Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Davis Twins #2

Making Choices

Rate this book
Both of the Davis twins are sexy and irresistible.
Will you choose the sweet and sensitive brother or the rakish bad boy?

In Taking Chances, the first book in this exciting series, we met Abigail Brown, a 28-year-old divorcée who had never felt sexually satisfied, much to her chagrin. Abby thought she had discovered her happily-ever-after ending when she stumbled upon the perfect man, who showed her the intense sensual bliss her body was capable of enjoying. Just when you thought you had this book all figured out, some unexpected surprises came along and completely shook up Abby's world.

Now, in Making Choices, the second book of Abby's story, she is faced with the impossible decision of choosing between the Davis twins. Who will Abby choose? Who should she choose? Will her decision make the twins hate each other? Abby has made a mess of her life. Will she be able to fix it and mend the relationship between the brothers she cares about? The wait is over! Find out now in Making Choices.

If you love naughty, complicated love triangles, you definitely want to spend the day (or night) getting to know the Davis twins!

186 pages, Kindle Edition

First published December 15, 2013

156 people are currently reading
963 people want to read

About the author

Ann Omasta

172 books1,136 followers
Ann Omasta is a USA Today bestselling author.

Subscribe to her YouTube channel for FREE audiobooks! https://www.youtube.com/@annomastaauthor

Here is a Top 10 list from Ann about her likes, dislikes, and oddities:

1. I despise whipped cream. There, I admitted it in writing. Let the ridiculing begin.
2. Even though I have lived as far south as Key Largo, Florida and as far north as Maine, I landed in the middle.
3. If I don't make a conscious effort not to, I will drink nothing but tea morning, noon and night. Hot tea, sweet tea, green tea––I love it all.
4. There doesn't seem to be much in life that is better than coming home to a couple of big dogs who are overjoyed to see me. My other family members usually show significantly less enthusiasm about my return.
5. Singing in my bestest, loudest voice does not make my family put on their happy faces. This includes the big, loving dogs referenced above.
6. Yes, I am aware that bestest is not a word.
7. Dorothy was right. There's no place like home.
8. All of the numerous bottles in my shower must be lined up with their labels facing out. It makes me feel a little like Julia Roberts' mean husband from the movie 'Sleeping with the Enemy,' but I can't seem to control this particular quirk.
9. I love, love, love finding a great bargain.
10. Did I mention that I hate whipped cream? It makes my stomach churn to look at it, touch it, smell it, or even think about it. Great––now I'm thinking about it. Ick!

** Ann would LOVE to send you a free novella ~ Aloha, Baby! Visit annomasta.com to let her know where to send it.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
199 (38%)
4 stars
168 (32%)
3 stars
108 (21%)
2 stars
23 (4%)
1 star
15 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
Profile Image for Terisa.
818 reviews6 followers
January 7, 2014
Abby finds herself pregnant and unsure who the father of her baby is. Is it Seth, the sweet amazing man that got scared and ran off when she told him that she loved him or was it his naughty identical twin brother, Sam, that makes her skin break out with goose bumps every time they’re in the same room together? Both men have forgiven her for her indiscretions and are patently waiting for her to choose. Of course, neither of them know that she’s pregnant and since she slept with both of them within 10 days of each other, there is really no way to find out.

I thought that there would be more drama in this book considering the plot but because both men were so amazing, there really wasn’t. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and laughed out loud at the epilogue when we finally find out what happened with ice bucket. I don’t want to give anything away so I won’t tell you who she finally chooses but I will tell you that there is a happily after for everyone in this book and I loved the way that author described the choosing of the name for the baby.
Profile Image for Mia Kerick.
Author 42 books539 followers
January 7, 2014
Ann Omasta may be a romance author but her novels’ plots are so chock full of twists and turns that they have the makings of mystery. As the plots lifts you and carries you away on its wild ride (you know the ones where you think so hard that you become convinced you know what is about to happen, in fact you are sure of it, but then it doesn’t happen) Omasta deals with issues of trust—in your own instincts as well as in the word of others—the concept of family—whether it is created by blood or choice or both, and the essence of what matters most.

I enjoyed Omasta’s first novel in the Chances and Choices Duology and am now fully satisfied by its sequel Making Choices. Highly recommended.
Profile Image for Karen Shortridge.
1,459 reviews19 followers
June 15, 2016
I read all three books one after the other and I seriously could not stop, I loved all the characters and this part of a wonderful story. Honestly I laughed until I cried quite a few times and teared up just as many you do get drawn into their world. In this part Abby has a very hard decision to make after finding herself pregnant and now told both Sam & Seth but she also doesn't know who the father is and they both want her so now she has to make that decision on who she wants???
Does she follow her heart and choose Seth who is the stable, grounded guy or choose Sam the one she thinks about always, can't keep her hands off, bad boy who sleeps around.
Courtney helps her a lot and it's great how they are there for each other. I can't wait to find out next part........
456 reviews2 followers
January 14, 2018
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Chances and Choices

I cheated...I had to know which Davis Abby ended up with and I cheated early in the book, before she had met Seth’s brother Sam. To say I loved this book would be an understatement...I inhaled it. While at times I thought Abby was a bit delusional with her rationalizations she really suffered from poor decisions making syndrome.
So I sometimes received questions about my reviews if there was cheating I the book. I can say that some narrow minded people might considered this a cheating but I totally didn’t. I just bought the omnibus edition with all four stories. It’s a Rave .from Me.
Profile Image for Kim Wijnja.
1,354 reviews5 followers
December 23, 2017
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
when I started the book I thought .. okay, we're going to look at it from his side. but when I read that it started on her side, I was very surprised. it was wonderful to read .. I soon found out that I had already brought in three parts before and so could just continue with the story. in a word a top book .. I will continue with part three.
Profile Image for Mary Winstead.
1,263 reviews16 followers
May 25, 2020
Making choices

Boy did Abby mess up sleeping with identical twins a week apart. Now pregnant too! What is Abby gonna do? She has to decide if she wants good guy Seth or Bad boy Sam? Hard decision to make, who will she choose? Loved this story being a Michigan girl myself. Great read.
Profile Image for Ashley Hedden.
5,259 reviews43 followers
May 5, 2023
Making Choices (The Davis Twins #2) was a great read by Ann Omasta. Abby is faces with the impossible decision of choosing which twin she is in love with. Abby knows she has made a mess of her life and doesn't want to get in between the brothers. I enjoyed reading this book and can't wait to read more by the author.
Profile Image for Victoria.
20 reviews
September 24, 2017
The first book was left with such uncertainty yet this book started right up with a definitive choice & the other brother acknowledging it was the right choice. Not at all like the characters at the end of the first book. Was expecting more angst.
Profile Image for Sylvie.
471 reviews2 followers
September 25, 2017
Anna is pregnant but is the baby Sam’s or Seth’s? An interesting read as the brother’s find out about the pregnancy and determine who the father is. Will one of them step up to be a father to her baby? Or will they be upset she slept with them both and let her deal with the pregnancy on her own?
278 reviews4 followers
September 30, 2020
Making Choices

When you find out you're pregnant and you're not sure who the father is, because you slept with twin brothers.. ..you have to make choices. Will they be the right ones?
Profile Image for Angela Quesada.
366 reviews
September 29, 2017
this was a good book - i just couldnt handle the wishy washy, insecure thoughts that came from this chick. I had to read past it.
Profile Image for Crystal.
87 reviews1 follower
November 23, 2017
I love

The Davis twins, they know tge meaning of FAMILY. Abigail and Courtney are a great pair of bffs. Annie, Abigails boss makes the book...she is hilarious. Off to buy book 3
1 review
May 22, 2018
Good Read fast read. Would recommend

Good Read fast read would recommend looking to read more from this author. Enjoyed this series have yet to read book 3
897 reviews1 follower
June 7, 2019
Drama continues as with the fantastic sex, but I'm glad she followed her heart.
Profile Image for Rosemary Hughes.
4,192 reviews23 followers
March 13, 2020
Okay, two possible fathers, both identical, so no chance at DNA elimination, one sweet kind caring and tender. The other darker, more dangerous, more sensuous.
How do you choose??
Profile Image for Indi Lane.
94 reviews
March 29, 2020
Actual rating 2.5
Besides sexual chemistry, these characters have nothing to build their relationship on. It just seems like a rather superficial romance to me
Profile Image for Melinda.
426 reviews
January 24, 2023
Not an overall bad book but it seemed very surface level of things and there was not much drama. For a book series that started out hot, it fizzled out. The drama came from her insecurities
Profile Image for Mckayla.
60 reviews16 followers
October 7, 2023
I had to dnf this book unfortunately I just couldn’t stay into it, I think a lot of people would enjoy I just got bored and moved onto a new book. 😅
Profile Image for Nancy Brady.
Author 7 books45 followers
November 21, 2015
The second half of romance duology that features Abigail involved with a set of identical twins, Seth and Sam Davis. Now pregnant, she must choose between the two...and she wants to choose the man she loves. The one that makes her heart race...the one that completes her.

But which one is the man she loves? Which one is the baby's father?

In this spicy romance, both of these men play a large part in her life. So, too, do her best friends Courtney and Annie. As her body grows ever larger with her baby, Abby will have to make some hard decisions in this conclusion of the first where she was torn between two lovers...
Profile Image for Tina.
783 reviews13 followers
October 16, 2014
This is the sequel to "Taking Chances", Book 2 (Making Choices) is the final book in "The Chances and Choices Duoligy"

This read (both books) was pure fluffy fun. I enjoyed reading both books. They were funny and entertaining. There was no great character or plot depth in my opinion but still I felt for the hero & heroine. Definitely an intriguing story that had lots of giggling moments.

At times it felt like there were things the author left out. It felt like she knew things that we didn't get to know. This was only a small issue though.




813 reviews4 followers
September 1, 2014
Abigail us in trouble. After sleeping with both brothers she doesn't know what to do. Seth has come back after disappearing, to say he lives her but she has to be honest with him and let him know she slept with his twin brother. They come to her and says that she has to chose. But she leaves for a week to do some thinking and do it alone. But will she find a solution? Which brother will she chose!
Profile Image for Keatyn's Mommy.
425 reviews1 follower
May 15, 2015
Twice the fun with Twins

Abby is just the run of the mill shy woman until she meets Sexy Seth! With having to leave post-it's for inspiration and little pep talks to having fun with twins. I fell in like with Abby. Seth is the man of her dreams until she meets Sam his identical twin brother!! Whew!! Are they completely identical? Only way to find out is to give it a read.

Great book would love more of this crazy crew of people!!
Profile Image for Shay.
515 reviews4 followers
January 9, 2014
The soap opera of Abigail and the Davis brothers continues in the second book. I still was able to predict what was coming, and still couldn't put the book down. This book felt a bit more rushed to get to the end and I was a little disappointed in the wrap up with Seth. But I still recommend it for someone looking for a little drama.
Profile Image for Kristin.
426 reviews
December 27, 2016
Great read

This was a great follow up to book one!! Abby must decide between two hot twin brothers and who she can see herself with!! What a terrible position to be in...right....to hotties... Will she just run away and choose neither or settle down now that she has more on her plate and just her to think about. A must read..can't wait to read more
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.