I think it’s really hard to write a trilogy in romance. What was missing from this third book was the high-stakes from book 1. I think, book 2, and book 3 could have been one book. Spoilers: we spend so much time in book 2 with Chris and Mallory just reconnecting and she doesn’t find out the whole story of why he left until the very end of the book. However, Chris ends up leaving again and it doesn’t really make sense because there’s no real stakes for them to not be together like there was in book one. Reese can’t destroy Mallory‘s life, because she already knows what he’s capable of and it makes no sense for them to have to split up again especially for another four years.
I think it would’ve made sense if that trust fund had been in Chris’s name, and that Reese had somehow tricked him into signing for it back in book one that would’ve made the stakes really high if Giselle went down for the medical fraud, because Chris could’ve also been implicated. It would have made the decision for them to be together more interesting. I just felt like Mallory was all over the place and I would cringe at some of the parts with her and Sloan. I know they are best friends but when she just walked in to her house, I was like girl Sloan is engaged, you can’t just intrude. It felt like everyone was moving forward and Mallory was still acting like a college girl when she’s 30! It was good she was in therapy but I found myself not really taking Mallory seriously. I think because I loved Mallory so much in Book 1, I was disappointed.
I get that she became more sexually liberated but her character was just 180 from Book 1. If Book 2 and 3 were one book with two parts, with some adjustments, Chris groveling, Reese going down, the plot twist with his Mom, Mallory taking risks with her career it would have been more of a satisfying end. This book just felt long and the predictable. I kind of wish Mallory’s job opportunity would have been something that took her out of New Haven. If she received that job opportunity in Book 2 but it would require her to be out of state or something and then her sending Chris away would be her choosing herself.
Then by book 3, we see her in therapy working through her issues, maybe trying to actually date seriously not the club hookups and Chris shows back up wanting another chance but having this potential case on his back and trying to take down Reese. Then maybe Mallory decides she wants to try being friends and they actually get that connection they had in book 1 back. Then it ends with Mallory choosing to be with Chris and happily ever after etc.
I don’t know y’all I’m an avid reader and JL Seegars is a ridiculously talented writer but this felt rushed, maybe she under pressure from all of the TikTok hype? We literally never get anything else from Reese, RJ like doesn’t exist in this book, the plot was just all over the place.
This May be an unpopular opinion but I didn’t like the crossover with Sloan and Dominic. The plot from Restore Me and Revive Me were just all over the place, I just wished they were truly separate books/timelines. Why couldn’t this book just be set after Sloan and Dom are already married? They didn’t add anything to the story! Even their wedding planning was unnecessary.
This is my last point and again might be unpopular, I’m starting to hate when romance writers just throw in a bunch of unnecessary smut when they could use that space for non sexual intimacy. Yes, I’m talking about the vacation to Antigua. It was the cringiest storyline, I’ve read to date. Chris’ character development makes me believe that he would never want other men and women seeing/watching Mal get off. I get the chase metaphor starting from book 1 but by book 3 it was cheesy. I think Book 1 chase metaphor was good but book 2 should have been running away/hiding metaphor and then book 3 could be standing still/allowing yourself to be found and the vulnerability that it takes to be seen.
Overall, I would recommend this book. I read it just get it over with but I’m disappointed. So much potential but completely missed the mark. I really think that Book 2 set Bool 3 up to fail. The plot was not strong enough from Book 2 to carry over and compel me as a reader to still care about the relationship. 🤷🏾♀️