What do you think?
Rate this book
Candlelight
Not yet published
Expected 21 Aug 26In the spring of 1986, the children of Beaumont, Texas disappear one by one. Vanishing without a trace from secluded streets, busy supermarkets, and dark bedroom closets. Drawn by the light of a candle only they can see. There are no witnesses, no bodies, and no explanation. Only the certainty that they were taken.
High school freshman Matthew Dean doesn't believe in faeries. But when he visits a forbidden clearing in the woods behind his home and rips open a gateway to the world of the fae, he invites something ancient and hungry back into his hometown.
Matthew's mother, Lina, a centuries-old witch in hiding, must now suffer the consequences of keeping their history a secret. And skeptical police detective Jacob Fusilier investigates the string of missing children while reality erodes around him.
The first book of The Grey Neighbors series, Candlelight is a dark fairy tale fueled by mythic horror, stolen innocence, and the scars parents leave for their children. There are no happily ever afters once the Grey Neighbors come calling…
High school freshman Matthew Dean doesn't believe in faeries. But when he visits a forbidden clearing in the woods behind his home and rips open a gateway to the world of the fae, he invites something ancient and hungry back into his hometown.
Matthew's mother, Lina, a centuries-old witch in hiding, must now suffer the consequences of keeping their history a secret. And skeptical police detective Jacob Fusilier investigates the string of missing children while reality erodes around him.
The first book of The Grey Neighbors series, Candlelight is a dark fairy tale fueled by mythic horror, stolen innocence, and the scars parents leave for their children. There are no happily ever afters once the Grey Neighbors come calling…
- GenresHorror
448 pages, Kindle Edition
Expected publication August 21, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Tropes & Content Warnings:
* Murder and graphic violence
* Child abuse
* Bullying
* Child abduction
* Dark fantasy
* Fae
* Celtic mythology
Dark folklore, sinister fae, memorable characters, and an atmosphere that evokes the charm of classic fantasy films drew me into this captivating and haunting story from the very first pages.
The premise immediately intrigued me, and I'm pleased to say the novel exceeded my expectations. It skillfully blends Celtic mythology, mystery, horror, and emotional character development into a story that feels both immersive and refreshingly original.
The narrative unfolds through four interconnected perspectives: Detective Jacob, young Matthew, his mother Lina, and Stacey, one of Matthew's classmates. Each of them is written with remarkable depth, carrying their own fears, regrets, and personal burdens. Their stories feel authentic, and their relationships evolve naturally throughout the novel. The author takes the time to reveal each character layer by layer, allowing readers to understand not only their choices but also the emotions driving them. Several times, I found myself unexpectedly invested in characters I hadn't anticipated becoming attached to, which made many of the story's emotional moments especially powerful.
One of the novel's highlights is its portrayal of the fae. Rather than presenting them as whimsical creatures of fairy tales, the author embraces their darker folkloric origins. These beings are ancient, beautiful, cruel, and impossible to predict. The Grey Neighbors, in particular, embody both wonder and terror, creating an atmosphere where beauty and danger constantly exist side by side. The result is a world that feels magical without ever becoming comforting.
The Celtic folklore woven throughout the novel is another standout feature. It is clear that significant care went into researching the mythology, and the inclusion of Irish language and cultural details gives the setting an additional sense of authenticity and depth. Instead of serving merely as decoration, these elements become an essential part of the story's identity.
The creatures themselves are genuinely unsettling. From the Dullahan to the Maoth'fala and other beings inspired by Irish folklore, the monsters feel rooted in ancient legends rather than familiar fantasy conventions. Their appearances bring a lingering sense of dread, and several scenes are genuinely chilling. While the horror never overshadows the story, it enhances the atmosphere beautifully, giving the novel a darker, more distinctive identity than many contemporary fantasy books.
Thank you, NetGalley, for the ARC!
* Murder and graphic violence
* Child abuse
* Bullying
* Child abduction
* Dark fantasy
* Fae
* Celtic mythology
Dark folklore, sinister fae, memorable characters, and an atmosphere that evokes the charm of classic fantasy films drew me into this captivating and haunting story from the very first pages.
The premise immediately intrigued me, and I'm pleased to say the novel exceeded my expectations. It skillfully blends Celtic mythology, mystery, horror, and emotional character development into a story that feels both immersive and refreshingly original.
The narrative unfolds through four interconnected perspectives: Detective Jacob, young Matthew, his mother Lina, and Stacey, one of Matthew's classmates. Each of them is written with remarkable depth, carrying their own fears, regrets, and personal burdens. Their stories feel authentic, and their relationships evolve naturally throughout the novel. The author takes the time to reveal each character layer by layer, allowing readers to understand not only their choices but also the emotions driving them. Several times, I found myself unexpectedly invested in characters I hadn't anticipated becoming attached to, which made many of the story's emotional moments especially powerful.
One of the novel's highlights is its portrayal of the fae. Rather than presenting them as whimsical creatures of fairy tales, the author embraces their darker folkloric origins. These beings are ancient, beautiful, cruel, and impossible to predict. The Grey Neighbors, in particular, embody both wonder and terror, creating an atmosphere where beauty and danger constantly exist side by side. The result is a world that feels magical without ever becoming comforting.
The Celtic folklore woven throughout the novel is another standout feature. It is clear that significant care went into researching the mythology, and the inclusion of Irish language and cultural details gives the setting an additional sense of authenticity and depth. Instead of serving merely as decoration, these elements become an essential part of the story's identity.
The creatures themselves are genuinely unsettling. From the Dullahan to the Maoth'fala and other beings inspired by Irish folklore, the monsters feel rooted in ancient legends rather than familiar fantasy conventions. Their appearances bring a lingering sense of dread, and several scenes are genuinely chilling. While the horror never overshadows the story, it enhances the atmosphere beautifully, giving the novel a darker, more distinctive identity than many contemporary fantasy books.
Thank you, NetGalley, for the ARC!
August 1, 2026
A dark, propulsive fantasy that grips you from the first missing child. Tolin weaves fairy lore with 1980s horror atmosphere as a teenager unwittingly opens a portal to the fae realm. The worldbuilding is intricate and creepy, though the plot moves fast enough that you’re still untangling secrets as the book ends. A solid series opener that hooks you into wanting more.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Dark folklore, terrifying fae, unforgettable characters, and the nostalgic magic of classic fantasy film Candlelight completely swept me into its enchanting and dangerous world. 🕯️✨🍂
Thank you 🙏 for the ARC provided by NetGalley, Twisted Spindle Press, and the author in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
As someone who likes dark fantasy films like Labyrinth and Legend, Candlelight immediately felt like the kind of story I was destined to fall into. Blending Irish and Welsh folklore with mythic horror, fae magic, and a heavy sense of unease, D.L. Tolin has created a world that feels both nostalgic and entirely its own.
Set partly in Southeast Texas, the story balances the familiar with the fantastical. The references to Beaumont and places like ShowTime Pizza gave the novel an authentic, grounded feel, while the creeping darkness beneath the surface constantly reminded me that this was no ordinary fantasy. From the opening pages, there is a sense that something ancient, dangerous, and hungry is lurking just beyond sight.
What truly made this book stand out for me, however, were the characters.
Matthew, Lina, Jacob, and Stacey felt like real people rather than simply pieces moving around a fantasy plot. Each of them carried their own struggles, fears, and emotional wounds, making it easy to become invested in their journeys. Tolin does an excellent job of slowly peeling back layers and revealing hidden depths within the cast. More than once, I found myself unexpectedly attached to a character or surprised by a decision that revealed a strength or vulnerability I hadn't anticipated.
The alternating perspectives kept the story moving at a perfect pace. Every time a chapter ended, I wanted to know what was happening with the other group, which made this an incredibly easy book to binge. The narrative constantly rewards curiosity, and I found myself reading far later than intended.
One of my favourite aspects was the way the faerie world was portrayed. This isn't a whimsical or comforting version of fae folklore. The Grey Neighbors are beautiful, mysterious, terrifying, and utterly unpredictable. Wonder and horror exist side by side throughout the novel, creating an atmosphere that feels magical while never allowing readers to feel completely safe. The mythology feels rich and well researched, and the Irish language elements added another layer of authenticity and immersion. I especially appreciated the pronunciation guide, although I would have loved to have it available at the beginning of the book.
The creatures and folklore-inspired horrors are genuinely unsettling. The Dullahan, the Maoth'fala, and the other mythological elements feel pulled from ancient nightmares rather than modern fantasy tropes. There are moments of real dread woven throughout the story that give the book a darker edge than many fantasy novels.
What stayed with me long after finishing wasn't a single plot twist or creature reveal, but the overall feeling the story created. It captured that rare sense of stepping into another world entirely, a world that is enchanting, dangerous, heartbreaking, and impossible to forget.
Candlelight is a dark fairy tale filled with mythic horror, family wounds, stolen innocence, and the lingering scars that parents leave behind. It's atmospheric, emotional, unsettling, and beautifully written. Most importantly, it left me wanting more. A haunting and unforgettable start to what promises to be an incredible series.
My Final Verdit:
When I finally closed the book, it wasn’t just the terrifying creatures like the Maoth’fala that lingered; it was the haunting atmosphere and the feeling that I wasn't quite ready to leave this world behind. It is a phenomenal start to The Grey Neighbors series, and I will absolutely be picking up the next installment when it drops next year!
Highly Recommended for fans of classic dark folklore, mythic horror, and 80s fantasy nostalgia.
Thank you 🙏 for the ARC provided by NetGalley, Twisted Spindle Press, and the author in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
As someone who likes dark fantasy films like Labyrinth and Legend, Candlelight immediately felt like the kind of story I was destined to fall into. Blending Irish and Welsh folklore with mythic horror, fae magic, and a heavy sense of unease, D.L. Tolin has created a world that feels both nostalgic and entirely its own.
Set partly in Southeast Texas, the story balances the familiar with the fantastical. The references to Beaumont and places like ShowTime Pizza gave the novel an authentic, grounded feel, while the creeping darkness beneath the surface constantly reminded me that this was no ordinary fantasy. From the opening pages, there is a sense that something ancient, dangerous, and hungry is lurking just beyond sight.
What truly made this book stand out for me, however, were the characters.
Matthew, Lina, Jacob, and Stacey felt like real people rather than simply pieces moving around a fantasy plot. Each of them carried their own struggles, fears, and emotional wounds, making it easy to become invested in their journeys. Tolin does an excellent job of slowly peeling back layers and revealing hidden depths within the cast. More than once, I found myself unexpectedly attached to a character or surprised by a decision that revealed a strength or vulnerability I hadn't anticipated.
The alternating perspectives kept the story moving at a perfect pace. Every time a chapter ended, I wanted to know what was happening with the other group, which made this an incredibly easy book to binge. The narrative constantly rewards curiosity, and I found myself reading far later than intended.
One of my favourite aspects was the way the faerie world was portrayed. This isn't a whimsical or comforting version of fae folklore. The Grey Neighbors are beautiful, mysterious, terrifying, and utterly unpredictable. Wonder and horror exist side by side throughout the novel, creating an atmosphere that feels magical while never allowing readers to feel completely safe. The mythology feels rich and well researched, and the Irish language elements added another layer of authenticity and immersion. I especially appreciated the pronunciation guide, although I would have loved to have it available at the beginning of the book.
The creatures and folklore-inspired horrors are genuinely unsettling. The Dullahan, the Maoth'fala, and the other mythological elements feel pulled from ancient nightmares rather than modern fantasy tropes. There are moments of real dread woven throughout the story that give the book a darker edge than many fantasy novels.
What stayed with me long after finishing wasn't a single plot twist or creature reveal, but the overall feeling the story created. It captured that rare sense of stepping into another world entirely, a world that is enchanting, dangerous, heartbreaking, and impossible to forget.
Candlelight is a dark fairy tale filled with mythic horror, family wounds, stolen innocence, and the lingering scars that parents leave behind. It's atmospheric, emotional, unsettling, and beautifully written. Most importantly, it left me wanting more. A haunting and unforgettable start to what promises to be an incredible series.
My Final Verdit:
When I finally closed the book, it wasn’t just the terrifying creatures like the Maoth’fala that lingered; it was the haunting atmosphere and the feeling that I wasn't quite ready to leave this world behind. It is a phenomenal start to The Grey Neighbors series, and I will absolutely be picking up the next installment when it drops next year!
Highly Recommended for fans of classic dark folklore, mythic horror, and 80s fantasy nostalgia.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
What a refreshingly unexpected, intriguing story. I went in expecting more folk horror, but the novel quickly became something else entirely. It’s much more of a dark modern fairy tale with strong folklore horror elements. The pacing is excellent. There is a lot of worldbuilding to establish, but the author avoids long stretches of exposition. Instead, information is woven naturally into the story, keeping the plot moving. Within just a few chapters, I was completely invested and eager to keep turning pages.
It’s a multi-POV novel, which is usually hit or miss for me, but the author balances the perspectives exceptionally well. I found myself equally invested in nearly every storyline, even before they began converging. The story primarily follows Matt, an ordinary kid whose life is suddenly upended when increasingly impossible things begin happening around him. I’ll leave it there because this is definitely a book best experienced with as few spoilers as possible.
The characters are rich, distinct, and well developed. One thing I especially appreciated was that the adults are actually competent. Instead of the common trope where every adult is oblivious while the child carries the entire story, the adults here are intelligent, capable, and actively involved. It was a refreshing change and helped ground the story. The author strikes a nice balance between character development and plot progression.
I was genuinely surprised by how much I enjoyed this book. It begins with a stronger folk horror atmosphere before evolving into a dark fantasy rooted in folklore, and the transition works beautifully. There is humor alongside genuine moments of horror, and the various beings drawn from folklore are incorporated naturally into the story. As someone who knows very little about folklore, I never felt lost or like I was being lectured. New creatures and concepts are introduced with just enough explanation to keep the story moving.
Fantasy readers, in particular, should absolutely give this one a look. While it contains horror elements, it ultimately feels much more like a dark fantasy than a horror novel. Despite some genuinely dark moments, there is plenty of warmth, humor, and a cast of characters worth rooting for.
My only real complaint is the ending. I don’t mind unanswered questions in the first book of a series, but this one leaves a lot unresolved. It’s very much a “to be continued” ending, and with the next book not releasing until 2027, that stings a little. That said, my frustration comes from how invested I became in these characters and this world. I would have happily read several hundred more pages.
It’s a multi-POV novel, which is usually hit or miss for me, but the author balances the perspectives exceptionally well. I found myself equally invested in nearly every storyline, even before they began converging. The story primarily follows Matt, an ordinary kid whose life is suddenly upended when increasingly impossible things begin happening around him. I’ll leave it there because this is definitely a book best experienced with as few spoilers as possible.
The characters are rich, distinct, and well developed. One thing I especially appreciated was that the adults are actually competent. Instead of the common trope where every adult is oblivious while the child carries the entire story, the adults here are intelligent, capable, and actively involved. It was a refreshing change and helped ground the story. The author strikes a nice balance between character development and plot progression.
I was genuinely surprised by how much I enjoyed this book. It begins with a stronger folk horror atmosphere before evolving into a dark fantasy rooted in folklore, and the transition works beautifully. There is humor alongside genuine moments of horror, and the various beings drawn from folklore are incorporated naturally into the story. As someone who knows very little about folklore, I never felt lost or like I was being lectured. New creatures and concepts are introduced with just enough explanation to keep the story moving.
Fantasy readers, in particular, should absolutely give this one a look. While it contains horror elements, it ultimately feels much more like a dark fantasy than a horror novel. Despite some genuinely dark moments, there is plenty of warmth, humor, and a cast of characters worth rooting for.
My only real complaint is the ending. I don’t mind unanswered questions in the first book of a series, but this one leaves a lot unresolved. It’s very much a “to be continued” ending, and with the next book not releasing until 2027, that stings a little. That said, my frustration comes from how invested I became in these characters and this world. I would have happily read several hundred more pages.
Review of advance copy
**Thank you to BookSirens and the author for the free eARC! I am leaving this review voluntarily.**
This was such a captivating mix of horror, dark fantasy, and true crime - so many genres I enjoy. Candlelight is a story about a boy named Matthew opening up a portal to the faery world and a series of dangerous events that follows. At the same time a detective, Jacob, is investigating a growing list of missing children cases, which we learn are related to this other world.
There is so much I enjoy about faery horror, which made this book a win for me. For one, faeries can be terrifying. They may look beautiful but they are incredibly dangerous and power-hungry. Secondly, I love how the world of faeries is so difficult that even temporally it does not line up with the human world. It makes the characters' time spent in the faery world that much more disorienting.
What stopped this book from being 5 stars for me is that so much is left open at the end! I know this is part of a series, so answers will come, but I was hoping for a bit more to wrap up than just the plot with Kit. I also felt that the epilogue was written in a way that initially gave the impression that months had passed, but it had actually only been 3 weeks. Lastly, I did feel like I knew Matthew the least of all the characters, even though he is the lead MC. I think this happened due to his chapters always circling around him, Merlin, and Puck, so the stage was constantly shared.
That being said, I am SO excited for book 2! This story had incredible body horror, an interesting cast of characters, and an intriguing world that I want to learn more about.
PS - This reminded me a lot of Jason Offut's The Girl in the Corn duology, which was an EXCELLENT 5/5 book. Thank you, D.L. Tolin, for writing another deliciously dark faery book!
This was such a captivating mix of horror, dark fantasy, and true crime - so many genres I enjoy. Candlelight is a story about a boy named Matthew opening up a portal to the faery world and a series of dangerous events that follows. At the same time a detective, Jacob, is investigating a growing list of missing children cases, which we learn are related to this other world.
There is so much I enjoy about faery horror, which made this book a win for me. For one, faeries can be terrifying. They may look beautiful but they are incredibly dangerous and power-hungry. Secondly, I love how the world of faeries is so difficult that even temporally it does not line up with the human world. It makes the characters' time spent in the faery world that much more disorienting.
What stopped this book from being 5 stars for me is that so much is left open at the end! I know this is part of a series, so answers will come, but I was hoping for a bit more to wrap up than just the plot with Kit. I also felt that the epilogue was written in a way that initially gave the impression that months had passed, but it had actually only been 3 weeks. Lastly, I did feel like I knew Matthew the least of all the characters, even though he is the lead MC. I think this happened due to his chapters always circling around him, Merlin, and Puck, so the stage was constantly shared.
That being said, I am SO excited for book 2! This story had incredible body horror, an interesting cast of characters, and an intriguing world that I want to learn more about.
PS - This reminded me a lot of Jason Offut's The Girl in the Corn duology, which was an EXCELLENT 5/5 book. Thank you, D.L. Tolin, for writing another deliciously dark faery book!
Review of advance copy
As someone who grew up loving 80s (dark) fantasy films like Labyrinth and Legend and who lives in the Houston area, Candlelight immediately drew me in with its Southeast Texas setting. The descriptions of Beaumont and places like ShowTime Pizza felt nostalgic and familiar, but there was always something unsettling lurking beneath the surface that kept me reading.
What stayed with me most, however, were the characters.
Matthew, Lina, Jacob, and even Stacey felt real enough that I found myself invested in them as people rather than simply as vehicles for the plot. Tolin has a knack for taking characters who initially seem familiar and revealing unexpected depth. More than once, I caught myself caring deeply about the fate of a character I never expected to like, or being surprised by a small choice that revealed a depth, vulnerability, or strength I hadn’t seen before.
Like the fantasy stories of my youth, Candlelight presents the faerie world as both beautiful and dangerous. Wonder and dread exist side by side, and the magic never feels entirely safe. The result is a story that captures the same sense of enchantment and unease that made those classic fantasy films so memorable.
When I finished the book, what lingered wasn’t a particular plot point or magical creature (although there are definitely those…the Maoth’fala)—it was the characters and the feeling that I wasn’t quite ready to leave their world behind.
I truly can’t wait for the next installment of The Grey Neighbors series & highly recommend book one!
What stayed with me most, however, were the characters.
Matthew, Lina, Jacob, and even Stacey felt real enough that I found myself invested in them as people rather than simply as vehicles for the plot. Tolin has a knack for taking characters who initially seem familiar and revealing unexpected depth. More than once, I caught myself caring deeply about the fate of a character I never expected to like, or being surprised by a small choice that revealed a depth, vulnerability, or strength I hadn’t seen before.
Like the fantasy stories of my youth, Candlelight presents the faerie world as both beautiful and dangerous. Wonder and dread exist side by side, and the magic never feels entirely safe. The result is a story that captures the same sense of enchantment and unease that made those classic fantasy films so memorable.
When I finished the book, what lingered wasn’t a particular plot point or magical creature (although there are definitely those…the Maoth’fala)—it was the characters and the feeling that I wasn’t quite ready to leave their world behind.
I truly can’t wait for the next installment of The Grey Neighbors series & highly recommend book one!
Review of advance copy
A folk fantasy/modern horror book that mixes 1980s Texas with celtic fae? Sounds right up my alley. It is a pretty odd mix but it really works.
I dont know why it is set i the 80s, since it would pretty much have worked within a current time too. But you get rid of plot killers like cellphones and internet and that makes for better storytelling.
The characters are good or very good. The good guys are easy to like and root for, but it is the bad guys that are really fantastic. From the school yard bullies to the supernatural monsters, the bad guys carries the storytelling and really makes the story flow.
Matthew, Linas and Staceys stories are pretty much non stop action at a fast pace and the action sequences are fast, fun and well written. The Texas cop story doesn’t really go anywhere and is the only part that feels like filler. But I get that it is just a set up for the continued story.
Which lead in to what I really did not like with Candlelight. One of my pet peeves is bokks without endings. Not an open ending, a total lack of an ending. Ok, this is book 1 in a series, but I feel like the story just ends suddenly. From a positive view point that means I was invested enough to really want to know what happens. From a negative point of view it just feels unsatisying and unfinished. I´m putting the next book on my to-read list, but hope that i has a more clear ending.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I dont know why it is set i the 80s, since it would pretty much have worked within a current time too. But you get rid of plot killers like cellphones and internet and that makes for better storytelling.
The characters are good or very good. The good guys are easy to like and root for, but it is the bad guys that are really fantastic. From the school yard bullies to the supernatural monsters, the bad guys carries the storytelling and really makes the story flow.
Matthew, Linas and Staceys stories are pretty much non stop action at a fast pace and the action sequences are fast, fun and well written. The Texas cop story doesn’t really go anywhere and is the only part that feels like filler. But I get that it is just a set up for the continued story.
Which lead in to what I really did not like with Candlelight. One of my pet peeves is bokks without endings. Not an open ending, a total lack of an ending. Ok, this is book 1 in a series, but I feel like the story just ends suddenly. From a positive view point that means I was invested enough to really want to know what happens. From a negative point of view it just feels unsatisying and unfinished. I´m putting the next book on my to-read list, but hope that i has a more clear ending.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was a 3.5 ⭐ rounded up for me. I appreciated the world building and atmosphere of this book a lot. But the characters felt a little shallow to me. I didn't get as attached to them as I wanted to be. I think some of this is the switching POVs and now long it takes to get to the meat of the book. At 40% I was still waiting to feel that pull - to be fully invested. If the pacing was more balanced, I think this would have gone better for me. That said, there was still a lot I liked and appreciated, and by 85% I was just starting to gain momentum, wanting more.
Some of the plot choices felt odd. I wasn't sure where this book was going for a bit. It reads like a mystery in a way (true crime aspects), but is very much fantasy. Jason's POV felt like what kept pulling the story away from it's main plot. What I think would have worked better is introducing his POV later in the story. Giving us time with Matt & his mom, friends/schoolmates, and "here say" about disappearances would have built up the tension and interest a lot more when Jason's POV is finally introduced. Like a welcome answer to our questions as opposed to adjusting to an adjacent storyline.
I'm not sure if I'll go for book 2 due to the "meh" attachment I have with these characters, but I'm interested enough in the universe/magic system I might! I'll keep this in my back pocket & see what book 2 looks like!
This was a 3.5 ⭐ rounded up for me. I appreciated the world building and atmosphere of this book a lot. But the characters felt a little shallow to me. I didn't get as attached to them as I wanted to be. I think some of this is the switching POVs and now long it takes to get to the meat of the book. At 40% I was still waiting to feel that pull - to be fully invested. If the pacing was more balanced, I think this would have gone better for me. That said, there was still a lot I liked and appreciated, and by 85% I was just starting to gain momentum, wanting more.
Some of the plot choices felt odd. I wasn't sure where this book was going for a bit. It reads like a mystery in a way (true crime aspects), but is very much fantasy. Jason's POV felt like what kept pulling the story away from it's main plot. What I think would have worked better is introducing his POV later in the story. Giving us time with Matt & his mom, friends/schoolmates, and "here say" about disappearances would have built up the tension and interest a lot more when Jason's POV is finally introduced. Like a welcome answer to our questions as opposed to adjusting to an adjacent storyline.
I'm not sure if I'll go for book 2 due to the "meh" attachment I have with these characters, but I'm interested enough in the universe/magic system I might! I'll keep this in my back pocket & see what book 2 looks like!
July 9, 2026
Going in blind and being swallowed by the darkest folklore.
Since I prefer skimming synopses just to catch the vibe without spoiling the experience, I went into Candlelight mostly blind, and what an excellent surprise. I was gripped by a story that dives headfirst into dark folklore and reclaims the most dangerous and ancestral side of fae mythology.
What made this experience perfect:
• Multiple Voices with Soul: The story is told through multiple points of view (multiple POVs), and the author does this incredibly well. Unlike other books with multiple POVs where you usually end up favoring one storyline, I was equally invested in all of them. The characters feel and behave completely differently from one another, each carrying their own weight, traumas, and backstories.
• The Dark Roots of Folklore: Ancient legends, witches, and Celtic mythology recover their original essence: dark, dense, gothic, and full of mystery. The suspenseful atmosphere is present throughout the entire book.
• A Pace Impossible to Put Down: The writing has a fantastic fluidity, ideal for digital readers. The chapters move forward without any dead moments or tedious descriptions. Before I knew it, the 50% mark was behind me in the blink of an eye.
A must-read for anyone who loves dark conspiracies, dense worlds, and complex character arcs. I can't wait to read the next one!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Since I prefer skimming synopses just to catch the vibe without spoiling the experience, I went into Candlelight mostly blind, and what an excellent surprise. I was gripped by a story that dives headfirst into dark folklore and reclaims the most dangerous and ancestral side of fae mythology.
What made this experience perfect:
• Multiple Voices with Soul: The story is told through multiple points of view (multiple POVs), and the author does this incredibly well. Unlike other books with multiple POVs where you usually end up favoring one storyline, I was equally invested in all of them. The characters feel and behave completely differently from one another, each carrying their own weight, traumas, and backstories.
• The Dark Roots of Folklore: Ancient legends, witches, and Celtic mythology recover their original essence: dark, dense, gothic, and full of mystery. The suspenseful atmosphere is present throughout the entire book.
• A Pace Impossible to Put Down: The writing has a fantastic fluidity, ideal for digital readers. The chapters move forward without any dead moments or tedious descriptions. Before I knew it, the 50% mark was behind me in the blink of an eye.
A must-read for anyone who loves dark conspiracies, dense worlds, and complex character arcs. I can't wait to read the next one!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Set in 1986 in Beaumont, TX, “Candlelight” centers on a string of mysterious disappearances where children are taken away by a candle flame that only they can see. Detective Jacob Fusilier takes the case which becomes personal when his daughter becomes one of the missing. High school student Matthew Dean, targeted by bullies and plagued by recurring nightmares, sleepwalks into the woods and, unwittingly, performs a ritual that open a portal to another world. This opening unleashes ancient, supernatural entities upon the town. At the same time, Matthew discovers his “true heritage.”
First of all, shame on you NetGalley for listing this book in the Horror category. Realistically, it was probably 90% fantasy, 5% police procedural, and 5% horror. The plot idea with the missing children was what attracted me but when the plot expanded into the fantasy realm, it became too cumbersome with multiple additional plot points. The characters are developed but rather uninteresting, especially Matthew who is the main character. I did like the Detective but, at the end, he does something completely idiotic. I feel like this was done in preparation for the eventual book 2 of the series.
This book wasn’t for me but, I’m sure some will like it.
First of all, shame on you NetGalley for listing this book in the Horror category. Realistically, it was probably 90% fantasy, 5% police procedural, and 5% horror. The plot idea with the missing children was what attracted me but when the plot expanded into the fantasy realm, it became too cumbersome with multiple additional plot points. The characters are developed but rather uninteresting, especially Matthew who is the main character. I did like the Detective but, at the end, he does something completely idiotic. I feel like this was done in preparation for the eventual book 2 of the series.
This book wasn’t for me but, I’m sure some will like it.
July 1, 2026
If you are familiar with or interested in classical Celtic mythology beyond what is often showcase and contemporary urban fantasy novels, beings with distinctly inhuman appearances and motives, there’s a lot that will feel rewarding in this book. These are not glittery humans with a little extra ruthlessness mixed in, and the story is delightfully chilling for it. there is, accessible at the end of the book, a pronunciation guide, which I found quite useful.
The story shifts between multiple perspectives, which I thought worked particularly well in this novel, the characters are distinct and distinctly flawed, and so I didn’t find myself pushing through one perspective because I was just eager to get back to a storyline I found more compelling, I was definitely eager to find out what happened next elsewhere, but each character was well drawn enough to hold my interest in the moment.
This is the first book in a perspective series, and we definitely get it some answers by the end of this book, but there is also a bit of a cliffhanger. Personally, I will look forward to the next in the series.
The story shifts between multiple perspectives, which I thought worked particularly well in this novel, the characters are distinct and distinctly flawed, and so I didn’t find myself pushing through one perspective because I was just eager to get back to a storyline I found more compelling, I was definitely eager to find out what happened next elsewhere, but each character was well drawn enough to hold my interest in the moment.
This is the first book in a perspective series, and we definitely get it some answers by the end of this book, but there is also a bit of a cliffhanger. Personally, I will look forward to the next in the series.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
“The first book in The Grey Neighbors series, Candlelight is a dark fairy tale fueled by mythic horror, stolen innocence, and the scars parents leave for their children. There are no happily ever afters once the Grey Neighbors come calling.”
I really enjoyed this book. The alternating chapters between the two main character groups kept me hooked, and I found myself binging large sections because I always wanted to know what happened next.
The Irish language elements were a lovely addition, and the pronunciation guide was helpful — though placing it at the start would have made it even better. I also really liked the addition of character names from other books as characters in this story.
I will be picking up the next instalment when it comes out next year
Publication Date - 21st August 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Twisted Spindle Press & the Author for providing me with an advanced reader copy (ebook) of this book in exchange for an honest review.
#Candlelight #NetGalley.
I really enjoyed this book. The alternating chapters between the two main character groups kept me hooked, and I found myself binging large sections because I always wanted to know what happened next.
The Irish language elements were a lovely addition, and the pronunciation guide was helpful — though placing it at the start would have made it even better. I also really liked the addition of character names from other books as characters in this story.
I will be picking up the next instalment when it comes out next year
Publication Date - 21st August 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Twisted Spindle Press & the Author for providing me with an advanced reader copy (ebook) of this book in exchange for an honest review.
#Candlelight #NetGalley.
July 23, 2026
I received this as a free advanced copy from BookSirens and am leaving this review voluntarily . I thoroughly enjoyed this book and found myself staying up late just to see what happens next. This is written in multiple POV and I was invested in every one of these characters. The good, the bad and the ugly- and the author did NOT pale away from showing the darker nature of the characters while laying bare their own fragile "humanity." Not all the characters are human. . . 😉
The prose is basic, but that is not a negative. Rather, it allows him to move the story forward at a steady pace, showing rather than telling the audience. It reads like a TV show you want to binge watch.
The story is wholly original and not so much horror but dark folklore/fantasy. There are elements of both without feeding into one or the other, which lends the story an air of originality i have yet to encounter in other novels.
I look forward to the next installment because i HAVE to know what happens to these characters!!!!
The prose is basic, but that is not a negative. Rather, it allows him to move the story forward at a steady pace, showing rather than telling the audience. It reads like a TV show you want to binge watch.
The story is wholly original and not so much horror but dark folklore/fantasy. There are elements of both without feeding into one or the other, which lends the story an air of originality i have yet to encounter in other novels.
I look forward to the next installment because i HAVE to know what happens to these characters!!!!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The missing children hooked me first. Beaumont in 1986 already feels a little wrong before Matthew accidentally tears open a gateway to the fae, and from there Candlelight gets increasingly nasty in a way I really enjoyed. These creatures belong much closer to old folklore than sparkly fantasy, and Puck was a welcome bit of levity whenever things got especially grim.
I also liked that Matthew isn’t carrying the entire book himself. His mother Lina has been hiding a massive amount from him, while Detective Jacob Fusilier is investigating the disappearing children from the completely human side of the mess. That combination makes the supernatural reveals feel earned instead of dumped on you all at once.
It does take its time getting there, particularly around the middle, but once the folklore starts crawling out of the woods, I was in. Darker than I expected, occasionally brutal, and a very solid opening to The Grey Neighbors.
I also liked that Matthew isn’t carrying the entire book himself. His mother Lina has been hiding a massive amount from him, while Detective Jacob Fusilier is investigating the disappearing children from the completely human side of the mess. That combination makes the supernatural reveals feel earned instead of dumped on you all at once.
It does take its time getting there, particularly around the middle, but once the folklore starts crawling out of the woods, I was in. Darker than I expected, occasionally brutal, and a very solid opening to The Grey Neighbors.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced reader's copy!
This was a fun, whimsical, yet still somehow tense and dark, read that I found to be quite enjoyable. There were a few moments where the plot lost me, like when Matthew is doing the blood magic and somehow even though what he is seeing has already happened the characters are acting like its happening in real time acknowledging his presence, which just honestly didn't make much sense/wasn't explained well. Other than that, I thought the characters were great and the stakes were high with a lot of action and intense moments. The descriptions were nice and I appreciated the pronunciation guide at the back of the book. Overall, can't wait to read the next book when it comes out! 4/5 ⭐️
This was a fun, whimsical, yet still somehow tense and dark, read that I found to be quite enjoyable. There were a few moments where the plot lost me, like when Matthew is doing the blood magic and somehow even though what he is seeing has already happened the characters are acting like its happening in real time acknowledging his presence, which just honestly didn't make much sense/wasn't explained well. Other than that, I thought the characters were great and the stakes were high with a lot of action and intense moments. The descriptions were nice and I appreciated the pronunciation guide at the back of the book. Overall, can't wait to read the next book when it comes out! 4/5 ⭐️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you for the arc NetGalley and Twisted Spindle Press! I was not prepared for this story, I went in totally blind because I loved the cover. I also loved all of the nods to the 80's as that is when I was born. Really fun to incorporate all of those old memories.
Finding out your mom is an old witch in hiding must be crazy! But to then be dragged into this whole new world. What a journey!
This was definitely dark and creepy. I love the Irish and Welsh folklore blended with horror. There was a lot of great characters who really made the story, though the world building was a little lacking. But otherwise, a great book. Check your triggers.
Finding out your mom is an old witch in hiding must be crazy! But to then be dragged into this whole new world. What a journey!
This was definitely dark and creepy. I love the Irish and Welsh folklore blended with horror. There was a lot of great characters who really made the story, though the world building was a little lacking. But otherwise, a great book. Check your triggers.
Review of advance copy
Overall I enjoyed this book, I liked the 80s setting and I was drawn to the Puck character pretty quickly. It wasn't as much horror as I expected, but I also love fantasy so that didn't bother me.
This has a dual storyline with multi POV. Mathew's story was easier for me to follow, it carried most of the story and had most of the action. During the Texas POV I had to fight the urge to skip ahead for most of the book, it felt more like a place holder.
Overall, I will probably read the second one, if just to figure out what happens next.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thank you Booksirens.
This has a dual storyline with multi POV. Mathew's story was easier for me to follow, it carried most of the story and had most of the action. During the Texas POV I had to fight the urge to skip ahead for most of the book, it felt more like a place holder.
Overall, I will probably read the second one, if just to figure out what happens next.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thank you Booksirens.
Review of advance copy
D.L. Tolin has crafted something truly mesmerizing with Candlelight. The cover promises a "grim but riveting tale," and the book absolutely delivers on that atmospheric tension. From the very beginning, you are pulled into an unfathomable otherworld that feels both dangerous and completely captivating. The alternate realm is deeply immersive, populated by excellent characters that linger in your mind long after you've put the book down. If you appreciate a story that seamlessly weaves dark mystery with vivid fantasy, this is a must-read. Highly recommended.
Gimme book two!
Gimme book two!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Wow, what a story! So many unanswered questions at the end too!! Can't wait for the next book to come out.
This book captivated me from the start and I easily finished it in 24 hours. I loved the dark folklore and the coming together of two worlds. The characters were strong and the story was well written.
Fantastic debut novel from the author, thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to be an ARC reader.
This book captivated me from the start and I easily finished it in 24 hours. I loved the dark folklore and the coming together of two worlds. The characters were strong and the story was well written.
Fantastic debut novel from the author, thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to be an ARC reader.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This book was such a treat! It perfectly characterizes what it was like growing up in the 80s with so many fun references. It kept me on the edge of my seat wondering what was going to happen next. Not my usual genre, but I really enjoyed the characters and turns that the story took - I’m looking forward to the next installment!
Review of advance copy received from Author
I was lucky enough to read an advance copy of David Tolin’s brilliant debut novel and could not put it down! The characters are enchanting and the story draws you in immediately and doesn’t let you go until the closing words. If you love dark fantasy, you’ll adore this book and (like me) will be anxiously awaiting the next installment!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Received as an advanced copy through NetGalley. This was a very interesting book that had me on edge of my seat and unnerved. Great pacing and writing overall. Definitely recommend, fun read
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
If you are a fan of nostalgia and dark fantasy then this book is for you. This book takes a few twists and turns in it that I was not expecting but made me keep reading. Never once did it feel like it was too much on the twists, fantasy, or even character or world building. It was a very enjoyable read.
August 10, 2026
Dark folklore blending Celtic mythology and a suspenseful atmosphere.
This story draws you in deeply from when the first child goes missing. A good part of the book is world building as it describes the sinister fae. The characters are real, vulnerable and full of their own regrets. Detective Jacob is investigating the missing children, and part of the book is from his POV.
The story feels like a tv series, with each chapter a different POV, but this works smartly. You get inside the head of each character at a steady pace.
The interspersing of supernatural and real life is clever and has echoes of Koontz and King.
The ending was a little too open for me but I’m guessing this is to set up book 2, which I am interested to read.
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC
This story draws you in deeply from when the first child goes missing. A good part of the book is world building as it describes the sinister fae. The characters are real, vulnerable and full of their own regrets. Detective Jacob is investigating the missing children, and part of the book is from his POV.
The story feels like a tv series, with each chapter a different POV, but this works smartly. You get inside the head of each character at a steady pace.
The interspersing of supernatural and real life is clever and has echoes of Koontz and King.
The ending was a little too open for me but I’m guessing this is to set up book 2, which I am interested to read.
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews