Well, it is "A Student Guide". Short, but it was a bit of a chore to get through. Some wonderful insights of his own, and also sharing important ideas from other critics. But, lacks vibrancy and humor - something that other Homeric scholars have been able to include in their texts.
I'm back to Homer after 40 years, and now finding that I need to read HIM, rather than books about him. On to the Oyssey!
The "Guide to Further Reading" is made up of a handful of short pieces, each in essay form. Unfortunately, when he cites critical works in his text he gives the author's name and the page number. It is then up to the reader to try and find that book in whichever and wherever in the short bibilographic pieces at the end of the book! Not handy.
Given all that, I do appreciate his scholarship, and including so much important information and critic theory in a short, introductory volume. I would read something by him again if I came acorss it.