Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

What It Feels Like

Rate this book
Maggie Townsend is great on her own.

A senior at the University of Washington, living with her best friend, and managing her obsessive-compulsive disorder better than she has in years, things are finally . . . good.

Sure, she has no clue what she wants to do with her life, has been single for longer than she cares to admit, and just watched her little sister get engaged—but it’s fine. Everything is fine.

So when her OCD starts spiking again, she blames it on the fact that graduation is fast approaching, she has a wedding to help plan, and that she suddenly can’t seem to stop running into the cute guy that she hasn’t seen since high school, everywhere. She tries to be the person everyone expects her to be and do what she always put a smile on her face and handle it.

She’ll show up every time, hoping no one notices the tapping on her leg, or the bags under her eyes, or the way she wonders what would happen if her thoughts get too loud. But when her grip on everything she’s worked so hard to stabilize starts to slip and the precariously balanced tower of her life starts to tilt—she wonders if she’s going to find out.

327 pages, Kindle Edition

Published May 19, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Allie Otoski

3 books75 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
15 (51%)
4 stars
7 (24%)
3 stars
7 (24%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
Profile Image for Allie Otoski.
Author 3 books75 followers
July 4, 2026
Oh hey btw I wrote another book! It’s out now! 😄
Profile Image for Isha.
Author 2 books9 followers
June 3, 2026
⭐️3.5 STARS⭐️

I loved Allie Otoski’s MORE THAN JUST US, which led to my pickup of WHAT IT FEELS LIKE. It does such a wonderful job of depicting the struggles of someone with OCD, and how that ties into someone who has anxiety. I LOVED reading about how Maggie struggled with her conditions and mental health (of course, don’t love it for her, but it felt very representative of the crew), and how it affected her relationships as a whole.

I also am obsessed with Maggie and Lev. This book is a bit different from Stella and Bridger’s story because the romance takes up less space, but I felt it worked really well in the story, since it gave Maggie the room to work out these issues on her own. The writing in general is very beautiful, and it was also super funny; I definitely laughed in surprise multiple times when reading. We also get to see Stella’s growth into a more confident, outgoing version of herself, and see her support Maggie so much.

Instead of centrally focusing on Maggie’s romance with Lev, the book focuses on her relationships with her parents, sister, and brother. Mostly, it focuses on her own anxieties and inward struggles. It spends a lot of time going through her inner thoughts.

Something that I thought was interesting: Maggie came off as a chaotic and outgoing character in MTJU, but here, reading about her inner thoughts made it feel the opposite. She was very awkward while speaking and overthought a lot of her words, and even Stella seemed more outgoing than she did. This shifted later on in the story, but I was wondering why it felt to be the opposite for the first bit.

What I think was missing for me: I felt that we spent a lot of time getting the same thoughts and breakdowns of Maggie’s inner thoughts. I don’t know how to explain this super well, but they were very repetitive (not the OCD effects/anxious thoughts themselves, but other inner monologues where she analyzes those). I think it took away from us seeing her OCD and anxiety worsen, and it also took away from seeing her character growth. So when everything went down at the 75%-ish mark, it felt so sudden and eventful, and THEN you got to see her change all of a sudden. I wish that I got to read about it throughout the whole novel instead of that repetition through the first half.

This book is very very different from MTJU, so don’t assume it’s the same (and both books are absolutely great—just different)!! I think it does a great job of depicting mental health/OCD/Anxiety in an honest, deep way while still being more lighthearted and an easier romance than the first one. Looking forward to more of Allie Otoski’s writing :) 🧡
Profile Image for Tara.
463 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 13, 2026
An absolute EASY 5 star!!!! I had the honor of being a sensitivity reader for this book and I could not have loved it more, it felt like these characters were written for me. I connected SO MUCH with our FMC, the representation of ICD was written in such a real, authentic and true way. I got chills reading so many lines in this book truly just because of how much I understood and connected to it. Allie is such a talented storyteller and I have no doubt has such a bright future in writing. I’m so glad I was able to read this one early and give my little input of the OCD rep, it’s clear how much the author cares about making it feels as natural and real as possible! So far this has been my favorite read of the year!! I’ve been waitingggg for Maggie’s story and it DID NOT disappoint!!!

Thank you to the author for an early beta copy of this book, it was an honored to read this one! All opinions are 100% my own!
Profile Image for Thecuckoo.
3 reviews
July 5, 2026
Such a good and accurate depiction of OCD. Maggie is a great character and so glad she finds her person in Lev. Although I must say I was a blubbering mess the last quarter of the book. Could not put it down.
Profile Image for Bri Wray.
3 reviews
July 19, 2026
The EASIEST 5 stars I’ve ever given. My favorite author!!! Allie truly has a gift. She gives such life and meaning to these characters and is so intentional. Her books have a beautiful way of making me feel at home. ❤️❤️
Profile Image for Abs.
331 reviews8 followers
June 26, 2026
I adored this story!!! I related to Maggie’s story more than I thought, & i loved the dynamic between her and Lev
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews