What do you think?
Rate this book
Falling for Flannel #1
The Story Between Us
Discover the wonderful Maple Lake community in this sweet fall romance by mother-daughter duo, Susan and Sarah May Warren!
365 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 29, 2026
About the author
Susan May Warren
303 books3,959 followersI can't help be amazed at the gifts God has delighted me with - a wonderful husband, four amazing children, and the opportunity to write for Him.
I've been writing as long as I can remember - I won my first book writing contest in first grade! Over the years, writing has become, for me, a way to praise God and see Him at work in my life.
Although I have a degree in Mass Communications from the University of MN, my real writing experience started when I penned the The Warren Report - a bi-monthly newsletter that detailed our ministry highlights.
Living in Russia meant I never lacked for great material - and those experiences naturally spilled out first into devotionals and magazine articles and finally into my first published story, "Measure of a Man," in the Tyndale/HeartQuest, Chance Encounters of the Heart anthology.
Susan and husbandI grew up in Wayzata, a suburb of Minneapolis, and became an avid camper from an early age. My favorite fir-lined spot is the north shore of Minnesota - it's where I met my husband, honeymooned and dreamed of living. The north woods easily became the foundation for my first series, The Deep Haven series.based on a little tourist town along the shores of Lake Superior. I have to admit - I'm terribly jealous of Mona, the heroine of my first full-length book, Happily Ever After, a Christy Award Finalist published in 2004 with Tyndale/Heartquest.
Our family moved home from the mission field in June 2004 -- and now we live in the beautiful town I'd always dreamed of! God has amazed me anew with His provision, and blessings -- and allowed me a season when I can write full time for Him.
I 'm delighted you've stopped in to visit. My hope is that you'll be blessed and encouraged by soul-stirring stories of regular people interacting with a God who loves them.
I'd love to hear from you! I love getting mail, especially from readers and I welcome your questions and comments. Write to me at susan@susanmaywarren.com. And, if you're interested, sign up for my newsletter, a quarterly sneak peek into upcoming releases and projects. Thank you for your interest and support.
God Bless and Happy Reading!
In His Grip,
Susan May Warren
I've been writing as long as I can remember - I won my first book writing contest in first grade! Over the years, writing has become, for me, a way to praise God and see Him at work in my life.
Although I have a degree in Mass Communications from the University of MN, my real writing experience started when I penned the The Warren Report - a bi-monthly newsletter that detailed our ministry highlights.
Living in Russia meant I never lacked for great material - and those experiences naturally spilled out first into devotionals and magazine articles and finally into my first published story, "Measure of a Man," in the Tyndale/HeartQuest, Chance Encounters of the Heart anthology.
Susan and husbandI grew up in Wayzata, a suburb of Minneapolis, and became an avid camper from an early age. My favorite fir-lined spot is the north shore of Minnesota - it's where I met my husband, honeymooned and dreamed of living. The north woods easily became the foundation for my first series, The Deep Haven series.based on a little tourist town along the shores of Lake Superior. I have to admit - I'm terribly jealous of Mona, the heroine of my first full-length book, Happily Ever After, a Christy Award Finalist published in 2004 with Tyndale/Heartquest.
Our family moved home from the mission field in June 2004 -- and now we live in the beautiful town I'd always dreamed of! God has amazed me anew with His provision, and blessings -- and allowed me a season when I can write full time for Him.
I 'm delighted you've stopped in to visit. My hope is that you'll be blessed and encouraged by soul-stirring stories of regular people interacting with a God who loves them.
I'd love to hear from you! I love getting mail, especially from readers and I welcome your questions and comments. Write to me at susan@susanmaywarren.com. And, if you're interested, sign up for my newsletter, a quarterly sneak peek into upcoming releases and projects. Thank you for your interest and support.
God Bless and Happy Reading!
In His Grip,
Susan May Warren
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
What a wonderful surprise - a Warren duo!
I really enjoyed how the theme of walls played out in this story. The grumpy hermit author, Nate Rivers, learned to look past his walls and consider that they weren’t as real as he’d made them out to be. I loved that Livvie Fox was instrumental in getting him to pivot.
The underlying theme of grief was well-written and the authors showed us how the characters harnessed the potential it had to transform them once they’d made room for it. I loved the reminder that grief doesn’t have to be the end of the story and that we can grieve with hope because that isn’t all there is. My biggest takeaway from this theme is that carrying someone else’s legacy doesn’t mean that we’ll be destroyed by their absence, but rather enriched by what they shared with us.
“God is at the helm. Even when we can’t see the next chapter.”
I’ll remember this emotionally rich book for what it reminded me about being someone who leaves an impact. I was inspired to live so that I can encourage others to be who they were meant to be.
I can’t wait for the next installment in this exciting new series.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
I really enjoyed how the theme of walls played out in this story. The grumpy hermit author, Nate Rivers, learned to look past his walls and consider that they weren’t as real as he’d made them out to be. I loved that Livvie Fox was instrumental in getting him to pivot.
The underlying theme of grief was well-written and the authors showed us how the characters harnessed the potential it had to transform them once they’d made room for it. I loved the reminder that grief doesn’t have to be the end of the story and that we can grieve with hope because that isn’t all there is. My biggest takeaway from this theme is that carrying someone else’s legacy doesn’t mean that we’ll be destroyed by their absence, but rather enriched by what they shared with us.
“God is at the helm. Even when we can’t see the next chapter.”
I’ll remember this emotionally rich book for what it reminded me about being someone who leaves an impact. I was inspired to live so that I can encourage others to be who they were meant to be.
I can’t wait for the next installment in this exciting new series.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
November 5, 2026
This was a really good read. It had great fall and small town vibes, and a good balance of grief and romance. I also really enjoyed the bonus epilogue. Highly recommend.
October 19, 2026
If you want to read a small-town fall romance, THIS is the one you should read. They're all as plentiful as cents in 10 dollars, but this is one of the better ones. I present to you: How This Book Has Every Hallmark and Why It's Better
I wanted to be part of the trend: Illustrated cute clingy couple on the cover ✅️ with fall vibes ✅️
I just read a Hallmark movie; I survived because it had substance/sustenance
1. Grumpy x Sunshine
My dudes, Nate is a grumpy recluse because he's grieving and I - and you, if you read this book - can FEEL his grief.
And it's not as dramatic, broken and angsty as you'd think it might be. I like this guy; he seems like a real one. Not on my Top 10 of favorite male characters ever, but rest assured, there was no cringe or ick to be found here. You will like him too.
2. The City Outsider
Livvie is the New York literary corporate worker who comes ✨️home to Maple Lake✨️ Whatever. I like her anyway. She's written so well. She's not a sunny manic pixie dream girl. The details we got of her work 🧡 show her, and what she can do in publishing 🩷 - and what she can't accomplish if she has a trash boss. No spoilers. But it was cinematic.
This is so funny and cute:
3. Third Act Breakup with the Misunderstanding?
They have a nice - this was me: 🥹 during it; so understandable and vulnerable and nice- fight. He storms back inside, slams the door, waits around 10 minutes, immediately feels bad (lol, don’t worry, guys. No toxicity here) He opens the door to go look for her, and she's already there. She never left (not in a creepy way). Their conversation? Just like the fight <3 (You probably don't know what I'm talking about...)
And then there's another fight. But that one's human and vulnerable and gives me the other side of romance amid the fluffy 'flannel' - be careful with each other. (There's so much grief in this book, yet it's so light, and nothing - at all - seems out of place.)
This book made me want to write a book. Any writer would like this book (...I think). The Thornwood Chronicles sound so cool; just look at this ⬇️
I loved every detail we got about the story within the story.
Also, I loved this quote as a reviewer, written by two authors:
[Livvie to Nate about his books] "I’ve read reviews—actual reviews, not the garbage ones from people who think criticism means cruelty—where readers talk about how Thornwood got them through [hard life things]"
I wanted to be part of the trend: Illustrated cute clingy couple on the cover ✅️ with fall vibes ✅️
I just read a Hallmark movie; I survived because it had substance/sustenance
1. Grumpy x Sunshine
My dudes, Nate is a grumpy recluse because he's grieving and I - and you, if you read this book - can FEEL his grief.
And it's not as dramatic, broken and angsty as you'd think it might be. I like this guy; he seems like a real one. Not on my Top 10 of favorite male characters ever, but rest assured, there was no cringe or ick to be found here. You will like him too.
2. The City Outsider
Livvie is the New York literary corporate worker who comes ✨️home to Maple Lake✨️ Whatever. I like her anyway. She's written so well. She's not a sunny manic pixie dream girl. The details we got of her work 🧡 show her, and what she can do in publishing 🩷 - and what she can't accomplish if she has a trash boss. No spoilers. But it was cinematic.
This is so funny and cute:
“You’re my happy ending,” he said. His voice was rough. Wrecked. “And I’m hoping I can be yours too.”
Livvie laughed—a real laugh, bright and startled and full of joy. “That’s a little sappy,” she said. “Please don’t write that.”
He grinned. The full grin, the one he’d almost forgotten he had. “I’ll write what I want.”
“Nate—”
“You can edit it later.”
3. Third Act Breakup with the Misunderstanding?
They have a nice - this was me: 🥹 during it; so understandable and vulnerable and nice- fight. He storms back inside, slams the door, waits around 10 minutes, immediately feels bad (lol, don’t worry, guys. No toxicity here) He opens the door to go look for her, and she's already there. She never left (not in a creepy way). Their conversation? Just like the fight <3 (You probably don't know what I'm talking about...)
And then there's another fight. But that one's human and vulnerable and gives me the other side of romance amid the fluffy 'flannel' - be careful with each other. (There's so much grief in this book, yet it's so light, and nothing - at all - seems out of place.)
This book made me want to write a book. Any writer would like this book (...I think). The Thornwood Chronicles sound so cool; just look at this ⬇️
"Aldric stands at the Wall of Sorrow, the one that protects Thornwood Forest. He has to reach Elara before the Blood Moon, but the wall is impenetrable—sealed for three hundred years. The magic that held the secrets of passage died with the previous Keeper of Secrets, his mentor, Morvain.”
“So go around it.” He gave her a look of pure, undiluted pity. “The wall extends from the Frozen Reaches to the Burning Sea. Six months to circumnavigate. Aldric has six days.”
“Okay, sorry, I just—”
“And the territories on either end are hostile. The Valdorians would execute him on sight. The Fire Clans would—”
“I said sorry.” She held up her hands. “I’m not the expert here. You are.”
“I’m not an expert. I’m stuck.” He sat up, running a hand through his hair. “Three years stuck. A thousand solutions tried and discarded. Every work-around violates established lore. Every clever trick undermines something else.”
“You’ve been thinking about this for three years?” His jaw tightened.
“Aldric doesn’t need to get through it.” Nate still stared at the water, but something had shifted in his face. Come alive. “He needs to understand why it exists. The Keepers didn’t seal it to keep people out. They sealed it to keep something in.”
...
“He’s been fighting the barrier. But the barrier isn’t his enemy. It’s a warning.” He turned to look at her, and his eyes burned differently—bright, urgent, present in a way he hadn’t been since she’d arrived. “He doesn’t need a door. He needs to find the thing the wall protects. And make a deal with it.”
...
“The deal has to cost him something. Something real.” The words tumbled faster now. “The thing behind the wall has been waiting three hundred years. It won’t let him pass for free. And his love for Elara—that’s his greatest strength, so it has to—”
“Get back to the house.” “What?” “Now. Right now.” She grabbed his arm and pulled him back toward the trail. “Before you lose it.”
I loved every detail we got about the story within the story.
Also, I loved this quote as a reviewer, written by two authors:
[Livvie to Nate about his books] "I’ve read reviews—actual reviews, not the garbage ones from people who think criticism means cruelty—where readers talk about how Thornwood got them through [hard life things]"
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
The Story Between Us by Susan and Sarah May Warren is a romance story set in the fall. Stories that are set in small towns remind me of my small town. Small, quiet and full of charm. The realistic part of the story is when the hero, Nate, has a really hard time trying to move on and write another book because his sister, who used to help craft the stories, is gone. She died a couple of years earlier. This resonates with me because I used to write all the time, and my dad would call me to check on my writing progress and talk through some story ideas. He passed away almost eleven years ago, and I have a really hard time writing anything for my fiction stories. I kept flipping through the pages of the story, wondering what the key would be to make Nate write again. Readers will like how Livvie is the guiding light to help Nate. Her words dig deep into him and help him to resume writing. The setting made me feel warm and cozy. I want to go visit Maple Lake, Minnesota. I love fall and winter, so this was the perfect setting for me. I’m not really a fan of romances, but this story hit a little closer to my heart. I recommend others to purchase this story.
I received a complimentary copy of Story Between Us by Susan May Warren and Sarah Warren from Sunrise Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
I received a complimentary copy of Story Between Us by Susan May Warren and Sarah Warren from Sunrise Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
September 30, 2026
Something about this story came in and wrapped itself around my heart and decided to stay. This romance is nuanced and thoughtful while mingling shared grief and toe-curling romance in a combination that was just entrancing. I loved both versions of Nate- the reclusive hermit drowning in grief and the sweetheart learning to live again. I loved plucky Livvie and vulnerable Livvie and how the two of these sweet characters begin to heal. It’s been awhile since I’ve actually had tears coming down my face reading, but this one did it. Poignant tears, not sad ones. I loved the Biblical truth woven throughout, and wisdom from Aunt Lila along the way. I loved the world building that gave us just the right taste of Nate’s story. I loved the descriptors of Livvie’s mural. I loved the lessons learned, the strength gained, and the heart of it all. If this is just a taste of what we get to look forward to in this series, let’s just say I’m all in. One of my favorite contemporary romances so far this year, for sure.
I received a complementary copy of this book from Sunrise Publishing. I was not required to review. My opinions are my own.
I received a complementary copy of this book from Sunrise Publishing. I was not required to review. My opinions are my own.
October 3, 2026
I simply did not want this story to end or to say goodbye to these characters. If you know me, you know I'm a fan of romance and a solid, well written love story, but oddly enough (or maybe, this is normal), I also appreciate when the romance is not the only plot line. While these characters had me giggling and kicking my feet, they also had me feeling so many other things along with them. I felt like I knew Nate and Livvie personally, and found myself cheering them on, rooting for their healing and happiness. This story was adorable, but also poignant. It made me giggle, but it also had beautiful, Biblical truths and wisdom woven throughout. I felt the grief, the conflict, the growth and healing. Do I wish I could read it again for the first time? Yes. Will I be buying a physical copy for my bookshelf and read it again and again? Absolutely.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
It was quite a while since a story connected with me in such an emotional way that I felt the characters' emotions, grief and joy. Nate was so lost in his grief and his struggle to move on. The authors took me on an emotional journey in his journey to the next step and healing.
Livvie with her positive, bubbly and nothing is a challenge attitude came into the story like a whirlwind and upended Nate’s reclusive hideout. Livvie had her own fears, dreams and struggles, but I enjoyed seeing how she went through her own journey of healing to discover her inner strength and stand up for herself.
This story was gripping, raw, real and also hopeful. I did not want to stop reading until the very last punctuation.
*I received a complimentary copy from the author. All opinions expressed are my own.*
Livvie with her positive, bubbly and nothing is a challenge attitude came into the story like a whirlwind and upended Nate’s reclusive hideout. Livvie had her own fears, dreams and struggles, but I enjoyed seeing how she went through her own journey of healing to discover her inner strength and stand up for herself.
This story was gripping, raw, real and also hopeful. I did not want to stop reading until the very last punctuation.
*I received a complimentary copy from the author. All opinions expressed are my own.*
September 12, 2026
This is the perfect read for the fall season! It’s cozy, it’s warm, it hits all the feels, and has everything I love about a book.
Memorable characters: Livvie Fox has worked for the same publishing house for years. She has an excellent knack for finding hidden gems and nurturing stories and their authors. And she gets no credit—until…
Ian Rivers is in danger of losing a contract and owing a HUGE advance. But Ian Rivers is a writing duo, a brother and sister team behind the Thornwood Chroniclers, a best selling high fantasy series the two cooked up when Emily, Nate’s sister, was battling illness.
Now she’s gone and he can no longer create in the world they made together. Livvie’s task: go back to her hometown, stay with her Aunt Lila, and somehow convince, coax, or coerce Nate into writing the final book.
It’s one of the best books I’ve read all year. And wow, did I want to read the Thornhill Chronicles! It would be fabulous should someone decide to write those books **hint hint**.
I received an advance copy from the publisher. I’m under no obligation and my review has not been solicited. Very highly recommend!
Memorable characters: Livvie Fox has worked for the same publishing house for years. She has an excellent knack for finding hidden gems and nurturing stories and their authors. And she gets no credit—until…
Ian Rivers is in danger of losing a contract and owing a HUGE advance. But Ian Rivers is a writing duo, a brother and sister team behind the Thornwood Chroniclers, a best selling high fantasy series the two cooked up when Emily, Nate’s sister, was battling illness.
Now she’s gone and he can no longer create in the world they made together. Livvie’s task: go back to her hometown, stay with her Aunt Lila, and somehow convince, coax, or coerce Nate into writing the final book.
It’s one of the best books I’ve read all year. And wow, did I want to read the Thornhill Chronicles! It would be fabulous should someone decide to write those books **hint hint**.
I received an advance copy from the publisher. I’m under no obligation and my review has not been solicited. Very highly recommend!
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 28, 2026The Story Between Us @susanmaywarren + @sarahmaywarren @sunrisemediagroup
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🫑 Kisses only
No Swearing
The perfect cozy fall read and it is oh so sweet with so many hearttelt moments. Getting to walk through Nate's grief with Livvie was definitely emotional at times. Especially since Nate was writing a grief journey into his novel. I truly loved this one!
"He needs to know there's life after loss. That carrying someone's legacy doesn't mean being destroyed by their absence. He has to face his own grief. And when he does, he'll find that it doesn't kill him. It transforms him."
Forced proximity
Sedona chance
Author x agent
Healing
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🫑 Kisses only
No Swearing
The perfect cozy fall read and it is oh so sweet with so many hearttelt moments. Getting to walk through Nate's grief with Livvie was definitely emotional at times. Especially since Nate was writing a grief journey into his novel. I truly loved this one!
"He needs to know there's life after loss. That carrying someone's legacy doesn't mean being destroyed by their absence. He has to face his own grief. And when he does, he'll find that it doesn't kill him. It transforms him."
Forced proximity
Sedona chance
Author x agent
Healing
September 14, 2026
After reading this book, I get the hype behind reading fall books because the vibes were EVERYTHING! Susan and Sarah are quickly becoming my favorite author duo and this book was no exception!
I fell in love with Nate and Livvie’s story from page one. The themes of overcoming grief and the walls that Nate erected between them made for a gripping and emotional story. Susan and Sarah have never yet failed to make me cry (in the best way).
As always, the prose was brilliant and the characters even more so! I also loved the way Nate’s novel was woven so seamlessly into the story! Filled with poignant faith themes and nostalgic fall vibes, this book is the perfect cozy read!
I fell in love with Nate and Livvie’s story from page one. The themes of overcoming grief and the walls that Nate erected between them made for a gripping and emotional story. Susan and Sarah have never yet failed to make me cry (in the best way).
As always, the prose was brilliant and the characters even more so! I also loved the way Nate’s novel was woven so seamlessly into the story! Filled with poignant faith themes and nostalgic fall vibes, this book is the perfect cozy read!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This wonderful story tied me up in knots and then untied the knots and made a gorgeous bow with a cleverly written and absorbing romance. Livvie Fox is a junior assistant at a publishing company in NYC, a world of sharks where she is the smallest fish and keeps getting eaten up by demands as her efforts are constantly overlooked by her boss. When the morning meeting turns to the topic of Nate Rivers, Livvie blurts out that she knows Nate and ends up being sent to encourage Nate to finish his book so he doesn’t nullify his contract. The scenes, once she arrives to the small town where her aunt and Nate live, are straight from what I imagine would be a spectacular Hallmark movie, with demands, cajoling and then gentle persuasion from Livvie and obstinate withdrawal from Nate. But Livvie is motivated and genuinely cares, knowing that Nate is still grieving. After all, who knows more about Nate’s grief than Livvie since she was Emma’s best friend? Emma, Nate’s sister who died three years ago, and the reason he stopped writing his epic tales haunts Nate’s present and ties him to a past that he cannot retrieve. Together, the Nate and Livvie must explore what they really want out of life, whether it is telling stories and painting, working in a publishing company or living near a beautiful lake. The story is complex, with appealing characters and great emotional depth as the topics of grief, natural talent and the hard work of writing are explored. This book is a refreshing look at a relationship that has believable drama, good chemistry between the characters and two adorable dogs named Huck and Finn. This is an enjoyable, heartwarming and soul-touching story of two people who need each other and have to discover that through some really dramatic and life-changing events.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions expressed are my own.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I absolutely adored this small town, faith-filled romance. What a great way to start this new series! I loved Maple Falls and all the cozy fall vibes. And I loved the townsfolk too. I very quickly became invested in the story and couldn’t read fast enough.
I really liked Livvie and Nate. I thought Livvie’s job at the publishing company as a junior agent was really interesting. She was very dedicated and determined about her work and what she believed in. I loved her sunshiney attitude. I really felt for Nate. He was still in the midst of grieving his sister and struggling to finish writing the series they had worked on together. I was really rooting for him. Nate and Livvie were both relatable in their own way. I thought they made such a good team. They pushed each other to do the next hard thing. It wasn’t easy, but it was so great seeing them grow and thrive again. I also really liked Livvie’s Aunt Lila. She was a no-nonsense lady who was also very supportive and full of wise words.
This story was poignant and sweet. Moving and heartfelt. There was a ton of depth and a powerful message of faith too. I loved it so much and highly, highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys small town contemporary romances! I can’t wait to visit Maple Falls again!
I received a copy of this book and voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and comments are my honest opinion.
I really liked Livvie and Nate. I thought Livvie’s job at the publishing company as a junior agent was really interesting. She was very dedicated and determined about her work and what she believed in. I loved her sunshiney attitude. I really felt for Nate. He was still in the midst of grieving his sister and struggling to finish writing the series they had worked on together. I was really rooting for him. Nate and Livvie were both relatable in their own way. I thought they made such a good team. They pushed each other to do the next hard thing. It wasn’t easy, but it was so great seeing them grow and thrive again. I also really liked Livvie’s Aunt Lila. She was a no-nonsense lady who was also very supportive and full of wise words.
This story was poignant and sweet. Moving and heartfelt. There was a ton of depth and a powerful message of faith too. I loved it so much and highly, highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys small town contemporary romances! I can’t wait to visit Maple Falls again!
I received a copy of this book and voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and comments are my honest opinion.
October 23, 2026
5 stars! Absolutely loved it!! A story of grief and pain and hope and love, written beautifully. It has depth and heart. I have read and loved many of Susan’s books, but have never read any by Sarah, but after reading this one, that will change!
October 10, 2026
A beautiful and heartfelt story that will make you believe in second chances, healing, and that God sees us even in the most broken of places. A perfect introduction to Maple Lake!!!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
"You trust that God's writing a better story than you could have plotted yourself."
Wow, I was not expecting Nate and Livvie's story to make me cry. But it did. It will make you cry tears of sorrow, redemption, and joy throughout the book. Nate's grief was palpable - a living thing that he could only hide from. His creative spirit, joy in writing, love for life and faith were all hidden beneath his grief without a way out until Livvie literally barged into his life to shake him up. Livvie had to shed her people pleasing tendencies and need to be useful and to stand up for herself. I loved how Livvie's faith in Nate gave him the inspiration to write and how Nate's faith in Livvie helped her realize she's seen and loved. The grump vs. sunshine trope mixed in with old adolescent crush becoming more worked perfectly with Nate and Livvie. The fantasy book Nate was writing really hooked me; I think Sarah and Susan May Warren should venture into YA fantasy!
I really enjoyed visiting Maple Lake, MN and can't wait for the next book in the series. I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Sunrise Publishing and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
Wow, I was not expecting Nate and Livvie's story to make me cry. But it did. It will make you cry tears of sorrow, redemption, and joy throughout the book. Nate's grief was palpable - a living thing that he could only hide from. His creative spirit, joy in writing, love for life and faith were all hidden beneath his grief without a way out until Livvie literally barged into his life to shake him up. Livvie had to shed her people pleasing tendencies and need to be useful and to stand up for herself. I loved how Livvie's faith in Nate gave him the inspiration to write and how Nate's faith in Livvie helped her realize she's seen and loved. The grump vs. sunshine trope mixed in with old adolescent crush becoming more worked perfectly with Nate and Livvie. The fantasy book Nate was writing really hooked me; I think Sarah and Susan May Warren should venture into YA fantasy!
I really enjoyed visiting Maple Lake, MN and can't wait for the next book in the series. I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Sunrise Publishing and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
October 7, 2026
It's official: Susan May and Sarah Warren make a great team. I went into The Story Between Us already planning to give brownie points since it's about writing and the writer's life, and since it's set in a real autumn (I'm in the South, so summer can be annoyingly clingy). Even without the brownie points though, The Story Between Us was excellent.
I didn't expect to see so much of myself in Livvie Fox, but the more I got to know her, the more I recognized and found encouragement in her. Watching her rediscover who she is, her love of art, and her passion for story and writers, uplifted me in myriad ways. I also found myself challenged and convicted because many of the questions Lila asks Livvie about what she wants and why she's trying to be indispensable, were questions I've only recently learned to ask. Plus, Livvie has a short monologue and strategic decision or two at the end that had me cheering, "YEAH!!!!"
I'll admit that next to Livvie, I worried about Nate's development. I've seen characters whose major arcs revolve around grief before, and they didn't necessarily come off well. Now, a grief arc is incredibly hard to do, so I was prepared to give Nate and his character development plenty of grace. It turned out though, I didn't need it. Nate has every reason to give up because life knocked him down hard. But while he does lean into grief and yes, self-pity, he's still a strong, creative, and incredibly compassionate person. It's just that as Lila says, hurt often gets in his way--as it does with all humans, which creates some wonderful themes about being human and bringing that humanity to God.
Speaking of, the spiritual threads here are subtle. I could argue they're too subtle, since they don't show up much until very close to the end, and one character is said to have faith but also given excuses for a lot of hurtful behavior. I'm also not entirely sure what Susie May and Sarah were trying to do with the "presence" of Emma. I mean, I think I get it, but not quite. That said, the actual conversations about and presence of God are handled gently, deftly, and as if God is a permanent resident of Maple Lake. I've read other books where this happens in and to a certain locale, and I always love it.
I did love the autumn setting. I was a little skeptical of a Flannel Festival--but then, I come from a region that has Woolly Worm and Catfish and Squirrel Festivals, what do I know? Anyway, the Flannel Festival was great fun. And that Storybook Corner! Oh. My. Goodness. I wanted to time travel so my inner little girl could curl up in Thornwood and visit--or visit as an adult!
As with many books like this, there are also plenty of "popping scenes," especially around the writing aspect of the novel. Look for:
-Almost any scene where Nate and Livvie are working on the Thornwood Chronicles together, especially Nate's breakthrough near the end
-The Storybook Corner in and of itself
-The understated symbolism of Livvie's fiddle-leaf fig
-The theme of invisibility vs. being loved for who you are (grab the tissues)!
Overall, this book made me more than excited to return to Maple Lake ASAP. If I can't have the Thornwood Chronicles, I'm sure I'll love a series like this, and I'm sure you will, too. Dive in, preferably with your favorite autumn beverage or soup by your side.
I didn't expect to see so much of myself in Livvie Fox, but the more I got to know her, the more I recognized and found encouragement in her. Watching her rediscover who she is, her love of art, and her passion for story and writers, uplifted me in myriad ways. I also found myself challenged and convicted because many of the questions Lila asks Livvie about what she wants and why she's trying to be indispensable, were questions I've only recently learned to ask. Plus, Livvie has a short monologue and strategic decision or two at the end that had me cheering, "YEAH!!!!"
I'll admit that next to Livvie, I worried about Nate's development. I've seen characters whose major arcs revolve around grief before, and they didn't necessarily come off well. Now, a grief arc is incredibly hard to do, so I was prepared to give Nate and his character development plenty of grace. It turned out though, I didn't need it. Nate has every reason to give up because life knocked him down hard. But while he does lean into grief and yes, self-pity, he's still a strong, creative, and incredibly compassionate person. It's just that as Lila says, hurt often gets in his way--as it does with all humans, which creates some wonderful themes about being human and bringing that humanity to God.
Speaking of, the spiritual threads here are subtle. I could argue they're too subtle, since they don't show up much until very close to the end, and one character is said to have faith but also given excuses for a lot of hurtful behavior. I'm also not entirely sure what Susie May and Sarah were trying to do with the "presence" of Emma. I mean, I think I get it, but not quite. That said, the actual conversations about and presence of God are handled gently, deftly, and as if God is a permanent resident of Maple Lake. I've read other books where this happens in and to a certain locale, and I always love it.
I did love the autumn setting. I was a little skeptical of a Flannel Festival--but then, I come from a region that has Woolly Worm and Catfish and Squirrel Festivals, what do I know? Anyway, the Flannel Festival was great fun. And that Storybook Corner! Oh. My. Goodness. I wanted to time travel so my inner little girl could curl up in Thornwood and visit--or visit as an adult!
As with many books like this, there are also plenty of "popping scenes," especially around the writing aspect of the novel. Look for:
-Almost any scene where Nate and Livvie are working on the Thornwood Chronicles together, especially Nate's breakthrough near the end
-The Storybook Corner in and of itself
-The understated symbolism of Livvie's fiddle-leaf fig
-The theme of invisibility vs. being loved for who you are (grab the tissues)!
Overall, this book made me more than excited to return to Maple Lake ASAP. If I can't have the Thornwood Chronicles, I'm sure I'll love a series like this, and I'm sure you will, too. Dive in, preferably with your favorite autumn beverage or soup by your side.
October 12, 2026
Such an emotional, heartwarming read! This book definitely takes you on a rollercoaster of emotions as you witness the aftermath of grief, what it looks like to get stuck in it, and how to learn to keep living as you begin to heal. There’s also a story within a story and a community so loving and supportive that you’ll want to move there!
Livvie’s career is on the line, so when her job mentions a struggling author who needs help meeting his deadline, she offers to step in. The struggling author is Nate, her late best friend’s brother and her longtime crush! What she thinks will be nothing more than a pep talk quickly turns into helping him navigate his grief and learn how to live again. She also has to help him trust himself and believe he can finish the story he’s writing. But Nate isn’t alone. Livvie is there every step of the way. The question is, is she there just to save her job, or does she want something more? And the more she helps him, the greater the risk of accidentally trampling on his already fragile feelings surrounding his sister’s death. Nate and Livvie both have the chance at a future they want, but they’ll have to step out in faith and learn to trust God and each other. When the deadline passes, they’ll both have to decide what comes next.
I loved this! It is a heavier read, and you truly feel the weight of the grief Nate is carrying. The way he has essentially stopped living broke my heart, and I found myself rooting for Livvie to help him find his way back to life.Watching their friendship grow into admiration, trust, and love was so sweet. And their kisses? They were absolutely worth the wait! I also loved the story within the story and the community’s involvement. Everyone was so invested in Nate’s journey and rooting for him, even when he didn’t realize it. They were all in his corner, and I loved seeing that kind of love and support. This was such a beautiful, emotional story about grief, healing, faith, love, and learning to live again.
I gave it 4.5 stars, rounded up to 5!
Livvie’s career is on the line, so when her job mentions a struggling author who needs help meeting his deadline, she offers to step in. The struggling author is Nate, her late best friend’s brother and her longtime crush! What she thinks will be nothing more than a pep talk quickly turns into helping him navigate his grief and learn how to live again. She also has to help him trust himself and believe he can finish the story he’s writing. But Nate isn’t alone. Livvie is there every step of the way. The question is, is she there just to save her job, or does she want something more? And the more she helps him, the greater the risk of accidentally trampling on his already fragile feelings surrounding his sister’s death. Nate and Livvie both have the chance at a future they want, but they’ll have to step out in faith and learn to trust God and each other. When the deadline passes, they’ll both have to decide what comes next.
I loved this! It is a heavier read, and you truly feel the weight of the grief Nate is carrying. The way he has essentially stopped living broke my heart, and I found myself rooting for Livvie to help him find his way back to life.Watching their friendship grow into admiration, trust, and love was so sweet. And their kisses? They were absolutely worth the wait! I also loved the story within the story and the community’s involvement. Everyone was so invested in Nate’s journey and rooting for him, even when he didn’t realize it. They were all in his corner, and I loved seeing that kind of love and support. This was such a beautiful, emotional story about grief, healing, faith, love, and learning to live again.
I gave it 4.5 stars, rounded up to 5!
September 29, 2026
This book is an emotional landmine with the recurring theme being grief and how it plays out in the lives of those left behind after the death of a loved one, a shattered world left behind in pieces.
Livvie Fox is not a fox in the henhouse in the New York publishing world. She is the polar opposite. She gives to people who have taken credit for her work and has an eye for talent, of which she never gets the credit for finding. When she volunteers to resurrect reclusive author Ian Rivers (Nate Rivers) to get his final book, she heads to Maple Lake. She understands his grief over losing his twin sister (the other half of the duo who actually wrote the other books in the series). Emma was also Livvie's friend.
I have to say that I got tearful quite often reading this book. The dynamic duo who wrote this book really know how to pull on the heartstrings of readers. Nate is in deep pain and has hidden himself away from everyone and everything thinking that was the answer, but it has only exacerbated the condition and deepened his grief.
I loved the way that Nate and Livvie both found themselves at a crossroads in their lives. They could choose to live and be their creative selves or bury themselves away. The romantic tension/chemistry between these two was also painful to watch, as they fought hat was clearly an attraction between two lost souls who needed each other. The story built piece by painful piece as you could see healing taking place, but it was not an easy road.
Livvie was my favorite character as she showed true character in her behavior. She gave and people continued to take from her, but she gave more. That's just who she was. She was a classic example of what everyone should strive to be. The ending was superb. For those who love an inspirational romance with a lot of artistic vibe in the storyline, you will love this one.
Thank you to Sunrise Publishing for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Livvie Fox is not a fox in the henhouse in the New York publishing world. She is the polar opposite. She gives to people who have taken credit for her work and has an eye for talent, of which she never gets the credit for finding. When she volunteers to resurrect reclusive author Ian Rivers (Nate Rivers) to get his final book, she heads to Maple Lake. She understands his grief over losing his twin sister (the other half of the duo who actually wrote the other books in the series). Emma was also Livvie's friend.
I have to say that I got tearful quite often reading this book. The dynamic duo who wrote this book really know how to pull on the heartstrings of readers. Nate is in deep pain and has hidden himself away from everyone and everything thinking that was the answer, but it has only exacerbated the condition and deepened his grief.
I loved the way that Nate and Livvie both found themselves at a crossroads in their lives. They could choose to live and be their creative selves or bury themselves away. The romantic tension/chemistry between these two was also painful to watch, as they fought hat was clearly an attraction between two lost souls who needed each other. The story built piece by painful piece as you could see healing taking place, but it was not an easy road.
Livvie was my favorite character as she showed true character in her behavior. She gave and people continued to take from her, but she gave more. That's just who she was. She was a classic example of what everyone should strive to be. The ending was superb. For those who love an inspirational romance with a lot of artistic vibe in the storyline, you will love this one.
Thank you to Sunrise Publishing for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 16, 2026
Oh, so sweet, another new series of books written with Susan May Warren and other authors. This one is set in the SWEET town of Maple Lake. And when I say sweet, I really mean it because the town is all about maple and maple things, and all things flannel.
It truly sounds like a delightful place to live, but I’d probably gain a ton of weight since there seem to be many yummy places.
This story isn’t all about the yummy stuff; it’s about an author stuck on his last book and how grief has locked him in his house. Nate used to write stories with his sister, but when she died, he couldn’t pick up the pen again. Then in walks Livvie. She’s not only from the agency for his books, but she was also his sister's best friend. She knows him on a deeper level.
There is so much in this story. There’s dealing with grief (or not dealing with grief). There’s finding courage, learning you have worth and value, conquering fears, and overcoming misconceptions. Oh, and there’s also bits of romance and wonderful life lessons woven throughout this story.
Whenever Susan May Warren writes a new book, I jump on it and devour it. When she writes with her daughter Sarah May Warren, well, you know it will be so good because they both have a wonderful flair for writing, and each brings such a wealth of skills that all their books are amazing. Their stories are relatable and fresh. They flow so smoothly that it’s like no time has passed, and you’ve read the whole thing!
I now look forward to continuing with all the other stories that will be set in this town.
I highly recommend picking up this book to start your adventures in Maple Lake with all its yummy and colorful characters.
It truly sounds like a delightful place to live, but I’d probably gain a ton of weight since there seem to be many yummy places.
This story isn’t all about the yummy stuff; it’s about an author stuck on his last book and how grief has locked him in his house. Nate used to write stories with his sister, but when she died, he couldn’t pick up the pen again. Then in walks Livvie. She’s not only from the agency for his books, but she was also his sister's best friend. She knows him on a deeper level.
There is so much in this story. There’s dealing with grief (or not dealing with grief). There’s finding courage, learning you have worth and value, conquering fears, and overcoming misconceptions. Oh, and there’s also bits of romance and wonderful life lessons woven throughout this story.
Whenever Susan May Warren writes a new book, I jump on it and devour it. When she writes with her daughter Sarah May Warren, well, you know it will be so good because they both have a wonderful flair for writing, and each brings such a wealth of skills that all their books are amazing. Their stories are relatable and fresh. They flow so smoothly that it’s like no time has passed, and you’ve read the whole thing!
I now look forward to continuing with all the other stories that will be set in this town.
I highly recommend picking up this book to start your adventures in Maple Lake with all its yummy and colorful characters.
September 23, 2026
"The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit."—Psalm 34: 18 (NIV)
How can I write into words just how I feel about this first book in the Falling for Flannel in Maple Lake, when there is absolutely everything and I do mean everything about this is perfection. Sarah and Susan May Warren, dynamic daughter duo writing partners on a few stories already published. You don’t need hundreds of words to write a review for a book that I don’t think could have gone any more beautiful. These two just have a different kind of mother daughter relationship vibe when it comes to crafting a story. I don’t want to talk about the individual characters as much but the story as a whole. Nate Rivers, is the one half of a world famous author duo, his sister, Emma was the other half. But she has since passed away and now Nate hasn’t wrote in 3 years. Olivia/Livvie is part of the publisher company of Nate’s book and is sent home to help get his next book written and published or he’ll lose the deal and money. These two have such amazing chemistry. Emma and Livvie were best friends when Livvie would spend her summers with her aunt, Lila. I loved so much of this story, it had deep emotional connection in my heart. I love a good story that pulls at my heartstrings and gives me a sense of peace and comfort as well.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are all my own.
How can I write into words just how I feel about this first book in the Falling for Flannel in Maple Lake, when there is absolutely everything and I do mean everything about this is perfection. Sarah and Susan May Warren, dynamic daughter duo writing partners on a few stories already published. You don’t need hundreds of words to write a review for a book that I don’t think could have gone any more beautiful. These two just have a different kind of mother daughter relationship vibe when it comes to crafting a story. I don’t want to talk about the individual characters as much but the story as a whole. Nate Rivers, is the one half of a world famous author duo, his sister, Emma was the other half. But she has since passed away and now Nate hasn’t wrote in 3 years. Olivia/Livvie is part of the publisher company of Nate’s book and is sent home to help get his next book written and published or he’ll lose the deal and money. These two have such amazing chemistry. Emma and Livvie were best friends when Livvie would spend her summers with her aunt, Lila. I loved so much of this story, it had deep emotional connection in my heart. I love a good story that pulls at my heartstrings and gives me a sense of peace and comfort as well.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are all my own.
October 5, 2026
BRILLIANT: 5+ stars!
Ms Warren’s authentic level of emotion, empathy and tension in this novel makes the reader feel included in the lives of the characters and I was captivated from beginning to end by the personalities, the plot and the setting.
Livvie is a complex character who combines the assertiveness required by her career, with the compliance she learned from her childhood experiences with workaholic parents, and which ultimately destroys her formal employment.
Kayaking and engaging with his dogs have been Nate’s only meaningful activities in three years. His intense grief, anger and even the undue guilt he feels will challenge many readers’ understanding. Livvie’s insight and the past tentative relationship they shared are the triggers Nate needs to rekindle his creativity, enabling him to realise his independence from his sister, Emma and to help him to begin living a more normal life.
Aunt Lila’s perceptive reassurances of Livvie’s rationale for her endeavours, and Nate’s changing moods in response to Livvie’s well-meaning actions give this novel extra impact.
However, the process of writing also fascinated me: Nate’s writer’s block initiated by his traumatic loss, the motivating process, the exchange of ideas which reflect reality and are translated into fantasy, and the sudden inspiration that allows the fluent recording of the story.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
Ms Warren’s authentic level of emotion, empathy and tension in this novel makes the reader feel included in the lives of the characters and I was captivated from beginning to end by the personalities, the plot and the setting.
Livvie is a complex character who combines the assertiveness required by her career, with the compliance she learned from her childhood experiences with workaholic parents, and which ultimately destroys her formal employment.
Kayaking and engaging with his dogs have been Nate’s only meaningful activities in three years. His intense grief, anger and even the undue guilt he feels will challenge many readers’ understanding. Livvie’s insight and the past tentative relationship they shared are the triggers Nate needs to rekindle his creativity, enabling him to realise his independence from his sister, Emma and to help him to begin living a more normal life.
Aunt Lila’s perceptive reassurances of Livvie’s rationale for her endeavours, and Nate’s changing moods in response to Livvie’s well-meaning actions give this novel extra impact.
However, the process of writing also fascinated me: Nate’s writer’s block initiated by his traumatic loss, the motivating process, the exchange of ideas which reflect reality and are translated into fantasy, and the sudden inspiration that allows the fluent recording of the story.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
October 21, 2026
I loved it! I love the conversational style of writing - so similar to Cindy Nichols (my favorite). For a HEA story it was a new plot concept and a fun one. The characters were so real I felt as if I was sometimes in the room with them sitting beside each. The dogs were adorable with their behavior on point. It was a lovely story about an unusual and unique situation. Livvie is adorable and her aunt is special. I also liked that it didn't have proselytizing in a Christian novel. Faith was sprinkled in in a delicate way.
I do have a few critiques. I don't like "cutesy" covers like this one. I actually don't like some of my own covers but that's my publisher's style. I am over cardigans! Doesn't anyone in this book ware anything else? I am also over a character sliding against a wall and ending up sitting on the floor with knees bent. I can't imagine a grown man doing this no matter what the circumstance. Actually, I can't imagine anyone doing it.
Oh, well . . . other than my personal offenses, it's a definite keeper. A unique story with delightful characters who seem to have the ability to zoom across country overnight. Where do they get those plane reservations? Not in 2026. Please read this story. I know you will enjoy it. It will fill your heart with hope.
I do have a few critiques. I don't like "cutesy" covers like this one. I actually don't like some of my own covers but that's my publisher's style. I am over cardigans! Doesn't anyone in this book ware anything else? I am also over a character sliding against a wall and ending up sitting on the floor with knees bent. I can't imagine a grown man doing this no matter what the circumstance. Actually, I can't imagine anyone doing it.
Oh, well . . . other than my personal offenses, it's a definite keeper. A unique story with delightful characters who seem to have the ability to zoom across country overnight. Where do they get those plane reservations? Not in 2026. Please read this story. I know you will enjoy it. It will fill your heart with hope.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Loved it! Great start to a new series!
Livvie Fox has a special place in her heart for Maple Lake Minnesota, her wise Aunt Lila, and her best friend Emma and yes, Emma's older brother Nate also. Only Livvie's been gone for several years, her best friend died young from a long time illness, and Nate has been stuck in grief for the last 3 years since his sister's funeral. The brother sister duo wrote a best selling series together and Nate is at a complete loss without his sister. Livvie is amazing at her job but extremely un-noticed and underappreciated. Since she knows the author, she is sent by the publisher to help Nate get writing and finish the book.
"Nate stared at her. The fierce, brilliant woman who'd showed up at his door and refused to leave. Who'd read his books. Who'd asked the questions no one else thought to ask and then waited-trusted him to find the answers."
You don't want to miss this wonderful story by the mother-daughter duo Susan May Warren and Sarah May Warren. I can't wait for the next one in the series!
Thank you to Sunrise Publishing for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own.
Livvie Fox has a special place in her heart for Maple Lake Minnesota, her wise Aunt Lila, and her best friend Emma and yes, Emma's older brother Nate also. Only Livvie's been gone for several years, her best friend died young from a long time illness, and Nate has been stuck in grief for the last 3 years since his sister's funeral. The brother sister duo wrote a best selling series together and Nate is at a complete loss without his sister. Livvie is amazing at her job but extremely un-noticed and underappreciated. Since she knows the author, she is sent by the publisher to help Nate get writing and finish the book.
"Nate stared at her. The fierce, brilliant woman who'd showed up at his door and refused to leave. Who'd read his books. Who'd asked the questions no one else thought to ask and then waited-trusted him to find the answers."
You don't want to miss this wonderful story by the mother-daughter duo Susan May Warren and Sarah May Warren. I can't wait for the next one in the series!
Thank you to Sunrise Publishing for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own.
October 1, 2026
Oh, the joy of a new series! How can one not trip over themselves to read a series called "Falling for Flannel"? SWOON.
In The Story Between Us, authors Susan and Sarah May Warren introduce us to Livvie Fox, a gal with great ideas for her publishing job, but who lacks the "New York shark attitude" she needs to get ahead. She's so nice! We also meet Nate Fox, a famous writer WAY past his deadline, but filled with grief-induced writer's block. Livvie has to save the book to save her job. What her boss doesn't know is she and Nate have history.
Did I mention the word 'swoon" already? Not only is this a charming love story stemming from a years-prior "almost kiss", but the grief aspect and working through it was so thoughtfully written. As someone told me when my own father died, "You never get over it, but you learn to live with it". This book really resonated with me for that and touched my heart. There's healing, heart, strength, confidence, faith, and love. I can't wait to head back to Maple Lake!
My thanks for the complimentary copy of this book. My opinions are entirely my own.
In The Story Between Us, authors Susan and Sarah May Warren introduce us to Livvie Fox, a gal with great ideas for her publishing job, but who lacks the "New York shark attitude" she needs to get ahead. She's so nice! We also meet Nate Fox, a famous writer WAY past his deadline, but filled with grief-induced writer's block. Livvie has to save the book to save her job. What her boss doesn't know is she and Nate have history.
Did I mention the word 'swoon" already? Not only is this a charming love story stemming from a years-prior "almost kiss", but the grief aspect and working through it was so thoughtfully written. As someone told me when my own father died, "You never get over it, but you learn to live with it". This book really resonated with me for that and touched my heart. There's healing, heart, strength, confidence, faith, and love. I can't wait to head back to Maple Lake!
My thanks for the complimentary copy of this book. My opinions are entirely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
If 'The Story Between Us' is an example of what the Warren women can do as a team, then I want alllllll the books! It's sweet but not sappy and tragic but not depressing; instead, it's inspiring in all the right ways. It's PERFECT.
I absolutely love Livvie. Talented and kind, she needs to learn her place and her worth, but I love her heart for helping others.
Nate is the ultimate sad, hunky hero in flannel. He's so relatable as he tries to hide from his hurt, but it's wonderful to watch him bloom again, even if he does have a few ... um ... problems along the way.
I can't WAIT for more of this series: the characters are great, the lessons are deep, and the town is one I want to go visit, so .....
If you like to read books that make you want to pick up and move, I highly recommend grabbing a copy of 'The Story Between Us' now. It's too good to miss.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
I absolutely love Livvie. Talented and kind, she needs to learn her place and her worth, but I love her heart for helping others.
Nate is the ultimate sad, hunky hero in flannel. He's so relatable as he tries to hide from his hurt, but it's wonderful to watch him bloom again, even if he does have a few ... um ... problems along the way.
I can't WAIT for more of this series: the characters are great, the lessons are deep, and the town is one I want to go visit, so .....
If you like to read books that make you want to pick up and move, I highly recommend grabbing a copy of 'The Story Between Us' now. It's too good to miss.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Grab a box of tissues and settle into the absolutely wonderful story that is The Story Between Us.
Nate Rivers is a grumpy author who hasn’t written a word in three years. The story ended with the death of his sister with whom he wrote his previous four books.
Livvie Fox is a junior agent at a literary agency. Livvie is invisible. Others take credit for her work and she lets them. She feels completely unseen and as if she has no voice.
With a looming lawsuit on the horizon if Nate doesn’t finish book five, Livvie offers to head to Maple Lake to help Nate, her late best friend’s brother.
If this book is any indication as to what the series will be like I can’t wait to read all of them. This book made me cry, chuckle, and fall in love with Maple Lake. I found aspects of both character’s personalities to be relatable. This story was just amazing!!
I received an arc of this book from the publisher. My opinions are my own.
Nate Rivers is a grumpy author who hasn’t written a word in three years. The story ended with the death of his sister with whom he wrote his previous four books.
Livvie Fox is a junior agent at a literary agency. Livvie is invisible. Others take credit for her work and she lets them. She feels completely unseen and as if she has no voice.
With a looming lawsuit on the horizon if Nate doesn’t finish book five, Livvie offers to head to Maple Lake to help Nate, her late best friend’s brother.
If this book is any indication as to what the series will be like I can’t wait to read all of them. This book made me cry, chuckle, and fall in love with Maple Lake. I found aspects of both character’s personalities to be relatable. This story was just amazing!!
I received an arc of this book from the publisher. My opinions are my own.
September 29, 2026
First off, I have to say I am loving these mother-daughter co-authored books! Susan and Sarah are a dynamic duo! Now for the story... if your familiar with Susan's Jonathan Island series, then you have found a mainland version in the town of Maple Lake, complete with festivals and all! Livvie Fox is living her dream working for a publishing company... or so she thinks... She remembers details about everyone, brings cupcakes, keeps the plant alive...but she keeps getting passed over for promotion and her ideas get taken by someone else. Nate is an author with Livvie's publishing company and the boy from her past. But Nate's sister passed away and he can't find the words to write the book that is due per his publishing contract. Livvie volunteers to go back to Maple Lake and see if she can get the book out of Nate. Sparks fly, healing starts, but can the book get done in time and can both Nate and Livvie find complete healing through it all?
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
A beautiful book of love and healing. Thank you to Sunrise Media Publishing for the book. All opinions are my own.
Nate has been grieving the death of his sister for three years. She was the other half of their writing duo. He hasn't been able to write anything since. He lives the life of a hermit.
Livvie is a junior agent at a publishing firm. She is also a friend of Nate and his sister, Emma, who has passed away. She volunteers to try to help him get the next book finished in two weeks. If she doesn't, Nate will be sued and owe $500,000 to the firm for the advance he received, and Livvie will be out of a job.
I love the arc of both of these characters. The healing that takes place in both of their lives. The need for faith that emerges.
I loved it.
Nate has been grieving the death of his sister for three years. She was the other half of their writing duo. He hasn't been able to write anything since. He lives the life of a hermit.
Livvie is a junior agent at a publishing firm. She is also a friend of Nate and his sister, Emma, who has passed away. She volunteers to try to help him get the next book finished in two weeks. If she doesn't, Nate will be sued and owe $500,000 to the firm for the advance he received, and Livvie will be out of a job.
I love the arc of both of these characters. The healing that takes place in both of their lives. The need for faith that emerges.
I loved it.
October 8, 2026
I love a bookish romance!
The fact that this one brought two friends and childhood sweethearts back together made the story even better! I also really want to read the Thornwood series now!
Livvie and Nate were such a sweet couple. And I loved how the book Nate needed to write brought them back together, but the way they saw each other was really what drew me in. The way Livvie knew what Nate needed in order to get writing again. And the way he had always noticed her when she thought she was invisible.
As always with these two authors, the message of faith weaved into the pages of this story were beautiful too. I loved the reminders of trust, faith, and love that I found in these pages.
Definitely would recommend!
The fact that this one brought two friends and childhood sweethearts back together made the story even better! I also really want to read the Thornwood series now!
Livvie and Nate were such a sweet couple. And I loved how the book Nate needed to write brought them back together, but the way they saw each other was really what drew me in. The way Livvie knew what Nate needed in order to get writing again. And the way he had always noticed her when she thought she was invisible.
As always with these two authors, the message of faith weaved into the pages of this story were beautiful too. I loved the reminders of trust, faith, and love that I found in these pages.
Definitely would recommend!
October 9, 2026
This is a good story. I liked the small-town feel, the fall vibes, and the idea of a flannel festival. Livvie and Lila were probably my favorite characters. Aunt and niece. Nate kinda got on my nerves a few times. I really hoped he wouldn't do what he ended up doing, but he did redeem himself by the end. It mentions faith in God, but it feels thrown in, almost to the point that it feels off. I don't know if that makes much sense. At one point, Nate gets a phone call from his mom, who hasn't really been mentioned up to that point. I don't know...about 3/4th into the book, things kinda felt rushed.
Overall, I enjoyed the story and highlighted several phrases.
Rating: PG
Language: clean read
Recommend: yes
Overall, I enjoyed the story and highlighted several phrases.
Rating: PG
Language: clean read
Recommend: yes
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews