Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Silverfin: The Little MerSir

Rate this book
Trading his glorious merfolk hair for human legs was supposed to be the hard part. Surviving falling in love with an absolute disaster of a pirate captain is another story entirely.

Silverfin has spent ages secretly stalking his favorite pirate. Not in a creepy way, but a deeply romantic, “watching him dramatically brood through portholes at midnight” kind of way. Captain Hawk is everything Silverfin has ever wanted: terrifying in battle, devastatingly handsome, tragically heartbroken, and unfortunately, entirely, human.

When Hawk’s inner darkness drives him to throw himself into the sea, Silverfin does the only reasonable thing a merman can do. He rescues the drowning captain, steals a single, unconscious kiss, and strikes a bargain with a sea goddess to trade his glorious merfolk hair for a pair of human legs. Stranded aboard the Orca under the sharp, extremely suspicious eye of the man he’s hopelessly obsessed with, Silverfin constructs a flawless plan: win Hawk’s heart, deliver him a legendary treasure galleon, and definitely do not reveal he’s secretly a creature of the deep.

Unfortunately, Hawk is a self-destructive menace with a death wish, and the crew thinks Silverfin is completely unhinged. His only ally is his ex-mermaid sister, but she’s got her hands full navigating her own chaotic romance with her feisty red-headed lady-love.

To top it all off, Silverfin might have technically cheated the sea goddess out of her end of the deal... and she is definitely coming to collect.

Yet, the wrath of the ocean is nothing compared to the fragility of Hawk’s heart. Beneath the armor of swagger and rum, Hawk is still bound to the memory of the man he lost. As their profound connection deepens into something undeniably real, Silverfin faces an impossible choice. He has to convince Hawk to finally leave his grief at the bottom of the sea, all while knowing that if his own hidden identity is exposed, the fragile trust they've built will shatter forever.

Silverfin: The Little MerSir is a queer pirate romantasy filled with found family chaos, hidden identities, sea magic, hurt and comfort, emotional healing, bonus sapphic romance, high-seas adventure, possessive yearning, explicit heat, and one extremely judgmental crab.

Perfect for fans of the witty, queer and maritime energy of Cat Sebastian and the intense emotional healing and explicit spice of K.J. Charles.

200 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 31, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

A.E. LeMercier

49 books52 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
14 (48%)
4 stars
12 (41%)
3 stars
1 (3%)
2 stars
1 (3%)
1 star
1 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Profile Image for Theresa G.
38 reviews
Review of advance copy
July 20, 2026
Please see my updates (1, 2, and 3) below, as this review was originally based on an early ARC that underwent substantial revisions before publication.

Overall, I enjoyed the story's unique premise and satisfying conclusion. By the end of the book, I was invested in the characters and appreciated how the major storylines came together. One of my favorite aspects of the story was Silverfin's interactions with the sharks. Despite losing a limb to one of them, Silverfin was able to demonstrate his resilience and prove that he was far from helpless. His willingness to stand up to predators showed both courage and growth without diminishing the reality of his struggle. Additionally, I enjoyed that he retained the ability to communicate with other Merfolk and sea creatures, which reinforced his connection to the underwater world and added depth to the story's world-building.

My biggest challenge was connecting with the characters during the first half of the book. I often found myself trying to understand connections rather than becoming emotionally invested in the characters. Once those details were revealed, the characters' motivations and relationships became much clearer, and I enjoyed the story much more. One of my favorite aspects of the romance was Silverfin's vulnerability. When Captain Hawk finally confronted his guilt and allowed himself to accept Silverfin's love, their emotional connection felt authentic and earned. From that point forward, their chemistry felt much more natural, making the conclusion especially satisfying.

Overall, I think I would have become emotionally invested much earlier if some of the key character motivations, relationships, and world-building details had been introduced sooner. Even so, I enjoyed the journey, appreciated the originality of the setting, and found the ending to be a satisfying payoff.

First Update:

I communicated with one of the authors directly (A.E. LeMercier) prior to submitting this review because I wanted them to obtain my honest feedback before making it public. The author explained their perspective—their goal was to write a short, primarily light-hearted rom-com. Their decisions were intentional, and I believe if I had understood that premise better going in, I would have had a different mindset while reading.

The author also informed me that a larger round of final revisions was being made to incorporate feedback just like mine, specifically around improving the secondary character arcs. This was my first experience volunteering to be an ARC reader, and I'm so impressed with the author's communication. I highly recommend giving this book a chance and I can't wait to read the final version!

This review was written before any revisions.

2nd Update:

The authors of Silverfin have decided to make substantial revisions to the manuscript before moving forward with publication. Therefore, my review may not pertain to the finished manuscript. If that is the case, I will either delete this review or provide another update.

3rd Update:

I downloaded the final version from Audible and am very satisfied with the revisions the authors made. Many of the concerns I had while reading the original ARC were addressed in the final version, and I appreciated seeing how thoughtfully the authors incorporated reader feedback. I enjoyed the revised version even more and am very happy that I returned to experience the finished story.
Profile Image for Carlton Schaps.
30 reviews
July 31, 2026
I originally read this book as an ARC read and enjoyed it so much I read it twice! It's a queer gender-bent take on the classic story of the Little Mermaid that draws a little bit more from classical mermaid/merman mythology than the famous Disney take on the Little Mermaid.

The main character is Silverfin, a merman, or "mer-sir" as they call themselves, who is reasinably kind but incredibly immature and, who, like another famous mer-person, falls in love with a sailor, in this case a pirate captain, just by watching him. Like that other famous mer-person, Silverfin makes a deal with the local sea witch to be allowed to pursue the apple of his eye. Through his time living amongst humans, Silverfin learns that life as a human is definitely more difficult than he had expected and that actual love, not just infatuation, is harder to come by but more valuable than he had ever thought.

This was a very enjoyable read. I appreciated that while it follows the traditional romance structure of a happily ever after, it does keep you guessing until the end of the book exactly what that looks like and who gets it. 5 stars.
Profile Image for Simona Niles.
Author 13 books10 followers
August 9, 2026
I might be biased, but I think it's fabulous!

Thank you to all our ARC readers who read and reviewed our precious gayby <3.

We did have a snafu with our PR firm, and they ended up telling our ARC readers that we were doing "major rewrites," and I would like to make it clear that the edits we made were minor, surgical and in support of making Mara's storyline stronger. Everything you loved about Hawk and Silverfin was not effected by any of the changes.
29 reviews2 followers
September 1, 2026
Sweet dumb genius Silver and his grumpy pirate are stinking adorable. The humor, the wit and the misadventures leading to an HEA are *chef's kiss*

Sharks are assholes.
Profile Image for Ana Silva.
1,143 reviews17 followers
August 18, 2026
Okay, this book was WAY too much fun!😂 Silverfin had me absolutely cracking up and then you throw a pirate named Hawk into the mix? I was sold. It gave captain Jack Sparrow vibes and I loved it!

It was one of those audios that’s just ridiculously easy to listen to because it’s so funny, flirty, spicy and never takes itself too seriously. I couldn’t stop listening because I genuinely wanted to see what kind of trouble those two would get into next!

Such a cute and entertaining listen and im so glad I had to opportunity to do so.

Profile Image for Mimi Lee.
224 reviews4 followers
October 15, 2026
I will forever have a smile on my face thinking about this book!
Trust these authors I randomly stumbled upon once, to write books that not only are really entertaining and funny but also have this beautiful emotional component that makes your heart feel alive!

This story has everything I adore. Silverfin is such a precious character!! He is sweet, curious, helpful and has a contagious excitement that just makes you grin and giggle. His vision of the world and of humans makes you reflect too, seeing things through his eyes gives you a new perspective. How far would you go for love? What are you willing to sacrifice to get what you want?
Captain Hawk our 2nd MMC was the complete opposite of Silverfin. Haunted by grief and sorrow, he lost his light. His feelings are really relatable and seeing him slowly warm up to Silverfin was so heartwarming.
This is such a healing hurt/comfort, grumpy/sunshine story, the emotional aspect of the MMCs’ relationship was what I enjoyed the most. They learn to not only love each other but to support and understand one another.
The intimacy was honestly beautiful!! Those first times ugh🥵 I love eager and playful couples!
Also the found family element was everything!!!

If you enjoy pirates, merfolk, adventure, a fish out of water, emotional journeys that make you smile and teary-eyed, this is a book I warmly recommend!


***

For the audiobook version. Please listen to it!!!!! Luulu Soul and Tyler Laux did such a wonderful job! The narration is so energetic, heartfelt and captivating! They both not only bring the characters to life but take you with them on that journey! It was so easy to lose track of time with how immersive it was. They both are definitely on my top list of favourite narrators. It is such a pleasure to listen to them because I know I will have a good time… and a really exciting one for sure, oh those spicy scenes are something else 😮‍💨😏🔥

***

Thank you so much A.E LeMercier for this beautiful review opportunity!💕
Profile Image for Nicole.
303 reviews24 followers
August 17, 2026
[Review of an advance reader copy received from the authors.]

It's a tale as old as time — a mer falling for a human and striking a bargain for a chance at love — but you've never heard it quite like this!

After saving the captain he's watched from afar from drowning, Silverfin, a sweetheart with a little more bravery than brains, comes up with the perfect plan — he'll trade his prized mane of hair to win the heart of his pirate king. Well, most of it anyway. Cheating the sea goddess out of a *little* of her payment is probably fine, right? And what better way to a pirate's heart than a ship full of gold?

Captain Samuel Hawk is a man with a painful past, seeking freedom and vengeance on the society that cost him his love by becoming the scourge of the Caribbean. So when a gorgeous young man washes up out of nowhere with a promise of the haul of a lifetime, well, it's only prudent to take him aboard and find out if he's less crazy than he seems.

SILVERFIN is a fun and frisky adventure with a lot of heart and double the happy endings. I was charmed by Silverfin's irreverent take on human customs and anatomy, as well as his unbridled delight when Hawk showed him just what that anatomy could do. :D I also loved the B-plot with Silverfin's sister Mara, who managed to support her brother's dream while wrangling a happily ever after of her own.
Profile Image for K.
666 reviews31 followers
Read
August 18, 2026
Due to manuscript revisions, the tour that I was due to read this book for was cancelled, but I received the revised ARC from the authors anyway, so still read the book.

I want to preface this with a few comments: one, I don't tend to like spice but I've been trying to read outside of my comfort zone, and two, the reasons I dislike this may be the exact reasons someone else loves it, so I'm still going to be honest.

I think really, where I went wrong was expecting something a bit like OFMD. This book is a queer interpretation of The Little Mermaid, and it absolutely does not have the plot richness of OFMD. To me, this read as a PWP fanfic - and I know there is absolutely a market for that, and there is a reason it is a popular tag on fanfic sites!

Reading this book, sadly, was an exercise in confirming my dislike of spicy stories, rather than expanding my interests. About sixty percent of the book was sex, and the storyline was absolutely secondary to that. Could I tell you anything about the characters' interests or passions beyond? Nope.

If you're looking for a lighthearted spicy achillean romance, I wholeheartedly recommend this book.
Profile Image for Panda Marie.
10 reviews1 follower
July 12, 2026
*ARC READ*


“ You are so much and everything I adore.”

This story is a fun combination of The Little Mermaid and Pirates of the Caribbean. Two of my favorite movies.

Instead of giving up his voice to the sea witch, Silverfin gives up his beautiful hair to the sea queen Mama Wata for his legs. There are no time constraints or requirements on Silverfin to make Captain Hawk fall in love with him which makes the story low angst. It’s almost an instalove story, with Silverfin’s supporting character sister Mara and a sassy crab attendant.

Silverfin still having his voice brings a lot of humor to the story since he says all the weird things that make Hawk do a double take.

All and all this story was a quick and fun read!
Profile Image for Wayne Tunks.
Author 2 books7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 15, 2026
What a delightful book it is, a charming and swash buckling adventure between a Mer-Sir and the pirate captain he has watched for years. I hadn't read a fantasy like this before and wasn't sure what to expect but ended up thoroughly enjoying it.
Enjoyable moments seeing Silverfin getting used to his new legs, all three of them, and the confusion and infatuation of Hawk, beguiled by the new man in his life promising to take him to find gold.
It is quite spicy and an easy read. Definitely recommended!
73 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 19, 2026
This is a fun, relatively short MM retelling of The Little Mermaid. In this version, the main character, Silverfin, saves the pirate king, makes a deal with a sea witch and comes back as a human. In order to get him to pay attention to Silverfin, he promises the location of a ship full of gold. If you love Ariel's cluelessness about all things human, then you will enjoy watching Silverfin explore his new world. If you're looking for something short and steamy, this is a relatively quick read that will keep you entertained.

Profile Image for El.
227 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 30, 2026
I received an ARC from the Authors!

I already know from their other collaborations that A.E. LeMercier and Simona Niles team up to write hilarious stuff together - and this one had me in stitches in so many parts! Silverfin is precious and I want to protect him with my life. No wonder the pirate captain falls for him despite being so focused on his own misery. I also really enjoyed the cornucopia of Sapphics who are the only people with a brain in this - and I'm very much here for it.

Sweet and spicy and just the right size to make this my favorite summer read!
Profile Image for Nancy.
3 reviews
September 5, 2026
Review for the audio: Great listen!! This was a delightfully loose retelling of the Little Mermaid. It had me laughing out loud and cheering for the MerSir and his pirate king. And I loved the style of the narration! Luulu Soul played a wide range of characters including the adorable MerSir in question, and Tyler Laux lent his voice to the sexy pirate Hawk. It was definitely more along the lines of voice acting than just your average narration.
Profile Image for Dee Layton.
1,621 reviews29 followers
August 8, 2026
This was an absolutely beautiful book. This book was a book that I sat down an immersed myself in from the very beginning. I also could not put it down and fell for the characters. This is the first time I have ever read this author and I am so hooked. I can't wait to see what they put out in the future or what is out now.
Profile Image for ShadowSmut Jen.
32 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 30, 2026
Loved this soooo much! Funny and heartwarming and hot! I fell in love with Silverfin right away, the characters in this story were all wonderful. I could not put this down, the spice was fantastic, a definite 5/5 read perfect for the summer!
Profile Image for Danielle.
10 reviews
July 12, 2026
Got an ACR copy of this book and really enjoyed it. It was really cute and fun to read. Would definitely recommend this book if you’re looking for a mix of The Little Mermaid and Pirates of the Caribbean.
Profile Image for Belinda Zamora.
3,111 reviews8 followers
July 31, 2026
I absolutely adored this hilarious and charming retelling of The Little Mermaid and Pirates of the Caribbean.
There's plenty of swashbuckling adventures to be had and the relationship development between Silverton and Hawk was absolutely amazing.
Profile Image for The Book Ssirren.
7,745 reviews192 followers
August 4, 2026
This story was funny, and filled with giggles. It was also very hot and had me fanning myself. I absolutely adored Silverfin. Hawke took awhile to grow on me. But overall this was a really great and fun story.
Profile Image for Heather E..
59 reviews
November 2, 2026
Spicy MM Romance 🔥🔥🔥🔥

Spicy but endearing! If you love MM romance and The Little Mermaid, this is for you!! Trust me you won't be disappointed. Who doesn't love a happy ending? Also the spice between the Captain and Silverfin 🔥🔥🔥 purchase this book today :)
Profile Image for amber.readslikealady.
20 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 15, 2026
This book weaves together high spice and deep emotions with lots of laughs beautifully in such a short amount of time. I loved everything: the trauma (check triggers), the banter, and the heat.
Profile Image for Therena.
Author 9 books527 followers
August 13, 2026
A cute MM mermaid (mersir) story if you want something spicy and endearing but low angst.
Profile Image for Hazeleyedbookdragon.
80 reviews4 followers
September 6, 2026
A swashbuckling good time! This spicy queer little mermaid retelling brings the heat and the humor. The audio narration is top tier!!! Pirates, merfolk, humor and spice… what more could you ask for?
Profile Image for Misty Bell.
305 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 9, 2026
This was adorable. A lovesick Mersir finds a grieving pirate captain and saves him from drowning himself. Gives his hair for legs and promises treasure to get close to him. Hawk thinks Silver is insane but goes along with it and falls head over heels for him along the way. Just a really cute story with lots of spice and humor.

Thanks to Hawthorn & Aster for the ARC!
Profile Image for Nicola Clements.
93 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 6, 2026
This was an ARC

This book is such a fun read!
I was in fits of giggles at the MerSir, Silverfin. His love interest is Hawk...a pirate.

I read this book in one go, couldn't put it down. If you're after a light hearted, fun spicy read, then this story is ideal.

It was a pleasure to get to read this by the authors, very much appreciated.

Thankyou A.E and Simona, you both have brilliant imaginations.
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews