Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Something always has bigger teeth.

Aspen

I've spent my life chasing emotions I can't understand. I don’t feel bad for what I am—I don’t feel much at all, really. I’m a monster, comfortable in my own skin. When I move to a small town where people go missing and they say the woods are haunted by a beast, I think I’ve finally found a place to settle.

And then he finds me… A creature made of shadow and moonlight.

A beast with wings that feeds on pure emotion.

A monster who says I belong to him.

Nox

I am the shadow that hangs over my small town by the mountains. I am the thing the children fear and the adults speak of in hushed voices. I’ve never cared to know a human, until Aspen shows up in the woods with blood on his hands. I feed on emotions, but his are volatile… different. He doesn’t feel fear, but I can taste the desire for violence just beneath his skin.

I want to consume him. I want to keep him. I want to peel away his layers and wrap him up in my wings until I can taste his heart on my tongue.

I never believed in mates, but I know Aspen is mine.

~~~

Pareidolia is a full-length MM dark monster romance, and is part of the Mayhem Manuscripts Cryptids shared world collaboration. Expect dark themes, scorching heat, and two monsters figuring out what love means in their twisted world.

328 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lee McCormick

26 books688 followers
Lee McCormick has been writing since they were very young, and they've finally found the courage to offer up some of their favorite ideas to the world. Parent to two amazing kids and three pretty fantastic dogs, they've always been fascinated with dark romance and love that transcends time and reason.

When they aren't busy working on their novels, you can usually find them browsing queer romance recommendations or playing a video game. 

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
271 (42%)
4 stars
216 (33%)
3 stars
124 (19%)
2 stars
27 (4%)
1 star
7 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 235 reviews
Profile Image for Bee (semi ia).
142 reviews82 followers
October 5, 2026
3.5 ⭐️

This is the perfect read for the spooky season! I was super excited for this one because I followed Lee's socials about all the reveals and honestly, it delivered! I'm a slut for a Mothman 💅. This book combines both horror and gorey elements, killings (because, well, they're both monsters in more ways than one I suppose) and the really unhinged, sexy spice that was so fun to read! And for the girlies that want some creative anatomy and spice, rest assured it's present!
I didn't expect a super deep story considering the length and purpose of the book, but it still managed to show their messed up but still kinda sweet? connection between them. I can't wait to get to read some more from the series as they come out 🖤
Profile Image for Tay.
207 reviews36 followers
September 27, 2026
5⭐️


If he’s a monster but why so hot and possessive 😫

MOTHDADDYYYYYYY… I think we need a MOTHDADDY like him cause DAMNNNNNNNNNN

Ughh this book had me in a chokehold i devoured it I couldn’t put it down I was simply captivated by this story. Aspen and Nox ohhhhh my sweet crazy killers I love them soo muchhhhh ughhh they were everything to me and more.

The way I fell in love with Nox and Aspen from the first time we met the both of them like I was simply in awe of them.


The whole monster plot was soooooo good ughhh omggg HES SO HOT I CANT. The way the mate bond aspect happened nox claimed Aspen and ever since then they were insane together omgggg they were so crazy and so toxic but so cute at the same time like they were enemies to lovers to the maxxxxxx like talk about thick boiling tension even when they are mates.

MONSTERS KNOW HOW TO F^VK CAUSE HOTTTTT DAMN IM A DAMN PUDDLE CAUSE OH MY GODDDDD. Like I was sweating

Ughh my sweet sweet monsters I love them so muchhhhhhh.

And the way Nox kept saying Aspen’s his and how jealous he was that Aspen had to go to town and he could sense people were loooking ay Aspen wrong even from all the way in the forest and he wanted to rip them to shreds was the hottest thing I’ve ever read this man was so downbad for Aspen it was crazyyyyy hot. He’s just a black cat disguised as a teddy bear cause ughh this crazy f^cker I love him. He would burn the whole town and rip them to shreds to have Aspen stay with him in the forest he doesn’t give a f^ck ughh it’s so hot I can’t even. Aspen has it real real good there 😏

One thing about lee McCormick is that they never disappoint and I loved this one and this might be one of my favorites they have written. I just loved Nox and Aspen and their love story/journey. And the ending 10% is classic Lee right there if I would say cause omggg packing in anxiety and stress omgggggggg I was shoook I’m not even kidding I was also scared like I was about to lose me marbles like ahhhhhhhhhhh!!!

HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMEND OMGGGGG MY FAVORITE SO FAR IN THE SERIES!!!!
Profile Image for Julia (bookish.jka).
1,047 reviews355 followers
September 30, 2026
"I want a love that will devour me until the idea of Aspen as a word that exists alone is erased from the world—that the very thought of it would mean death. All consuming. I want the exact kind of love that only Nox can give."

Pareidolia by the fabulous Lee McCormick, is one of the books in the Mayhem Manuscripts Season 2: Cryptids shared world collaboration, and this is Nox and Aspen's story.

What better way to start my return to MM monster romance than with a sociopathic serial killer falling for an emotion-eating monster! Aspen and Nox are both completely comfortable with exactly what the other is and I loved the possessive, all-consuming connection between them.

There’s plenty of blood, violence, spice and some wonderfully unhinged ideas about what constitutes romance, and while it didn’t quite consume me the way Nox apparently wanted to consume Aspen, I had the best time with these two monsters!🖤

What To Expect:

🖤 MM dark monster romance
🖤 Mothman x serial killer
🖤 Monster x human
🖤 Sociopathic MC
🖤 “My mate”
🖤 Possessive & obsessive
🖤 Dark themes and violence
🖤 Lots of spice
🖤 (Questionable!) HEA

4 ⭐
Profile Image for 369Pages.
1,005 reviews93 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 26, 2026
4.5⭐️
If you want a dark romance where the bad guys get their happily ever after in blood and shadows, then this is going to be your jam.
Aspen is an author (who has maybe killed some people), and is returning to his hometown after his parents’ passing. A hometown where a monster is said to live in the woods.
Aspen is the only person who has ever piqued the monster’s interest. He’s not scared of the monster. Yet he craves to feel fear, to feel what he hasn’t been able to in his life.

Pareidolia is a gruesome, dark, sexy, and gorgeously written monster romance that’s going to give you:
-emotionless killer x bloodthirsty emotion-eating moth monster
-shadow tentacles 👀 wings 👀 and more!
-“Run.”
-evil characters but they’re interesting that way
-dark obsession and possessive behaviour

Guys this one is dark.. but as always with Lee, it’s so goooooood! Genuinely, both MCs are irredeemably evil, and they don’t want to change that. In fact, they maybe make each other worse. But they also become obsessed with each other. Two beings who truly thought they were alone found someone to be theirs. And if that ain’t romantic, I don’t know what is 😈

This book isn’t for the faint of heart, but I ate it up!
Profile Image for Chrissy_reads2727.
130 reviews31 followers
September 30, 2026
ARC Review: 5 ⭐️ MASTERPIECE. NO NOTES.

When I tell you this is EXACTLY 👏 WHAT 👏 I 👏 NEEDED 👏

This was LITERAL perfection. I have been needing something DARK and this book delivered! You want a romance where the monster is actually a monster? You want a romance where dark meets darker? You want a romance where they don't "get better" but relish in the darkness together like the monsters they are?! This is the book for you 😈

Aspen an unfeeling sociopath has come back to the woods where he grew up.... these woods hold his secrets and some secrets of their own for he's not the only monster here.

He comes face to face with something he convinced himself was an illusion.... his imagination run wild...... a flash of white and red.... eyes that lure you in... wings that hum with your every desire...

Only Aspen is immune to the monsters lure, as he doesn't have emotions for the monster to feed on. But that means Nox has what Aspen's always craved..... the key to FEEL.

These two are LITERAL soulmates and I am so here for every page of depravity and mayhem in this masterpiece.

Please for the love of everything unholy Lee, give us more Monster romance, cause this is your calling 😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨
Profile Image for Aly.
114 reviews70 followers
September 28, 2026
👏 Bravo. 4.5 ⭐️I really hope Lee continues to write monster books. The dark and twisted is always a given with them. 😜 and that’s exactly what keeps coming back for more!! but I loved this one!
Profile Image for J.J..
415 reviews5 followers
October 3, 2026
This story was so interesting and unique!

I really liked the premise of the book, and Nox and Aspen were both interesting characters. However, I had a hard time getting into this story for some reason. The middle of the book felt kind of slow, which is strange because the book was quite short.

Still looking forward to the next books in this series!
Profile Image for Finalgirl.
124 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 25, 2026
If you like to watch the world burn and your romances bloody Pareidolia should be your first read of the spooky season. Book one of the Mayhem Manuscripts: Cryptids, starts out with a bang. This is not a love story...it's a horror story that weaves a tale of toxic love between a very broken psychopath and a very ancient monster.

There will be no redemption arc, no come to Jesus moment and certainly no skipping through a field of flowers singing Kum Ba Ya. Bad people do bad things and monsters are just that, monsters. Blood will be spilled, innocent people will scream while they die, and the "bad guys" will walk off into the moonlight covered in their dirty deeds...I for one am here for it! Give me that that dark disturbed story, give me that horror "nothing good survives" vibes, the MMCs get their HEA, in the end that's all I care about and of course, a good story. Pareidolia delivers.

Lee McCormick out does themself with this one, the spicey scenes are wild (understatement) and probably not for everyone- but this may be the first time I cackled like a manic at the sheer audacity and Kafkaesque surrealness of a spice scene. Think shadow daddy hentai.... lol. Clearly check your triggers!

But seeing as how I'm not a normal person and most of my literary and cinematic preferences /history are heavily rooted in horror I fully enjoyed this book. Body horror is one of my favorite genres, so when it comes to mixing that with my love of mm romance I'm practically salivating. The story is fast paced and intriguing, and even though the MMC's aren't heroes, or even antiheroes, I found myself cheer and rooting for their HEA, the rest of the world be damned. If it wasn't for my human need for sleep, I would have finished it in one sitting. I didn't want to put it down. I even found myself getting emotional. I mean who wouldn't tear up when the two leads spice it up near a decapitated dead body surrounded by blood. And the ending... chef's kiss. (no spoilers here, you'll have to read it for yourself).

This isn't the most depraved thing I have ever read (dead inside wins that award), but it is a little different than most of Lee's past works. So, keep that in mind. There is a wonderful sort of parallel to Loves Ace, and the red thread of fate theory. What if there was a black tendril of fate for bad people? I mean we all deserve love right, even if we do go a little stabby stabby sometimes.

Pareidolia is a wild and bizarre dark romance, and one of my favorite works from McCormick. I would highly recommend it especially if you wanted something a bit different to start of the season with. Like I said before- check your triggers and expect some wtf moments.
Profile Image for Kate.
1,987 reviews415 followers
October 13, 2026
4.5 stars!

Aspen feels nothing until he meets Nox and these two are soul mates. Nox may be a moth man monster that lives in a reality he’s created himself but Aspen calls to his shadows in a way he’s never felt.

“You’re mine, Aspen. The moment you stepped into this forest, you were. The moment you gave me the offering of a dying man, you were… and the moment you touched my wings and took in my shadows, you were. There’s no changing it. There’s no running.”


Despite Aspen’s reservations about having someone in his life, Nox is fully committed to keeping him.

“My shadows found a home in your hollow.”


I loved this. It was sexy and erotic. Dark and gritty. The characters were complex and the plot was fun. Aspen and Nox were 🥵🥵🥵.

“Because every part of you was made to shape around every part of me, little monster. You can run, but in the end, my shadows will always find you.”


I thoroughly enjoyed this monster romance!
Profile Image for Erin spice_Asylum.
157 reviews25 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 1, 2026
This book is dark and creepy and absolutely perfect to start off the Halloween season. It just scratched such a perfect horror itch in my brain, and I loved it. It’s such a unique take on a monster romance that I’ve genuinely never read anything like it, and it was so refreshing. It’s very dark, but it’s mixed with so many other elements too that it creates such a perfect balance. It has the perfect mix of plot and spice, with pacing that is absolutely perfect for a horror romance. You constantly have your adrenaline a little bit up, but not to the point where you feel anxious. I genuinely can’t say enough good things about the entire storyline, and holy wow… THAT FREAKING ENDING!!! If there is one person who knows how to write a perfect dark romance it’s lee!
Profile Image for Kayla Allen.
489 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 26, 2026
Holy hell! This was one heck of a ride! It was absolutely addicting! They are morally black characters that you can’t help but love! They are perfect for one another and you will be rooting for them! I loved this book so freaking much. I had high expectations and boy did it meet them! This book is an absolute must read!
Profile Image for Madison.
120 reviews1 follower
October 17, 2026
This book was so insanely unhinged, but what can I say, it was a fun read for spooky season 😅🤣 DEFINITELY dark romance. If you want some dark and twisted MM romance this is your book 👏🏻 I am here for mothman though.
Profile Image for Mikaela (risqué.romance).
814 reviews40 followers
September 28, 2026
✨May contain spoilers✨

I absolutely loved this book so much. Nox and Aspen were so worth the wait and I definitely was not disappointed at all. They had me on the edge of my seat throughout the entire book. Whenever Lee comes out with a book, I just know they’re going to get me hooked from start to finish.

I loved Aspen from the moment we meet him because he’s perfect just the way he is. He is different and he doesn’t care what people think. He sees and thinks differently. His parents even kicked him out because of that.

Nox and Aspen were absolutely perfect for one another. With the dark tendencies, I was hooked from start to finish. I love how Nox immediately set his eyes on Aspen from the moment he laid his eyes upon them.

And holy moly, those spice scenes were everything I wanted and more. I think these truly top any spice scenes that Lee has ever done and goodness gracious, I was so intrigued. The “heart” scene met my expectations and so much more.

I loved the jealousy scene that we did get with Nox because no one dared to touch what belonged to him.

If you’re looking for a dark romance where it’s not the heroes that get their happily ever after but the villains, this book is so for you.

I received a copy of this book and this is my honest review.
Profile Image for Amanda.
2,469 reviews101 followers
October 6, 2026
I love that Lee leaned fully into the dark. Honestly, as a horror romance girlie, I would even say it hit those notes at times, which is 100% my jam and I was all for it. Plus a literal moth man? Yes please and thank you. It did take me a loooong time to connect with the MCs though. I'm not sure why, but unfortunately, i did struggle quite a bit.
Profile Image for GiveMeBooksOrGiveMeDeath.
85 reviews18 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 29, 2026
Pareidolia is a horror story with a very dark and twisted romance between an ancient shadow monster, who takes the form of a moth man, and a sociopathic writer who is more or less human. From beginning to end this book is very intense so please be sure to read the trigger warnings. Nox is quite a monster, from his appearance to his abilities, but when you have a specific craving, you won’t be satisfied till you sate it. That’s where our human Aspen comes in. Due to his particular issues he has what Nox craves, or rather he’s missing something that humans usually have…Fear. These two are drawn together like a moth to a flame. Sorry I couldn’t resist. lol. Throughout this book, we see not only their “ relationship” involve but each other as well. I felt like I was watching a horror movie in real time as I read this. While most stories are predictable for me I did not anticipate the ending, which was a very nice surprise. Both of our monsters get a happy ending, well happy for them anyway, not so much everybody else. This is definitely one of my new favorite books and my new favorite from this author. For book one of the series it was quite the book to kick it off. I highly recommend it if you enjoy this type of book.

Tropes: Mothman x Human, Sociopath Writer, Fear Play.Blood Play.Shadow Play, “Little Monster”,
Murder As A Love Language, Wing Kink, “Love Feels Like Dying”

Story 5/5
Spice 4/5
Profile Image for angie_bookrecs.
339 reviews66 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 29, 2026
Just like Aspen, I love it when the monsters in my books win. And babyyy, in this one? They sure AF do!!

Aspen completely hooked me from the beginning. He's a horror author with a complicated relationship with his own humanity. He doesn't experience emotions the way other people do, and he's spent years trying to suppress the darker instincts he knows are lurking underneath.

Then he meets Nox...

Nox is an ancient creature who feeds on emotions, and Aspen is unlike anyone he's ever encountered. He doesn't react with fear the way a human should, and Nox is immediately fascinated by him.

Very quickly, that fascination turns into something much more possessive.

There's something incredibly satisfying about watching Aspen learn what emotions actually feel like, while Nox discovers feelings he never thought he could experience himself.

The romance is dark, obsessive, primal, and beautifully fucked up. But underneath all the blood and violence is a beautiful story about finding a place you belong.

The atmosphere was fantastic, the horror elements were deliciously creepy, and the chemistry between these two was off the charts!!

Dark. Bloody. Weird. Sexy. Emotional.
Exactly my kind of fucked up.
10/10. No notes.
Profile Image for Michelle Exploringwithchapters.
288 reviews11 followers
October 2, 2026
I was so scared to read this book! I received the ARC and realized it was marketed a bit more on the horror side and totally panicked. I am a total chicken and the gore and blood themes do not get me excited lol. I know you are encouraged to check your triggers and respect your mental health and had fully accepted this would not be for me, and it would be the first ARC I was unable to complete. I kept seeing reviews saying how quickly they got hooked on the story! The book released yesterday and so Happy October 1st- Let's just do it! I started the book around 4pm, and read through the evening, finishing this morning as soon as I woke up. This book absolutely grabs you quick. I highlighted a few things but really, I just absorbed this interestingly dark and beautiful story. It was completely not what I was expecting! I am so glad I read this! It was the perfect start to my October reading!
Profile Image for Cynthia M Brow.
1,755 reviews23 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 30, 2026
Pareidolia is part of the multi author Mayhem Manuscripts Season Two: Cryptids series. Each book can be read as a standalone but why not enjoy the whole series. Please read the trigger warnings before you start this book because it really is a dark monster romance, with emphasis on the dark. This is the story of Aspen a human and Nox a moth monster. I couldn't put this book down once I started it. I loved these two and how perfect they are for each other. I loved the chemistry and steam these guys brought to the page. I loved , loved this book. It is so well written but I wouldn't expect anything else from Lee McCormick. I'm looking forward to seeing what Lee McCormick writes next. I would definitely recommend this book.
received a free review copy
Profile Image for Julia Toth.
636 reviews13 followers
October 15, 2026
Wow! Just wow! This was a horror romance and it was a really good one at that! It's dark, and gory, but it also has sweeter moments. This story sucked me in from the start and I was riveted. There were a couple of twists which I enjoyed a lot. Did this manage to tear me up a bit? You bet it did and I wouldn't expect anything less from a book written by Lee. Also, Nox's tendrils? I love a character that has tendrils that help them.
Nox and Aspen were inevitable from the start and I was here for them getting their happily ever after whatever that took.
This was a wild ride and I loved every moment of it. This is also a great spooky season read, so it's definitely a book you need to pick up if you like gory stories with a romance.
Profile Image for Natalie.
794 reviews26 followers
October 12, 2026
Nox and Aspen were made for each other. Both are drawn to the darkness and desires that others would be scared of. I loved possessive Nox and his desire to get rid of anyone who dares to touch Aspen. I loved the story, the gore, and the spice. Lee never disappoints! This is my second read from the Mayhem Manuscripts Season Two series, and I'm excited to read more.
Profile Image for Katelyn .
99 reviews1 follower
October 20, 2026
This was so good. I was a little nervous to read this but omg I loved it so much. The story line kept you engaged the whole time, the pace was perfect, and the characters fit together so well. I loved it so much, and the last chapter perfect!
Profile Image for Nari.
79 reviews
October 3, 2026
Too many innocent people died in this for my liking. Im all for fcuked up morally grey characters killing bad people, but killing innocent people is apparently where I draw the line.
Profile Image for A Good Girl’s Bookshelf.
154 reviews7 followers
October 4, 2026


Unhinged, bloody, and deviantly romantic—this is horror-romance in its most depraved, unfiltered glory! Lee McCormick completely incinerates the rulebook with Pareidolia, delivering an utterly intoxicating MM monster horror story that makes zero apologies for being dark, gruesome, and deliciously toxic. Part of the Mayhem Manuscripts: Cryptids shared world, this book abandons all hopes of a traditional redemption arc and instead plunges headfirst into a shadow-drenched universe where two irredeemable monsters find their brutal, soul-binding happily ever after amidst the carnage.

We follow Aspen, a detached, sociopathic author with blood on his hands who feels virtually nothing: no guilt, no remorse, and certainly no fear. Settling into his small hometown where locals whisper of a terrifying entity lurking in the woods, Aspen doesn't run from the rumors; he hungers to feel anything, even terror. What he finds in the dark canopy is Nox: an ancient, winged Mothman creature forged from shadow and moonlight who feeds on human emotion. When Nox tastes the volatile, fear-devoid desire for violence simmering under Aspen's skin, a primal, possessive mate bond detonates. What ensues is a dark, bloody game of cat-and-mouse between a human psychopath and a shadowy cryptid who decides Aspen belongs to him, body, soul, and blood. Aspen thinks he's the ultimate villain until he meets an ancient cryptid who sees his lethal tendencies and finds them irresistable. Their dynamic is purely "I can make him worse", these two deeply broken, predatory beings realizing they no longer have to be alone in the dark. Nox is the ultimate dark shadow daddy wrapped in terrifying, winged glory. His territorial instincts are off the charts; he will literally slaughter an entire town just for looking at Aspen wrong.

The contrast between his lethal nature and his absolute terrifying devotion to his mate will leave you utterly obsessed. The steamy scenes in this book are not for the faint of heart! Featuring shadow tentacles, wings, primal biting, blood play, and literal heart touching. The intimacy is mind-bendingly hot. From the visceral body horror to the nail-biting final ten percent, McCormick weaves a fast-paced, high-stress atmosphere that reads like a dark fantasy horror film where you can't help but root for the bad guys to burn the world down together. Make no mistake: this is not a story of heroic anti-heroes or sweet redemption. Innocent people die, blood is spilled without hesitation, and both leads are genuinely, irredeemably evil (and I loved it). However, if you step into this book embracing the dark comedy, body horror, and absurdism of two murderous souls falling in love over corpses, you will find an addictive, unforgettable masterpiece of dark fiction.

Pareidolia is a deliciously dark, twisted, and wildly entertaining horror-romance that proves even the most broken, bloodthirsty monsters deserve a black tendril of fate. If you're ready to leave your morals at the door and dive into a bloody, shadow-drenched romance, grab this book immediately!

Instagram: @goodgirlsbookshelf_
Profile Image for Layy.
269 reviews27 followers
October 19, 2026
3.75 ⭐️’s.

I don’t really know how to feel. Overall this book felt OKAY. I didn’t love it but I also didn’t hate it.

We meet Aspen, who we get a pretty good glimpse and then details later, how he’s always been “not normal”. He can’t really feel anything, so it’s through his stories as an author, that he TRIES to feel something, but really understands the monster POV more than anything. He doesn’t want to be back in the little town he came from (when you read it, you find out exactly WHY), but he attracts the mysterious and scary legend in the Forrest, Nox.

Nox is honestly so curious about Aspen because all he tastes is apathy. Like calls to like and he quickly realizes that Aspen is a true “little monster” underneath the human skin he wears. Nox comes in quick with being obsessive, possessive, and unapologetically a monster (don’t hold me to the same human morals you hold yourself to, type of vibes) which I LOVED. It’s so refreshing to read about a monster who doesn’t conform to human morals simply because they fell in love with a human or have a human mate lol.

Aspen definitely has some autassassinophilia 🤣 it just goes beyond being a masochist lmao. The man is just as unhinged and crazy as his monster counterpart. I really enjoyed their encounters and dry, dark humor when alone.

I feel like, where I struggled the most, was the plot not moving. We stood in a weird limbo of “he gets me, I don’t like being understood by a monster, but I crave what he offers me, he succumbs, they f*ck, and then Aspen tries to pull away and have some normalcy.” The cycle was consistent the whole way through. It also confused me how much Aspen fought Nox’s advances. He already “drew home” multiple times how he hated interacting with people and the mundane feeling of having to fake it with the normal people, but he kept trying to go back to it? I’m sorry, but if you know you aren’t “normal” and you know that this monster is offering you everything you ever wanted, there was no reason for Aspen to fight his desire up until 68% into the book. The back and forth wasn’t sexy or tension filled, it was off putting and took me out of the story multiple times.

After that, we just kept being stuck on Aspen wanting to seem “normal”. Get a job in town, implicate his neighbors in his shenanigans bc he wanted to play with fire… all for what exactly? I feel like somewhere in here, the plot got lost, and the author really honed in on two different monsters, feeling some semblance of love in the only way that they could feel, and Aspen finally accepting his place in the forest with Nox.

This book is gory; it’s definitely a horror romance where innocents die and the monsters (both of them) give no absolute flying fuck who and what they kill. That wasn’t the issue so much as what was mentioned above.

Overall, this book was okay. I can see why people loved it but unfortunately I pay too close attention to plot and pacing and this just didn’t hit for me.
Profile Image for Abigail Beckwith.
2,031 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 27, 2026
Here's Lee McCormick's "Pareidolia." It's a novel in the multi-author series, Mayhem Manuscripts Season Two: Cryptids.

["Something always has bigger teeth.

Aspen
I've spent my life chasing emotions I can't understand. I don’t feel bad for what I am—I don’t feel much at all, really. I’m a monster, comfortable in my own skin. When I move to a small town where people go missing and they say the woods are haunted by a beast, I think I’ve finally found a place to settle.
And then he finds me… A creature made of shadow and moonlight.
A beast with wings that feeds on pure emotion.
A monster who says I belong to him.

Nox
I am the shadow that hangs over my small town by the mountains. I am the thing the children fear and the adults speak of in hushed voices. I’ve never cared to know a human, until Aspen shows up in the woods with blood on his hands. I feed on emotions, but his are volatile… different. He doesn’t feel fear, but I can taste the desire for violence just beneath his skin.
I want to consume him. I want to keep him. I want to peel away his layers and wrap him up in my wings until I can taste his heart on my tongue.
I never believed in mates, but I know Aspen is mine."]

Dude, can you be that shocked that the monster wants to keep you when you literally just called him "my monster"? This being chapter two. Chapter one, you mentioned that you tattooed him on your body.

Sure, Nox didn't understand the difference between asking and telling, but Aspen barely felt any emotions so... they work. They really work. Nox feeds and teaches Aspen about "typical" human emotions that he's never felt before, and Aspen feed Nox that cold apathy and that untampered lust. Two monsters don't cancel each other out; they make each other stronger. Nox taught Aspen to welcome his monstrous side. Aspen taught Nox a little bit about being human.

And another fabulous epilogue that ties into what was quite frankly a fabulously dark prologue.

Trigger Warnings: blood play, death, gore, murder, body horror, cnc, forced mating/marking, violence, torture, kidnapping, stalking/hunting/capturing of MC, mentions of past child abuse, and more.

#pareidolia #leemccormick #mortis #tenebrous #hollow #feral #paligenesis #tenebrous #golden #hush #leech #noctis #solivagant #solais #marked #mayhemmanuscripts #mayhemmanuscriptsseasontwo #mayhemmanuscriptscryptids #mayhemmanuscriptsseasontwocryptids #books #queerbooks #queererotica #bodicerippers #bookstagram #bookphotography #ilovebooks
Profile Image for Ashley Dead.inside_but_reads.
278 reviews45 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 28, 2026
🚩🚩 Please check all the CWs before going into this one! It's a Dark Horror Romance in which our guys get their happy ending but absolutely at the cost of everyone else! Morally Black would definitely fit these two if they even cared about morals 😂 so please please check and re-check them! Your mental health matters 🖤

🌶🌶🌶🌶

Nox has lived in Duskfen Forest since before the forest even had a name. He feeds off the emotions of the people he "steals" and there normally isn't anything left once he is done. That is until Apsen. Nox spots Aspen after some events leave Aspen with a body to get ride of and instead of getting fear or pain from Aspen he gets.....Nothing. Aspen is a Sociopath and doesn't have emotions to spare which intrigues Nox more then anything ever has before.
Aspen has come home to Duskfen after he left when he was 15 to get away from his parents who didn't hide the fact they thought he was a monster. Aspen has since learned to hide that part of himself and always wear a mask but the mask is slipping. This story is what happens when one monster finds another and neither of them need to hide anymore. Nox isn't letting go of Aspen and after a bit of push and pull Aspen doesn't really want to be let go of.
This is one of my favorite types of reads because your brain is scrambled a bit and your throwing your own morals into the wind and rooting for the monsters to win and get their HEA...innocent people be damned 😂
Aspen doesn't have to hide with Nox he knows Nox accepts him just as he is and he can let that dark side out finally. Their version of love is very toxic and Obsessive but hearing it as a declaration changes the world entirely.

"I won’t show you what love feels like, little monster. I will show you what it is to be consumed, to be owned by the shadows. I’ll show you what it feels like to be mine.”

"Never Without"
"Never Alone"


Tropes/Tags

Dark Horror Romance
Monster/Human
Mothman/Sociopath
Mates
Forced Proximity
Possessive MC
Touch Him and 💀
CNC
Shadow Play
🩸 Play
Primal Play
Shadow Sounding
Spitting/Monster Fluids
Marking/Biting
171 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 28, 2026
Intro:
This book is an MM horror romance between Aspen, a human coming back to his hometown after the death of his parents and Nox, a monster lurking in the woods, waiting to prey on those who are misfortunate enough to wander into his woods

Tropes/Highlights:
-Dual POV
-MM
-Mothman/Human
-Shadow Play
-Sociopath Writer
-Fear Play
-Wing Kink
-Shapeshifter
-"My Mate"
-HEA


Likes:
-Character development
-Moth powers
-He can fly
-Aspen's job
-Fire tower
-Not dates
-Primal play
-Spice
-Bite marks
-Gift in the woods
-World building
-Comes when called
-The ending
-Nox's protective/possessiveness


Quotes:
-"Fuck, of course even a giant-ass moth is going to judge me for how fucked up I am"
-"I don't know if he's suicidal or just that sure of me... though they could be considered one and the same"
-"Because every part of you was made to shape around every part of me, little monster"
-"There are no walls made my man that would keep me away from you, little monster. If humans tried to chain you, I'd teach them that their flesh is just a prison for their bones"
-"He's bossy for someone whose skin I could peel off"
-"He screams my name the same way humans shout to their God–for mercy and salvation"
-"Never without. Never alone"


This was the first book I have read from Lee and it was so good! I don't know what this says about me, but I was laughing at these two characters for most of the book. They are so cute and murdery. Nox is not one to ask for anything, instead he demands and expects his word to be taken as law. Aspen spent his whole life trying to hide his true self away from the world and with Nox he can finally learn to let go, to be the little monster he was meant to be. It was adorable seeing these two characters grow and the raw connection they had with one another. The ending was a bit heart-wrenching, but it's so worth it. I highly recommend reading this book if you love casual murder, things that lurk in the shadows, a monster made of darkness with an obsession for one special human and a legend the town with never forget
Profile Image for Brenna Mobley.
350 reviews33 followers
October 4, 2026
Pareidolia - Lee McCormick
Rating : ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice : 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️

Tropes :
❤️ monster romance
🖤 Mothman x human killer
❤️ sociopath horror writer
🖤 blood play, fear play, shadow play
❤️ shapeshifter monster
🖤 “my mate”
❤️ “I want to touch your heart” (literally)

Review:
This was honestly a really fun time. There were so many times that had me cackling throughout this just because the ridiculous brutal honest depravity between these two. The perfect bloody horror romance to dive into for spooky season. Aspen is trying to just live in the shadows and write his horror books alone, but the shadows - Nox - sense him and want him for himself. Such an intriguing concept that was really fun to dive into, a monster that doesn’t feel human emotions but feeds off them, and a human who doesn’t feel human emotions and wishes he could. Aspen is able to feel things he’s never felt when they strike a sort of bargain and Nox feeds him his shadows (literally… in every hole) and floods his senses with emotions he could only ever mimic but never truly understand. The bond between them deepens without either of them really meaning for it to, as they find a solace in each other where they can be exactly who they are. Monsters. This book is a horror romance in a true sense that it’s a budding romance for Aspen and Nox… but a horror to anyone else they encounter. Definitely a fun time and I’ll be checking out both the rest from this multi author collaboration as well as more works from this author.

My only cons was I’m an emotional reader so it was hard for me to connect to two characters that, for much of the book, don’t actually feel emotions. I loved where they ended up, but the high conflict and resolution part felt quite rushed because it all happened at like the 90% mark. But overall it delivered exactly what it said it would, and the vibes were great.
Profile Image for Brittany Dean.
149 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 29, 2026
We all have read stories where the hero falls in love with a villain, but this tale is about a monster falling in love with another monster. I’m not quite sure how I got here but I am so glad I did.

Aspen (aka Alex) is a horror author/psychopath who returns to his hometown after the untimely death of his parents. Without the ability to feel emotions, this is more of an annoyance to him especially since his parents declared him a monster and kicked him out as a teenager. The only reason for his return is the fact that his parents left him their house in their will.

Uninterested in returning to a place he wasn’t wanted, he decides to stay in the fire tower that’s located in the woods behind the house. Not only is this convenient for his current circumstances but it also holds memories and curiosities Aspen has been craving answers too for the 8 years since his departure. Que the Mothman.

Nox, as the Mothman names himself, is known as the monster in the woods. While the townsfolk tell stories about him, no one has actually seen him for certain..except Aspen on that special night. Nox is a devourer of human emotions and the fact that Aspen cannot feel emotions as a normal human should, Nox is instantly intrigued. And when their path collides in present day…everything changes.

This story is dark, depraved, spicy and full of possessive macho energy…. But I loved every second of it. I also didn’t expect to get emotional in a monster romance but there I was, on the verge of tears at the ending. Would definitely recommend this to anyone who doesn’t mind some serious triggers and enjoys some good MM spicy scenes 🥵🌶️
Profile Image for paris.
132 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 30, 2026
𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠: ★ ★ ★ ★ ☆ (4.2)

*𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰*

⊹ | 𝙋𝙖𝙧𝙚𝙞𝙙𝙤𝙡𝙞𝙖 by Lee McCormick is a dark M/M monster romance. It is part of the 𝘔𝘢𝘺𝘩𝘦𝘮 𝘔𝘢𝘯𝘶𝘴𝘤𝘳𝘪𝘱𝘵𝘴 𝘚𝘦𝘢𝘴𝘰𝘯 𝘛𝘸𝘰: 𝘊𝘳𝘺𝘱𝘵𝘪𝘥𝘴 series and follows Nox and Aspen, aka Alex. This story explores themes that some readers may find triggering.

After seeing all the art and alternate book covers for this, I was so excited to dive in. Was it a bit intense at times? Yes, but it was still so good, and I loved it. I was totally a fan of the crazy killer moth man who fed off of human emotions and lived in a spooky forest.

This was the second book I’ve read by the author, and I think when I’m in the mood, their darker vibes and themes are perfect for me. That being said, at the moment I don’t know how I feel about the spicy scenes. I liked them, but at times they could get pretty crazy. That didn’t stop me from finishing this book; it was just something different. I do recommend that you definitely check the trigger warnings before proceeding because things can get pretty messy.

While things were intense here and there between them, they also had some really cute moments together as well. They were two monsters trying to learn how to love together, and that was beautiful. The third act had my jaw on the floor, however it was super interesting seeing how everything played out in the end.

Overall, this series has been amazing so far! I’m truly so grateful that I had the opportunity to be an ARC reader for this book. I would definitely recommend this book to all my dark monster romance readers. I can’t wait to dive into the rest of this series soon.


— 𝑹𝒆𝒗𝒊𝒆𝒘 𝒃𝒚 𝑷.𝑹.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 235 reviews