Some people walk into your life quietly. Jensen Shaw walked into Aoife Walsh's diner on a Tuesday night, sat at the counter, and left a fifty-dollar tip on a six-dollar check. He came back the following Tuesday. And the one after that.
He never explained himself. She never asked.
What they built over seven months had no name and no future, right up until the moment it had both. When Jensen said the unforgivable thing, Aoife left without a word. She did not plan to be found.
He found her anyway. Now the question is whether what he has to offer is anything close to what she deserves.
What's Left of Us is a slow-burn dual-POV contemporary romance about the quiet moments that change everything, and the loud ones that almost ruin it.
💛 Grumpy/Sunshine 💛 Brooding Hero 💛 Situationship to More 💛 Surprise Pregnancy 💛 He Falls First 💛 She Deserved Better (and gets it!) 💛 Dual POV 💛 Complete Standalone 💛HEA
Sage Monroe is an indie romance author from East Tennessee, where she spent more than three decades as an educator before retiring to write the stories she'd been quietly saving up for years.
Her writing lives at the intersection of emotional realism and desire — stories about love that's complicated by circumstance, people who want things they're not supposed to want, and the quiet moments that change everything. She writes for readers who want to feel something real.
Sage approaches fiction the way she once approached a classroom: with attention to the individual, a belief in the power of a well-told story, and a firm conviction that the most honest writing happens when you stop playing it safe. Her debut novel was released in 2026, and she has several projects currently in development.
She lives in Tennessee and can usually be found on her back porch with a book, a glass of sweet tea, and something in the works.
It’s all telling verses showing. Very little actual interaction. There’s very little angst too which is so surprising considering this is a story about the H who uses the h for sex and comfort while dealing with the grief of losing his wife and kids. I love a h who suffers in silence but I want that suffering, not just the silence. She never calls him out on anything.
I wanted more all around. If we’re not going to get the angst then at least give us the romance. Im fine with pregnancy pushing our couple together but I need there to be more between them than that by the end. I wish the author would have developed this more. Them sitting around and reading next to each other is cute and all but it doesn’t do much to make those fuzzy lovey feelings develop for the reader.
I am not happy about the fact that they’re still living in the house that the H had with his wife at the end of the book. A house that’s referred to as the monument to his past life. She deserved more from him.
this is supposed to be a book where she realises she deserves better(and she gets it). instead, we have a woman who constantly accepts people treating her like shit like it’s no big deal. besides, he didn’t love her. she’s just a replacement. even in fiction it seems men don’t really have to try, and women will just accept crumbs if it means they’re not alone. i mean, seriously??!
I did not feel his love for Aoife. If it wasn’t for the babies, he would be mourning his dead wife forever. I feel like he decided to live Aoife because she became the mum of his kids and he decided that she was there and had suffered enough for him. Like pity love which is so so sad.
Aoife deserved so much better than to be the rebound for a grieving man. There’s this haze of sadness and grief still in there relationship and it makes believing their relationship would survive even harder.
This is perhaps one of the most depressing books I’ve ever read. There is no joy in the book at all. I’m really not sure how I feel right now other than very unsettled.
The writing style was different as well - each chapter is just like a summary. Kind of hard to get used to.
This book has all kinds of tropes I adore including second best and forced proximity with a down-on-her-luck heroine. I was surprised to see this author is in East Tennessee (me too), because the characters are Irish. I thought this story had a very strong start, but it fell flat in places. Mostly with the telling rather than showing.
The h was a paragon of self control. The H’s backstory was heartbreaking. The MIL was so unnecessarily cruel. The h just took it all in stoic silence. Also, there were some confusing passages where the main characters referred to themselves in third person. It needs some editing and more showing than telling. I ended this book not sure that he would’ve chosen her had there not been babies. This is a closed door romance, so no smut.
I read this one today and I don’t know how to feel. Actually I do. I feel sorry for Aoife. I don’t believe Jensen loves her. She’s never going to be his number one. If it weren’t for the kids they’d be well and truely done.
And I also didn’t like the mother in law. I know Jensen told her to stop but she purposefully tried to cause harm and stress. What she said was damaging and the fact that Jensen could still stand there and say that he wants her in his life after that…what in the heck.
That kind of stress inducing crazy behaviour could have killed his children and he’s just “I still love you and please don’t do that again” it’s just insane to me. So yeah. It’s a decent read but the fact that I don’t in anyway believe the “love” story and how the MIL was handled, really bothered me.
When I finished reading it I was a little stunned. I hate that Aoife settled for that. She and her children deserved better.
This is an intensely emotional read. The H's wife, daughter and infant son were all killed in a tragic car accident. He needed to spend six weeks in a facility to end his use of alcohol to cope with the devastating loss. Two and a half years later he goes to a diner after his cemetery visit to delay returning to his house. The h is a server and seeing the sadness in his eyes, she brings him a coffee without asking. The H leaves a fifty dollar bill to pay for a six dollar tab. He begins regular Tuesday visits to the diner. He asks the h for her number. He enters into a sexual relationship with the h (there is no on page sex)but keeps the h separate from his normal life e.g., taking her to out of the way restaurants. There is a focus on emotions - feeling them, identifying them, noticing that different people react emotionally in different ways to the same event. Powerful for me.
Overall Opinion: Not for me. There was no character growth, no depth, very little interaction between main characters. I’m not sure if this is her first book, that’s why I gave it two stars and not one.
Brief Summary of the Storyline: H (Jensen) looses his wife and 2 children in a car accident at the very beginning of the book. He spirals and starts drinking. Every week he visits their graves and one day after walks into a diner and meets h (Aoife) they start a physical affair (his family has been gone for 3 years at this point) and she ends up pregnant. Jensen reacts badly and says and does unforgivable (in my opinion) things. She disappears and he finds her months after. HEA with OC
POV: His/Hers/Third Person
Overall Pace of Story: It was ok. Found myself skimming towards the end.
Instalove: No
H rating: 2 He was hard to like. I know he was in pain and grieving but that’s doesn’t give him the right to hurt other people
h rating: 2 Very meek. Very quiet. Doesn’t ever stick up for herself. Not strong
Sadness level: 1 (for me) There is on page death. You would think with the subject matter it would be angsty and sad but no. It’s written in such a way that most of it is 3rd person and I just wasn’t connecting with anyone or what they’re going through
Push/Pull: Sort of, only on his part. He wants her, he doesn’t. He can’t admit to wanting to be with her
Heat level: 0
Descriptive sex: No
OW/OM drama: No, but there is mother in law drama
Sex scene with OW or OM: No
Cheating: No
Separation: She runs but only after he leaves her
Possible Triggers: Death of a spouse and death of young children
Closure: Yes
3rd Act Breakup: No
- Does Not have cheating - Does Not have a descriptive sex scene with OW/OM - Does have the H pushing away - Does Not have OTT sad parts - Does have a HEA ending
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This story sucked me in from the very beginning to the very end. It's a very sad story for everyone involved. Jenson lost his entire family in one accident, and he has a very difficult time moving on from that devastating loss. Aoife has had a very heartbreaking life too. She's lost everyone in her life and despite her being alone for most of her life, she's still relies on the kind words of her deceased grandmother to keep her looking towards a positive future and never giving up.
After years of Jenson living in a lonely fog of depression and despair, he comes across Aoife in a cafe she works in. He studies her for a bit, then gives into his attraction to her. Their relationship was very sad. Aoife desperately inhaled the smidgen of affection (she had always craved in life) that Jensen barely gave her, while simultaneously clinging onto his guilt of his promise to never move on from the love of his deceased family.
There was a lot of sadness throughout this entire story, and I devoured it all. I live for angsty stories, and this one had a melancholy angst that broke my heart. Aoife and Jensen finally find their way to becoming a couple by the ending, and it's very sweet. This story has such a realistic sadness to it. I loved it all. I can see why there are people out there who don't like this sad of a story, but for me it was perfection. ["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>
I'm not a fan of main characters who are still deeply hung up on their deceased partners, so that may be part of why this book didn't work for me. But from that premise onward, everything just went downhill.
The book is marketed as "he falls first," but it felt more like "he had no other choice." I never felt convinced that Jensen truly loved Aoife. More often, it seemed like he was projecting his feelings for his late wife and children onto her, treating her as a replacement rather than seeing her as her own person.
It's also advertised as "she deserved better (and she gets it)," but I didn't see that reflected in the story at all. Jensen's reaction to Aoife's pregnancy was disappointing, and I found it frustrating how quickly she let him back into her life afterward. There was very little accountability or growth to make that resolution feel earned.
I understand that the book is on the shorter side, but brevity isn't an excuse for shallow characterization. I've read novellas that delivered far more emotional depth and development. By the end, I was still left wondering whether Jensen would have truly loved Aoife if they hadn't been expecting twins.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The first few chapters of this story were really emotional and it sets the stage for a really tragic but healing storyline. However, the rest of the story didn't quite deliver on that potential.
Aoife and Jensen. They meet, 3 years after he loses his wife, toddler and newborn in a tragic accident. It's not clear how and why they click but it seems like he's seeking comfort, and she's there. It leads to an accidental pregnancy and he doesn't deal well with the news, so she leaves but he finds her and tries to repair the situation. Another spoiler alert: he does.
There were some very large plot holes and I would've loved to read more about their relationship, feelings and emotions. This was a clean read, which isn't an issue, but that was an added factor in making the book feel a bit "wooden".
I do think the author has potential and the writing was good, in parts.
This story should be the reason why most readers loathe the dead ex trope with a passion. Why folks continue to write it and label it as "romance", I will never understand.
From start to finish, MMC never stopped mourning or loving his dead wife and kids. He would never have chosen FMC if not for the fact he needed a babysitter for his kids. And even when he supposedly does choose her, there is no passion, no love, no anything. Author even had them living in the same home he lived with his dead family that is a shrine to them.
There are ways to do a dead-ex trope, and there is....this. One star only because I needed it counted otherwise GR has a tendency to mark them 5 stars when doing technical upgrades. ☹️
This is a very poorly written book about a heavy topic. At first I thought it was the style of writing but nearing the end the inconsistencies felt like it was written by AI.
I’m not going to touch on the plot because to each their own regarding angst, grovel etc.
We were told what was happening in the book about 90% of the book, I kid you not. There was barely any dialogue. Everything was explained, “I told her, he said to me etc”. It was so strange. It will come to a part where a conversation was happening, one character will have a dialogue and the next character explains their answer in a narration instead.
So. odd!
But towards the end was when you can see the AI/ terrible editing. Dialogues that made no sense / was out of place, pronouns that didn’t fit the sentence etc.
I really enjoyed this book. It was heartwarming and heartbreaking at the same time. Jensen went though something no sane person would be able to go through alone.
The writing could be fixed a bit here and there. I wish there was a bit more dialogue between the characters instead of the writer telling us what is going on. Let your characters express themselves a bit more.
There were some parts where it would switch to third person. For example, Jensen would be speaking and he would talk in the third person randomly.
Overall, a good story but needs a bit of tweaks here and there.
1⭐ Ughhh, I’m so annoyed. This book just… wasn’t it.
“He falls first”? Girl, where. He’s still fully in love with his dead wife.
And that whole “she deserved better (and gets it!)” tag? What exactly does she get? To be the replacement prize? The safe choice. To be the woman raising her babies in a house that feels more like a memorial than a home. He stayed because of the kids, not because he loves her.
The ex mother‑in‑law was awful, and Jensen letting her treat Aoife like that made me dislike him even more.
By the end, I was just sad for Aoife. She deserved so much more than settling for a man who could never love her completely.
'Until the moment everything changed and she stopped waiting for him to figure it out. Now he has to decide if what he has left to offer is anything close to what she deserves.'
The characters were well developed. Plot was intriguing. World building was solidly drawn. All in all a very good read. Recommend.
Grab a copy!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This was a tough book to read. A fatal car accident costs Jensen's life to become empty and meaningless when his wife and childen died. His coping mechanisms almost cost him his life, too. Enter Aoife, a waitress who just shows care.
Not sure if this book was a love story or a study on healing. The writing is great but there is a link missing to bring it together.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I am rating this 5 stars and I have also given "Angry God" by LJ Shen 5 stars. These two books couldn't be more different.
Aoife did something I wish more characters did, which is never let a man tell you he doesn't want you twice. It was everything Jensen deserved to come looking for her and not be able to find her, with no one to blame but himself.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This was a heavy read but in a good, raw, emotional way. It’s a different writing style than I am used to but still full of emotion and grief and love. The grief was heavy and it was a journey to find the way to love and a HEA. For a novella, this made an impact that stays with you.
I really felt for Aoife while reading this book. It’s a short story, but it carries so much emotion.
I didn’t hate Jensen. I actually understood his pain and everything surrounding what happened to him. I loved how his story unfolded, and I especially loved the ending. It felt emotional and satisfying, and I’m really glad I gave this one a chance. 🥹❤️