I imagine that books like these must have been the late 19th century equivalent of well-directed, well-acted action movies in our times. They might be entertaining, you might even be excited at times, but you won’t remain with a lasting sense of value.
Just like an action movie, this lacks depth on all fronts. The villain is hardly fleshed out. There is little to no psychological insight into any of the characters (of which you could, on the other hand, argue that it is more true to life; although I don’t deny there’s people with deep understanding of human nature, most of the time we won’t know more than we directly experience). The pace is a bit off (it was a slow start, and the point before the last 20 pages or so seemed like a proper finale). It’s unnecessarily descriptive, adding little to narrative or setting, with many aspects repeated to boredom (the ship’s position on the charts, the size of the ships, etc.) And, of course, it has a happy ending.
But, I did like the fact that it was adventurous. It’s nice to have read something from the ‘adventure novel’ genre now. I don’t think I’ve ever done that before, at least not consciously so. However, this does remind me of my childhood years, reading my uncle’s old series of Arendsoog (Eagle’s Eye) books; a series about Native Americans and cowboys. That might be comparable, although not strictly of the ‘adventure novel’ kind; after all, it hardly considered travel.
Nice read, but not an author I’m likely to return to. Reminds me of George Simenon, the Belgian detective story writer, in a way. Both have the acumen to write a compelling story (Simenon grasped me more, as his work is more concerned with the human condition), but they just don’t leave much of a lasting impact. However, they are both nice reads if you don’t feel up to proper literary work, but don’t want to degrade to complete stupidity either.
It is, also, an interesting view into those times.
Somewhere between 3,5 and 4 stars, mainly for historical significance.
Edit: Reading only a bit about Verne’s historical significance in his Goodreads author profile does shine a new light of interest on his work; as a father of science fiction, writing about many kinds of travel that were not yet possible in his time. I do have to admit that I was struck by this work being written decades before the Titanic embarked on its ill-fated journey.
Edit 2: Reflecting on what I wrote down here makes me realise that this is the very first time I’m concerned with these structural aspects of a text (pacing, repetition, setting, etcetera). That actually says a lot about the books I read, and perhaps quite a bit about myself, too. I’ve simply hardly read books where I was concerned with this most basic of aspects of a properly written text. I had a first premonition of it during my read of Brave New World, which I did not consider especially literarily appealing, although it was — by and large — structurally sound, but appreciated mainly for its idea expressed. But it might also be that I simply have a very strong tendency towards the deeply introspective texts, and much less so to the more environmentally, story and narrative focussed texts.