Leidner presents a lovely and swift compilation of quips that correlate with key points of Lincoln's life. Since I am not a comprehensive Lincoln nut, I benefited from this book with its light-hearted retelling of his life. While his life is told with brief details, the sprinkled bits of Lincoln's humor keeps up the levity and interest for me. So when he gets to a punchline, I managed a chuckle now and then. I rather enjoyed Leidner's informative approach; it beats other history books or a Wikipedia scan—far from being a drawling read. And its handheld size made it an awesome choice for reading on the go; whenever I waited at a restaurant or had a long line, back to Lincoln.
As far as what Lincoln fans would get out of this experience, I'm wondering if it would perhaps be too basic for them. I'm sure many of them may already be aware of the drama with his father and his wife, how he balanced his professional life, and his ruts within his political careers; since the book breezes through the nitty-gritty details in some ways, they may be lacking. Leidner warns at the start of the book that it isn't meant to be a complete autobiography, but where some sections are given more attention than others, it may leave that itch for them.
While I appreciated the historical explanations, I'm hesitant to recommend this to everyone I know. I feel like certain jokes are fair for their time but may unintentionally strike a nerve with contemporary audiences. Particularly the jokes about Douglas or Mary Todd. I'm also thinking that readers outside of U.S.A. might be a little lost regarding the political debates and conflicts since there is some assumptions that you are vaguely familiar with the geography of this particular part of history. Thankfully, Leidner didn't include many of the racist jokes that Lincoln was known to indulge in, though I know that there will be a nagging part of my imagination which hears a group of people insisting about their omissions and therefore call the book inaccurate.
Leidner paints Lincoln in a flawed and likable light. Understandable, really. No surprise when he has written many other Lincoln books too. At times, however, he may be seen as being a tad too heroic. It's a bias that I accept though—it's hard not to when Lincoln turns out to be a charming guy to me. Still would choose Lincoln's Gift over a broad presidential humor book in a heartbeat. Try this book if you want to a lighter read about Lincoln.
I received the book for free through Goodreads Giveaways.