Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Love Like Drowning: An MM dark horror romance

Rate this book
An obsession with his captor means there’s no need for escape–he’s already home.

The worst thing Gregory’s ever done is have the audacity to hope that he can be forgiven.

The second worst thing is murder.

He never wanted to. He had to. People just won’t leave him alone.

It doesn’t matter–cold stares and colder shoulders were all he ever knew long before there were any bodies buried in the ground.

Meeting the magnetic son of a billionaire by chance one night abruptly tears down the walls of the safe, isolated life Gregory built for himself.

Sinclair is charismatic, affable and inexplicably full of sunshine at two in the morning.

He accosts Gregory when he should have crossed the street to avoid him.

He flirts relentlessly instead of recoiling in disgust.

Gregory’s never had a friend before, let alone a boyfriend but Sinclair is hell-bent on peeling open Gregory’s shell.

Gregory’s afraid he might do something impulsive.

Something life-altering and reckless.

Something like text Sinclair back.

That is, if he can get back to his cabin and bury the dead body in the trunk of his car first.

Sinclair, meanwhile, is on the hunt for the latest victim to tie up in his basement–and he’s just found the perfect one, the kind he adores most of all: an isolated, anxious, lonely man who no one will possibly miss.

Gregory is strange and jumpy and flustered dizzy by the slightest attention–he’ll cry just right when Sinclair finally flashes his knife.

Sinclair only has two rules:
Don’t sleep with the victims.
Don’t let them live.

There's just one problem: Sinclair might like his new plaything a little too much. Enough to break every rule he's ever made for himself.

…And he has no idea Gregory has a body count of his own.

In the whirlwind of their mutual obsession, killing each other is easy–but keeping each other is hard.

Features:
🫀Instant mutual obsession + slow burn relationship development
🫀Kidnapping (captor x captive)
🫀He falls harder
🫀Morally Black & Gray characters
🫀Exploration of mental health and past trauma
🫀LONG length (773 pages)
🫀Slice-of-life elements
🫀Unreliable narrator
🫀Dark comedy elements

[Love Like Drowning is an MM dark, serial killer x serial killer horror romance with high heat, heavy horror themes and even heavier romance. The gore and violence is extreme and romanticized. Psychological and physical torture occurs between the main couple. Trauma will be had, limbs will be amputated, and domestic bliss WILL ensue. Happily ever after is guaranteed (for better or worse). An extensive list of content warnings can be found at the back of the book.]

814 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 3, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Carson Wulff

5 books49 followers

• About:
A non-binary, neurodivergent, queer, independent author with a love for m/m dark romance (emphasis on the romance).

I'm passionate about mental health advocacy and enjoy exploring neurodivergence through the funhouse mirror of fiction and horror.

• Newsletter:
To be the first to hear about new releases, sign up for my newsletter here:
https://buttondown.com/wulff

•Patreon:
https://patreon.com/ngbri

Readers always have my permission for creating fanworks. Please show me!

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
106 (62%)
4 stars
34 (20%)
3 stars
21 (12%)
2 stars
6 (3%)
1 star
2 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
Profile Image for paracosmere.
554 reviews7 followers
June 30, 2026
4.5 stars!

Wow. The author just didn't do this half-assed, did they? They just didn't mince words, did they? And oh man was I glad. Gotta respect how they did not hold back on the gore, the torture, the mental dilemma. MCs' actions were unfiltered and clearly intentional, given they have their own reasons.

Almost 800 pages and it just flew by.

The MCs' terrible behaviors weren't disguised with good intentions, not veiled with placating reasons.

Julian Sinclair was pure evil and totally sadistic. Even after getting together with Gregory. He did not mellow down at all even in love.

And I must say Gregory shared the same inclination, albeit in a slightly different vein. When he puts his mind into it, nothing could ever stop him.

It was mind-stirring to show their obsession and lbr, insanity, in such a romantic lens. I've awed and cooed while they're both covered in blood like WTF this what they're doing to me lmaooo

I wouldn't call it communication but Julian and Gregory have always been honest. About their desire to hurt, to possess, to protect, to live. Such visceral emotions hadn't been written as beautifully as they had in this book. They're both sick and twisted and in love.

And what a way for Gregory to get welcomed to the family I almost choked up from laughing. And oh Gregory, that final act of love for Julian at the end. I was not expecting that at all, I was hysterical until everything's over!

This was narrated via Gregory's POV all throughout. I think it would've been really interesting to see what's on Julian's mind as well. But it is what is, and this was still super good. Plus points that it's in a third-person PV.

All in all, never a dull chapter. I was always on my toes. I was always waiting for another shoe to drop. Like surely, right? But there's an odd beauty to a story like this and I just don't know how to explain it.

I'm sure I still have a lot more to say but long story short, I enjoyed everything in it.
Profile Image for Rae.
396 reviews11 followers
June 25, 2026
All I can say is…Wow! I think this is the most unique, fucked up, and awesome thing I’ve ever read 🤣 This is NOT a traditional romance, or a traditional relationship. I don’t know if I even like Sinclair OR Gregory, but I also kind of do…? Their ending made me all swoony🤣🤣
If you’re not squeamish, and you like DARK romance, just read it!

This book is a chonky boi, and for a minute it felt a little slow in the middle, but then when you get closer to the end you realize that the lull is necessary to really make that ending hit home…this is full of surprises, and twists, and mutual obsession and possession on a whole new level!

Spice: Yes
HEA: Yes
3rd Act Breakup: I wouldn’t call it that 🤣
Trauma: Yes 😂
Profile Image for Jen.
111 reviews23 followers
October 13, 2026
This book made me feel unsettled, unsteady, and even uncomfortable.... Despite that, and even more likely because of it, I thought this was absolutely incredible! From the very beginning, I really identified with Gregory. He's an introvert, a hermit, and has such extreme social anxiety. He's so grumpy and lonely, and just so precious. No wonder Sinclair can't resist taking care of him...

Despite the initial impression, Sinclair can be hard to like at times. He's sadistic, capricious, and cruel, but he cares deeply for those that are dear to him. It's painful to see Gregory suffer until he becomes one of those people to Sinclair, but it's so beautiful how they come to love and understand each other.

As much as I ended up absolutely adoring this book though, I caution anyone interested in reading it to be aware of what they're getting into. This was the most graphically violent and gruesome book I've ever read. There is blood, torture, and sometimes incomprehensible cruelty between the MC's. It all gets better and makes sense in the end, if you can wrap your head around it, but some scenes can be hard to read even for the most open-minded people.

It's a long book, with instant lust, but a very slow burn until they truly love and trust each other. There's proper spice, and it can be pretty hot, but there's not a lot of it for how long the book is. It was so intense though, and I will be remembering this for a long time. I highly recommend it to anyone that thinks they can handle it, and I really hope that this author writes more books! 😍😍😍
Profile Image for Brittany Michaele.
136 reviews1 follower
June 14, 2026
Sometimes love hurts

Wow...I devoured this book. Couldn't put it down! These two are CRAZY.
Gregory is a loner, a weirdo but honeslty I get him. Sinclair is a true extrovert which may be scarier than his other preferences. Together...
Well there's someone out there for everyone right?
Mind the trigger warnings and get ready for a bloody good time
14 reviews
June 4, 2026
I cannot understate how much I adore this book. It has everything that I want in a dark romance. It is hysterically funny, deeply emotional, satisfyingly intricate and delightfully terrifying. I laughed, cried, giggled and yelled my way through this book.

Gregory is an incredible protagonist. He had me yelling at him like he could hear me because boy your priorities!! I know Sinclair is the man of your dreams and all because he's a person who looks at you, but you are still in danger!! This is not the time to be thinking about how hot your boyfriend is!!! Except that it totally is and I love Gregory for how much heart and how little self preservation he has.

Sinclair is… breathtaking. I agree with everything Gregory has to say about him. He's perfect and I am not exaggerating when I say I laugh at every single line of his. He's a serial killer who loves people and loves killing people and there's just something cool about a guy who's found his calling in life and is utterly satisfied with it.

So they're both great characters separately but then you get them together and something really wild and amazing happens. Sparks fly, people get shoved into barrels of water, kisses get sloppy, amputations happen, people fall in love, brothers are scandalized, garden parties are attended, and YOU KNOW people die.

Their love story is so beautiful and so meaningful and so touching and it changes them both in foundational ways and made me feel like if these two (affectionately) idiots can make it work then the rest of us regular joes out here are definitely getting in our own way.

I could not believe the turns this story took. Gregory as the protagonist is fantastic at lulling you into a false sense of security only for me to remember that oh yeah, this story is insane in the best possible way. And that exact thing happens like four different times and it got me every single time. It's a roller coaster of a story and the hills got steeper every time and I loved screaming about it every time. And I love detail that pays off in a story and this one has SO MUCH DETAIL and it always pays off and is always relevant and so satisfying to see. The tension baked into so many scenes is riveting, and there were so many scenes that I could just see playing out in my head like it's a movie (please please make a movie out of this book).

This story is genuinely a masterpiece. I loved the writing and the plot and all of the elements that came together in such a masterfully created package.

I loved every moment of the experience of reading this story and when it was over I was thrilled to live in a world where it exists.
Profile Image for Gabby.
214 reviews3 followers
October 12, 2026
This is officially my favorite dark horror romance book ever, if not my favorite book EVER.

This is a true horror romance-there were parts I struggled to read, but I couldn’t get enough and couldn’t stop. It was 800ish pages and never felt bored for a second, that’s high praise from me because my adhd usually kicks in around 400 pages.
My mind is blown, I may have a hard time ordering my thoughts, but I’ll try.

Gregory is a touch starved recluse who thinks the entire world is against him. He has no friends, his family hardly speaks to him and he lives in a remote cabin deep in the woods. He has somewhat strange hobbies and secrets that are eating him alive.

Sinclair (Julian) is the most interesting and captivating character. He is sadistic, hilarious, unapologetic, bright and sunny,narcissistic-I see him as half golden retriever/half satan himself.
He is extremely well off money wise, has some hobbies of his own that are beyond horrifying and an insane family.

These two characters are so different but also so similar in many ways. When they meet, both men break many of their own rules to be together. They are each other’s salvation and addiction.
Now this isn’t a traditional love story, there’s abuse, torture, kidnapping, check the trigger warnings for sure.
However, I found this book refreshing in a weird way. I liked how warped both men are and Julian is just straight up evil without apology. There wasn’t any justification for his behavior and I loved that about him.

My only question, unless I missed it somehow

I love this author’s writing and this was a phenomenal read that will forever live in my head!!!! I’m so obsessed!!!

Profile Image for Showarst.
1,299 reviews
Did Not Finish
June 6, 2026
Love like Drowning by Carson Wulff was an interesting premise that in the end just wasn’t for me. It was well-written and intriguing and I made it about 30% in. I loved Gregory but not Sinclair. It was hard for me to root for the relationship after learning more about Sinclair. I think there will be a lot of people who will love this— just not me.

I received an ARC from the author and GRR for my honest review.

Profile Image for Olivia.
252 reviews2 followers
November 10, 2026
This was just 800 pages of me thinking WTF am I reading?!, but somehow an unending dichotomy of emotions made it impossible to stop
308 reviews10 followers
Read
May 24, 2026
Love Like Drowning is an intense and psychologically immersive dark romance that blends horror, obsession, emotional vulnerability, and dark humor into a uniquely gripping reading experience. Carson Wulff creates a story that is unapologetically chaotic and emotionally charged, pulling readers deep into the unstable yet fascinating dynamic between two deeply damaged characters.

What makes the novel especially compelling is the contrast between brutality and emotional intimacy. Beneath the violence, tension, and morally complex decisions lies a surprisingly layered exploration of loneliness, trauma, identity, and connection. Gregory and Sinclair are both unsettling and strangely human, and their evolving relationship carries a level of emotional intensity that keeps the story consistently engaging.

The writing balances suspense, psychological tension, and moments of dark humor with confidence, allowing the emotional and character driven elements to remain at the center of the narrative. The atmosphere feels immersive throughout, and the slow unraveling of both characters creates a relationship dynamic that is unpredictable, disturbing, and emotionally charged all at once.

Bold, emotionally intense, and highly atmospheric, Love Like Drowning stands out as a memorable dark horror romance that will strongly appeal to readers who appreciate morally gray characters, psychological complexity, and emotionally driven storytelling.
Profile Image for unholyren.
1 review
October 29, 2026
Love Like Drowning. geniuelly what the fuck. i don't even know where to begin with this book. i need more people to read it. I NEED MORE PEOPLE TO READ LOVE LIKE DROWNING. (especially if you like gatobobs media) i have so much to say about this book and nobody to say it to. i crave to talk about these characters. i need to talk about them. i need more people to understand.

gregory and sinclair. WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH THESE TWO. i love them so much it's genuinely ridiculous. they make me feel so fucking good it's almost impossible to explain. i don't even know what to do with all the feelings i have about them. I am not normal about this book and i don't think i ever will be.

gregory, oh my god. i have NEVER resonated with a character this much in my entire life. i've never felt so seen by a book before, and i genuinely don't know how to explain what that feels like. i love his character and his story so much,i think a part of me will always be grateful for getting to read something that made me feel so understood.

and then there's sinclair. GOD. his little jokes are so fucking stupid and i love them SO MUCH. they get me every single time. but it's not even just that, he's genuinely SO charismatic and charming and i fear i would fall for him too. NO DOUBT. not even a second of hesitation. WHAT THE FUCK AM I SUPPOSED TO DO WITH THAT. i love these two for so many different reasons and i could genuinely talk about them for hours btw If you like Sinclair and you're interested in reading more about him or sum Carson writes LLD in Sinclairs POV on Patreon so worth checking out!!!

but genuinely, underneath all my screaming, this book means more to me than i know how to explain. it moved me so deeply that i cried over it, and not just because it was somehow sad, but because something about it reached a part of me that nothing else ever has. seeing so much of myself in gregory made me feel understood in a way i would never expected to experience through a book.

i wish i could explain what this book means to me that actually does it justice, but i don't think i can. all i know is that it made me cry, made me feel understood, and gave me something to hold onto. i don't think i'll ever forget how this book made me feel, and i'm so, so glad i got to read it.
Profile Image for aziza.
66 reviews
Did Not Finish
October 17, 2026
DNF @ 30%

No, no, no. I can't take it anymore.

While I appreciate the stellar writing and am genuinely impressed by the book's commitment to its bit and its characters, this flavor and level of dark isn't for me.

I like a romance that challenges my preferences and makes me a little uncomfortable, but I draw the line at body-torture horror and the deeply unromantic gesture of disregarding a love interest's existential need for symmetry while indulging in it. I felt deeply for Gregory at the beginning, but 30% in, I can't find even the tiniest bit of sympathy or understanding for either of the mcs anymore, and found myself completely disconnected from both of them.

Gregory's desire to either escape from Sinclair, hate him and take revenge on him, or love him and be with him seems to swing between extremes so quickly, and with so little apparent logic the further the book goes on, that it was hard to settle into their dynamic or find the emotional consistency that would have kept the story grounded for me.

I'm sorry, Gabby. I tried, but unfortunately, this just isn't for me :(
Profile Image for Nicole.
491 reviews20 followers
June 10, 2026
Review for Love like Drowning by Carson Wulff

Tropes: Long list of Triggers

Dark
Kink/BDSM
Instand mutual obsession
Kidnapping
Morally gray characters
Slow-burn relationship building
mental health and past trauma
Dark comedy
Serial killer romance
high heat
Heavy horror and gore
Physical torture between the main couple


This story was dark, but I kind of liked it. There were times I had to put it down because this is the first time I have read a story like this one. Gregory & Sinclair were intriquging but also quite dark. I have begun to love reading dark stories, but this was a new dark for me, which isn't bad. I felt this story was well-written to where even in hard parts I just had to keep reading till I found out what happens with these two. The way Carson wrote the psychologically dark romance was so well done. I haven't read anything like this story. I will have to read another to see more of their writing style.

Nicole Harvey
Profile Image for Ashley Carrillo.
422 reviews1 follower
June 13, 2026
Wow. It has been a long while since I read such a long book. Especially a dark romance with violence, unaliving, torture, comedy, spice, delusion, romance and all the unhinged madness that makes a 800 page book fly by! Gregory may seem lonely, unsuspecting and shy but Sinclair is about to find out he's anything but. He may at first have plans about making him one of his many victims and plans to keep his rules of not sleeping with his victims or letting them go but he comes to find that Gregory is like no other he's ever encountered and has underestimated him. Gregory is a man with a body count (not the sexual kind. Iykyk) as high as his. And what do you get when you have two serial unalivers together? This book. I cannot begin to explain the whole premise of this book because I'd be here all night but I definitely would recommend this book and one day re read just to go back into Gregory and Sinclair's world that may be heavy but is also so much more.
Profile Image for Linda.
964 reviews18 followers
June 7, 2026
This is a deep dark psychological romance between 2 serial killers. Sinclair kills for the thrill, Gregory believes his kills are in "self defense" They meet one night on a quiet street, they text & call for awhile till they finally meet in person. Mutual obsession. Medium angst. Well written, long but so worth it. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
2 reviews
September 28, 2026
i dont think any book will ever affect me the same way Love Like Drowning has. It has quickly become my favorite book in all my 22 years of life, and Carson Wulff has quickly become my favorite author.

i feel so strongly about this book in a way i can’t describe. i identify with gregory so much, so much that it was physically painful to read about the way he thinks about himself. i’ve cried, and laughed, and felt sick to my stomach right along with him. i’ve fallen in love with sinclair and gregory as well, and it makes me so unbelievably sad that i’ve finished reading gregories story. it’s like losing a close friend! there are so many sentiments about this book that i wish i could publicly express and i’d desperately love to befriend Carson and pick apart their brain and learn absolutely everything I can about these two.

their relationship is utterly devastating and intriguing. there were so many moments that had me biting my nails and saying “Please stop- but don’t you dare!” and whispering to myself “This is so hot!” on the exact same page. 800 pages simply wasn’t enough and I would gladly read thousands of pages about them.

Carson’s writing style is also beautiful, highlighting the morbid and grotesque in a sickeningly sweet and suffocating love that can only come deep from the heart.

i’m beyond antsy for anything that comes next, and i cannot recommend Love Like Drowning enough. please, please, please- if you ever only read one book in your life, read this book.
3 reviews
September 13, 2026
The main characters are both super compelling. Gregory is especially relatable to me as an autistic aquarist myself haha. This book made me feel exposed and appreciated for my rawest, most tender parts.

This is a must-read if you want to read a ‘dark romance’ but don’t want to read something with noncon/rape. The MCs hurt each other in many ways, but when it comes to sex everything is consensual, and my understanding is that’s not an easy thing to come by in this genre.

The narration can feel a little repetitive, both stylistically and thematically. Still more than worth your time.
Profile Image for Nic Blue.
4 reviews
October 2, 2026
Horrifyingly beautiful

Wow. Just wow.
This book is a rollercoaster. I was so overwhelmed by the size of it but something about it drew me to reading this and I do not regret it for a second.
This is a DARK HORROR novel- arguably not romantic at all. SO READ THE TRIGGERS. AND THEN READ THEM AGAIN.
But with that being said, it's also beautiful, riveting, and addicting. Wulff wrote this with such passion and enthusiasm and attention to detail that I could not. stop. reading. The characters are insanely complex, the plot keeps you hooked, and the writing style is beautiful and easy to follow. I was extremely surprised to find that this was all under the work of one person. Carson Wulff, you are a master of an indie author. I cannot WAIT to see what else you come up!
Profile Image for spacecamp.
489 reviews9 followers
September 12, 2026
So this is DARK dark. Like when people rec a dark romance and you’re expecting a princess boy with an unhinged obsessed “only soft for him” trope? Yeah, this is not that.
We’ve got the most anxious neurodivergent hermit in Gregory. He’s lived his life in the shadow of an accidental death when he was a child, bullied by his peers, treated with contempt by his family. He lives an isolated life in a cabin in the woods, with aquariums and nature as his company. But things change when he stumbles into the path of Sinclair, and unhinged obsession comes into play on both their ends.

Did not expect this to be 800 pages. I stopped halfway through to read something fluffy because it’s just so dark and so long and I was feeling a bit buried under it.

I would honestly say, I have had no idea where this book is going or where we’ll end up. Like it’s such a twisty little maze of hallways. It’s legit like being trapped in a house of horrors. There’s definitely no morally grey here, because I don’t think Sinclair has any morals? I suppose he has one, that’s disclosed eventually. Gregory does, but they’re definitely just whatever twisted morality system he’s developed to deal with neurodivergence and trauma.

There is a lot of emotion here, on the surface from Gregory and under many layers for Sinclair. It can be a really hard read because of Gregory’s emotional state, Sinclair’s hobby of torturing people for funsies, and the level of gore and emotional rollercoaster. I had to double check that an HEA was coming at some point when all signs pointed towards being chopped up and stuffed in garbage bags.

Notes:
Another for the “chained up in his basement” microtrope
Two deranged MCs
Love that Gregory’s sister calls him Eggy
Picked it up because it had so few reviews
Really great artwork on the author’s Patreon
Seriously this is so dark, I had to double check that it has a HEA
Mental health rep, in the sense that it’s exploited and manipulated to torture the MC
Forced proximity
Five squeamish stars
3 reviews
August 7, 2026
Could not finish, after 1/4. Might be your cup of tea though

I did not know what I was reading when I chose it.

It is well-written, the plot started out quite intriguingly, the format of the narration is fast-paced and takes the reader along with the MC's constant flow of thoughts - although it leads to an untrustworthy narrator.

Learning about Gregory and his thought process got me hooked.
The fresh take on neuro divergency was surprising but some things were a miss. No diagnosis, no ideas, no indication, everyone hates and bullies him but he hasn't done anything wrong (apart from bring carcasses to his parents and not be able to talk to strangers ). He genuinely thinks he is fine but has seen countless therapists, doctors and psychiatrists, was prescribed pills.... he has no clarity on who he is, but constantly thinks he is worthless, abhorrent etc. both seem to clash.


However too many plot elements disrupted my reading and made it difficult to continue
- the MC's naivety was too much, I thought I was misreading sarcasm or poorly written character traits

- after two weeks they're all over each other. Gregory I understand because he's touch- starved and inexperienced ( also he's been verbally, physically and emotionally abused for 20 years). But he's not completely ignorant. He's agoraphobic and wary of social interactions therefore should be cautious 24/7. He bumps into one guy and loses his mind/falls head over heels because Sinclair is pretty and wants to talk?

-He observes fishes and animals all day in the woods, reads extensively about botany and wildlife, but has no gut instinct about some random stranger who is 'charismatic' because he becomes a massive sub after 2 texts ? I don't think it holds enough weight.
Also he invites him to his home ( what kind of introvert does that?) and lets him bolt the door ?

- he kills several people, skins animals, breaks and carves bones, and chops wood all day but doesn't overpower Sinclair in the car ? He's ferocious and introverted but fawns over Sinclair after 2 seconds..
Doesn't overpower in the basement ? Or pushes the barrel when it has holes in the lid so the water EMPTIES from the barrel?

- Sinclair's personality is all over the place and I could not keep up. Every time he opens his mouth I think ' sarcasm', and it doesn't ring as a true thing someone would say.



Oddly enough if Sinclair were out of the picture, I'd be more interested in the plot

Have fun reading it though because lots of people apparently did !
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Zakle.
22 reviews16 followers
August 9, 2026
I had this book recommended to me on an extreme horror literature subreddit. And I'm so glad it was! The folk lured me in with character development, murder, and gay.

Beginning when I first started reading, I saw "Gatobob" and I strapped in. I had a feeling about what I was in for. I was not disappointed. Anyone who mentions Gatobob positively are my people.

This is certainly not going to be something everyone likes, and that's okay. I loved Gregory and Julian. Even their families, who didn't see much screen time, were fun to read about. Gregory's parents a bit less fun for me personally; my mother hated my hobby of doll collecting and threw away my rocks.

Where there is violence, gore, and sex, I felt like Wulff's writing style and addition of dark comedy in places make it a good introduction to dark fiction in general. If you can't handle this, you likely won't be able to handle the rest of what extreme horror offers.
Profile Image for Jine.
562 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
May 31, 2026
literally had to sit for awhile before I could write this
This book was something totally different than I’ve ever read it was so damn complex and the story was unhinged but in the best possible way! This is a serial killer x serial killer mm romance
Gregory is almost mugged and ends up killing the man and he goes on a walk as an alibi where he meets Sinclair who asks to borrow his phone but Gregory lies and says he doesn’t have one so Sinclair gives Gregory his number on his arm and they begin texting
Gregory lives a very very isolated life so when this friendship starts he’s kind of dumbfounded that someone would have any interest in him at all
After their first date Gregory ends up in Sinclairs basement with the intent to kill him
Their relationship is different at first Sinclair likes scaring him I mean he ends up in a industrial sized tub with the goal of drowning him
What Gregory don’t know is that this is something Sinclair does all the time
There is multiple mutilations in this book some fingers and a leg LOL I feel like in the beginning it’s a little Stockholm syndrome for Gregory but it changes quickly because no one in his life has ever understood his uniqueness and Sinclair does because he is like Gregory but he had the supportive family
It takes Sinclair longer for him to admit his feelings and gets uncomfortable and dismissive when Gregory confesses his so freely
Sinclairs family will a absolutely nuts and I can see why it took him so long to introduce Gregory I mean the red room but Gregory did so good I cheered LOL
I laughed so many times during this with just the absurdity in the best way possible
Even though their relationship was NOT a usual one I cheered for them to make it and it was touch and go I mean a leg amputation would normally put a damper on things!
It’s a long book but if you don’t mind gore a little torture and absurdity then this is for you!
Profile Image for Youwill.
4 reviews
June 17, 2026
Get ready for the degradation kink, boys!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Homies who don't love degradation kink can see themselves out. The rest of us refined freaks will handle this one.

Let me tell you about my boy Gregory. I just met him but if anything happened to him I'd kill everyone in this room and then myself (a joke, I jest, don't call the police on me. Or him). He is a shy sensitive 28 year old virgin who is SO lonely and isolated from social phobia due to childhood bullying that he weeps openly when someone is nice to him. He also pops a boner at the slightest hint of praise. My kind of man. He's my baby and he's never done anything wrong in his life. Except for the murder.

OKAY... so... yeah. HE'S A SERIAL KILLER. Fine. Let's jot that down. BUT only because people keep trying to hurt him! He doesn't wanna hurt anyone! He was defending himself! I am as delusional as he is!

Sinclair... he... he wants to hurt people. He loves it. It’s his favorite thing in life. He's the spoiled rich sadist son of a billionaire and he loves killing people. It brings him joy. I want him to stick his... knife... in my face and tell me to do my chores. So does Gregory. Sinclair's an extrovert who loves shy losers like Gregory and immediately is obsessed with him. He doesn't know Gregory's killed people too but when he finds out he's just that much more cooked. And by cooked I mean so in love it makes him look stupid. Don't let him fool you when he's calling Gregory "pathetic" and taunting him for his many flaws- he's really saying "I love you" and "I want to kiss you sloppy". You know, just like in The Princess Bride.

These guys are a match made in hell and I cheered so loud I THREW MY KINDLE when Sinclair finally broke and ***SPOILERS*** admitted he loved Gregory during the public marriage proposal. And I might have cried as hard as Gregory did.
Profile Image for Andrea.
535 reviews6 followers
October 8, 2026
MM
🌶️🌶️🌶️
Dark
Serial killer/intended victim
Virgin

Gregory is a very isolated individual. He has lived in a cabin in the woods for the past 10 years. His only friends are his numerous fish scattered throughout his home in multiple aquariums. He is extremely antisocial due to a traumatic childhood. But I believe he is also autistic. When he was 8, a neighbor boy tried to drown him in their lake. He fought back and ended up drowning the boy. He was ostracized from his peers, adults, his family from that day forward.

When he was 18, that boy’s younger brother bumped into him in the woods. He tried to kill Gregory too but Gregory fought back again and killed him. This time he didn’t let anybody know and buried him in the woods near his cabin. An older lady knocked on his cabin door and tried to force her way into his cabin, so he defended himself and his home, killing and burying her alongside body number one.

Today, he was attacked outside the supermarket. He fought back and killed this man too. He will take him back to his cabin to dispose of. But he needs an alibi, so he drives across town and goes for a walk along a street with cameras. There he bumps into a man. Even though he has social phobia, they strike up a conversation. The man insists on giving Gregory his phone number.

He contemplates for days but ends up texting him. They text for weeks. A bit of sexting. He finally agrees to meet the man for a date. He ends up drugged and tied up in this man’s basement. His name is Julian but goes by his surname, Sinclair.. Turns out he is a serial killer but there is more that I won’t give away. He tortures Gregory a bit but Gregory likes the attention. He wants Sinclair to keep him.

For some reason I expected Sinclair to do more to Gregory. It was pretty tame for horror erotica. I would love to hear about the other Sinclair brothers and if they decide to find love too.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Esme The Bookworm.
34 reviews
August 31, 2026
This was an incredibly dark MM romance and I ate it up.

The story explores trauma, mental health, obsession, violence, and a deeply unconventional relationship between two very damaged individuals. Both main characters are morally grey, and the romance develops in ways that will likely divide readers. If you’re looking for a healthy relationship, this is not the book for you.

What kept me invested was the emotional complexity of the characters. Greg struggles with severe social anxiety, trauma, and isolation, while Sinclair is manipulative, dangerous, and deeply unsettling. Despite this, I found their dynamic fascinating because beneath all the darkness was a desire to be understood and accepted for who they truly were.

One of the strongest aspects of the book was how it explored the idea of being seen. Both characters carry significant emotional baggage, and while their relationship is far from healthy, they each find something in the other that they have been missing for a long time. I found myself unexpectedly invested in their journey and curious to see where the story would take them.

This book contains a significant amount of dark content and readers should check content warnings before picking it up. However, for readers who enjoy dark romance, morally complex characters, and relationships that explore the line between love, obsession, and acceptance, this may be worth checking out.

Overall, this was a dark, disturbing, and surprisingly emotional read that stayed with me long after I finished it.
Profile Image for Lena Elisabeth.
37 reviews
October 21, 2026
JESUS!!! I’ve never struggled so much to find words for a book review.
What a thoroughly deranged little 800-page story!

I’ve been very opposed to reading Dark Romance in the past (past as in six months ago) but recently I’ve been trying to be more open and it’s been worth it (when I die, please bury me holding my copy of Pure Silence by K.L. Hiers).

So then I saw a comment on Reddit a few weeks ago of someone talking about this book with some plot details and I thought NOPE that’s where I draw the line but then my friend Gabby started reading it (thank you Gabby!) and I was intrigued, very tentatively at first.

This was so fucking repulsive, terrifying and MEAN. I’ve never read anything like it, the combination of romance and horror with all of the physical and emotional abuse reaalllly fucked with my head.
But it was also absolutely hilarious in a very unique way?? I wasn’t expecting the amount of times I laughed and shrieked out loud at the absurdity of what I was reading. I have a total of 74 highlighted text passages for this with a wide range of reasons for why they stood out to me.

Do I want to read something similar to this in the near future? Nope, absolutely not. This was a difficult read and it had me extremely conflicted about my feelings.
There were some things where I had to acknowledge that while it may not have been my cup of tea, it was still very well done. Some plot choices though, I straight up disliked and felt like they didn’t really make a lot of sense.

All in all, this was like 90% brilliant, unapologetically shocking and I’m sure I will be thinking about it for a looong time.

Also, you’re telling me the author did all the writing and editing of this long ass book themself??? That is so fucking impressive.
Profile Image for Syren.
39 reviews1 follower
September 27, 2026
Spice level 🌶🌶🌶/5

This is most definitely a *dark* romance, and the premise of it being double serial killers really drew me in. However, I felt that the overall length of the novel was the killer for me. I felt like a lot got drug out and made the pacing hard to stay engaged with.
I can appreciate the neurodivergent representation in regards to anxiety and trauma, but sometimes instead of being presented in a relateable way, it felt like the same thing was repeated over and over for pages at a time.
I did enjoy the dynamic between Gregory and Sinclair and seeing Sinclair slowly show his care. I warn that this is a DARK romance, so it isn't sunshine and rainbows and kinks per se. It's dark and gritty. But that plays into the dynamic of the serial killer aspect.
When the story picked up, it was great and intriguing. And watching how Gregory's anxiety descend really drew it all in. You feel for him in a way because of all he has endured and why he has done what he has. And the way Sinclair plays on that. Like I said their dynamic is engaging. Sinclair taking Gregory captive as his next victim only for Gregory to love the attention Sinclair gives him is such a dark and twisted road.
But with how slow paced it was, I hesitate to recommend it as much since I struggled with staying engaged.
Profile Image for Nina Diab.
5,560 reviews55 followers
July 10, 2026
I absolutely loved this book! As soon as I read the premise I was utterly fascinated and had to read it. Not my first serial killer romance. But a mm serial killer x serial killer is a rarer find for me. Great world building and wonderful characters. I loved both Gregory and Sinclair so so much! I was hooked from Gregory's very first page. Very introverted and very anti-people. A lot of pain inside him, yet desperate for someone to see him as worthy; as wanted. His and Sinclair's first meeting left him almost frozen to the spot in social anxiety, uncertainty, and shock. And knowing who Sinclair was from the blurb only fascinated me more. I can't help but wonder my reaction I'd I didn't know Sinclair was a killer from the start, but this book is perfect just the way it is. Tension, suspense, chemistry, humor, death. I never knew where things would go in their twists and turns. This book brought out all my emotions. And I was completely hooked. What a fantastic read! And my first story by this author. I am definitely looking for more! And I am desperate to listen to this in audio someday! Absolutely perfect! 5 stars
Profile Image for Bee.
656 reviews17 followers
June 16, 2026
Read to me by Alexa

3⭐️ for pacing/ length I think. At some point…. I was just kind of like okay…. Let’s start wrapping this up. The rest of the rating is based on my general enjoyment. Not my fave, but not bad either and to no fault of the author. Some elements just were not my cuppa. None of the darker elements. That was fine.

Though…. I will say it was difficult to feel the connection between Sinclair and Gregory at times because of the way Sinclair is written but I think that may have been intentional. Gregory is also unsure because of the way Sinclair treats him. Part of me appreciates the challenge of writing a dynamic character like Sinclair. He’s pretty awful. And yet the author needs to make us like him at least a little. I don’t think they fully succeeded. When Sinclair is not with Gregory, the people in his life perceive him as charming and charismatic and I think some of that was missing for the reader. I think we could have used some of that version of him too.

But otherwise I liked that this is a true dark romance with unconventional relationship dynamics.
Profile Image for Grace Felder.
1 review
October 12, 2026
I’ve literally never written a review on Goodreads before but after staying up until 2 and ignoring my responsibilities I fear I must give credit.

THIS is what I want in a dark romance. Both of these characters were walking contradictions who did atrocious things, and yet I loved them. Both of them were so well fleshed out (even with only one POV) and so unique. I’ve never read anything like this before. Never thought I would read a truly heartfelt book about self acceptance and love in relation to serial killers.

Plus It walked an extremely fine line throughout. On one hand, I was on the edge my seat the whole time thinking one of them was going to kill the other (literally right up until the end!), and yet on the other- I truly bought into their romance and wanted them to end up together. That’s hard to pull off!

Took off .25 because this has some editing issues, but I also saw that the author self edited and they certainly did a better job than I would have, so who am I to judge 😅
2 reviews
August 8, 2026
I know for a fact that no other book has ever pulled me so thoroughly into another person's psyche and made me not want to leave. I've never fallen in love with characters so terribly flawed, anxious, and frustrating. I've never met a character made up so thoroughly of shattered pieces... and felt the need to cut themselves into even tinier pieces. I've never seen a love simultaneously wrought with so much tenderness and brutality. Gregory and Sinclair fought tooth and nail for their love story and have earned a place in my heart forever. Everyone who has an open mind for gore, heartache, and an absurd level of mushiness should read this.

No words can ever truly describe what this book has done to or for me, but I still had to give it a try since it deserves so much more visibility. It's the longest book I've ever read and somehow it feels like I spent the shortest amount of time with it. Nearly 800 pages went by in the blink of an eye, but I will carry this story with me forever.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews