Forever Defiant: The angsty, enemies to lovers, sports romance

by Eve L. Mitchell

🖤 Morally grey MMC
🖤 Sports romance
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🖤 Fake Dating
🖤 Opposites attract
🖤 Romantic suspense

I want the truth. He wants to ruin me.

The Alabama Lions are hiding something, and I’m determined to expose the team. Write the story that will burn their whole program down.

They know I’m watching. So they sent him.

Dustin Slater. Star wide receiver. Killer body. Filthy mouth. His job was simple — warn me off, wear me down, keep me too distracted to dig.

Instead, he pins me with that wicked smile, gets too close, and makes every warning sound like a dare.

I’m chasing the truth. A missing girl. A name wiped from every record. Powerful men who’ll do anything to keep their secrets buried.

But he gets in my way. In my head. Under my skin. Until wanting him is the only thought I have left.

I should walk away from Dustin. I should walk away from it all.

But I’ve never known when to quit.

And now I want him almost as much as I want the truth.

This angsty, morally grey, college sports romance is perfect for fans of Meagan Brandy, Chloe Walsh, Parker S. Huntington, Rosa Lucas, L.J Shen, Rebecca Jenshak, Nikki Lawson

This series must be read in order.

Recommended for readers 18+

Readers are falling for Forever

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘This series just keeps getting better!’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘I absolutely loved it! The chemistry between Hadley and Dustin was obvious from page one, and their oil and water interactions just fed more fuel to an ever-simmering fire.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘I'm instantly in love! The writing is fantastic, this is not your average football romance . . . Football, mystery, spice, strong characters, great plot . . . I loved it!’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘This book was gritty, very steamy but definitely very gritty . . . [it] got the balance just right.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘I have read book 1 (Forever Reckless) and loved it . . . and love this book more.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘Forever Defiant absolutely got me . . . If you love enemies-to-lovers, fake dating, protective heroes who are secretly soft, and heroines who refuse to be told what to do, definitely pick this one up. Dustin and Hadley completely won me over.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘I absolutely loved the dynamic between Hadley and Dustin . . . If you enjoy sports romances, enemies-to-lovers, fake dating, secrets, protective heroes, and strong independent FMCs, this book is definitely worth picking up.’

Love the Alabama Lions? Meet the opposing team - The Ruthless Devils, from Eve Mitchell’s universe.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘Well that just blew my freaking mind.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘Dark romance is quickly becoming one of my favourite genres and this book cemented for me why.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘10000000% recommend.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘Dark and delicious, this story is fabulous 💖.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘WOW just WOW! . . . another brilliant book by Eve.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘If you like enemies-to-lovers, morally grey men, and college sports romance that pulls no punches, this one’s for you.’

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ‘I couldn't put it down. I loved everything about this book.’

Genres: Suspense, Mystery, Enemies To Lovers, Romance

422 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 7, 2026

About the author

Eve L. Mitchell is a USA Today Bestselling author who writes contemporary romance and urban fantasy.

Being an avid reader from a young age, Eve still considers herself to be a reader first. She believes there is nothing better than getting that new book either on your e-reader or in your hands, and the fact she may bring that excitement to a fellow reader, fills her with wonder. She writes under a pen name because otherwise her Secret Agent status will be revoked.

Eve lives in the North East of Scotland, with her three coffee machines and her significant other, Mr. M. She enjoys NFL Football, music and having long conversations with the voices in her head, which sometimes turn into the stories she writes.

Reviews

[Joanna · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.75 rounded to 4 stars for me.

Hadley is trying uncover more of shady stuff going on in Wrighton University’s football program.Dustin Slater a Star wide receiver warn her off,and Hadley will not let him to stop her from find out the truth.It seems that this is bigger than Hadley even thought and the one who knew something disappear.

Will she get her answers or will the football program and the players stop her?

It was an enjoyable romantic suspense,and I can't wait to find out what is really going on.I enjoyed the most part,especially the mystery,romance was ok,but I didn't feel the chemistry between the main characters.It just lacks something,Dustin for the most part behave like he really didn't want to even bother with Hadley,so that for me fall short.That being said the mystery in this book was engrossing,and I could not wait if they find something new.The ending was surprising and I can't wait for the next book in the series.

Thank you Joffe Books for arc,my review is honest and my own.

[Sue Em · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.25⭐
Came for the romance, captivated by the mystery. Hadley, a journalism student at Wright University, knows there is something wrong or corrupt with the football department there and is determined to uncover it. Dustin, the wide receiver, is a player in every sense of the word, and only interested in making it to the NFL draft next year. Their attraction/antipathy is the catalyst for great banter and fireworks. Book is packed with interesting secondary characters with their own back stories I want to know. My only disappointment...needing to wait for next book after cliffhanger ending. Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.

[Julie Booklover · Rating 4 out of 5]

I picked this up because I liked the blurb, but it was one of those reads, that you are turning the last page long before you are ready for the book to end. A sports romance with plenty of mystery, questionable characters, high stakes, and plenty of chemistry. Lets begin with the mystery surrounding the Alabama Lions, a missing girl and secrets. Suspense is edge of your seat, pages turning, and addictive.

Hadley is a journalist who knows in her bones there is something wrong at the Wright University football department. She is determined to uncover whatever is going on.

Dustin Slater, wide receiver, plans to make it to the show in the next draft. He and Hadley have a opposites attract, giving us the best banter, and sparks.

What I like is the balance of suspense, romance, and mystery. The tension is fantastic and my only dislike is we end on cliff. Now we are waiting for the next book.

Thank you to the NetGalley Joffe Books | Choc Lit for the advanced copy; this is my voluntary review.

[Renée · Rating 4 out of 5]

Forever Defiant by Eve L. Mitchell is the second book in the Fourth and Forever series.

Dustin and Hadley’s story took me a bit to get into, which was a first for me reading Eve’s books, but once I was deep into the story I really enjoyed it. The angsty enemies to lovers vibes, the “f*ck it” moment and cat and mouse chase that kept going, until they were wholly consumed by each other.

The mystery of the football team continued and with Hadley’s reporter/investigation skills coming it play, it fills in more pieces of the puzzle. I liked that the other main characters from Forever Reckless still had a key part to play in all of this.

The development of Hadley and Sav’s friendship was also a perfect addition to the storyline.

Honestly, Hadley and Dustin had so much attraction and tension, that the world seemed to disappear around them.

Looking forward to Noah’s book, so much!!! Cause that ending has me needing to read how this pans out, but also there’s something about Noah!

[VickydpBooks · Rating 4 out of 5]

If you love sports romances with high stakes, sizzling chemistry, and plenty of mystery, this one is definitely worth picking up.

The tension between the morally grey Dustin Slater and the determined journalist heroine is impossible to ignore.

Their enemies-to-lovers dynamic is packed with banter, undeniable attraction, and a fake dating trope that only makes their chemistry even more addictive.

As complete opposites, they constantly challenge each other, making every interaction entertaining.

What really sets this story apart is the romantic suspense. The mystery surrounding the Alabama Lions, a missing girl, and long-buried secrets adds genuine intrigue and keeps the pages turning.

It’s not just about the romance—there’s a compelling investigation that raises the stakes and gives the story real depth.

Dustin is the kind of morally grey MMC who keeps you guessing. He’s protective, frustrating, and impossible to resist, while the heroine’s determination to uncover the truth makes her easy to root for.

Together, they create a romance filled with tension, trust issues, and emotional moments that make their journey satisfying.

This is an addictive blend of sports romance, enemies to lovers, fake dating, opposites attract, and romantic suspense. If you enjoy fast-paced romances with mystery, morally grey heroes, and plenty of chemistry, this is one to add to your TBR.

[Faiza · Rating 4 out of 5]

I picked this up expecting a light football romance, but it turned into so much more than that. Between the romance, the mystery surrounding Wright University, and the incredible character dynamics, I was hooked from beginning to end.

Hadley immediately stood out to me. As a journalism student, she's relentless when she believes something isn't right, and she's convinced there's corruption tied to the university's football program. Even when people warn her to stop asking questions, she refuses to back down. I loved how determined and fearless she was, even though it was obvious she carried plenty of emotional walls of her own.

Dustin couldn't have made a worse first impression. He's focused on football, the upcoming NFL draft, and staying away from anything that could jeopardize his future. His constant attempts to shut Hadley's investigation down made him seem arrogant at first, but as the story unfolded, it became clear his actions came from fear rather than selfishness. He wasn't trying to control her—he was trying to protect her from dangers she didn't fully understand. That realization completely changed the way I viewed him.

One of my favorite things about this book was how patiently the romance developed. There wasn't an instant love story or dramatic whirlwind relationship. Dustin and Hadley slowly chipped away at each other's defenses, building trust through every conversation, argument, and quiet moment together. Their chemistry felt authentic because neither of them was ready to be vulnerable right away.

The fake dating storyline was exactly the kind of trope I love when it's done well. Watching them play the role of a couple while their feelings gradually became impossible to ignore was both entertaining and incredibly satisfying. Long before either of them admitted the truth, it was obvious they had stopped pretending. Their emotional journey never felt rushed, which made every romantic moment land even harder.

What made their relationship special wasn't just the attraction between them—it was the way they constantly pushed each other to grow. Hadley challenged Dustin to look beyond football, while Dustin became someone Hadley could finally rely on without losing her independence. Their connection was built on mutual respect, loyalty, and a genuine desire to keep each other safe, and that made their romance feel incredibly rewarding.

The mystery added another layer that kept me invested throughout the entire book. Every new clue about the football program made me want answers just as badly as Hadley did, and I loved that the suspense never took away from the romance. Instead, both storylines strengthened each other.

The supporting cast deserves recognition too. The friendship between Savvy and Hadley was one of my favorite parts outside of the romance, and there are several side characters whose stories I'm already excited to read.

That ending left me with completely mixed emotions. Seeing Dustin and Hadley finally get the future they deserved put the biggest smile on my face, but the unresolved situation surrounding the football program left me desperate for more. Ending on that cliffhanger was cruel in the best way because now I need Noah's book as soon as possible.

[Sandy S · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5stars. FOREVER DEFIANT is the second instalment in Eve L Mitchell’s contemporary, new adult FOURTH AND FOREVER erotic, football, romantic suspense series. This is twenty-one year old wide-receiver Dustin Slater, and journalism student Hadley Peterson’s story line. FOREVER DEFIANT should not be read as a stand alone as there is a continuing story line throughout. There is a slight cross-over with the characters from the author’s The Ruthless Devil’s series,


NOTE: Due to the nature of the story line premise, there may be triggers for more sensitive readers.


Told from dual first person perspectives ( Hadley and Dustin) FOREVER DEFIANT follows journalism student Hadley Peterson as she continues to search for the truth. Something is wrong with college sports, something dark, hidden, and always behind the scenes but as Hadley begins to dig into the Alabama Lions football organization, she never expected to find herself falling for wide receiver Dustin Slater. Under the guise of doing an expose on Dustin Slater, Hadley begins to dig into the past, and discovers the Lions have buried a story, the names and events have been wiped from the school’s records, and with the help of quarterback Dante and Savannah (Forever Reckless 1), Dustin, and Dustin’s roommate and fellow football player Noah Matthews, Hadley goes in search of the truth. Dustin struggles with Hadley’s presence in his life, and her need to uncover the truth but Hadley’s search is threatening the security of the game, and the people in charge are taking notice.


The world building, once again, focuses on the demands of college football, scandals and the darker side of athletics as Hadley follows the hunt for evidence, evidence buried and deleted, leaving little to no trail . Something happened four years earlier, and Hadley is determined to uncover the truth. The game is all about the W, and anything or anyone that interferes, is silenced or disappears.


The relationship between Hadley and Dustin begins acrimoniously. Dustin Slater does not trust our story line heroine, a woman who is digging into the sport he loves, and the secrets hidden behind the wins and championships but there is definitely a darkness that threatens the school, and working with Hadley, brings our couple together, The $ex scenes are are intimate and passionate without the use of over the top sexually graphic language and text.


The secondary and supporting characters are charismatic, determined and dynamic. We are reintroduced to Dante and Savannah, Noah Matthews, Coach TJ Hembry, Coach Sutherland, Savannah’s father Dean Maxwell Cole, as well as Dustin’s parents and his sister Naya.


FOREVER DEFIANT is a thought provoking story of secrets and lies, power and control, betrayal and vengeance, family and relationships, acceptance and love. The character driven premise is dramatic, edgy and gritty; the romance is seductive; the characters are desperate, often intimidating and captivating. FOREVER DEFIANT ends on a cliff hanger-you have been warned.

[Karolyn · Rating 5 out of 5]

Here is my review for Forever Defiant by Eve L Mitchell

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this enemies to lovers, American football University sports romance which sees Hadley Peterson pursuing the truth about a missing girl whose record has been wiped from everywhere that could possibly hold it. Deep pockets and powerful men can move mountains to do anything to keep their secrets buried. Dustin Slater, star wide receiver for the Alabama Lions is sent to warn me off as they know I'm positive the team is hiding something. They want him to keep me too occupied to dig. Instead, an attraction forms and he gets into my head and under my skin. It gets so I want him as much as I want the truth!

Oh my! This book is sizzling as you read it. The attraction is there although Dustin and Hadley do their best to deny it. It’s a superbly written story which carries on where the first book left off, so it is best to read them in order. The story is told in two povs, ‘Dustin’ and ‘Hadley’. I love reading these types of stories as you seem to learn so much about the characters telling them as well. It’s well plotted and thought out. It’s mainly the same main characters as book one. The story flowed fluently and I found I got so invested in reading the story, I couldn’t put the book down. This is book two of the series and a brilliant addition to it.

Synopsis :


🖤 Morally grey MMC
🖤 Sports romance
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🖤 Fake Dating
🖤 Opposites attract
🖤 Romantic suspense

I want the truth. He wants to ruin me.

The Alabama Lions are hiding something, and I’m determined to expose the team. Write the story that will burn their whole program down.

They know I’m watching. So they sent him.

Dustin Slater. Star wide receiver. Killer body. Filthy mouth. His job was simple — warn me off, wear me down, keep me too distracted to dig.

Instead, he pins me with that wicked smile, gets too close, and makes every warning sound like a dare.

I’m chasing the truth. A missing girl. A name wiped from every record. Powerful men who’ll do anything to keep their secrets buried.

But he gets in my way. In my head. Under my skin. Until wanting him is the only thought I have left.

I should walk away from Dustin. I should walk away from it all.

But I’ve never known when to quit.

And now I want him almost as much as I want the truth.

This angsty, morally grey, college sports romance is perfect for fans of Meagan Brandy, Chloe Walsh, Parker S. Huntington, Rosa Lucas, L.J Shen, Rebecca Jenshak, Nikki Lawson

This series must be read in order.

Recommended for readers 18+

[Catherine Noel · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever Defiant absolutely got me.

I went into this expecting a fun football romance, but I ended up getting so attached to Dustin and Hadley. Their relationship was the kind that sneaks up on you. They start off butting heads because Hadley is determined to figure out what’s really going on with the football program, and Dustin is basically doing everything he can to keep her from getting herself into trouble. He comes across as such a jerk at first, but once you realize he’s terrified of what could happen to her if she keeps digging, everything hits differently.

Hadley was probably my favorite part of the book. She’s smart, stubborn, and so guarded, and I loved watching her slowly let Dustin in. Neither of them falls first or falls fast. It takes time, and that’s what made their relationship feel so real. Every conversation, every moment they spent together, every crack in their walls had me rooting for them harder and harder.

And the fake dating? I ate it up. Watching them pretend to be together while clearly catching real feelings was so much fun. There were so many moments where they were technically still “faking” it, but you could tell neither of them was fooling themselves anymore. The realization of their feelings felt natural and earned, which made the payoff even better.

What really got me was how much Dustin and Hadley genuinely cared about each other. Beneath all the tension, banter, and drama was a relationship built on trust and protection. Dustin wanting to keep Hadley safe and Hadley refusing to back down no matter what made them such a great match. They definitely challenged each other.

That ending had me feeling two completely different emotions at the same time. I was smiling because Dustin and Hadley finally got their happily ever after and admitted what everyone already knew, but I was also sitting there staring at the last page because of that football program cliffhanger. I need the Noah’s book immediately! Also, shout out to the developed friendship between Savvy and Hadley. They were so entertaining.

If you love enemies-to-lovers, fake dating, protective heroes who are secretly soft, and heroines who refuse to be told what to do, definitely pick this one up. Dustin and Hadley completely won me over. This is the second book in the series, they first being about Dante and Savvy and I loved it just as much. Eve L. Mitchell is by far one of my favorite authors of the genre.

[Bianca Duthie · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is book two in the Fourth and Forever series. In book 1 we met the three stars of the Lions college football team - Dante, Dustin and Noah. It focused on QB10, otherwise known as Dante as his relationship with the Dean's daughter - Savvy - progressed. This book focused on Dustin, and we got to know Hadley, who we were briefly introduced to at the end of book 1. We also continued to see Dante and Savvys relationship flourish which is something I really like in books like this. We also got a few glimpses into Noah's background, my heart aches for him, he seems so lovely and supportive, and I really hope the next book sees his story being told with him being able to share his tale with those that love him.
While the books centre around a romantic relationship in each book, I think what makes them even better for me is the emphasis on the friendships. Dante and Dustin really want Noah to be happy, I love seeing the three of them banter with each other. Savvy and Hadley form a surprisingly lovely friendship also. Hadley seemed like such a prickly pear and Savvy had spent so long repressing who she was for her dad, so its lovely to see these women uplifting one another!
Like book 1 this is action-packed from start to finish. There's so much to think about and going on. We've become deeper inviegled in the drama of the secrets that I am convinced that Coach Sutherland is the mastermind of! I cannot wait to see how things continue to unfold in the next book!
There are a number of spicy scenes, but like with book 1 you have to wait a good chunk to get to them, but when you do, it is HOT!
We have a surprise cameo from the characters from the Cardinal Saints team who we met in another series by this author. They were what got me into this authors sports romances and I really liked those characters. It was only a short crossover but I thought it was great, I'd love to see more from them in the sequel - maybe they become integral to the truth coming out, I definitely think they know more than they were telling!
The book ends on a massive cliffhanger - I seriously did not see that one coming, either part of it! It was such a good reveal and I cannot wait to delve into that deeper in book 3, I really hope I dont have long to wait!
If you love sports romances with lots of drama and intrigue then you do not want to miss this series!

[Heidi Lengenfelder · Rating 4 out of 5]

I received an advance review copy of this book and am leaving this review voluntarily and honestly.

If you love sports romance with a dangerous edge, morally grey heroes, sizzling chemistry, and a mystery that refuses to let up, *Forever Defiant* delivers all of that while keeping the tension high from beginning to end.

At first glance, Dustin Slater seems like the typical cocky football star—confident, charming, and far too comfortable getting under everyone's skin. But the more the story unfolds, the clearer it becomes that there's far more beneath his carefully crafted reputation. His morally grey decisions constantly blur the line between protector and problem, making him an endlessly fascinating hero.

His match in every way is the fiercely determined journalist who refuses to back down. She's driven by the need to uncover the truth surrounding a missing girl and the secrets buried within a powerhouse football program. Even when she's warned away, intimidated, or tempted, she never loses sight of why she started. Her determination makes her easy to root for, even when her investigation puts everything—including her heart—at risk.

The fake dating dynamic adds plenty of entertaining moments, especially because neither character can stand the other in the beginning. Their banter is sharp, the attraction is undeniable, and every forced interaction chips away at the walls they've built around themselves. Watching enemies slowly become reluctant allies—and eventually something much deeper—felt natural despite the constant suspense surrounding them.

What really elevates the story is that the romance never overshadows the mystery. The investigation into the missing girl adds genuine stakes, creating an atmosphere where every revelation feels dangerous and every answer comes with new questions. The suspense keeps the pages turning just as much as the romance does.

Fans of morally grey heroes, fake dating, enemies-to-lovers tension, football romances, and romantic suspense will find plenty to love here. The blend of emotional vulnerability, high-stakes secrets, and undeniable chemistry makes *Forever Defiant* an addictive read that balances romance with genuine intrigue.

[Paula Phillips · Rating 3 out of 5]

There's something wonderfully fitting about a book landing in my hands on my own birthday. Forever Defiant published on the 7th of July, and reading it felt like unwrapping a gift made just for me the kind of serendipity that makes this whole reviewing hobby of mine feel a little bit magical.

From the first chapter, I was hooked, but it wasn't Dustin Slater's wicked smile that pulled me in hardest , it was Hadley. I don't think I've resonated with a heroine quite this much in a long time. Watching her chase the truth, notebook in hand, utterly unwilling to back down even when powerful men wanted her silenced, stirred something very personal in me. Journalism has always been my own quiet dream one I chased extramurally through years of study, and one I've kept alive for two decades now, writing for online magazines and review sites in whatever spare hours I could find.

These days you'll find my byline over at Gothic Bite Magazine, a US-based publication where I write a true crime column alongside odd, wonderfully weird little pieces. So when Hadley refused to let the story go, refused to let Dustin or anyone distract her from digging for the truth, I felt like I was reading a piece of myself.

Eve L. Mitchell balances the suspense beautifully against the sports romance backbone. The Alabama Lions' secrets simmer under every scene, and Dustin Slater is exactly the kind of morally grey MMC that makes enemies-to-lovers sing , filthy-mouthed, dangerous, and yet somehow devastatingly protective in the moments that count. The opposites-attract chemistry between him and Hadley crackles, and the forbidden-love tension never once feels forced.

I'll admit, I came into this book still riding the high of Elle Kennedy's Off Campus series and its first season adaptation, that particular flavour of angsty, morally grey sports romance where the characters actually stay true to themselves throughout. Forever Defiant scratched that same itch beautifully, while still carving out its own identity with the suspense thread woven through.

A cosy, angsty, addictive read and one that will always feel a little bit like my own birthday gift from Eve L. Mitchell.

[Akku · Rating 4 out of 5]

• 𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠 - 4✨

• 𝐑𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞 - July 7, 2026 - Available Now

• 𝐓𝐫𝐨𝐩𝐞𝐬 -
- College Sports Romance
- Football Player x Journalism Student
- Enemies to Lovers
- Slow Burn
- Forced Proximity
- Opposites Attract
- Found Family
- Mystery & Secrets

• 𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 -
Hadley is a journalism student determined to uncover the secrets hidden inside her university's football program. Dustin is one of the team's biggest stars and the last person who wants those secrets exposed. What starts as constant tension and clashes slowly turns into something neither of them can ignore.
I really enjoyed this one. The mix of sports romance and mystery kept me hooked from the beginning. Hadley was strong, determined, and never backed down when things became difficult. Dustin had that protective football player energy that I absolutely love.
The chemistry between them was sweet and frustrating in the best way because of all the secrets standing between them. I loved watching their relationship develop naturally and seeing them slowly learn to trust each other. Their moments together felt genuine and added a lot of heart to the story.
The mystery surrounding the football program added extra drama and kept me turning the pages. I enjoyed following Hadley as she searched for answers and uncovered the truth piece by piece. It gave the story something more than just romance and made it even more engaging.
The friend group was another highlight for me. Their banter, loyalty, and support for each other made me smile so many times. I became attached to several side characters and now I am especially excited for Noah's story after that ending.
While I would have loved a little more depth in a few emotional moments, I still had a great time reading this book. It was entertaining, emotional, and addictive enough to keep me invested until the very last page.
Overall, this was a fun sports romance filled with secrets, tension, friendship, and a satisfying romance. A solid 4-star read for me and I can't wait to see what comes next in this series.
Thank you zoolosbooktour for the ARC!

[K T · Rating 5 out of 5]

First of all - even though this isn't listed (on Netgalley at least) as part of a series, it absolutely is... and I didn't connect the dots until I was partway through the book... This is Book 2 in the "Fourth and Forever" series... they are interconnected standalones, but it is very helpful to read the books in order as there are weird happenings at the college that they are working on uncovering... I have read book 1 (Forever Reckless) & loved it... and love this book more, knowing it's connected to that book (yes, I should have looked a bit more closely before I started reading it!! LOL)

This is Dustin & Hadley's story... but there is also a lot about Dante & Savvy (from Book 1) & Noah (Book 3 will be about him!! I can't wait!)... and they are trying to solve some discrepancies about the college - in Book 1 they were mostly focused on weird payouts & the like.... in this book, Hadley starts off (she is a journalist, after all) looking into a freshman football player (Mason) who disappeared 3 years ago in a strange way... and it was covered up & made to look like he was never there...

I really enjoyed the book... it is fast paced... and I kept hoping we would find out what happened to Mason (spoiler... it doesn't resolve in this book!!! argh!!)... but I enjoyed the drama with the other young adults anyhow... I like their friendship and loved how Dustin & Hadley's relationship came to be & how it changed a bit the more they got to know each other...

I loved Dustin's family!!! Their visit home was one of the best parts of the book!!

Can't wait to read Book 3!!!

Spice level: 3/5

*football romance
*sports romance
*college/young adult romance
*fake dating
*she's a journalist
*enemies to lovers
*romantic suspense (mild suspense)

Thank you to the author (Eve L. Mitchell), publisher (Joffe Books/Choc Lit) & Netgalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

[Nicole · Rating 5 out of 5]

Last semester, Hadley uncovered what she believed were shady practices within Wrighton University’s football program, and after she was forced to take down a blog post exposing them, she is even more convinced that she was right. Spotting one of the team’s star players in the bar one night, she sees it as a chance to get an inside scoop, but when things get a little too close for comfort, she backs off, not wanting to compromise herself for a story. When she gets assigned to shadow one of the freshman players for an assignment, she quickly realizes that there is a lot more to the story than she ever imagined, if only she could find away to stop the pull she feels everytime her lease favourite wide receiver gets close.

What Dustin and his friends uncovered last semester could be enough to destroy the university, and any dreams he had of being drafted to the NFL. While they don’t want to leave things buried, they also don’t want to act until they have irrefutable proof, so when he realizes the girl he almost hooked up with at the bar is Hadley, the same journalism student who they found out had been investigating the football program, he knows he needs to keep his distance. But Hadley is persistent and refuses to let things go, and Dustin finds himself both wanting to keep her away, and keep her safe.

I received an early copy of this book from @Netgalley and I absolutely loved it! The chemistry between Hadley and Dustin was obvious from page one, and their oil and water interactions just fed more fuel to an ever-simmering fire. I loved how they challenged each other, but also became fiercely protective of the other. While Forever Reckless fed us the first bits of the Athletic Department secrets, this one brought us a whole other angle to uncover, and with characters from the Ruthless Devils brought in, the final volume is sure to be explosive.

[A · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thanks to Netgalley for this advanced reader copy, Forever Defiant was a 4 star read for me. Typically this isnt a book i would request but i did decide to give this a go after reading the synopsis. I feel that this book is between romance and partly thriller as well as it had a strong headline in here of mystery which i thought was really interesting but i felt like i should have read book one first. This was my fault as i should have requested this first . The book is set in a college environment where students are trying to find themselves and build their careers and reputations. But they can clearly see something's not right, it lies between ethics and do you just allow things to happen under your nose just for the sake of having a quiet life and being accepted and liked. Or do you go against it and the people around you to find out what really goes on. How defiant are you willing to be and whose path do you cross between this is where Hadley our main fmc meets Dustin.

The forever defiant part has a underlying tone of going against the odds in certain situations and it was required in this book to be able to find out the truth, i liked Hadleys fire in her soul and being able to be independent and not being afraid to stand on your own.

The other characters all had their own story again it was likeable and relatable for the different stages in their life. Am not a massive sports fan but i think it gave a really good insight into the determination required for young males training and actually how hard it can be for them. They base their whole life around this.

There is tension between alot of the characters and the ending i had to read twice, i really do need to read book one !

[Crystal Conwell · Rating 5 out of 5]

NetGalley ARC Review

Forever Defiant by Forever Defiant was such a great read. I absolutely loved the dynamic between Hadley and Dustin.

Hadley is a journalism major who is determined to expose what she believes is happening behind the scenes within the athletic program. She's convinced something isn't right and is willing to do whatever it takes to uncover the truth. What she never expects, though, is for the star wide receiver, Dustin, to completely turn her world upside down.

They say there's a fine line between love and hate, and Hadley and Dustin prove that perfectly. Their constant clashes and mutual frustration quickly evolve into undeniable chemistry. What starts as intense attraction soon develops into something much deeper, with Dustin transforming from a grumpy, frustrating athlete into someone fiercely protective of Hadley.

The problem? Hadley is fiercely independent. She hates being told what to do and refuses to believe she needs anyone looking out for her. Watching these two battle their feelings while slowly realizing they actually balance each other out made for such an entertaining and emotional journey.

If you enjoy sports romances, enemies-to-lovers, fake dating, secrets, protective heroes, and strong independent FMCs, this book is definitely worth picking up.

I enjoyed this story so much and cannot wait for the next book in the series. While Dustin and Hadley's story delivered a satisfying romance, there are still plenty of unanswered questions surrounding the larger backstory, and I'm excited to see where the author takes things next.

[Sally (bookishbursnoll) · Rating 4 out of 5]

"No more fake relationship bullshit. You're mine. Got it?"

Write it in the stars, Dustin Slater is a new book boyfriend whom I ADORE 👏🏻

I won't lie, I was a little...miffed for the first 30% of this book, frustratingly thinking 'there's something missing here, they keep being real vague about a certain subject and characters etc' and turns out it was my own silly fault - I missed the whole first book!! Somehow I've done it again and read the second book in a series, so yes I had missed something very important that involved a number of characters and after I realised it was my own fault, the book made sense!? Immediately reading the first one, just to fill that gap 🏃‍♀️

The second half of the book is definitely better than the first half, I will say that, and it actually got a little creepy in some places, finding out about a certain character #iykyk 👀 I absolutely loved the characters of Hadley and Dustin as the main MCs, aswell as the side characters and I am keen as runner bean to find out more about them all - except Dante who is the first book LOL 🤪 The chemistry between Hadley and Dustin is fantastic and WOWZA the fake dating, the "fuck it" 🥵, the spice, absolutely SENSATIONAL 👏🏻

It's not a full 5 ⭐️ for me because the pacing at the beginning reaaaaally confused me with the night out and tbh kinda set a bad tone for me, so I'm VERY glad it completely turned around for me from the 40% mark - thank you Eve L Mitchell, I can't wait for the next one!! (When is the date please!?)

Thank you NetGalley and Joffe Books for the e-arc

[Claire · Rating 2 out of 5]

This book and I never really connected, and I'm not sure we ever got there.

It took me nearly two weeks to get past the 18% mark, which is extremely unusual for me since I typically finish that much of a book within a day or two. I considered DNFing at least three separate times before ultimately deciding to push through and finish it.

One of my biggest struggles was with the characters. The FMC initially came across as someone willing to stand up for what she believed was right, but that characterization quickly shifted. As the story progressed, she often felt desperate and unnecessarily stubborn while simultaneously trying to project a "cool girl" persona, which made it difficult for me to connect with her.

The MMC was even more challenging. I found him deeply unlikeable and often confusing. The story repeatedly tells readers that he is a player, but instead of showing that naturally through his actions, it felt like the narrative was trying to convince me of it. The characterization never fully landed for me.

I also found much of the dialogue ridiculously long. Many conversations seemed to go on without contributing meaningful character development, plot progression, or tension, which made the book feel much slower than it needed to be.

Overall, this was not a book I enjoyed. Between the pacing, the character work, and the excessive dialogue, the story felt disjointed and overly wordy.

[Nathalie DeSousa · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5/5

Thanks to NetGalley for the copy of the book. I had fun reading this book, and it surprised me, as I went in looking for a sport romance and got much more than that.

An enemies to lovers, fake dating football romance that packs suspense and intrigue on its plot. Dustin and Hadley, the couple you did not see coming, but just fit in so perfectly. She is the reporter trying to uncover what is happening in the football program, she is stubborn, decisive, smart, a bit impulsive, but careful with her feelings and heart. She is ready to dig even when she keeps finding blocks at every step of the way. Dustin is the wide receiver who in his way is trying to veer off the investigation, though he comes as brash, he is caring, protective, and also afraid of the trouble she can run into.

THere is a mystery that lingers all through the plot that keeps the read entertaining and addicting. When they set into a fake relationship (to try to keep each other safe), they set a path to friendship that slowly brings trust and that spark of attraction and turns it into a real relationship. Their slow burn romance doesn't feel instant, instead it feels earned and settled.

The only negative (or a positive) is that you don't get a solved mystery, instead it leaves that part on a cliffhanger of sorts that sets the next book and leave you wanting the next story (let's hope is Noah's)

[Mita · Rating 2 out of 5]

Ok, so the book had a very typical wattpad-y storyline. It was good initially for the mystery part then the mystery got sidelined and boring.

The FMC was good at first, stubborn but good; then she became annoying, chasing and asking unnecessary stupid questions to the MMC. Like girl, you're here for your story, what would you do knowing why someone you met 2 weeks ago, who doesn't have the basic decency to be polite to you and insults you on every step, makes fun of you, instigates others against you, is suddenly ignoring you?? You should be thankful and chase your story not him!

The MMC is utterly unlikable. Don't know how he (or they) fell in love when all he thinks about is her body. He was so confused like one second he is hating and insulting her and then kissing her in the next. Make it make sense bro!

I liked Savvy among the side characters, and by their conversations, it seemed Noah was the most sensible one of the trio.

Didn't know it was part of a series and I have no intention of continuing the rest of the books. I want to know about the mystery but won't be able to take this torture again.

Thanks to Netgalley for providing me an eARC of the book in exchange of an honest review.

[Sonja Charters · Rating 4 out of 5]

How am I already back and reviewing the second book in this series!?

I only read book 1 - Forever Reckless - back in June so you can imagine my shock when Fourth And Forever series book 2 landed in my inbox!?

 

This book centres around Hadley, searching for the truth the Lions are keeping hidden and Dustin, the bad boy that the team have sent to warn her off and keep her distracted.

 

You can already see the issue here can't you!?

I couldn't wait to find out how this enemies to lovers would work out because right from the start, I wasn't even sure if they'd both survive the book!

 

I loved the way they got under each others skins and we see the walls that they've carefully constructed slowly come crashing down and all this ejnsecurities and vulnerabilities come flooding out.

 

The chemistry was off the charts and of course we see some spicy moments between the pair.

But the mystery of what's being hidden really keeps this story so compelling and I just know that we're going to have to piece this together over the whole series.

 

I love this author's writing style and the way that I can drawn in by just the first few pages.

Completely gripped, I couldn't put this down and raced through it.

 

I'm already excited to get my hands on book 3 to find out more....

 

 

 

 
 

[Kelly · Rating 4 out of 5]

I'm reviewing this as part of a tour with Zooloo's Book Tours.

This enemies-to-lovers sports romance is the second in a series by this author. Dustin is a wide receiver for the Alabama Lions, and Hadley is a journalist. She needs the team for her story, but she finds Dustin very distracting…

Dustin seemed like that type of guy; you know he's probably trouble, but you want him anyway, and I think that's a type of character that readers always enjoy. I enjoyed Hadley as a character too, as I identified with her a little bit in some ways.

When it's enemies-to-lovers, you know it's going to be messy, and Dustin and Hadley's initial exchanges made me smile. I liked how Dustin's character developed as the story progressed. I also appreciated the return of some characters that I recognised from the first book. If you haven't read the first book though, I'd say this works well as a standalone.

If you enjoy sports romance, maybe Dustin could be your next book boyfriend.

Thank you to Zooloo's Book Tours, and to the author and publisher, for the opportunity to read and review this.

[Katy Jenkins · Rating 5 out of 5]

⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ can I give it more stars?!?!

Forever Defiant by Eve L. Mitchell had me completely hooked from beginning to end!

After that ending in book one, I was dying to find out what happened next. It was obvious there was so much more going on at the school than anyone realized, and this book did not disappoint. The mystery deepened, the stakes got higher, and I found myself constantly trying to piece everything together.

The tension in this book was absolutely off the charts. Between the secrets surrounding the coaching staff and the feeling that everyone was hiding something, there was an underlying sense of suspense in every chapter.

I especially loved the push and pull between Dustin and Hadley. Her determination to pursue the story puts her on a collision course with everything Dustin and his friends have worked so hard to build. I genuinely didn't know which path he would choose, and that uncertainty kept me turning pages late into the night.

Eve L. Mitchell delivered another addictive installment filled with tension, secrets, and emotional conflict. The ending left me desperate for more, and I cannot wait to see how everything plays out in the next book!

[Terry · Rating 5 out of 5]

5 Stars … This series just keeps getting better!

I loved Hadley and Dustin! Dustin is the wide receiver for his college football team the Lions. He is a player through and through … on and off the field, but he doesn’t know what hit him when Hadley enters his world. Hadley is a journalist student and her curious nature is constantly getting her into trouble. She is assigned to shadow a player on the football team for a school paper … that was a big mistake! I loved her smart mouth … she didn’t take anything from anybody. The chemistry between Dustin and Hadley is off the charts … my iPad almost melted! This book had it all … it made me laugh out loud and swoon. The banter between the characters is so realistic while the twists and turns just kept on coming … I love that in a book. It was great that Dante, Savvy and Noah were in this book quite a bit. I can’t wait for Noah’s story … which I hope is next!

I received an ARC courtesy of Joffe Books through NetGalley.

[Cait's Reading Nook · Rating 4 out of 5]

I read the first book of the series, Forever Reckless, and enjoyed the story and the same is for book two Forever Defiant as we learn more about Dustin and Hadley’s story.

Hadley is a journalist, investigating The Alabama Lions and a cover up. She has been operating under a guide of working on a profile of Dustin, a player on the team (and a morally grey MMC). Both she and Dustin work together to solve the mystery.

Secrets are revealed as the novel unfolds. The novel is a romance, but it also includes suspense and mystery. I found the exploration of these themes intriguing and engaging alongside seeing Dustin and Haley’s bond grow.

I’ve enjoyed how each of the books of the series leave a cliffhanger and we’re ready for the next book! I found the build of Dustin and Hadley’s connection well paced, bringing the story Hadley is working on into focus and building the story and characters’ journey’s around it.

[Serena Nicholls · Rating 5 out of 5]

Definitely ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Forever Defiant is everything I hoped for and more. Eve has delivered another addictive sports romance packed with sizzling chemistry, emotional depth, and the perfect amount of angst. From the very first chapter, I was completely invested in the characters and couldn't turn the pages fast enough. Hadley and Dustin are just insanely addictive

The enemies-to-lovers tension is absolutely phenomenal. Every interaction is filled with banter, frustration, and undeniable attraction that slowly builds into something unforgettable. The emotional journey feels authentic, with both characters forced to confront their pasts, their fears, and the walls they've built around themselves.

What really stood out was the character development. Watching them grow individually while learning to trust and love each other made every heartbreaking and heartwarming moment worth it. I wasn't sure they would actually make it at one point without actually killing each other 🤣🤣The romance is passionate, the dialogue is engaging, and the story strikes a wonderful balance between emotional vulnerability and swoon-worthy moments.

Eve L. Mitchell has a talent for creating characters you genuinely care about, and once again she's written a story that keeps you hooked from beginning to end. If you love sports romance with plenty of angst, unforgettable chemistry, emotional twists, and a hard-earned happily ever after, Forever Defiant is an absolute must-read. You do need to read the first book before reading this so you understand the back story but I honestly can't wait to see what Eve brings in the next book
:::

[Emma Andrea · Rating 3 out of 5]

I really enjoyed forever defiant and Hadley and Dustins dynamic, but the whole find what's up with the sports department bit could have been expanded on better since I didn't get much of what's going on, the book is described as an angsty enemies to lovers sports romance, I didn't see much angst...

Or maybe I read too many books that take the angst to crying in your room falling to knees begging for forgiveness and teary rejections 🤷🏻‍♀️

The first bit was a bit o pf a slow start but I really got sucked in and definitely enjoyed myself as I read, however I don't think I'm invested enough for the next book, but there wasn't much of a cliffhanger which might be my issue.

Might have been better with everything solved in one book

Overall a fun read, enemies to lovers, sports romance fun friend group, if you like sports romance you WILL like this book

[Phil Rogers · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is the second in the Forever Series and easily read as a stand-alone.
A classic enemies to lovers story centred around the football game. Hadley, a young blogger is convinced that something is going on behind the scenes of the University football team. She’s determined to expose the misleading but is forced to take down her exposé blog or face legal action. She goes undercover and comes close up to her arch enemy Dustin. What she suspects could destroy the University team and scupper Justin’s plans of Pro football. There follows a cat and mouse game ( more cat than mouse). The two antagonists are gradually but inextricably drawn together.
A bit of a romp with comic interlude and a great follow on to Forever Reckless. It gives some insight into the American university sports sponsorships and the big monied NFL.
Not recommended for the vicars wife!

[Heather · Rating 3 out of 5]

Thoughts upon starting the book: Maybe it’s just me but it felt like it was just a lot of back and forth dialogue and a bit hard to follow the story at least in the beginning.
Thoughts at the end: I did eventually get into it but unfortunately for me I didn’t know this was part of an interconnected series until nearing the end and realizing we won’t uncover the truth of what the football team is hiding by the end of the book and that this was also book 2 so maybe I wouldn’t have felt lost if I had read book 1 first.
Overall I did enjoy it, just took me a bit to get use to the writing style and care about the characters, again just know this is not a true standalone so maybe read book 1 first.
Thanks to NetGalley and Choclit for granting me this book.