Charles Burns’s “Big Baby” comics ingeniously combine real-world horrors with the stuff of old-school monster movies and horror comics. Through the naïve eyes of an ambiguously aged but decidedly prepubescent protagonist, incomprehensible and disturbing topics like sex and domestic violence merge and blend with monsters, ghosts and extraterrestrials. The result is sometimes humorous, but it also does a really great job of genuinely capturing a child’s perception of the adult world, and the feeling of alienation and horror that it can instill – the sense of the world being big, confusing and somehow dark, with untold terrors potentially lurking around every corner.
This work isn’t as complex or sophisticated as Burns’s magnum opus, Black Hole, but it’s nonetheless incredibly accomplished. Most strikingly, even though some of these pages predate Black Hole by more than a decade, Burns’s inimitable visual style is already fully formed, and his line work is already inhumanly precise. As in all of his comics that I’ve read so far, every panel looks great.
The collection (at least my French paperback from Cornélius) contains four separate comics, which share characters but don’t otherwise interlink, so I’ll briefly address each one individually:
The two-page opener, simply titled Big Baby, is the collection’s oldest material, originally published in issue #5 of Raw magazine in 1983. It’s a simple episode, structured a bit like a gag strip, and it mainly just serves to introduce protagonist Tony Delmonto. Even though not much happens, it’s still a lot of fun, relishing in a child’s sense of imagination.
The 30-page Curse of the Molemen (originally published by Raw Books in 1986 as a standalone one-shot) is absolutely brilliant, and it’s probably my favourite comic in the book. It’s full of mystery, as well as horror both mundane and fantastical. It definitely fits into the category of “suburban horror”, exploring the dark side of 1950s suburbia in a really original and compelling way.
The 20-page Teen Plague (originally published in 1989, in the first issue of Raw magazine’s second volume) has been described a prototype for Black Hole, but actually the similarities are fairly superficial. In any case, this is a great comic in its own right, with a clever story and an inventive premise, though not as much real horror to it as Curse of the Molemen. I guess this is the funniest and most light-hearted comic here, especially as a significant chunk of it is taken up by a loving pastiche of corny old-school horror (a comic within the comic).
I think the final piece, the 30-page Blood Club (originally published by Kitchen Sink Press as a standalone one-shot in 1992), is the most complex and fully realized in terms of plot. Whereas the collection’s other comics are primarily about atmosphere, mystery and cool concepts, this one is more narrative-driven. It also has more conventional pathos, with more focus on realistic and relatable social interactions. It feels a bit less imaginative than Curse of the Molemen or Teen Plague – its central premise is fairly standard ghost story fare – but it’s really interesting to see Burns moving into the believable human drama that makes Black Hole so great.
In short, the material in this collection exhibits Burns’s signature mix of thought-provoking enigma, literary depth, great art, and page-turning excitement. This work might not rival the brilliance of Black Hole, but it’s still absolutely excellent.