What do you think?
Rate this book
Shrike #1
The Masked Songbird
Edinburgh accountant Gwenllian Maule is surviving. She’s got a boyfriend, a rescued pet bird and a flatmate to share rent. Gwen’s biggest challenges: stretching her last twenty quid until payday and not antagonising her terrifying boss.
Then Gwen mistakenly drinks a mysterious beverage that gives her heightened senses, accelerated healing powers and astonishing strength. All of which come in handy the night she rescues her activist neighbour from a beat-down by political thugs.
Now Gwen must figure out what else the serum has done to her body, who else is interested and how her boss is involved. Finally—and most mysteriously—she must uncover how this whole debacle is connected to the looming referendum on Scottish independence.
Superpowers don't make a superhero. Real strength isn't something you're born with -- it's something you build.
Then Gwen mistakenly drinks a mysterious beverage that gives her heightened senses, accelerated healing powers and astonishing strength. All of which come in handy the night she rescues her activist neighbour from a beat-down by political thugs.
Now Gwen must figure out what else the serum has done to her body, who else is interested and how her boss is involved. Finally—and most mysteriously—she must uncover how this whole debacle is connected to the looming referendum on Scottish independence.
Superpowers don't make a superhero. Real strength isn't something you're born with -- it's something you build.
354 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2014
4 people are currently reading
253 people want to read
About the author
Emmie Mears
21 books153 followersEmmie Mears writes the books they always needed to read about characters they wish they could be. Emmie is multilingual, autistic, agender, and a bad pescetarian.
Emmie makes their home with two cats in Glasgow, Scotland and hopes to keep it that way.
Emmie is represented by Sara Megibow of kt literary.
Emmie makes their home with two cats in Glasgow, Scotland and hopes to keep it that way.
Emmie is represented by Sara Megibow of kt literary.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 35 reviews
March 21, 2018
This is a pretty grisly super hero origins story that takes place in Scotland. And, note, I usually read lesfic or books with f/f relationships and this book is not that. I did totally dig the lead's ultimate love interest, though.
Gwen is an accountant by profession and passive by nature, letting people walk all over her in work and in life. Both her boss and her boyfriend are awful yet she continually tolerates and fears their reproach and abandonment. She's an odd one to be a real life super hero but one event leads to another that gets her there.
I'm not up on many super hero stories but this read is on the darker side in the vein of Batman (or worse). I've read the entire Ayala Storme series by this author and though that story was also dark, the lead's sarcastic wit offered a lot of humor in the narrative, too. In contrast, this does not which made the story bleaker than I expected.
I personally found the book a little slow but each chapter definitely sets the tone and builds the backstory of Gwen's character so we can see how much she changes over time both physically and emotionally. It also introduces and lays down the different people in Gwen's life who know her new super hero identity and support her in a certain capacity. And this extra cast is great and well depicted. The book isn't tedious but it doesn't suffer from lack of detail.
As far as super heroes go, Gwen's identity is based upon a great grey shrike which was cool. And, once she harnesses her power, she's pretty bad ass.
Gwen herself is a likable enough character. She's a sweetheart, actually, and I was really rooting for her. But a few things I just wanted to scream at her about, namely her boyfriend. Oi! Her lack of curiosity and tolerance made her seem thick at times. And, then I was frustrated in the climax. I couldn't figure out why Gwen didn't freak out about a person that goes missing. I felt it should've triggered urgency but instead Gwen goes off to do other things first and doesn't even seem to have that missing person in her head. Maybe I read it wrong but, as a reader, I was thinking, "huh"?
The book had a lot to establish and there's a lot going on. As mentioned, there are super hero origins and development and then we have some mystery and m/f romance. The read has a decent amount of violence and gore with some unexpected triggers of disease (alzheimer's and cancer), infertility, death, and loss of child (in a few different ways).
As this takes place in Scotland around an independence referendum, politics, and terrorism, the setting was unique, really well detailed, and topical. The author knew what she was doing there.
I liked the backstory and build up of the entire story. It's an intense read with a lot of suspense. But the last third of the book felt somewhat loose to me like everything was thrown together and then there was that odd lack of urgency I mentioned.
On the whole, I ended up thinking this was a great origins story with an okay plot line that has better yet to come. 3.5 stars
Gwen is an accountant by profession and passive by nature, letting people walk all over her in work and in life. Both her boss and her boyfriend are awful yet she continually tolerates and fears their reproach and abandonment. She's an odd one to be a real life super hero but one event leads to another that gets her there.
I'm not up on many super hero stories but this read is on the darker side in the vein of Batman (or worse). I've read the entire Ayala Storme series by this author and though that story was also dark, the lead's sarcastic wit offered a lot of humor in the narrative, too. In contrast, this does not which made the story bleaker than I expected.
I personally found the book a little slow but each chapter definitely sets the tone and builds the backstory of Gwen's character so we can see how much she changes over time both physically and emotionally. It also introduces and lays down the different people in Gwen's life who know her new super hero identity and support her in a certain capacity. And this extra cast is great and well depicted. The book isn't tedious but it doesn't suffer from lack of detail.
As far as super heroes go, Gwen's identity is based upon a great grey shrike which was cool. And, once she harnesses her power, she's pretty bad ass.
Gwen herself is a likable enough character. She's a sweetheart, actually, and I was really rooting for her. But a few things I just wanted to scream at her about, namely her boyfriend. Oi! Her lack of curiosity and tolerance made her seem thick at times. And, then I was frustrated in the climax. I couldn't figure out why Gwen didn't freak out about a person that goes missing. I felt it should've triggered urgency but instead Gwen goes off to do other things first and doesn't even seem to have that missing person in her head. Maybe I read it wrong but, as a reader, I was thinking, "huh"?
The book had a lot to establish and there's a lot going on. As mentioned, there are super hero origins and development and then we have some mystery and m/f romance. The read has a decent amount of violence and gore with some unexpected triggers of disease (alzheimer's and cancer), infertility, death, and loss of child (in a few different ways).
As this takes place in Scotland around an independence referendum, politics, and terrorism, the setting was unique, really well detailed, and topical. The author knew what she was doing there.
I liked the backstory and build up of the entire story. It's an intense read with a lot of suspense. But the last third of the book felt somewhat loose to me like everything was thrown together and then there was that odd lack of urgency I mentioned.
On the whole, I ended up thinking this was a great origins story with an okay plot line that has better yet to come. 3.5 stars
September 23, 2014
This is a really excellent first novel. It took me a few chapters to get into it, but then it really hit its stride and I was gripped. I love Gwen as a heroine - she's so relatable it almost feels wrong to call her a "superhero", but she is, and she's a great one. I also love that the explanation for her superpowers wasn't just dismissed with a wave of a wand, but had a realistic explanation - with associated side effects, like constantly needing to eat.
I felt like this book could have been a bit longer so that the story had more time and space to develop - I struggled a bit with the villains' motivation, because they seemed bent on being really really evil, almost disproportionate to their cause. I own that I don't have a good understanding of the political situation, so maybe it is serious and dramatic enough to warrant the kind of intrigue that goes on here, but I did battle with their motivation. I think that more background and more development of the villains as characters would have helped to mitigate that.
There were also a few points where I felt another look by an editor could have helped - there were quite a few sentences I had to reread to make sense of - but overall I loved the writing and the use of language. There were a lot of quirky turns of phrase that made me smile or even laugh out loud ("Try not to get dead" as a helpful piece of advice was one of my favourites).
The sexual tension between Gwen and Taog was really convincing and well handled, and I particlarly enjoyed seeing Gwen and Magda's friendship develop. I really hope to see more of that in the next book.
Overall, this was charming, engaging, feminist, and obviously written with a lot of heart (I certainly teared up at the end). I look forward to the sequel!
I felt like this book could have been a bit longer so that the story had more time and space to develop - I struggled a bit with the villains' motivation, because they seemed bent on being really really evil, almost disproportionate to their cause. I own that I don't have a good understanding of the political situation, so maybe it is serious and dramatic enough to warrant the kind of intrigue that goes on here, but I did battle with their motivation. I think that more background and more development of the villains as characters would have helped to mitigate that.
There were also a few points where I felt another look by an editor could have helped - there were quite a few sentences I had to reread to make sense of - but overall I loved the writing and the use of language. There were a lot of quirky turns of phrase that made me smile or even laugh out loud ("Try not to get dead" as a helpful piece of advice was one of my favourites).
The sexual tension between Gwen and Taog was really convincing and well handled, and I particlarly enjoyed seeing Gwen and Magda's friendship develop. I really hope to see more of that in the next book.
Overall, this was charming, engaging, feminist, and obviously written with a lot of heart (I certainly teared up at the end). I look forward to the sequel!
February 11, 2014
This is a great read for anyone who enjoys a solid, action-packed thriller with compelling characters. The Scottish setting adds depth and credibility to this urban fantasy.
A strong effort by author Emmie Mears, the book is just the first of a hopefully long and profitable series. Readers will probably be casting the film version in their minds as they read.
I'm looking forward to Shrike #2.
A strong effort by author Emmie Mears, the book is just the first of a hopefully long and profitable series. Readers will probably be casting the film version in their minds as they read.
I'm looking forward to Shrike #2.
December 31, 2015
I loved this book quite a bit. The debut from Emmie Mears was everything I could have hoped for. Without being spoilery, this was a fantastic trip through the origin of a woman superhero. The main character is flawed in a way that feels true, and by the end you are rooting for her to find her path and win the day. There is a romance element to the story, but it definitely plays second fiddle to the greater love story of a woman discovering herself, which is really my favorite kind of love story these days.
July 14, 2014
A modern superhero epic that hits the spot. Gwen Maule is a fantastic protagonist, and Mears does a great job of creating a realistic plight and a vivid sense of time and place. Brisk pacing and unexpected twists. Overall, a very rewarding read and I'm looking forward to seeing what's next from Gwen Maule.
September 2, 2014
I loved this book. If you like origin stories you'll love this. If you like political intrigue you'll love this. If you love birds you'll probably cry, but it's okay because vengeance will be yours in the end. Seriously. Go out and grab this one.
July 21, 2014
Emmie Mears has a very gentle hand with language, and her first novel, the Masked Songbird, displays her writing skills brilliantly. Timely, with its references to Scotland's referendum debate, the Masked Songbird is peppered with history, politics, and socioeconomic guideposts, yet one needn't be fluent in the topic, as Emmie walks the reader through the fine points. Meanwhile, the story is painted with the brushstrokes of a comic book master, keeping the action moving and the humor and wit offering a one-two punch.
I couldn't put this book down. (So much so that I had to negotiate with myself whether "I have a really awesome book to finish" was a justifying excuse for calling out of work.)
Gwen Maule is such a relatable character, especially for women.
I can't wait for the next installment!
I couldn't put this book down. (So much so that I had to negotiate with myself whether "I have a really awesome book to finish" was a justifying excuse for calling out of work.)
Gwen Maule is such a relatable character, especially for women.
I can't wait for the next installment!
December 28, 2014
I really enjoyed this book. An interesting urban fantasy with elements of a political thriller and a romance. The characters are sharply written and the details of the Scottish setting are vivid. Having the backdrop of the Scottish Independence referendum was very intriguing and informative. The author Emmie Mears writes with a strong voice and a lot of heart. The superhero origians story is well done, not overdone, with realistic effects for a relatable woman. I am looking forward to more in this series.
January 3, 2015
I love good urban fantasy. If it tosses current political events into the mix, that's even better. The Masked Songbird tells the story of how one ordinary accountant becomes extraordinary and helps shape the future of not only her life, but her country. It certainly hits the mark for both urban fantasy and political thriller. I look forward to the next one in the series to follow the continuing adventures of the Shrike.
September 2, 2014
This book was a lot of fun. It's really nice to see a lady hero, and even nicer to see one who's more concerned about kicking ass than she is about getting a boyfriend (for a change). I thought it was gonna be all fun and games but there was actually some pretty heavy stuff in here. I shed a few tears. Marvel should probably get on this...
April 11, 2015
I truly enjoyed this story! Watching Gwen learn to use her powers was great fun. There was one part of the ending that I was a little disappointed in but as a writer myself I think the author ended it how she should have, even though it wasn't necessarily what I wanted as the reader.
November 27, 2016
Emmie Mears is my favourite new urban fantasy discovery for 2016. I devoured her Ayala Storme series and then went looking for more. The Masked Songbird was her debut, but didn’t suffer for it — it has all the hallmarks of her writing, in that it’s action-packed and full of heart.
Despite the blurb, Gwen starts off in a pretty dark place. Yes, she has a boyfriend — but Angus is a manipulative prick one step away from being abusive. Yes, she has a job — but her terrifying boss is clearly a corporate psychopath (and, it turns out, a regular psychopath too) who has it out for her. Gwen’s life is very grey and grim.
That all changes when, in typical superhero-origin style, Gwen ingests an experimental serum hidden in a bottle of soft drink. But not in a “wow, I have powers; I rock now” way. More in a “what the hell is happening” way. She pays a pretty steep price for her powers (I won’t go into details, because spoilers), and gets her ass handed to her at least once because she gets in over her head. Strength does not automatically equal skill, after all.
And, even with her superpowers, it takes Gwen a while to realise she deserves better than what she has, especially with regards to Angus. She suffers from that sadly fairly common delusion that being with a scumbag is better than being single. (Hint: it’s not!) I’m pleased to say that she grows throughout the story and comes to realise she doesn’t need him.
I haven’t read very many true superhero books, though a lot of urban fantasy has the trappings of a superhero story. The Masked Songbird is pure superhero, down to the spandex costume and the crime-fighting. I loved it so much!
I loved watching Gwen’s friendship with her flatmate Magda turn from “friendly acquaintances” into “BFFs”. And Taog (pronounced “took”, apparently — Welsh names do my head in), the kindly and hot next door neighbour, is patient and committed to his beliefs. There is definite tension there, but Gwen resists it, not wanting to cheat on Angus. Hopefully their relationship will develop further in the sequel.
The overarching events that provide the backdrop and the external story relate to the Scottish independence referendum in 2014 (when The Masked Songbird was originally released). The book is set in the lead-up to the vote, and explores the idea of an extremist pro-UK group, Britannia, trying to suppress the “leave” campaign while scaring the public into voting to stay. I did struggle with how truly evil the Britannia members were at times … but I suppose every superhero needs an evil super-villain. (And there’s no doubt that people have gotten violent over this sort of thing in the past … though not usually without religion being a factor too.)
I’ve already bought the sequel and can’t wait to get stuck into it. I highly recommend this one.
Despite the blurb, Gwen starts off in a pretty dark place. Yes, she has a boyfriend — but Angus is a manipulative prick one step away from being abusive. Yes, she has a job — but her terrifying boss is clearly a corporate psychopath (and, it turns out, a regular psychopath too) who has it out for her. Gwen’s life is very grey and grim.
That all changes when, in typical superhero-origin style, Gwen ingests an experimental serum hidden in a bottle of soft drink. But not in a “wow, I have powers; I rock now” way. More in a “what the hell is happening” way. She pays a pretty steep price for her powers (I won’t go into details, because spoilers), and gets her ass handed to her at least once because she gets in over her head. Strength does not automatically equal skill, after all.
And, even with her superpowers, it takes Gwen a while to realise she deserves better than what she has, especially with regards to Angus. She suffers from that sadly fairly common delusion that being with a scumbag is better than being single. (Hint: it’s not!) I’m pleased to say that she grows throughout the story and comes to realise she doesn’t need him.
I haven’t read very many true superhero books, though a lot of urban fantasy has the trappings of a superhero story. The Masked Songbird is pure superhero, down to the spandex costume and the crime-fighting. I loved it so much!
I loved watching Gwen’s friendship with her flatmate Magda turn from “friendly acquaintances” into “BFFs”. And Taog (pronounced “took”, apparently — Welsh names do my head in), the kindly and hot next door neighbour, is patient and committed to his beliefs. There is definite tension there, but Gwen resists it, not wanting to cheat on Angus. Hopefully their relationship will develop further in the sequel.
The overarching events that provide the backdrop and the external story relate to the Scottish independence referendum in 2014 (when The Masked Songbird was originally released). The book is set in the lead-up to the vote, and explores the idea of an extremist pro-UK group, Britannia, trying to suppress the “leave” campaign while scaring the public into voting to stay. I did struggle with how truly evil the Britannia members were at times … but I suppose every superhero needs an evil super-villain. (And there’s no doubt that people have gotten violent over this sort of thing in the past … though not usually without religion being a factor too.)
I’ve already bought the sequel and can’t wait to get stuck into it. I highly recommend this one.
January 21, 2021
An unexpected book, can't remember where I picked it up but enjoyed the ride even though it was a bit grim.
The m/c is likeable and believable with a decent supporting cast, I especially liked her Polish friend and house sharer Magda.
The story, with the Scottish independence referendum background is good, even if a little weak in places (which keeps it below my 5 star threshold) and the pages keep turning nicely.
Don't know enough about Scottish Independence to make an intelligent comment but as the author lives in Glasgow I guess it must be fairly true to life but last time I looked Scotland was still part of the UK so I suspect there is an element of wishful thinking in the same way certain folks here would like secession from our Union.
If I come across the next in the series I will read it - no real hurry though
The m/c is likeable and believable with a decent supporting cast, I especially liked her Polish friend and house sharer Magda.
The story, with the Scottish independence referendum background is good, even if a little weak in places (which keeps it below my 5 star threshold) and the pages keep turning nicely.
Don't know enough about Scottish Independence to make an intelligent comment but as the author lives in Glasgow I guess it must be fairly true to life but last time I looked Scotland was still part of the UK so I suspect there is an element of wishful thinking in the same way certain folks here would like secession from our Union.
If I come across the next in the series I will read it - no real hurry though
June 5, 2018
Devoured this in one night, when I'd meant to go to bed early. This captured me from the start, between the brilliant voice and the humor shining through all the tense moments. I'll admit, I save this author for when I'm in a book rut or when I keep bouncing off books because I'm not getting into them, because I know they'll always pull me in.
August 30, 2017
Brilliant superhero story, even better personal story
One of the best superhero(ine) novels I've ever read, and it comes down to the author's absolutely brilliant method of capturing personal moments and crafting believable and wonderful characters.
One of the best superhero(ine) novels I've ever read, and it comes down to the author's absolutely brilliant method of capturing personal moments and crafting believable and wonderful characters.
April 4, 2019
Very enjoyable!! Strong writing, good story, interesting characters, compelling political backdrop.
Now I just have to figure out how to get books 2 and 3...
Now I just have to figure out how to get books 2 and 3...
September 11, 2014
This book came on my radar after it was mentioned by a couple of high-profile book blogs. Set in Edinburgh in the run-up to the Independence Referendum, we follow the adventures of accountant Gwen and her transformation into something of a Superwoman. As a Scot who enjoys fantasy/UF, it sounded worth a look.
Overall, I enjoyed the book but with a few minor niggles. The author has a very engaging style of writing and the plot moves along at a rapid pace. I liked Gwen's character and found myself smirking a few times at some of her thoughts and comments. I also loved the idea of using the Scottish independence referendum as a plot driver. This naturally appeals to me as someone directly affected, but I think it would work well for readers with no vested interest too. Whilst the tone is mostly light-hearted, there were a couple of emotionally affecting scenes that drew sympathy and helped to bring Gwen to life.
However, I do have a few complaints.
This is a 'superhero' style of story, and characters in this genre often aren't especially nuanced (at least, this is my understanding) but this style of characterisation doesn't work well for me. I felt that Gwen was reasonably well-developed, but I can't say the same for the main antagonist. I didn't find her credible at all. Even learning of her motivations wasn't enough to dispel the feel of an Evil Baddie straight from central casting. I also couldn't get on board with Gwen's 'Batwoman' costume. Probably if you read a lot of comic books you'll take this in your stride, but I was rolling my eyes. It didn't feel 'in character' to me.
Another niggle I have is an issue that comes up a lot when authors set books in a different country. Emmie Mears is an American, though I understand she lived in Scotland for a while, and she captures some elements of Scottish language very well. She also slips up several times. When I read that Gwen walked 'six blocks', the narrative screeches to a halt. We don't talk about distances or geography in those terms in the UK. Nor do we have 'candy wrappers'. (If you want to use the vernacular, I'd suggest 'sweetie papers'). And unless Gwen has the wealth of Montgomery Burns, she's not fitting an office folder into her 'purse'. She might fit it into her handbag. I think these Americanisms were particularly jarring because Ms. Mears uses Scottish slang so very effectively elsewhere. However, I give her 10/10 for describing characters as 'blootered' LMAO!
I have one more grumble to make about a non-native author. This is serious nitpicking, so feel free to skip the next paragraph if you aren't interested in a geographical rant. However, it's such a bizarre error. Even if you knew nothing about Scotland, five minutes research on Google Maps would have put you right.
Very minor spoiler ahead ... at one point in the book, Gwen leaves Edinburgh to drive to her parents' house in Sutherland. (For the geographically challenged, Sutherland is a region in the very north of mainland Scotland.) From references in the book, the parents appear to live in the western part of Sutherland, north of Ullapool, probably near Loch Assynt. Gwen drives north towards Inverness, then for some inexplicable reason, she heads back down along Loch Ness towards Fort William. Um, why? There's a perfectly good road right there in Inverness that'll take you all the way north to Ullapool. Why on earth would you drive south? The Highlands are sparsely populated and there simply aren't all that many roads, so whilst I think you can probably drive from Fort William to Ullapool without, you know, going back the way you just came, it's adding about 150 miles of minor roads to your journey. Gwen isn't sight-seeing. She's driving at night in a hurry, so why on earth would she head down Loch Ness? Was it just the case that the author wanted to namecheck the famous Loch? It makes no sense.
But enough rambling. Despite my niggles, it's a fun book if you're in the right mood. I enjoyed the last few pages especially, with the descriptions of Edinburgh on referendum day, and the sense of a country poised on the brink. I was going to give the book 3.5 stars, but I'll round it up to four for eloquently capturing that sense of the unknown and of hope. Cheers for that!
Overall, I enjoyed the book but with a few minor niggles. The author has a very engaging style of writing and the plot moves along at a rapid pace. I liked Gwen's character and found myself smirking a few times at some of her thoughts and comments. I also loved the idea of using the Scottish independence referendum as a plot driver. This naturally appeals to me as someone directly affected, but I think it would work well for readers with no vested interest too. Whilst the tone is mostly light-hearted, there were a couple of emotionally affecting scenes that drew sympathy and helped to bring Gwen to life.
However, I do have a few complaints.
This is a 'superhero' style of story, and characters in this genre often aren't especially nuanced (at least, this is my understanding) but this style of characterisation doesn't work well for me. I felt that Gwen was reasonably well-developed, but I can't say the same for the main antagonist. I didn't find her credible at all. Even learning of her motivations wasn't enough to dispel the feel of an Evil Baddie straight from central casting. I also couldn't get on board with Gwen's 'Batwoman' costume. Probably if you read a lot of comic books you'll take this in your stride, but I was rolling my eyes. It didn't feel 'in character' to me.
Another niggle I have is an issue that comes up a lot when authors set books in a different country. Emmie Mears is an American, though I understand she lived in Scotland for a while, and she captures some elements of Scottish language very well. She also slips up several times. When I read that Gwen walked 'six blocks', the narrative screeches to a halt. We don't talk about distances or geography in those terms in the UK. Nor do we have 'candy wrappers'. (If you want to use the vernacular, I'd suggest 'sweetie papers'). And unless Gwen has the wealth of Montgomery Burns, she's not fitting an office folder into her 'purse'. She might fit it into her handbag. I think these Americanisms were particularly jarring because Ms. Mears uses Scottish slang so very effectively elsewhere. However, I give her 10/10 for describing characters as 'blootered' LMAO!
I have one more grumble to make about a non-native author. This is serious nitpicking, so feel free to skip the next paragraph if you aren't interested in a geographical rant. However, it's such a bizarre error. Even if you knew nothing about Scotland, five minutes research on Google Maps would have put you right.
Very minor spoiler ahead ... at one point in the book, Gwen leaves Edinburgh to drive to her parents' house in Sutherland. (For the geographically challenged, Sutherland is a region in the very north of mainland Scotland.) From references in the book, the parents appear to live in the western part of Sutherland, north of Ullapool, probably near Loch Assynt. Gwen drives north towards Inverness, then for some inexplicable reason, she heads back down along Loch Ness towards Fort William. Um, why? There's a perfectly good road right there in Inverness that'll take you all the way north to Ullapool. Why on earth would you drive south? The Highlands are sparsely populated and there simply aren't all that many roads, so whilst I think you can probably drive from Fort William to Ullapool without, you know, going back the way you just came, it's adding about 150 miles of minor roads to your journey. Gwen isn't sight-seeing. She's driving at night in a hurry, so why on earth would she head down Loch Ness? Was it just the case that the author wanted to namecheck the famous Loch? It makes no sense.
But enough rambling. Despite my niggles, it's a fun book if you're in the right mood. I enjoyed the last few pages especially, with the descriptions of Edinburgh on referendum day, and the sense of a country poised on the brink. I was going to give the book 3.5 stars, but I'll round it up to four for eloquently capturing that sense of the unknown and of hope. Cheers for that!
November 3, 2014
I adored this book.
The voice. This voice is everything I want from first person. Gwen is fun to hang around with, and you never quite know what she’ll do next–which is why it’s totally believable that she’d suck down an open beverage when she finds herself in desperate need of one (no spoilers here!).
The story is rigorously true to its own internal logic, and to Gwen’s character. I know her well, so I believe in her choices. She may be hapless from the beginning, as the blurb tells us, but it’s clear she’s tough even before she can leap onto rooftops. She’s good at her job, yet she’s stuck with an evil boss. She’s bad at budgeting, but she doesn’t “solve” the problem by throwing expensive meals/shoes/etc. on credit cards (or hell, even affordable ones–the woman is barely surviving). She has flaws, interesting flaws that directly effect the direction of the novel. She’s also competent enough before she gets her super strength that I believe in her ass-kicking abilities when she does find she has powers–and in the loyalty and kindness that drive her to use them. It’s beautifully done.
The supporting characters are also intriguing. Gwen’s evil boss makes all other evil bosses look like kittens. Her neighbor is a-dor-a-ble. Her flatmate is charming. And her boyfriend…yeah, I think I dated him once. Even those who appear only briefly are memorable and nuanced, which I love–layers and secrets keep me guessing all the way through.
This book strikes a beautiful balance between a fun origin story and a serious contemplation of the price involved in becoming a hero. That choice fascinates me, as do the consequences. I think about it more than I should, probably. I love superheroes. I wrote a novel about superheroes. It’s nothing like this book, but my point is that I was proudly biased when I started reading The Masked Songbird, and I wasn’t disappointed. I was thrilled to see a female superhero who faces these choices and the sacrifices that come with them, who rises to the occasion just like Cap and Spider Man–but (I’m itching to tell you more, but I won’t) brings her own unique spin to the story, too.
What surprised me the most about this novel was its depth of heart. It’s clear from page one that it’s going to be a fun read, but woe betide you if you go in expecting Emmie Mears to pull any punches. She raises the stakes throughout the novel, and she delivers. There’s a line in the climax that hit me so hard I had to put my e-reader down for a few minutes to catch my breath. It’s a moment that could be cheesy, but Ms. Mears pulls it off without sugary sentiment.
Is it too soon to ask for a Gwen Maule TV series? In the vein of Arrow? I’d love that. More importantly though, there’s a sequel on the way–which means lots more quality time with Gwen!
*review originally posted on my blog
The voice. This voice is everything I want from first person. Gwen is fun to hang around with, and you never quite know what she’ll do next–which is why it’s totally believable that she’d suck down an open beverage when she finds herself in desperate need of one (no spoilers here!).
The story is rigorously true to its own internal logic, and to Gwen’s character. I know her well, so I believe in her choices. She may be hapless from the beginning, as the blurb tells us, but it’s clear she’s tough even before she can leap onto rooftops. She’s good at her job, yet she’s stuck with an evil boss. She’s bad at budgeting, but she doesn’t “solve” the problem by throwing expensive meals/shoes/etc. on credit cards (or hell, even affordable ones–the woman is barely surviving). She has flaws, interesting flaws that directly effect the direction of the novel. She’s also competent enough before she gets her super strength that I believe in her ass-kicking abilities when she does find she has powers–and in the loyalty and kindness that drive her to use them. It’s beautifully done.
The supporting characters are also intriguing. Gwen’s evil boss makes all other evil bosses look like kittens. Her neighbor is a-dor-a-ble. Her flatmate is charming. And her boyfriend…yeah, I think I dated him once. Even those who appear only briefly are memorable and nuanced, which I love–layers and secrets keep me guessing all the way through.
This book strikes a beautiful balance between a fun origin story and a serious contemplation of the price involved in becoming a hero. That choice fascinates me, as do the consequences. I think about it more than I should, probably. I love superheroes. I wrote a novel about superheroes. It’s nothing like this book, but my point is that I was proudly biased when I started reading The Masked Songbird, and I wasn’t disappointed. I was thrilled to see a female superhero who faces these choices and the sacrifices that come with them, who rises to the occasion just like Cap and Spider Man–but (I’m itching to tell you more, but I won’t) brings her own unique spin to the story, too.
What surprised me the most about this novel was its depth of heart. It’s clear from page one that it’s going to be a fun read, but woe betide you if you go in expecting Emmie Mears to pull any punches. She raises the stakes throughout the novel, and she delivers. There’s a line in the climax that hit me so hard I had to put my e-reader down for a few minutes to catch my breath. It’s a moment that could be cheesy, but Ms. Mears pulls it off without sugary sentiment.
Is it too soon to ask for a Gwen Maule TV series? In the vein of Arrow? I’d love that. More importantly though, there’s a sequel on the way–which means lots more quality time with Gwen!
*review originally posted on my blog
August 5, 2014
3.5 stars overall - Though most of the stories are on the lite side and could have benefited from just a few more pages to give them a bit more heft, there is a nice variety to this collection with a time travel romance, a super hero origin story in addition to the advertised paranormal romance and urban fantasy.
Reap & Redeem Lisa Medley - Supporting character Kylen had a promising setup up here - especially since that fact that he is going to lose another woman that he loves is a heartstring 'tugger' - but this story was pretty ambitious for the space. There is a lot going on in the background for the larger series arc and the transition in the romance - which is the key to making a short story romance work for me - is just too abrupt to 'sell' me. I am really interested in the next up leading man but I wish that the setup for the conflict for the next leading lady had been different. Overall this ended up be more on the okay side
The Masked Songbird Emmie Mears - I enjoyed this super hero story which only had the promise of romance - super heroes are a nice change of pace - this story was more on the rambling side though that didn't really bother me. Pretty good.
Protective Ink - Misty Simon - I liked this follow on to Wicked Ink - I liked leading lady magical tattoo artist Lissa a lot and seeing more of Jackson - who was the handler of the super hero leading man in the previous story. I liked that Jackson got his own super power and the fact that Lissa and Jackson are long time friends who have always have had secret feelings for each other makes the romance work in the small space. This was my favorite of the stories.
Mine Tomorrow - Jackie Braun - Ultimately this ends up with a Somewhere in Time vibe - but with a better HEA - I liked it even though it was short. I like the time period and that the leade met at a recognizable 'major' historical event is pretty neat.
Reap & Redeem Lisa Medley - Supporting character Kylen had a promising setup up here - especially since that fact that he is going to lose another woman that he loves is a heartstring 'tugger' - but this story was pretty ambitious for the space. There is a lot going on in the background for the larger series arc and the transition in the romance - which is the key to making a short story romance work for me - is just too abrupt to 'sell' me. I am really interested in the next up leading man but I wish that the setup for the conflict for the next leading lady had been different. Overall this ended up be more on the okay side
The Masked Songbird Emmie Mears - I enjoyed this super hero story which only had the promise of romance - super heroes are a nice change of pace - this story was more on the rambling side though that didn't really bother me. Pretty good.
Protective Ink - Misty Simon - I liked this follow on to Wicked Ink - I liked leading lady magical tattoo artist Lissa a lot and seeing more of Jackson - who was the handler of the super hero leading man in the previous story. I liked that Jackson got his own super power and the fact that Lissa and Jackson are long time friends who have always have had secret feelings for each other makes the romance work in the small space. This was my favorite of the stories.
Mine Tomorrow - Jackie Braun - Ultimately this ends up with a Somewhere in Time vibe - but with a better HEA - I liked it even though it was short. I like the time period and that the leade met at a recognizable 'major' historical event is pretty neat.
September 14, 2014
This was a really good book. It wasn't just about a girl becoming a superhero accidentally. It also involved friendship, romance, and self-discovery. There was action, suspense, and drama. I never got bored while reading, and in the end, I found it quite unputdownable.
Gwen was an interesting main character. She wasn't immediately likable, since she started out the story with no backbone. She let both her boss and boyfriend walk all over her. However, that all began to change. Over the course of the novel, she began to get stronger, both physically and mentally. She started finding herself, and learning about her own opinions and feelings, as well as her own self-worth. In the end, I thought Gwen was an awesome, compassionate heroine, and I can't wait to read more about her.
The side characters in this book were quite well-done. There was Angus, Gwen's boyfriend at the start of the novel. I hated him, and couldn't wait for Gwen to realize how badly he was treating her. Then, there was Gwen's roommate and friend, Magda. I loved how she and Gwen grew closer over time, and how easily Magda took to helping Gwen out with things. Next, there was Taog, Gwen's neighbor who was a political activist. I really liked him. He was an artist, who was pretty up-front about his feelings. It was great. Finally, there was Gwen's boss, who was pretty horrible. However, I appreciated the fact that the author gave her a solid motive.
The plot of this book was great. It followed Gwen as she accidentally became a superhero. I loved that when this happened, it came with some side effects, such as her needing to constantly eat. Then, Gwen had to figure out what exactly her boss was up to, and what it had to do with Scotland's political situation. It also involved Gwen discovering herself, and learning to speak for herself. I found the action, romance, and suspense pretty thrilling.
Overall, I really liked this book. The heroine was ultimately very relatable and likable, and the side characters were mostly well-developed. The pace was pretty quick too. Therefore, I'd definitely recommend this book if you're looking for a read about a superhero that's just a bit different.
Gwen was an interesting main character. She wasn't immediately likable, since she started out the story with no backbone. She let both her boss and boyfriend walk all over her. However, that all began to change. Over the course of the novel, she began to get stronger, both physically and mentally. She started finding herself, and learning about her own opinions and feelings, as well as her own self-worth. In the end, I thought Gwen was an awesome, compassionate heroine, and I can't wait to read more about her.
The side characters in this book were quite well-done. There was Angus, Gwen's boyfriend at the start of the novel. I hated him, and couldn't wait for Gwen to realize how badly he was treating her. Then, there was Gwen's roommate and friend, Magda. I loved how she and Gwen grew closer over time, and how easily Magda took to helping Gwen out with things. Next, there was Taog, Gwen's neighbor who was a political activist. I really liked him. He was an artist, who was pretty up-front about his feelings. It was great. Finally, there was Gwen's boss, who was pretty horrible. However, I appreciated the fact that the author gave her a solid motive.
The plot of this book was great. It followed Gwen as she accidentally became a superhero. I loved that when this happened, it came with some side effects, such as her needing to constantly eat. Then, Gwen had to figure out what exactly her boss was up to, and what it had to do with Scotland's political situation. It also involved Gwen discovering herself, and learning to speak for herself. I found the action, romance, and suspense pretty thrilling.
Overall, I really liked this book. The heroine was ultimately very relatable and likable, and the side characters were mostly well-developed. The pace was pretty quick too. Therefore, I'd definitely recommend this book if you're looking for a read about a superhero that's just a bit different.
February 10, 2015
I greatly enjoyed the first adventures of Gwen Maule, aka The Shrike, in Emmie Mears's The Masked Songbird. I like my heroines strong yet believably human, and that is what Gwen is, with her lousy accounting job she can't afford to quit, her scummy boyfriend she can't quite bring herself to dump, and the parents she hasn't visited in two years because she can't face watching her mother waste away with dementia. I liked the fact that even when she gets superpowers, she still needs other people, like the roommate who sews her costumes and the trainer who teaches her to fight, because having super-strength doesn't mean you know anything about martial arts... a point often overlooked in tales of this sort, along with the possible downsides of superpowers for a woman's body and various gritty physical discomforts that Mears describes vividly.
Now as to my critiques, cards on the table, I am not a supporter of Scottish independence, a crucial plot point in this novel. The reasons for my views aren't important here (and certainly aren't due to any dislike for the glorious land and people of Scotland). I was more than willing to root for a free Alba and to believe the worst of the Unionists for the sake of the story (and after all, the terrorist Orangemen in Northern Ireland certainly showed that supporters of Great Britain aren't necessarily civilized). But the bad guys in this novel behave in a way that isn't just one-dimensionally evil, it's also unbelievably stupid for people whose aim is for Scotland to remain part of the United Kingdom. The Shrike deserves fully fleshed-out villains to fight in her next adventure, which I for one am looking forward to.
This review is cross-posted on my blog, martianperspective.blogspot.com.
Now as to my critiques, cards on the table, I am not a supporter of Scottish independence, a crucial plot point in this novel. The reasons for my views aren't important here (and certainly aren't due to any dislike for the glorious land and people of Scotland). I was more than willing to root for a free Alba and to believe the worst of the Unionists for the sake of the story (and after all, the terrorist Orangemen in Northern Ireland certainly showed that supporters of Great Britain aren't necessarily civilized). But the bad guys in this novel behave in a way that isn't just one-dimensionally evil, it's also unbelievably stupid for people whose aim is for Scotland to remain part of the United Kingdom. The Shrike deserves fully fleshed-out villains to fight in her next adventure, which I for one am looking forward to.
This review is cross-posted on my blog, martianperspective.blogspot.com.
November 6, 2014
I read this in a couple of hours. I have mixed feelings about it. So I'll just type up my impressions.
1) This is a really unusual HQ, I've never read one like it. It's more SF with a hint of romance, but there's no central romance. This is neither positive or negative to me.
2) The negatives heaped on the heroine to (IMO) stress the changes in her later were to my mind unrealistic and overblown. And I saw some but not much reaction from her. She seemed rather removed from all of it, including the deaths she caused (and by that I mean those she killed). It may have been an intended side effect of her change, but it was distasteful.
3) Still, it was cathartic watching her gain strength and confidence and making changes in her life.
4) Cardboard villains, for the most part.
5) Massive political statements about Scottish independence. I guess it's a moot point now. But it's a major part of the novel and presses for a certain POV, and gets a little preachy toward the end. Still, it's told in close third person so it could be argued that this is the heroine who needs to feel validated after what happens to her in the story.
6) For all that irked me, this was a much more complex story than I'm used to getting from HQ, and a female -centric one at that with a woman who stands on her own. I'm just not sure that I admire all that she'd done to get there. On the other hand, I'm not sure that I am supposed to. B+
1) This is a really unusual HQ, I've never read one like it. It's more SF with a hint of romance, but there's no central romance. This is neither positive or negative to me.
2) The negatives heaped on the heroine to (IMO) stress the changes in her later were to my mind unrealistic and overblown. And I saw some but not much reaction from her. She seemed rather removed from all of it, including the deaths she caused (and by that I mean those she killed). It may have been an intended side effect of her change, but it was distasteful.
3) Still, it was cathartic watching her gain strength and confidence and making changes in her life.
4) Cardboard villains, for the most part.
5) Massive political statements about Scottish independence. I guess it's a moot point now. But it's a major part of the novel and presses for a certain POV, and gets a little preachy toward the end. Still, it's told in close third person so it could be argued that this is the heroine who needs to feel validated after what happens to her in the story.
6) For all that irked me, this was a much more complex story than I'm used to getting from HQ, and a female -centric one at that with a woman who stands on her own. I'm just not sure that I admire all that she'd done to get there. On the other hand, I'm not sure that I am supposed to. B+
February 21, 2016
This book has everything you can dream up for the genre: super heroes (or heroines, as the case may be), mysteries, science experiments gone awry, Scottish accents, silly banter, costumes, fight scenes, political intrigue, love, loss and plenty more.
I was caught up in the fast pace of the book; feeling with the characters and trying desperately to solve the mysteries. Many of the issues are very serious, but they are often approached in a lighthearted way. This does not diminish the issues, only forces one to see things differently.
I love how Gwen’s daily life and routine is detailed. Time is very consciously measured, as are meals. Readers get to experience how the serum affects her in more than just unattainable ways such as strength and speed. We get to join her in her hunger as her metabolism is kicked into overdrive. We get to understand the discomforts and unpleasantness as well as the awe of new “powers”.
The minor characters are also well fleshed out. We come to care for them as much as for the Gwen. And we certainly come to hate the antagonists.
I finished this book (the second time) on the day the Scottish referendum for Independence was being voted upon. It just sort of happened that way.
I eagerly await joining Gwen in the future installments of the Scottish Songbird.
I was caught up in the fast pace of the book; feeling with the characters and trying desperately to solve the mysteries. Many of the issues are very serious, but they are often approached in a lighthearted way. This does not diminish the issues, only forces one to see things differently.
I love how Gwen’s daily life and routine is detailed. Time is very consciously measured, as are meals. Readers get to experience how the serum affects her in more than just unattainable ways such as strength and speed. We get to join her in her hunger as her metabolism is kicked into overdrive. We get to understand the discomforts and unpleasantness as well as the awe of new “powers”.
The minor characters are also well fleshed out. We come to care for them as much as for the Gwen. And we certainly come to hate the antagonists.
I finished this book (the second time) on the day the Scottish referendum for Independence was being voted upon. It just sort of happened that way.
I eagerly await joining Gwen in the future installments of the Scottish Songbird.
September 1, 2015
This was 100% fun. I'm a sucker for superhero fiction. Slap some masks and some superpowers onto a book and I will read it, no questions asked. So when a friend recommended this to me, I knew I had to pick it up.
Was this the best superhero book ever? Nope. Did I love every second of it? YOU BET.
This was so much fun. The characters were likeable, the plot moved along at a fast clip, and it was at the perfect level of cheesiness. The ending was a good and satisfying, though not perfectly happy.
I really hope to see a book two sometime in the near future.
Was this the best superhero book ever? Nope. Did I love every second of it? YOU BET.
This was so much fun. The characters were likeable, the plot moved along at a fast clip, and it was at the perfect level of cheesiness. The ending was a good and satisfying, though not perfectly happy.
I really hope to see a book two sometime in the near future.
November 26, 2014
Definitely a fun story and a great addition to the swelling ranks of unique and somewhat unconventional superheroes. But what really stood out for me as an American reader was the refreshing voice of a Scottish writer, her characters and the location. It makes a wonderful change of pace to read something that doesn't happen to New Yorkers, Angelenos or Londoners.
June 8, 2015
the answer is Yes. Read this book.
Well written, thought provoking. Uncomfortable at times and then triumphant. Fantastical as well. I found myself reading until the wee hours without noticing, it's been a long time since that happened. I will definitely be reading the next installment. Thanks for writing, Emmie Mears. Please continue.
Well written, thought provoking. Uncomfortable at times and then triumphant. Fantastical as well. I found myself reading until the wee hours without noticing, it's been a long time since that happened. I will definitely be reading the next installment. Thanks for writing, Emmie Mears. Please continue.
January 18, 2015
It's obvious that Emmie has spent some time in Scotland. The world felt vivid and the characters' voices brought it to life.
A lot more blood than I was expecting. But Gwennie kicks some serious arse, and it is awesome!
Great debut, Emmie!
A lot more blood than I was expecting. But Gwennie kicks some serious arse, and it is awesome!
Great debut, Emmie!
August 20, 2016
THE MASKED SONGBIRD by Emmie Mears is a fantastic read that sweeps you into Gwen Maule's world from the very first page and keeps you invested through the very last page. Strong writing, diverse and beautifully voiced cast, and a blast to read.
January 1, 2015
I really enjoyed the urban fantasy set against the backdrop of the recent Scottish referendum. n interesting choice, but i love the interplay of both Scotland and the protagonist trying t figure out their own future together.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 35 reviews