Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ivy League Players #4

Unforgettable Player

Rate this book
Ever fallen in love with someone you shouldn't have fallen in love with?

Connor feels like a failure. After taking a break from his Ivy League college to work a sales job in California, he is home to fulfil a promise to his old junior hockey coach.
Like he doesn't have enough problems, a guy he's known all his life as his sister's adorkable best friend has become hot overnight and he's about to be stuck with him for the entire summer break.

Elliot has had a crush on his best friend's older brother for as long as he can remember. He had his gay awakening to the sight of Connor Ryan standing in the laundry room in his underwear for god's sake!
Good job he's used to ignoring his straight guy crush. Plus, if Scout discovered that his childish crush still stood, the friendship would be ruined.

This is book four in the Ivy League Players series; a series of books set at a different college with a new set of characters in each story. Each book can be read in any order and as a standalone.

Best friend's brother, nerd/jock, hockey coaching, forbidden love, forced proximity and childhood crushes come to life.

264 pages, Paperback

Published June 6, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Emmery Fox

15 books121 followers
When I'm not trying to invent the perfect book boyfriend, I'm studying towards a graduate degree in Modern History, trying to little avail to get better at drawing and watching You've Got Mail for the millionth time!

I write spicy MM romance with special emphasis on sports, small towns and childhood sweethearts.

I love romance books with spicy scenes that don't feel detached from the couple's relationship dynamics, and when our protagonists respect and root for each other.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
138 (24%)
4 stars
238 (42%)
3 stars
160 (28%)
2 stars
20 (3%)
1 star
4 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
Profile Image for Kenreadsalot.
587 reviews13 followers
July 3, 2026
This is a good 3 stars. It wasn’t revolutionary enough to get 4 stars, but it was a good simple read. The whole sibling’s best friend trope is kind of silly in my opinion. The relationship and spice was pretty good though. Cute!

Enjoyment (5) 3
Feelings (1) .5
Plot (1) .25
Setting (1) .25
Respectability/writing (1) .5
Characters (1) .5

Total rating: 5
Profile Image for Elle.
424 reviews7 followers
June 17, 2026
sometimes it’s just like well i read it and that’s something
Profile Image for Maddi Marina.
591 reviews2 followers
June 7, 2026
such a solid book in a very solid standalone series! i loved the growing connection between elliot and connor and seeing them fight their true feelings in an effort to keep it “casual”. while i was right there with elliot being anxious about scout not knowing and feeling betrayed, i always feel like it’s so much better to just let them know, but that being said i think the revelation about their feelings was done super well and i just loved how scout and connor’s family always embraced elliot. i also think the storyline with elliot’s father and grief/depression was beautiful and added to the depth of the story, especially with it being such a short book.
Profile Image for Mother Of Dragons 86.
115 reviews3 followers
November 16, 2026
ALC Review provided by Blue Nose Audio

UNFORGETTABLE PLAYER

Emmery Fox | Ivy League Players

A sweet, spicy MM hockey romance with childhood crushes, secret feelings, and a surprisingly emotional storyline.

I really enjoyed Eli and Connor's relationship. Eli, with his quiet, nerdy personality and feelings he's kept hidden for years, and Connor, who's struggling with his own insecurities and trying to figure out where he belongs. Their chemistry was lovely, and I loved watching them find something special in each other.

But what really stood out to me was the way the author handled grief, depression, and the pressure of feeling like you're never good enough. Some moments were genuinely heartbreaking.

There's also a philosophical conversation about the different ways we can destroy ourselves, either by chasing temporary pleasures or by denying ourselves happiness in the name of doing what's right. That message really stayed with me.

As for Scout... well, she drove me absolutely nuts. She's loud, bossy, overbearing, and sometimes downright obnoxious. Definitely not my favorite character. 😂

THE AUDIOBOOK 🎧

Nathaniel Ames was such a wonderful discovery! His performance was emotionally engaging, expressive, and beautifully captured Eli's personality and emotions.

Liam DiCosimo was good as always, with natural pacing and dialogue that flowed comfortably, although some parts felt a little flat in their intonation.

BOOK: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5

AUDIOBOOK: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5

Not my favorite in the Ivy League Players series (Unrecognizable Player still holds that spot!), but definitely one I'd recommend. A lovely MM hockey romance with more emotional depth than I initially expected.
Profile Image for Karohere.
16 reviews
October 14, 2026
The story is pretty cute, and they have a lot of chemistry. I’m not the biggest fan of the sister. There are definitely a few plotlines that were just randomly dropped or felt rushed, but the book is pretty short, so it makes sense. There are also some spelling mistakes in the book.
Profile Image for Alex.
246 reviews
October 27, 2026
I had a hard time enjoying this one - the characters weren't as likeable and I wasn't feeling the dynamics between anyone
Profile Image for Gudrun Lara.
132 reviews1 follower
September 21, 2026
Rating: 2,5⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️

If I am being honest then I have to say that this was my least favorite book in the series🫣
It took my suuuch a long time getting into it since I wasn’t really vibing with it

Also I got to add that Scout just irritated me a lot cause miss girl calm down please!

This isn’t as spicy as the other three books in the series but the spicy scenes were spicy
Profile Image for Rosenthal Read.
141 reviews1 follower
July 18, 2026
DNF 54%

Il n’y a aucune alchimie entre les personnages.
Assez pauvre en émotion. On ne comprend pas d’où sort l’attirance de Connor, elle est littéralement juste sexuelle pour moi, quand bien même l’auteur essaye de nous faire croire qu’il le kiffe à mort alors que ça arrive d’un coup, sans raison. On apprend à 30% du roman qu’il le voit de temps en temps sur le campus car ils sont à la même fac et quand il se retrouve avec lui l’été il se rend compte qu’il a changé physiquement qu’il lui plaît…. C’est pas cohérent ! Ça n’a pas de sens, ça manque d’explication ! À la limite ça fait 5/6 ans qu’ils ne s’étaient pas vus, pq pas mais là… et puis Connor qui savait que Eliott avait un crush et il n’en parle pas, ne se demande pas si c’est encore le cas, ce n’est même pas un sujet !
Je ne comprends pas pq Scout est aussi insupportable avec frère, a mener Eliott par le bout du nez. Alors que des qu’elle peut elle dit qu’elle adore son frère, qu’il aurait du lui parler de ses pb… meuf tu lui parles mal, tu le repousses et tu l’insultes tout le temps ! Meme moi j’aurais pas eu envie de te parler
On comprend pas trop non pq Connor a tout abandonné sans se battre d’ailleurs, juste pcq il ne veut pas être dans une ligue mineur. Mec redescend sur terre, accepte quelques échecs et rebondis
C’est vraiment bâclé dans l’intrigue et la narration
Et je trouve Connor limite parfois sur le consentement ! Eliott lui dit plein de fois non, ou que ce n’est pas une bonne idée, OK il dit qu’il est 100% in dans sa tête mais jamais vraiment à voix haute avant que Connor le toi je ou l’embrasse… et Connor je l’ai trouvé plusieurs fois forceur (genre quand ils dorment dans le même lit)
Bref ça ne l’a pas fait MAIS je vais en tenter un autre de la série histoire de voir
Profile Image for Jen Wycech.
1,974 reviews36 followers
November 16, 2026
Best Friend’s Brother
Nerd x Jock
MM Romance
Size Difference
Hurt x Comfort
Friends to Lovers
Dual POV - 1st person

Duet narration - Liam DiCosimo & Nathaniel Ames
Perfection. These two were wonderful together.

Book #4 Ivy League Players series

I am loving this series by Emmery Fox. The characters are likeable, the stories are easy to follow, and entertaining. This one follows Connor as he returns home for a few weeks for a leave from his job in sales after blowing up on his boss. Connor struggles with feeling like he is enough for anything. He was in college but not doing great, he is a hockey player but feels his skills are mediocre at best, and he doesn't want to disappoint his family. Elliott is Connor's sisters nerdy friend that has had a crush on Connor for years but he is certain Connor is straight... but is he really?

This story is super sweet & cute, fast paced and easy to read in one sitting. I ate their story up. I loved that Connor is a jock but completely comfortable with his sexuality. He is not ashamed of being who he is in that aspect of his life all while second guessing himself in everything else. Elliott was adorable. Dealing with family drama with his dad yet staying strong with his schoolwork. Connor & Elliott are wonderful together giving support to one another where it is needed.

Overall, I enjoyed the book. This series is full of heartwarming, sweet, cute, & spicy MM stories. Loving it.

Thank you Emmery Fox & Blue Nose Audio for this ALC.
November 15, 2026
Unforgettable Player 🎧
Written by: Emmery Fox
Performed by: Liam DiCosimo & Nathaniel Ames

✨ALC REVIEW ✨

Thank you to BlueNose Audio for the ALC and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

This series is crazy cute. It’s good for a pallet cleanse also. Each one so dang cute, they tug your giggle strings. Ms Fox does such a good job at keeping to her story line but it’s definitely not cookie cutter.
The narration carried this story so much, I finished in a day. The slowest of slow burns and it was so well written, the voice actors had an easy job. And one they did so well. I’m biased as I’m a huge DiCosimo fan. And that takes nothing away from Mr Ames whom is a first for me with this book. Look forward to hearing more from him.
Highly recommend
Story: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Narration: 🎙️🎙️🎙️🎙️🎙️
Profile Image for Lottie .
173 reviews3 followers
November 16, 2026
Duet narration audiobook just makes everything better

I absolutely loved the connection between the main characters. Their chemistry was wonderful, and I really enjoyed the balance of humour, romance and those more vulnerable moments that gave the story so much heart.

The banter was definitely one of my favourite parts. I love it when characters have that effortless back-and-forth, where you can feel the attraction building through every conversation. It made their relationship so much fun to follow, while the emotional moments added another layer to their connection.
Profile Image for Amy.
865 reviews44 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 5, 2026
And Emmery Fox did it again.

This book made me ache, long to comfort, laugh, groan, grin, and fall in love with a wonderful set of characters like I've been waiting for them the whole time.

Each book she writes easily slides into my comfort read pile upon completion. And I'll treasure each re-read as much as i do revisiting old friends.

*Ebook enjoyed in ARC format, but paperback purchased with my own money. Cuz, book trophies.
Profile Image for Aurelinho.
143 reviews
July 13, 2026
This trope is dumb and i couldn't get over how the fact that he was his sister friend was the biggest problem of the world and i get that they're young or whatever but still

This would've been better if it focused on the grief of Elliot's dad and Connor's self esteem, but we got a whole lot of problems that were treated superficially and basically no chemistry development

So it's a cliché nothing burguer that i didn't mind reading
Profile Image for Inda Deleon.
143 reviews12 followers
September 28, 2026
super cute

I think this is a cute romance that navigated some self esteem issues as well as grief. The sister’s character was pretty awful in the beginning but softened by the end. Connor and Elliot were childhood friends also so I felt it was more that than sister’s best friend. I think it had a sweet ending too.
Profile Image for Rachel.
594 reviews1 follower
July 21, 2026
rounding up to 3 ⭐️

I’m really disappointed because I have really enjoyed every book in this series so far but this one fell flat for me didn’t really care for any characters main or otherwise and even the storyline… it took me forever but I finished it.
Profile Image for Paul Jarvis.
14 reviews
September 20, 2026
Although I loved the 4th book in this series, I was a little annoyed with so many simple spelling mistakes throughout the book.. still don’t let it put you off, always love a happy ending .. definitely worth the read
72 reviews
September 24, 2026
Solid hockey romance with the typical sibling's best friend who's had a crush since forever setup. There are quite a few serious aspects like grief and depression. The mc deals really badly with things not going his way, but grows during the book.
1 review
June 6, 2026
Absolutely loved this! The characters were well developed and easy to connect with, love how the relationships evolved throughout the book. Would definitely recommend!
Profile Image for Millie.
42 reviews4 followers
June 6, 2026
A perfect palette cleanser !! 💓💓
Profile Image for Rachel.
32 reviews
June 23, 2026
Easy reading. Nothing overly bad or good about it.
Profile Image for Megan.
774 reviews
July 27, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars

Just your basic, cute romance. Didn't like the sister stuff but the issues with Eli's dad was good.
Profile Image for BarbieQDiva.
87 reviews
August 14, 2026
Lovely story, very spicy at times but I love that regardless! Lost a star because I couldn’t stand Scout - she was an awful character lol but everyone else and their backstories and just adored.
16 reviews
July 10, 2026
Really liked this book
Profile Image for Itzel .
225 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 19, 2026
I freaking love this book!! It was so good. it’s definitely tied with unlovable player as my favorite from whole series.


This was the perfect story to end an amazing series. It was sweet but while the story does deal with some heavy elements still has that lightness that perfectly balances the story. The characters were amazing Connor was such great character I identify with him a lot, sometimes we have our future mapped out that is hard to comprehend that while we may faced some bumps in our journey it doesn’t mean we have to give up,I’m happy he learned to let go of that mindset in the end. And Elliot was equally as amazing , they way he was also dealing with his grief, his father’s grief and also finally having the attention of your crush but being scared to loose one of the most important person because of it, oh my poor Eli he deserved all the happiness and I’m glad he had it.
Overall this was such a good story I was hooked from the beginning and couldn’t put it down, it was also bittersweet because it’s the last one of the series so it definitely makes it an unforgettable one.

I would like to add another trope that should have been added is he fell first but he fell harder because my dear Connor was down bad for Eli. And also the spice was delicious In this one, 100% recommend. Can’t wait for what else Emmery has in store next!!





Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews