Is rage reading healthy? productive? ... Well, if you think so, it's definitely worth reading this. All of this continues to make both incredibly angry and profoundly sad.
My hat's off to Lewis, who I tend to like anyway ... I've read a fair number of his books and really enjoyed most of them. But even if this isn't a great book, I'm particularly enamored with, and appreciative of, the undertaking - his Trump-era (now) trilogy, The Fifth Risk and its follow-on companions, Who is Government?, and now this.
On the one hand this is an anecdote-driven expose of the naive, misguided, poorly orchestrated, embarrassing, almost certainly self-serving, and ultimately failed, DOGE (Musk-driven Department of Government Efficiency) debacle, while also, similar to the other two related books, a celebration of a small number of the extraordinary people (now formerly) in federal government or service that do great things for the public that most folks don't think or know about (but, if they did, they'd appreciate ... unless, in some cases, they're so fundamentally cruel that that part of their mind (or soul?) just doesn't function ... Side note: pages 208-215 in the hardback, the extended riff on Russell Vought is only shockingly depressing if you haven't been following him and his handiwork for years.
What's particularly crazy, reading the book by the time it made it onto bookstore shelves, is that, in light of all of the insanity we read about in the daily news, it's easy to forget about DOGE.... But we shouldn't. So, once again, I'm glad Lewis wrote this (and that I bought and read it).
It's difficult for me to be objective about this stuff. I've spent my entire professional life either in federal service or in work related to, broadly, the business of government. Alas, (it is what it is, but) I'm not terribly sympathetic to folks who (not only permitted, but facilitated, and, for some, celebrated, Trump twice becoming President, but) complain about paying taxes (yeah, I'm with Oliver Wendall Holmes: Taxes are what [or the price] we pay for a civilized society.) but expect, among other things, safe air travel, smooth highways (and public infrastructure), safe food, accurate weather reporting (and disaster support and firefighting services), access to innovative medical interventions, stable banking and financial markets, a national defense, and, well, you get the idea.
As part of the generation that grew up learning Civics or being taught the value of government in school (remember all of that stuff about how with rights come responsibilities?), part of me thinks that books two and three in this trilogy would make for terrific reading (or supplemental reading) in one of those classes today. Then I'm reminded that one of the reasons we got to this point is that so many advocated so strongly against maintaining those kinds of classes in public school curricula (or, of course, diluted the public school systems) ... while, at the same time, increasingly rejecting science as, well, science, ... and I would say, at this point, I'm digressing, but ... nah ... read the book.