What do you think?
Rate this book
The Scent of Sea and Ash: The Twin Flames Trilogy Book One
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
July 2, 2026
I received an advanced reader’s copy of this book and was not paid for my review.
***
Chess is a foundling hiding a secret gift and a mysterious talon shaped birthmark. When a golden helmed rider on a giant raptor steals her brother, she and her sister venture into the perilous unknown to bring him home. What they discover will answer long forgotten questions, but the cost might be higher than they ever imagined.
- Found family
- Secret gifts
- Giant raptors
- Rescue mission
- Mysterious origins
***
This book has absolutely taken me on a journey across the worlds, from small and quiet boat communities to bustling cities, from a charismatic trader and his harem racing across the desert to an isolated fort city on the edge of war, to an abandoned kingdom and so much more. This is not a simple, quick or easy journey for any of the characters, and we ride right alongside them.
With a large cast of characters and multiple point-of-view storytelling, this book might not be for everyone, but I really enjoyed its complexity. Our FMC is Chess, a child found lost at sea and rescued into a chosen family. She may love them with her entire being, but Chess has secrets even from them. As the race begins to save her chosen brother who has been kidnapped, Chess and her family will face so much more than they even knew existed.
The cast of characters in this story aren’t simple. You can both like and dislike them from one page to the next. Watching them deal with a range of human relationships from friendship, to protection, to lust and love, it is complex and never clear cut. I am not usually a fan of love triangles, however, the way it is told in this story layers it with such emotion that it makes the book unputdownable.
The story is not just focussed on love and who is getting in whose pants though. This is a society at war with the Purge, a dangerous dragon and his hordes of beast armies. They are on the very brink of falling or saving themselves, but there are prophecies at play here, which of course means nothing is simple. That being said, the pacing of the book is very different to what you would expect, flying through some sections so fast you feel like you are hooked onto a giant eagle and holding on for dear life, whilst others are slow and reflective, showing the reality of the lives of our characters.
This was such an interesting book, and series, to get stuck into. At times I wanted to scream at or slap the characters silly, and I was chomping at the bit for things to hurry up or slow down. But actually, I think that is the beauty of this story. It was very easy to read, but it forced you to pay attention, to keep going, to find out what was going to happen to our cast of characters. It grabbed you by the hand and dragged you into joy, then launched you off a cliff of grief and pain. If you are looking for a fantasy that encompasses epic world building, delivered in an easy-to-read morsel, but also features complex and sometimes unlikeable characters who feel painfully real, then this is absolutely the series for you.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ - Easy to read, but complex and painfully human characters.
***
Chess is a foundling hiding a secret gift and a mysterious talon shaped birthmark. When a golden helmed rider on a giant raptor steals her brother, she and her sister venture into the perilous unknown to bring him home. What they discover will answer long forgotten questions, but the cost might be higher than they ever imagined.
- Found family
- Secret gifts
- Giant raptors
- Rescue mission
- Mysterious origins
***
This book has absolutely taken me on a journey across the worlds, from small and quiet boat communities to bustling cities, from a charismatic trader and his harem racing across the desert to an isolated fort city on the edge of war, to an abandoned kingdom and so much more. This is not a simple, quick or easy journey for any of the characters, and we ride right alongside them.
With a large cast of characters and multiple point-of-view storytelling, this book might not be for everyone, but I really enjoyed its complexity. Our FMC is Chess, a child found lost at sea and rescued into a chosen family. She may love them with her entire being, but Chess has secrets even from them. As the race begins to save her chosen brother who has been kidnapped, Chess and her family will face so much more than they even knew existed.
The cast of characters in this story aren’t simple. You can both like and dislike them from one page to the next. Watching them deal with a range of human relationships from friendship, to protection, to lust and love, it is complex and never clear cut. I am not usually a fan of love triangles, however, the way it is told in this story layers it with such emotion that it makes the book unputdownable.
The story is not just focussed on love and who is getting in whose pants though. This is a society at war with the Purge, a dangerous dragon and his hordes of beast armies. They are on the very brink of falling or saving themselves, but there are prophecies at play here, which of course means nothing is simple. That being said, the pacing of the book is very different to what you would expect, flying through some sections so fast you feel like you are hooked onto a giant eagle and holding on for dear life, whilst others are slow and reflective, showing the reality of the lives of our characters.
This was such an interesting book, and series, to get stuck into. At times I wanted to scream at or slap the characters silly, and I was chomping at the bit for things to hurry up or slow down. But actually, I think that is the beauty of this story. It was very easy to read, but it forced you to pay attention, to keep going, to find out what was going to happen to our cast of characters. It grabbed you by the hand and dragged you into joy, then launched you off a cliff of grief and pain. If you are looking for a fantasy that encompasses epic world building, delivered in an easy-to-read morsel, but also features complex and sometimes unlikeable characters who feel painfully real, then this is absolutely the series for you.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ - Easy to read, but complex and painfully human characters.
July 11, 2026
4.5 Stars
The Scent of Sea and Ash
Beth Ann Bautiste
I have not read straight-up fantasy in a long time. Even looking back on my feed here, I have been staying in historical & fluffy-romance-ville for a while!
I knew I wanted to read Beth's book because, honestly, I like her vibe and felt I could trust her to write a story I would enjoy. (& enjoy I did! 💖)
She, like me, is not only a chicken lady, BUT A SILKIE LADY, and when I discovered she wrote a silkie into her story... Well, I had to read it!!
✨️THE SILKIE IS IN THE FIRST CHAPTER, AND SHE IS BEAUTIFUL.✨️
Okay, got that out of the way.
Things I loved (other than the chicken):
🌊 WATER! The Ocean! YAY! At some point, I sat by the water to read and had the best immersion reading experience ever.
Fresh sea air while reading about a man who smells like water, heck yeah!
🫶 Language! The way the characters spoke was different enough from how we speak today. From their slang to "finger talk" and use of LOOKS & LIPS.
It was easy to imagine being in a different world.
🫂 Found Family ~A very unique way of CHOOSING your family and showing what familial love bonds can look like.
🦅 GIANT BIRDS. Oh Em Gee. If you are scared of birds, be warned. They are big. They are loyal. Gandalf would be proud.
🔮 The magic system/fantasy elements~ easy to learn and understand! (Thank you!)
❤️🔥On the LOVE/Sex/Romance part...
There are people in love with each other, and there are people simply enjoying each other.
There is open-door sex, which reads like a regular part of living a pleasure-filled life. Nothing explicit.
There is a LOVE TRIANGLE. It makes sense and feels important to the story.
💚Read this book if you like being transported to somewhere lush while reading!
💙If you like multiple POVs (you get 3!)
💛If you like a trilogy where the first book is an excellent setup for MORE and leaves you hanging, but also being okay with waiting for the next one because of the epilogue!
🎵 If you like MUSICIANS who are totally Sevro-Coded. Eau de Cale, rock on.
Thank you for the ARC, Beth!
PS. GO CHECK OUT THE ARTWORK ON HER PAGE!!!!!!!
GO FIND PEARL, ASAP.
The Scent of Sea and Ash
Beth Ann Bautiste
I have not read straight-up fantasy in a long time. Even looking back on my feed here, I have been staying in historical & fluffy-romance-ville for a while!
I knew I wanted to read Beth's book because, honestly, I like her vibe and felt I could trust her to write a story I would enjoy. (& enjoy I did! 💖)
She, like me, is not only a chicken lady, BUT A SILKIE LADY, and when I discovered she wrote a silkie into her story... Well, I had to read it!!
✨️THE SILKIE IS IN THE FIRST CHAPTER, AND SHE IS BEAUTIFUL.✨️
Okay, got that out of the way.
Things I loved (other than the chicken):
🌊 WATER! The Ocean! YAY! At some point, I sat by the water to read and had the best immersion reading experience ever.
Fresh sea air while reading about a man who smells like water, heck yeah!
🫶 Language! The way the characters spoke was different enough from how we speak today. From their slang to "finger talk" and use of LOOKS & LIPS.
It was easy to imagine being in a different world.
🫂 Found Family ~A very unique way of CHOOSING your family and showing what familial love bonds can look like.
🦅 GIANT BIRDS. Oh Em Gee. If you are scared of birds, be warned. They are big. They are loyal. Gandalf would be proud.
🔮 The magic system/fantasy elements~ easy to learn and understand! (Thank you!)
❤️🔥On the LOVE/Sex/Romance part...
There are people in love with each other, and there are people simply enjoying each other.
There is open-door sex, which reads like a regular part of living a pleasure-filled life. Nothing explicit.
There is a LOVE TRIANGLE. It makes sense and feels important to the story.
💚Read this book if you like being transported to somewhere lush while reading!
💙If you like multiple POVs (you get 3!)
💛If you like a trilogy where the first book is an excellent setup for MORE and leaves you hanging, but also being okay with waiting for the next one because of the epilogue!
🎵 If you like MUSICIANS who are totally Sevro-Coded. Eau de Cale, rock on.
Thank you for the ARC, Beth!
PS. GO CHECK OUT THE ARTWORK ON HER PAGE!!!!!!!
GO FIND PEARL, ASAP.
Review of advance copy received from Author
~ I received this eARC free from the author. Thank you to Beth Ann Bautiste! My opinions are my own and voluntarily given~
The Scent of Sea and Ash by Beth Bautiste is a fast paced, character driven fantasy romance that takes familiar tropes and gives them a clever little twist. This story has an ancient prophecy, firestarter magic, ancient evil, fated love, found family, orphan themes, bonded animals, morally complex characters, and multi POV storytelling, but none of it feels like a copy and paste version of what we’ve seen before. It has found family, but make it literal. Fated love, but make it complicated. Prophecy, but make it hidden. Orphan trope, but reverse it. Bonded animals, but not the ones that first come to mind.
What really worked for me was the emotional thread running underneath all the fantasy stakes. The story leans into the idea that the human heart can be ruined by greed, mistrust, and grief, but also healed by love, courage, and strength. One quote that really captured that feeling for me was, “Her heart pounded against my chest. A heart I would protect as long as there was breath in my body.” Y’all know I’m a sucker for that kind of devotion, and moments like that gave both the romance and the larger realm level conflict a lot more weight.
I also loved the found family/chosen family dynamics woven throughout the story. The relationships felt meaningful, and the morally complex characters kept me guessing about motivations and loyalties. The multi POV format added depth to the world and helped raise the stakes as the ancient prophecy slowly unfolded.
It moves quickly, but the characters still feel like the heart of the story, which is my favorite kind of romantasy balance. I rated this 4 stars with a 3 spice level, and I’d recommend it to readers who love:
- Ancient prophecy
- Found family / chosen family
- Morally complex characters
- Multi POV
- Complicated bonds
- Emotional stakes
- Fantasy romance with fresh twists and plenty of heart
The Scent of Sea and Ash by Beth Bautiste is a fast paced, character driven fantasy romance that takes familiar tropes and gives them a clever little twist. This story has an ancient prophecy, firestarter magic, ancient evil, fated love, found family, orphan themes, bonded animals, morally complex characters, and multi POV storytelling, but none of it feels like a copy and paste version of what we’ve seen before. It has found family, but make it literal. Fated love, but make it complicated. Prophecy, but make it hidden. Orphan trope, but reverse it. Bonded animals, but not the ones that first come to mind.
What really worked for me was the emotional thread running underneath all the fantasy stakes. The story leans into the idea that the human heart can be ruined by greed, mistrust, and grief, but also healed by love, courage, and strength. One quote that really captured that feeling for me was, “Her heart pounded against my chest. A heart I would protect as long as there was breath in my body.” Y’all know I’m a sucker for that kind of devotion, and moments like that gave both the romance and the larger realm level conflict a lot more weight.
I also loved the found family/chosen family dynamics woven throughout the story. The relationships felt meaningful, and the morally complex characters kept me guessing about motivations and loyalties. The multi POV format added depth to the world and helped raise the stakes as the ancient prophecy slowly unfolded.
It moves quickly, but the characters still feel like the heart of the story, which is my favorite kind of romantasy balance. I rated this 4 stars with a 3 spice level, and I’d recommend it to readers who love:
- Ancient prophecy
- Found family / chosen family
- Morally complex characters
- Multi POV
- Complicated bonds
- Emotional stakes
- Fantasy romance with fresh twists and plenty of heart
July 20, 2026
I received this as an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
A richly imagined fantasy with unforgettable characters and an emotional journey
The Scent of Sea and Ash is an ambitious, character-driven fantasy that weaves together multiple perspectives, prophecy, war, and found family into an immersive adventure. Beth Ann Bautiste creates a vivid world filled with danger, mythology, and heart, making it easy to become invested in the lives of Chess, Serowyn, and Hvitir as their seemingly separate paths slowly begin to intertwine.
The strength of this book lies in its characters. Each protagonist has their own compelling struggles and motivations, and I found myself equally invested in all three storylines. Chess’s determination to save her brother, Serowyn’s battle between duty and destiny, and Hvitir’s fight for freedom all carried plenty of emotional weight. Their individual journeys explored themes of identity, sacrifice, belonging, and resilience in a way that felt both meaningful and engaging.
The world-building is beautifully detailed, with unique creatures, ancient prophecies, and a rich history that gradually unfolds throughout the story. While the opening takes a little time to settle into, the payoff is well worth it as the plot gathers momentum and the connections between the characters become clearer. The writing is atmospheric, bringing both the beauty and brutality of the world vividly to life.
At times the number of perspectives and lore meant I had to pay close attention, and there were moments where the pacing slowed slightly while the world expanded. However, once everything began falling into place, I found myself completely invested in where the story was heading.
Overall, The Scent of Sea and Ash is an imaginative fantasy filled with memorable characters, emotional stakes, and a fascinating world that leaves you eager to see what comes next. If you enjoy epic fantasy with prophecy, found family, multiple POVs, and richly layered world-building, this is definitely one to pick up.
A richly imagined fantasy with unforgettable characters and an emotional journey
The Scent of Sea and Ash is an ambitious, character-driven fantasy that weaves together multiple perspectives, prophecy, war, and found family into an immersive adventure. Beth Ann Bautiste creates a vivid world filled with danger, mythology, and heart, making it easy to become invested in the lives of Chess, Serowyn, and Hvitir as their seemingly separate paths slowly begin to intertwine.
The strength of this book lies in its characters. Each protagonist has their own compelling struggles and motivations, and I found myself equally invested in all three storylines. Chess’s determination to save her brother, Serowyn’s battle between duty and destiny, and Hvitir’s fight for freedom all carried plenty of emotional weight. Their individual journeys explored themes of identity, sacrifice, belonging, and resilience in a way that felt both meaningful and engaging.
The world-building is beautifully detailed, with unique creatures, ancient prophecies, and a rich history that gradually unfolds throughout the story. While the opening takes a little time to settle into, the payoff is well worth it as the plot gathers momentum and the connections between the characters become clearer. The writing is atmospheric, bringing both the beauty and brutality of the world vividly to life.
At times the number of perspectives and lore meant I had to pay close attention, and there were moments where the pacing slowed slightly while the world expanded. However, once everything began falling into place, I found myself completely invested in where the story was heading.
Overall, The Scent of Sea and Ash is an imaginative fantasy filled with memorable characters, emotional stakes, and a fascinating world that leaves you eager to see what comes next. If you enjoy epic fantasy with prophecy, found family, multiple POVs, and richly layered world-building, this is definitely one to pick up.
June 11, 2026
“Her heart pounded against my chest. A heart I would protect as long as there was breath in my body.”
✨ Ancient prophecy
✨ Found family / chosen family
✨ Morally complex characters
✨ Multi POV
This has a really strong concept at its core. Chess is a foundling with a hidden gift, a stolen chosen brother, and a story that clearly builds towards something much bigger than it first appears.
There’s a strong sense of fate and connection running through it, like everything is being pulled together by something larger than the characters themselves.
“That man has no idea what family is. You are my family, Lovey. You and Bronny,”
The found family dynamic was one of the highlights for me. It brought warmth and emotional grounding that worked really well against the heavier plot elements.
“Regnum Draconum, he called it: Realm of Dragons. That struck me as mighty fanciful for a place full of magic. Magic was not something we wanted any part of.”
The worldbuilding is ambitious, with a lot of lore, magic systems and multiple POV threads. For me personally, the multi POV structure made it harder to stay fully grounded in the story.
“I had said the words that I had kept to myself since she came back into my life, and she didn’t reject them. Words that meant I wasn’t alone anymore, words that made everything in my father’s sketchbooks real.”
I can see why this works really well for readers who love big, layered fantasy worlds. It just didn’t fully click for me in the same way, and I didn’t stay as connected to the characters or narrative as I usually prefer.
“That feeling of fate, connection, destiny, and lives colliding in ways bigger than anyone understands.”
Still a really ambitious fantasy with a lot going on, just more of a “not quite my perfect fit” read. I’m sure it will find the perfect readers.
Chaos, vibes, and opinions are all my own ✨ please give credit if you share.
✨ Ancient prophecy
✨ Found family / chosen family
✨ Morally complex characters
✨ Multi POV
This has a really strong concept at its core. Chess is a foundling with a hidden gift, a stolen chosen brother, and a story that clearly builds towards something much bigger than it first appears.
There’s a strong sense of fate and connection running through it, like everything is being pulled together by something larger than the characters themselves.
“That man has no idea what family is. You are my family, Lovey. You and Bronny,”
The found family dynamic was one of the highlights for me. It brought warmth and emotional grounding that worked really well against the heavier plot elements.
“Regnum Draconum, he called it: Realm of Dragons. That struck me as mighty fanciful for a place full of magic. Magic was not something we wanted any part of.”
The worldbuilding is ambitious, with a lot of lore, magic systems and multiple POV threads. For me personally, the multi POV structure made it harder to stay fully grounded in the story.
“I had said the words that I had kept to myself since she came back into my life, and she didn’t reject them. Words that meant I wasn’t alone anymore, words that made everything in my father’s sketchbooks real.”
I can see why this works really well for readers who love big, layered fantasy worlds. It just didn’t fully click for me in the same way, and I didn’t stay as connected to the characters or narrative as I usually prefer.
“That feeling of fate, connection, destiny, and lives colliding in ways bigger than anyone understands.”
Still a really ambitious fantasy with a lot going on, just more of a “not quite my perfect fit” read. I’m sure it will find the perfect readers.
Chaos, vibes, and opinions are all my own ✨ please give credit if you share.
July 23, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Format 📱
Okay… this book completely stole my heart. 🥹❤️
I don’t even know where to start because this story gave me everything I love in fantasy. Pirates, dragons, unique magic, found family, adventure, and characters that felt so real that I never wanted to leave them.
Chess was such an easy character to love. She’s funny, stubborn, loyal, and just the right amount of chaotic. I found myself smiling so many times because of her, and I loved watching her grow throughout the story.
The found family in this book was EVERYTHING. Grandmeer, Lovey, Bronny… they weren’t just side characters. They became home. Their love and loyalty for each other made my heart so happy, and those relationships were honestly one of my favorite parts of the entire book.
The world building is beautiful. It takes a little time to settle into, but trust me, it’s worth it. Every new piece of the world made me want to keep reading, and before I knew it, I was completely immersed.
I also loved that the romance never took over the story. It was there, but it felt earned and never distracted from the adventure. The fantasy stayed front and center, and I appreciated that so much.
This is the kind of book that reminds me why I love fantasy in the first place. It made me laugh, made me emotional, and completely swept me away.
If you love found family, pirates, dragons, unique magic, unforgettable characters, and fantasy that feels like an adventure from beginning to end… please put this one on your TBR. I already know this is going to be one of those books I think about long after I finish it.
Format 📱
Okay… this book completely stole my heart. 🥹❤️
I don’t even know where to start because this story gave me everything I love in fantasy. Pirates, dragons, unique magic, found family, adventure, and characters that felt so real that I never wanted to leave them.
Chess was such an easy character to love. She’s funny, stubborn, loyal, and just the right amount of chaotic. I found myself smiling so many times because of her, and I loved watching her grow throughout the story.
The found family in this book was EVERYTHING. Grandmeer, Lovey, Bronny… they weren’t just side characters. They became home. Their love and loyalty for each other made my heart so happy, and those relationships were honestly one of my favorite parts of the entire book.
The world building is beautiful. It takes a little time to settle into, but trust me, it’s worth it. Every new piece of the world made me want to keep reading, and before I knew it, I was completely immersed.
I also loved that the romance never took over the story. It was there, but it felt earned and never distracted from the adventure. The fantasy stayed front and center, and I appreciated that so much.
This is the kind of book that reminds me why I love fantasy in the first place. It made me laugh, made me emotional, and completely swept me away.
If you love found family, pirates, dragons, unique magic, unforgettable characters, and fantasy that feels like an adventure from beginning to end… please put this one on your TBR. I already know this is going to be one of those books I think about long after I finish it.
June 20, 2026
I received an ARC of this book and was excited to read it.
And for the first 300 pages, I liked it. The world was unique though, even with the glossary at the beginning, I'll admit all the different types of people and magic were very confusing and hard to keep straight. But that didn't turn me off, and I got used to it after a while. I really liked the relationship between Chess and Sero, especially with how he didn't push her and gave her a chance to choose him. Elite level yearning from that guy. Loved it. Exactly the type of MMC you want. At times, it's what kept me reading, wanting to see how their relationship developed.
And I feel like there could have been plenty of tension and issues to overcome for them without adding a third party.
But then Pearl was thrown into the mix, and a love triangle was shoved where, I'll be perfectly honest, I didn't personally feel like it belonged or made sense based on how the author had described the supposed "connection" between Chess and Sero. And how Pearl was built up as a big brother/ protector character until that point. To me, love triangles promote 'cheating culture', but try to make that seem okay, and I just don't like it as a trope/plot device. It tainted the whole story for me after that. Which makes me sad because, up until that point, it felt like a series I would really enjoy, and now I don't even know if I'II continue it. If you're a fan of love triangles, you may really like it. It just wasn't my cup of tea.
And for the first 300 pages, I liked it. The world was unique though, even with the glossary at the beginning, I'll admit all the different types of people and magic were very confusing and hard to keep straight. But that didn't turn me off, and I got used to it after a while. I really liked the relationship between Chess and Sero, especially with how he didn't push her and gave her a chance to choose him. Elite level yearning from that guy. Loved it. Exactly the type of MMC you want. At times, it's what kept me reading, wanting to see how their relationship developed.
And I feel like there could have been plenty of tension and issues to overcome for them without adding a third party.
But then Pearl was thrown into the mix, and a love triangle was shoved where, I'll be perfectly honest, I didn't personally feel like it belonged or made sense based on how the author had described the supposed "connection" between Chess and Sero. And how Pearl was built up as a big brother/ protector character until that point. To me, love triangles promote 'cheating culture', but try to make that seem okay, and I just don't like it as a trope/plot device. It tainted the whole story for me after that. Which makes me sad because, up until that point, it felt like a series I would really enjoy, and now I don't even know if I'II continue it. If you're a fan of love triangles, you may really like it. It just wasn't my cup of tea.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 6, 2026
I just finished The Scent of Sea and Ash and immediately found myself deep in theory mode—replaying scenes, connecting clues, and trying to piece together every hint I might have missed. It’s the kind of story that lingers long after you turn the final page.
At the heart of the book is Chess, a compelling and fierce FMC whose journey becomes even more gripping as prophecies begin to unfold around her in unexpected ways. Nothing feels predictable, and I appreciated how much the story kept me questioning what I thought I understood.
The world-building is rich and immersive, with dragons and giant eagles woven naturally into a setting where magic feels both intricate and deeply personal. The abilities in this world aren’t just powers—they shape identity, relationships, and the choices characters are forced to make, which adds a lot of depth to the story.
I also really enjoyed the emotional tension throughout, especially the romance element, which kept me constantly unsure in the best way.
As a debut in what feels like a much larger unfolding series, this book does a great job of introducing a complex world while still leaving plenty of questions unanswered. It sets the stage for something much bigger, and I’m very curious to see where the story goes next.
Overall, this was an engaging and immersive read that pulled me in quickly and kept me invested until the end.
At the heart of the book is Chess, a compelling and fierce FMC whose journey becomes even more gripping as prophecies begin to unfold around her in unexpected ways. Nothing feels predictable, and I appreciated how much the story kept me questioning what I thought I understood.
The world-building is rich and immersive, with dragons and giant eagles woven naturally into a setting where magic feels both intricate and deeply personal. The abilities in this world aren’t just powers—they shape identity, relationships, and the choices characters are forced to make, which adds a lot of depth to the story.
I also really enjoyed the emotional tension throughout, especially the romance element, which kept me constantly unsure in the best way.
As a debut in what feels like a much larger unfolding series, this book does a great job of introducing a complex world while still leaving plenty of questions unanswered. It sets the stage for something much bigger, and I’m very curious to see where the story goes next.
Overall, this was an engaging and immersive read that pulled me in quickly and kept me invested until the end.
July 21, 2026
Thank you for the gifted copy!
So I don’t even know where to begin with this book! I’m still wrapping my head around everything that happened! There are so many moving parts (characters, locations, etc) but it all comes together and makes sense as the story progresses. I do love multiple POVs because I want to understand what all of the characters are thinking/what’s motivating them. The glossary is very helpful with this story too!
I love Chess and feel for all of the heartbreak and loss she has went through throughout the story. I understand her hesitance with Sero after how her chosen family was treated but he also felt horrible. I need more information on the bond she shares with him too. With that said, I’m still torn with this love triangle! I want to know more about Chess’ history with Pearl throughout the years before they met in person because I feel like there are things we don’t know about their connection. I also want to learn more about the Purge and the history of this war.
There’s a lot more story to tell and I’m looking forward to it! The take home here is I NEED answers!
So I don’t even know where to begin with this book! I’m still wrapping my head around everything that happened! There are so many moving parts (characters, locations, etc) but it all comes together and makes sense as the story progresses. I do love multiple POVs because I want to understand what all of the characters are thinking/what’s motivating them. The glossary is very helpful with this story too!
I love Chess and feel for all of the heartbreak and loss she has went through throughout the story. I understand her hesitance with Sero after how her chosen family was treated but he also felt horrible. I need more information on the bond she shares with him too. With that said, I’m still torn with this love triangle! I want to know more about Chess’ history with Pearl throughout the years before they met in person because I feel like there are things we don’t know about their connection. I also want to learn more about the Purge and the history of this war.
There’s a lot more story to tell and I’m looking forward to it! The take home here is I NEED answers!
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC Review
.
Theres some interesting world building in this book. Subtle hints at familiar places and names but set in a world that doesnt feel familiar and suggests maybe some post apocalypse type future where earth has had to rebuild from scratch.
The family trio has a really sweet bond in the way that they care for each other and are fully bound to each others lives. I enjoyed the writing around chosen family and how important choice is
I appreciated that the FMC had genuine connections with each guy in the love triangle, her relationship with each one is completely different and makes the choice more conflicting without feeling like its forced drama.
There isnt a huge amount of time spent on the larger conflict in the story which I think does it a little bit of a disservice. Enemies appear out of no where and someone has to explain it to the FMC, which makes sense because shes been far away from all of this, but also makes the story feel a bit disjointed - like its taking place in two seperate worlds.
.
Theres some interesting world building in this book. Subtle hints at familiar places and names but set in a world that doesnt feel familiar and suggests maybe some post apocalypse type future where earth has had to rebuild from scratch.
The family trio has a really sweet bond in the way that they care for each other and are fully bound to each others lives. I enjoyed the writing around chosen family and how important choice is
I appreciated that the FMC had genuine connections with each guy in the love triangle, her relationship with each one is completely different and makes the choice more conflicting without feeling like its forced drama.
There isnt a huge amount of time spent on the larger conflict in the story which I think does it a little bit of a disservice. Enemies appear out of no where and someone has to explain it to the FMC, which makes sense because shes been far away from all of this, but also makes the story feel a bit disjointed - like its taking place in two seperate worlds.
Review of advance copy
From the very first page, it is clear that The Scent of Sea and Ash is a very well-crafted story.
The writing style, atmosphere, and overall tone feel polished and intentional throughout. The world-building is particularly strong: layered, immersive, and thoughtfully developed rather than feeling superficial, rushed, or simply there to support the romance.
I usually pay more attention to the fantasy elements in romantasy, but the romance here felt meaningful beyond being purely entertaining. I was fully invested in Chess’ journey, and the side characters added depth to the story and felt purposeful rather than distracting from the main narrative.
Beth Ann Bautiste has created a world that feels carefully considered, both in its setting and character dynamics, and I am very interested to see where the story goes in book two.
Also… now I want a raven for a pet. IYKYK.
Thank you to the author and publisher for the ARC.
The writing style, atmosphere, and overall tone feel polished and intentional throughout. The world-building is particularly strong: layered, immersive, and thoughtfully developed rather than feeling superficial, rushed, or simply there to support the romance.
I usually pay more attention to the fantasy elements in romantasy, but the romance here felt meaningful beyond being purely entertaining. I was fully invested in Chess’ journey, and the side characters added depth to the story and felt purposeful rather than distracting from the main narrative.
Beth Ann Bautiste has created a world that feels carefully considered, both in its setting and character dynamics, and I am very interested to see where the story goes in book two.
Also… now I want a raven for a pet. IYKYK.
Thank you to the author and publisher for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Right from the title and striking cover, The Scent of Sea and Ash challenges expectations. This haunting story as rich and layered as scent, as vast as the sea, and as warming and potentially dangerous as coal burning down to ash. Each word is carefully chosen, each character earned their place—in the book and in my heart—and every choice the author made was considered, fresh, and sometimes jaw-dropping. I love when authors take familiar tropes and reshape them into something completely original. Beth Ann goes one step farther, she remakes them in ways that make them seem like that’s the way they should have always been. This is found family you won’t forget, and a story that shows how different kinds of love can stretch a heart and prepare it for the romance—one true love not a triangle—that will give it wings. If you love romantasy where the fantasy is as important as the epic romance and no assumption is ever safe, The Scent of Sea and Ash is perfect.
May 26, 2026
🌊🔥 BOOK REVIEW 🔥🌊
Okay LISTEN. 😭✨
I went into this book knowing almost nothing and at first I was like “okay, where are we going with this?” …and then around chapter 3 or 4 this story grabbed me by the SOUL and absolutely refused to let go. 🌊🔥
Chess is a foundling with a hidden gift, a kidnapped chosen brother, ancient prophecy, dangerous destinies, and a journey that spirals into something SO much bigger than she ever imagined. And somehow every revelation just kept escalating in the BEST way possible.
This book gave me vibes reminiscent of Cloud Atlas — that feeling of fate, connection, destiny, and lives colliding in ways bigger than anyone understands. 👀✨
AND THE CHARACTERS???
Beth Ann somehow made me emotionally invested in EVERYONE. The heroes. The morally gray ones. Even the villains. Like HOW am I supposed to recover when I love every single chaotic person in this story?! 😭💀
Also… that cliffhanger?????
OH. MY. GAWD.
I finished this book staring at the ceiling questioning my existence because WHAT DO YOU MEAN IT ENDS LIKE THAT?! 🤯🔥 I genuinely thought I knew who I was rooting for romantically and then this book came in swinging like “actually… THINK AGAIN.” 😩🖤
If you love:
✨ ancient prophecies
✨ found family / chosen family
✨ emotional fantasy journeys
✨ shocking twists
✨ morally complex characters
✨ “just one more chapter” syndrome
✨ endings that leave you emotionally damaged
…you NEED this on your radar IMMEDIATELY. 🌊🔥
Okay LISTEN. 😭✨
I went into this book knowing almost nothing and at first I was like “okay, where are we going with this?” …and then around chapter 3 or 4 this story grabbed me by the SOUL and absolutely refused to let go. 🌊🔥
Chess is a foundling with a hidden gift, a kidnapped chosen brother, ancient prophecy, dangerous destinies, and a journey that spirals into something SO much bigger than she ever imagined. And somehow every revelation just kept escalating in the BEST way possible.
This book gave me vibes reminiscent of Cloud Atlas — that feeling of fate, connection, destiny, and lives colliding in ways bigger than anyone understands. 👀✨
AND THE CHARACTERS???
Beth Ann somehow made me emotionally invested in EVERYONE. The heroes. The morally gray ones. Even the villains. Like HOW am I supposed to recover when I love every single chaotic person in this story?! 😭💀
Also… that cliffhanger?????
OH. MY. GAWD.
I finished this book staring at the ceiling questioning my existence because WHAT DO YOU MEAN IT ENDS LIKE THAT?! 🤯🔥 I genuinely thought I knew who I was rooting for romantically and then this book came in swinging like “actually… THINK AGAIN.” 😩🖤
If you love:
✨ ancient prophecies
✨ found family / chosen family
✨ emotional fantasy journeys
✨ shocking twists
✨ morally complex characters
✨ “just one more chapter” syndrome
✨ endings that leave you emotionally damaged
…you NEED this on your radar IMMEDIATELY. 🌊🔥
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is Beth’s debut novel, and she hit it out of the park. It’s honestly difficult to classify A Scent of Sea and Ash. It is a bit of a romantasy, but it’s more. Romance is shallow. These relationships are deep and strong. The fantasy aspect is not the focus, but a background character if you will. Read it, and you will understand the dilemma in classifying it.
I’m a Louisiana girl, so I loved and completely related to the opening setting. If you like it, too, don’t get too comfortable because these folks TRAVEL. The settings are diverse. The world building is vast, but not so much you feel overwhelmed or lost. Beth brings an intimacy to each stop in the adventure.
I’m going to stay vague about the characters. I don’t know how to discuss them without over sharing. But they are each unique and flawed and human - except the ones that aren’t (human, that is).
Read the book.
I’m a Louisiana girl, so I loved and completely related to the opening setting. If you like it, too, don’t get too comfortable because these folks TRAVEL. The settings are diverse. The world building is vast, but not so much you feel overwhelmed or lost. Beth brings an intimacy to each stop in the adventure.
I’m going to stay vague about the characters. I don’t know how to discuss them without over sharing. But they are each unique and flawed and human - except the ones that aren’t (human, that is).
Read the book.
July 25, 2026
This was definitely a complex read filled with a new world and new ideas. I particularly loved the raptors and ravens and the beast wielding power that some characters had. So intriguing following the self-discovery discovery journey of Chess across the different worlds from the sea to the mountains and the camp. I also found the use of 'finger talk' so clever to add to the depth and secrecy of Pearl's character. This is definitely a story you need to pay close attention to as it shifts so quickly between the cahracters and different places. I did find myself turning back a couple of times to re-read sections to make sure I didn't miss anything! I was very shocked by the last few chapters and it was so fast paced it was almost overwhelming, and that epilogue has me absolutely on the edge of my seat waiting for the next addition to this story.
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC copy provided by the author
The Scent of Sea and Ash has pretty much everything I could want in a fantasy novel: dragon lore, ancient prophecies, rich history, multiple magic systems, romance, spice, and plenty of twists…
What I loved most was the atmosphere. The imagery created such immersive, cozy vibes that I could easily lose myself in the world. Whether you’re here for the magic, the romance, or the epic adventure, there’s something in this story for every reader.
And that ending… excuse me?! I have questions. So many questions! I would very much like to shake the author and demand the next book immediately.
If you enjoy high fantasy with romance, dragons, magic, and a story that keeps you turning pages late into the night, definitely add this one to your TBR!
The Scent of Sea and Ash has pretty much everything I could want in a fantasy novel: dragon lore, ancient prophecies, rich history, multiple magic systems, romance, spice, and plenty of twists…
What I loved most was the atmosphere. The imagery created such immersive, cozy vibes that I could easily lose myself in the world. Whether you’re here for the magic, the romance, or the epic adventure, there’s something in this story for every reader.
And that ending… excuse me?! I have questions. So many questions! I would very much like to shake the author and demand the next book immediately.
If you enjoy high fantasy with romance, dragons, magic, and a story that keeps you turning pages late into the night, definitely add this one to your TBR!
July 14, 2026
I had the opportunity to meet the author, so I quickly paused my other book to read this one before I met her.
I went in blind. I was going with a friend who had read it, and wanted to be able to talk about the book.
What I found was a wonderful story that kept me interested and enchanted.
Things I really enjoyed:
Found family with a unique cultural tradition that paints a really beautiful picture.
The depiction of grief. Stunning and real. Those of use that have experienced loss will recognize the honest and raw writing.
Giant eagles and ravens: um…bird riders? Yes please.
Fated vs. Choice: this book deals a lot with choice and free will.
I am excited to see where this trilogy goes.
I went in blind. I was going with a friend who had read it, and wanted to be able to talk about the book.
What I found was a wonderful story that kept me interested and enchanted.
Things I really enjoyed:
Found family with a unique cultural tradition that paints a really beautiful picture.
The depiction of grief. Stunning and real. Those of use that have experienced loss will recognize the honest and raw writing.
Giant eagles and ravens: um…bird riders? Yes please.
Fated vs. Choice: this book deals a lot with choice and free will.
I am excited to see where this trilogy goes.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I couldn’t put this book down! The unique world building, magic system and characters had me hooked right away!
The pacing is perfect, I was on the edge of my seat the whole time! Laughing, crying, swooning!
One of my favorite things about this book is how the romance subplot doesn’t follow the normal “rules” that most books do. So refreshing! And the way I want to carry some of these characters in my pocket at all times is probably unhealthy. Just wait until you meet Pearl. Trust me ;)
I can’t wait until the next book comes out!
The pacing is perfect, I was on the edge of my seat the whole time! Laughing, crying, swooning!
One of my favorite things about this book is how the romance subplot doesn’t follow the normal “rules” that most books do. So refreshing! And the way I want to carry some of these characters in my pocket at all times is probably unhealthy. Just wait until you meet Pearl. Trust me ;)
I can’t wait until the next book comes out!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
ARC RECEIVED FROM NETGALLEY
This was such a fun adventure that had me engaged from the very start. The highlight and most well done aspect was the world building that was very easy to get lost in. This is a lovely fantasy with great tension that will keep you engaged the whole way through. This novel was very well balanced and I enjoyed the dynamic between the characters and how they worked with one another.
You will definitely enjoyed this if you love a well crafted fantasy world with rich world build and lore.
This was such a fun adventure that had me engaged from the very start. The highlight and most well done aspect was the world building that was very easy to get lost in. This is a lovely fantasy with great tension that will keep you engaged the whole way through. This novel was very well balanced and I enjoyed the dynamic between the characters and how they worked with one another.
You will definitely enjoyed this if you love a well crafted fantasy world with rich world build and lore.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is an imaginative, refreshing read that did not follow the predictable formula. Unique ideas, worlds, and characters that are original and memorable— just wait! The subtle romance is woven naturally into the story. A beautifully written, magical fantasy! Cannot WAIT for the next book— the characters stay with you!
Review of advance copy received from Author
OMGEEE🤩 I love this book from the ups and downs, love and loss and twists and turns!!! The characters are brilliantly written from their physical descriptions, thoughts and emotions-this story will grip you to your core❤️ I’m waiting on bated breath for the sequel !!
July 13, 2026
Loved it. I found this to be a good read on a rainy summer day.
July 21, 2026
DNF at 35%. I just couldn't get into this book
Review of advance copy received from Author
Go and add this to your Tbr now. You won’t regret it. This is a character driven fantasy Romance with rich history, found family, fire magic, and oh the evil. fated mates, bonded animals, and an emotional journey you want to go on. Chess‘ journey is fast paced with lots of twists. It grabs a hold of you and doesn’t let go till the very end and then you want more.
Thank you for this arc which was given as a gift for an honest review
Thank you for this arc which was given as a gift for an honest review
Review of advance copy received from Author
I literally just put down The Scent of Sea and Ash by Beth Ann Bautiste and had to immediately come over to my computer to write about it. Holy crap. The end of this book is A LOT to process, and I am DYING for book two.
First of all, when I started this book, the very first thing that caught my attention was the vibes of the world. I was absolutely enraptured by the nautical atmosphere at the beginning, but what I loved most is how much the world shifts throughout the journey. The vibes evolve so much as the characters travel, and somehow every setting felt just as immersive as the last.
Bautiste has an incredible talent for pulling you into her world. You should see how massive my moodboard is for this book because the amount of pins I saved is honestly insane. Every chapter brought new, vivid images to mind, and that is entirely thanks to Bautiste’s storytelling. She makes the world feel alive in a way that had me completely locked in.
So you may be asking, “Sarah, what the heck is this book even about? We need details!” Well, my friends, let me tell you.
The Scent of Sea and Ash centers around our FMC, Chestnut, or Chess, who was found at a young age by an elderly woman living by the sea. Grandmeer raises Chess alongside her “chosen” siblings, Bronze (Bronny) and Lovejoie (Lovey). And when I say chosen, I mean chosen. This book takes found family and turns it into an actual, legitimate thing through ceremony, which I thought was such a cool concept.
One day, Bronny is taken by a mysterious eagle flier and brought to the land where these fliers reside. Because of this, Chess and Lovey set off on a journey across their world, encountering all kinds of new people and places along the way. During that journey, Chess begins uncovering answers about her past while also discovering a future that may have already been decided for her.
Although the story mainly follows Chess, we also get multiple POVs, including Hvitir and Serowyn, two men who find themselves completely drawn to Chess and her family of chosen.
The vibes of this book are absolutely immaculate, but the characters and their journey are what will keep you turning the pages until the very end. While reading, I couldn’t help but feel the joy, sadness, fear, and shock right alongside these characters. This is one of those books where the second you open the page, it feels like you’ve been transported somewhere else entirely.
And the ending? Yeah. I’m still processing it. Just know it will leave you absolutely shocked and desperate for book two.
If you love fantasy, romance, immersive world-building, and epic journeys, The Scent of Sea and Ash is absolutely one to add to your TBR
First of all, when I started this book, the very first thing that caught my attention was the vibes of the world. I was absolutely enraptured by the nautical atmosphere at the beginning, but what I loved most is how much the world shifts throughout the journey. The vibes evolve so much as the characters travel, and somehow every setting felt just as immersive as the last.
Bautiste has an incredible talent for pulling you into her world. You should see how massive my moodboard is for this book because the amount of pins I saved is honestly insane. Every chapter brought new, vivid images to mind, and that is entirely thanks to Bautiste’s storytelling. She makes the world feel alive in a way that had me completely locked in.
So you may be asking, “Sarah, what the heck is this book even about? We need details!” Well, my friends, let me tell you.
The Scent of Sea and Ash centers around our FMC, Chestnut, or Chess, who was found at a young age by an elderly woman living by the sea. Grandmeer raises Chess alongside her “chosen” siblings, Bronze (Bronny) and Lovejoie (Lovey). And when I say chosen, I mean chosen. This book takes found family and turns it into an actual, legitimate thing through ceremony, which I thought was such a cool concept.
One day, Bronny is taken by a mysterious eagle flier and brought to the land where these fliers reside. Because of this, Chess and Lovey set off on a journey across their world, encountering all kinds of new people and places along the way. During that journey, Chess begins uncovering answers about her past while also discovering a future that may have already been decided for her.
Although the story mainly follows Chess, we also get multiple POVs, including Hvitir and Serowyn, two men who find themselves completely drawn to Chess and her family of chosen.
The vibes of this book are absolutely immaculate, but the characters and their journey are what will keep you turning the pages until the very end. While reading, I couldn’t help but feel the joy, sadness, fear, and shock right alongside these characters. This is one of those books where the second you open the page, it feels like you’ve been transported somewhere else entirely.
And the ending? Yeah. I’m still processing it. Just know it will leave you absolutely shocked and desperate for book two.
If you love fantasy, romance, immersive world-building, and epic journeys, The Scent of Sea and Ash is absolutely one to add to your TBR
Review of advance copy received from Author
If you love found family, prophecies, fated love, giant raptors and secret gifts you’ll want to pick this one up. I was really looking forward to reading it after following the author on Instagram and seeing artwork of the characters and post about the story. It absolutely lived up to the excitement for me.
When I tried to think of comparable books, I thought of Throne of Glass. While the stories themselves are very different, this book gave me a similar feeling. It has that same fresh, immersive quality that feels inspired rather than derivative. In a genre where so many fantasy books can start to blur together, this story genuinely stood out.
One thing I especially appreciated was the pacing. I never found it exhausting or slow. I was engaged the entire time and never felt bored.
The characters were another huge highlight for me. I felt deeply connected to them and genuinely cared about what happened on their journey. Their personalities, emotions, and motivations came through clearly, which made them feel real and memorable.
Some books fade from my mind shortly after I finish them, but this story and these characters have really stayed with me. There are still mysteries left unanswered, but instead of feeling incomplete, they made me even more invested and eager to continue the series.
Overall, this was such a unique and refreshing fantasy read, and I highly recommend it to anyone who loves emotionally engaging characters, found family dynamics, and adventurous fantasy worlds.
When I tried to think of comparable books, I thought of Throne of Glass. While the stories themselves are very different, this book gave me a similar feeling. It has that same fresh, immersive quality that feels inspired rather than derivative. In a genre where so many fantasy books can start to blur together, this story genuinely stood out.
One thing I especially appreciated was the pacing. I never found it exhausting or slow. I was engaged the entire time and never felt bored.
The characters were another huge highlight for me. I felt deeply connected to them and genuinely cared about what happened on their journey. Their personalities, emotions, and motivations came through clearly, which made them feel real and memorable.
Some books fade from my mind shortly after I finish them, but this story and these characters have really stayed with me. There are still mysteries left unanswered, but instead of feeling incomplete, they made me even more invested and eager to continue the series.
Overall, this was such a unique and refreshing fantasy read, and I highly recommend it to anyone who loves emotionally engaging characters, found family dynamics, and adventurous fantasy worlds.
Review of advance copy
This book was amazing. I loved the character development and the plot was so engaging. There was some great creativity and as a big reader it’s always nice to be surprised by new ideas. I was engaged with this book through the whole story and am so looking forward to reading the second book. If you want a great fantasy read try this book!
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews