This boxed set contains the complete Foreverland trilogy (there is a short story prequel, ‘The Seeds of Foreverland’ available separately).
The three books in this set tell the complete story of Foreverland, a virtual reality created from networked human minds instead of computers. Whilst the individual stories are linked thematically and via plot/characters, the tone of each novel is completely different.
Annihilation was my favourite, and also the most disturbing of the three. The juxtaposition of the sunny idyllic setting and purported caring rehabilitation with the hidden darkness of the Haystack torture and the selfish theft is absolutely chilling and perfectly balanced.
There is a strong theme of free will and how much choice and control we can actually have over our lives and the direction they take (which runs through the entire trilogy). In Annihilation it is the character of Reed which exposes the fallacy in the ‘free will’ argument used by the Investors, because is it really a free choice in life if your only other option is hopeless torment? Repeatedly through this series we hear Investors claiming the children ‘chose to waste’ their lives and also ‘chose’ to enter Foreverland. But we see with Reed that the choice is an illusion, and this is highlighted when we move on to Dead and see that the life Cyn ‘wasted’ originally was one of poverty, pain, rape and violence. Meanwhile the Investors who feel they deserve a second chance at theirs are making their ‘choice’ from a position of wealth, power and privilege.
The tone of Dead is somewhat bleaker than the first book. From the beginning, the reader is wrong-footed because we realise that we never really questioned what happened to the girls we glimpsed briefly in Foreverland… they were simply another incentive for the boys to take that needle, not ‘real’ characters.
Suddenly we are faced with the effects of the boys’ actions on the lives of those girls, who instead of a luxurious paradise with games rooms and beaches, live in hardship and rags in a bunkhouse in the snow, chopping wood and reheating limited tinned supplies. While the boys are bribed with a mixture of carrot and stick to make their ‘free choice’, the girls apparently only get the stick.
Still, again, the author brings these characters to life for the reader, in all their imperfections, selfishness, anger and violence, then shows us that even the darkest past can allow for different choices and the most unlikely people can make heroic sacrifices when the bonds of humanity and understanding are invoked.
Again, in addition to a chilling sci-fi scenario, there are mysteries, questions and twists throughout the plot, that keep the reader guessing to the very end.
Whilst the first two books can each be read as stand-alone stories, Ashes is dependent on the previous installments, as it forms a bridge between the boys’ and girls’ stories and brings them both together to answer the hanging questions and put a lid on the story of Foreverland, with a bow on top.
The tone of Ashes is very different: less bleak and mysterious and more dreamlike. I was reminded of both Inception and The Truman Show in the way Alessandra’s role played out. It turned out that whilst Cyn and Danny Boy were our protagonists throughout, Alessandra and Reed are our dei ex machina, or more accurately, gods IN the machine!
I enjoyed book 3, but felt that the plot was somewhat weaker and more chaotic than the first two installments, and that whilst the ending was immensely satisfying emotionally, looked at dispassionately it appears a bit too smooth and convenient to ring with truth as the previous books did. Also I wanted to see more of Zin again – he had great potential in the first book that I felt was underutilised.
Overall I absolutely loved this series and could not stop until I knew every detail of what was going on. Days after finishing and moving on to my next read, I am still coming back to these stories and pondering the questions they raised, and shivering at the (very plausible) idea of Foreverland. After all, how do we know it’s not all a dream? Did the top stop? Is that lilac I can smell?