There are certain stories that I just have to read every adaptation I can get my hands on; Pride & Prejudice is one of those stories. I won't lie, this tendency has burned me before, but I can't escape it. So, I bought this, because I couldn't not. And honestly, I wasn't expecting much. Ok, fine. I went in telling myself it's a *variation*, take it all with a mountain of salt. And then, I started reading and... I couldn't stop.
Let's not tell anyone how late I stayed up finishing this, because it would be embarrassing. Let's also not tell anyone how many times I said things, out loud, like a crazy person. "This author really gets Jane Austen! She understands! She's read Pride & Prejudice more than once. Oh, is she an actual, honest to goodness fan or what?" Let's also not mention that I might've wiped away a stray tear or two because it was so clearly a creation borne out of love for Pride and Prejudice. And, if anything gets me, it's when someone loves something I love too and then creates something to show that love.
This author gets Pride and Prejudice. Honestly, better that some expensive film adaptations. (Not even kidding.) This author gets the characters. The time period. The heart of the book. It's all in there. It's pretty amazing. I lost track of the number of times I wanted to just high five her and then ask if she'd do another one. Emma? Please?
She doesn't rewrite Pride & Prejudice or readapt it. She takes these timeless characters and this timeless love story and asks, "What if a couple of things were a little different?" and answers that question beautifully. It feels like Lizzy, it feels like Darcy. The plot feels plausible and the characters behave in a way that makes sense for the changes to the plot, while remaining true characters we love. It also feels quite historically accurate. It was a joy to read and to appreciate Pride & Prejudice in a different way. A joy to see some of my favorite literary characters portrayed so well. For example, I really loved how Wickham was handled, I definitely think that's how Lizzy would have responded to him, had she not been prejudiced against Darcy.
I know what you're thinking, if it's so great... Why the four stars, hmmm? Hmmmm? Well, there are a couple of tiny quibbles. *Tiny.* Some phrases are repeated throughout the book: "batted her stubby lashes at him" being one and there are a couple writing weaknesses. There's also some confusion for me about exactly where Bingley fits in the social scale. Is he in trade? Is he not in trade? If he's in trade, why is he hanging with Darcy? Also, the author uses some creative liberties with secondary characters. (I didn't remove a star for this, because I didn't mind at all, but, you know, the more you know.)
Tldr? I really enjoyed this. I wish more adaptations of my favorite stories were done this well. It is clear that the author loves and knows Pride & Prejudice and honored it with a fun, creative take on the classic tale.