Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
LIVE

Nominee for the 2026 Goodreads Choice Awards

Vote for this book, or another nominee in Readers' Favorite Mystery & Thriller.

Dissection of a Murder

Rate this book
Nothing is as it seems—and no one is telling the truth—in this page-turning thriller about a young lawyer forced to defend a man on trial for murder against the mentor who taught her her husband.

When Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked by the a well-known, well-respected judge, whose death sent shockwaves through the legal community. She’s also incredulous—she’s nowhere near experienced enough to handle such a high-profile assignment—but the defendant is he wants her, and only her, to represent him.

Except he’s refusing to talk. And if that wasn’t complicated enough, Leila soon learns her opponent is the most ruthless prosecutor she’s ever her husband.

It’s an impossible situation, yet Leila is determined to sway the jury to her side—until she’s blindsided once again by a shadowy figure from her past. Suddenly, Leila finds herself fighting not only for her client and marriage, but also to keep her own secrets buried. And if she has to rewrite the rules to win, so be it.

410 pages, Hardcover

First published May 5, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jo Murray

4 books734 followers
Jo Murray grew up in Teesside, England, during the ’90s, when working-class girls were told they probably shouldn’t try to become barristers. Thankfully, she ignored everyone. After studying Classics at Newcastle University, she went to law school and was a criminal barrister before leaving the profession to look after her two children. She lives in North Yorkshire.

source: Amazon

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
19,475 (30%)
4 stars
30,091 (47%)
3 stars
11,643 (18%)
2 stars
1,960 (3%)
1 star
447 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 9,114 reviews
Profile Image for Nilufer Ozmekik.
3,282 reviews64.8k followers
January 23, 2026
My fellow bookworms… may I?
Can I officially introduce the best legal thriller of 2026?
🥁 Drum roll, please… 🥁
The crown goes to Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray.

From the very first page, I fell hard for Jo Murray’s razor-sharp writing style. The second I finished, I immediately started searching for her backlist—scrolling, refreshing, scrolling again—only to realize this was her first novel. And yes… I actually screamed. Because I need more Jo Murray thrillers in my life, immediately. She is now on my auto-approved author list, and I will read anything she writes next without even checking the blurb.
A dream for legal-thriller lovers

And here’s the fun twist:
The upcoming Presumed Innocent Season 2 adaptation is already rumored to be spectacular—but I genuinely believe this story may top it.
Yes, I’ll miss Jake Gyllenhaal terribly… but with Rachel Brosnahan, Matthew Rhys, and Courtney B. Vance joining the cast, this adaptation is already screaming Emmy bait.
Rachel as Leila Reynolds? Absolute perfection. Tell me she won’t eat that role alive.
But first—let’s give this novel the standing ovation it deserves.

What makes Dissection of a Murder so addictive?
This book has everything I want in a legal thriller:
⚖️ Sharp courtroom tension
🧩 A layered mystery
🔥 High emotional stakes
👀 Dual timelines and perspectives
🕵️ A chilling, anonymous watcher

The story unfolds through Leila Reynolds and the mysterious Witness X, whose intersecting narratives blend past and present in a way that never lets you relax.

Leila learned the law from her husband and mentor, Julian—a legendary attorney who shaped her career and pushed her to the top, even helping secure her place in the Legal 500. Their relationship is built on ambition, loyalty, and shared victories… until everything cracks.
Five years earlier, Leila defended Jack Miller, a man wrongfully convicted and imprisoned for two years. Now, Jack is accused of murdering Judge Anton Smythe—the very man who once sentenced him, while Jack’s foster mother was dying of cancer.
And Jack requests only one lawyer: Leila.
The problem?
Leila has never handled a criminal murder case.
And the prosecutor?
Her own husband.
Julian plays to win. And this time, he has no intention of letting Leila save her client.

A shadow watching from the dark…
As the case grows darker, a terrifying presence emerges.
Someone is watching Leila and Julian’s home.
Someone sends Julian a cryptic birthday gift.
Someone stalks Leila, trolls her online, and knows far too much.

Who is Witness X?
What are they hiding?
And how are they connected to Jack, the judge, and Leila’s past?
Every clue is a thread—and when they finally connect, the truth is more disturbing than anything Leila is ready to face.

“Nothing is ever black and white—especially when it comes to the law.”

Final Verdict
This novel is fast, relentless, and impossible to put down.

You will:
bite off your perfectly manicured nails,
forget to blink,
and gasp at every twist.

By the end, you’ll need a spa day to recover from the stress—and it will be completely worth it.
This isn’t just a five-star book.
This is sky-full-of-stars, whole-planet-level brilliant.
The best thriller I’ve read in years.
I laughed like Villanelle at the end—shocked, thrilled, and already desperate for more.

📚 Go get your copy.
I already ordered mine for a future reread.
Endless thanks to NetGalley and Dutton for sharing this absolute MASTERPIECE in exchange for my honest thoughts.
I truly appreciate it.

medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
Profile Image for Josh.
370 reviews347 followers
May 19, 2026
5/5 ★

It is going to be VERY hard to top this book on my favorite books of the year list because WOW I loved this.

It’s such a great feeling when you love a book so much that it reminds you why you love reading. This debut did that for me.


In Dissection of a Murder, young lawyer Leila Reynolds is forced to defend a murder suspect in a high-profile case against the ruthless prosecutor who knows her best: her husband. As secrets from her past resurface, Leila must fight for her client, her marriage, and the truth before everything she’s hidden is exposed.

I cannot believe this is a debut! Jo Murray is such a talented writer. This book reads like it was written by someone who has been releasing books for years.

The mystery was complex and the clues were perfectly plotted. The characters felt layered and real, and the tension, heartbreak, and passion for the case could be felt throughout the whole story.

Prior to this book, I thought courtroom legal thrillers were far from my type of book, but I left this one craving more of them. I especially found it interesting how the UK’s justice system is structured compared to the US. The fact that it was husband vs. wife made everything even more intense as the case became more and more competitive.

Leila was such a memorable protagonist and probably my favorite of the year. She has her flaws, but I haven’t felt such complex emotions for a character in a long time, which demonstrates just how well written this story was.

On top of the mystery being intense and the characters being complex and well developed, there are also MULTIPLE breathtaking twists. I was able to piece most of them together before they happened, but in a way that made me feel like a detective following the clues, not like they were obvious. I still had those jaw dropping moments I love when everything was actually revealed. I actually gasped on the last page when I saw how it ended.

Part of why I loved it so much could be that this was my introduction to the new subgenre of courtroom legal thrillers, as I mentioned, so the story arc felt very new to me and so well done.

I wish I could force everyone to drop what they are reading and read this book… it was that fast paced, intense, and gripping for me.

—

Follow my Bookstagram and Booktok for all things mystery, thriller, and horror novels!

instagram.com/joshxreads
tiktok.com/@joshxreads
Profile Image for MarilynW.
2,156 reviews4,886 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
March 18, 2026
Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray

So many moving parts in this story and it had my brain churning the entire time. We get several POVs and the POVs that stand out the most for me are those of Leila Reynolds and Witness X. Leila will be handling her first murder case and she has already defended the accused murderer for a lesser crime in the past. Witness X has things to say and most of those are about person from the past who turned out to be not what they first appeared to be. Then we get to see and hear the rumor mill that surrounds the lives of those high up in this world of law and order (or disorder) and have to wonder just how many reliable narrators exist in this world.

Leila's world is very likely to explode and bury her under the debris of that explosion. Not only is she defending the accused murderer of a well respected judge but the lawyer on the prosecuting side is none other than Leila's highly lauded husband, a man who was her mentor before he was her husband. Just what will this do to the marriage of Leila and Julian, a marriage that seems so near perfect to the outside world?

As if Leila's task isn't difficult enough, the accused, a man who started his life in crime at an early age, will not even speak up for himself at all. He won't say anything about what did or did not happen, he's not willing to give his side of the story. Leila will be going into court with nothing from the man she is defending and her husband is more than ready to destroy Leila and her client in court.

This is a book I didn't want to put down. I also had no idea who was doing what much of the time. The shocks and twists keep coming and they come all the way to the very end of the story. Plus, there is a bit where the reader is required to fill in a huge blank, not something I'm fond of doing, but if I must do so, then my opinion is set in stone because I've been given that option from Leila and the author. Be sure to check the reviews of Jayme, Ceecee, and DeAnn because the book makes for great discussion.

Publication May 7, 2026

Thank you to Dutton and NetGalley for this ARC.
Profile Image for Laura Lovesreading.
524 reviews3,800 followers
May 2, 2026
YOUR HONOUR… I OBJECT

Dissection of a Murder is a high-stakes legal thriller about Leila Reynolds, a barrister defending a client accused of murdering a respected judge. The case is complicated by a silent defendant, a prosecutor who is her husband, and her own hidden secrets.

Urghhhhhh! Listen I am not saying the high ratings for this book is wrong, I’m just saying… I don’t get it.

The beginning had me balls deep and I was super invested, but along the way I wanted to claw my eyes out! I was SOOOO BORED! Leila as a narrator was not doing it for me at all. I found her so uninteresting and somewhat idiotic. As a lawyer I promise you I would shit bricks if I found out she was the one defending me.

Now I don’t want to toot my own horn but that ‘twist’… I clocked it VERY early on! Is it a good twist… sure why not… but my main gripe of why it didn’t work for me will spoil the book!

I did enjoy the courtroom scenes! These always tend to be my favourite with legal thrillers, but everything outside of that was dull and somewhat dragged for me.

For me personally this would work better in a tv/ film adaptation. Not a bad book but the twist could have been executed better.



2.5 ⭐


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⋆。°✩pre read⋆。°✩
I hear this is the legal thriller of the year!?
I can’t wait to be the judge of that! 😏
I hope it delivers!
🖤💛❤️🖤
Profile Image for Jayme C (Brunetteslikebookstoo).
1,725 reviews5,120 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
March 18, 2026
This book is being ADAPTED FOR THE SECOND SEASON OF APPLE TV+’S PRESUMED INNOCENT, STARRING EMMY AWARD-WINNER RACHEL BROSNAHAN.

“ A jury consists of 12 persons, chosen to decide who has the best lawyer.” Robert Frost

AS ADVERTISED, this is a page-turning LEGAL THRILLER about a young Barrister named Leila Reynolds who has just been assigned her first murder case. It’s a case which is much more “high profile” than what she would have liked for her first-defending a man accused of killing a well respected judge.

But, it’s a career making case IF she can beat the odds, and WIN.

One additional challenge-It is being prosecuted by her much more experienced mentor-who is now HER HUSBAND.

But the defendant is insistent: he wants her, and only her, to represent him, as she had represented him in a case years prior.

So why is he refusing to talk?

Since he won’t tell Leila what really happened, she cannot plan a defense. She will be forced to fly by the seat of her pants and hope to sway the jury—by planting enough doubt in the Jurors minds and by delivering a great closing argument- All while being harassed by someone using the hashtag @JustAnotherDumbBlonde.

The book opens with a handy explanation of how the Criminal Justice system works in England and Wales, followed by the story which unfolds in 2️⃣ parts…

Part One (62%) THE ARREST counts down the days prior to the trial when Leila and Davina, the Solicitor she is working with discover evidence and build their defense.

Part Two (38%) is THE TRIAL

Both Parts also contain chapters from Witness X, who knows what really happened on the night in question.

AND, the revelations AFTER the trial ends were most definitely SURPRISING!

Although you WILL learn which Barrister was more persuasive or maybe just more likable, there is one thread left open ended which will be fun to debate with your Book Club or friends, as I was able to do with Marilyn, DeAnn and Ceecee.

Will make my FAVORITES list for 2026!

NOW AVAILABLE!

Thank You to Dutton for the gifted ARC provided through NetGalley. As always, these are my candid thoughts!
Profile Image for Maureen .
1,800 reviews7,523 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
January 10, 2026
When defence lawyer, Leila Reynolds, takes on her first murder case, it happens to be the murder of 56 year old highly respected High Court judge Anton Smythe.

The defendant, Jack Millman, asked for Leila specifically, but he refuses to talk or even inform her what his plea will be when the court case begins. Will he plead guilty or not guilty?

How on earth is she going to win this case in such circumstances. Leila knows that the ones she has to convince are the jury, and so begins the fight for the case of her professional life. The trouble is, she’s faced with a courtroom full of liars!

As legal thrillers go, this is right up there with the best of them. It’s clever, it’s twisty, it’s gripping, and had I not have guessed the main twist it would have been 5 stars all the way. Don’t let that put you off though, because this is definitely a must read!

*Thank you to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for an ARC in exchange for an honest unbiased review *
53 reviews22 followers
May 7, 2026
no it doesn’t work like that, you can’t have the unreliable narrator be so unreliable they’re lying to themselves. that’s insane. that’s not a plot twist, it’s just insane
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Joey R..
415 reviews1,014 followers
May 21, 2026
4.0 stars— I have been wanting to read “Dissection of a Murder” by Jo Murray as soon as I began seeing multiple 5 star reviews on Goodreads several weeks ago. The fact that the book is a legal thriller by a brand new author just added to my anticipation. The book is told from the perspective of Leila, a criminal barrister in England. I had to do a little research during the early chapters of this book in order to understand the differences between the criminal justice systems of the United States and England. The book begins with Leila agreeing to accept the appointment of representing a murder defendant, Jack, who is charged with murdering a local judge. The case is complicated further by the fact that the prosecutor assigned to the case is Julian, Leila’s husband. Leila basically learned how to practice law under the instruction of Julian who was her pupil-master until she was ready to practice on her own. Although technically allowed under limited circumstances in both countries, I wouldn’t want to try a case (especially one this high-profile) against my spouse. Needless to say the relationship of Julian and Leila is put under great strain as a result of their decision to face off in court. “Dissection” did take a while for me to get into. The first half of the book was very slow in my opinion with a lot of character building and drawn out scenes that I lost interest in quickly. However, at about the halfway point (coincidentally when the murder trial began 🤔), this book picked up major momentum. In fact, I couldn’t put it down for the final half of the book. The book was able to tie together the very interesting trial to an initially very boring stalker mystery in a plausible and interesting way. The conclusion of the book was also very nicely done (although not the biggest fan of unresolved plot points). The courtroom scenes themselves were a little sparse on details, but not everyone is as good at writing courtroom scenes as Scott Turow. I definitely would recommend this book— as the last half of the book more than makes up for the slow start. I look forward to reading Ms. Murray in the future if this is the kind of twisting and turning courtroom thriller she publishes in the future.
Profile Image for Karen.
3,013 reviews1,853 followers
May 30, 2026
“A jury consists of twelve persons chosen to decide who has the better lawyer.” – Robert Frost

The book begins with a clear understanding of working definitions of murder, the jury, solicitors and barristers, ending the explanation with the note that ‘this is how the criminal trial system works in England and Wales.’

“But not always.”

Which leads readers into a prologue that in first person narrative introduces the accused. Or does it?

“If this trial has taught you anything, ladies and gentlemen, it’s that not everything is as it seems.”

And that is truly the premise of this story. What readers think they know, think again. We are taken down a long, winding, twisting road that may confuse, bewilder, and manipulate us into believing one thing, only to discover something entirely different.

And then, the ending.

The question becomes: will readers enjoy the ride — or not? And, as is typical with murder mysteries packed with multiple plot twists, will justice ultimately prevail?

With unlikable characters and somewhat unreliable narrators, readers are left questioning what exactly they just witnessed — and whether the truth was ever really present to uncover in the first place.

Described as a ‘breathlessly compulsive courtroom drama with expertly crafted twists that readers won’t see coming,’ this debut novel will either completely capture readers or leave them feeling frustrated by its relentless misdirection.

For me, the verdict still feels undecided.

Because in the end, it will be all about the reader, anyway.

(No spoilers from me.)

Clearly this book has resonated with many readers, so I encourage you to read other reviews and see if it might work better for you.

⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 stars
Profile Image for Ira Perkins.
55 reviews794 followers
September 30, 2026
Inception meets Suits. Slick lawyers, a murder trial, and twist after twist that made me question everything. What a debut!

Overall rating: 4.25/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌘

Legal thrillers aren’t usually my thing. I picked up Dissection of a Murder because I’d heard it was full of twists, and a good twist is one of my favourite things in a novel. Jo Murray delivered. Every time I thought I’d worked out what was happening, boom, another layer came away and I had to think again.

It did take a while to grab me. The trial doesn’t really begin until roughly 60% of the way through, and I found some of the setup a bit plodding. But once the courtroom scenes began, this became impossible to put down. Bye bye sleep!

Plot Summary

Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case: a respected judge has been killed, and the accused man insists that she defend him. He also refuses to tell her what happened. Helpful.

And the prosecutor she’ll be facing? Her husband, who was also her mentor. As Leila prepares for trial, the book switches between her perspective and that of someone called Witness X. I spent much of it asking who Witness X was, what they were hiding, and how they fitted into everything Leila thought she knew.

“Nothing is ever black and white”

The twists: 5/5

This is where Murray got me. I’d form a theory, find a clue that seemed to support it, then have to throw the whole thing out when another layer was revealed. I think I guessed about six different identities for Witness X.

And the second half doesn’t rely on one big reveal. It hits you with twist after twist. I did guess one major twist before the reveal, which is always a slight bummer, but I didn’t get there straight away. There were plenty of other twists I completely missed. I had so much fun trying to keep up.

The courtroom: 4.75/5

This was the part I’d been waiting for. With so many lawyers involved, I never felt I could take anyone’s account entirely at face value. The arguments and manoeuvring in court gave me something to puzzle through while I tried to work out who was telling the truth.

“A jury consists of 12 persons chosen to decide who has the better lawyer.”

Robert Frost

That’s the Inception meets Suits feeling for me: layers being pulled back inside this slick, competitive lawyer world. Once the trial got going, I couldn’t leave it alone. This is probably one of the best courtroom thrillers I’ve read. Granted, I don’t read heaps of them, but still.

The characters: 3.25/5

I enjoyed trying to figure these people out much more than I enjoyed being around them. There’s a very Suits sort of energy to the good-looking, polished lawyers and their ambitions. Underneath all that slickness, quite a few of them made me feel a bit yuck. Maybe that was intentional. It certainly helped make everyone harder to trust.

Leila was the hardest one for me. She seemed very concerned with what people thought of her, and I never clicked with her outlook. Spending so much time in her head could have sunk the book for me. Instead, the twists kept pulling me past that discomfort. That’s how good the mystery was: I didn’t need to like Leila to desperately want to know what was going on.

Writing and pace: 4/5

The slow build is my biggest complaint. Murray spends a lot of time establishing the characters and atmosphere before getting to the courtroom material I loved. A few bits of dialogue made me cringe too, though that was minor.

Otherwise, the writing is really good, especially for a first novel. Keeping all these perspectives and secrets in play takes some doing. I can’t wait to see what Jo Murray comes up with next.

Why not 5 stars?

• The slow start: It took me too long to get hooked. The courtroom scenes only got going around the 60% mark.

• One guessed twist: I worked out a major reveal beforehand, though plenty of others caught me completely off guard.

• The company: I struggled to spend so much time with Leila and the other rather unlikeable lawyers.

Even with those complaints, I had a brilliant time once the case got moving. The twists kept overcoming things that might otherwise have put me off. Pretty incredible for a debut.

🔹 Who I’d recommend this to: 🔹 If you like courtroom drama that keeps you second-guessing what people tell you, give this a go. Be prepared for a slower build and a cast you may not warm to. For me, the trial and the layers of the mystery were well worth waiting for.

Adaptation note: Dissection of a Murder is set to be adapted as season two of Presumed Innocent. That really suits it. At times I felt as though I was reading a television series, and I’m especially curious to see what they do with the two perspectives and Witness X.

🔹 Other books I’d recommend alongside this: 🔹 For another thriller where you’re never quite sure whom to trust, try Gone Girl. And if you haven’t read Agatha Christie’s The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, go in blind. I’m saying nothing else about that one.

🔹 A question for you: 🔹 If you’ve read this, what else would you recommend me in the same vein?


************************************************************************************

Currently reading: Crime room drama that I've heard is a bit hard to figure out
Profile Image for Stacy.
375 reviews220 followers
July 23, 2026
Everyone is lying in this book, and I loved trying to figure out who was telling the truth.

Leila is assigned her first murder case to defend, but there's one major complication, she has to face off against her mentor, who also happens to be her husband.

The story is told from multiple points of view, which is a style I always enjoy because it adds depth and keeps the mystery unfolding.

Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the author threw in a twist I never saw coming.

I enjoyed this book
Profile Image for Ceecee .
2,953 reviews2,477 followers
December 27, 2025
What is justice? It probably means different things to different people. Will Judge Anton Smythe, 56, get justice for his murder? Is the tale of the prosecutor, Julian Kesler, tells at trial the true version of events or does the defence lawyer Leila Reynolds put across a robustly different interpretation that may lead to a not guilty verdict for Jack Millman? What is Jack’s definition of justice? This indeed is a dissection of a murder, but remember, don’t trust anyone, especially the lawyers.

Oh my goodness, where to start with this one, perhaps with I reluctantly put it down when real life intrudes. There are so many layers involved in this very definition of a legal thriller that makes it such a clever novel. The dynamics are off the charts, between Julian and Leila, Leila and the characters in Chambers, Leila and Jack and so on with excellent characterisation into the bargain. Leila is especially fascinating as to whether she’s likeable, you decide. There’s so much misogyny directed at Leila my blood boils. The least said about Julian the better but I’d love to wipe that arrogant smirk of his smooth veneer. There are some side characters and I become desperate to know what the story is there and the identity of one of the points of view is a tantalising puzzle.

The author creates an escalating air of threat and menace, a watchfulness that gives prickles at the back of the neck. There’s twist upon twist, whiplash like, making it a terrific thriller as I genuinely have no idea what’s going to implode/explode next. Add in the legal element and that makes it big winner for me.

What of the trial? It’s electric, riveting and totally enthralling. It’s suspenseful, tense and very dramatic and I’ll say no more as this is one courtroom thriller that begs to be read.

Overall, it’s very clever and creative, it’s well written and perfectly paced with several points of view which works so well, building the suspense and a pile of questions. It’s a cracker of a book which praise be, has a really good conclusion.

With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Pan Macmillan for the much appreciated early copy in return for an honest review.
6 reviews
May 9, 2026
You will never convince me that the first person narrator lying to themselves, and the reader, the entire time is a good twist. God what a waste of time I hate books like this so much
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Dutchie.
612 reviews206 followers
May 16, 2026
Uh oh. What I was hoping to be a really awesome courtroom drama kind of fell into the meh territory for me.

Leila has just been assigned her first murder case. The defendant is making it near impossible to give him a proper defense, and to make matters worse, the prosecutor is her husband. As evidence comes to light, it is clear this isn’t an open and shut case.

I don’t know why this didn’t work for me. I was having a hard time staying interested during the first part; however, once the second part hit it, it definitely gained momentum. I’ve also come to realize that I don’t like unnamed narrators thrown into the mix. It completely takes me out of the plot. I’ve read a few books recently that have used this plot device, and it just doesn’t work for me; this was no exception. As for the characters themselves, they kind of lacked depth. I never got a good feel for their intentions besides seeing how the trial would play out. Lastly, maybe I read too many thrillers, but the twist kind of just fell flat for me.

It’s possible I would have enjoyed this more had I not just read a really awesome courtroom drama by Kia Abdullah.

I’m obviously an outlier; almost all of my GR friends really enjoyed this one, so please check out their reviews.
Profile Image for suspenseisthrillingme.
1,155 reviews1,248 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
May 1, 2026
BANGER ALERT! BANGER ALERT!

WHAAAT?!? NO F***ING WAY!!! A twisty, page-turning, knockout of a debut, Dissection of a Murder had everything you could want in a binge-worthy novel. From the morally gray characters to the chess-like moves and cat-and-mouse games, it was a mind-blowing tale of murder, drama, intrigue, and well-plotted schemes. You see, not only were each of the characters multifaceted, complex, and true-to-life, but the story itself was fast-paced and propulsive as well as thought-provoking. Exploring power, revenge, justice, and love all while making me question right vs. wrong, it was a gripping psychological and legal thriller all rolled into one. Delivering both clever insight into human nature and high stakes courtroom drama, I was utterly blown away by this masterpiece of a novel. And that was before I even reached that last eye-popping page…

So what was the absolute best piece of this thriller? Well, beyond the legal setting, toxic relationships, and layers of dark secrets, there were a number of twists that hit just the right chords. You see, they had me shocked all the way down to my toes. Topped off by a perfectly timed climax with a plot-shifting reveal, it was still the *mic drop* move on the very last page that outdid all of the others in one single go. All in all, this deftly plotted tour de force has just been added to my favorite reads of the year. Emotionally charged and razor-sharp all while giving off an Anatomy of a Scandal-meets-The Silent Patient vibe, this is one book that’s guaranteed to live rent-free in my head for a very, VERY long time. After all, I not only ate up this banger of a novel in under twenty-four hours, but I’ve already added it to my must-reread pile. Rating of 5+++ stars.

SYNOPSIS:

When Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked by the victim: a well-known, well-respected judge, whose death sent shockwaves through the legal community. She’s also incredulous—she’s nowhere near experienced enough to handle such a high-profile assignment—but the defendant is insistent: he wants her, and only her, to represent him.

Except he’s refusing to talk. And if that wasn’t complicated enough, Leila soon learns her opponent is the most ruthless prosecutor she’s ever known: her husband.

It’s an impossible situation, yet Leila is determined to sway the jury—until she’s blindsided once again by a shadowy figure from her past. Suddenly, Leila finds herself fighting not only for her client and marriage, but also to keep her own secrets buried. And if she has to rewrite the rules to win, so be it.

Thank you Jo Murray and Dutton Books for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.

PUB DATE: May 5, 2026

Content warning: misogyny, sexism, dementia, stalking, gaslighting, blackmail, infidelity, violence, murder, alcoholism, toxic friendship/relationship, mention of: child abuse, pedophilia
Profile Image for Tina .
887 reviews843 followers
June 3, 2026
4.5 ⭐️
Wow! What a clever legal thriller and to think this is a DEBUT novel! It's going on my 2026 favourites.

Leila Reynolds is a young lawyer who's handed the case of a lifetime. A respected judge has been murdered and the accused is asking specifically to be defended by her. The only thing is he's not talking at all about what happened that night. On top of it all the prosecution is none other than Leila's very own husband and former mentor. He's known to be ruthless in the courtroom. Can Leila win this case against him?

The title is perfect for the story! I found this one so interesting and thrilling. It opens with an explanation about the legal system in England and Wales. It's then told in the POV of Leila and some chapters are told from the POV of Witness X. So much going on and no one to be trusted. I enjoyed all the side characters and especially the "in chambers" moments. This was one that really surprised. That ending? Ooh I liked it!

I've been told this book will be the basis for Season 2 of, "Presumed Innocent" on Apple TV. I can't wait to watch it.

Published May 5, 2026

Many thanks to NetGalley and Dutton Books for the Advance Reader's Copy.
Profile Image for Abbie Konnick.
174 reviews22k followers
July 13, 2026
This one was really interesting! It felt a little chaotic at the end, but I still think it all came together well and I enjoyed all the twists and turns!
Profile Image for Darcia Helle.
Author 31 books751 followers
May 18, 2026
I'm an outlier with an unpopular opinion on this one.

The premise intrigued me, and I enjoyed learning how different the UK legal system is from the US system. But I felt like pacing dragged, and the main character irked me with her constant whining.

People I know raved about the big twist, so I expected to be wowed. Well.. Rant ahead.



Anyway... clearly most readers aren't as irritated by the ploy as I am. So ignore me. Read this one if it appeals to you.

*Thanks to Dutton Books for the free eARC, provided via NetGalley.*
Profile Image for Val ⚓️ Shameless Handmaiden ⚓️.
2,198 reviews37.1k followers
July 27, 2026
4.5 Stars

I really like how the author laid this thing out. I did still manage to figure out the main twist, but wasn't one huuuuuuunnnndred percent sure until the very end. So bravo.

I feel like anything else I try to say about this book might err on the side of spoiler, so I will only say that I enjoyed Leila as our main protagonist. I loved the interspersed Witness X chapters. The rules. The slow unfolding of character history. The interesting things I learned about the British system of law.

I can see myself re-reading this again to see what jumps out. I will definitely read more from this author.
Profile Image for Darla.
5,277 reviews1,405 followers
September 17, 2026
This legal thriller had me thinking about Perry Mason in the best way.

I know that shows my age, but the drama in the courtroom was off the charts!

Why ALL the stars?

🌟The big reveals. They keep on coming. Nothing is as it seems.

🌟 Witness X. Who is she? That question kept me guessing as we met potential candidates.

🌟 Rule #1: Don't get caught. Witness X has eleven rules for her life. Will she or won't she?

🌟 Courtroom drama. The prep, execution, and aftermath of the defense were absolutely riveting.

🌟 I listened to this one and Joanne Froggatt did a great job bringing it to life. I took extra walks just so I could hear more.

Hand this one to fans of Alice Feeney and watch for the next read from Jo Murray.🤩
Profile Image for Rachel Hanes.
737 reviews1,274 followers
September 6, 2026
This was certainly a wild ride! I had fun with this book, and I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough to find out what was going to happen!

In this story, Leila Reynolds is a young lawyer who is given her first murder case. The victim is a well-respected judge, Anton Smythe. The defendant in this case only wanted Leila to represent him, and no one else. Not only is Leila already nervous to be taking on such a high-profile case, but her defendant refuses to speak about what happened the night of said case. And did I mention that the prosecutor for the case is her very experienced husband, Julian?! Julian taught Leila all the tricks of the trade, how will she ever go up against that? Will their marriage be able to survive such a public and high-profile murder case?

Throughout this story each chapter is the POV from Leila or Witness X. Witness X was there the night of judge Anton Smythe’s murder, and X has 12 rules that they follow in life. Did one of these rules get messed up along the way? Or will all of these rules play out in the end?

This has been a very popular book, and I can see why! I do recommend reading this book, and I hope that everyone has as much fun dissecting this murder as much I did!

BOTM, May 2026
Profile Image for Barbara .
2,022 reviews1,816 followers
June 25, 2026
Thank you to my Goodreads friends whose enthusiastic reviews piqued my interest in "Dissection of a Murder" by Jo Murray. It proved to be the perfect choice for our Road Trip Book Club with my husband. After several days on the road, we needed something riveting to carry us through the final 11-plus hours of driving, and this legal thriller delivered. An added bonus: the novel is being adapted for the second season of Apple TV's Presumed Innocent. I'll definitely be watching.

Leila Reynolds finds herself defending a man accused of murdering a highly respected judge while facing off against her own husband in court. He is a far more experienced barrister and, by Leila's own admission, the more naturally gifted legal mind. One fascinating aspect of the story is that, within the English legal system, a husband and wife can serve as opposing counsel without it constituting a conflict of interest.

Leila is an immensely relatable protagonist, particularly for women. Her struggles to balance career ambitions, marriage, and personal baggage feel authentic and compelling. As professional and personal challenges mount, the story becomes increasingly addictive. Leila's upbringing was far from idyllic, and through her narration we gradually learn how her difficult childhood and her father's teachings shaped her worldview.

The first-person perspective offers a fascinating glimpse into the legal profession--the strategy, manipulation, courtroom theatrics, and psychological maneuvering that occur behind the scenes. Watching Leila grow in confidence is deeply satisfying, though her increasingly risky decisions often leave the reader anxious about the consequences. Adding to the suspense, her client remains frustratingly silent, refusing to provide information that could help his own defense.

Interspersed throughout the novel are the "Witness X" chapters, which reveal the survival rules Leila's father taught her as a child. These sections are unsettling and haunting, prompting readers to wonder what kind of childhood could produce such lessons. Murray uses them masterfully to build dread and suspense while gradually unveiling clues about Leila's past and a mysterious figure who continues to cast a shadow over her life.

The audiobook is elevated by Joanne Froggatt's superb narration. She captures both the emotional vulnerability and steely determination of Leila, making an already engrossing story even more compelling.

My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed this thriller. While some readers have been dissatisfied with the ending, we found it absolutely fitting, and the perfect conclusion to a tense, intelligent, and thoroughly entertaining legal drama.

Profile Image for Helga  Martiros.
1,482 reviews651 followers
September 22, 2026
A fast-paced legal thriller that keeps you guessing till the end.
Honestly, I didn't even know this was a debut novel! I usually stay away from courtroom novels, as I don't have the patience to read about the procedures and legal jargon, but this one not only did not bore, but had good twists and turns. In short, I was entertained.
Profile Image for Rebecca.
640 reviews956 followers
July 5, 2026
“There are two sides to every story”

Murder mystery? Courtroom drama? Unreliable characters? Say less.

This was one of those books that had me constantly second guessing everyone. Just when I thought I had worked out what happened, another twist would appear and send me right back to square one. The courtroom elements added an extra layer of tension, and I loved trying to piece together the truth alongside the investigation.

The pacing was great, the stakes kept rising, and the question of guilt or innocence hung over every page. If you enjoy crime fiction that keeps you guessing and makes you play detective, this is definitely worth picking up.

I Highly Recommend!

4.5⭐️
Profile Image for Nina (ninjasbooks).
1,810 reviews2,065 followers
June 1, 2026
Now this was something else. Something delicious and intriguing. A new flavor in a sea of familiar tastes, one that stood out. It helps that it was already one of my favorite tastes, legal thrillers when done well always makes me very enthusiastic. And this one made
me so excited I could have run a marathon on the adrenaline it created. And the twist.
Well.
This. Is. The. Mother. Of. All. Twists.

Read it for yourself, and maybe you’ll discover a new favorite flavor as well.
Profile Image for L A.
904 reviews399 followers
May 16, 2026
"Nothing is as it seems—and no one is telling the truth—in this page-turning thriller about a young lawyer forced to defend a man on trial for murder against the mentor who taught her everything: her husband."

Leila Reynolds has been assigned to her first murder case. The victim was a well-respected judge, Anton Smythe. The defendant is Jack, which she has defended before and he wants her to represent him again. The prosecutor is her husband Julian. He is handsome and well-known in the courtroom. This takes place in Durham, England. It has to be one of the best legal thrillers I've read and will be tops in 2026. No way that it could be a debut, but the author has plenty of experience with trials as a barrister herself. This is also the continuation of Presumed Innocent on Apple TV.
This kept me on the edge and heart pacing wildly. The most irritating part is the gender inequality towards Leila in the courtroom even with her own husband underscoring her. While the case is incredibly real, tensions soar and Leila's personal life is on trial. Someone from her past is lurking in the shadows as well as alternating chapters with an anonymous witness.
This is crazy good and I'm lost without it because this is all I have thought about. Don't miss this one!! Great job to the author.
Thank you NetGalley and Dutton for this incredible ARC in exchange for my own review.
Profile Image for Francesca (pavisfrancesca).
410 reviews8,035 followers
June 8, 2026
Y'all were right about this one. If you love a twist you will LOVE this.

This author took a simple legal thriller plot and made it into something generational, hell yes
Profile Image for NILTON TEIXEIRA.
1,390 reviews718 followers
May 27, 2026
“Dissection of a Murder”, by Jo Murray

3 stars ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

I was expecting to love this book. Some of my friends loved it and claimed that this is the best book they have read that included an unreliable narrator. I take it that they have never read “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd”, by Agatha Christie, which in my opinion is a masterclass in mystery that revolutionized the genre by using a highly deceptive narrator.

Anyways…

In the beginning I had the impression that I had read a similar story or watched a movie or tv show that had the same kind of premise. But I could be wrong about this.

Although I liked the concept and the development of the story, I found the writing to be very pedestrian, with very weak dialogues. I wasn’t sure if I was going to be able to finish it, but when I was at 15% I predicted the major twist and I had to continue reading just to prove me wrong. But I wasn’t.

There were some interesting scenes, but i was really looking forward to reading about the trial, which stars after 63% in the book. It was a long wait. Some parts did drag on for too long.

As for the trial, I didn’t think it was that thrilling or spectacular. There were some good points, but nothing that I could say was extraordinary.

The conclusion was extremely disappointing. A cheap trick that didn’t sit well with me, but I won’t explain why I didn’t like it, as it would spoil the experience. But my ratings are based only on the writing and concept, and not because I did not like the ending.

Anyways, in general it wasn’t a bad read. I was entertained and it was a fast read.

E-book (Kobo): 416 pages (default), 110k words, 73 chapters
Profile Image for Holly  B .
985 reviews3,116 followers
September 5, 2026
"Nothing is ever black and white."

A married couple, both lawyers, up against each other in the courtroom. It is Leila Reynold's first murder trial and she has been hired for the defence. Her husband, Julian, the most ruthless prosecutor she has ever known, also experienced.

This made for a great legal thriller with some anonymous chapters from a Witness X, some characters highly skilled in manipulation, an intense emotional chess game and plenty of dirty little secrets!

The final verdict, completely unexpected!

Published in May 2026

Profile Image for Jayne.
1,192 reviews831 followers
May 27, 2026


Meticulously performed dissections can be unsettling as layers are stripped away to vividly expose hidden inner workings.

➡️ SCALPELS, PLEASE!!!!
Let’s dissect what went right and what went wrong with this legal thriller.

➡️ THE ANATOMY OF WHAT WORKED
🔷 A Brilliant Premise: A female barrister is handed her first high-stakes murder case, only to realize her courtroom opponent is the most ruthless prosecutor she’s ever known: her husband. The domestic-meets-legal tension was ultra-compelling.
🔷 Sensational Courtroom Drama: The closing testimonies and legal battles were electric. Because the author is a former barrister, the legal details, procedures, and courtroom atmosphere felt authentic and sharp.
🔷 Unreliable Narrators: Mark this book as "reliable" for its gripping portrayal of unreliable narrators. I dare you to guess whose testimony is truthful.

➡️ WHERE THE DISSECTION FALTERED
🔷 Uneven Pacing: The book's slow, repetitive start took too long to build momentum.
🔷 Too Many Unbelievable Shocking Twists in Rapid Succession:
Once the book reached its final 25%, the narrative shifted into hyperdrive, delivering a dizzying barrage of "whiplash" shocking twists that felt more eye-rolling than earned.
🔷 "Witness X" Needed A Scapel. The alternating "Witness X" POVs did not work. Removing this POV and using a different strategy to add the "Witness X" reveal would have significantly helped the pacing.

I listened to the audiobook, expertly narrated by Joanne Froggatt. Her performance was outstanding—carrying the listener through the slower chapters and bringing genuine gravitas to the courtroom scenes.

➡️ THE VERDICT:
A highly impressive debut with top-tier legal realism, held back by uneven pacing and too many eye-rolling moments.

3.5 Stars, Rounded Up.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 9,114 reviews