What do you think?
Rate this book


Kindle Edition
Published August 5, 2026
That's the problem... people like you. You think about wars lightyears away or politicians writing rules that, at their worst, hurt people like me, and, at their best, don't even know we exist.I started writing this review before Europe was gripped by a series of protests in France, Italy, and Spain serious enough to force the hands of their governments (brutal crackdowns in France and Spain, capitulation in Spain where the government called a snap election), and the day after a Serbian student protest movement ousted its ten-year strongman. It's a reminder that Star Wars themes are timeless. Push too hard, and people will push back. But Philips doesn't stop there. Just because the Worker's grievances are genuine doesn't mean he's the only who's right. Sure, I support the students, and I think they're right to rise up against the complacency, incompetence or cronyism of recent governments, but they also need to realise that the problems they face aren't the only ones, nor are the solutions as obvious as they might believe. That's why Chirrut's counter-argument is just as powerful:
I don't speak of far off wars to ignore your struggles. I speak of them because suffering flows downhill. The choices made in palaces and starships always find their way to people like you.
I've worked maybe fifteen different jobs in my life, always serving one master or another... always just barely scraping by on what little credits I earned... and some I stole. I've had other people telling me what to do or not do - What job to do, how to do it, how much money I need, you two telling me I have to go with you. But not once in my life have I ever cared enough about something that I'd die for it.Pragmatism can only get us so far, it doesn't make us reach for the stars why we need to believe in something more.