In London, Vivian drives her ambulance through the burning streets, tending to the wounded and dying with a steadiness her colleagues mistake for courage. It is not courage. It is duty - the only language she has ever been taught to speak.
In Oxford, Dame Beryl stands alone in the cupola of the Radcliffe Camera and holds the magical defenses of the British Isles together by sheer force of will. Her body is failing. Her grief is vast. She has given everything to the protection of her country and her people, and she will give whatever remains.
These two women have circled each other for years - mentor and heir, guardian and charge, each convinced that love and duty cannot coexist. But when a long-buried secret surfaces from the night that made Vivian an orphan, everything either woman believes about herself, about the other, and about the nature of magic begins to fracture.
Set against the thunder of the Blitz and the ancient landscape of Arthurian Britain, A Subtler Magic is a novel about the cost of devotion, the courage it takes to remember, and the quiet, irresistible power of the one spell neither woman ever learned to cast.
Mike is the creator of Carmarthen Hall and a whole new world of Thaumaturgy.
Mike received his BA from Moravian University, his MA in English Literature from Middlebury’s Bread Loaf School of English, and he has studied as an independent scholar at the Centre for Medieval and Renaissance Studies in Oxford and the Oxford Centre for Fantasy. For many years, he taught at the Maine School of Science and Mathematics, one of the top public schools in America. While there, he was a Semifinalist for Maine State Teacher of the Year, served as Chair of English and Performing Arts, and was a frequent guest speaker around Maine, including addressing pre-service teachers at the University of Maine. He has been published in Independent Teacher Magazine and Mythprint.
Mike lives with his ridiculous and wonderful family on Cape Cod. During the day, he can be found writing at various libraries and cafes around the Cape, as well as speaking and teaching across the region. In the evenings, he assumes many identities at the Academy of Performing Arts in Orleans.
How Oxford escaped the Blitz and World War II unscathed has, historically, been a big question mark. But in Michael D. McCartney’s “A Subtler Magic,” thaumaturgy—or magic, as we’d call it—had more than something to do with it. And the powers at work to protect it are both a blessed gift and a cursed burden to those who wield them.
One hallmark of a good novel is its ability to completely absorb readers and envelop them in the world at hand. In this debut novel, McCartney, former vice chairman of the Sandwich Library Board of Trustees, does just that. Weaving together ancient Arthurian legend and the much more modern history of World War II, McCartney has built a world that is uniquely situated as a complex, fantasy-driven narrative occurring concurrently and in response to very real and very consequential acts of war and destruction. The result is a very compelling novel, something fanciful yet all too real, with greatly satisfying execution—especially notable for a breakout author.
His studies at Oxford, discussed in his author’s note, permeate the pages in a way that only intense attention to detail can. McCartney’s care for the world he has built is apparent in his cultivation of it, rooted in real-life experience and studies alongside the mentors and scholars of Oxford.
Lady of the Lake Dame Beryl Llyn presides over Carmarthen Hall, Oxford’s college of thaumaturgical studies, while the Blitz shatters London and other locations across the United Kingdom around her. Her granddaughter and Lady-In-Waiting, Vivian, is driving an ambulance in London, much to Dame Beryl’s chagrin. But Oxford needs defending, Vivian or not, and while Dame Beryl is willing to hold up the trestles of the city herself if it comes to it; her physical (and thaumaturgical) ability to do so is another question entirely.
As this duo of strong-willed, dynamic and all-around admirable ladies wrestle with each other’s differing ideas of responsibility and destiny against the backdrop of the Axis powers, they’re joined by a cast of characters that readers will in turn adore, question and root for. There’s Fräulein Luisa Grunberg, a German Jew grappling with both immense power and deep concern for her family still back home; Graham Broady, a quirky student driven by equal parts heart and sheer intelligence; old Professor Norton, who is wise, endearing and brings a certain sense of warmth to the story unfolding amid a war-torn setting; prim Lord Bredon, Dame Beryl’s righthand man, with his watchful eye and air of affluence; along with Vivian’s sharp-witted best friend Franny and love interest, the Reverend Captain Charles Swanson. And, of course, the novel is colored by the omnipotent presence of the absent Merlin Ambrosius, the legendary wizard whose lore serves as the foundation for the novel.
McCartney does an impressive job of telling a story, steeped in rich legend and history, in a way that readers can identify as singular by the time they’re through the author’s note, and know for sure by the story’s close. It is rare to find a story so rich that the reader feels like she’s been swallowed whole by it, are effortlessly occupying the space the author’s mind has carved out, but this novel does just that.
The thaumaturgical forces that pulse deep within the earth and power the wonder of McCartney’s world are not unlike those of his prose, the powerful yet graceful vehicle driving and steering the reader through the journey of the entire novel. And the route doesn’t miss a single nook or cranny; readers get the expansive view, from ancient rites, spells and lore to realistically tense depictions of war and diplomacy during World War II and a historic setting so palpable that the reader feels wholly transported back in time to historic Oxford circa 1940, McCartney’s novel is a work of rich historical-fantasy fiction that leaves readers craving more from Carmarthen Hall and the world of the Lady of the Lake.
Fantastic! The worldbuilding is immersive, and the characters are compelling, including lots of complicated women as the driving forces, which I always enjoy. Definitely going to keep my eye out for more set in this world.
This was a special book. Not only did McCartney bring you vividly to WWII England but also to a land of fantasy/magic; and he does it with beautiful imagery and fanciful imagination. The lead characters, these magical women, are so well written. He portrays strong characters that hold the fate of the world in their hands during WWII. You travel along with each character as they transverse the Blitz and you are fully invested as they battle against the Axis Forces. I thoroughly enjoyed this novel, especially how McCartney excels in the command of the English language. It is beautifully written.
This book was engaging and unique. I loved the mix of history and fantasy. While at some parts it did feel slightly repetitive, I couldn't stop reading.