What do you think?
Rate this book
Superman: Earth One #3
Superman: Earth One Vol. 3
WHO WILL SAVE SUPERMAN?
Earth has turned its back, leaving Clark Kent at the mercy of the Luthors and Zod
Invulnerable? Maybe.
Alone? Definitely.
In his brief stint as a costumed superhero, Clark Kent has run a gauntlet of the world's most deadly and monstrous villains. However, his most dire threat may come from two powerless human beings. Who both just happen to be the two smartest people on the planet.
Lex and Alexandra Luthor have been paid very well to find a way to cancel Superman's powers. The man who destroyed Krypton has been welcomed and invited by the world governments to complete his mission with the murder of Kal-El.
Betrayed, at his most vulnerable, there is no place to hide and no one he can trust. The newcomer from Smallville who would be Superman faces his greatest challenge yet as the world he fought to save sells him out.
Writer J. Michael Straczynski is joined by artist Ardian Syaf (BATGIRL) in the third installment of the #1 New York Times best-selling series SUPERMAN: EARTH ONE, an epic story of betrayal and sacrifice in the name of truth and justice.
Earth has turned its back, leaving Clark Kent at the mercy of the Luthors and Zod
Invulnerable? Maybe.
Alone? Definitely.
In his brief stint as a costumed superhero, Clark Kent has run a gauntlet of the world's most deadly and monstrous villains. However, his most dire threat may come from two powerless human beings. Who both just happen to be the two smartest people on the planet.
Lex and Alexandra Luthor have been paid very well to find a way to cancel Superman's powers. The man who destroyed Krypton has been welcomed and invited by the world governments to complete his mission with the murder of Kal-El.
Betrayed, at his most vulnerable, there is no place to hide and no one he can trust. The newcomer from Smallville who would be Superman faces his greatest challenge yet as the world he fought to save sells him out.
Writer J. Michael Straczynski is joined by artist Ardian Syaf (BATGIRL) in the third installment of the #1 New York Times best-selling series SUPERMAN: EARTH ONE, an epic story of betrayal and sacrifice in the name of truth and justice.
136 pages, Paperback
First published February 10, 2015
About the author
J. Michael Straczynski
1,389 books1,312 followersJoseph Michael Straczynski is an American filmmaker and comic book writer. He is the founder of Synthetic Worlds Ltd. and Studio JMS and is best known as the creator of the science fiction television series Babylon 5 (1993–1998) and its spinoff Crusade (1999), as well as the series Jeremiah (2002–2004) and Sense8 (2015–2018). He is the executor of the estate of Harlan Ellison.
Straczynski wrote the psychological drama film Changeling (2008) and was co-writer on the martial arts thriller Ninja Assassin (2009), was one of the key writers for (and had a cameo in) Marvel's Thor (2011), as well as the horror film Underworld: Awakening (2012), and the apocalyptic horror film World War Z (2013). From 2001 to 2007, Straczynski wrote Marvel Comics' The Amazing Spider-Man, followed by runs on Thor and Fantastic Four. He is the author of the Superman: Earth One trilogy of graphic novels, and he has written Superman, Wonder Woman, and Before Watchmen for DC Comics. Straczynski is the creator and writer of several original comic book series such as Rising Stars, Midnight Nation, Dream Police, and Ten Grand through Joe's Comics.
A prolific writer across a variety of media and former journalist, Straczynski is the author of the autobiography Becoming Superman (2019) for HarperVoyager, the novel Together We Will Go (2021) for Simon & Schuster, and Becoming a Writer, Staying a Writer (2021) for Benbella Books. In 2020 he was named Head of the Creative Council for the comics publishing company Artists, Writers and Artisans.
Straczynski is a long-time participant in Usenet and other early computer networks, interacting with fans through various online forums (including GEnie, CompuServe, and America Online) since 1984. He is credited as being the first TV producer to directly engage with fans on the Internet and to allow viewer viewpoints to influence the look and feel of his show. Two prominent areas where he had a presence were GEnie and the newsgroup rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.moderated.
Straczynski wrote the psychological drama film Changeling (2008) and was co-writer on the martial arts thriller Ninja Assassin (2009), was one of the key writers for (and had a cameo in) Marvel's Thor (2011), as well as the horror film Underworld: Awakening (2012), and the apocalyptic horror film World War Z (2013). From 2001 to 2007, Straczynski wrote Marvel Comics' The Amazing Spider-Man, followed by runs on Thor and Fantastic Four. He is the author of the Superman: Earth One trilogy of graphic novels, and he has written Superman, Wonder Woman, and Before Watchmen for DC Comics. Straczynski is the creator and writer of several original comic book series such as Rising Stars, Midnight Nation, Dream Police, and Ten Grand through Joe's Comics.
A prolific writer across a variety of media and former journalist, Straczynski is the author of the autobiography Becoming Superman (2019) for HarperVoyager, the novel Together We Will Go (2021) for Simon & Schuster, and Becoming a Writer, Staying a Writer (2021) for Benbella Books. In 2020 he was named Head of the Creative Council for the comics publishing company Artists, Writers and Artisans.
Straczynski is a long-time participant in Usenet and other early computer networks, interacting with fans through various online forums (including GEnie, CompuServe, and America Online) since 1984. He is credited as being the first TV producer to directly engage with fans on the Internet and to allow viewer viewpoints to influence the look and feel of his show. Two prominent areas where he had a presence were GEnie and the newsgroup rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.moderated.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 277 reviews
January 17, 2015
In the final volume, Zod comes to Earth with a new origin story.
But he's still the same old evil villain and eventually his true colors shine through. However, do to some serious miscalculation on the part of the world's governments they align with him to take out Superman. It doesn't 100% make sense, to be honest.
If they don't trust one superpowered Kryptonian, why would they trust another one?
But hey, we wouldn't have a superfight without it and that's all we're really looking for anyway.
This one also solidifies the origin of this Earth's Lex Luthor, but the less I say about that, the better. Cool twist.
Clark and Lois call an uneasy truce in the newsroom, and Lois becomes Superman's go-to person for advice on how to not freak out governments. Much.
The romance between Clark and Lisa heats up and the ending was sweet.
Pretty cool ending all in all. It's probably never going to go down as one of my favorite incarnations of Superman simply because Clark is awkward, closed off, and occasionally just plain weird.
But I appreciated what Straczynski did with this Elseworlds story a lot more this time around.
Recommended.
But he's still the same old evil villain and eventually his true colors shine through. However, do to some serious miscalculation on the part of the world's governments they align with him to take out Superman. It doesn't 100% make sense, to be honest.
If they don't trust one superpowered Kryptonian, why would they trust another one?
But hey, we wouldn't have a superfight without it and that's all we're really looking for anyway.
This one also solidifies the origin of this Earth's Lex Luthor, but the less I say about that, the better. Cool twist.
Clark and Lois call an uneasy truce in the newsroom, and Lois becomes Superman's go-to person for advice on how to not freak out governments. Much.
The romance between Clark and Lisa heats up and the ending was sweet.
Pretty cool ending all in all. It's probably never going to go down as one of my favorite incarnations of Superman simply because Clark is awkward, closed off, and occasionally just plain weird.
But I appreciated what Straczynski did with this Elseworlds story a lot more this time around.
Recommended.
May 7, 2015
Great option to Clark Kent’s fans!
This is the third volume of “Superman: Earth One” which is a yearly publication setting the character in an “elseworld” (a parallel dimension).
Creative Team:
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski
Illustrator: Ardian Syaf
Inker: Sandra Hope (because she is one of the best inker in the business, so it’s always relevant to mention her if she is on the book).
WHAT MAKES HIM SUPERMAN?
If one man with a bullet in Dallas, or Memphis, or India can change the world. How much can one person with an idea... or even just the will to speak out... change the world?
What makes him Superman? One wrong answer could be his alien planet of origin or his superpowers. After all, he didn’t know from where he was from or got superpowers until adulthood, so his education and values came from his Earth’s adoptive parents, and he needed to grew up as a regular kid.
But even in previous incarnations where he arrived with all that alien knowledge in his brain and with already powered abilities, the key of what makes him Superman weren’t those mentioned elements.
What makes him Superman is that he could be anybody who wish BUT he decided to be Superman, he decided to take the impossible never-ending challenge of protecting a world which isn’t his own and to save as many possible lives, instead of having an easy life. People would say, well he isn’t a millionaire, he couldn’t have an easy life... hey, people, he can make diamonds from coal with his bare hands! He could be rich if he wishes to, but he was educated to gain his living, but of course, that doesn’t stop him to make some diamonds when a hospital bill of a dear close one needs to be paid.
SOMETHINGS... OLD, NEW, BORROWED & BLUE
Just because you do something doesn’t mean you should do it.
Superman: Earth One is a retelling of Superman’s life since its beginning.
In Volume One, it was told how he resolved to become a reporter for Daily Planet and his first challenge as Superman (where Clark’s struggles to find a suitable career was awesome but the expected super battle was okay).
In Volume Two, it was told how the governments are worried about having a Superman in the world, specially if he decides to tumble an oppressive foreign regime, and therefore now the governments are looking for options to have in hand in case if they need to engage against Superman.
Along in the construction of this “elseworlds” story, and continuing on this Third Volume, you have somethings...
Old: You have classic recognizable elements and characters such as the Daily Planet, Lois Lane, Jimmy Olsen, Perry White, Martha Kent, Lex Luthor, etc...
New: Lisa Lasalle who is Clark’s girlfriend (and she is easily the best thing in the series!), Alexandra Luthor who is Lex Luthor’s wife (and the married couple has a scientific consulting company).
Borrowed: Without complaining, but just mentioning that it’s clear that this series have taken some “borrowed” elements from other comic books such like Spider-Man and believe it or not, in this Third Volume even there is a Lion King situation!... Nants ingonyama bagithi baba!!!
Blue: His suit! D’oh! (which keeps his red shorts over his blue pants).
But no, while you have all the four things needed, nope, there isn’t any wedding yet.
CLARK KENT V SUPERMAN: DAWN OF EARTH ONE
Clark, if she’s got issues, then you’ve got a ten-volume set complete with illustrations, footnotes, an index, appendices, woodcuts, a table of contents...
Okay, okay, okay --
What really makes awesome this comic book series isn’t Superman. It’s not like he isn’t shown great, he does, but his villains and the involving battles aren’t anything you haven’t read/watched before.
However, Clark...
Finally, Clark’s personal life is relevant, it’s interesting and it’s taking unpredictable roads.
Actually, it’s more rewarding reading the scenes with Clark in his personal life, than when he needs to put into the suit and go out and flying to save the world.
If you’re looking for this comic book series for Superman’s action, hardly you will be dissapointed, but you won’t get much original stuff neither.
However, if you are looking for this comic book series for Clark’s life, definitely you will be in the right comic book.
This is the third volume of “Superman: Earth One” which is a yearly publication setting the character in an “elseworld” (a parallel dimension).
Creative Team:
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski
Illustrator: Ardian Syaf
Inker: Sandra Hope (because she is one of the best inker in the business, so it’s always relevant to mention her if she is on the book).
WHAT MAKES HIM SUPERMAN?
If one man with a bullet in Dallas, or Memphis, or India can change the world. How much can one person with an idea... or even just the will to speak out... change the world?
What makes him Superman? One wrong answer could be his alien planet of origin or his superpowers. After all, he didn’t know from where he was from or got superpowers until adulthood, so his education and values came from his Earth’s adoptive parents, and he needed to grew up as a regular kid.
But even in previous incarnations where he arrived with all that alien knowledge in his brain and with already powered abilities, the key of what makes him Superman weren’t those mentioned elements.
What makes him Superman is that he could be anybody who wish BUT he decided to be Superman, he decided to take the impossible never-ending challenge of protecting a world which isn’t his own and to save as many possible lives, instead of having an easy life. People would say, well he isn’t a millionaire, he couldn’t have an easy life... hey, people, he can make diamonds from coal with his bare hands! He could be rich if he wishes to, but he was educated to gain his living, but of course, that doesn’t stop him to make some diamonds when a hospital bill of a dear close one needs to be paid.
SOMETHINGS... OLD, NEW, BORROWED & BLUE
Just because you do something doesn’t mean you should do it.
Superman: Earth One is a retelling of Superman’s life since its beginning.
In Volume One, it was told how he resolved to become a reporter for Daily Planet and his first challenge as Superman (where Clark’s struggles to find a suitable career was awesome but the expected super battle was okay).
In Volume Two, it was told how the governments are worried about having a Superman in the world, specially if he decides to tumble an oppressive foreign regime, and therefore now the governments are looking for options to have in hand in case if they need to engage against Superman.
Along in the construction of this “elseworlds” story, and continuing on this Third Volume, you have somethings...
Old: You have classic recognizable elements and characters such as the Daily Planet, Lois Lane, Jimmy Olsen, Perry White, Martha Kent, Lex Luthor, etc...
New: Lisa Lasalle who is Clark’s girlfriend (and she is easily the best thing in the series!), Alexandra Luthor who is Lex Luthor’s wife (and the married couple has a scientific consulting company).
Borrowed: Without complaining, but just mentioning that it’s clear that this series have taken some “borrowed” elements from other comic books such like Spider-Man and believe it or not, in this Third Volume even there is a Lion King situation!... Nants ingonyama bagithi baba!!!
Blue: His suit! D’oh! (which keeps his red shorts over his blue pants).
But no, while you have all the four things needed, nope, there isn’t any wedding yet.
CLARK KENT V SUPERMAN: DAWN OF EARTH ONE
Clark, if she’s got issues, then you’ve got a ten-volume set complete with illustrations, footnotes, an index, appendices, woodcuts, a table of contents...
Okay, okay, okay --
What really makes awesome this comic book series isn’t Superman. It’s not like he isn’t shown great, he does, but his villains and the involving battles aren’t anything you haven’t read/watched before.
However, Clark...
Finally, Clark’s personal life is relevant, it’s interesting and it’s taking unpredictable roads.
Actually, it’s more rewarding reading the scenes with Clark in his personal life, than when he needs to put into the suit and go out and flying to save the world.
If you’re looking for this comic book series for Superman’s action, hardly you will be dissapointed, but you won’t get much original stuff neither.
However, if you are looking for this comic book series for Clark’s life, definitely you will be in the right comic book.
September 24, 2019
"You're scaring people, and I know that's not what you want . . ." -- Lois Lane, to Superman
With the arrival of the third volume this series is now giving Batman: Earth One a run for its money on which is the best from this particular DC imprint. Superman simultaneously has to contend with Earth's governments collectively turning their back on him (as they have been suspicious of this new alien do-gooder, and the involved collateral damage with his actions) AND the arrival of the vexed, villainous Zod of Krypton (who holds a long-standing grudge against the 'El' family a.k.a. Superman's deceased kin). And on top of all of this someone from Clark Kent's small inner circle accidentally learns of his costumed secret identity. Lots of action and drama - plus a few surprises, such as the set-up for an antagonist in a possible future volume - in this reimagining of a superhero legend.
With the arrival of the third volume this series is now giving Batman: Earth One a run for its money on which is the best from this particular DC imprint. Superman simultaneously has to contend with Earth's governments collectively turning their back on him (as they have been suspicious of this new alien do-gooder, and the involved collateral damage with his actions) AND the arrival of the vexed, villainous Zod of Krypton (who holds a long-standing grudge against the 'El' family a.k.a. Superman's deceased kin). And on top of all of this someone from Clark Kent's small inner circle accidentally learns of his costumed secret identity. Lots of action and drama - plus a few surprises, such as the set-up for an antagonist in a possible future volume - in this reimagining of a superhero legend.
April 11, 2017
I rated this comic book based on the content, not because the penciller, just for your info.
I had purchased this book from a GR friend only a few days before I noticed about the X-Men Gold #1 Controversy. To be honest, if I choose a comic based on the contributors, I check who is the writer, not the penciller. So, it was a coincidence.
Now the review:
I never read Superman Earth One before. So, I was surprised with some new changes in this version of Superman. Especially I like the new lover of Superman, Lisa. And I agree with other reviews, the personal life of Clark Kent is the fascinating part of this volume. (Well, personally I am afraid a villain, maybe Alexa, will kill Lisa and made Clark an even darker person in this already a gloomy Superman). In general, I like the more human Clark/Superman. .
But I don't like the Luthors, especially the twist, I felt it was really forced. It was a shame actually, if it was a better twist, it could become my fav Luthors.
I had purchased this book from a GR friend only a few days before I noticed about the X-Men Gold #1 Controversy. To be honest, if I choose a comic based on the contributors, I check who is the writer, not the penciller. So, it was a coincidence.
Now the review:
I never read Superman Earth One before. So, I was surprised with some new changes in this version of Superman. Especially I like the new lover of Superman, Lisa. And I agree with other reviews, the personal life of Clark Kent is the fascinating part of this volume. (Well, personally I am afraid a villain, maybe Alexa, will kill Lisa and made Clark an even darker person in this already a gloomy Superman). In general, I like the more human Clark/Superman. .
But I don't like the Luthors, especially the twist, I felt it was really forced. It was a shame actually, if it was a better twist, it could become my fav Luthors.
June 6, 2015
Very disappointed in this one. A big step down from the previous volumes, reason being I hoped they would have created new enemies again or explored something new like previously and in smaller respects like lex Luther they have, but Zod.....again oh come on. He's such a boring bad guy.
This whole volume bored me to death when Zod was in it. As soon as I found out the bad guy was Zod I switched off.
Hopefully the next volume will be better.
This whole volume bored me to death when Zod was in it. As soon as I found out the bad guy was Zod I switched off.
Hopefully the next volume will be better.
February 4, 2015
First off, thanks to NetGalley for an ARC! It took forever for me to FINALLY get approved by one of the majors!
Luckily, I'd already read the first 2 volumes, so I wasn't going in blind.
In this story, we find out that a certain Kryptonian isn't the last survivor...there's another, and he's seeking out Kal.
The real basis for the story is still a combo of Clark growing as a human, and Superman being looked at with mistrust and suspicion by the militaries and governments of the world.
Lex Luthor, who appeared at the end of volume 2, appears again here, though in a somewhat different mindset than you might be used to. He also doesn't appear alone...
Lois 100% steals an idea from Jim Gordon, and wisely, Superman points out how bad an idea it is in addition to being what she thinks is a good one.
However, when the second Kryptonian arrives, he disarms Kal with kindness, while convincing the global powers that perhaps Kal isn't all he claims to be...this is some good villainous duplicity.
The art is strong, just as it was in the first two volumes, though a new artist has taken over, the style remains similar, and still very enjoyable.
When everyone turns their back on Superman, he is tested beyond his abilities, and it will be from two very unlikely sources that he draws strength and support. One of them for sure was a welcome twist in the Superman mythos for sure, and the other was a fitting way to move an important subplot forward in a very agreeable way.
Without any spoilers, I'll just say that there's new twists on old favourites and parts of the Superman Origin/Story, and for the most part, I find they work very well. That being said, other than the one reversal of character, there's not much majorly different here from the regular Superman, though I do enjoy this one.
Straczynski has written another solid volume to this series, but it's not quite as WOW as the other two were...however, it's stil a good Superman story that really emphasizes his young nature striving to embrace and learn even more from humanity. This Superman (and Clark) are both growing in leaps and bounds, and I do look forward to seeing where this will go from here.
Thanks again to NetGalley for the Advance Review Copy (digital).
Luckily, I'd already read the first 2 volumes, so I wasn't going in blind.
In this story, we find out that a certain Kryptonian isn't the last survivor...there's another, and he's seeking out Kal.
The real basis for the story is still a combo of Clark growing as a human, and Superman being looked at with mistrust and suspicion by the militaries and governments of the world.
Lex Luthor, who appeared at the end of volume 2, appears again here, though in a somewhat different mindset than you might be used to. He also doesn't appear alone...
Lois 100% steals an idea from Jim Gordon, and wisely, Superman points out how bad an idea it is in addition to being what she thinks is a good one.
However, when the second Kryptonian arrives, he disarms Kal with kindness, while convincing the global powers that perhaps Kal isn't all he claims to be...this is some good villainous duplicity.
The art is strong, just as it was in the first two volumes, though a new artist has taken over, the style remains similar, and still very enjoyable.
When everyone turns their back on Superman, he is tested beyond his abilities, and it will be from two very unlikely sources that he draws strength and support. One of them for sure was a welcome twist in the Superman mythos for sure, and the other was a fitting way to move an important subplot forward in a very agreeable way.
Without any spoilers, I'll just say that there's new twists on old favourites and parts of the Superman Origin/Story, and for the most part, I find they work very well. That being said, other than the one reversal of character, there's not much majorly different here from the regular Superman, though I do enjoy this one.
Straczynski has written another solid volume to this series, but it's not quite as WOW as the other two were...however, it's stil a good Superman story that really emphasizes his young nature striving to embrace and learn even more from humanity. This Superman (and Clark) are both growing in leaps and bounds, and I do look forward to seeing where this will go from here.
Thanks again to NetGalley for the Advance Review Copy (digital).
January 29, 2019
A good (what I can only guess is) conclusion to the Earth One Superman books. I haven’t heard of any more books in the line being announced, but I would gladly pick up Volume 4 if they decide to continue. I like where Superman and Lisa ended, but I’m not sure I really care for “Lex”. I did like where this took Zod, who I usually don’t care for, but I’m not sure how I feel about the “Ruling Family” of Krypton part. This does feel like a slight retread of the first volume, but it’s been so long since I’ve read it that I don’t really mind.
October 24, 2021
This was okay but seriously? Governments making decisions on a whim. Superman's speech should have been given by someone on their council before they decided they had to do away with him. I had other issues too but I've already forgotten them, so whatever. Lisa and Clark are cute together.
March 11, 2015
Excellent alternate universe tale, just wish they'd come out faster ;-)
April 27, 2021
Rating: more of a 2.5 stars?
The artwork is still lovely, but the characters and their decisions leave many things to be desired. Although it's understandable that the governments on Earth and many people are weary of Superman and his unstoppable power, still Lex's wife Alexa Luthor, came off cold hearted and crazy at the end--she blames everything on Superman but, isn't she the one to go after him in the first place? On the other hand, Lex himself is a pleasant surprise, plus the guy has some sexy red hair this time!
Zod shows up in this volume as the main antagonist, I can't say I like his new outlook much (hoodie just doesn't look sexy and badass on him, sorry) and I'm not sure will he ever show up again in the later volumes.
Still, I do like Clark's girlfriend Lisa and Clark's relationship with Lois, plus neither of these two women are some damsel in distress that need saving.
The artwork is still lovely, but the characters and their decisions leave many things to be desired. Although it's understandable that the governments on Earth and many people are weary of Superman and his unstoppable power, still Lex's wife Alexa Luthor, came off cold hearted and crazy at the end--she blames everything on Superman but, isn't she the one to go after him in the first place? On the other hand, Lex himself is a pleasant surprise, plus the guy has some sexy red hair this time!
Zod shows up in this volume as the main antagonist, I can't say I like his new outlook much (hoodie just doesn't look sexy and badass on him, sorry) and I'm not sure will he ever show up again in the later volumes.
Still, I do like Clark's girlfriend Lisa and Clark's relationship with Lois, plus neither of these two women are some damsel in distress that need saving.
January 3, 2017
I love this volume. I though volume one was great, volume two I felt was a little bit rushed and really a set up to this volume. I was right, this is a direct continuation of the fall out from the last volume. The story and art work is great. The improvement on the art work for this volume is that the pannels go together better. Meaning it does feel like too much of the gone past between panels.
Superman crossed a line in the last volume. He did what he though was best for the world by removing a corrupt evil dictator from power in his country. The rest of the world leaders are worried if it is going to be their turn next. To resolve this problem they turn husband and wife scientists, the Luthors. Witness the origin of Superman's greatest nemesis with a twist. Then there is Zod the only one who can match Superman physically.
Great action, moral dilemmas and great story telling. This is a book that has it all. I like the way that because Superman is still young he is still naïve about his emotions and human perceptions as well. I am also glad that he loses his temper from time to time an say exactly what I as a reader thinking. I love Ardian Syaf take on Zod. I also like the fact that Superman gets a proper taste or mortality in the volume as well. I can't wait for the next volume.
Superman crossed a line in the last volume. He did what he though was best for the world by removing a corrupt evil dictator from power in his country. The rest of the world leaders are worried if it is going to be their turn next. To resolve this problem they turn husband and wife scientists, the Luthors. Witness the origin of Superman's greatest nemesis with a twist. Then there is Zod the only one who can match Superman physically.
Great action, moral dilemmas and great story telling. This is a book that has it all. I like the way that because Superman is still young he is still naïve about his emotions and human perceptions as well. I am also glad that he loses his temper from time to time an say exactly what I as a reader thinking. I love Ardian Syaf take on Zod. I also like the fact that Superman gets a proper taste or mortality in the volume as well. I can't wait for the next volume.
September 3, 2014
Also reviewed on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mUREy...
WOW AGAIN, AGAIN AND AGAIN!!! I loved the first 2 volumes and this volume is just as good! So this volume has Zod as the villain, I really liked his costume, pretty badass! The writing is still good, the characters are well done, ending fight scene was done a little differently compared to the first 2 volumes but still very well done! There is a change of artist but the new art is really nice! I also appreciate DC picking someone with a similar art style to Shane Davis making his replacement perfect! The spin they do on Lex Luthor makes me excited for the next one! Overall a book which deserves a badass seal of approval! (If i was Angry Joe lol)
WOW AGAIN, AGAIN AND AGAIN!!! I loved the first 2 volumes and this volume is just as good! So this volume has Zod as the villain, I really liked his costume, pretty badass! The writing is still good, the characters are well done, ending fight scene was done a little differently compared to the first 2 volumes but still very well done! There is a change of artist but the new art is really nice! I also appreciate DC picking someone with a similar art style to Shane Davis making his replacement perfect! The spin they do on Lex Luthor makes me excited for the next one! Overall a book which deserves a badass seal of approval! (If i was Angry Joe lol)
December 5, 2021
Superman: Earth One, Volume 3 is a graphic novel penned by J. Michael Straczynski and penciled by Ardian Syaf. It is a modernized re-imagining of the Superman origin series outside the main universe.
Superman has emerged victorious in the aftermath of his battle with Parasite and his interference in the nation of Borada, but at a cost. The US military is more determined than ever to neutralize what they see as a clear and present danger and the United Nations grows increasingly concerned over Superman.
Dr. Alexander Luthor and his wife, Alexandra, play the footage of Superman's battle with Tyrell, revealing that Superman is vulnerable to red solar radiation – a weakness they can employ against Superman.
Meanwhile, in an unspecified desert, an extraterrestrial ship lands. A mysterious humanoid figure appears, and begins to develop powers under Earth's yellow sun. He then tests his powers on a group of soldiers that appear before him, killing them all with ease.
When Superman later goes to the scene of a collapsing bridge, another super-powered being named Zod-El appears, who says he is Superman's biological uncle. Zod claims that he has been searching for Kal-El ever since Krypton exploded. Though Superman is glad that he is not the only survivor of Krypton, he is skeptical of whether Zod is an ally.
Zod addresses the United Nations, stating that the House of El caused the planet Krypton to explode, and that Superman is a threat. Zod persuades the delegates that he is an ally and wants to help them kill Superman.
Superman: Earth One, Volume 3 is written and constructed rather well. In the previous installments, Straczynski had already succeeded in exploring the Clark Kent side of things and the various difficulties the character faces in trying to fit in and live a normal life. This time, the Superman side comes more sharply into focus. Whether battling Zod, saving innocents, or addressing the United Nations, this character shows a maturity he didn't have before. However, with two villains to write about, each didn't get the space and time needed to really develop.
Syaf's penciling is done rather well. Taking over from Shane Davis, Syaf shows a greater ability to use body language and facial expressions to enhance the storytelling. His Superman is meatier and not feels like a teenager in adult clothes. On the other hand, the level of detail and clarity in this installment are never very consistent. Certain pages have a loose, rushed quality, especially in cases where characters are rendered only in silhouette.
All in all, Superman: Earth One, Volume 3 is a good concluding graphic novel of a tale about the modernization of the Superman mythos.
Superman has emerged victorious in the aftermath of his battle with Parasite and his interference in the nation of Borada, but at a cost. The US military is more determined than ever to neutralize what they see as a clear and present danger and the United Nations grows increasingly concerned over Superman.
Dr. Alexander Luthor and his wife, Alexandra, play the footage of Superman's battle with Tyrell, revealing that Superman is vulnerable to red solar radiation – a weakness they can employ against Superman.
Meanwhile, in an unspecified desert, an extraterrestrial ship lands. A mysterious humanoid figure appears, and begins to develop powers under Earth's yellow sun. He then tests his powers on a group of soldiers that appear before him, killing them all with ease.
When Superman later goes to the scene of a collapsing bridge, another super-powered being named Zod-El appears, who says he is Superman's biological uncle. Zod claims that he has been searching for Kal-El ever since Krypton exploded. Though Superman is glad that he is not the only survivor of Krypton, he is skeptical of whether Zod is an ally.
Zod addresses the United Nations, stating that the House of El caused the planet Krypton to explode, and that Superman is a threat. Zod persuades the delegates that he is an ally and wants to help them kill Superman.
Superman: Earth One, Volume 3 is written and constructed rather well. In the previous installments, Straczynski had already succeeded in exploring the Clark Kent side of things and the various difficulties the character faces in trying to fit in and live a normal life. This time, the Superman side comes more sharply into focus. Whether battling Zod, saving innocents, or addressing the United Nations, this character shows a maturity he didn't have before. However, with two villains to write about, each didn't get the space and time needed to really develop.
Syaf's penciling is done rather well. Taking over from Shane Davis, Syaf shows a greater ability to use body language and facial expressions to enhance the storytelling. His Superman is meatier and not feels like a teenager in adult clothes. On the other hand, the level of detail and clarity in this installment are never very consistent. Certain pages have a loose, rushed quality, especially in cases where characters are rendered only in silhouette.
All in all, Superman: Earth One, Volume 3 is a good concluding graphic novel of a tale about the modernization of the Superman mythos.
February 23, 2022
The third volume of the Superman Earth One series continues being fantastic.
This time we meet the Luthors and they are very different from the main continuity, but an interesting take on them for sure. The Villain here is Zod and although he is not entirely original he has some cool changes (and a cool suit).
We also see the relationships Clark has with Lisa, Lois, Jimmy and the others evolve and I have to say I'm a big fan of what Straczynski is doing here.
The art changes from the previous volumes as Ardian Syaf takes over from Shane Davis and he does an amazing job.
My only complains is that this wasn't longer and maybe felt a bit rushed.
I definitely recommend the whole Earth One series.
This time we meet the Luthors and they are very different from the main continuity, but an interesting take on them for sure. The Villain here is Zod and although he is not entirely original he has some cool changes (and a cool suit).
We also see the relationships Clark has with Lisa, Lois, Jimmy and the others evolve and I have to say I'm a big fan of what Straczynski is doing here.
The art changes from the previous volumes as Ardian Syaf takes over from Shane Davis and he does an amazing job.
My only complains is that this wasn't longer and maybe felt a bit rushed.
I definitely recommend the whole Earth One series.
January 9, 2017
This was definitely my least favorite of the "Superman: Earth One" trilogy by J. Michael Straczynski. That says something considering my thoughts on the two previous volumes.
In this finale, it is revealed that it was actually General Zod who was behind the destruction of Krypton. He has now followed Kal-El to Earth to finish what Tyrell and the Dherons were unable to accomplish in volume 1; the death of Superman.
Zod somehow manages to convince the governments of the world to not interfere, while he essentially murders Superman on live TV. What these same governments thought Zod would do once the one man capable of stopping him was gone is not addressed. A battle ensues, Superman is brutally beaten by Zod and is only saved by the intervention of Lisa Lasalle and ironically, Lex Luthor. The trilogy comes to a conclusion with Lex sacrificing himself to save Superman, Alexandra Luthor killing Zod (in an act of revenge) and dedicating her remaining years to killing the Last Son of Krypton.
Of all the Superman stories I've read featuring my personal favorite villain General Zod, this one was the one I enjoyed the least. There was simply no originality to this/his story.
In conclusion, I likely wouldn't recommend the "Superman: Earth One" trilogy to new readers of Superman comics, there are simply too many superior stories/arcs to start with. I think these Earth One elseworlds stories are better suited to seasoned readers of DC comics looking for something new. Hopefully my upcoming re-reads of Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern and Teen Titans: Earth One will be more enjoyable than Superman.
In this finale, it is revealed that it was actually General Zod who was behind the destruction of Krypton. He has now followed Kal-El to Earth to finish what Tyrell and the Dherons were unable to accomplish in volume 1; the death of Superman.
Zod somehow manages to convince the governments of the world to not interfere, while he essentially murders Superman on live TV. What these same governments thought Zod would do once the one man capable of stopping him was gone is not addressed. A battle ensues, Superman is brutally beaten by Zod and is only saved by the intervention of Lisa Lasalle and ironically, Lex Luthor. The trilogy comes to a conclusion with Lex sacrificing himself to save Superman, Alexandra Luthor killing Zod (in an act of revenge) and dedicating her remaining years to killing the Last Son of Krypton.
Of all the Superman stories I've read featuring my personal favorite villain General Zod, this one was the one I enjoyed the least. There was simply no originality to this/his story.
In conclusion, I likely wouldn't recommend the "Superman: Earth One" trilogy to new readers of Superman comics, there are simply too many superior stories/arcs to start with. I think these Earth One elseworlds stories are better suited to seasoned readers of DC comics looking for something new. Hopefully my upcoming re-reads of Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern and Teen Titans: Earth One will be more enjoyable than Superman.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 10, 2019
Well, I wasn't expecting that twist! The antagonist was quite a dick!
I really liked these comics! I liked seeing the human side of Superman. There seems to be a big love/hate reaction to these series, but I really liked them.
I really liked these comics! I liked seeing the human side of Superman. There seems to be a big love/hate reaction to these series, but I really liked them.
March 25, 2015
In the third volume of "Earth One," Superman's two most popular villains are reintroduced and redefined in an epic way. Zod comes to Earth to battle Kal-El, and finds a chilling ally. Straczynski is fearless at introducing new characters and radically changing classic ones in a way that fits this new world. This series is great.
January 28, 2015
The best of this series so far. This is getting fun.
August 27, 2018
Pretty good ending to the Earth One series. I didn't like Zod that much, never have mainly because of he movies, but it's a good enough graphic novel.
Check out my new blog!
Check out my new blog!
June 12, 2021
This one made the whole series worth it, and offers a really powerful take on what makes Superman eternally compelling: the power of one good person choosing to do the right thing despite the world’s indifference.
Throughout this series, Clark has struggled with finding meaning, given that he can do almost anything. And he’s found that meaning in people who choose to do the hard thing, who walk towards danger rather than away. This chapter closes the loop by revealing people who are as inspired by Superman’s courage as he is by theirs.
Throughout this series, Clark has struggled with finding meaning, given that he can do almost anything. And he’s found that meaning in people who choose to do the hard thing, who walk towards danger rather than away. This chapter closes the loop by revealing people who are as inspired by Superman’s courage as he is by theirs.
February 12, 2015
JMS's updated take on the Man of Steel continues to be a fascinating read. With this latest volume, he puts his own spin on Supes' two most iconic villains: the devious Lex Luthor and the power-hungry Zod. Probably the best Zod moment in this book is when he's beating the snot out of a nearly-powerless Superman and tells him something to the effect of: the only reason I haven't broken your legs is so you'll have something to use to kneel before me. That pretty much sums of Zod nicely. I wouldn't have minded a little more depth in Zod's character, but JMS made up for that with the Luthors. I don't want to reveal any spoilers, but his version of the Luthor villain is fascinating. Another great addition to this version of Supes is his budding affair with his neighbor Lisa, who works as an escort. I love the juxtaposition between her and Clark. They come from such different worlds (in Clark's case, quite literally) but it's touching that they find some solace and companionship in each other. This is a Superman that honors all that has come before while respectfully adding to and rearranging the character's legend. Loved it.
June 11, 2016
Excellent! The best of the Earth One Superman books. I'm really enjoying this origin story! The art is by a different person this time, but they've kept to the same style and look. There are new characters we haven't had in the Superman-verse before and I'm liking them, but also there is a return of familiar ones. This volume has Superman working to save the world when another survivor of Krypton arrives to destroy him. Since Earth isn't taking too kindly to Supe's interfering with world affairs they turn a blind eye to it, but everything works out in the end. I love that Lex Luthor is a good guy in this, but Superman makes an enemy of the Luthor family nevertheless. Great read!
December 24, 2015
This is by far the best volume of the series so far. It gets a solid 3 if not a 3.4. The art is once again nice, and I liked the idea of Lex a lot (Though not the final outcome) I also loved the moments with Clark and his mother in this volume, very well done. We also got deeper into Clark and who he is, and what makes him different than the previous incarnations of this character. I just wish the villain could have been better like all the other volumes but a fun 3-arc story so far and would def pick up volume 4 whenever it comes out.
December 27, 2014
This was probably my least favorite of the Superman, Earth One series. Not because it was poorly written, but because it left so much unresolved. Interesting twist on the traditional take on Luthor. I look forward to seeing how that pans out.
February 14, 2015
I realize that Earth One is each individual writer's private sandbox that gives them carte blanche to do whatever moves them to do. That being said, any story that the author was trying to tell was completely overshadowed by all the absolute crazy that he introduced to the story.
February 25, 2015
I have to say this book is pretty good, I really enjoy this earth one series not just with superman but as a whole. mind you I'm not much of a superman fan at all. I don't know if this book is a four star but it's like a 3.8 lol worth the read if you're a earth one fan
October 19, 2015
Well....That was bloody fast...can`t wait for the next novel though ^_^
January 9, 2023
I love Superman: Earth One, Volume 3, and I think it's the best book in the Superman: Earth One series. One of its strengths is how it handles the way the world responds to Superman's actions. After seeing what he did in Borada and witnessing the destruction caused by his fights, they are understandably afraid. Yet, in their desire and intent for safety and security they turned to desperate and atrocious measures, especially after Zod plays off their fear.
Zod is one of the best-written antagonists in this trilogy. He is a three-dimensional character who may have began with good intentions in trying to help Krypton, but employed brutal (that is an understatement; I can't say much more without spoiling) tactics to achieve his goals. He also was Superman/Clark's toughest antagonist in this trilogy. The art shows the pain he inflicts on Clark so well. I felt for Superman/Clark.
Clark himself had another solid arc in this. He is a very good man with good intentions. Yet, as we see throughout the book, even with good (or understandable) intentions, mistakes can be made. Going back to an earlier point, he had good intentions with what he did in Borada and I empathize with him. Yet, there are also flaws with what he did as well and he struggles with the consequences of his actions. He also struggles with trying to decide what to do with his power, especially when he's faced with so much hostility (but also refuses to be apathetic in the face of injustice and when lives are at stake). Another solid aspect of his arc is being willing to both embrace who he is and being vulnerable. He has some superb character growth in this story.
The side characters are great too. I like Lisa much more in this book than I did in book two. There is more depth to her character in this book. We see her strength through her courage and kindness. She helps to bring the best out of Clark and, in spite of her own fears and worries, she pursues her dreams and goals. Lois is great too. While the book resolves the tension between her and Clark a bit quickly, we get to see the positive impact she has on Clark/Superman. I do wish we got to see more of her though, but, with so many characters in this trilogy, it is hard to fit everyone in.
As for the other characters, I like how Alexandra and Lex Luthor were written. This is a different take than what I've seen in the animated series and comics. I can't say much more without spoiling, but I like the twists with both of the Luthors and the way that their arcs end up. And, as with both Zod and Superman, there is also the case of good (or at least, understandable) intentions with them but also consequences.
Overall, I really enjoyed Volume 3. It is the last book in this series, and I wish there were more. There is so much more that can be told, but it also ends well. The humor itself was a mixed bag, but overall, the writing is very good. I give this book a 4.5 (rounded up to 5) and I recommend this book.
Zod is one of the best-written antagonists in this trilogy. He is a three-dimensional character who may have began with good intentions in trying to help Krypton, but employed brutal (that is an understatement; I can't say much more without spoiling) tactics to achieve his goals. He also was Superman/Clark's toughest antagonist in this trilogy. The art shows the pain he inflicts on Clark so well. I felt for Superman/Clark.
Clark himself had another solid arc in this. He is a very good man with good intentions. Yet, as we see throughout the book, even with good (or understandable) intentions, mistakes can be made. Going back to an earlier point, he had good intentions with what he did in Borada and I empathize with him. Yet, there are also flaws with what he did as well and he struggles with the consequences of his actions. He also struggles with trying to decide what to do with his power, especially when he's faced with so much hostility (but also refuses to be apathetic in the face of injustice and when lives are at stake). Another solid aspect of his arc is being willing to both embrace who he is and being vulnerable. He has some superb character growth in this story.
The side characters are great too. I like Lisa much more in this book than I did in book two. There is more depth to her character in this book. We see her strength through her courage and kindness. She helps to bring the best out of Clark and, in spite of her own fears and worries, she pursues her dreams and goals. Lois is great too. While the book resolves the tension between her and Clark a bit quickly, we get to see the positive impact she has on Clark/Superman. I do wish we got to see more of her though, but, with so many characters in this trilogy, it is hard to fit everyone in.
As for the other characters, I like how Alexandra and Lex Luthor were written. This is a different take than what I've seen in the animated series and comics. I can't say much more without spoiling, but I like the twists with both of the Luthors and the way that their arcs end up. And, as with both Zod and Superman, there is also the case of good (or at least, understandable) intentions with them but also consequences.
Overall, I really enjoyed Volume 3. It is the last book in this series, and I wish there were more. There is so much more that can be told, but it also ends well. The humor itself was a mixed bag, but overall, the writing is very good. I give this book a 4.5 (rounded up to 5) and I recommend this book.
March 23, 2025
Clark Kent is still haunted by the nightmares of his childhood, when his parents sent him away from Krypton inits final seconds before being destroyed. Lex Luthor has a theory on how to depower Superman. The news is welcome by the army. Supes begins this volume suckered by everybody. All that innocence must be taken advantage of. By the end he learns who his friends are and what he must do to to perform his role as protector.
December 30, 2018
Volume 3 of Superman: Earth One continued the story in stellar fashion, and was better than volume 2, but still not up to par with volume 1. This chapter introduced us (with great retellings) to Zod and Mr. and Mrs. Lex Luthor! Zod's story does retread familiar tropes, and there isn't enough development with him to truly understand his motives. However, with the Luthors (known as Lex Squared), we are given a completely different Lex than what is familiar, with his wife becoming what we are accustomed to with regard to a vendetta against Superman. The stories and development of the major players are advanced with great writing, including some great dialogue between Clark and his mother. Superman delivered a great speech at the end, and exchanged important words between he and Lois. I'll be disappointed if this is the last chapter, and I was curious as to why volumes 1 and 2 chose to end with a news story, and this one did not. Regardless, if this is to be the final volume of Superman's Earth One saga, then I'm torn: I want to read more but it also ended well enough to interpret what happens from here. A sign of great writing is people wanting more but also knowing when to conclude satisfactorily. I believe this series may have pulled off both. Recommended for Superman fans and casual comic readers alike.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 277 reviews