Bookshop owner Charley James is plunged into a mystery involving a rare book worth killing for in this new Cozy Bookshop Mystery by award-winning and national bestselling author T.C. LoTempio.
No treats but lots of tricks and murder!
Retired thriller author and current bookshop owner Charley James is preparing for Halloween in her small hometown of Austin, Pennsylvania—what she isn’t prepared for is discovering the body of a woman at the local inn.
Charley recognizes the stranger as a suspicious customer who popped in just to hide a rather peculiar book at her store—did she already know she was about to lose her life for it?
Pursuing this mysterious case, Charley can’t seem to stay out of trouble, and no one knows this better than Detective Hottie, Ian Grant. But Charley has a mind of her own and, together with cat Poe, sets off on another puzzle-riddled quest, unaware that the killer might be someone she knows . . .
“If you’ve ever wondered what it would be like to read a Hallmark Mystery movie in book format, wonder no more” (Cozy Crime Mystery). For fans of Laura Childs's Tea Shop Mysteries, Jenn McKinlay's Library Lover's Mysteries, and Ellery Adams's Secret, Book & Scone Society Novels.
While Toni LoTempio does not commit – or solve – murders in real life, she has no trouble doing it on paper.
Her lifelong love of mysteries began early on when she was introduced to her first Nancy Drew mystery at age 10 – The Secret in the Old Attic. She lists among her favorite mystery/suspense writers Erle Stanley Gardner, Mary Higgins Clark and James Patterson, as well as EJ Copperman, Steve Hockensmith, Victoria Laurie, Ali Brandon, Rita Mae Brown, Miranda James and Sofie Kelly to name only a few!
Toni is also passionate about her love for animals, as demonstrated with her four cats: Trixie, Princess, Maxx and, of course, ROCCO, who not only provided the inspiration for the character of Nick the cat in the Nick and Nora mystery series, but who also writes his own blog and does charity work for Nathan Fillion’s charity, Kids Need to Read!
Toni’s also devoted to miniseries like The Thorn Birds, Dancing with the Stars, reruns of Murder She Wrote and Castle (of course!).
She (and ROCCO, albeit he’s uncredited) pen the Nick and Nora mystery series from Berkley Prime Crime.
She, Rocco and company make their home in Clifton, New Jersey, just twenty minutes from the Big Apple – New York
and A Strong Premise, But Not the Right Fit for Me
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing this ALC.
DNF at 63%.
This cozy mystery delivered exactly what I expected in the best ways: a charming bookstore setting, likable recurring characters, light humor, and an approachable mystery. I also appreciated that, despite being connected to an existing series, it provided enough context that I never felt lost as a new reader.
The narration by Christa Lewis was enjoyable, and the audiobook production wasn’t the issue. In fact, I found myself engaged whenever I was fully focused on the story. Unfortunately, as the book progressed, I noticed myself zoning out more often and becoming less invested. By the halfway point, I was listening more out of obligation than genuine curiosity about what would happen next.
Ultimately, this was a reader-fit decision rather than a reflection of the book’s quality. Fans of slower-paced cozy mysteries with a strong sense of place and a lovable cast of recurring characters will likely enjoy this much more than I did. For me, the story simply wasn’t able to maintain my attention consistently enough to continue. 3.5⭐
Who Should Listen Readers who enjoy cozy mysteries with a charming bookshop setting, recurring characters, light humor, and a slower-paced mystery that prioritizes atmosphere and community over fast-paced twists.
I requested this one because I had already read and enjoyed the audio-ARC of the first book in the series, Murder on the Books.
The series revolves around a mystery writer, Charley James, who finds herself in a series of real-life murder mysteries. No one in town is aware that Charley is a famous author struggling with writer’s block; as far as they know, she owns a bookshop in a double storefront and her best friend Zane owns a bakery in the other half.
Charley and Zane are preparing their stores for Halloween when they discover the body of a woman at the local inn. Charley recognises her as a customer who visited her store earlier in the day. Charley and her cat Poe set off to solve the murder and its puzzle-riddled side-quest.
Narrator Christa Lewis has a lovely voice for a cosy mystery.
This is a classic cosy mystery, with a mix of suspense, friendship, and a hint of romance (but not too much) If you love stories with bookshops, bakeries, and quirky characters (especially cats with big personalities), or if you enjoyed the Gilmore Girls, or other books that have a cat with main character energy for example The Widows' Guide to... series by Amanda Ashby.
Buried in a Book was a fun, cozy mystery with just enough action to keep things moving. It started to lose me a little around the last 20%, but I was still invested enough to finish. As someone who's obsessed with Edgar Allan Poe, I loved the inspiration behind the story, and the cat's name was easily one of my favorite details.
The mystery is a little cheesy at times, but that's part of its charm. I'd definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a light mystery or trying to get back into reading.