Rating: minus 25. On a scale of minus 15 to plus 5.
It is sometimes more difficult to generate the needed enthusiasm to rewrite a review than to write a new.
Before I continue, I need a YouTube visit. This was made possible by Doctor Who/Be Kind, NCMI, Sarah Paine, Keffals, Suchomimus, LuckyBlackCat, RevolutionarythOt, Terrible Writing Advice, Red Glasgow, Hindustan Times, Owen Jones, Bernadette Banner, Nomadic Crobot, Kayla Says, Verilybitchie, The Interesting Times, Welcome to Ukraine, Savannah Brown, Philosophy Tube, Media is Fay, Not Even Emily, Ponderful,
I've Had It, History with Kayleigh, Sailing Melody, Ship Happens, Discourse Minis, The Ministry of Miniatures, Ukraine Calling, The Kavernacle, Perun, Mandy, KernowDamo, Dr Fatima, Lady Knight the Brave, Ash L G, Abby Cox, Engineering with Rosie, Your True Shelf, The Closet Historian, New Enlightenment with Ashley, The Welsh Viking, The Bands of HM Royal Marines, History of Everything, Lisandra Vazquez, Anark,
Jabzy, The How and Why of Mathematics, Jess of the Shire, SK Media, Foster on the Spectrum, Hello Future Me, Amie's Literary Empire, Amanda the Jedi, Friendly Space Ninja, Squire, Kings and Generals, Anna from Ukraine, The Shades of Orange, Delamer, OrangeRiver, Bookslike Whoa, Jessie Gender, Dropkick Murphys, Sally's economics, The Gaze, Vlad Vexler, Crow Caller, Supertanskiii, Oliver Lugg. Biz, Reese Waters.
I recently saw that a member of the Morons Are Great Americans, who whilst insulting an essayist, complain to her that I listed other trans creators. The plague of Snowflakes (nasty, self-important, US white man-babies) continues unabated. A trigger warning then.
The channels I mention include architect, farmer, blond, bi, socialist, Kenyan, tall, mathematician, intersex, military historian, archaeologist, het, musician, cosplayer, social historian, lesbian, German, older, military boardgamer, culture critic, lumber mill family, trans, book reviewer, redhaired, artist, married, asexual, WOC, communist, mathematician, cis, sewist, primatologist, modeller, Swedish, queer, photographer, theoretical physicist and other creators known as Women.
Almost as damaging to the limited reference group are channels hosted by the wood worker, neurodivergent, Canadian, chemist, astrophysicist, fashion historian, particle physicist, other BIPOC, linguist, fashion historian, other LGBTQI+, Irish, book critic, architect, hobbyist, older, anarchist, artist, comedian, short, film reviewer, Ukrainian, fantasy gamer and other creators known (outside the USA) as Human Beings.
Should the voices demand a visit to any of these, I suggest emergency therapy, adoption of a hobby such as reading or a visit to the nearest Taoist monastery.
Continuing to mock these idiots is tiring. Fortunately I remember the early days interview with a middle aged Ukrainian teacher who organised and led her civilian anti-tank team in hunting Russian armour north of Kyiv. In the face of their example, I can not but continue. Glory to Ukraine. Glory to the Heroes. Crimea is Ukraine.
This book is one of the best examples of bad writing, which ever I have read.
There is no worldbuilding. This book was a major effort to finish but that was early days on Amazon and I had not yet decided to bin rubbish. I have not finished a book as bad for more than three years. I also have not DNF'd so many titles ever.
Prior to their invasion, aliens build huge towers on seven mountains on earth as the backbone of the broadcast power network to be used by their invasion army. No satellite, government or other noticed.
Rather than mine the Oort Cloud and the Kuiper Belt, they may have decided that they would invade Earth because gas and ice giants are boring.
They land an army despite their super technology. which includes strange rays to drain all moisture from humans. The aliens seemed not to notice the oceans.
There are only two nations on Earth., China and the USA. Fortunately for the aliens, a dozen or so super US mercenaries destroyed the Chinese state.
The US military consist of branches of New Tech Corporation. Clever naming that. How they generated a profit from that ownership escaped me. That the US Marines were not part of New Tech was not explained.
A PhD heading a government base personally leads raids and scouting expeditions against the super advanced aliens, as one would expect. Not.
That concludes my observations of unbelievable plot, characters with less definition than video avatars, plot holes galore, dialogue worthy of a ten year old and more or perhaps less.
Have earned another visit to the YouTube. This next is courtesy of Doctor Who/Where I Stand, is Where I Fall, NCMI, SK Media, Scaredketchup, The Juice Media, Agro Squirrel Narrates, Emma Thorne, The British Museum, Jake Broe, Honest Government Ads, Anna from Ukraine, World Anvil Worldbuilding, Reads with Rachel, Tale Foundry, Eileen, Books and Lala, Jessie Gender, ThePrimeChronus, The Pioneer, Cindy's Villa, Steve Shives,
The New Enlightenment with Ashley, The Confused Adipose, Kozak Muzon, Autumn's Boutique, A Life of Lit, Jean's Thoughts, Abbie Emmons, Bobbing Along, Ship Happens, Dust, Ukraine Calling Me, A Confused Brit, Cruising Alba, Philosophy Tube, Simply Christine, Hannah's Books, FAFO, Acollierastro, Elina Charatsidou, Daisy Viktoria, Mom on the Spectrum, The Dadvocate, The Chloe Connection, Jay Reed, FunkyFrogBait,
Raptor Chatter, Hoots, Smack the Pony, May, Riverboat Jack, Kirkpattiecake, Up and Atom, Verilybitchie, Physics Girl, CBC News, Planarwalker, Terrible Writing Advice, SciFi Odyssey, Gutsick Gibbon, TIKHistory, Chloe Daniels, Jay Exci, Raw News and Politics, France 24, Daily Live, Mynameismarines, Purple Ella, Fran Blanche,
Zoe Gardner, Jack Edwards, The Institute of Art and Ideas, Emancipation Media, Lindsay Nikole, Warthog Defence, Lee Francis, Naughty Nana DUZ, Barry's Economics, Strange Lucidity, Betty on a Boat, Times Radio.
This was an example of the worst of low end US science fiction. There are three publisher standards - No Effort, Pathetic and Godawful. Kindle loans provide a broad selection of each.
I began visiting YouTube a bit more than two years ago in search of science fiction film and TV commentary. There were a surprising number of channels devoted to the genre, which led me to the lifestyle, documentary, hobbyist and essayist channels. My last but most gratifying discovery was that of the book tube. 😍 The channels host communities of thoughtful, curious and courteous readers in love with the entirety of the world of books.
I promise the environment is opposite to whatever Goodreads are. The essayist and other educational channels carry sponsorship of dedicated educational sites, of which Nebula is my favourite.
Another YouTube break. This next is made possible by Doctor Who/Never Cruel or Cowardly -Ozar, NCMI, Deerstalker Pictures, Andrewism, Ben and Emily, Horses, Female Warriors - Teresatessa, Kris Atomic, Yarmak, Alice Cappelle, Owen Jones, AllShorts, WokeGardener, Lindsay Ellis, Mia Asano, Leeja Miller, Snappy Dragon, Karolina Zebrowska, J. Draper, Shannon Makes, Engineering Knits, Anne Applebaum,
kgb detected, Leena Norms, Camper Vibe, Cindy's Villa, NFKRZ, Lily Simpson, Aid Thompsin, Anka Daily News, Cruising the Cut, Ben and Emily, Nomadic Crobot, Diary of an unusual Life, Ruby Granger, Duo Vagari, How To Do Stuff, ThatDaneshGuy, Tabithaspeakspolitics, Hardy's Books, Books and Things, HBomberGuy, Political CUSTARD, May, Nicole Chilaka-Ukpo, Activist Witch, Diary of a Ditch Witch,
Marianne Williamson, JohnTheDuncan, WhoCulture, Fit 2B Read, Book Furnace, Gary's Economics, Lurie Daniel Favors, Roisin's Reading, Cheri Jacobus, Lena Down Under, Ember Green, The Dice Keep, Legendary Tactics, Smitty's Game Table, Mark's Game Room, Scotland History Tours, Battle Guide, Invicta, Hawk's podcasts, Brandon Fisichella, Kazachka, Strange Aeons, sidneymorss, It ain't half hot mum,
Planarwalker, Up and Atom, Physics Girl, Irish Myths, Jen The Librarian, CriminOlly, JuLingo, Nini Music, Litt Up, Songs Sped Up, Puddles Pity Party, Daily Soak, The Onion, Dominc Noble, MilitaryRated, Political X, NanyaCim, Shawna the Mom, Elvira Bary, Inside Russia, Brigitte Empire, Tom Powell, Letterkenny, Guard the Leaf.
Consider treating this as a hostile site. 🤔
Goodreads do not encourage or allow discourse and critical thought. As example, I wrote a short direct review of a book glorifying the quest of a newly rich twat to overthrow the US government with the aid of the military in order that he not pay taxes. Prophetic in hindsight.
I found the theme or something like it, which is popular in Kindle selections to be both dangerous and unhealthy.
The book was Powers of The Earth. The blurb now changed, likened it to "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" which that book in no way resembles. It was instead, "Atlas Shrugged" set on the Moon
The writer, Travis Corcoran self-described as libertarian (now anarcho capitalist without the millions), advocate for the return of chattel slavery (popular US stance with the State of Utah completing the first forced labour prison for detained homeless), veteran, employee of an unnamed US agency and admirer of Putin (popular among US patriots).
The Corcoran and six fellow patriots took exception. There followed a year of comments asserting that my lack of a response was narcissistic, challenging my intelligence, European racism is a social good (now openly espoused by Thiel, Musk and others) and more. Surprisingly not a single comment addressed the merits of that drivel.
I was disappointed that no comments offered insights into the origins of Yamnaya culture. Such is life.
The layers of irony almost overwhelmed my communist soul.
A final comment was delivered by Claes Rees Jr aka Cgr710 now ka Clayton R Jesse Jr, who proudly declared after referencing the contents of my last message to a Goodreads friend, that They had "won" (?).
I discovered after that They (and many friends) apparently launched a year long campaign of vile sexual/sexist, racist and other comments against every female creator of channels which I mentioned. It continues still.
The midteen boater and her mother, theoretical physicist, model builder, primatologist and others were not charmed by American courtship ritual.
While They were unable to secure sex partners, They did increase the world's overabundance of unpleasantness. They also delivered an eerily perfect self-portrait of the snowflake (vicious, poorly socialised, outraged US man-child) to a multinational audience.
Quite the Victory. Goodreads discourse was not quite what I had expected at start.
Another stepaway to the YouTube. This next was made possible by Doctor Who/Day of the Doctor - The Oncoming Storm, Broken Peach, Imperial War Museums. Kings and Generals, Military Aviation History, ScaredKetchup, Dark Brandon, FAFO, The Marsh Family, SandRhoman History, The Great War, Dropkick Murphys, TIKHistory, TimeGhost History, Brit in Germany, Democratic Penguins Republic, Gingers are Black,
Twinshangout Kenya, Left of Black, MoAn Inc, Just in Time Worldbuilding, Oceanliner Designs, Isaac Arthur, Central Crossing, Shannon Makes, Hat Historian, Historical Fashion, Secret Sauce of StoryCraft, Roads with Belle, Roisin's Reading, Raw News and Politics, Ukraine Today, The Military Show, Heather Cox Richardson, Todd Maffin.
Larry. & Paul, The Cosy Creative, Ukraine News TV, Yugopnik, Think that Through, Andrewism, Parkrose Permaculture, Kneecap, Candid with Lubna, TechnoFeudalism, Event Horizon, Dr J Marion Sims, TMX News, Amanda's Mild Takes, Professor Tim Wilson, Black Stories Journal, Mary Trump Media. Mallen Baker, IMY2, Nerdforge.
Ominous music begins. 😊 The example at the top is extreme but not the first or only directed directed at myself and other readers who dare to write one star or two star reviews of bad science fiction or book tubers who might agree. Members who are mental are not the worst of the site. Goodreads/Kindle employees have abetted doxxing, stalking and threats with no Amazon action against members, writers who organise or employees who aid either.
In my case by way of example, Goodreads/Kindle shared my limited message history with these emotionally damaged man-children. There followed a favour requested of Australian Intelligence through Pine Gap Centre by some US secret clearance holder to interrogate the one friend, whom I occasionally messaged. I was concerned for my friend who feared for my safety.
Recently a seventh ex-employee of EBay was sentenced for the harassment of a couple, whose small ecommerce channel was deemed unkind to EBay. They were awarded several millions and the ex-employee had been the EBay Chief of Global Security or some such. This was well before the ascension of the US data corporations, which indicates to me that their behaviours will become more outrageous. Things to think about.
I have a small list of precautions. Remove any personal information from member profile and avoid the message function. Remove the lurker, those who do not post. These are monitors likely for comment gangs or employee dummies, not admirers.
With the Amazon penchant for Alterations of customer pages and other minor (?) harassment, the screenshot of the ugly, odd or threatening are invaluable. There are BooKTubers to direct a reader to more useful reader forums
Kindle are the more dangerous. Do Not use Email, Contacts, Calendar or Files. Amazon read customer emails without notice or permission . Make of that what you will.
Do Not "Purchase" Kindle e-books. Downloads belong to Amazon and may deleted at Their whim. There are BookTubers to direct the reader to other ebook and device vendors. They are helpful in suggesting alternatives to ebook purchase.
Between a hacking attempt and the Australian incident imagine what might have happened. Amazon have never been trustworthy but my thought is that it will be more openly monopolistic going forward.
You may not be targeted at present but your temporary immunity is dependent on the whims of psychopathic employees/members. The one question which they will never ask is "Are we the baddies?". Bear in mind that they have minimal oversight, no morality and no restraint but these beasties are US patriots. Ominous music ends. 😊
Be safe and may we all find Good Reading. 🤗
These are some of my favourites.
NCMI, Russian Media Monitor, Bobbing Along, Scaredketchup, Mrs Betty Bowers, History with Kayleigh, Ben and Emily, Shitty Book Club, A Day of Small Things, Some More News, The Book Leo, Abney Park, Rachel MacDonald, Clever Dick Films, Not even Emily, Prime of Midlife, Chris and Shell, Owen Jones, The Second Story, Elin Harness,
Dark Seas, UATV, Dark Docs, Munecat, Tibees, Max Mayorov, It's Black Friday, Abbie Emmons, Historical Fashion, Lily Alexandre, Dark Brandon, Are We the baddies - Mitchell and Webb, Sabine Hossenfelder, Science of Science Fiction, Hello Future Me, The Clockwork Reader, The British Museum, Joe Blogs, Weirdo Book Club, Living Anachronism,
Quinn's Ideas, Templin Institute, Capitalist Realism, Beyond Books, Alt Shift X, Roomies Digest, A Life of Lit, JuLingo, Dominic Noble, A Cup of Nicole, Bookslike Whoa, The Russian Dude, The Caspian Report, NFKRZ, Kathy's Flog in France, Asianometry, Red Plateaus, Red Viburnam Song, Military History Visualized, Tin Sonzya,
Cold Fusion, Lady of the library, Princess Weekes, Cruising Alba, Cruising Crafts, Adult Wednesday Addams - 2 seasons, Viva La Dirt League, Kazachka, Abby Cox ,nTom Powell, iWriterly, Queen City Minis, Verilybitchie, Planet D, Naughty Nana DUZ, The Grungeon Master, Cecilia Blomdahl, Fran Blanche, BlondiHacks, Katii, Whilenoiz,
What Vivi did next, TVP World, Omeleto, Dungeons and Discourse, The Cold War, Up and Atom, Engineering with Rosie, Caitlin Doughty, MIchael Lambert, Claus Kellerman POV,v ThePrimeChronus,, Spacedock, OrangeRiver, Trae Crowder, Big Train, Nordic Perspective, PonySmasher, Linguoer Mechanic, Hej Sokoly, Brickcrafts, Travelling K.
I wish you a fine morning, a glorious afternoon, a pleasant evening, a wonderful night and may we all continue learning.
This quote seems appropriate to British, German and other readers.
"Tell the lowest white man that he is better than the best black man, he will never notice that you are picking his pocket. Hell, give him someone to look down on and he'll empty his pockets for you."
US President Lyndon B Johnson