Tom Thomson: The Silence and the Storm

by David P. Silcox

With over seventy new reproductions of never-before-published paintings and new essays, Tom Thomson is the most comprehensive collection of the artist’s work ever published. The original edition in 1977 commemorated the 100th year of Thomson’s birth and the 60th of his untimely death. Tom The Silence and The Storm was an instant classic. Thomson’s brief, brilliant life, and his mysterious death in a canoe accident, quickly gained him mythic status. The book became a legend in its own right and a perennial favourite among Canadian art fans and collectors. This newly designed and greatly expanded edition revives a classic, adds many new images, and offers new insights into Thomson’s work, his techniques and his enduring appeal. Candid in its assessment of one of twentieth-century Canada’s biggest art stars, Tom Thomson stands out for its original approach and thoroughness. Thomson’s sketches and finest works are reproduced in colour, at approximately the same size as the originals. This stunning new edition is a fitting tribute to a great and beloved Canadian artist.

Genres: Art, Nonfiction, Biography, Canada

272 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 1977

Reviews

[Jaidee · Rating 5 out of 5]

5 "mystical, immersive, pleasurable" stars !!!

Tie-6th Favorite Read of 2024 Award

My ardent affection for Tom Thomson continues to grow as I continue to explore his life and artistry. I was able to get this ebook from the library and it far surpassed all my expectations in both formatting, education and enjoyment. To have eighty percent of his art in one collection is a true treasure.

The introduction is both audacious and purple and so unlike Mr. Thomson's art that it served as a very cheeky counterpoint. The main chapters were informative and interpretive and I disagree with much but that only added to my own appreciation and burgeoning admiration. As my partner and I continue to move away from human interaction and spend more and more time solitarily focusing on our own art, domestic crafts, nature and spiritual practices this book was a both a boon and a balm.

I was moved immensely sometimes to blissful tears as I meditated on some of the paintings and sketches and truly was soul food for me.

My darling partner has ordered me a hard copy and this will truly be one of my most favorite art books and will be added to our small collection.

Mr. Thompson's early death is now just not sad for me but tragic as who knows where his art would have led...

I am including three of my most favorite paintings....

Northern River 1914-1915




Pine Tree at Sunset 1915



Maple Saplings 1916



Rest in peace Mr. Thompson and thank you for your vision of our Ontario Near North which is now my home...

[Alex O'Brien · Rating 5 out of 5]

Absolutely gorgeous colour representations of Tom Thomson's paintings and sketches, along with interesting biographical information and artistic assessment.

[David · Rating 5 out of 5]

Few coffee table books like this are as well organized chronologically and theme wise as this book. It is well researched informative and inspirational. A Thorough pleasure to read and observe some of the best paintings ever done by a Canadian!!!

[Marjorie · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the second read for me. I received it as a gift in 1978. Recently I listened to a YouTube video 0n Tom Thompson and this book was mentioned.
It is mainly pictures of Tom's work. The authors talk about his work and the men who worked with painted with and supported him.
He died, likely falling from his canoe and striking his head. Many stories have grown around his death making him a bit of a mystery.
It would have been interesting had he lived to see the direction he may have taken his painting.
This is a beautiful book and has been republished.

[Janet Roger · Rating 5 out of 5]

Until I arrived in Vancouver a few weeks ago I had never heard of Tom Thompson. Which in some ways is a pity because it means I’ve been many years not knowing some stunning Canadian landscape portrayals and a handful of spectacular flower paintings. On the other hand there’s not much better than coming across an artist out of the blue and realizing that as isolated as Tom Thompson was from the developing trends in European art at the turn of the 20th century, he was nevertheless formulating his own particular style that had he lived longer may well have tipped over into full blown expressionism.

But he didn’t live longer. On July 8th 1917, Thompson’s body was found floating in Canoe Lake in Algonquin Park, Ontario. Did he fall or was he pushed? Well, the authors talk about that too but their book was published in 1977, sixty years after the event when theories still multiplied and science wasn’t helping out much. Now, more than a hundred years on, with much improved forensic skills to hand, it seems no one knows for sure where to find the body. Maybe everyone prefers the mystery.

Given the large format, you might be forgiven for mistaking this for a coffee-table book but it’s not. In fact it’s about as close as we can get to seeing Thompson’s oil sketches in their original size, without turning up at an exhibition. I enjoyed it immensely.

[Gregory Klages · Rating 2 out of 5]

The thirtieth anniversary revised edition of "Tom Thomson: The Silence and the Storm" offers an abundance of attractive reproductions of Thomson’s art. The text, however, suffers from at least two disappointing and surprising factual errors about the facts of Tom Thomson's death.

On pg. 49, the text states:
“[Thomson’s] feet weren’t tangled in wire, as has been repeatedly suggested, because [Mark] Robinson noted at the time the body was recovered that Thomson had carefully bound copper fishing line around a sprained ankle to give it support."

What are the errors?:
- In 1917, Mark Robinson did not record finding fishing line on Thomson’s corpse.
- Mark Robinson never, ever mentioned anything about Thomson having an ankle sprain.

For a fuller explanation, with web links to evidence, read my comments at:
goo.gl/HLXX5p

[Phlat Philler]

Grew up with this book in my home. As new immigrants to Canada in the seventies, it was a revelation. Many years later I recall canoeing in the spot where Tom Thomson mysteriously died. It was like coming home. This book, as Thomson's work is part of my heritage. I love it.