What do you think?
Rate this book
Not Yours Duet #1
Whispered Promises
I’ve been alone my whole life. That part I can handle.
It’s the grief that’s breaking me.
After losing the only person who ever chose me, I’m running on empty, tending my rescue farm, fighting my anxiety, and lying awake at 3am pretending I’m fine. I don’t need saving. I just need to survive.
Then four men step into my life.
Nate, who scowls at everyone except me.
Noah, who sits with me in the quiet and never asks for more than I can give.
Brynn, who learns my favourite foods and makes sure I never go without.
And Max, who treats making me laugh like it’s the most important job he’s ever had.
I didn’t ask for any of this, but warmth has a way of getting in.
The problem is, not everyone circling my life has good intentions. Some people want what I have.
And some will take it, regardless of the consequences or the hurt it causes.
Will it be possible for us all to forgive and forget, or will we forever drown in fear and heartache? Or maybe we'll never get the chance to know.
Whispered Promises is a spicy, medium burn, MFMMM why choose romance. It's the first in the Not Yours Duet and ends on a cliffhanger. For mature readers, and parts may be triggering. The second in the duet is a darker read.
It’s the grief that’s breaking me.
After losing the only person who ever chose me, I’m running on empty, tending my rescue farm, fighting my anxiety, and lying awake at 3am pretending I’m fine. I don’t need saving. I just need to survive.
Then four men step into my life.
Nate, who scowls at everyone except me.
Noah, who sits with me in the quiet and never asks for more than I can give.
Brynn, who learns my favourite foods and makes sure I never go without.
And Max, who treats making me laugh like it’s the most important job he’s ever had.
I didn’t ask for any of this, but warmth has a way of getting in.
The problem is, not everyone circling my life has good intentions. Some people want what I have.
And some will take it, regardless of the consequences or the hurt it causes.
Will it be possible for us all to forgive and forget, or will we forever drown in fear and heartache? Or maybe we'll never get the chance to know.
Whispered Promises is a spicy, medium burn, MFMMM why choose romance. It's the first in the Not Yours Duet and ends on a cliffhanger. For mature readers, and parts may be triggering. The second in the duet is a darker read.
431 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 24, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 180 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
You can't, well you can and you did, leave us like that!! Oh, the guys are going to freak!
Rosy is a sweet, insecure, generous human trying to make her way after the loss of her beloved grandmother. She encounters four very different men, each with their own trauma, who find their missing piece in Rosy. I enjoyed the different relationships she is creating with each man and their protectiveness of her. I need book 2 asap, and no, I don't really believe that was even remotely a heartfelt apology....
Rosy is a sweet, insecure, generous human trying to make her way after the loss of her beloved grandmother. She encounters four very different men, each with their own trauma, who find their missing piece in Rosy. I enjoyed the different relationships she is creating with each man and their protectiveness of her. I need book 2 asap, and no, I don't really believe that was even remotely a heartfelt apology....
September 14, 2026
I feel like I need to read Darkened Promises as well before I can form an accurate opinion of this one.
Book 1 in the Not Yours duet focuses on the blooming relationships between Rosy and her men and how she’s navigating having feelings for not one, not two, but four very different men - while also simultaneously struggling with her own insecurities. One would get overwhelmed for less.
With four MMCs and one FMC, there are a lot of main characters to keep track of, but the book does a great job in distinguishing the men and I never got confused as to who is who - not even in the beginning.
I have to admit that the book was a bit too insta-love for me at the beginning, from all parties.
The build-up with Nate and Max flows naturally. Rosy regularly sees Nate at the gym and they walk home together, Max helped out at the animal sanctuary and he came over to spend some time with Moshi - Rosy’s kitten.
The attraction to Noah and Bry on the other hand felt a bit sudden. Bry made food for Rosy a couple of times and she’s going to do a buddy read with Noah but that’s basically it before Rosy starts talking about feelings for them. It would have been more believeable if she’d spent more time with them first. For example cooking together with Bry or actually reading together with Noah. For me, it felt like she just needed to be attracted to them too for the plot in the beginning.
At one point in the story Rosy and Max have a conversation, and Rosy really started to annoy me after that (I can’t go into detail here without spoiling stuff), though she did redeem herself near the end.
The “problem” with most why choose novels I’ve read so far is that they can be more smut than plot, but that wasn’t the case with this book. Obviously there’s more spice towards the end when Rosy’s relationship with the different men progresses, but it never feels like it overshadows the plot.
The book ends on a cliffhanger, and even though there were hints that something threatening was going on, it was mentioned so sporadically that I almost forgot about it.
Because of this, it does make this book feel somewhat like a long setup for the next one. Despite some frustrations, I did enjoy reading it though (and let’s be honest, how can you not love Max?), and I am looking forward to seeing how the story continues in Darkened Promises.
(I received this book as an ARC and I am leaving this review voluntarily.)
Book 1 in the Not Yours duet focuses on the blooming relationships between Rosy and her men and how she’s navigating having feelings for not one, not two, but four very different men - while also simultaneously struggling with her own insecurities. One would get overwhelmed for less.
With four MMCs and one FMC, there are a lot of main characters to keep track of, but the book does a great job in distinguishing the men and I never got confused as to who is who - not even in the beginning.
I have to admit that the book was a bit too insta-love for me at the beginning, from all parties.
The build-up with Nate and Max flows naturally. Rosy regularly sees Nate at the gym and they walk home together, Max helped out at the animal sanctuary and he came over to spend some time with Moshi - Rosy’s kitten.
The attraction to Noah and Bry on the other hand felt a bit sudden. Bry made food for Rosy a couple of times and she’s going to do a buddy read with Noah but that’s basically it before Rosy starts talking about feelings for them. It would have been more believeable if she’d spent more time with them first. For example cooking together with Bry or actually reading together with Noah. For me, it felt like she just needed to be attracted to them too for the plot in the beginning.
At one point in the story Rosy and Max have a conversation, and Rosy really started to annoy me after that (I can’t go into detail here without spoiling stuff), though she did redeem herself near the end.
The “problem” with most why choose novels I’ve read so far is that they can be more smut than plot, but that wasn’t the case with this book. Obviously there’s more spice towards the end when Rosy’s relationship with the different men progresses, but it never feels like it overshadows the plot.
The book ends on a cliffhanger, and even though there were hints that something threatening was going on, it was mentioned so sporadically that I almost forgot about it.
Because of this, it does make this book feel somewhat like a long setup for the next one. Despite some frustrations, I did enjoy reading it though (and let’s be honest, how can you not love Max?), and I am looking forward to seeing how the story continues in Darkened Promises.
(I received this book as an ARC and I am leaving this review voluntarily.)
September 25, 2026
4🌟 | 4🌶️
The combination of emotional vulnerability and four very different MMCs made this an easy romance to get attached to. Rosy was such an easy character to connect with, especially as she dealt with grief and anxiety while slowly letting people into her life. I liked seeing her find comfort in having people around her, even when she wasn’t always sure how to accept it.
Each MMC brought something completely different to the dynamic, which kept the relationships interesting. Max’s golden retriever energy was definitely my weakness, while Nate’s protective side, Noah’s quiet understanding, and Brynn’s thoughtful, caring nature each gave Rosy something different. The relationships developed at slightly different speeds, but I enjoyed watching them become more comfortable and genuine as the story went on.
The emotional side of the romance worked especially well for me, and I liked that the spice added to the relationships without taking over the story. There are hints of something darker happening in the background, and the ending definitely made me curious about where everything is heading.
I finished this feeling invested in the characters and ready to see what comes next.
~~~~
A sincere thank you to Issy Eva and Happily Booked PR for the ARC! 🥰📚
I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
The combination of emotional vulnerability and four very different MMCs made this an easy romance to get attached to. Rosy was such an easy character to connect with, especially as she dealt with grief and anxiety while slowly letting people into her life. I liked seeing her find comfort in having people around her, even when she wasn’t always sure how to accept it.
Each MMC brought something completely different to the dynamic, which kept the relationships interesting. Max’s golden retriever energy was definitely my weakness, while Nate’s protective side, Noah’s quiet understanding, and Brynn’s thoughtful, caring nature each gave Rosy something different. The relationships developed at slightly different speeds, but I enjoyed watching them become more comfortable and genuine as the story went on.
The emotional side of the romance worked especially well for me, and I liked that the spice added to the relationships without taking over the story. There are hints of something darker happening in the background, and the ending definitely made me curious about where everything is heading.
I finished this feeling invested in the characters and ready to see what comes next.
~~~~
A sincere thank you to Issy Eva and Happily Booked PR for the ARC! 🥰📚
I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
September 19, 2026
Wow! I can’t get over that ending! Can’t believe you left us feeling this way 😭
I do love a why choose and this did not disappoint, I wouldn’t choose between them either. I loved them all, although I think Nate would have to be my favourite 🫣
I love how they all build Rosys self esteem and confidence and stand in her corner especially against her dick of a boss!
Bring on book two!!
I do love a why choose and this did not disappoint, I wouldn’t choose between them either. I loved them all, although I think Nate would have to be my favourite 🫣
I love how they all build Rosys self esteem and confidence and stand in her corner especially against her dick of a boss!
Bring on book two!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 21, 2026
Whispered Promises is the first book in the Not Yours Duet—a spicy, medium-burn why choose romance that hits so much harder than you’d expect. It ends on a cliffhanger, is for mature readers, and touches on some difficult themes that may be triggering; just a note that the follow-up leans even darker. An emotional, gripping read that pulls you right in!
I’ve spent my whole life on my own—and I’ve always been okay with that. It’s the grief that’s tearing me apart.
Now that the only person who ever truly chose me is gone, I’m running on nothing but fumes: looking after my rescue farm, fighting every wave of anxiety, lying awake at 3am telling everyone I’m managing just fine. I don’t need anyone to come to my rescue. I just need to get through each day.
Then four men walk into my world.
Nate, who scowls at the whole room but softens the second he looks at me.
Noah, who’ll sit in the quiet with me for hours, never pushing for more than I can give.
Brynn, who memorises every little thing I like and makes sure I never go without.
And Max, who treats making me smile like it’s the only thing that matters.
I never asked for any of this—but warmth has a way of seeping through even the thickest walls. But not everyone hovering close by means well. Some want what I have, and they’ll take it, no matter who gets hurt along the way.
Can we ever leave the fear and heartache behind? Or will we never even get the chance to try?
I’ve spent my whole life on my own—and I’ve always been okay with that. It’s the grief that’s tearing me apart.
Now that the only person who ever truly chose me is gone, I’m running on nothing but fumes: looking after my rescue farm, fighting every wave of anxiety, lying awake at 3am telling everyone I’m managing just fine. I don’t need anyone to come to my rescue. I just need to get through each day.
Then four men walk into my world.
Nate, who scowls at the whole room but softens the second he looks at me.
Noah, who’ll sit in the quiet with me for hours, never pushing for more than I can give.
Brynn, who memorises every little thing I like and makes sure I never go without.
And Max, who treats making me smile like it’s the only thing that matters.
I never asked for any of this—but warmth has a way of seeping through even the thickest walls. But not everyone hovering close by means well. Some want what I have, and they’ll take it, no matter who gets hurt along the way.
Can we ever leave the fear and heartache behind? Or will we never even get the chance to try?
September 1, 2026
Thank you to Happily Booked PR and Issy Eva for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a honest review.
I’ve been alone my whole life. That part I can handle. It’s the grief that’s breaking me. After losing the only person who ever chose me, I’m running on empty, tending my rescue farm, fighting my anxiety, and lying awake at 3am pretending I’m fine. I don’t need saving. I just need to survive. Then four men step into my life. Nate, who scowls at everyone except me. Noah, who sits with me in the quiet and never asks for more than I can give. Brynn, who learns my favourite foods and makes sure I never go without. And Max, who treats making me laugh like it’s the most important job he’s ever had. I didn’t ask for any of this, but warmth has a way of getting in. The problem is, not everyone circling my life has good intentions. Some people want what I have. And some will take it, regardless of the consequences or the hurt it causes. Will it be possible for us all to forgive and forget, or will we forever drown in fear and heartache? Or maybe we'll never get the chance to know.
Rosy is an absolute sweetheart. So kind and caring, she wears her heart completely on her sleeve. There were moments I wish we could have seen her with a little more backbone yet at the same time she was perfect. I saw far too much of myself in Rosy, so perhaps that’s why I wanted her to stand up for herself more. Because I can be too giving and too patient and too kind to a point it incites frustration as it’s then expected of me. It’ll be interesting to see how her character develops after that ending!
The boys were certainly interesting and fun to read. From Nate’s dirty mouth and protective instincts, to Noah’s sweetness and vulnerability, to Bry’s caretaking and magic hands with cooking, to Max’s ability to lighten up a room… All together they created a dynamic that felt real and comfortable - like a warm hug. It was great getting to see each of them have individual time with Rosy, allowing her to bring each of them out their shells and be more authentic. I can only imagine that the ending is going to throw a massive spanner in and trigger all of their protective instincts. I can’t wait to see it.
If I stumble across a why choose story, you can pretty much guarantee that I’m going to read it. This one drew me in because of the emotional aspect. We have a female lead who is filled with anxious thoughts and feelings and four men who are besotted with her, flaws and all. I will say, this book felt very light on actual plot which is reflected in my rating. Don’t get me wrong, I really liked the fact that emotions are openly discussed and explored as part of the group, but it feels as though very little else happens beyond being emotional and slowly getting to know each other. We do get some serious creepiness at work which is something that contributes but it remains more of a glossed over plot point than a key part unfortunately. Character wise, it’s all very confined to the group or work which works for the story. Our focus is very much on the attraction each of them feels and remains there. I would have loved more with Steph, Rosy’s roommate, as she was so sweet and supportive! But totally get that word constraints make such a thing difficult. Romance wise, it felt simultaneously insta-love and slow burn. I’m not a fan of insta-love romances but because of this slow burn aspect and things thriving off emotions, I found myself enjoying watching relationships unfold and strengthen. And I can safely say the spice delivered too! The ending has me utterly intrigued by what is going to happen in the sequel. Despite my medium rating, I definitely want to see what happens next. I’m hoping that I’ll love it more than the beginning of their story!
Overall, Whispered Promises is a why choose romance that certainly intrigued me, though slightly missed the mark on plot.
⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Thank you again to Happily Booked PR and Issy Eva for an advanced copy of this book.
I’ve been alone my whole life. That part I can handle. It’s the grief that’s breaking me. After losing the only person who ever chose me, I’m running on empty, tending my rescue farm, fighting my anxiety, and lying awake at 3am pretending I’m fine. I don’t need saving. I just need to survive. Then four men step into my life. Nate, who scowls at everyone except me. Noah, who sits with me in the quiet and never asks for more than I can give. Brynn, who learns my favourite foods and makes sure I never go without. And Max, who treats making me laugh like it’s the most important job he’s ever had. I didn’t ask for any of this, but warmth has a way of getting in. The problem is, not everyone circling my life has good intentions. Some people want what I have. And some will take it, regardless of the consequences or the hurt it causes. Will it be possible for us all to forgive and forget, or will we forever drown in fear and heartache? Or maybe we'll never get the chance to know.
Rosy is an absolute sweetheart. So kind and caring, she wears her heart completely on her sleeve. There were moments I wish we could have seen her with a little more backbone yet at the same time she was perfect. I saw far too much of myself in Rosy, so perhaps that’s why I wanted her to stand up for herself more. Because I can be too giving and too patient and too kind to a point it incites frustration as it’s then expected of me. It’ll be interesting to see how her character develops after that ending!
The boys were certainly interesting and fun to read. From Nate’s dirty mouth and protective instincts, to Noah’s sweetness and vulnerability, to Bry’s caretaking and magic hands with cooking, to Max’s ability to lighten up a room… All together they created a dynamic that felt real and comfortable - like a warm hug. It was great getting to see each of them have individual time with Rosy, allowing her to bring each of them out their shells and be more authentic. I can only imagine that the ending is going to throw a massive spanner in and trigger all of their protective instincts. I can’t wait to see it.
If I stumble across a why choose story, you can pretty much guarantee that I’m going to read it. This one drew me in because of the emotional aspect. We have a female lead who is filled with anxious thoughts and feelings and four men who are besotted with her, flaws and all. I will say, this book felt very light on actual plot which is reflected in my rating. Don’t get me wrong, I really liked the fact that emotions are openly discussed and explored as part of the group, but it feels as though very little else happens beyond being emotional and slowly getting to know each other. We do get some serious creepiness at work which is something that contributes but it remains more of a glossed over plot point than a key part unfortunately. Character wise, it’s all very confined to the group or work which works for the story. Our focus is very much on the attraction each of them feels and remains there. I would have loved more with Steph, Rosy’s roommate, as she was so sweet and supportive! But totally get that word constraints make such a thing difficult. Romance wise, it felt simultaneously insta-love and slow burn. I’m not a fan of insta-love romances but because of this slow burn aspect and things thriving off emotions, I found myself enjoying watching relationships unfold and strengthen. And I can safely say the spice delivered too! The ending has me utterly intrigued by what is going to happen in the sequel. Despite my medium rating, I definitely want to see what happens next. I’m hoping that I’ll love it more than the beginning of their story!
Overall, Whispered Promises is a why choose romance that certainly intrigued me, though slightly missed the mark on plot.
⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Thank you again to Happily Booked PR and Issy Eva for an advanced copy of this book.
September 30, 2026
FMC surprised when not 1 but 4 men actually want her
Whispered Promises is the debut by Issy Eva and is a duet so expect a cliffhanger ending. Book one was very sweet and book two is supposed to be dark which makes sense when you get to said cliffhanger.
I will say that there was a lot more getting to know you and opportunity to fall in love with some of the character more than others. I also think the one who hurt her with his words needed to work harder but that's just me.
So we have Rosy our FMC who is a sweet but shy people pleaser. She is still grieving the loss of the one person who was always there for her. She has one friend who is also her roommate. Rosy needs confidence and someone to want her for who she is.
Enter the four men who are her neighbors. Nate is the guy she met at the gym. He is easy to talk to and they tend to work out together even in companionable silence. He is the overprotective one who avoids relationships. Max is full golden retriever. He is quick to offer to help at the sanctuary or come say high to the scared foster kitten. He is sweet and loveable. Brynn is thoughtful and nurturing. He is the one who cooks and feeds everyone. He has no issues accommodating her preferences and is happy to feed her every day. Lastly we have quiet Noah. He is our reader and these two take turns suggesting books to buddy read or listen to.
All of the guys are sweet but our girl is guarded and it takes her a while to open up. She is also always waiting for them to decide she isn't worth it.
I was not surprised by what happened at the end but it felt like most of the story avoided what the "threat" might be. I'm definitely interested in seeing what happens in book 2.
Whispered Promises is the debut by Issy Eva and is a duet so expect a cliffhanger ending. Book one was very sweet and book two is supposed to be dark which makes sense when you get to said cliffhanger.
I will say that there was a lot more getting to know you and opportunity to fall in love with some of the character more than others. I also think the one who hurt her with his words needed to work harder but that's just me.
So we have Rosy our FMC who is a sweet but shy people pleaser. She is still grieving the loss of the one person who was always there for her. She has one friend who is also her roommate. Rosy needs confidence and someone to want her for who she is.
Enter the four men who are her neighbors. Nate is the guy she met at the gym. He is easy to talk to and they tend to work out together even in companionable silence. He is the overprotective one who avoids relationships. Max is full golden retriever. He is quick to offer to help at the sanctuary or come say high to the scared foster kitten. He is sweet and loveable. Brynn is thoughtful and nurturing. He is the one who cooks and feeds everyone. He has no issues accommodating her preferences and is happy to feed her every day. Lastly we have quiet Noah. He is our reader and these two take turns suggesting books to buddy read or listen to.
All of the guys are sweet but our girl is guarded and it takes her a while to open up. She is also always waiting for them to decide she isn't worth it.
I was not surprised by what happened at the end but it felt like most of the story avoided what the "threat" might be. I'm definitely interested in seeing what happens in book 2.
Read
September 20, 2026Advance copy received from Wings and Words and the author.
My first why choose and what an easy start to this trop!
A good 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ romance.
I had such a good time with Whispered Promises! Rosy was easy to connect with, and I loved the mix of personalities between her and the four guys. Each relationship felt different, which made the story really enjoyable.
There’s plenty of chemistry, some fun moments, and just enough mystery to keep me curious about what’s coming next. It’s clear this book is setting everything up for the second half, and honestly, I’m ready for it!
Definitely looking forward to book two!
My first why choose and what an easy start to this trop!
A good 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ romance.
I had such a good time with Whispered Promises! Rosy was easy to connect with, and I loved the mix of personalities between her and the four guys. Each relationship felt different, which made the story really enjoyable.
There’s plenty of chemistry, some fun moments, and just enough mystery to keep me curious about what’s coming next. It’s clear this book is setting everything up for the second half, and honestly, I’m ready for it!
Definitely looking forward to book two!
September 13, 2026
Thank you to Issy Eva and Beth at wings and words for allowing me to arc read this book.
Wow wow wow, Rosy is shy and insecure young woman who is trying to find her way after loosing her beloved nanna, trying to juggle 2 jobs and a volunteering job, she comes across Nate, Noah, Max and bryn, I loved the relationships she has with these four men who also have there very own trauma, they all look after her and they all try and protect Rosy, in the best way possible.
I devoured this book and then the cliffhanger happened, I cannot wait for book 2 to come out
Wow wow wow, Rosy is shy and insecure young woman who is trying to find her way after loosing her beloved nanna, trying to juggle 2 jobs and a volunteering job, she comes across Nate, Noah, Max and bryn, I loved the relationships she has with these four men who also have there very own trauma, they all look after her and they all try and protect Rosy, in the best way possible.
I devoured this book and then the cliffhanger happened, I cannot wait for book 2 to come out
Review of advance copy
my first ever why choose and it didnt disappoint i got this book as an arc reader and i feel honoured. i need book two like yesterday that ending. damn. for me ity was an easy read but i feel thats because of the light plot and the fact we saw all men develop a relationship with rosy the fmc. i loved the protectedness of Nate, Noah, max and Bryn despite thneir own traumas. i would reccommend and i deffo need book 2.
September 23, 2026
I would like to say thank you to the author Izzy Eva and the wings and words community for giving me the opportunity to read this book.
This book was truly inspiring I loved every part of it. The writing was amazing and I loved that all of the characters were realistic and relatable. It’s also a why choose and that’s one of my favourite types of books this was one of the best books I have read in a while and I would highly recommend it was enjoyed and made me laugh.
There are five main characters:
First Rosy the MFC I loved her because she was the kind of woman who was relatable she was strong in her own way through her kindness and empathy for others but she also had her realistic insecurities and weaknesses some of her thought patterns in the book by the way she was written was so realistic to real life situations where people struggle with vulnerabilities and anxiety and they are slightly awkward at times so I enjoyed that about her the most.
Then you have Nate one of the protective love of interests he was protective and possessive but he has a soft spot for her so I loved him.
Then max the sweet lovable guy who made me laugh so much and was just a flirty fantastic love interest with his own flaws that’s what I like about the writing they will have their own flaws and insecurities, but I love him regardless.
Then you have Noah an empathetic emotionally mature sweetheart, who was an amazing listener and he was supportive to one of the characters especially the FMC and he had a flirty side as well, but he was just more of a gentleman about it which I loved because every single one of the MMC is different, but I love them all for different reasons that’s what makes this book so unique and special.
Then last, but not least certainly not least because I think he’s my favourite overall even though it’s hard to decide we have Bry. He’s also a sweetheart and he is good at cooking and he takes care of them all. He’s such a gentleman as well and their relationship was unique because him and MFC took a more SlowBurn approach and it was interesting to read I definitely want to see more of him in the next book though but he’s most definitely my favourite because a man cares that deeply is lovely to see in a book and he has a beautiful qualities alongside his flaws
I will recommend this book probably for the rest of my life. It was incredible and every character was well thought out loveable and uniquely flawed I loved every single one of them for different reasons and they were all different and it was great to see so many different varieties of personality in the MMC’s.
My only complaint is that I want book 2 RIGHT NOW! Because that ending was too much and it was diabolical
This book was truly inspiring I loved every part of it. The writing was amazing and I loved that all of the characters were realistic and relatable. It’s also a why choose and that’s one of my favourite types of books this was one of the best books I have read in a while and I would highly recommend it was enjoyed and made me laugh.
There are five main characters:
First Rosy the MFC I loved her because she was the kind of woman who was relatable she was strong in her own way through her kindness and empathy for others but she also had her realistic insecurities and weaknesses some of her thought patterns in the book by the way she was written was so realistic to real life situations where people struggle with vulnerabilities and anxiety and they are slightly awkward at times so I enjoyed that about her the most.
Then you have Nate one of the protective love of interests he was protective and possessive but he has a soft spot for her so I loved him.
Then max the sweet lovable guy who made me laugh so much and was just a flirty fantastic love interest with his own flaws that’s what I like about the writing they will have their own flaws and insecurities, but I love him regardless.
Then you have Noah an empathetic emotionally mature sweetheart, who was an amazing listener and he was supportive to one of the characters especially the FMC and he had a flirty side as well, but he was just more of a gentleman about it which I loved because every single one of the MMC is different, but I love them all for different reasons that’s what makes this book so unique and special.
Then last, but not least certainly not least because I think he’s my favourite overall even though it’s hard to decide we have Bry. He’s also a sweetheart and he is good at cooking and he takes care of them all. He’s such a gentleman as well and their relationship was unique because him and MFC took a more SlowBurn approach and it was interesting to read I definitely want to see more of him in the next book though but he’s most definitely my favourite because a man cares that deeply is lovely to see in a book and he has a beautiful qualities alongside his flaws
I will recommend this book probably for the rest of my life. It was incredible and every character was well thought out loveable and uniquely flawed I loved every single one of them for different reasons and they were all different and it was great to see so many different varieties of personality in the MMC’s.
My only complaint is that I want book 2 RIGHT NOW! Because that ending was too much and it was diabolical
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received an ARC of Whispered Promises, and I genuinely really enjoyed this book.
Rosie was such an easy character to connect with. I loved how much she cared about animals, especially through her volunteering at the farm, and I really liked seeing her slowly become part of this little family made up of Nate, Max and the other guys. The relationship dynamic is definitely unconventional, and at first I wasn’t quite sure how I was going to feel about it. Rosie is attracted to more than one of them, they all develop feelings for her, and the idea of them sharing a relationship is eventually brought up. It’s definitely not your typical romance setup, and there were moments where the situation felt slightly strange to me simply because it is so far outside the usual relationship structure. However, I thought the way it was approached was actually very well done. Nothing felt rushed, and the more sensitive conversations surrounding their feelings, boundaries and fears were handled with a lot more care than I expected. I especially liked Max’s storyline. His hesitation made sense because of what he had been through in his previous relationship, and I liked that his fear of getting hurt again wasn’t simply ignored for the sake of the romance. His friendship with Rosie and the tension between what they both wanted made their relationship one of the most interesting parts of the book for me. I also really loved the found-family element. The guys genuinely care about Rosie, and as the book progresses you can really see how protective they become of her and how naturally she begins fitting into their lives.
There is also a lot happening outside of the romance. Rosie is dealing with a horrible work environment, a creepy boss, pressure surrounding her living situation, and mysterious messages and gift from an unknown person. I liked that there was this darker mystery running underneath the romance because it gave the story another layer and kept me wondering what was actually going on. And then that ending... The book finishes on a huge cliffhanger, and I definitely need to know what happens next.
Overall, I really enjoyed Whispered Promises. The relationship dynamic may be unconventional, but I thought it was handled thoughtfully, and I loved the connection between Rosie and the guys. Between the romance, the found-family feeling, the emotional moments and the mystery slowly building in the background, there was always something keeping me interested.
Thank you for the ARC! I’m definitely looking forward to continuing the story.
Rosie was such an easy character to connect with. I loved how much she cared about animals, especially through her volunteering at the farm, and I really liked seeing her slowly become part of this little family made up of Nate, Max and the other guys. The relationship dynamic is definitely unconventional, and at first I wasn’t quite sure how I was going to feel about it. Rosie is attracted to more than one of them, they all develop feelings for her, and the idea of them sharing a relationship is eventually brought up. It’s definitely not your typical romance setup, and there were moments where the situation felt slightly strange to me simply because it is so far outside the usual relationship structure. However, I thought the way it was approached was actually very well done. Nothing felt rushed, and the more sensitive conversations surrounding their feelings, boundaries and fears were handled with a lot more care than I expected. I especially liked Max’s storyline. His hesitation made sense because of what he had been through in his previous relationship, and I liked that his fear of getting hurt again wasn’t simply ignored for the sake of the romance. His friendship with Rosie and the tension between what they both wanted made their relationship one of the most interesting parts of the book for me. I also really loved the found-family element. The guys genuinely care about Rosie, and as the book progresses you can really see how protective they become of her and how naturally she begins fitting into their lives.
There is also a lot happening outside of the romance. Rosie is dealing with a horrible work environment, a creepy boss, pressure surrounding her living situation, and mysterious messages and gift from an unknown person. I liked that there was this darker mystery running underneath the romance because it gave the story another layer and kept me wondering what was actually going on. And then that ending... The book finishes on a huge cliffhanger, and I definitely need to know what happens next.
Overall, I really enjoyed Whispered Promises. The relationship dynamic may be unconventional, but I thought it was handled thoughtfully, and I loved the connection between Rosie and the guys. Between the romance, the found-family feeling, the emotional moments and the mystery slowly building in the background, there was always something keeping me interested.
Thank you for the ARC! I’m definitely looking forward to continuing the story.
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
Whispered Promises opens with a quiet kind of heartbreak that feels painfully real.
Rosy has spent her life alone, and while solitude itself never broke her, the fresh grief of losing her beloved grandmother (the one person who ever truly loved her) has left her running on fumes.
She tends her rescue farm, battles anxiety in the small hours, and tells herself she’s fine because survival is the only goal she can manage right now….
Then four men move into her world, neighbours who somehow see past the careful walls she has built and the story becomes something warmer, messier, and far more hopeful than she ever expected.
Nate is the one who scowls at everyone else yet softens only for her. (Favourite microtrope at the moment) Noah simply sits with her in the silence, never demanding more than she can give. Brynn learns her favourite foods and makes sure she never goes without, while Max treats every laugh he can pull from her like the most important work of his life. (I know we shouldn’t have a favourite, but I think Max might just come out on top 🫣)
None of them arrived to save her, and she never asked them to, yet their steady presence begins to crack the isolation she has worn like armour.
The farm, the animals, the slow building domesticity of shared meals and quiet evenings all feel like a gentle reclaiming of space she thought she had lost forever.
What i loved about the book was that undercurrent of threat. Not everyone in her life has kind intentions, and the growing sense that someone wants what she has and will take it without care for the cost adds a tension that kept me turning those pages.
The author balances the hurt/comfort romance with real emotional weight, letting Rosy’s anxiety and grief remain present even as warmth starts to take root. The four men are distinct without competing for the spotlight, each offering a different kind of care that feels earned rather than convenient.
By the time the story closes, the question of whether forgiveness and healing are possible hangs in the air with genuine uncertainty.
Whispered Promises is the kind of contemporary why choose that understands loneliness as both a wound and a kind of strength, and it trusts us to sit with that complexity while still delivering the found family comfort so many of us crave.
It is a tender, slightly shadowed beginning that makes the wait for the second book feel almost unfair.
And one word ……. CLIFFHANGER!!!! 🙃🙃
🦋
*copy supplied for review
4.5 ⭐
Rosy has spent her life alone, and while solitude itself never broke her, the fresh grief of losing her beloved grandmother (the one person who ever truly loved her) has left her running on fumes.
She tends her rescue farm, battles anxiety in the small hours, and tells herself she’s fine because survival is the only goal she can manage right now….
Then four men move into her world, neighbours who somehow see past the careful walls she has built and the story becomes something warmer, messier, and far more hopeful than she ever expected.
Nate is the one who scowls at everyone else yet softens only for her. (Favourite microtrope at the moment) Noah simply sits with her in the silence, never demanding more than she can give. Brynn learns her favourite foods and makes sure she never goes without, while Max treats every laugh he can pull from her like the most important work of his life. (I know we shouldn’t have a favourite, but I think Max might just come out on top 🫣)
None of them arrived to save her, and she never asked them to, yet their steady presence begins to crack the isolation she has worn like armour.
The farm, the animals, the slow building domesticity of shared meals and quiet evenings all feel like a gentle reclaiming of space she thought she had lost forever.
What i loved about the book was that undercurrent of threat. Not everyone in her life has kind intentions, and the growing sense that someone wants what she has and will take it without care for the cost adds a tension that kept me turning those pages.
The author balances the hurt/comfort romance with real emotional weight, letting Rosy’s anxiety and grief remain present even as warmth starts to take root. The four men are distinct without competing for the spotlight, each offering a different kind of care that feels earned rather than convenient.
By the time the story closes, the question of whether forgiveness and healing are possible hangs in the air with genuine uncertainty.
Whispered Promises is the kind of contemporary why choose that understands loneliness as both a wound and a kind of strength, and it trusts us to sit with that complexity while still delivering the found family comfort so many of us crave.
It is a tender, slightly shadowed beginning that makes the wait for the second book feel almost unfair.
And one word ……. CLIFFHANGER!!!! 🙃🙃
🦋
*copy supplied for review
4.5 ⭐
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thank you to Issy Eva and Wings & Words for the ARC opportunity.
I am so excited for Darkened Promises after that ending! I need to know what happens.
Whispered Promises is book one of the Not Yours Yet Duet. We follow Rosy who is trying to work through her anxieties while recovering from the loss of her Nanna. The only person who truly understood, accepted and loved her.
She works multiple jobs to make a living while volunteering at the local animal rescue farm. Using exercise to calm her mind and animals are her safe space. She is a wonderful character who is in need of support but won't admit it to herself.
Luckily she has four ... yes 4! ... handsome neighbours who make her their mission.
Max is the golden retriever who wants to make her happy and laugh. Noah is the cinnamon roll character who shares her love of books and wants to spend time with her. Nate is grumpy and moody but melts for her. Finally there is Brynn who is the caretaker and learns about her favourite things to make her happy. Each character has their own trauma but have come together as a brotherhood.
The why choose is strong in this story with some open door spice.
Finally, sprinkled through the book are unusual texts and incidents that hint towards a threat. Culminating in a cliffhanger.
If you like a why choose reverse harem give this a try.
Tropes:
Why choose
MFMMM
Reverse harem
Found family
Stalking
Anxiety representation
I am so excited for Darkened Promises after that ending! I need to know what happens.
Whispered Promises is book one of the Not Yours Yet Duet. We follow Rosy who is trying to work through her anxieties while recovering from the loss of her Nanna. The only person who truly understood, accepted and loved her.
She works multiple jobs to make a living while volunteering at the local animal rescue farm. Using exercise to calm her mind and animals are her safe space. She is a wonderful character who is in need of support but won't admit it to herself.
Luckily she has four ... yes 4! ... handsome neighbours who make her their mission.
Max is the golden retriever who wants to make her happy and laugh. Noah is the cinnamon roll character who shares her love of books and wants to spend time with her. Nate is grumpy and moody but melts for her. Finally there is Brynn who is the caretaker and learns about her favourite things to make her happy. Each character has their own trauma but have come together as a brotherhood.
The why choose is strong in this story with some open door spice.
Finally, sprinkled through the book are unusual texts and incidents that hint towards a threat. Culminating in a cliffhanger.
If you like a why choose reverse harem give this a try.
Tropes:
Why choose
MFMMM
Reverse harem
Found family
Stalking
Anxiety representation
September 27, 2026
I give Whispered Promises a solid 4 stars! It’s the first book in a duet, and honestly, Chef's kiss, I absolutely loved it.
You get multiple different types of MMCs in this story with Nate, Noah, Maxi, and Bry, and I am completely obsessed with all of them. Now Maxi, there are some things he did that I didn't like, so there are definitely things that he needs to catch up on, not going to lie! His heart just isn't in the right place like Rosy's is yet.
And then there's Peter, that man gives me the creeps. After that ending, I can’t wait to see what happens next. That cliffhanger at the end of Book 1, oh no, no, no... you cannot do that to me! I am proper desperate to get my hands on Book 2 (Darkened Promises) right now so I can see exactly how it all plays out.
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy (ARC) of this book via Happily Booked PR in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.
🌼Why Choose/MFMMM
🖤Medium burn
🌼Neighbours to lovers
🖤Multi POV
🌼Rescue animals
🖤Found family
🌼Anxiety Rep
🖤Darker themes including stalking and grief
🌼No pregnancy
🖤No bullying inside the harem
🌼Hurt/Comfort
🖤Golden Retriever MMC
🌼Introverted FMC
🖤Cinnamon Roll MMC
🌼Caretaker MMC
🖤Grumpy MMC
You get multiple different types of MMCs in this story with Nate, Noah, Maxi, and Bry, and I am completely obsessed with all of them. Now Maxi, there are some things he did that I didn't like, so there are definitely things that he needs to catch up on, not going to lie! His heart just isn't in the right place like Rosy's is yet.
And then there's Peter, that man gives me the creeps. After that ending, I can’t wait to see what happens next. That cliffhanger at the end of Book 1, oh no, no, no... you cannot do that to me! I am proper desperate to get my hands on Book 2 (Darkened Promises) right now so I can see exactly how it all plays out.
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy (ARC) of this book via Happily Booked PR in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.
🌼Why Choose/MFMMM
🖤Medium burn
🌼Neighbours to lovers
🖤Multi POV
🌼Rescue animals
🖤Found family
🌼Anxiety Rep
🖤Darker themes including stalking and grief
🌼No pregnancy
🖤No bullying inside the harem
🌼Hurt/Comfort
🖤Golden Retriever MMC
🌼Introverted FMC
🖤Cinnamon Roll MMC
🌼Caretaker MMC
🖤Grumpy MMC
October 12, 2026
As someone who has never read a romance book before...so decided to jump straight in with a Why Choose....I've totally surprised myself at how much fun I had reading this book! It was such a cosy, un putdownable read that I got through so fast. Too fast in fact because now I can't (but have to) wait to read part two! 👀
I loved the writing style of this and found Rosy and her anxious thoughts so relatable. Its the first time I've read a book with a character whose brain works like mine and that was really captivating. And then to have four guys all besotted with her?! Mind blown 😂🤯 I loved the guys' different personalities and how they each complimented something different with Rosy. And that together they all were able to support one another through their own personal struggles.
I enjoyed the stalker elements scattered throughout the book too, which I know is a taste of what is to come in the next book. It added an exciting extra layer to the story, without overwhelming it, so we could spend lots of time focussing on the characters and relationship building, which set us up for what ever happens next!
Congratulations to Issy Eva for a brilliant debut ❤️
I loved the writing style of this and found Rosy and her anxious thoughts so relatable. Its the first time I've read a book with a character whose brain works like mine and that was really captivating. And then to have four guys all besotted with her?! Mind blown 😂🤯 I loved the guys' different personalities and how they each complimented something different with Rosy. And that together they all were able to support one another through their own personal struggles.
I enjoyed the stalker elements scattered throughout the book too, which I know is a taste of what is to come in the next book. It added an exciting extra layer to the story, without overwhelming it, so we could spend lots of time focussing on the characters and relationship building, which set us up for what ever happens next!
Congratulations to Issy Eva for a brilliant debut ❤️
Review of advance copy received from Author
4.5⭐
Whispered promises follows rosy who is an introverted, animal loving, anxiety ridden, bright clothes wearing women with a huge heart. She lives in a building with her flat mate Steph a few doors down from 4 guys. She meets Max first on passing and they chat and he volunteers at the farm she helps out at, then she meets Nate at the gym she goes to twice a week and they slowly invite her over for dinner where she meets Bry & noah. Rosy is nervous but when she goes she finds a safe space with the guys and gets to know them all individually and falls for them all. Max has golden retriever energy and always makes her laugh, Bry is an amazing cook and always takes care of her, noah is a teacher who helps her emotionally and buddy reads with her & Nate is her gym partner and protector. The guys also all fall for her and decide that they can all date her with no guilt or jealousy involved as long as she's happy. The character development is fantastic. I loved each of them! The real life struggles were spot on. The writing style and the way this story is put together is just perfect. The mental health representation and their life stories as to why they all have the mental battles they do is explained brilliantly. The twist at the end has me needing the next book like yesterday! I really enjoyed this book and I can't wait to see where darkened promises take us next.
Whispered promises follows rosy who is an introverted, animal loving, anxiety ridden, bright clothes wearing women with a huge heart. She lives in a building with her flat mate Steph a few doors down from 4 guys. She meets Max first on passing and they chat and he volunteers at the farm she helps out at, then she meets Nate at the gym she goes to twice a week and they slowly invite her over for dinner where she meets Bry & noah. Rosy is nervous but when she goes she finds a safe space with the guys and gets to know them all individually and falls for them all. Max has golden retriever energy and always makes her laugh, Bry is an amazing cook and always takes care of her, noah is a teacher who helps her emotionally and buddy reads with her & Nate is her gym partner and protector. The guys also all fall for her and decide that they can all date her with no guilt or jealousy involved as long as she's happy. The character development is fantastic. I loved each of them! The real life struggles were spot on. The writing style and the way this story is put together is just perfect. The mental health representation and their life stories as to why they all have the mental battles they do is explained brilliantly. The twist at the end has me needing the next book like yesterday! I really enjoyed this book and I can't wait to see where darkened promises take us next.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I love why choose romance and this was the perfect addition to my collection.
First off, I have to say I really loved Rosy. I am also an anxious introvert who prefers animals to people, so I instantly connected with her. I was screaming at her to stand up for herself though, which is easier said than done.
I loved each of the guys. Why choose romances are always so fun because each of the guys always has such a distinct personality and I love the variety. Choosing who I liked best was hard! I think it depended on my mood that day. I think I would choose Max today, followed in close second by Noah.
I loved their relationship with Rosy. She gets something different from each of them and brings the best out in all of them. They all adore her and are so protective. Where can I find the 4 of them please.
I loved the spice but the book was so much more than that which can be difficult to find in why choose romance. It’s emotional, there’s trauma, great mental health rep and oh my god, that ending! When is book 2 coming out please???
Overall, I rate this 4⭐️
First off, I have to say I really loved Rosy. I am also an anxious introvert who prefers animals to people, so I instantly connected with her. I was screaming at her to stand up for herself though, which is easier said than done.
I loved each of the guys. Why choose romances are always so fun because each of the guys always has such a distinct personality and I love the variety. Choosing who I liked best was hard! I think it depended on my mood that day. I think I would choose Max today, followed in close second by Noah.
I loved their relationship with Rosy. She gets something different from each of them and brings the best out in all of them. They all adore her and are so protective. Where can I find the 4 of them please.
I loved the spice but the book was so much more than that which can be difficult to find in why choose romance. It’s emotional, there’s trauma, great mental health rep and oh my god, that ending! When is book 2 coming out please???
Overall, I rate this 4⭐️
September 24, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
There was a lot of potential with these characters but I found the book long for the events that took place-in that not much happened. It was mostly internal monologue and some of it was repetitive that I found myself yelling in my head for the characters to move along already. I did love most of the characters though and I do want to see them get their HEA in part 2 so I will be continuing the duet.
There was a lot of potential with these characters but I found the book long for the events that took place-in that not much happened. It was mostly internal monologue and some of it was repetitive that I found myself yelling in my head for the characters to move along already. I did love most of the characters though and I do want to see them get their HEA in part 2 so I will be continuing the duet.
October 1, 2026
I absolutely loved this. Rosy was such a doll. And her neighbors, oh my. What I loved the most was the vulnerability in this. I loved the way the guys came into her life, and each brought something different. The way they connected really brought Rosy into herself. Her growth and becoming a stronger woman, all while making that spice extra hot. It was perfect. I devoured this one. I was obsessed. Absolutely loved this.
September 22, 2026
I’ve been alone my whole life. That part I can handle.
It’s the grief that’s breaking me.
After losing the only person who ever chose me, I’m running on empty, tending my rescue farm, fighting my anxiety, and lying awake at 3am pretending I’m fine. I don’t need saving. I just need to survive.
Then four men step into my life.
Nate, who scowls at everyone except me.
Noah, who sits with me in the quiet and never asks for more than I can give.
Brynn, who learns my favourite foods and makes sure I never go without.
And Max, who treats making me laugh like it’s the most important job he’s ever had.
I didn’t ask for any of this, but warmth has a way of getting in.
The problem is, not everyone circling my life has good intentions. Some people want what I have.
And some will take it, regardless of the consequences or the hurt it causes.
Will it be possible for us all to forgive and forget, or will we forever drown in fear and heartache? Or maybe we'll never get the chance to know.
Omg I can’t wait for Darkened Promises, I need to continue reading!!! That cliffhanger nooooo!
It’s the grief that’s breaking me.
After losing the only person who ever chose me, I’m running on empty, tending my rescue farm, fighting my anxiety, and lying awake at 3am pretending I’m fine. I don’t need saving. I just need to survive.
Then four men step into my life.
Nate, who scowls at everyone except me.
Noah, who sits with me in the quiet and never asks for more than I can give.
Brynn, who learns my favourite foods and makes sure I never go without.
And Max, who treats making me laugh like it’s the most important job he’s ever had.
I didn’t ask for any of this, but warmth has a way of getting in.
The problem is, not everyone circling my life has good intentions. Some people want what I have.
And some will take it, regardless of the consequences or the hurt it causes.
Will it be possible for us all to forgive and forget, or will we forever drown in fear and heartache? Or maybe we'll never get the chance to know.
Omg I can’t wait for Darkened Promises, I need to continue reading!!! That cliffhanger nooooo!
September 11, 2026
This is a cute and cosy why choose romance which is so refreshing. I really enjoyed it. I really enjoyed reading how the characters relationships came together. Ooosh the cliffhanger though I really need book 2 to find out what happens.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I very much enjoyed this book!
I have never read a why choose, that’s so wholesome!
The beginning half of this book is getting to know all the characters and their personalities and the second half is a little spicy.
I will say; one of the characters is supposed to be a man of few words but it comes across more as he just misses words out of sentences, which kind of irked me a bit.
There’s a good storyline and so many questions to be answered!
After reading that ending, I’m soo excited for the next book!
I have never read a why choose, that’s so wholesome!
The beginning half of this book is getting to know all the characters and their personalities and the second half is a little spicy.
I will say; one of the characters is supposed to be a man of few words but it comes across more as he just misses words out of sentences, which kind of irked me a bit.
There’s a good storyline and so many questions to be answered!
After reading that ending, I’m soo excited for the next book!
Review of advance copy
loved this book. the character development is amazing. love how much attention to detail there was in each persons personality. it was an easy fast paced read. i flew through the pages enjoying every moment of reading this book. i got this book as an ARC copy from wings&words
Review of advance copy received from Author
This was a thoughly enjoyable yet heart wrenching book an enjoyable storyline thats extremely well written.
September 3, 2026
A spicy MMMMF why choose with rescue animals and a cliffhanger?! I was hooked from the start, and I am climbing the walls and screaming for the next one.
Rosy was such a relatable character with her anxiety and inner thoughts, every single character was unique and well written. I ended up reading this basically in a single day because of how captivating it was, each relationship being beautiful in their own way!
Rosy was such a relatable character with her anxiety and inner thoughts, every single character was unique and well written. I ended up reading this basically in a single day because of how captivating it was, each relationship being beautiful in their own way!
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 4, 2026⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
This was such a fun and easy read! I was hooked pretty quickly and honestly, I flew through it. There’s something about four completely different men bringing their own personalities to the story that just WORKED for me. 😍
💙 Rosy — I really liked her character and how relatable she felt.
💙 Max — the golden retriever energy and his shenanigans had me laughing 😂
💙 Bry — the caring, protective side of him had me absolutely swooning 🥹
💙 Nate — that mouth… 🥵 Let’s just say he definitely knows how to keep things interesting!
💙 Noah — sweet, affectionate and vulnerable… my heart 🥹
I really enjoyed getting to know each of the relationships individually and seeing how the guys already had such a strong friendship/family bond. They all brought something completely different to the table, which made it very difficult to pick a favourite!
There’s also a little mystery/danger running in the background, which added another layer to the story and definitely left me with questions 👀 I have a few theories and I NEED to know if I’m right!
The romance is definitely more of a slow build, with lots of tension and yearning, but I think that made the moments we did get even better. 🔥
I really enjoyed this one and I’m definitely invested enough to continue with the series. Especially after that ending… 👀 Now I just need book 2 because I NEED to know what happens next!
🌶️🌶️🌶️
This was such a fun and easy read! I was hooked pretty quickly and honestly, I flew through it. There’s something about four completely different men bringing their own personalities to the story that just WORKED for me. 😍
💙 Rosy — I really liked her character and how relatable she felt.
💙 Max — the golden retriever energy and his shenanigans had me laughing 😂
💙 Bry — the caring, protective side of him had me absolutely swooning 🥹
💙 Nate — that mouth… 🥵 Let’s just say he definitely knows how to keep things interesting!
💙 Noah — sweet, affectionate and vulnerable… my heart 🥹
I really enjoyed getting to know each of the relationships individually and seeing how the guys already had such a strong friendship/family bond. They all brought something completely different to the table, which made it very difficult to pick a favourite!
There’s also a little mystery/danger running in the background, which added another layer to the story and definitely left me with questions 👀 I have a few theories and I NEED to know if I’m right!
The romance is definitely more of a slow build, with lots of tension and yearning, but I think that made the moments we did get even better. 🔥
I really enjoyed this one and I’m definitely invested enough to continue with the series. Especially after that ending… 👀 Now I just need book 2 because I NEED to know what happens next!
Review of advance copy received from Author
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
I really adored *Whispered Promises*. Rosy is such a fantastic FMC for me because she is quirky, passionate, insecure, and an absolute overthinker—and somehow all of that makes her incredibly endearing and relatable. At different points in my life, I have absolutely been Rosy in some way, so understanding her and where she is coming from was really easy for me.
Rosy has her life organized in a way that works for her, even if it isn't necessarily the life she dreamed about. She works an office job she doesn't particularly enjoy because bills are a thing, picks up extra money doing food deliveries, and spends her weekends volunteering at a local rescue farm. Dating isn't exactly high on her priority list, especially after some pretty bad experiences in her past.
Then there is Nate, her gruff, stoic, gym-rat neighbor who actually speaks to her first at the gym. 😂 From there, things slowly start changing. She's already friendly with his roommate Max, and before long Max is helping her at the farm and inviting her to dinner. Then Bry and Noah enter the picture, and suddenly Rosy's carefully functioning little world gets a whole lot more complicated.
I really liked that each of the guys felt distinct. They all have their own personalities, their own baggage, and their own reasons for keeping people at arm's length, but somehow they work incredibly well together as a group. I've read several reverse harem/why-choose books, and while they all share that basic trope, each story handles the dynamic differently. I think *Whispered Promises* does a good job establishing why these four men fit together and, more importantly, why each of them fits with Rosy.
This first book is very much a setup for the duet, and you can tell. The pacing is a little slower from a story perspective, but considering the second half is coming next month, I actually think that works here. We get time to understand who these men are, what they've been through, and how their feelings for Rosy develop instead of everything happening at once.
There is also a little side plot involving a stalker who, so far, has been more creepy than dangerous. But the way that storyline is developing has me wondering just how harmless he's actually going to stay... 👀
And then there is the spice. 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
The story may take its time building, but the spice absolutely does not. 😂 I really enjoyed Rosy's relationship with intimacy. She isn't afraid of it, exactly, but she does have those moments where she has to remind herself that these men want her just as much as she wants them. We get some really good scenes with each of the guys, and I appreciated that the chemistry felt different depending on who she was with.
I like all four of the guys, but if I'm picking favorites so far, Nate and Bry have my attention. 👀 I'm very curious whether book two is going to change that.
Overall, I really enjoyed this first half of the duet. It gave me enough character development, chemistry, and unanswered questions to make me very ready to see what happens next.
Now excuse me while I go stare at the calendar and wait for book two. 😂
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
I really adored *Whispered Promises*. Rosy is such a fantastic FMC for me because she is quirky, passionate, insecure, and an absolute overthinker—and somehow all of that makes her incredibly endearing and relatable. At different points in my life, I have absolutely been Rosy in some way, so understanding her and where she is coming from was really easy for me.
Rosy has her life organized in a way that works for her, even if it isn't necessarily the life she dreamed about. She works an office job she doesn't particularly enjoy because bills are a thing, picks up extra money doing food deliveries, and spends her weekends volunteering at a local rescue farm. Dating isn't exactly high on her priority list, especially after some pretty bad experiences in her past.
Then there is Nate, her gruff, stoic, gym-rat neighbor who actually speaks to her first at the gym. 😂 From there, things slowly start changing. She's already friendly with his roommate Max, and before long Max is helping her at the farm and inviting her to dinner. Then Bry and Noah enter the picture, and suddenly Rosy's carefully functioning little world gets a whole lot more complicated.
I really liked that each of the guys felt distinct. They all have their own personalities, their own baggage, and their own reasons for keeping people at arm's length, but somehow they work incredibly well together as a group. I've read several reverse harem/why-choose books, and while they all share that basic trope, each story handles the dynamic differently. I think *Whispered Promises* does a good job establishing why these four men fit together and, more importantly, why each of them fits with Rosy.
This first book is very much a setup for the duet, and you can tell. The pacing is a little slower from a story perspective, but considering the second half is coming next month, I actually think that works here. We get time to understand who these men are, what they've been through, and how their feelings for Rosy develop instead of everything happening at once.
There is also a little side plot involving a stalker who, so far, has been more creepy than dangerous. But the way that storyline is developing has me wondering just how harmless he's actually going to stay... 👀
And then there is the spice. 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
The story may take its time building, but the spice absolutely does not. 😂 I really enjoyed Rosy's relationship with intimacy. She isn't afraid of it, exactly, but she does have those moments where she has to remind herself that these men want her just as much as she wants them. We get some really good scenes with each of the guys, and I appreciated that the chemistry felt different depending on who she was with.
I like all four of the guys, but if I'm picking favorites so far, Nate and Bry have my attention. 👀 I'm very curious whether book two is going to change that.
Overall, I really enjoyed this first half of the duet. It gave me enough character development, chemistry, and unanswered questions to make me very ready to see what happens next.
Now excuse me while I go stare at the calendar and wait for book two. 😂
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 19, 2026
WOW! This book is SO GOOD! 😭❤️ I absolutely love that she wears the weirdest, most adorable socks. Honestly, those little details make a character even more lovable to me!
I am SO curious about who the mysterious unknown number belongs to and who the white flowers are from. 👀 I have a pretty good idea, especially after how this book ended, but I NEED CONFIRMATION! I love when a book leaves you with questions that make you want to immediately pick up the next one.
And GOSH, I don't even know who I like more: Bry or Nate! 😂 Bry has the food thing going for him, and Nate has the possessiveness that makes me love him. How am I supposed to choose?! They're both so good in their own ways!
But can we PLEASE talk about the buddy read and buddy listen aspect of this book?! Because honestly, WHO WOULDN'T LOVE HAVING THEIR OTHER HALF ACTUALLY BE INTERESTED IN THEIR BOOKS AND WANTING TO READ OR LISTEN ALONG WITH THEM?! 😭❤️ That is probably my absolute favorite thing about this story. The idea of sharing something you love with someone who genuinely wants to be part of it is just so adorable to me. As a book lover, that would make my heart SO HAPPY!
I was also surprised by how I felt about Max. Usually, the funny, golden-retriever-type guy ends up being my second favorite after the grumpy one. I typically LOVE that kind of character! But for some reason, I found myself kind of hating Max in this book, which I honestly wasn't expecting. 😂 It's always interesting when a character type you usually love doesn't quite work for you in a particular story!
I cannot WAIT to read the next book in this series! I really hope the author keeps writing these amazing stories because I'm already so invested in these characters and want MORE!
AND CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE RESCUE KITTEN?! OMG!!! 😭🐱 Who doesn't love a rescue kitten?! That alone deserves some extra love!
Overall, I had such a good time reading this book! Between the adorable little details, the characters, the romance, and the idea of sharing your love of books with your person, there was so much to enjoy. Now I just need to get my hands on the next book because I NEED TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENS NEXT! ❤️📚
I am SO curious about who the mysterious unknown number belongs to and who the white flowers are from. 👀 I have a pretty good idea, especially after how this book ended, but I NEED CONFIRMATION! I love when a book leaves you with questions that make you want to immediately pick up the next one.
And GOSH, I don't even know who I like more: Bry or Nate! 😂 Bry has the food thing going for him, and Nate has the possessiveness that makes me love him. How am I supposed to choose?! They're both so good in their own ways!
But can we PLEASE talk about the buddy read and buddy listen aspect of this book?! Because honestly, WHO WOULDN'T LOVE HAVING THEIR OTHER HALF ACTUALLY BE INTERESTED IN THEIR BOOKS AND WANTING TO READ OR LISTEN ALONG WITH THEM?! 😭❤️ That is probably my absolute favorite thing about this story. The idea of sharing something you love with someone who genuinely wants to be part of it is just so adorable to me. As a book lover, that would make my heart SO HAPPY!
I was also surprised by how I felt about Max. Usually, the funny, golden-retriever-type guy ends up being my second favorite after the grumpy one. I typically LOVE that kind of character! But for some reason, I found myself kind of hating Max in this book, which I honestly wasn't expecting. 😂 It's always interesting when a character type you usually love doesn't quite work for you in a particular story!
I cannot WAIT to read the next book in this series! I really hope the author keeps writing these amazing stories because I'm already so invested in these characters and want MORE!
AND CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE RESCUE KITTEN?! OMG!!! 😭🐱 Who doesn't love a rescue kitten?! That alone deserves some extra love!
Overall, I had such a good time reading this book! Between the adorable little details, the characters, the romance, and the idea of sharing your love of books with your person, there was so much to enjoy. Now I just need to get my hands on the next book because I NEED TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENS NEXT! ❤️📚
October 29, 2026
DNF @ 55% / 30 chapters read
I'm bummed to DNF this, but I keep putting it down to check TikTok or scroll anything else. And after reading practically 6 books in a row that kept my attention pretty much hooked, this just feels... off. So, I'm quitting here.
Positives: I love the characters and how different they are from each other. I see the found family vibes and how they are there for each other to heal. We are halfway through the story and still in the kissing stage and I love it. Yay slow(ish) burn! There are also hints that there is something bad brewing with the texts that Rosy is getting and her creepy coworkers.
Negatives: I'm just bored. Yes, it is a slow burn focusing on the 4 relationships developing which is really cute, but most of the page time is Rosy's anxiety -- honestly, valid, I feel you girl -- which is unfortunately boring because it feels repetitive. It also means that it doesn't feel like we are getting a lot of page time with the guys. I know this is incorrect, the last chapter was literally her and Bry chatting in a car together, but... yeah idk how to explain it other than I wish there was more time of the 5 of them together and interacting like a unit? Not just one on one dates? But I like the one on one dates because it makes each relationship feel stronger soooo ugh idk.
And the creepy vibes are too spread out to actually make it feel like something is going to happen. She doesn't take them seriously anymore. This is, again, understandable though because if the police said there isn't anything they can do, what else can you do but ignore it?
So, this is a hard one to rate. I like everything in the book. Great cast, lovely slow burn, creepy undertones (with the trigger warnings explaining that things are NOT going to be okay for Rosy soon), found family. I'm just not connecting with it, I'm not hooked and dying to read more. Maybe if I had read this at another time????? If I'm told by friends to give it another go I will, but alas, not today.
I'm bummed to DNF this, but I keep putting it down to check TikTok or scroll anything else. And after reading practically 6 books in a row that kept my attention pretty much hooked, this just feels... off. So, I'm quitting here.
Positives: I love the characters and how different they are from each other. I see the found family vibes and how they are there for each other to heal. We are halfway through the story and still in the kissing stage and I love it. Yay slow(ish) burn! There are also hints that there is something bad brewing with the texts that Rosy is getting and her creepy coworkers.
Negatives: I'm just bored. Yes, it is a slow burn focusing on the 4 relationships developing which is really cute, but most of the page time is Rosy's anxiety -- honestly, valid, I feel you girl -- which is unfortunately boring because it feels repetitive. It also means that it doesn't feel like we are getting a lot of page time with the guys. I know this is incorrect, the last chapter was literally her and Bry chatting in a car together, but... yeah idk how to explain it other than I wish there was more time of the 5 of them together and interacting like a unit? Not just one on one dates? But I like the one on one dates because it makes each relationship feel stronger soooo ugh idk.
And the creepy vibes are too spread out to actually make it feel like something is going to happen. She doesn't take them seriously anymore. This is, again, understandable though because if the police said there isn't anything they can do, what else can you do but ignore it?
So, this is a hard one to rate. I like everything in the book. Great cast, lovely slow burn, creepy undertones (with the trigger warnings explaining that things are NOT going to be okay for Rosy soon), found family. I'm just not connecting with it, I'm not hooked and dying to read more. Maybe if I had read this at another time????? If I'm told by friends to give it another go I will, but alas, not today.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 180 reviews