt like the characters were having fun on their own without bothering to include the readers. I felt like I was thrown into a second book without much explanation. Things had already happened, and most of them were simply mentioned instead of letting readers experience them alongside the characters. I literally had to visit Goodreads in the middle of reading because I thought there was a prequel or something.
On top of that, I also struggled with the writing. It was basically: something happened ☞ long monologue/brief flashback ☞ continue with what happened. Ofc, different authors have different writing styles, but this particular style is such a momentum killer for me. I'm lost. When I got to the part where the MCs planned their journey to hunt the villain together and it failed to make me excited, I knew I should stop.
*I received an advanced copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own*
This book just didn't hit the mark for me. I really like the premise of the story, and the author's writing was so descriptive it was easy to imagine the story. It all just felt too rushed (it is a very short book). I'm still confused on the lore in this world, there were so many gods and celestials introduced and I'm still not really sure what any of the deities actual purpose are, except that one exploded and cursed the world I guess. Cerise's back story and trauma could have really been heart wrenching and compelling, but it didn't get talked about in detail enough. The resolution was anticlimactic. I was also incredibly distracted by how many times the word "Beloved" was used. I really think if this book was longer so that Cerise's back story could be explored, more world building, and draw out the romance and main story more I would have enjoyed it more
This was almost a DNF for me, but I was eventually compelled enough by the story to come back to it and get through it. There was clearly so much work that went into the backstory and worldbuilding for this one. The world itself feels much bigger than this story, with enough history and mythology to support future stories with entirely different characters–which, at times, I found more exciting to think about than the story I was actually reading. I hope the author has plans to revisit this world, because it would be a shame not to continue utilizing something with such potential, and which was limited by the length and focus of this work.
Overall I found this story entertaining, but it fell a little flat–I felt a bit removed from the story. This was for a few reasons, the first of which is pacing. The narrative dragged in places, around plot points that were obviously inevitable, especially in the first two thirds of the story. When the story did move forward, it felt like it happened to further the romantic narrative arc, and happened when it was convenient for the author rather than when it was organic for the characters and plot. While foregrounding romance is understandable in this genre, I prefer when it feels like the rest of the plot is pivotal to the romance–when it’s what creates tension, forces character growth or change, challenges characters’ assumptions about each other, etc. In this story, some of those things did occur (e.g. there was tension because of forced proximity, assumptions were challenged) but the plot outside of the romance felt incidental, like the only thing moving the relationship forward was forced proximity, and many other plot details could have been changed without the romantic dynamic being affected. The rest of the plot felt as though it ran parallel to the romantic arc, rather than being interwoven with the romance.
I also felt that the prose didn't always seem in sync with the narrative, which kept me from really feeling immersed in the story. The picture painted of this place is one that is bleak, desperate, unforgiving. A world in steady decline with seemingly no hope of things getting easier. These characters are surrounded by hardship and death, but while reading it I rarely connected with a sense of darkness or desperation. The prose often felt too direct and expository to create much atmosphere; it told me what this world is like without making me feel like I’m actually inhabiting it.
That said, I did finish it, which speaks to how compelling I found the underlying premise and world. I just wish the execution had pulled me into that world as much as the ideas did.
Holy sh*t. THIS is what I want when I pick up a fantasy book.
Withering Wood grabbed me by the throat, dragged me into a world of magic, danger, impossible choices, and a winter that feels alive (brr). The prose in this book is stunning. I could TASTE this world. I could feel the frost in my bones and practically breathe the magic woven through every page. It has been a long time since I’ve read fantasy with this kind of lush, immersive language, and I forgot how much I missed getting completely lost in beautiful writing.
The world-building is incredible, but the characters are what made this book unputdownable. They don’t feel like fantasy tropes placed into a pretty setting. They feel like people who have existed long before we arrived, with histories, wounds, hopes, and fears that make them feel painfully real. I could see myself wanting to know these people if I somehow stumbled into this world (but also, pls no, necromancy is icky).
And Oberon. Oh, Oberon. The YEARNING.
This man looks at Cerise like she hung the goddamn moon, kicked a hole straight through it, and he would personally thank her if she decided to kick a hole through him too.
He is DOWN. BAD. The man is absolutely gone, and watching him be so completely devoted was delicious. Give me a prince who could probably destroy kingdoms but instead chooses to look at one woman like she is the entire universe (and kneel while doing it).
And Cerise? Now THAT is a FMC.
This woman is not a heroine because she is untouched by pain. She is a heroine because pain has tried to take everything from her and she keeps getting back up anyway (we love a stubborn woman lol). She carries devastating trauma and chronic pain, but neither becomes her entire identity. She's sharp, protective, and absolutely ruthless when it comes to the people she loves. She doesn’t need someone to save her. She needs someone to stand beside her, hand her a goddamn weapon, and remind her that she doesn’t have to carry everything alone.
I devoured this book in one sitting, and I have only one tiny complaint: I NEED MORE.
Thank you to Morgan Vayle for providing me with an ARC copy of Withering Wood. This review reflects my honest opinion, and now I will be patiently waiting for whatever comes next.
The Withering Wood is a Snow White and Rose Red retelling with refreshed depictions, clever twists, and wholesome characters. All the while keeping the world-building and cast sleek and uncluttered, Vayle gives us a glimpse of a world ill-suited for, but in dire need of fairy tales. The setting is one rarely depicted: a post-apocalyptic medieval fantasy era
Cerise is a retired veteran from the momentous wars with a necrotic god, who despite having been defeated, decided to take the world with it. The sun is blocked by a mauve canopy of clouds, plunging the earth into a perpetual toxic winter. While battling chronic pain due to her war injury, Cerise wants nothing else but to protect her sister and the little settlement they have carved for themselves in the decaying forest. She'll battle all trying to threaten her home: the spreading necrosis, a mysterious bear, a necromancing dwarf, or even the Lich God himself.
I love when a retelling manages to remain lyrical while still anchored in an original situation. Vayle employs the source material not as a foundation but as the key to her story; the story's spirit is completely her own, but the myth shines through like palimpsest's echoes. My memories of the story's archetypes were never disappointed, and yet the optics were renewed. This Rose-Red is strong and decisive, as though the cheerful and lively traits she would have had before the war have been roughed and buried. Her conflicts as an unsupported wounded veteran and her battles with reminders of her traumatic experiences were fairly depicted, bringing attention to a cause we know well. I especially connected to Cerise through her chronic pain, and appreciated how Vayle never let us forget how debilitating and constant her suffering is.
All in all, I adored this book. It's a short read, consider it an involved bedtime story. Despite the cold out there, it's full of warm and fuzzies.
Unfortunately I did have to DNF this and it wasn't done lightly. The book just wasn't for me. My 3 star rating was everything up to the 40% I stopped reading at.
However I will say, it has beautifully descriptive language and the author absolutely knows how to set a scene. I was captivated in the first 20% of the book, and it fell a little flat for me personally.
However it also made me want a bear 🐻
Thank you to the author for a copy of the ARC for my free review. This will certainly be a 5 star read for some people and I encourage everyone who thinks about reading this to check it out and decide for yourself :)
Spoiler review - to justify why I wanted to give 3 star, almost did 2.5.
I really wanted to enjoy the book, for a shorter novella, I struggled. I feel given everything was brought to the book it should not have been a novella. A lot of behind the scenes world building, without the actual world being given.
Part 1 and 2 were slow to me. I love the representation of the FMC being disabled, but one can only take so much "woe is me". Maybe if the format was laid so we went back in time to explain the pain better would it be fitting, like a glimpse each time. Instead we got the same thing, undead weighing her down, nothing more. I fully understand PTSD works differently for everyone, but for a book, in order to feel the connection better, an explanation is needed.
Part 3 and 4 picked up a lot, the tension between Cerise and Oberon was there, but something felt off, I am not sure what word to use to describe it. Just off. Once they finally got it over with and they went to battle basically, I had to reread because that felt disconnected.
Overall, it was not for me, but I am sure if some out there this would be a story for them.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Thank you to the author, Morgan Vayle, for providing me with an eARC of The Withering Wood.
3⭐️
Let's start with what I liked. I liked that the FMC is rough around the edges and described as not conventionally attractive, not petite, and strong. I appreciated the PTSD and chronic pain representation. The MMC is a golden retriever type. I love the romantic dynamic of a strong FMC with a damsel in distress MMC. This story and the world building were unique. Which leads me into what didn't work for me.
This book is novella length but the world the author was trying to build was so complex. It needed to be a full length novel. Also, this was marketed as a Snow White x Rose Red retelling and I thought I was familiar with these stories, but I am not seeing the connection to either. So I do feel a bit mislead.
I would love to see this fleshed out into a longer book. It would allow more insight into the backstory and lore that I think was needed to be more invested in the overall outcome of the characters
3.5⭐️ I would like to thank the author for this Advanced Reader copy.
I liked the premise of the book. The descriptions were so detailed and I liked the backstory the author created for each character.
Unfortunately, this book is too short to be this slow paced, in my opinion. I wish we got more of Cerise's back story and trauma because the descriptions were so good, I know that this would have made the book that much better.
I liked the relationships evolution and pace, I feel like even though their trip was approximately 2 weeks, it didn't feel too rushed. I wished Cerise got some more character development because she was so stubborn at first that I didn't really like nor understand her reactions. I feel like having had a better understanding of her past and how the curse actually started and got that bad would have elevated this read. It seems that maybe some important puzzle pieces stayed in the authors mind rather than were written in the story.
The withering word; a dark snow White and rose red retelling. After researching the Snow White & Red Rose story I can confirm that this is a retelling of that story. I would have liked to see both sisters get their respected partners though.
I was unsure why Ix-God was required to be used, I understand from the beginning of the book where the pronunciation guide that ix is basically used as the corrupted aspect of the gods. So an ix God is considered the evil gods, but I also didn't feel that it was required for the storytelling.
This was definitely a slow burn for me. I struggled with the first couple of chapters getting into the story, but once I got past the third chapter I really started to enjoy the book and I could visualise the characters and I was really enjoying the story and I wanted to read more.
The book definitely gets better as it goes on and there is just the right amount of spice for a book that is basically a novella with only 16 chapters.
The author did well with creating a retelling of a Brothers Grimm story in such a short amount of time and it is a good book and I did enjoy it. There were just some aspects that I was unsure of as I have mentioned above.
I do have to say my favourite character is the prince. I found his story arc the most interesting to learn about and it was refreshing seeing a main character that had green flags instead of red flags and was a genuine person who was looking out for the female main character.
This is a really good read. Absolutely love the book. This is the first time I've ever read anything by this author so I was really blown Away by everything in it. I love the fact that I could get lost in the book and it kept my attention and it was really really good.
Thank you again to Morgan for having me on her ARC team! I am so glad I got to read this one early. I am leaving this review completely for free and of my own thoughts and opinions.
I really vibed with this book. It had interesting world building, great chronic pain rep and a FMC I really was rooting for.
The premise of this story was interesting and I thought the world development and lore we got for a book that was only 192 pages was really good. I could have happily read more of this world and would love to know even more about its Gods and the war.
There was really well written chronic pain rep in this and some PTSD representation as well which added a lot of depth to the FMC and I really liked the way it adjusted how she interacted with the world and her sister.
Cerise was cold, harsh and slow to trust and I absolutely loved that. Her personality fit the backstory we were given for her perfectly and it made the slow softening of her towards the MMC Oberon all the sweeter.
Oberon was a gentle sweetheart and I loved him. A man who could have been spoilt and unwilling to try but instead pushed himself to learn and fight and do something. His little flirtations throughout were also so fun and had me smiling.
The romance, while a bit faster paced due to the length of the book, just really hit for me. The tender care he showed towards her was so sweet and the love declarations weren't really love declarations, more an expression of wanting the chance to learn all the intricate details of each other which to me hit even harder and was just perfect for these characters.
Over all I really enjoyed this read and definitely recommend it as a darker book that reads up quickly and would be great for the spooky season.
This is one of those stories that is rich in lore, where the author weaves a tale of mystery and a quest to defeat evil. It definitely gives a very nostalgic dark fairytale feel.
Cerise, our FMC, is still recovering from the horrors of war but also having to face evil trying to creep up on her doorstep. She and her sister, Eirwen, are trying to live a quiet life but nothing seems to never be that simple. They then encounter a bear and their lives change forever. I really loved the dynamic these three end up having in the first part of the book. It was interesting to see how different the sisters are, yet they both just love and care for each other so fiercely.
Then we are introduced to Oberon in the best way possible. I was giggling at this scene cause the man was just naked as could be 🤣. Oberon soon became such a fun character, he absolutely has no problem being bossed around by Cerise. If anything, he wants her to do it more 🤣. The banter between these two was super fun and I just wanted more! The spicy scenes between them were also blush worthy, I approved.
Of course the hunt to end the necromancer was an interesting part of the book, the lore behind it was also super intriguing. I could see this book being another hundred pages and I wouldn't be mad at it. I think some parts of the story were a bit rushed, but I enjoyed the overall plot. Cerise was an absolute bad*ss, and I really liked how the author addressed her chronic pain.
Definitely an interesting read, I really liked the characters, I just wanted more!!
So apparently my review got deleted (maybe in the new rating update) so posting again
Thank you to Morgan Vayle for providing an ARC copy. All thoughts about the book are my own.
Part 1: The book introduces the PTSD in the FMC immediately. This is done respectfully and, while prominent, is not done in a way that is an over-the-top caricature. I also enjoyed seeing the dichotomy in hope/belief that Cerise and Eirwen have due to their differences in experiences and backgrounds with the war. The whole part introduces the daily life and turns that on its head. The pacing was well done, though I wish we got a little more on the magic system of the world. I understand that this is a novella, so it didn’t hinder my reading at all, but I do wish there was maybe a little prologue or history section before the story begins to give a bit on how the magics of the gods and necromancy work, who can use one or the other, etc.
Part 2: This part contains the reveal of why the bear's eyes look familiar, and I do not like the fact that our FMC didn’t realize. There is a strong connection from the past that I do not find realistic for her not to recognize it. Not a problem overall with the story, but it really bothered me and felt like a huge inconsistency of the character. This inconsistency did taint the rest of my reading experience, especially because she has some chapters with so many references to vivid flashbacks and again references to the rarity of this eye color that I really felt like a poor character choice that could have just been fixed by giving the bear a different eye color. Beyond that, I did appreciate the pacing of this part. It allowed us as readers to start to feel the shift in their relationship and provide some tension. I appreciate that the author wasn’t afraid to allow the tension to exist and grow between them while they also could emotionally understand one another more.
Part 3 and Epilogue: This part held the bulk of the action. The pacing was well done, and I enjoyed the way everything the book was building toward finally came to its apex in a way that made sense. The payoff from the romance felt earned but not over the top. The change in Cerise didn’t feel completely realistic. She goes through some “what if” scenarios that would have never happened, and with how logical she is, these scenarios feel a little ridiculous and out of character. Other changes are much more realistic about her view, but this feels like another out-of-character moment that took me out of the story a bit. Overall though, I did like where this story ended and how it did not needlessly drag on further than it needed to bring closure. I think this novella had the makings to actually be a great novel in a series, and while I had some issues with characterization consistency, I think this was a good first step into fantasy that I hope Morgan sticks with.
Ok so I was privileged to be gifted the arc for whispering woods and as always I went in blind
I was very pleasantly surprised, not only is this a great and short fantasy read, featuring a badass FMC and a smoking hot MMc… but it is also amazingly deep and covers incredibly difficult topics like: ptsd, trauma, self worth based on self image and battle scars, and character growth beyond all of those things, and it covers them in a very beautiful and heartfelt way.
We see growth in the FMCs view of herself and the world and healing beginning in her mind and heart. We see her mind change as she experiences new perspectives and grows to trust people outside of her safe space.
Overall this is a really beautiful read, well written and touching. It’s also exciting and unique it’s its take on a post apocalyptic fantasy world!
I really enjoyed this read and will 100% be purchasing Morgan’s other books!
I'll be honest I forgot what this was about after I signed up for the ARC and while reading it...
It was slow at first and a lot of names thrown out. I did appreciate all the info that was in the beginning like names and places. I was actually surprised it had a pronunciation guide because normally I just shorten what it is to get through it.
Cersie and her sister live outside the cursed land with her making daily checks. Cersie was a warrior and fought in the war and was left with battle wounds. She comes home to see that her sister has let a bear in the house.
Unbeknownst to them, the bear isn't actually a bear, but Prince Oberon. Together, he and Cersie fight attractions and evil.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I have to read this book again as I read it too quickly the first time but I can provide a review. I loved the characters and the pace of the book. It was an easy read but again I read it too quickly so I have to read it again to enjoy the full aspect.
I received an ARC of The Withering Wood by Morgan Vayle, a Snow White and Rose Red retelling, and I absolutely loved it.
This may be a novella, but the real reason I finished it in two sittings is that I simply couldn’t look away.
Cerise, our FMC, is an absolute badass! She’s strong, unyielding, and fiercely protective. She carries a lifetime of trauma. She lives with chronic pain while fighting every day to protect her sister, the only person she cherishes in this godforsaken land. Together, they eke out a miserable existence in a dying forest overrun by the bones of a dead god. At Cerise’s side is Beloved, her specialized, magically imbued, double-headed battle-axe that stands as tall as she does. Beloved is practically a main character in her own right. Cerise uses her as a walking staff, a weapon, and a constant source of safety.
Morgan Vayle does an incredible job of bringing the dying woods and their bitter eternal cold to life. You can picture exactly what these characters are facing, and you feel how tenuous their survival and safety truly are.
Enter Oberon, our gentle and charming prince and total golden retriever MMC. He never tries to take advantage of Cerise or push past her boundaries. Instead, he quietly helps whenever she allows it. Slowly attempting to earn her trust. Their push and pull is so entertaining.
Cerise and Oberon must work together to kill a necromancer if they have any hope of stopping the spreading blight. The pacing is quick, the magic feels fresh and original, and I loved recognizing the parallels to the original fairy tales along the way.
This was beautifully written, imaginative, and completely absorbing. I loved it for exactly what it is: a fast-paced, magical novella with a fierce heroine and a sweet hero. 10/10 recommend!
This was an interesting read for sure. I initially picked it up because I love fairytale retellings and Snow White and Rose Red is such an underrated one despite being one of my favs so I had to read this one. Turns out, the writing and storyline was so good I practically inhaled it.
Cerise was such a breath of fresh air that she quickly became my favourite character. Altough I do find Oberon to be hilarious. I loved him so much from the start and how whipped he was for her. The trope "He fell first and harder" is for sure accurate. But I am here for it. Cerise is written in a way that makes you understand every single one of her decisions and you agree with her despite liking different characters or having different belives. It is incredible. But the entire world makes sense, feels rich, and the characters feel real as well. That being said, I need a book about Eirwen now too. She could be so interesting and deserves her story to have told too.
I wrote cold as one of the adjectives because I don't know how I can describe the athmosphere better. The way I had shivers going through my body despite it being warm here still was amazing. It just goes to show how well the novel is written.
I enjoyed this one very much and look forward to read more from Morgan - if every book feels like this, it will only be amazing.
There's something to be said about a novella that captures the feel of a fully fleshed out 800+ page fantasy novel. I don't know how Morgan did it, but The Withering Wood sucked me in and never let go until the very last page. And come to find out, this will not only be a series of interconnected standalones, but they will ALL remain novellas. Personally, I think this type of experience is what the Fantasy genre is missing and will bring more readers toward magical stories without the intimidating page count.
The story itself was wonderful! I'm still blown away that such DEEP connections could be forged in less than 200 pages. The chapters were longer, which I think still gave that intimate feel of a longer in depth fantasy. I will never, ever forget these characters and hope they make big appearances in what's coming. I'm in it for the long haul with these and can't wait for what's next!
I was provided an advanced reader copy for an honest review!
Thank you Morgan Vayle for allowing me to review this arc. These opinions are my own!
This is a nice short fantasy story with a little bit of spice thrown in it. If you are looking for a quick fix for your daily dose of fantasy, check this book out. It has some magic, little bit of action, little bit of heat and a HEA. You got a cursed prince and an ex-soldier that hates his family stuck on a mission to save the cursed lands together. What could possibly happen as they trek across the snow covered lands??
Hi everyone! The story’s protagonists are Cerise and Oberon. Cerise is strong, fiercely protective of her loved ones—especially her sister—and carries deep emotional pain. Oberon is helpful, kind, and generous. But there is also another character—one the likes of which I haven't encountered in any other book. That character is Beloved; she isn't human but an object—a weapon of war, an axe. As you can tell, we have unique world-building, a powerful story, and a plot that has it all. The author’s writing style is fast-paced, gripping, enjoyable, captivating, and enchanting.
Thank you to the author for an advanced copy! This is my honest review :)
It took me until the second chapter to get into this book but once I did, obsessed!
At under 200 pages, there is no wasted words, yet we still get a decent amount of world building and character back stories. Cerise is a grumpy bitch (I mean she has PTSD and has been fucked over by the world so I get it) but brave and strong and kind hearted underneath it all. Oberon is the best MMC, rugged and kind and supportive but funny and cool. The first chapter imo is a bit clunky - I feel like it forces too much about the bone forest when we don’t know enough to make sense, when it could be (and is) done in more detail over the next frw chapters. Once we got to chapter 2 the info and pacing and writing was perfect.
I believe this is a standalone book, and it’s short, it’s dark but also lighthearted in ways, so there’s no reason not to try it and many too :)
🌹 Snow White & Rose Red Retelling 👑 External Winter 🖤 Axe to Throat 🌹 One Tent 👑 Hurt/Comfort 🌹 Chronic Pain Rep 🖤 PTSD Rep 🌹 Black cat FMC x Golden Retriever MMC
Releasing September 22, 2026
My first look at this book I was honestly so excited because of how gorgeous the cover is and I really love the name Oberon. <3 Then I realized it was a Snow White and Red Rose retelling and when I said I consumed this book, I mean CONSUMED.
I loved getting to see the romance and adventure unfold. When the book ended I wanted a part two. This was the perfect little pick me up and you can totally read it in one day!
Thank you again so much to author Morgan Vayle for this exceptional read!