Ariana—the girl he once loved. Grayson—the boy who gave her his heart. Christian—the shadow between them.
On the night that should have been theirs, beneath the warm glow of their new home and in the middle of their engagement party, Grayson found Ariana in a room with his best friend. Betrayal burned in his veins. Rage blinded him. He dragged her out, into the night, paying no heed to the shocked whispers of their guests. His family, his blood, made sure every piece of hers was gone. Her belongings lay scattered on the lawn, shame woven into every discarded piece.
They did not ask. They did not question. They simply erased her. But she had not betrayed him. She had been ruined. Christian had taken what was never his to claim.
Two friends gathered what remained of her—her dignity, her pain, her broken spirit. They drove her away, far from the house that should have been hers, far from the love that had turned to hate. She stayed with them for days, silent, shattered. And then, she vanished. Three years passed.
Grayson had moved on, or so it seemed. Another woman wore the ring meant for Ariana. Another love had taken root where theirs had been torn apart.
But Ariana had returned. Not as the girl he cast aside. Not as the woman he once loved. She came back with fire in her heart. She came back for revenge.
This is a betrayal / grovel / revenge second chance read. If you're in the mood for that, you might like it, as long as you don't mind it feeling undercooked. The premise is good, the execution is mid.
Ariana and Grayson meet in college and fall in love. A few years later, at their engagement party, she's set up to look like she's cheating on him. She's not. Instead of noticing that she is literally drugged and half-unconscious, or asking her any questions about what happened, Grayson is enraged about her "cheating," kicks her out, and lets his family be awful to her. A few years later, Ariana comes back for revenge against everyone who was involved in that disaster: Grayson, his family who set it up, etc. For extra angst, when she returns, Grayson is engaged to another woman.
That's a good angsty premise! I'm into all that. (I also like that Ariana is not celibate while Grayson is engaged to an OW). The problem is, this feels like the first draft of a story that needs to be fleshed out and put through at least 2 more drafts. We're told that Ariana and Grayson have this deep connection, but we just have to take the story's word for it, it's hardly shown. We're told that his family was mean to her for a while before the disaster at their engagement party, but we don't even get any scenes of his family being mean to her.
This book didn't have to be 500 pages long, in order to do that -- Cate C Wells' books are about the same length as this one, and in her books like Return to Monte Carlo, we get a scene of the hero's family being mean to the heroine, so that we really understand that dynamic. This book is just bare bones telling us this information, without showing it. So, the angst didn't land as well as it should have.
And weirdly, it skipped over relevant details like that, but then it picked odd irrelevant stuff to show on the page. For example, at the beginning when Ariana and Grayson meet in college, he hooks up a lot. Their "meet cute" is actually gross, because she sees him in the library getting a BJ from another woman. I know a lot of readers would hate that. I don't mind it, IF it's relevant to their relationship, or is deeply rooted in his character and understanding his behavior. Like, what was going on inside of him psychologically that made him such a playboy? Why is Ariana so special that he changed his ways for her? This story didn't address any of that, and it didn't end up being relevant to his character, or to their relationship.
So the story included random stuff like that, and then it didn't include things that it DID need to address. Like, Grayson kept saying he wasn't sure why he acted the way he did on the night of the disaster -- why he didn't even question Ariana "cheating" on him, and immediately threw her out. Him having anger issues and blindly trusting his family is much more relevant to this story's plot than him being a playboy!
Instead of showing us him hooking up with other woman (which didn't end up being relevant), why didn't this book instead show us why he was so blind to his family being evil? Why didn't it show us what could have been going on in his mind, to make him so angry and impulsive? It's not satisfying when we're 70% into this book and he's sorry about what he did, but he's still like, "I'm still not sure why I acted like that."
All of this stuff could have been fixed if the author spent like, 1 more month putting this book through another draft or two. This had potential. So, if she has anyone around her - beta readers, editors - they're doing her dirty, in not telling her that (unless they are, and she's ignoring it).
Self note:To be written in the front of this book in small, tired handwriting, possibly while lying face-down on a rug.
I am not reading this yet. I am waiting for one of my Goodreads besties to take the bullet first. This is not enthusiasm. This is risk management.
Based on past experiences with this author, I already know the structural reality of her books: nobody is held accountable except the people who were not cheating. The actual cheaters and actual assholes will be coddled like teething infants. There will be rocking. There will be coddling. There will be something described with the same gentle energy as "tum tum time," which is a phrase I have to live with now. The male lead will suffer exactly one kind of suffering, and it will be the kind that happens entirely inside his own head while he looks brooding and damp. He will not lose his job, his friends, or his parking spot. He will simply think "I am sad" for three chapters, and the narrative will treat this as redemption.
I am begging the universe, with the enthusiasm of someone filling out taxes, that this time the asshole actually suffers in real, external, humiliating ways. I want him to be embarrassed in public. I want someone to yell at him. I want consequences that are not just him frowning at a river. But I am not optimistic. I have been burned before.
Now....Regarding the comments.
I have already seen the readers saying the FMC should have ended up with Stephen instead of the loser MMC who destroyed her life because he thought she cheated. And to those readers, I say this with the emotional weight : please just go ask ChatGPT to write you one chapter of FMC and Stephen being happy. Because if this author had written that ending, it would have been exactly one chapter. Maybe two, if she was feeling generous. In those one to two chapters, Stephen and the FMC would be platonic for ninety percent of the page count, then suddenly fall in love, get married, have kids, and build a business. All of it would happen in dialogue like "I guess we're married now" and "the twins are named after your grandmother." And then the author would have to do the real work, which is writing a whole sequel love story for the original loser MMC.
And that sequel would feature a new female lead. You already know her. She is a manic pixie nightmare wrapped in blonde highlights. She is not like other girls. She will tell you this within three pages. She owns a bakery. She has a black belt. She says things like "I beat the shit out of losers" while standing directly in front of a loser she will spend the entire book drooling over. She herself got cheated on last Tuesday, but that will not stop her from staring at the MMC's jawline in chapter one. And this is not a hypothetical. This actually happened in a real book by this author. I read it with my own two eyes. The hero of that story had a name that rhymed with "asshole." And also with "troll." And also with "dole," as in the thing you might go on after spending money on that book. And also with "pole," as in the thing you would rather struck him with than read his internal monologue again. And also with "bowl," as in the thing you would like to vomit into. His name was exactly one consonant away from being a lump of carbon you dig out of the ground. You know who I mean. We all know who I mean.
And you know what? You are all too insensitive to make this author do the labor of writing a two-chapter love story for the FMC and Stephen. That would be labor. Actual work. She would have to make sure the FMC did not upgrade, actually. Because God forbid a woman ends up with someone who didn't ruin her life over a misunderstanding. That would require emotional nuance and page time. Meanwhile, writing a whole sequel about the original loser? That is not labor. That is not hard work. That is just... letting the wattpad girlies cry. That sequel would take an emotional toll. On them. Specifically. The kind of emotional toll that involves posting crying gifs in the comments and saying "he just needs love" while ignoring that he committed emotional arson on the FMC's entire life. That sequel would be the Temu version of Fifty Shades of Grey trauma porn. Same cheap packaging. Same red flags painted as romance. Same "I can fix him" energy but with worse grammar and a hero whose name rhymes with a hole in the ground.
So no. I am not reading this until someone I trust tells me there is no tum tum time, no boo-boo kissing, and no scene where the MMC cries softly and the FMC pets his hair like he is a rescue puppy who peed on the carpet but looked sad about it. I want him to face consequences. Real ones. Not thought-suffering. Not internal angst. I want him to be wrong and for the book to know he is wrong without making it the FMC's job to fix him with the power of her forgiveness.
Until then, this book sits on the shelf. Staring at me. Judging me. Waiting for me to be weak.
Nooooo, why the fuck did she take him back !?! Like gave him another chance. He betrayed, he ruined her, completely destroyed her and few sweet words after he gets to know the truth, that he didn't even try to find himself, and his too little, too late apologies start. Stephen my poor man. No I didn't expect this sort of betrayal from this author. 💔💔
DV should not be used as comeuppance for OW. We see her showing up to an event at the end of the book with bruises and verbal abůse from her husband. Absolutely not. She absolutely deserved something for her part in what happened, but never DV.
Ok I am unable to leave a more detailed review at this time, but will be back to flesh it out at a later date!
Ariana and Grayson were in love. They consumed each other. However, evil forces were at work. Jealousy and greed along with valued friends, ow wannabes, and family were working against them. When Ariana is found in a compromising position with Grayson’s bff, he doesn’t give her a chance to explain. He is very cruel and removes her from his life in a brutal demoralizing way! He basically runs her out of town and makes her whole family outcasts.
She was set up. She is angry. She is out for revenge.
Neither one remained celibate in their years apart. Grayson is engaged to Lila, and Ariana has a very wealthy fwb going on with Stephen. But beneath all the hate, Grayson and Ariana still burn for each other. Is it love? Passion? Hate? Or a combination…
Ariana’s revenge took center stage. Even when truths started to be revealed, she was only interested in one thing…destroying Grayson and anyone who took part in her destruction. They underestimated her. They underestimated her connections. They might have burned down the relationship, but she rose from the ashes like a magnificent phoenix!
As the story progresses however, we see that revenge is not always worth the cost. Ariana risks losing her humanity in pursuit of justice and restitution. It makes one start to question who are the real villains and who are the victims? Some you will see stay the same throughout, while other character roles become more murky.
I started this story despising Grayson. How could he not see what was happening? How could he treat her the way he did? By the end of the story, I am asking myself Why is Ariana continuing in this scheme? Does she not see Grayson’s pain? His love?
Lots of people to despise in this story! Some secrets get revealed. And betrayals take many forms.
This is a second chance story. Our two original characters have a long bumpy road ahead of them, but they do make it back to each other. I cried when it looked like it was all lost, but Jona gives us a fabulous ending with and epilogue, that put my torn up heart back together again.
Cheating = there was no actual cheating but the H was tricked into believing the h cheated with his bff at their engagement party
H sees h with OM = H walks in on his bff/om and the h looking like they are about to have sex
SA/R = h was drugged by the bff/OM and was assaulted but no penetration. h had thought she was sexually assaulted but at the hospital they told her that it did not look like she had sex
OW/OM drama = bff/OM was actually gay and was blackmailed by H's sister/OW1 to assault the h. Comeuppance? BFF/OM loses his boyfriend and exiles himself to live on a farm for years. Still terrified he will be outed, but he does come clean with both the h and H, then he ends up with his boyfriend and they leave town as the h really could not ever forgive him (as she shouldn't). OW1 along with several other OW (H's mom, chick that wanted the H) all worked to separate the H from the h and did so with the whole SA/R set up they made to look like the h was cheating. They also, out of H's earshot, were mean and insulting to the h. Comeuppance? When h comes back to town, she makes them all pay and it is a glorious takedown.
The h gets her pounds of flesh back and then some!
Grovel = once H knows the truth his grovel is selfless and intense. Takes a while but eventually they find their way back to each other.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I wasn’t sure that there was a single way for me to forgive Grace. After everything that he did and the way he didn’t trust her coming back from that seemed an insurmountable mountain. However, as often found with this author, she found a way and after really sitting and thinking about this book and everything that they went through, I have to say it really was truly exceptional. I like that she did not have a celibate female. Too many authors continue to pigeonhole women to this role that we have fought for centuries to leave behind. I really liked the FMC. She stuck with the revenge until she could sit in a place with herself that she didn’t need it anymore. The only things I didn’t love about it were Stephen was an incredible character who I really wanted to find happiness and then the chef at her restaurant was also really great. I think I would’ve loved it even more if she had introduced some side characters that might’ve been the love interests for those men because they both deserve to happy ever after. Otherwise the book was perfect.
1. Grayson and Ari met in college where he pursued her relentlessly to get her to go out with him. I wanted to give Ari a high five for knowing her worth and making him work for it. But after she finally agreed to go out with him, he humiliated her by constantly flirting with other girls and letting them hang all over him knowing that everyone on campus thought they were a couple. She finally gave him an ultimatum to make him agree to be with just her. She should have grown a spine and some self respect, walked away and never looked back. 2. I think that Ari’s need for revenge was completely justified and I didn’t like that Grayson was “disappointed” in her and that her friends tried to make her feel guilty for it. At the same time, I lost respect for her when she had no problem with all of the people who were collateral damage in her schemes. 3. There are some acts that are irredeemable and I’m afraid that to me, Grayson’s treatment of Ari was one of them. 4. When there were whole scenes and conversations from chapter 24 repeated in chapter 29, I’d had enough. DNF
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
First red flag was the female lead getting turned on watching the male lead get blown in a library. I personally hate shit like that, added to the virgin heroine-manwhore hero dynamic. I decided to skip ahead to the gut punch moment and then the moment where the hero finally finds out she was assaulted (and the heroine had plenty of opportunities to tell him but refused to because she was afraid of him not believing her? Despite her being here for revenge? Girl why do you care?), to see if things got better. And when the hero finds out his best friend Christian raped his fiancee... he asks how Christian could do this to him. I was already losing faith in how the book was gonna handle such a serious topic, considering it refused to call a spade a spade and said Christian "hurt" her, but the confrontation convinced me I was gonna be disappointed by the other 400 pages of this book so I DNF'd.
I like this author's imagination in that there is something a little uncommon in her approach to tropes. When I was about one third through this book so much had happened already I couldn't predict what more there could be to the story. The H "finds" the h with his friend during their engagement party and loses it and humiliates her in front of guests. This is a case of the H believing the worst rather than hearing the h's side and acting on it only to find out he was wrong. This trope is a favorite of mine. The h leaves town to avoid small town judgement and the H. Much to his surprise, she returns three years later and the bulk of the story becomes about her revenge. The H now has a fiancee and a horrible sister and parents. His grovel includes both small and large gestures.
I concur it’s humanly impossible to still be in love with someone who kicked you out after you were SAed. Like not an ounce of you would hold onto any love after facing such tragedy and yet being assaulted again within a minute by someone who should love and trust you.
No, not happening. After 3 years she is still in love?!?! I think she should have carved out some time out of her revenge plot to get therapy. Also, why are The Hale’s investing in a business that’s run by an absolute new person with no experience whatsoever in the industry. Cmon you expect me to believe that 3 years is all it took for her to get backed up by such powerhouse.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This was a new author to me, I just read the synopsis and I was sold!! The author wrote the longing,hate, angst soo good. I felt anger for grayson in the beginning of chapters for what he did to Arianna, but I fell in love with him later on. He was such a good soul it was astonishing that he belonged to such selfish and piece of shit family.. I loved Stephen's character too in this and I am hoping the writer gives his book to us bcs that man was sexy!!! Anyways, good book and I would definitely read her future books..
The story was pretty good but the execution was lacking. From the beginning of the story, the reason for revenge was weak and the build up of their love sounded more like obsession than love. Both Ari and Gray had chances later in life to rebuild and find happiness outside of each other but didn't bevause of the need for revenge but the reader hurts for those who were innocent and caught in the aftermath. I kept hoping to read what happened to the people who loved both these characters praying they get happy ending but there was no follow up. It was a little unsatisfying.
A lot about this story just really bothered me.. first of all, he should have been able to tell that his fiancee was literally drugged??? Second, her not telling him the truth right away felt like a way to just prolong the drama. Third, he almost grovelled too much… like it got to the point where I felt embarrassed for him and when the MMC is no longer desirable, I lose interest. Also, of course she’s the girl every single successful guy wants 🙈
Personally, didn’t really like any of the characters in this book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
At first I was anxious knowing that the point of no return for the story was coming. Then the FMC rise to vengeance was condoned yep I’ll say it. But the twist near the end…. I like a lot. Yes the original couple do come back together. But omg what happens to the villains of the story was karma at its best. I recommend to everyone 18+ due to mature themes.
This one gutted me, not once... but twice! Not only do you get the 1st brutal one that tore this beautiful cpl apart; you also got the 2nd when the mmc finds out what he thought happened was all a lie... This was a beautiful read and it was a written with such heart and soul. So much hurt and anger, so much love and longing. Another excellent book by Jona ❤️
Read this on her Patreon. I love how strong Ariana was systematically conducting her revenge and strategized her moves. Both had moved on with someone else before they met again but redeeming Grayson was not instant. He really worked hard for it.
I usually really like this author but this book felt really disjointed, the beginning and end of this book is written in a way that feels like the book was written by two different people as the style of writing is completely different.
Good book on betrayal and revenge. Liked both characters. Writing was solid and felt there was no AI or ESL element involved. Recommend to those who like this topic!